RD /i W 1 nof;

o

6

Bulletin

British Museum

(Natural History)

Historical Series

VOLUME 17 NUMBER 1

25 MAY 1989

IF'

The Bulletin oj the British Museum ( .\atuial History), instituted in 1949,
is issued in four scientific series. Botany, Entomology, Geology
(incorporating Mineralogy) and Zoology, and an Historical series.

The Historical Series is edited in the Museum's Library
Librarian: Mr R. E. R. Banks

Editor: Miss P. Gilbert

Papers in the Bulletin are primarily the results of research carried out on the
unique and ever-growing collections of the Museum, both by the scientific stalT
and by specialists from elsewhere who make use of the Museum's resources.
Many of the papers are works of reference that will remain indispensable for
years to come.

A volume contains about 256 pages, made up of two numbers: published Spring
and Autumn. Subscriptions may be placed for one or more of the series on an
Annual basis. Individual volumes and back numbers can be purchased and a
Bulletin catalogue, by series, is available. Orders and enquiries should be sent
to:

Sales Department,

Natural History Museum Publications,

British Museum (Natural History),

Cromwell Road.

London SW7 5BD

Telephone: 0\-93S-93S6
Telex: 929437 NH PUBS G
Fa.v. 01-938-8709

World List abbreviation: Bull. Br. Mus. luit. Hisi (hist. Ser.;
© British Museum (Natural History). 1989

ISBN 0 565 09011 9 Historical Series

ISSN 0068 2306 Vol 17. No. 1. pp. 1 165

British Museum (Natural History)

Cromwell Road

London SW7 5BD Issued 25 May 1 989

Typcici by J & L Composition!^. Filcy. Nonh Yorkshire

Pnnicd b> Hcnrj Ling Ltd, at ihc Dorset Press. Dorchester Doreci

Bui! Br Mm. Niir Hisi (hist. Sc-r ) 17( 1 ) I-Ih5

Issued 25 May 1989

Notes on Insects, 1692 & 1695
By Charles duBois

Edited with an introduction b\

L. JESSOP

Department of Entomologv, British Museum of Natural
Cromwell Road. London 'SW7 5BD

CONTENTS

Introduction 1. .®'!^/?".'SH. MUSLUM

Life of Charles duBois f . . . . l>l*J!'!'.' ! . 'jl VP/;ri

Notes on the Manuscript | "a-Hi*-!

Further Reading j .4.v!vW.!.9,6v.

References i ti..>cf-^M^„„. . .

Appendix (duBois correspondence) ; . i .1. .,. ^-^^y. i;u"-A-e,'.-
Facsimile and Transcription of the "■■^■■f-npt "' . ■JUlrj, X

1

2
13
21
21
23
29

INTRODUCTION

Entomology in the seventeenth century is most commonly exemplified in the modern
mind by Mouffet's Theater of Insects. That work, with its wealth of superstitions and
ridiculous remedies, provides a strong reinforcement of modern prejudices about the
inadequacies of past scientists, yet in reality it is atypical of the entomological scene of
the times when it was published. When both manuscripts and serious published works of
the period are examined, what is constantly surprising is the straightforward, common-
sense approach of most of the naturalists of the time: John Ray, for instance, wnMe to
Hans Sloane in April 1699 (teste Lankester, 1898)

The most I have done is in observing the generation and transmutations of the
papilionaceous tribe, of which I have found at least 2IH1 species near my own
habitation, necdum finitae, every year bringing new ones to my knowledge. Of these,
as many as I could get the eggs or caterpillars of, 1 have fed and endeavoured to brmg
to their changes, though I have failed in many. This hath taken me up no small time
and pains.

Apart from the archaic language, these sentences may well have been written by a
naturalist of the late twentieth century.

The notebook reproduced here belongs to the tradition of John Ray rather than
Thomas Mouffet. It is the work of Charles duBois, who is now chiefly remembered as a
botanist and horticulturalist. When he wrote the work, duBois was a reasonably wealthy
London merchant involved in the silk trade, and he was then in his mid thirties. His
social circle at the time he was writing probably already included several of the leading
naturalists on the London scene, whose activities seem lo have been as much social as
scientific.

Why duBois wrote the notebook is not known; it may have been an attempt lo dehne
what he knew of the insects as a whole or of the insect fauna local to Milcham, but there
was probably also an additional element of enjoyment in drawing the figures that

2 L. JESSOP

accompany the descriptions; considerable time must have been spent in their production,
and they are of tine quahty. These notes may originally have been intended for
publication (although there is no evidence of such an intention). If so. duBois may have
deferred to Petiver and to Ray, who was in 1695 working towards his Historia
Insectorum .

It must be remembered that at the time the notebook was written there were no
identification guides available of the sort that we have now. In the absence of books to
help him. it is probable that duBois turned to other naturalists for assistance — men such
as James Petiver, for instance, who contributed a specimen that is figured in the
notebook, kept his own insect collecting diary and published some of his collecting
records in the Monthly Miscellany and elsewhere.

The present work reproduces duBois" text in facsimile and as a transcript, and
transcripts are also appended of his surviving correspondence. A summary is given of
what is known about Charles duBois' life and times. This summary has no pretentions to
being complete: there are probably a number of further references to the man buried
among the mass of letters in the Sloane MSS and in the Journal Book of the Royal
Socieiv. and there may be further information to be gleaned from census and ta.\ records
in the Public Record Office. A detailed account drawing on all sources was thought
inappropriate to this publication, which is primarily concerned with presenting the text of
the notebook.

The Spelling, and Possible Pronunciation of duBois' Name:

In his letters and will Charles duBois always signed his name with a lower case d and
without a space between the u and B. and this usage is followed in the present
publication. Other authors have given the name as Dubois or Du Bois, and their
orthography is followed when the text of works is cited.

A note on the verso of Add. MSS 22,851 f. 186 spells the name as Du Boys. If this was
written by someone who had heard the name but not seen it written, it could be an
indication of how it was pronounced.

References to Entries in the Notebook

Where entries in the notebook are discussed below, they are numbered according to
their place in the various sections. Thus 'notes 5' is the fifth entry in the notes section.
'Papilio 9" the ninth in the genus Papilio, and 'Tunbridge Wells 4' the fourth species
described from Tunbridge Wells.

LIFE OF CHARLES DUBOIS

The following account is broadly based on that of Foster (1924: 113-124). Unfortunately.
Foster did not provide references to many of his sources of information, and his account
is here taken at face value. Where additional information has been obtained in the course
of the preparation of the current work or where facts quoted by Foster have been
checked to their source, the source is cited.

CHARLBS DUBOIS INSECT NOTES i

Background

Charles duBois belonged to a Huguenot family that had already been living in England
for at least two generations. He was the eldest son of John (aka Jean) duBois, who
described himself in his will as citizen and weaver of London (P.R.O. 1 1/378 [169 Hare]).
Charles" date of birth is usually given as 1656 (Foster, 1924 claimed it was 1653): his
gravestone indicates that he was 83 years old when he died, which was on the 20 or 21
October 1741), and that places his date of birth between the 22 October 1656 and the 19
October 1657. No record of baptism has been traced.

The records of L'Eglise de Londres in Threadneedle Street report a marriage on the 1 1
January 1652 between Jean duBois, son of Jean, native of Canterbury and Anne Herle,
daughter of Charles Herle, 'Ministre de la Parolle de Dieu", native of Winwick in the
County of Lancaster. Anne Herle was probably Charles" mother, and she must have died
while he was still a boy, since his father re-married in 1662. Foster (1887) in a register of
London marriage licences recorded that John duBois of the parish of St Mary
Aldermanbury, a widower aged 40, took out a licence on the 10 September to marry
Sarah Waldo, a spinster aged 22, daughter of Anne Waldo, of All Hallows, Honey Lane,
London, widow, who consented, the marriage to take place at All Hallows aforesaid, or
St Faith, London (dated 10 Sept. 1662). It would appear that the marriage took place
neither at All Hallows nor at St Faith, as the register of L"Eglise de Londres
(Threadneedle Street) records the marriage occurring there on 27 July 1662. John duBois
was still described as a native of Canterbury, and Sarah Waldo as daughter of Daniel
Waldo, native of London.

There are seven sons and one daughter mentioned in John duBois" will.

The Waldo family had been living in England since the mid sixteenth century and
contained several wealthy merchants among its members (Jones, 1863). The only Waldo
listed in the 1666 hearth tax records for All Hallows Honey Lane was Edward, a mercer
of the Streete Syde, who was taxed for seven hearths (P.R.O. E179 252/32). A note in
the same set of records says that there was no collection in St Mary Aldermanbury
because the collector was 'appointed to begin his collection on Monday the 3rd day of
September, 1666 but was prevented by the fire".

The duBois and Waldo families could probably be classed as fairly wealthy members of
the London community. The parishes they lived in were themselves well-to-do areas of
the city (St Mary Aldermanbury had been described by Stow in 1603 as follows: 'In this
Alderman bury streete be diverse faire houses on both the sides, meete for marchants or
men of Worship, and in the midst thereof is a fayre Conduit"), whilst the seven hearths of
the Waldo household is a mark of substantial prosperity, as is the situation of their house
(not in a yard or lane, but in a street) (see Power in Beier & Finlay, 1986, for a discussion
of indicators of wealth in seventeenth century London). Their profession was not
unusual: about 20% of the population of the city was employed in the cloth trade at that
time (Beier in Beier & Finlay, 1986), about half of those listed in the All Hallows Honey
Lane parish in the 1666 hearth tax return being silkmen (P.R.O. E179 252/32).

Charles duBois himself later also joined the cloth trade, being bequeathed in his
lather's will a share in a mercer's business and the silk trade. These businesses were also
part-owned by his fathers brother, also called Charies (PRO. wills 1 1/378 [169 Hare]).

Charles duBois" knowledge of the silk trade is implied in the description of the species
'notes 43", the tail of which he describes as being 'large and very hairy, blunt at the end
like that of the papilio of a silk worm".

Assuming that Charles duBois spent his childhood in London, among his early
memories would have been the outbreak of plague in 1665, which killed almost one-fifth
and incapacitated up to one-third of the population of London (see Slack in Beier &
Finlay, 1986) and the great fire of 1666, which destroyed almost all of the City of

4 I . JESSOP

London, including the whole of the parishes of St Mar>' Aldermanbury and All Hallows
Honey Lane. Unfortunately no evidence relating to his early life has vet conic to light,
the earliest record of his existence being in 16S4. when he was mentioned in his father's
will, at which time he would have been about 28 years old. Presumablv he was then
already occupied somehow in the cloth trade, as he was considered fitted b\ his father to
take over part of the famiU business on his death.

No evidence has been found of Charles duBois ha\ insi married.

John duBois and Politics

John duBois is known to have been involved in the political life of the City of London. In
1682 there was a political struggle between the Royal Court and the Whigs, who were
determined to exclude the Duke of York from the succession. It was felt by the Court
that it was important that the government of the City of London should be in svmpathetic
hands. In the election of two Sheriffs. John duBois and Fhomas Papillon (who were
probably old friends, both being chosen in \b>7 by the French Church in Limdon to
remonstrate with the committee appointed by Cromwell to settle disputes in that bod\ )
were nominated by the Whigs in opposition to two candidates fa\oured bv the Lord
Mayor (who supported the Court). The candidates were presented to the citi7cns on
Midsummer Day. and as the meeting was in the favour of the Whig candidates, the Lord
Mayor declared the meeting adjourned. The citizens, ignoring the order of adjournment,
declared Papillon and duBois elected.

This election was declared void and a fresh one ordered, which resulted in Papillon
and duBois again being returned, but the Lord Mayor ignored the decision and
announced that the two Court candidates had been chosen.

In February l(iS4. Papillon and duBois issued writs against the Lord Ma\or lor making
a false return, and on his refusing to enter an appearance, he was arrested and detained
in custody for six hours. After the action had been abandoned, the Mavor retaliated by
claiming £10. ()()() damages for false impnsonment. The trial took place under the
notorious Chief Justice Jeffreys, who secured a verdict for the lull amount claimed.
Papillon tied to Utrecht until the Revolution made it safe for him to return to London.
The Lord Mayor would probably then have turned his attention to duBois. but by that
lime the latter was dead: his burial is registered at the parish church of St Mary
.Aldermanbury on the 30 October 1684 and his will was proved on the .^ November.

John duBois was elected a Committee of the East India Company in 1681 (Committee
was the title given to each of the 24 directors elected annually by the East India Compaiu
to manage its affairs), possibly through the inlluence of Papillon. who was Dcputv
Governor and at that time fighting the Lory section of the Companv. Papillon was
replaced as Deputy Governor b\ Robert Thomson in 1682 and retired in 168.^. but John
duBois remained a Committee until his death.

John duBois' Son.s and the East India Company

In April 1691 John duBois' son. also called John, became a Committee of the I-^ast India
Company. He had married in July 1690. and the licence describes him as 'about 25",
which would place his date of birth at about I66.S and thus make him the step-brother of
Charles. John duBois the younger remained a member of the Court of the Company for
six and a half years, and on M) September 1697 was appointed to the post of Cashier-
(ieneral (usually called Treasurer) at a salary of £200 plus £100 a year gratuity. This
appointment necessitated his retirement from the Court of the Company.

CH \R1 1 sin IU1IS INSllMNCVnS 5

John iliiHois tlic \oungcr died in 1702. ;uul on 27 October 1702 ("luiilcs duRois \v;is
appointed to the post ot C'ashiei-Cieneial. Charles diiBois ua\e seeinilv ol 14,|I00 tor the
faitlilul diseliari;e of his duties.

A Charles duBois was a Conmiittee Ironi April Id'-'S initil 17(W. but unless he was
given permission to continue in that post at the same time as beini; Treasurer, this must
have been a second person with the same name.

During the tenure ol John duHois the younger, .ind ol Ch.irles duHois as Treasurer,
the East India Company underwent tremendous ditticulties. The following sequence of
events is taken from Hunter (UMl.S):

\in^H 1-nemies of the Old I'ast India Conip.my formed an association allied lo ihe Whigs

in Parliament, to break the nionopolv of trade
Id'-'.i Sir Josia Child, In bribes 'on the most lavish se.ile', procured ,i tr.idmg ch.irtei liom

the Crown.
1 (i''4 The I louse of Commons passed a resolution that all the subjects of England hav e a

right to trade with the East Indies unless prohibited by Act of Parliament.
l(i'*5 .An inquiry into briberv and corruption concerning the affair ruined several

politicians.
lO^^'S .-Xn .issocKition constituted bv .in .Vet of I'arli.inient. the '(ieneral Societv' (also

known as the New Company), was granted exclusive trade with the Fast Indies,

saving the rights o\ the C)ld Conipanv . which were due to expire in 17111
Ib^S Ihe Old Compain subscribed t.^l.s.OOO m the name of John duHois to the New

Company, thus giv ing them a major uiterest in it.

There followed a bitter struggle between the OUt and New Companies, both in Hngland
and Indi.i.

1702 Under pressure from Crown and Parliament tlie two companies were forced into a

union.
I70S The union was made .ibsolute.

The only reference to these struggles in Charles duBois' surviving manuscripts can be
found in the letter he wrote to Ciovernor Pill in September 1702 (Add, MSS 22,851,
ff. 1S4-IS.S — see appendix).

Some records exist of Charles diiBois' saUirv (lOR llti7). In 1710 he was paid f20() a
vear. and in I72.s £201) salary plus f'lOO graluitv His standing in the (\impany can be
deduced from the fad thai in 1710 onlv two home ofticers were paid a higher salary: the
Seeretarv (£240) and the .•Xcconiplant Cieneral (i;2.s(l). T'oster ( l'>24) mentions that on 27
March 172.^ Charles duBois was given a gratuity of >00 guineas and on S March 17.^2 a
similar amount, with an allowance of t'.sO a year for house rent.

1-urther indicators of the wealth of the duBois family are that at the time of the union
of the two companies Charles duBois held stock to the value of £2.885 12s,. while almost
£5.000 worth of stock was held by three of his step-brothers.

The final amalgamation of the Old and New Companies required a reconsideration of
the ofticers employeil, but Charles duBois must have proved satisfactory, as he was
eonlirmed in his post on 2*1 May 1704.

In addition to his position as Treasurer of Ihe United C\inipanv. Charles duBois was
one of Ihe seven Trustees of the Old Company, becoming sole Iruslee in 17Vi on the
death of the only other Trustee then surviving, T^dward Ciibbon.

6 L. JESSOP

Financial Scandals

In the later years of his life, Charles duBois was involved in two financial scandals in his
work for the East India Company.

First, on 5 August 1730. the Chairman announced at a General Court that six of the
supercargoes of the fleet lately returned (including Charles" nephew. Waldo duBois, who
was third supercargo) had been found to have conspired to falsify their accounts, despite
the fact that the chief supracargo might fairly and honestly gain upon the success of one
voyage from eight to ten thousand pounds, and the rest in proportion". An action
brought against the culprits in the Court of Chancery resulted in them paying the
Company almost £l.'i,(HH).

On 12 June 1734 the Committee of the Treasury of the Company reported that they
had found a deficiency in the cash of about £1 1 .()()(), arising from the officers" practice of
taking buyers" notes instead of cash in clearing goods (despite strict orders to the
contrary) and of lending money to officials of the East India Company. Charles duBois
and a clerk named Tullidge (who seems to have been chiefly responsible) were
examined, and Tullidge was suspended. Charles duBois was accjuitted of dishonesty, but
was found guilty of lack of supervision and dereliction of duty in not acquainting the
Court of the Company with the state of affairs.

On 24 July 1734 a general court was held, at which a memorial from Charles duBois
was read, pleading his great age (he was now about 78) and long service. He placed all
blame on Tullidge. declaring that the latter had. four years back, without his knowledge
accepted notes from merchants to an amount between £30.()()() and £40. ()()(). and that on
discovering this he had been frightened to disclose the facts in case the position of the
debtors should be irretrievably shaken and the money lost to the company altogether. He
had himself managed to get in the greater part of the amount, and the total deficiency
would not much exceed £3.000. Further, he declared that although £60.000.000 had
passed through the treasury during his tenure, he had never drawn any illicit profit, and
that in the year of the South Sea crash he had saved the company many thousands. His
employers were merciful, and accepted £300 from him in full discharge of his liability.
That his position in the Company was not compromised is shown by a gratuity of £150
given to him in December 1737 and another one in April 1740.

duBois and Mitcham

In his will. John duBois senior bequeathed to Charles "my house and land in Micham in
Surrey with all the appurtenances thereunto belonging except the furniture in the best
chamber there which 1 give & leave to the disposal of my executor" (P.R.O. 11/378 [169
Hare]). Mitcham at the turn of the eighteenth century appears to have been a pleasant
area. It was described by Aubrey (1718: 142) as being 'situate about nine miles from
London, and well inhabited, and much frequented by the citizens of our Metropolis".

The house was situated on the south side of Upper Green East, and the grounds were
about 15 acres in extent. The original house was pulled down towards the end of
the eighteenth century, and replaced by another (The Firs), which has also been
demolished, the site currently (1987) being occupied by a number of houses and shops.
The boundarv of the I-'irs site is clearly shown in the Ordnance Survcv 25 inch: 1 mile map
of 1867.

Charles duBois was verified in the Mitcham vestry minutes of 18 June 1738 as being
entitled in his own right to a pew in the north aisle of the parish church which the owners
and occupiers of his house had enjoyed 'since time immemorial' (Surrey Record Office.
Court Rolls of the Manor of Biggin and Tamworth: teste E. N. Montague, per. comm.).

CHARLES DUBOIS INSECT NOTES

,~fT!if^li"\

-^■y, ,;*.', .).i^ .ttfc

f .\'

THE DU BOIS TOMB

He is remembered for his generosity in donating £200 for the purchase of Queen Anne's
Bounty to augment the meagre income of the vicar of Mitcham (Jones, 1863).

Charles duBois lies buried in the family grave in Mitcham churchyard (Church Road,
Mitcham) close by that of the Waldos on the north side of the church: his will specified
that he should be buried on the side of the church 'where the fewest graves are" (P.R.O.
11/705 [264 Browne]). The inscription on the tomb slab indicated thai he died '20 Oct.
A.D. 1740, aetat. 83' (although the Gentleman's Magazine for 1740 (p. 325) says the
death was on the 21 October). The tomb stone was also inscribed with the names of
Waldo duBois (his brother's son, who died on 20 February 1746), Ebeneezer duBois
(Charles' stepbrother, who died on 14 April 1747) and Sarah Charlotte duBois (his niece,
who died on 12 April 1757 — not to be confused with the Sarah Waldo who married
Humphrey Sibthorp and who died on 1 August 1756). A figure of the grave was given in
Foster (1924), and is reproduced above. Foster described the inscriptions as being barely
legible and the slab as being broken into six pieces: in 1987 only two of those pieces could
be located, one being face-down on the ground beside the grave and the other (bearing
part of Sarah Charlotte's name and eulogy) lying at an angle on the grave site.

In 1716 the court baron of the Mitcham manor of Biggin and Tamworth was notified of
the death of Mary duBois, and approved the admission of her son Charles as a tenant of
the manor holding land in 'the Commonfield of Mitcham called Blacklands'. This seems
to indicate thai a second Charles duBois was living in the area at thai lime (E. N.
Montague, pers. comm). It is not known which man leased from Mary Bait in 1736 'two
parcels of customary land containing by estimation 10 acres more or less called Blowers
or Cold Blows formerly in the occupation of Philip Gardner'.

8 L. JESSOP

The Mitcham Garden

In Loudon (1838: 62-63) is a reference to an account prepared bv the Society of
Gardeners, which indicates duBois' importance as a horticuhurahst. It says that duBois
'has . . . not only been very industrious to procure plants from abroad, but also as
generous in communicating whatever his garden would afford, as also many useful
observations relating both to their culture and uses." Loudon also gave a brief account of
the state of duBois" garden in Mitcham in 1835. and listed some of the trees planted by
him that still remained: a very large weeping willow; a nettle tree, with branches covering
a space 50ft in diameter and a trunk 6'M" in circumference; a pinaster with a clear trunk
about 4011 high and a girth 3ft from the ground 4ft. and a total height of 60ft; an old. large
and handsome mulberry tree, the branches of which covered a space 60ft in diameter;
very old and large scots pines [hence the name of the house built on the site]; a very large
stone pine; a large Prunus Mahaleb; a fine Pleleci irifoliula; a stag's horn sumach, with a
trunk 6ft in girth, and an old Bignomia radicans and a large Arbutus (names as given by
Loudon).

Anon (1812) claimed that duBois 'was a great and celebrated botanist, and had an
excellent botanic garden to his house on the upper green, where the fair is kept, at
Mitcham, in Surrey", and Lambert's manuscript note about famous gardens (MS in the
library of the Linnean Society of London) says that duBois had 'a Great Collection of
stove plants &c in great perfection" (stove plants are plants that were grown in heated
houses).

duBois" reputation as a botanic gardener is indicated by entries in the minute books of
the Royal Society reporting that he was being given batches of imported seeds to raise
and then reporting back to the Society on his success (two entries seen: I March 1698/9,
and 3 December 1701). Perhaps another indication of his standing is the dedication to
him of the third decade of Bradley's Historia Plantarum Succulentarum in 1725.

It would appear from Peter Collinson's letter to William Byrd II in 1730 (from a
contemporary transcription in the Westover manuscripts, Virginia Historical Society.
teste Dr A. W. Armstrong) that Charles duBois carefully observed different methods of
cultivation, and passed his observations on to others. Collinson says:

I will close this long relation with an observation of a very curious gentleman Mr
Charles Dubois who in his travels thro' the South parts of France & Spain was very
agreeably entertained in their gardens from variety of fruits growing together being
regularly planted with cherries apples & pears and against every tree grew a vine which
run up into the tree and was supported by its branches. & when he was there, was
picntilully hung with fruit, and ripen'd to great perfection and a moderate skill in
pruning served.

A little can be deduced about duBois' garden from his insect notebook. For instance
the references to 'The Rasps" (Musca quadripennis 1, Musca 5 & 15 and notes 28 & 36),
'Currans" (Scarabeus 14, Musca 7. Musca 15, Vespa 2 and Notes 1), an apple tree
(Scarabeus 32), cherry leaves (Apis 4), 'Aprecock Leaves" (Musca 13 and notes 8) and a
gooseberry bush (Scarabeus 29) indicate that he probably grew those fruits. Scarabeus 8
is described as being taken on a rose. Scarabeus 1 and 3 were taken whilst digging the
ground in September, Scarabeus 24 out of new-dug earth in April, and the chrysalis of
Phalaena 25 out of new-dug earth at the beginning of June. Thysanoptera (notes 29) are
described as being associated with hot-beds, Scarabei aquatici 1 was taken in water in a
pond, and this could have been the pond in the garden marked on the 1867 Ordnance
Survey map. The garden probably also contained a water tub (Scarabeus 10), a
woodshed (Phalaena 28) and an outside privy ('necessary house', notes 33).

CHARLES DUBOIS INSECT NOTES 9

Scientific and Social Activities

Towards the end of the seventeenth eentury, there was a group of naturaHsts in the
London area, who possessed a considerable body of knowledge about natural history. It
is unfortunate that because they published very little about their activities and findings,
their knowledge perished with them, and as a corollary many of these figures now lie in
relative obscurity Several of these naturalists were of a similar age: for instance, Joseph
Dandridge (baptised 1664); James Petiver (born 1663); William Sherard (born 1659);
Adam Buddie (born approx. 166(1); Sir Hans Sloane (born 166(1); Samuel Doody (born
1656); and of course Charles duBois (born ca 1656). Leonard Plukenet, who was born in
1641, was slightly older than the others.

Fortunately a lot of the private correspondence of the participants in the natural
history scene of that time found its way into the vast assemblage of papers now known as
the Sloane manuscripts, and in recent years some historians have researched into these
papers and presented interpretations of the activities of some of Charles duBois'
contemporaries. Fasti (1950) (a doctoral thesis, a copy of which is in the BMNH), for
instance, studied one of duBois' known associates, William Sherard. and Stearns (1952)
summarised the life and activities of another associate, James Petiver. Fasti's work in
particular contains much information on the naturalists of that time.

The activities of the group of friends included meetings in coffee houses (Sloane MSS
4067, f.7), where they are known to have examined botanical specimens (Sloane MSS
4037, ff. 102-103). and in taverns (Sloane MSS 4066, f. 283-284). They also made
botanical excursions (e.g. to Chislehurst bogg: Sloane MSS 4066, f.283).

The group of naturalists was referred to by Pasti and Stearns as the Temple Coffee
House Club, and as the Temple Coffee House Botany Club, but there is no evidence of
contemporary use of these names. It was Pasti who first discovered the existence of a club
at the Temple Coffee House, the earliest certain reference to which is in a letter from
William Vernon to Sloane dated July 1698 (Sloane MSS 4037, ff. 102-103) in which
Vernon says that he will bring a collection of plants every Friday night to be discussed.
Only one other letter so far discovered (Sloane MSS 4067, f.7: undated) refers to a club
at the Temple Coffee House.

Stearns claimed that duBois was a member of the Temple Coffee House Botany Club,
the evidence cited for this being Sloane MSS 4067, f.81 and Sloane MSS 4020, f.l()7 (the
mayoral permit that allowed duBois and several friends to travel to Gravesend on a
Sunday) (sec appendix for text). Sloane MSS 4067, f.81 is a letter from Petiver to
Breynius, dated Christmas eve, 1692, and includes the sentence "Yesternight aft a
Meeting of Botanick ffriends, amongst whom were present y^' Ingenious Dr Plukenett.
Dr Sloan, Dr Robinson. Mr Newton, Mr Doody, Mr Dale, Mr Du-Bois &c, who all
dranke & wisht y' health.' As neither of these letters refer either to a club or to the
Temple Coffee House, there is no firm evidence presently known that proves duBois was
a member of that club.

Other than the letters cited in the appendix and Sloane MSS 4067. f.81 (quoted above)
the only references to Charles duBois' participation in the scientific life of the group that
have so far come to light are three letters cited in Nichols (1817);

Mr Tillcman Botiart was with mc; and presently came Mr Maningham. with Mr Rand;
and soon after that, Mr Dubois and my Brother. It is the first lime so many (lor there
are few more) have met together since I came into England . . . wc remembered all our
Botanic Friends. (10 May 17IU. William Sherard to Richard Richardson)

I fear Mr Dubois has suffered as much as others. Not having been at Mitcham all the
winter, till within this ten days, having been long ill: I called in on him this evening.

10 L. JF.SSOP

and was told he was returned mueh heltcr. but was lain down. (28 March 1721.
Sherard to Richardson, discussing gardens)

Dr Dillenius ... is to go to Mitchain to view what Mr Dubois has. (Dillenius was
preparing a book on Lichenes. Musci &c) (7 December 1721. Sherard to Richardson)

Apart from the insect notebook presented here, which is dated 1692 and 1695, there is
no evidence of Charles duBois" involvement in these activities before his letter to Sir
Hans Sioane dated 29 May 1697 (Sloane MSS 4036, f.316: see appendix).

An analysis of the Sloane correspondence, Collinson (1766) and Nichols (1817) as well
as the duBois insect notebook provides us with a list of some of the naturalists of that
time who were Charles duBois' acquaintances. The known names are: Tilleman Bobart,
Joannes Philippus (aka Jacobus) Breynius, Peter Collinson. John Cox, Samuel Dale,
James (?=Joseph) Dandridge, Dr J. J. Dillenius, Samuel Doody. Richard Fildon, Rev.
Thomas Maningham, Joseph Miller. James Newton. James Petiver, Leonard Plukenet,
Isaac Rand, Richard Richardson, Tancred Robinson, William Sherard and his brother
James, Sir Hans Sloane, William Stonestreet and John Verdy. The only one of these
scientific associates mentioned in Charles duBois' will was Isaac Rand, who was
bequeathed £10, but as his profession (apothecary) was stated in the will, he may have
served the duBois family in a professional capacity, as did Sloane (Sloane MSS 4056,
f.62 — see appendix).

duBois' friends outside the scientific world must have included men of considerable
power, as in 1702 he described Robert Harley, then Speaker of the House of Commons,
and Sir Francis Wyndham as being 'both my very kind friends' (Add. MSS 22851, f. 186
[see appendix]). Foster (1924) noted that a Charles duBois attended the funeral of
Samuel Pepys in June 1703 and was given a ring value 15 shillings, but there is no
evidence that it was this Charles duBois.

duBois provided observations to John Ray, as Ray (1724: 364) includes the statement:
Violae canlnae varietatem, si non speciem diversam ohservavit D. Du-Bois . . . Maio
mense in pc2scuis circa Miicham. There is, however, no evidence that the two men ever
met, although they did have mutual friends, e.g. Petiver & Sloane (see Raven, 1942 for
information on Ray's associates), nor that he met Dr Buckley, who sent him curiosities
from India (Add. MSS 22851, f.184-185 [see appendix]).

The Introduction of Rice to Carolina

Collinson (1766) gives an account of the introduction of rice into the (then) British
colony of Carolina. It reads:

In the year 1696. my sagacious friend Charles Dubois, then |sic| treasurer to the Ea<:t
India Company, told me often with pleasure, that he first put the Carolinians on the
culture of rice.

He happened one day, in that year, to meet Thomas Marsh, a Carolina merchant, at
the coffee house, to whom he said, 1 have been thinking, from the situation, nature of
the soil, and climate, that rice may be produced to great advantage in Carolina: But
says Marsh, how shall we get some to try? Why. says Dubois. 1 will enquire for it
amongst our India captains. — Accordingly, a money bag full of Fmsi India rice was
given to Marsh, and he sent it to South Carolina; and in the year 1698. he told his
friend Dubois, that it had succeeded very well.

A briefer account of Collinson's recollection is to be found in a draft letter from
Collinson to Samuel Eveleigh dated 22 April 1737 (in the library of the Linnean Society,
teste Dr A. W. Armstrong), which reads:

CHARLES OLIBOIS' INSECT NOTES 11

Mr Dubois. Treasurer to the E. India Comp, who is yett Living, has Several times told
Mee that att the request of Mr. Marsh a Marchant He Procur'd for him a Hundred
pound Money bag of Rice to send to Carolina . . .

Foster (1924) claims, however, that it was not Charles duBois but his step-brother
John who was responsible for the introduction of rice to Carolina. It is of course possible
that Charles utilised John's influence in the East India Company to help him in his
scheme and John thus obtained some of the credit.

It should be noted that rice did succeed very well in Carolina (see Collinson, 1766), but
that further introductions were initially necessary before it became properly established.

duBois and the Royal Society

Charles duBois was elected a Fellow of the Royal Society in 1700. At that time, election
to Fellowship was not an honour conferred usually upon exceptionally outstanding
scientists as it is now, but seems to have been open to anyone with a serious scientific
interest.

An index exists for entries in the Journal Book of the Royal Society up to the year
1700. Those concerning duBois are as follows:

13 April 1698; 'Mr Cha", Dubois presented an entire Cocode Maldivia [?Coco de Mer,
Lodoicea maldntca] for which great rarity it was ordered y' he should have the thanks
of the Society and that Mr Hunt should make an Exact Draught of it to represent it in
sev' postures and y' it sH be carefully preserved in ye Repository.'

1 March 1698/9: It was reported that seeds from the East India collection had been
examined by Sloane and given to Dr Uvedale. Mr Doudy [= Doody?). the Bishop of
London, the Duchess of Beaufort, Mr Dubois and Mr Bobart, who would try to grow
them and report back to the Society on their success.

30 November 170(1: Mr Charles Dubois, Capt. Edmund Hally and Mr John Chile of
Oxford were also ballotted & Chosen Members of the Society.'

Another entry has been seen in the Journal Book, dated 3 December 1701: a report
that seeds from Virginia were to be divided between the 'Duchess of Beaufort, the
Bishop of London, Dr Uvedale. Mr Waller, Mr Dubois and Mr Doody.'

On 27 May 1714 it was reported that: Mr Charles DuBois some time since Chosen a
ffellow of the R.S. being put to the ballot his Election was Confirmed, and being
present sealed the Bond paid his Admission money Subscribed the obligation and was
Admitted a Fellow of the R.S.' It is not clear why duBois waited 14 years between
election and admittance.

The Genus Duboisia

The genus Duboisia (Scrophulariaceae) was described by Robert Brown (Brown. 1810).
It has been claimed (e.g. in the Charles duBois entry in the Dictionary of National
Biography) that Duboisia was named in honour of Charles duBois, yet there is no
evidence in the original description to support the theory. Don (1838: 479) stated that
Duboisia was named after Louis Dubois.

12 L. JESSOP

Charles duBois' Collections

In his will (P.R.O. 1 1/705 [264 Browne]), Charles duBois bequeathed to his brother-in-
law Ebeneezer all of his books and also:

all my Books of specimens of Dryed plants the cases and drawers in which the same
are all my natural and artificial curiosities and samples of all my Roman and other
coins and medalls and whatsoever shall be in my closet at Mitcham ... or in the
gardens there to be held and enjoyed by him . . . except and rescr\ing unto my heire
Sarah Charlotte duBois the liberty of taking to her own use such Books Coins and
other curiosities in the said closet as she shall think fitt

Concerning the library, several books are mentioned in the insect notebook and
duBois' correspondence, but it is possible that he had seen some or all of these in the
libraries of his friends. The only work that can be said with certainty to have been owned
by duBois is Albin ( 1720) A Natural History of F.nglish Insects, as his name is among the
list of subscribers.

The next mention of the collection was in Anon (1812), which comprises notes made
by Mendes da Costa on collections of naturalists. Da Costa says of duBois that "he had
collections of shells, fossils &c of which I saw some at Mr Waldo's, junior, about 1760."
Presumably on the death of Ebeneezer duBois the Closet and its contents had passed on
to the nephew Waldo duBois.

The present whereabouts of the Roman and other coins, books, shells, fossils etc. is
not known: they may still exist or they may not, but the specimens of dried plants did
survive and are now located in the collections of Oxford University, possibly being
acquired by that institution through the influence of Sarah (grand-daughter of Samuel
Waldo, Charles duBois' Stepmother's brother), who had married Humphrey Sibthorp,
the Sherardian Professor of Botany in 1740 (Jones, 186.^: 16).

The herbarium was described in detail by Druce (1928), who described the way in
which it was badly treated under the direction of Professor Balfour. Druce also listed the
British plants contained in the herbarium and some of the botanists who contributed
specimens: most of the known British collectors of the period are represented as well as
foreign botanists such as Pitton de Tournefort. Collections of plants from India and the
Cape are mentioned as well as their collectors. The herbarium also contains specimens
that Mark Catesby collected in America, which indicates that Charles duBois was one of
those who provided the money for his expedition. He also subscribed to W. Houstoun's
expedition to the Spanish colonies in the Americas in 1732 (Sloane MSS 405.3, f. 167).

Charles duBois contributed specimens of plants to the Sloane herbarium, and these
are discussed by Dandy (Dandy. 1958). If duBois had a collection of preserved insects
and if they had been incorporated in the Sloane collection, they would almost certainly
have perished in the "periodical bonfires of Sloanian specimens' held by W. E. Leach. By
1833 it was reported that "literally not a vestige' remained of Sloane's insect collection
(Stearn, 1981:205-206).

Charles duBois' Character

It is usual in biographies to give some indication of the character of the person portrayed.
In the case of Charles duBois there is not much on which to base a character analysis:
his correspondence reveals very little about his private life, and he did not commit to
paper any of those violent differences of opinion that generally cast light on historic
personalities.

CHARLES DUBOIS' INSECTNOTES 13

Although Charles duBois often signed his letters as 'your humble and obedient
servant", it is to be doubted that this was any more than a formula: letter-writers of the
seventeenth and eighteenth centuries had no more humility and obedience than
twentieth century writers have sincerity or fidelity. No portrait is known to exist, so we
cannot read his character from his features.

The contemporary references to duBois" character are few. Petiver calls him his
'worthy friend' (Sloane MSS 2347 item 77), while Peter Collinson refers to him as 'a very
curious gentleman'; curious in those days meaning full of curiosity, not implying
strangeness as it does today (letter to William Byrd II, 1730 in Virginia Historical
Society) and on another occasion calls him 'my sagacious friend' (Collinson, 1766).

Because of the frequent references in his correspondence to meetings (at Coffee
Houses or Drinking Houses or at the houses of his friends), Charles duBois leaves an
overall impression of being a fairly 'clubable' character, yet it should be remembered
that there is only a handful of such references in a life span of 83 years.

Foster (1924) painted the following pen-picture:

To myself 1 Hgure him as a kindly old gentleman in spectacles, riding down from
London on a Friday evening, and reining in his nag to a walk as the lavender fields of
Mitcham come into view; or later on, seated in his library over a cup of tea, telling his
niece the news of the town and turning over the leaves of a botanical treatise to settle
some question which has occurred to him during his journey; or next morning, in a
shabby coat and with a bandanna handkerchief tied round his head, pottering about
his sunny garden and in and out of his greenhouses, marking the progress of his latest
importations and scribbling additions to his notes.

Attractive as such a romantic picture of the man is, we should not forget that there is no
evidence to support it.

To the present editor, the deepest insight into Charles duBois' character is the phrase
that occurs in the last paragraph of his will (P.R.O. 11/705 [264 Browne]), which was
dated 29 April 1737, three years before his decease. It says: 'and now heartily and
sincerely forgiveing all and every person whatsoever that have in any way injured me I
most humbly recommend my Soul unto thy hands. ' What is most telling is not that he is
remembering his friends, as most people would at such a time, but at the last
remembering his enemies kindly. This marks him as an essentially good man.

NOTES ON THE MANUSCRIPT

Introduction

The manuscript reproduced here in facsimile is now located in the Entomology Library
of the British Museum (Natural History), where it has the press mark S.B.o D.I2 A.
Notes on the hrst and last pages indicate that the work was purchased from Professor J.
Percival of 'Leighton'. Shinlield Green, Reading, Berks by the British Museum (Natural
History) on the 28 February 1945 for £4.00. The history of the manuscript is otherwise
unknown. Professor John Percival (1863-1949) worked at the University of Reading
between 1902 and 1932 where he was first lecturer in, and later Professor of Agricultural
Botany (obituary by Brierly. 1949).

The authorship of the manuscript was anonymous until 1986. when work on editing it
for publication began. There are two indications supporting the belief that it is the work

14 L. JESSOP

of Charles duBois: first, the handwriting, which agrees strongly with that contained in his
autograph letters, and secondly, there is an entry in James Petiver's collecting diary (not
the work of James Plukcnel, as claimed by Hammond, 1975 — the handwriting is
definitely that of Petiver) which says "77 Papilio aurora marmorea oculata . . . This I
caught Sept 23. 1695 going to my worthy Friends Mr Ch: Du-Bois's at Mitcham . . .'
(Sloane MSS 2347). This last entry agrees with Papilio 9 of the present notebook, which
was reportedly 'given me by M' Petiver 23"" September who took it v"^^ Same day coming
to Mitcham'.

In 1986 the pages of the work were thick and hard, having been at some time painted
with starch, but in that year they were treated to remove the starch; that process also
resulted in the writing becoming a little fainter. The book was also disbound (it was not
at that time in its original binding) and currently comprises single sheets, the exception
being the two folios containing the sideways-written notes, which are joined together. It
is the intention of the British Museum (Natural History) Entomology Library to have the
book rebound in the near future.

The manuscript comprises 64 folios of Charles duBois' work and a title page added
later by a different hand, which is also reproduced here. Some comments on the contents
of the work by an unknown hand are associated with the manuscript, but are not
reproduced here. Also not reproduced are the 20 sides that are completely blank.

The folios are sized 145 mm by 181-183 mm in the first part of the work (as it was
found in 1986) and from the folio beginning with Notes 14 to the end of the work the
pages are sized 145 mm by 186 mm. The manuscript is in sepia coloured ink on cream
coloured paper, and is reproduced here in slightly greater contrast than the original. A
small part of the manuscript, for instance the page containing Scarabeus 33-35, is in
blacker ink.

At one stage, when the work was ordered as it was found in 1986. the pages have been
numbered, a number being written in pencil at the bottom right hand corner of alternate
sides.

The order of the pages in 1986 did not present a logical progression of notes, and the
order has been re-arranged in the present work. There is no evidence that the sequence
of pages then or now is as Charles du Bois intended.

The order as bound was:

Papilio 1-12 Notes (sideways) 21-33

Tunbridge Wells 4-5 Apis 1^

Tunbridge Wells 1-3 Cimex

Muscac quadripennes 1-3 Musca 1-11

Musca 12-17 Palaena 1-30

Scarabeus 1-11 Notes 1-20

Scarabei aquatici Notes 34-79

Pseudo-Scarabei Vcspa 1-10

Gryllotalpa Miscellany thoughts about vegetables.

Notes (sideways) 28-31

The manuscript is capable of division into four parts:

1. Notes upon Insects, which contains 79 entries, and is dated 1692-1695. One part of
these notes is written sideways, and does not interpolate well with the other pages
(note 20 is on the reverse of a page starting with note .34, so the sideways-written notes
cannot be inserted in numerical order).

2. Several sections of descriptions of insects arranged systematically by genus, but not
systematically within genus.

3. Descriptions of five insects collected in Tunbridge Wells

CHARLES DUBOIS' INSECT NOTES 15

4. Miscellany thoughts about vegetables.

Some species occur twice in the notebook, once in Notes and once under their genus.
Where this is the case there is a spot of ink present at the end of each line of text of Notes,
and in some cases a vertical line is drawn through the text. This, and the general
untidiness of Notes when compared to the sections arranged systematically leads
naturally to the conclusion that Notes was a rough piece of work that was later re-
organised, the generic arrangement being the final version. It is not clear, however, why
some of the species were re-worked and some were not.

In the present work the generically-arranged section is presented first, in the order:
Papilio; Phalaena; Scarabeus; Scarabei aquatici; Pseudo-Scarabei; Gryllotalpa; Muscae
quadripennes; Musca; Vespa; Apis; Cimex.

This section is followed by the five Tunbridge Wells specimens, then Notes and finally
the miscellaneous thoughts on vegetables.

Places and Dates of Capture

The year of capture of individual species is not known, except for the indication of 1692
and 1695 on the first page of Notes, and for Papilio 9, which the Petiver collecting diary
(Sloane MSS 2347) confirms was caught in 1695.

The dates in the diary are not those of the modern calendar, as 11 days were omitted
from the year 1752 in order to bring the British into line with the Julian calendar. All of
the dates in the diary are therefore 1 1 days later in the modern calendar (1 April old style
is equivalent to 12 April new style). In duBois' time, the New Year began on the 25
March, which is why some of the dates given in correspondence written early in the year
are given two years, e.g. 2 February 1712/3 (Sloane MSS 4065, f. 100)— this date would
be the 13 February 1713 new style.

The places of capture given in the notebook are as follows: between London and
Mitcham (Papilio 9); by the riverside (Papilio 11 and Scarabeus 11); Tunbridge Wells
Common (Tunbridge Wells 5 and Phalaena 19); the Lane near East Field [now Eastfields
Lane, Mitcham?) (Musca 14 and Phalaena 26); Greenwich town (Scarabeus 9); in the
street in London (Scarabeus 40); the gravel pits (Scarabeus 41); 'about our house in
London' (Pseudo-scarabeus); 'in my brother's garden at Hackney' (Musca 1) and Mr
Stonestreet's house at Carshalton (Phalaena 26).

It is probable that most of the remaining specimens were collected in the vicinity of
Mitcham, but it should be borne in mind that there is no concrete evidence for that
assumption.

Literature mentioned in the Manuscript

Notes 57 and 60 mention Dni Hook Micrograph. This is: Hooke, R. 1665. Micrographia:
or some phvsiologwal descriptions oj miiuite bodies made by magnifying glasses.

Notes 29 and Phalaena 13 mention Mouffet, and question its accuracy. Mouffet is
quoted in Latin and not English, which may indicate the edition duBois used: Mouffet,
T. 1634. Insectoruni sive minimorum Animaliiim Theatnim, not the 1658 translation.

Pseudo Scarabei mentions Swammerdam. This is: Swammerdam, J. 1669. Historia
Insectoriim generulis.

Apis 1 (Bombylius) mentions Purchas's Theatre of flying insects. Anno 1657. This is:
Purchas, S. 1657. A Theatre ofpoliticull Flying Insects. Wherein especially the nature . . .
and the manner of right-ordering of the Bee. is discovered and described.

16 L. JESSOP

duBois' Assumptions

Part of the attraction of old works is the amusement to be gained from the sometimes
outlandish assumptions and prejudice they contain. Thence the continued attraction of
works such as the bestiaries and Mouffets Theater of Insects.

The duBois manuscript contains little that is ridiculous: it is a work of sound common
sense about a mundane (rather than exotic) subject, and there are no unicorns or other
fantastic beasts. Probably the only outlandish notion in the notebook is that the head of
the caterpillar is that end which is the tail of the butterfly (Phalaena 14). This notion is
not original, for it is contained in Mouffet's discussion of silk molhs where he says: 'This
is a pleasing thing and worthy to be noted, that the head of the Silk-worm, makes the tail
of the butterfly in that golden coloured metamorphosis, and the tail the head; which also
happeneth in all other catterpillars that are changed into an Aurelia." The belief possibly
arose from seeing the head of the butterfly emerging from the free end of a hanging
pupa, and assuming that head end of the caterpillar attaches to the pupation site
(whereas in fact they attach by the tail end). The belief had already been refuted by Ray
in 1660, who says (translation by Ewan and Prime): It will not be proper (for the matter
can be easily observed) to draw attention to the mistake which Moulet and others make
in asserting that the head of the caterpillar is changed into the tail of the moth: for in
every caterpillar that I have seen the exact opposite is fact.'

Some of the instances where duBois leaves plain description and indulges in supposition
are:

Papilio 8: The first pair [of legs are] plumose serving to brush the eyes and head I

suppose.

Phalaena 25: the female soon lays her eggs whether she doth coire or not. though in this

last case they are sterile.

Scarabeus 2: Perhaps this may be the female, which in most cases is the biggest.

Pseudo-Scarahei: It appears they grow after exclusion.

Notes 14: The mouth is like a lobster's claws, opening sideways and one going over the

other so that it seems to be an insect of prey in armour.

Notes 26: Query if kin to the cuckoo spit (note that duBois does not describe the cuckoo

spit bug — perhaps he thought it was too common to include).

Notes 49: This contrivance is to preser\e the true wings from being wetted when they

swim.

In some cases duBois questions his own identifications, or gives reasons for them. For
instance, in the description of Musca 1 he says that the way of flying and looks of it would
make one suspect it a bee, but that it has but two wings and a head of the make of a fly.
This distinction between Hymenoptera and Diptera was probably made after he had
described Notes 18 (which is hymenopteran) as a dipteran (Musca respoides . . .).
The distinctions between Hymenoptera and dipterous mimics of Hymenoptera suggest
that duBois was familiar with the notion of looking beyond superhcial appearances and
at the underlying structures of an animal when classifying it.

List of Determinations

The help of various members of the staff of the Entomology Department of the British
Museum (Natural History) in arriving at the following determinations is gratefully
acknowledged.

Abbreviations used in this section are: Dipt., Diptera; Col., Coleoptcra; Hym.,
Hymenoptera; Lep., Lepidoptcra.

CHARLES DUBOIS' lNSr;CT NOTES '^

(Jenus Papilionaeum (all I>epldoptera)

1 NympliuliJjc-' /l,i,'/i"v iinuiic (Small Idrloiscshcll)

2 Pieridac. Pieris rapae tcmalc (Small While)

3 Satyridac. Lasiommiitii megera {WM)

4 Nymphalidac. Vunc.sra a(u/rt«M (Red Admiral)

5 Pieridac. Gonopleryx rliamm (Brimstone)

6 Nymphalidac. Polygoma c-alhum (Comma)

7 Pieridac. Pifru hra.vs/iaf (Large White)

8 Nymphalidac. Cv«'/i(« <"«/"' (Painted Lady)

9 Lycaenidae. /.yiucmj /i/i/ucu.v (Small Copper)

10 Satyridac. Maniola jitrtiini (Meadow Brown)

1 1 Satyridac. Aplumuipm hvpeninlhiis (Ringlet)

12 Satyridac. Maniohi iiiriiim underside (Meadow Brown)

Genus Phalaenaceum

1 Lep.. Pyralidae. //v/«<i|)V,i,'W ii'."a''.v (Gold Triangle)

2 Lep.. Pyralidae. ? Cramhiis pcrtella

3 Lep., Pyralidae. '?? Agripfuhi iiuiiiniauiki

4 Lep. indct.
.S L.cp. indet.
h Lep. indet.

7 Lep.. Noctuidac. Aulograplui gumma (Silver Y)

H Lep. indet.

9 Lep., Pterophoridac. Pierophonis penladMlyhi

Id Lep. indet.

1 1 Lep., Pyralidae. ?? Caloptria falsella

12 Lep., Arctiidae. Tyria jacohaeae (Cinnabar Moth)
1.3 Lep., Zygaemdac. Zygama Infiilii. or Z. Itmucruf

14 Lep., Hepialidae. ? Hepuilm lupulmm (Common Swift)

l.S L.cp. indct.

Ih Lep.. Noctuidac. Acnmiiu psi. or A. Iridens

17 Lep., Hepialidae. Hepialits luimiili female (Ghost Swift)

IK Lep., Pyralidae. '.' Aphamia soctella female (Bee Moth)

m Lep., Lymantriidae. ? F.uproctis chrysorrhoea (Brown-Tail) or I.vmiilria salicis

20 Lep., Arctiidae. Arena ca/a (Garden Tiger)

21 Lep., Noctuidac. Agnilis exclamatioms male (Heart and Dart)

22 Lep., Noctuidac. ?? /Mvr/»>nno species.

23 Lep., Geometridae. Xamlunhiie jimiuala (Garden Carpet)

24 Lep., Geometridae. Campiogrumma bilmeata (Yellow Shell)

25 Lep. indet.

26 Lep, Geometridae. 77;m«(/ra gnsfudj (Blood-vein)

27 indct.

28 indct.
24 indet.
30 indet.

Scarabinum Genus (all Coleoptera)

1 Carabidae. 7 Nebna hmicoUis

2 Carabidae. Calalhiis fuscipes

3 Carabidae. Carahns sp.

4 Chrysomclidae. Timanha tenehricosa

5 Anobiidac. ? Slegohium pankeum

6 Elateridae. Melamiliis villiisiis

7 Elateridae. '} Atliom hacmorrhiitdalis

8 Cerambycidae. SlentKorus meruiianus
'^ Scarabaeidae. Ceioma aiirata

10 Chrysomclidae. Gaslrophysa vindula

11 Chrysomelidac. Phaedon farmoriciae

18 L. JESSOP

12 Chrysomelidae. "? Prasocuris jimci

13 Mordcllidac. MordelUstena abdominalis

14 Canlharidac, Cantharis pellucida or C. nigricans

15 CaiMhdTidaQ. Cantharis lividaoT C. cryptica

16 Canlharidac. Rha^onycha fidva

17 Oedemeridae. Ischnomera caendea or Oedetm-ra lurida

18 Curculionidac. Ciuniis sp.

19 Coccinellidac. Adalia bipunciaia

20 Scarabaeidae. Phyllopertha horlicola

21 Cerambycidac. Clylus arielLs

22 Curculionidac. Phyllohius ?pomaceiis

23 Tcnebrionidae. Blups muvronata

24 Carabidae. Harpalus affinis

23 ? Dermestidac (Dermesies sp.) or Anobiidae (Xesiohium rujovdhsum)

26 Coleoptera indet.

27 Scarabaeidae. -4p/i(>(^'w5 sp.

28 Carabidae. Notiophdiis ? higuttaius

29 Pyrochroidae. Pyrochroa serraticomis

30 Carabidae. Pleroslichus madidiis

31 Carabidae. Cicindeia campeslris

32 Curculionidac. "!Ph\llohius urgentatus

33 Coccinellidac. Adalia '^bipunciaia or decempunclala

34 Cerambycidac. "^Grammoptera mjicornis

35 Tcnebrionidae. Cylindrinolus laeviocloslrialus

36 Tcnebrionidae. Cylindrinolus laeviocloslrialus

37 Chrysomelidae. Gaslrophysa viridula

38 Scarabaeidae. Melolonlha meloloniha

39 Melyridac. Malachtus '.'bipuslulalus or vindis

40 Silphidae. /"/id/idto/j/ii/Hj species, probably 5mH(i/i«

41 Carabidae. "^Bembidion species, or Asaphidion species

Scarabei aquatici

1 Col.. Dytiscidae Probably -4^a/j(ts species

Pseudo-Scarabei

1 Dictyoptera. Blatla orienlalis

Gryllotalpa

1 Orthoplcra. Gryllolalpidae. Cirvllotalpa sp . if Bnlish then G. gryllotalpa

Muscae quadripennes

1 Mecoplcra, Panorpidae. Panorpa sp.

2 Ncuroptcra. Chrysopidae. Chrysopa sens. lat.

3 Neuroptera. Chrysopidae. Chrysopa sens. lal.

Musca (all Diptera)

1 Syrphidac. ?Lucozona lucorum. Volucella inflala or V.pellucens

2 Syrphidae. '!Syrphus sp.

3 Syrphidac. ?Syrphus ^p.

4 Syrphidae. 'JPlaiycheirus sp.

5 ?Sarcophagidac, 'JSarcophaga

6 Sarcophagidac. Sarcophaga sp.

7 Stratiomyiidae. Sargus sp.

8 Syrphidae.

9 Syrphidae. Erislalis lenax

10 Straliomyiidae. '^Beris sp.

1 1 Mmpididac. F.mpis livida male.

12 Muscidac. Helinasp.

13 Diplera indct.

CHARLES DUBOIS' INSECT NOTES

14 Syrphidac. Chrysoloxum caulum

15 Dolichopodldac, Ptn-iiliihothnis nohililattis

16 lUiciUa (Calliphoridac) or Dohehopodidae

17 Syrphidac. Rhmgia campeslris

Vespinum genus

1 Hym., indet.

2 Hym.. indet.

3 Hym.. '.'Myrmosidac. Myrmusa

4 Hym., Ichneumonidac

5 Hym , Ichneumonidac

6 Hym., Ichneumonidac

7 Hym., Ichneumonidac

8 indet.

9 Hym., Ichneumonidac
10 Hym., Ichneumonidac

Apinum genus

1 Hym., Apidae. Bomhiis llucorum

1 Hym., Apidae. IChelosumw

3 Hym, Tcnlhrcdmidac. 'Alhiilia

4 Hym. Chrysididae.

Genus Cimicinum

1 Hemiplcra, Pentalomidac (immature).

Tunbridge Wells

1 Hym., Apidae. Romhiis f.p.. 'lapidariiis or niderariiis

2 indet.

3 Lep.. Pieridae. Pieri.s napi (Green-veined White)

4 Lep., Satyridae. Pyroma liihonus male (Gatekeeper)

5 Col, Geotrupidac. Geolrupes ?spiniger or slercorarius

Notes upon Insects &c.

1 Dipt.. Empididac. F.mpis Ifs.tt'lhua male

2 Lep., Geomctridac (immature)

3 Lep. (immature)

3 (repeated number) indct.

4 jScarabcus 6]

5 Hym., Tenthrcdinidac.

6 IScarabeus I8|

7 Lep., Noctuidac. Cm ullia verhasci iMu\]c'in)

8 Lep. (immature)

9 Dipt. Tahanidae. Haemalopota sp., probably H. pluvialis

10 Hemiptcra, contlalion of aphids and typhlocybine Cicadellidac

11 Lep., Cossidae. 7? Zeuzera pyrina (Leopard Moth)

12 |Phalaena9|

13 mdet.

14 [Vespa 1|
LS jcimex 1|
1(1 IMusca 15]

17 IScarabeus 13|

18 Hym, Tenthrcdinidac. IMacrophya^p.

19 IScarabeus I7|

20 [Vespa 4|

21 IScarabeus 21]

22 IScarabeus 14|

23 IScarabeus 15|

24 IScarabeus 201

19

20 L. JESSOP

25 Hym., Tenthridinidac. Nemalm ribesii (immalurc)

26 Hemiptera, Miridae. Lygocoris sp.

27 indct. . possibly the same as Notes 26

28 Col.. Njtidulidac. Mfligethes aenetts

29 Thysanoptera. Phlaeothripidae

28 (repeated number) Odonata. Libetlulidae. LiheUula depressa

29 (repeated number) Odonala. '^ Platycnemu pennipes (Platyencmididae). or Coenagrionidae

30 ?Diplopoda

31 ?Coleoptera

32 Col.. Carabidae. Agonum dorsale

33 Dipt.. Anisopodidae. Sylvicola fenesiralis

34 C'Vcspa 5]

35 |'.'Vespa4J

36 Hym., Tenthredinidae. '^Tenthreda

37 IMusca 10)

38 Dipt-, Conopidae, Myopa sp,. probably ;V/. testacea

39 Dipt. Syrphidac. Myolepta luleula
4(1 Dipt-. Syrphidae. Chrysogaster sp.

41 Dipt.. Platystomatidae. Platystoma senunationis

42 |Scarabeus8]

43 jphalaena 16|

44 Hemiptera, Cercopidae. 1 Phdaenus spumarius
4.^ Dipt indet.

46 Dipt. ■^'Syrphidae

47 Dipt.. '.'Syrphidae

48 Dipt.. 'Syrphidae

49 (Scarabei aquatici 1|

50 jphalaena 12]

51 jphalaena I3|

52 jPhalaena I4|

53 |Scarabeus9|

54 jscarabeus 10)

55 Dipt, indet.
.56 IPhalaena 15|

57 Dipt., Calliphoridae. Calliphora sp.. probably C. vicitw

58 Dipt.. ?Lonchaea sp. (Lonchaeidae)

59 Dipt, indet.

60 Dipt, (there are figures in Hook's Micrographia of Culex)

61 IPapilio 10|

62 IScarabeus 5]

63 IScarabeus 4|

64 (Pseudo-Scarabei l|

65 [Scarabeus 33]

66 (Scarabeus 6|

67 [Scarabeus 7|

68 jphalaena 17]

69 jPhalaena I8|

70 jScarabeus 16]

71 Dipt, indet

72 Dipt.. Syrphidae. Platycheirus sp.

73 Dipt, indet.

74 IScarabeus 11|

75 jScarabeus 12]

76 jPapilio 11 1

77 jpapilio 12i

78 Ephemcroptera. Baetidae. Kloeon dipierum

79 Lep., Noctuidac (Vrani/rflpi.vi (Broom Moth)

CHARLES DUBOIS' INSECT NOTES 21

FURTHER READING

Allen (1976) is the best general introduction to the history of natural history in Britain,
and if possible this should be supplemented by reading through back issues of the Journal
of the Society for the Bibliography of Natural History (later Archives of Natural History),
which contains some very readable articles. Raven (1942) is an excellent work, which
describes the life and achievements of John Ray, some of whose friends and correspond-
ents were either probably or certainly acquainted with Charles duBois.

On the entomological side Lisney (196(1) contains biographical notes on those
entomologists who published during the 17th and 18th centuries, as well as a
detailed bibliography of the period. Gardner (1930) deals in detail with the compila-
tion and publication of Mouffet's Theater of Insects. Allen (1967) and Bristowe (1976)
discuss the entomological activities of duBois" contemporaries, especially Joseph
Dandridge. Bodenheimer (1928-29 — in German) discusses extensively entomology
before Linnaeus.

Several British naturalists contemporary with duBois, mainly known as botanists, are
discussed in Pasti (1950), a microfilm of which is lodged in the library of the British
Museum (Natural History). The best description of the botanical scene of the period is
contained in Henrey (1975). Dandy (1958) contains accounts of those botanists who are
known to have contributed to the Sloane Herbarium, many of whom must have been
friends of duBois. Most of the references to duBois as a botanist were first traced through
Britten and Boulger (1931), which was revised by Desmond (1977).

The social history of 17th-century London is covered excellently in Beier and Finlay
(1986), which contains a large number of references to papers on the state of the
metropolis in duBois' time. The history of the East India Company is covered by several
works, but the most detailed account by far of the duBois family involvement in it is
contained in Foster (1924), which also contains a drawing of Charles duBois' grave.

Acknowledgements. I would like to thank the lollowing for their assistance in the production of
this work: the Entomology Librarians of the British Museum (Natural History) (Miss J. Harvey
and Miss P. Gilbert); the librarians of the British Library. Guildhall tJbrary, India Office Library,
Linncan Society of London, Public Record Office and Royal Society; Mr D. E. Allen; Mr E. N.
Montague; Dr A. W. Armstrong, and my colleagues in the Entomology Department of the British
Museum (Natural History). Special thanks are due to the Photographic Unit of the British
Museum (Natural History) for their excellent work in photographing the manuscript.

Thanks are due to the British Library and the Royal Society for granting permission to publish
transcripts of manuscripts in their collections.

reff;rences

Unpublished References: abbreviations used

Add. MSS: British Library, London, Additional Manuscripts.

I. OR.; Records of the East India Company now held in the India Office Library and Records,

London.
P.R.O.; Manuscripts in the Public Record Office London.
Sloane MSS: Sloane manuscripts in the British Library, London.

22 L. JESSOP

Published References

[Anon] 1812. Notices and Anecdotes of Literati. Collectors. &c. from a MS by the late Mendcs de

Costa and collected between 1747 and 1788. The Gentleman's Magazine and HislorUal Chronicle

82: 205-207.
Allen, D. E. 1966. Joseph Dandridge and the first Aurelian Society. The Entomologist's Record and

Journal of Variation 78: 89-94.

1976. The Naturalist in Britain, a Social History. London (Allen Lane) xii + 292 pp.

Aubrey, J. 1718. The Natural History and Antiquities of the County of Surrey. London (Curll)

Volume II. viii + 307 pp.
Beier, A. L. & Finlay, R. 1986. The Making of the Metropolis. London 1500-1700. London & New

\ork (Longman) x + 283 pp.
Bodenheimer, F. S. 1928-29. Materialen zur Geschichie der Entomologie his Linne. Berlin (Junk)

Volume 1, X + 498 pp; volume II. vi + 486 pp.
Bristowc. W. S. 1967. The life & work of a great English naturalist. Joseph Dandridge (1664-

1746). Entomologist's Gazette 18: 73-89.
Brierly, W. B. 1949. John Percival. Proceedings of the Linnean Society of London 161: 248-251.
Britten, J. & Boulger, G. S. 1931. A biographical Index of deceased British <t Irish Botanists.

London (Taylor & Francis) 342 pp.
Brown, R. 1810. Prodromus Florae Novae Hollandiue el Insula Van-Oiemen. London (Johnson)

592 pp.
Collinson, P. 1766. An account of the Introduction of Rice and Tar into our Colonies. The

Gentleman's Magazine and Historical Chronicle 36: 278-279.
Dandy, J. E. 1958. The Sloane Herbarium. London (British Museum (Natural History)) 246 pp.
Don, G. 1838. A General System of Gardening and Botany. London (Rivington & others) Volume

4. 908 pp.
Desmond, R. 1977. Dictionary of British and Irish Botanists and Horiiculturalists. London (Taylor

& Francis) xxvi + 747 pp.
Druce, G. C. 1928. British plants contained in the Du Bois Herbarium at Oxford. 1690-1723.

Report Botanical Society and Exchange Club of the British Isles 8: 463-493.
Foster, J. 1887. London Marriage Licences 1521-1869. London (Ouaritch) 1595 pp.
Foster, Sir W. 1924. The East India House: its history and associations. London (John Lane. The

Bodlcy Head) x + 250 pp.
Gardner, W. 1930. A Lancashire entomologist in the time of Queen Elizabeth. Annual Report and

Proceedings of the Lancashire and Cheshire Entomological Society 52-54: 31-52.
Hammond, P. M. 1975. Seventeenth century British Colcoptera from the Collection of Leonard

Plukenet (1642-1706). Entomologhis Gazette 26 : 261-268.
Henrey, B. 1975. British Botanical and Horticultural Literature before 1800. London. New York &

Toronto (Oxford University Press) Volume 11. xvi + 748 pp.
Hunter, Sir W. W. 1908. In: The Imperial Gazeleer of India. The Indian Empire. II. Historical.

Oxford (Clarendon Press) xxv + 573 pp.
Jones, M. C. 1863. Notes Respecting the Family of Waldo. Edinburgh (Printed for private

circulation) iv + 35 pp.
Lankester, E. 1898. The Correspondence of John Ray. London (The Ray Society) xvi + 502 pp.
Lisney, A. A. I960. A Bibliography of British Lepidoplera 1608-1799. London (Chiswick Press)

315 pp.
Loudon, J. C. 1838. Arboretum el Fruclicelum Rrittanicum. London (the author) Volume I . ccxxx

+ 494 pp.
Mouffet, T. 1658. The Theater of Insects: or lesser living Creatures. In: Topsell. E. The History of

Four Fooled Beasts and Serpents ... London (E.C.): 889-11.30. (reprinted 1967 by Cass.

London).
Nichols, J. 1817. Illustrations of the Literary History of the Eighteenth Century. Volume I. London

(Nichols. Son & Bentley) 840 pp.
Pa.sti, J. 1950. Consul Sherard: Amateur botanist and patron of learning. PhD thesis (University of

Illinois) 253 pp.
Raven, C. E. 1942. John Ray. Naturalist. His Life and Works. Cambridge (Cambridge University

Press) xix + .502 pp. (reprinted 1986 by Cambridge University Press).

CHARLES DUBOIS" INSECT NOTES 23

Ray, J. 1660. Catalogus Planlanim circa Canlabrigiam. Cambridge (Ncaland), & lAindon (Martin,

Allcstry & Dicas) 182 + 103 pp. (Translated by A. H. Ewan & C. T. Prime, 1975).

1710. Hiswna Insectoriim. London (Churchill) 400 pp.

1724. Svnopsis Melhodicii Stirpiiim. 3rd edition. London (Innys) 482 + 30 pp.

Stearn, W. T. 1981 . The Nutural History Museum at South Kensington. London (Heinemann) .xxiii

+ 414 pp.
Stearns, R. P. 1952. James Petiver Promoter of Natural Science, c. 1663-1718. Proceedings of the

American Antiquarian Society 62: 243-365.
Stow, J. 1603. A Survey of London (reprinted 1971, Oxford (Clarendon Press) two volumes, xcviii

+ 352 and 476 pp.) '

APPENDIX

Additional to the letters copied below, two manuscripts in the British Library signed by
duBois, and photocopies of three pages in the Plant Sciences Library in Oxford have
been examined:

Add.MSS 36,139, f.255 is a receipt for twenty nine pounds nine shillings and eight pence,
being 6% of £49L8., the value of 126 oz. of gold seized at Portsmouth (Add. MSS 36,139
f.254 is a letter signed by the secretary of the East India Company saying that the
company have no objection to the delivery of the gold. The note is dated 28th February
1732, by which date duBois was 76 years old).

Add. MSS 22,852, f. 173 is an official letter to Pitt regarding his status as President and
Governor of Fort St George. It is signed by duBois as well as several others, presumably
officials of the East India Company.

The Oxford manuscript comprises lists, apparently the contents of books of plants,
probably from India.

duBois Letters, in date order

1. Sloane MSS 4036, f. 3 16.

For Dr Hans Sloane

S' I beg your Pardon for not sending you the acco'. underwritten before, but
my want of Health & multiplicity of business of late hinder'd me from many
things, y' were my duty; & particularly that of paying this Respect to you: the
acco'. I have of a Jew of Amsterdam book keeper to the East India Company of
Holland is, that Gold is permitted to be exported from Japan by Authority, but
limited by Certain Regulations that are agreed to by y" Dutch & Japonese to a
determinate Quantity, as is also the whole Trade between them; I am sensible
what I lose by the misfortune of not enjoying your Conversation of late, which I
hope to regain in a little Time by more exact waiting on you, & the rest of the
good Company, I am

Yo' Obliged humble Serv'.
May 29"' 1697 Charles duBois.

2. Sloane MSS 3321, f.46.
[To Petiver]

Sr I send you some odd things y' came from India which I found by chance in
y'= remains of a person gone thither, if they are of no Significancy, commit y"'

24 1 . JFSSOP

to y' Flames. 1 should be glad you would please to give me your Opitiicm upon
the China Fragm'^. I sent you in a little brown paper book at your leisure. Prav
does not Mr Ray mention Somewhere a potamogeiton found upon Wandsworth
common, if he does or you guess what I aim at, refer me to the place, I am

Yo' humble Ser'
Rec'd ve Mav 8 1 7(K) Charles duBois

No 1

3. Add. MSS 22,851, f. 186.
For the Hon''''^ Tho. Pitt Esq.
President at Fort S' George
India.

Mr Charles Du Bovs lo recommend Mes' Lyde & Lockyer
ye Colchester Rec'' Sept Q'" 1702

Sr 98

I am obliged to recommend to you the bearers. M' James Lyde & M' Charles
Lockyer, the former is sent to India at the request of the worthy Speaker of the
House of Commons M' Robert Harley. the latter at the desire of another
member of the House S' Francis Wyndham. these Gentlemen are both my very
kind Friends. & the young Gentlemen now sent will I am persuaded deserve
your patronage. Your countenance & direction will be a favour which I shall
acknowledge on all occasions if you please to let them have it. 1 am already deep
in your Debt for your kindness to my brothers Family in his Absence, but your
freedome to me encourages me to go on further. I refer you to the General
Letter for publick Affairs, particularly about y" Union of the two Companyes.
which will put an End to the disputes between us at home & abroad; the
Company have a just Sense of the goodness of your Conduct in those unhappy
matters; I am

Sr

Yo' obliged humble Ser'
Feb. 18"' 171)1/2 Charles duBois.

4. Add. MSS 22,851, ff.184-185

For the Hon''''^ Thomas Pitt Esq. President of Fort S' George
from Mr Cha DuBois for the Colchest' Sep' the 9"' 1702
Answerd
S' 97

Your obliging letter of the 19"' Sept. 17(K) came to my hands for which. &
the favours therein mcntion'd. done to my brother & his Family I return to you
my hearty thanks, your kind promises of further Service I acknowlcdg with due
Respect. I have nothing to request of You but on my brothers account, that you
would favour him in giving him such advice & countenance as may be of use to
him, & to issue if possible in India, the remains of his unhappy accounts. And I
hope if it please God he live. He may do so well, as to keep himself clear from
any future troubles. & be in a Condition to make some return for your particular
friendship. Wc are at last agreed to unite with the New Company so that you will
be Eased of the Troubles you have undergone in the Support of our particular
Interest, in which every one of us as far as I hnd, is very amply satisfyed. & own
your acquitting your Self with Honour. Courage & Conduct on our behalf This
union you will have an account of by our Letters. My Share in contributing to it I
must in decency omit to mention, only I can truly say that when Some rubbs

CHARLES DUBOIS' INSECTNOTES

were removed, I applyed my small Capacity ti) effect it with all Sincerity &
diligence, & the adventurers who commissioned me one of their 7 Trustees in
that affaire, arc pleased not to censure my management therein. There are some
particulars in the agreement the reasons of which perhaps may not be presently
obvious, but when you shall consider that our business was not to diminish the
Powers of y^' New Company, w'^'' were to be our own. that many things were
enacted by Law which must be submitted to. it being no Season to offer at a new
Law, that we were subjected to become Members of the New by y° Act as it
stood upon any foot of agreement. & y'' Clauses subjecting all our affairs to
Entryes with them. & disputes about penaltycs & Forfeitures, I think upon the
whole it is well. The mutual Releases we give each other, & the Kings joining
therein sets all right; The powers reserved in the King to form us into one joint
Interest being the foundation of the whole, which was a thought it pleased God
to put into my Mind, & his Ma'"', being party in this new agreement gives us a
new form of Administration only, upon the Powers & Authorityes of y*" 2
Million act. w"*' is now equally ours & theirs.

S' I have taken Care of the freeing your Liquors from Freight the Court
readily ordering it upon the first motion. What you write about y" dead rich man
has too much truth. I belive affairs will never again be so unequally managed,
the Gentlemen of both Comp"\ who will be chosen I doubt not but so ballance
things as to render any attempts of that nature impracticable. Your not
remembering me I wonder not at, my Conversation & business not leading me
into your way. whereby I lost that happiness, but as you are pleased to allow mc
the Liberty of your acquaintance by Letters I shall be proud of any Opportunity
of expressing my just esteem for you for your honourable Management of the
Companys business. & for the generous Care of my Relations you have been
pleas'd to take. & Shall readily do you any Service in my power. I have but one
thing more to trouble you with, D' Buckley is so kind as to furnish me with some
Curiosityes in his way, they have been sent sometimes by the under Officers of
y'^ Ship, & thereby have been subject to delay & Searches here, if the Captain
were charged with them, their coming to my hands would be more Safe and
expeditios. I have thought sometimes that some of your best Indian fruits might
be persuaded to grow at S' Helena, by sending their fresh & ripe Stone Seeds or
kernells, the Cjovernour has directions to take Care of their planting., it would
be an improvement to the Hand. I ask your pardon for this long detention from

yo'. more weighty Affairs, & am

Yo' Obliged humb Serv'
Charles duBois
Since the above was writ. It has pleased God to take to himself our King, to our
great Surprize & Consternation. But the Queen now reigning has already by her
wise & good Conduct so gain'd the Hearts of her Subjects, as to lind no
Difference in their Happiness. I have directed the papers of state that have been
publick on this occasion to be put into the Companyes Packet.
London 13'" March I70I/2
Please to favour me in Sending the Enclosed to my bro. or Sister.

5.SloaneMSS4039, L22()

[To Sloane]

S' I mentioned to you the other day some Indian specimens Your allowing
me to present you with them gives you this Trouble, which upon your admission,
shall be follow'd by more. I owe a peculiar acknowledgement for the humanity
you always treat me with; this, when accompanyed with my thanks for your
favours may be a beginning to be out of debt. & enable me to venture running
on Score anew. I dare not say that your doubles of English specimens are what I

25

26

I.. JF.SSOP

want some of. unless I had merited more from you than I find my self capable of,
but Men of your Temper act ex mero motu. & free Grace Sometimes. I am

Yo' Obliged humb Ser'
DecM.1703 Charles duBois

6. Sloane MSS 4039, f. 221.

(To Sloane]

S' I am obliged to Dr Buckley at Fort St George & to be even with him
intend to send him a few books in his own way. You arc so Great a Master, that
if you will do me the Favour to send me a List to y' value of 4 or .S li of such
medicinal or Chirurgical books as arc new & well done, it will keep up in him y"'
Spirit of improving Natural history which has been so far advanced by you. that
I'm sure you can't help promoting it all laudible ways, a Line by y"' pony post will
find me if directed to y"' Lamp in Fcnchurch Street. I am

S' Yo' Obliged humb Ser'
Dec' 2 1703. Charles duBois.

7. Sloane MSS 4064, f.47.

[To Petiver]

S' Herewith you will receive a book of Insects w"'' I found last night directed
to you. I have sent 2 books of specimens w''' to clear to me by putting down on
y^ papers where I may refer to for a name that I may without sparing more time
than I can afford, will be an obligation to be acknowledged in any manner you
shall direct

Yo' humb. Ser'
Decemb. 26. 1704 Charles duBois

No 2

8. William Sherard correspondence 575 (Royal Society)

R nov' 27"- 1705 / Answ Jan" 18 / DuBois/

To Dr William Sherard / English Consul in Smirna

Dear Sir

I rec'd your Obliging present of Plants by the hands of Mr Petiver. but the
Seeds you sent by the Britannia miscarryed; 1 had the favour of seeing yours to
Mr Petiver & rejoyce in the expectation of what is like to be done further by
your hand in the Improvement of Botany. Your kind promise of sending me
plants & seeds I please my self in. might not some of your bulbs. & tuberous
Roots grow here if taken up in proper Seasons? I persuade my Self they would;
& then what a glorious accession might we not have to the Furniture of our
Gardens, all under your Name. & as oft as seen bringing to mind so considerable
a Benefactor to us & the History of Nature; I am very glad to hear of your
welfare by all Occasions, the Service 1 did intend to do your Nephew Fryer. I
was disappointed in by the late application his Father made, but 1 think that
disappointment was the Occasion of his being better placed; 1 shall be very
proud in receiving any commands you shall please to honour mc with. I am

S' Yo' Very humble &

obliged Servant

'""''"" Charles duBois

CHARLES DUBOIS' INSECT NOTES 27

9. Sloane MSS 4064, f. 156.

[To Petiver]

S' I should be glad to have Dr Plukencts Books sent me if you have done with
them, & in case you have any thing to send to India, it is near the time, the ships
being dispatching

Yo' humble Ser'
Jan 3 1707/8 Charles duBois

(No 3)

10. Sloane MSS 3.322, f. 15

For Mr Petiver at his house in Aldersgate Street

S' I take the Liberty you were pleased to give mc of sending you some
specimens, which if you will be so kind as to name, or to make References to
your Museum or any other Author, where I may find them, you will do me a
favour, & save mc a great deal of time & trouble in guessing at what, you can
very readily direct mc to at once; If among them there are any that you have not,
if you mark them with a P they or their duplicates arc at your Service

I am S' Yo' humble Serv'
Feb. 2. 1712/13 Charles duBois

11. Sloane MSS 4065, f, 100.

Mr Petiver

S' I having a friend going to Paris on a publick acco'. whom I can oblige to do
mc any kindness, I thought the notice might be of service to you, to convey any
thing you might want to be transmitted thither, or bring from thence, his stay
will be but short. If you will let me know when & where I may see you, I will
inform you more particularly, I am

S' Yo' humble Ser'
Feb 12 1712/13 Charles duBois

12. Sloane MSS 4048, f.8.

(To Sloane]

Sr My thanks being paid only verbally for your Noble present, I take this
occasion of returning your Paper. & also of repeating my acknowledgement for
your curious & instructing Book. & for the humanity you have always Shew'd
me, & particularly in your last kind allowing an old Acquaintance to take up
some of your valuable time to sec the great accessions to your ample collection;
I shall with great pleasure attend you, when your more significant affaires will
allow you to give mc notice when my Attendance on You will be least
inconvenient. I am

S' Yo'. Obliged humb. Serv'
June 2.5. 1725 Charles duBois.

13. Sloane MSS 4053, f.l86

[This letter is in very shaky handwriting]

To S' Hans Sloane Bar' at his house in Bloomsbury.
Hon'' S'.

28

L. JESSOP

Knowing your Curiosity. I talie the Liberty of sending you a Bird brought
from Mocka in Arabia faehx by one of our Coffee ships.

The name it goes by in that country is a Lohong It eats any kind of Fish or
Flesh. & seems to be an undescribed Bird. I am with due Respect

S' Yo'. most hunib. Serv'
18 March 1733/4 Charles duBois

14. Sloane MSS 4055, f. 145

For Sr Hans Sloane Bar', at his House in Bloomsbury.
Hon''. S'.

The kind Invitation you were pleas'd to send me to dine with you. & my other
good Friends, I am extreamly thankfull to you for; I was in the Country that day
on acco". of my Indisposition. & some business 1 had to do there, which
deprived me of the Pleasure of your good Company. My age & Infirmitys I hope
will plead my Excuse. & that you will yet allow me to be with great Respect

S'. Yo'. Obliged humble Serv'.
Tower hill
22 July 1737 Charles duBois.

15. Sloane MSS 4055, f.257.

For S' Hans Sloane at his House in Bloomsbury
Good S'

Your kind Invitation to dine with you 1 thank you for: it would have been
most acceptable to mc. could my attendance on our East India Court this day
have been dispensed with, but, that can not well be. I heartily wish you an happy
new year. I am

S'. Obliged humble Serv'.
Dcccmb'. .30'" 1737. Charles duBois.

16. Sloane MSS 4056, f.62

For S' Hans Sloane Bar' at his House m Bloomsbury Square,
S'

My Sister du Bois whom you were so kind as to visit at her Daughters house
Mrs Waldo'' on great Tower hill, apprehending her Eyes to be worse since her
bleeding, desires me to let you know so much, & prays the favour of your
ordenng what you think proper for her to do further; if you cannot so well judg
without seeing her again, please by a Line to let mc know: I am very sorry I was
not at home when you last did me the Favour to call at my House. 1 am

S' Yo'. obliged humble Serv'.
Great Tower Hill
3'' March 1738/9. Charles duBois.

17. Sloane MSS 4066, f.336.

[To Petiver]

S' I pray the favour of a line from you by a porter, any time after Tuesday

night where 1 may wait on you, & when, having a necessary occasion for your

CHARLES DUBOIS' INSECI NOTES 29

advice & assistance, I have taken due care of what you sent. I would attend you
sooner, but am obliged to be out of Town 2 or 3 days, am

Yo'humbScr'
Jan 23|noycar|. C. duBois

18. Sloane MSS 4066. f.337.

[To Petiver]

S', I ask your pardon for keeping your Books so long, I have now returned

them with the thanks of

Yo' humble Serv'
|no date) Charles duB|rest of word cut off]

Mayoral Permit: Sloane MSS 4020, f 107.

London Ss: Permitt and suffer the bearers hereof Charles DuBois Esq. James
Pettiver Josep Miller John Cox Richard Fildon James Dandridgc and John
Verdy together with their Watchmen Scrvt' or Attendants peacably and quietly
to pass and travell from hence by water this day being the Lord's Day to
Gravesend in the County of Kent it being represented to me that they have
extraordinary occasions for their soe doeing therefore you are not in any wise to
hinder them therein. Given under my hand and scale the twelfth day of July
1713.

Richard Hoarc Mayor
To the Rulers of the Waterman's
Company and all every
Constables and others whom these
may concernc

FASCIMILE AND TRANSCRIPTION OF THE MANUSCRIPT

In the following transcription the spelling and punctuation in text of the notebook has
been followed as closely as possible, for instance duBois spells what is now called
Scarabaeus as Scarabeus, and his spelling is followed.

duBois' use of the letter v for thorn has been retained: readers unfamiliar with that
letter should note that it is pronounced as th. In the few places where the long s has been
used in the manuscript, this is rendered by lower case s.

There are a few places where the paper has darkened to such an extent that the text is
no longer legible, and in other cases a line has been trimmed off in the process of
binding. In these instances the missing text is marked by four asterisks in square
brackets. Ihe few other editorial comments in the text are also indicated within square
brackets.

A page break in the notebook is indicated in the transcription by a short rule

Insects
K.
ms. notes on Insects, with original drawings written and drawn by a collector in 1692 & 1695.

Purchased from Prof. J. Percival, 'Leighton', Shinfield Green, Reading, Berks.

30 L. JESSOP

Genus Papilionaeum
PURCHASED

28 FEB 1945 (note added on stamp on last page: £4.(K)]

1
Papilio perennis. an 12 Moufet pag. 101.

Taken y" 19 July. It is a nimble fly. & sit with its wings erect, sometimes clapping them down,
The lowest figure in Moufet p. 101 agrees pretty well with it, but his description is not exact.

The whole body & head is a deep Sad, with long sad brown hairs, especially on y'' Thorax, y^
horns arc long & jointed, y' knob ends in yellow, y" Ground of y" wings on y'^ upper Side is a full
Orange, the upper wing is the Smaller, at y" Setting on it is Sad, 3 large black spots are placed on y^
upper Edge on each Side y'' middle one, y*" ground is buff; & beyond the i"' near y^' End is white +
; The under wing is fill'd about y'"' middle |**'*] with long brown hairs,The greater 1/2 is black,
then Orange, then a row of bla. Arches, filld with peach in y'' middle then black and brown lines
undulated, y"^ edge is serrate, y"^ under Side is somewhat like y' upper Side but darker colours, &
instead of Orange, pale buff colour. + One large black spot is at y" under Edge, & 2 Smaller above
it.

TTiis lives through y" winter, it is often found sheltered in Chambers, & taken in windows shilt,
upon y'' breaking out of a Clear Sun in y^' Spring. The figure is expanded too much, for y' Sake of
seeing all y'' wings.

Papilio alba, alls 6 maculis nigris notatis, extremitatibus etiam nigris.

Taken 17th July in y" Garden, The head is white, y" Eyes round large & black, y'' Thorax & Tail
black set thick w"' white hairs, y"' horns w'" with black knobs the upper Side of y'' wings white the
upper wings have 2 black spots each, & the ends black, y*^ under wings have each one black spot on
y' outward Edge on y" Under Sides, y' tips of y"' upper wings, & all y" under wings are brimstone
colour, y' upper wings have 2 black Spots each on y*^ under Sides, y*" legs are greenish white

[3]
Papilio elcgans fusco-fulvus [****]eus alis oculatis (Takjen y° 1st Sept upon Flos. Africanus
[Ye] head and Thorax are Sad. covered with dark brown hairs, y" Eyes Sad also y"^ horns arc finely
marked all y" length with Sad and white alternately Set. y" knobs at y"" End Black, y" legs arc of y'-'
Same colour with y" Thorax, the blackish & w"" hair, y^' wings are finely marked w"' large Orange
Spots upon a Sad ground. towar|ds| y"^ End of each upper wing is a black Spot with a Small white
Speck in y' middle of it. y'^ under wings have only orange towards the Ends, w"' .^ black Spots in
each, w"" w"' Specks in them. & a fourth more obscure, these Spots are Circled round w"' orange
Underneath y^' upper wings are almost all Orange. & the underwings finely marbled with different
Shades of Sad & cloth colours.

4. Papilio elcgans alis nigris, nebulis aurantii colore, maculis albisque notatus.

Taken 16'*' Sept. upon y'^ flowers of Tagetes. The whole body & head are very black & hairy, y*-"
Eyes sad brown, the horns Spcckt black and white alternately all y' way. y'-' knobs black tipt at y'
Ends wth white. The upper wings on y'^ upper Side are very black except towards y*^ Ends, where
they incline to purplish, the long bars cross y"' are deep Orange, y"^ other Spots white, y' Edges are
Scallopt. y" points are black, between y" white, with a line of purplish above them, the under
wings arc black w"' a broad border of Orange, on each of w''' is set 4 Small black Spots in a Row.
tipt & scallopt as before, y*" outward Edge is white, all y^' wings near y'' body arc Set with very fine
long black hairs. The under Side is very beautifull. The upper wings on this Side are Scarlet where
they are Orange on y' other. & w" on this where they arc w" on y" other, between y' white & y"
Scarlet is a fine blue cloud w"' black in y" midst, y^' upper edge near y^ Setting on is finely markt
blue and black like a Jays feather, y' ends of y^' wing are brown olive buff & ash colours in clouds &

CHARLES DUBOIS' INSECT NOTES 31

Spots. The under wings have 2 large buff colourd Spots about the middle of the outward Edge, y''
most of y'^ remainder is clouded of many Sad colours extreamly fine, at y'^ bottom are 3 Spots like
[remainder trimmed offl.

[****)ers, y'^ border is made of lighter colours, y' legs brown.

5
Papilio sulphurca alis angulosis

Taken y"' 16 September upon y' flowers of Sultan; The Eyes arc Sad brown, y' upper part of y"^
head, & Along under the wings, is a dirty red. the horns are of y^' Same colour, & short, y" Ends
thick, not distinctly knobbed, the whole remainder of y'-' body and wings is brimstone colour, in
one deeper, in another taken 22"' 7*", paler, the thorax & that part of y'' Tail next is is very thick set
with Small shining hairs standing upwards, y" proboscis is black; In y' midst of every wing stands an
Orange Spot, less in y' upper wings; & bigger in the under ones; y'^ Edges of the wings have also
Small Orange Spots set at some distance from each other

6. Papilio alis laciniatis

Taken 2,V'' Sept'. The head & body are Sad brown, y" horns of y" Same colour except y^' tips of
y'-' knobs w'^'" arc white. The proboscis & legs are brown, y^ latter pretty long, the wings arc cut in &
variously indented on the Edges, they Orange, marked with Sad spotts & clouds; Underneath they
are finely marbled, with shades of sads and browns, y*" upper part Sadder y'^ lower part lighter, in y"^
place where y'' Sad ends on y" under wings is set on each a very white mark like a c thus C.

7
Papilio alba altera major, alis subtus maculatus extremitatibus nigris

Taken the 23"' Sept'. It is larger than N".2 about y"' head of a dirty whitish green, the Eyes
greener, & Show as if they were Spotted with Small black Spots, w"'' by a glass appear fairer, &
change their Scituation as they are differently objected to y" light, the horns are black Spcckt with
white y'' knobs at y" End tipt with white, y'^ upper Side of y"' body or tail is black & hairy the under
Side white, y'^ legs white the proboscis black. The upper wings white y'' Ends black underneath
white also tipt with brimstone, with black spots in y' midst of each. The under-wings are with set
each with a black spot in y' middle of y*" outward Edge, underneath of a dirty brimstone colour, a
little of y' Edge near y"^ body is Orange colourd.

8
Papilio elegans agilis, Bella donna dicta, y" Painted Lady

Taken 27'*' of September upon y"" flowers of Tagetes, It is very Shy and difficult to come at. The
Eyes are black, y'' head Set thick with brown hairs, y" horns black tipt with white at y'' Ends, The
Thorax black, set with brown hairs, y' upper part of y"" Tail black mixt with red, y" under part ash
colour'd, as are y*" Legs w"*' are pretty long, y'^ first pair plumose. Serving to brush y' Eyes & head 1
suppose. The upper Side of the upper wings is of a Sad ground, y'^ 3 larger inner marks Orange in
one and redder in another Sort perhaps they are of different Sexes, y"' 5 Spots at y" End are white,
y"' under Sides are near y"' Same but lighter The upper Sides of y" under wings are Sad with broad
borders of Orange Spotted with black, y' under Side is finely marbled wth Several Sad colours
interspersed with white Veins & spots & Eyes at y' bottoms.

9
Papilio minor alis aurantii colore, maculatis, & pulchre Splcndentibus.

Given me by M' Petiver 23"' September who took it y" Same day coming to Mitcham; It is Small, y*-'
horns are broken off, y' Eyes shine like Gold, y" head & body are black, y'= Legs ash colour'd. The
upper Sides of y' upper wings are Orange & Shine, set w'" black Spots, which on y' other Sides arc

32 L. JESSOP

Eyes, & the Orange Paler. >'' border of y'^ wing is Sad; The inner wings are Sad w"" a border of full
Orange, Seallopt with Sad, & fringed, y" under Side is paler Sad. Set with several Specks, w'" y''
Scallopt border.

10

Papilio fusca, alis externis oculo nigro insignitis.

Taken y" beginning of July on the Grass in y'' Fields. The Eyes are reddish Sad; The whole head,
horns body, & under wings Sad, & somewhat Shining, the upper wings are Sad, shaded & clouded
with Orange about the middle of them, towards y^ Corners of each Stands a full black Spot, with 2
Small white Specks in it. The under side of both pairs of wings is the most vivid, that of y' upper
wings is finely parted in wavy with a lighter colour near the ends.

11
Papilio fusca alis subtus 16 maculis oculatis notatis.

Taken 4'" July by The River Side. The Head, horns, body & upper side of y" wings arc all Sad
colour'd, these last are Set with many long hairs especially near y"' head, the I.eggs are browner.
The under Side of y^' wings is marked with Eyes as in y'' Figure. Three in each upper wing. & Five
in each under wing; In these Spots the Hrst ring is Orange, within that Black, & in the Center a
white Speck.

12
Papilio fusca. alis internis oculatis 11) quodammodo accedens. Mouf. n"4. p.lfl."!. fig:
Taken with y' last. This is darker all over than N" 10, The Orange appears not so much on y"' back
of y*-' upper wings but more underneath, where it is almost all Orange, y"" under part of the under
wings is mostly sadder. & y"^ Ends lighter, w"' ?> black Spots in each towards y'' bottom The Eyes
are black w"' white Edges behind. & before just by the nose, brown; I have one just like this but
only with two spots in each under wing.

Genus Phalaenaceum

The Notes of a Phalaena. whereby it seems chiefly to differ from a Papilio. speaking generally, are

1. To fly by night or after Sunset.

2. To sit with its wings dependent, or horizontal, & not erect.

3. To be heavyer & duller, at least to appear so by day.

4. To be more hairy, to defend y"' from y'' Injury of Night-dews.

5. To have weaker, & Slenderer horns, ending in a point, without a knob at y' End; & to be m
some kinds plumose.

1 . Phalaena minor alis ex fusco & rubro mixtis, maculis Strammeis.

Taken 2.^ July in y'' morning. The Head & Horns are light Tawny, the Eyes greenish, y'' body & tail
light-Tawny, & Shining, y"' legs also, & Set w"' 2 or .^ stiff hairs about y' middle the wings
underneath arc reddish Straw colour; above they are redder, y" upper wings have each 2 straw
colour spot at y'^ outward Edge y'' under, two small lines each of y'' Same colour, they arc fringed
w"" a light Tawny.

2
2. Phalaena alba parva graminea. The Grass Moth

Taken 2^ July. They fly in meadows in the Evening in Numbers, keeping near y' ground making
short flights, & lighting a Stalk, where they arc not easily seen because their wings lye close one on
another along their body. The whole body & wings arc of a light ash Silvery colour & Shining, y^'
Eyes arc black, from y'' Nose 2 long productions come forth, y" horns are Slender & blackish, y'
legs arc long & Somewhat branched.

CHARLES DUBOIS' INSECT NOTES 33

3. Phalaena alba parva graminca minor

Taken at y"' Same time & place. The difference between these is only That this is smaller, & y"

underwings deep ash, fringed with white, perhaps this is the male;

4. Phalaena minor splendens eapite fusco, alis ex purpurea & fusco mixtis

Taken 23 July in y^ morning early, flying. The head is almost black, y^' Eyes Sad & shining, y'' horns
of y" coulour of the head, y' body & tail light ash, with a Shew of purple. Shining, y^' legs Sad.
shining and a little branched The wings underneath of y^ colour of y'' Tail, but Sadder towards y"
outer Edges; Above, y^" upper wings are marbled with Sad & a pale purple, the inner wmgs light
ash, fringed, & Shining. The Hgurc is a little less than the life.

5. Phalaena minor, alis ex fusco & cinerea mixtis

Taken flying at y'^^ Same time. The head is ash colour, y'' Eyes black, y'^ body & tail y'" Same, the
Eyes of the Rings on y'-' Tail are whitish, underneath all Shining ash, y" legs small & a little
branched, y''' upper wings are ash, with 4 marbled darker Spots on each, v'^^ under wings Shining
ash, & folded as are those of most Small Phalaenaea

6. Phalaena cinerea minor alis macula fusca obscure notatis.

Taken w"* y"' last. The Eyes Sad, y" whole upper part is Sad ash & shining. & lighter underneath,
marked as (2) w'^'' is y"' underside of y" upperwing. On y'^^ upperwing are 2 small dull Sad Spots, y"
ash colourd Legs are long. & Somewhat branched.

7. Phalaena cinerea media dorso nudo.

Taken in y'' evening about y' middle of July, It flyes very swift, & plays about y^' flowers. The Head
& Thorax are thick & bluff, cover'd wth long ash colourd hair, except the midst of y' back w''' is
naked Cover'd with an Orange shining Skin. I am in some doubt least I rub'd off y^' hair when 1
took it, but I caught 2 or 3 Since & when I look on them they are all so. The upper wings have 2
white spots like a (Y) & are Shadowed with dark upon ash as in the figure, under y^' Thorax is very
long hair, y" legs are Sad. a little branchy; This kmd is not dorso nudo. M' Petiver calls it y"
Gamma, from y^ form of y' Letter on its wings.

ft

8. Phalaena media alis ex fusco fulvis. dorso nudo.

Taken 23"' July in the Evenmg. It is such another as y'' last but not so big. w"" a naked back like y'.
The head body & legs sad. y" Eyes black, y'' upper wings marked sad & light brown as in y' figure,
the under wings all Sad; underneath it is all Sad, with a Shew of reddishncss,

9. Phalaena alba plumata

Taken in y*^^ evening July 23"' Hying. The Eyes are black The Tail hath a Shew of greenishncss.
about 1/2 an inch long. & Slender. The Legs are very long. & branched, y"^^ 2"" Joynt short, y" last to
y'^ toes very long. Each of y^' wings is made of 2 perfect Feathers joyned together near their
Origine, y'^ Antennae + an inch long.

10. Phalaena cinerea alis maculatis. cornubus plumatis.

Taken 26 July in y'^ night by a Candle. It is all over dirty ash colour wth Sad colour marks on y^'
upper wings as in y"^ lig'. y^ horns are brownish & appear thick, but in a good light are made like an
herring bone or thin Set feather as (2) not directly oppt)site but Setting downwards ' The legs are
long & a little branchy.

1 1 Phalaena minor cinerea alis marmoreis.

Taken in y"" night by a Candle July 27 It is all ash colour except y^ upper wings w'^'' are marbled w"'
Sad Strokes as in y*" fig', y^' Nose is long, y^' horns small & Short, y^' Legs long, & a littly branehy. y"
whole under Side is Sad ash.

12. Phalaena pratensis Mouffeti 3'' p. 98.

Taken about y'^ midst of June flying in a medow by day; The whole body. head, horns & legs are

34

L. JESSOP

very black, the wings extend beyond the End of y" Tail, each of y'' upper wings is almost black,
with long Scarlet Streaks where the black is in y'' picture, & 2 Scarlet Spots at the end of each wing.
y^' inward Spot biggest, y' inward edges arc Scarlet also the underwings are wholly cherry colour'd.
except y'' lodges, which are Sad. y'' under & upper Sides of both pair are alike. & they are all linely
fringeil at v' Fnds.

13. Phalaena pratensis Mouffeti prima p-g. 97.

Taken 29"' June in Coitu on a Stalk of Corn; there is no visible difference between y*" Male &
Female; It is like y' last, but y'-' body & Tail is much bigger. The horns also grow thick towards y"
Ends, the Sad of y'' wings Shines more greenish. & the Scarlet on y^ upper wings is disposed into 5
fair Spots. & in some 2 more on y" inner edges, the wings hang down. y° under wings are much less
y" y'' upper ones, w'*' is not observed in Mouffcts hgure

14 Phalaena albo-fusca alis variegatis

About y'' End of June I found an Aurelia hanging upon a Twig. «'•■ 1 put into a box. & when I
came to look on it. it had produced y' Phalaena above named The whole body & under wings arc
of a pale cloth colour, the upper wings are variegated, both wings underneath are of y'' Same cloth
colour with y' body. The Aurelia w''' is drawn too little, was left thus & Seems to confirm y'
Notion, y'' the head of y'' Catterpillar. is that end w'^*' is y" tail of y' Butterfly.

l.>, Phalaena fusca alis 4 maculis insigni reniissi notatus

Taken flymg about a Candle m the (iarden. m the beginning of July. It is all sad colour'd except the
under wings which are ash. the upper wings are marked as in the hgure with a Sadder colour, the
Eyes are near black & prominent; when it Stands, y" wings lye horizontal, and the under t)nes are
quite covcr'd by the upper

lb. Phalaena media grisea. alis maculis. cruciformibus notatis. oculis atris

Taken y" last of June on a Ladyes clothes The head is Short & pointed, y'' Eyes prominent & very
black, from each runs a black stroke to y' Shoulders, y^ horns are white at y'' Setting on. & after
black, small & ending in a point. The back between y" head & wings is very hairy the upper wings
are light grey with Cross like marks of sad w"'' are Edged with white, the Ends are Scallopt; y''
under wings are white, t^i Shine like Sattin. & scallopt also. & saddish colour'd at v' Ends, y'' under
Sides of y" upper wings have some sad Spots on y"' The Tail is Large & very hairy, blunt at y" End
like y' of y"' Papilio of a Silk worm. & grey, but whiter along the middle of its underside The Thighs
are thick set with white hairs, y^ Legs black & white in Small alternate Spots.

17
Phalaena media straminea

Taken in y' night by a Candle amongst Nettles Julv s"'. The whole is straw-colour'd. the Eyes
black; The upper wings have faint reddish undulated Lines on y'". The under wings are as long &
near as large as the upper, y'' Leggs are pretty large, strong. & brown; when it was stuck down to a
box with a pin. it laid many very small, round, white Eggs, w'*" Stuck not to y' box. but rowTd away
as they came out. w'^'' Eggs in ,^ hours time turned black. The Tail is darker colour'd. especially
towards y*^ End. It Sits with its wings hanging down.

18
Phalaena alis ex fusco virescentibus maculis nigris notatis.

Taken with the last; The head is ash colour ending in a long proboscis, v'^ Eyes sadder, v'' horns
pretty long & ash color'd. The upper wings are greenish towards y'' upper Edges, towards v'^ ends
turrow'd. w"' Small black specks at y^' ends of y" Furrows, y^' middle parts of y*" wings are of a
shining purplish Sad. on y" upper part of w''' are two black spots a bigger & a lesser in each wing;
The under wings are ash colour'd A: Shining; The Tail sad ash. the legs are long, ash eoL'. &
somewhat branched. While it was stuck down with a pin it laid many small oblong white Eggs, w*^^''

CHARLES DUBOIS' INSECT NOTES 35

was performed by its thrusting out at y" End of its Tail a long white transparent Tube, w'^^'' it
wriggled about & thrust out & drew in often. & now & then one might see the Egg come through
it, w"'' it stuck to y^' box whereon it was fixt.

19

Phalaena lota alba.

Taken in August upon y" Grass on Tunbridg Wells Common It is all over white; The Eyes only
w^'' arc brown, y^' Legs very hairy. After it was stuck down with a pin, it excluded much brown
woolly matter, wherein it laid its Eggs, w*^'' were there hatcht in 2 or 3 dayes. I fed them with young
lettuce leaves, but they dyed in a week or 10 days, they were of the hairy kind of Cattcrpillers.

20
Phalaena major clcgans tricolor, Goedartij W.

This sort I hatched, & fed y'' Catterpillar w''' they commonly call Shepheards Dogs The Eyes are
sad brown, y' head & body, thick set with brown hair, just at y' juncture of y"^^ Neck & Sholders,
Scarlet; The horns come out of a Small scarlet knob, they are white set with 2 rows of very line
brown hairs, in manner of a feather. The ground of y' upper wings is pale Isabella marked with
large sad intorted Spots, underneath y" Isabella is deeper; The under wings are pale Scarlet spotted
with fair black spots, underneath y^' ground is pale Orange, The upper side of y'^ Tail is deep
Orange, y' under Side sad except at y^ junctures of y' rings w"'' are deep Orange; The Legs are
Strong, Sad, & a little branched, the upper part of y" Thighs' Scarlet.

21 Phalaena lo Pae;in mihi.

Taken on y^' (iround y^ beginning of June. It is all hairy, much so about y" head, y"^ Eyes Sad, y"
whole except y^ whitish undcrwing of a dirty sad colour, y' lind of y'^^ Tail thick & brushy. The
uppcrsides of y"^ upper wings are marked w"' a Streight black stroke, & 2 round ones less black, &
are Saddest towards the Ends where runs across them a lighter undulating Stroke. The Horns are
long and linely lealherd. 1 suspect this to he the male of 2.'i, when it was taken it was on y" ground,
& could not yet lly, being as I suppose newly gotten out of its Chrysalis, w''' perhaps was buried as
was that of 25.

22
Phalaena aliquatenus purpurascens, uniolor .Splendens. Margarita, mihi.

Taken y' beginning of June. The Eyes are black, the head not very big. y^' horns slender & pretty
long, the whole Body Sad. y" upper Sides of the upper, & y^ Ends of y'^ upper Sides of the under
wings are of a Shining Sad colour mixt with a faint purplish colour Towards y^' upper part of y''
under side of y^ upper wings, & towards the upper end of the underwings on y'' upper Side is a fine
mother of pearl colour.

23
Phalaena cinerca, maculis fuscis variegatis magnis notata.

Taken y'^^ beginning of June, The head is small &. sad colour'd, as is also y' Thorax, y^ horns small,
the Tail ash colourd, y^ Wings also, upon y^ upper wings on the outward edge Stand 3 large Sad,
mixt. Spots, y' upper two, when the wings are near, making an equilateral triangle, the fringe of y''
upper wings alternately black & white

24
Phalaena fulva striis tranversis undulatis notata, interdiu sub arborum foliis degens.
Taken y^ middle of June, at which time if one Shake y'' boughs of bushes one may see y'" frequently
fly out & make to y' underside of a Leaf of the next bush. The whole is Tawny yellow or buff. The
uppcrsides of y^ wings are finely marked with waved Lines of white or Sadder buff running
tranversely as far as about 2/3 of y" Length of the wing the rest to y" end is of a lighter buff, & more
obscurelv undulated

36 L. JESSOP

25
Phalacna fusca c Chrysalide in terra supulta prorumpcns.

About y' beginning of June I found in the new dug Earth several thiek sad brown ChrysaHs's, w'^^''
put up in a box one of them produeed this Phalaena about 14 days after The Eyes are black, y'^
head Short set on a thick hairy bluff Thorax. Cover'd with reddish Sad hairs, y' Tail thick. & hairy
with rings of whitish at y^' annulary junctures. The horns long. fine. & brown, y' wings sad. with
paler strokes on their Ribbs. y"' upper part of y' under wing in soine positions shining like peacocks
feathers, but it had battcr'd it self in the box & was not curiously perfect; It had laid above 100
Round yellowish Eggs in the box, w''' it had finely fix'd by the glutinous matter about y"' in the
quincunx order. & therefore is a female & by the by. One way of knowing the males from y"
Females in this papilionaceous Species is by halchmg their Chrysalis's for the Female soon lays her
Eggs whether she doth coire or not. tho' in this last case they are Steril.

:6

Phalaena alis angulosis. I.inea tranversa alas in duas partes dividens l.inca acquinoctialis mihi
Taken by M' Stoncstrcct at night by a Candle Set in his window at Carshalton, It is of a brownish
Cream colour, y^ head & horns small, y' Eyes very black, the Ends of all the wings arc pink colour,
a reddish brown fair Line crosses all the wings. & below it a Smaller sadder line undulates almost
from end to end of y'^ other line, underneath it is Set w"' innumerable small Specks. & y^
aforemention'd 2 Lines are Sad appearing on this side also.

27
Phalacna 1 1 cognata si non eadem alis pulchre pictis.

Taken about y' End of May in a Lane in East Field. It is a Small Moth, pale ash colour, the under
wings Saddest, the ends of y"^ upper wings are prettily marked.

28
Phalaena pulchra fusca, alis tribus portiunculis undulatis, divisis.

Taken about y'' middle of July in y^ Woodhouse amongst y"^ Loggs. The head us yellowish brown,
y*^ Eyes paler. & Shining, the Lcggs (w'-'*' are long) & the edges of y*"' upper wings on y*^ under Side
of a Reddish brown, y'' tail on the under Side Sadder. & as it were variegated. & Shining the upper
part of the Thorax Tail. Sad. only y' end of the Tail reddish brown. The outer wings arc divided
into .'^ portions next y'' head. & y'' Ends reddish Sad. that in y*^ midst between them brown edged
w"' a waved white Line on each Side, the inner wings sad with white variegations, y^ ends of all y'
wings have a Small white stroke cross them.

29
Phalaena alba cucullata. alis duobus maculis majoribus ornata

Taken about y^ middle of July. The Eyes are small & black, the head, horns Thorax, & beginning
of y^' 1****1 Sad mixt so as to make a triangle, a large round Spot of |**'*] is on each wing on y^
outer Edge, The wings otherwise are white, save that towards y' Ends they are more ash colour'd
& blackish at y^' Tips, y' inner wings underneath have a Small black Speck in y' midst of each, y^
Leggs arc Speckled.

.^0
Phalaena ochroleuca cucullata mmor

This is y" Sort y' is bred of those animalls that eat y' feathers of the Skms ol y' Stuft birds, they fly
about them all y" Summer in the Evening

Scarabinum Genus

1
1. Scarabeus Terrestris nigro fuscus
Taken 9"' September out of y'' ground as it was digging, it is all over almost black; somewhat

CHARl.FSDLIBOIS' INSECT NOTES 37

inclining to Sad brown y^' head is flat almost of y" figure of an heart, furnished at y" mouth w"' small
feelers, y'^^ Eyes small & black, below which Stand y'' two horns near 1/2 an inch long, & appear
joynted if attentively lookt at, y'^^ Thorax is tlat & sharp edged, y" Edges somewhat turned up, y"
Vaginae smooth, Shmmg & furrow'd lengthwaycs, the leggs towards y'' Ends are brownish,
somewhat longer than is common y*^^ hinder ones especially, w'^'' are Slenderer also.

2
Idem major vaginis non Splendentibus

I remember not where or when taken. This differs not from y' last, except y" the Vaginae are of a
Sad dark colour, not so black as y" last, & Shine less, & y^' legs are wholly brown; This hath on y*^^
under Side of the Thorax, just before y" Setting y'^^ forelegs 2 small, round, brown, shining
prominent knobs, w"''' y'^' other hath not. perhaps this may be the female, w'^^'' in most insects is y^
biggest.

3
3. Scarabeus terrcstris. corpore nigro oblongo tumido.

Taken 10 September, digging in y'" Garden it came out of the Ground, it runs nimbly the figure is
somewhat bigger than the life. It is all over of a dusky black, 4 large Feelers hang at y^ mouth, just
under y" Forceps, y' 2 uppermost longest, & having each 3 joynts. y'^ 2 undermost Shorter &
jointed also, all ending in knobs, above y"' Stands y'' forceps or pincers, w"' which it bites Strongly,
y"^ Eyes arc Small, & black, under them the horns come out near an inch long each, <t joynted, the
Thorax plate is turned up at y'^^ Edges, + y" Vaginae turn up at y^' Edges all round, & towards y^'
Thorax Shine like Steel, y' tail reaches a little beyond y^ Ends of y"', y'' tail is very thick in y''
middle especially rising up to a ridge in y"^^ middle both above & beneath; underneath it is very
black & Shining, The legs especially y'" hinder ones are large & long.

+ The Vaginae shine remissly, when Seen through a Glass appear rugose.

4. Scarabeus melanocyaneus Mouffeti p. 160.

Taken about y" End of June. It is all over very black. The figure is Sufficient for y' Rest.

5. Scarabeus ex minimis, ex fusco aurantius.

Found in y' beginning of July a Small oblong dark Orange colour'd slow paced Beetle, alive among
old Indian Seed y' came to me formerly by y' Name of Dustoa Vitlu.

6. Scarabeus elasticus major. The bigger Castanet Beetle.

Taken in June. The whole is of a dirty Sad colour The Head Small, y" Eyes Scarce discernible. The
Thorax plate pitted in next y"^^ body. The Vaginae a little striate, y'' under part of y'' Tail smooth and
Strongly armed, divided by ."i or 6 Shells of armour. The Legs of a middling Length, When touched
it falls from y*^^ place as if dead, when laid on the Back, it will jerk up by a Spring seated in y^' Neck
to a good hcigth, by w^'' mean it recovers its feet, when it springs it makes a noise Snapping w''' is
y' Reason of its name

7. Scarabeus elasticus minor. The lesser Castanet Beetle.

Taken in . This hath y' Same Springing Faculty as y"^ former. The head is very Small, with two

Small black Eyes; The Thorax plate blackish, the Vaginae ehesnut colour'd, w'*" reach all round,
lower than y" Edges or Sides of y'' Tail, y'^ under part of y' Tail is of y'' Same colour. The Thorax
plate is continued over Some part of y' Tail.

8. Scarabeus fulvus oblongus Cornubus. & pedibus praelongis.

Taken on a Rose about y^' middle of June, The head is longish. The Eyes on each Side Small &
black, between w''' a furrow lyes y*^ length of y'^' head; Below y'' Eyes come out 2 long jointed
Horns bending round towards the Ends, Sad Orange towards y'^^ head & growing Sadder upwards,
& near y*" Ends whitish. The Thorax plate is cloth colour'd, unequall, ordcpress'd. in Some places;
y" Tail part is Squarish at y" Setting on to y" Thorax, & broad, & tapers to y" End where it is blunt,
y' Vaginae are pale ehesnut. Smooth & Shining, y'' under part of y^ Tail is cloth colour'd & Shines,

38 L. JESSOP

only y' End is Sad Orange, as are y' Legs also, except y" joints of the 4 foremost, & y' thigfis of y"^
fiindmost. w''*' arc The Legs are long, especially y' last joint.

9

Scarabcus Maialis gloriosa Splcndens The Golden Dorr.

Taken flying in Circenwich Town, in the End of May, It is of y' May bug or Dorr Kind; It shines
like greenish Gold all over the upper Side, & copper on y' under side of y" Tail part. The Head is
Small & Squarish, y' Thorax pretty large, y^' plate shaped almost like a Heart, from y" hinder part
of which in the middle, a Triangular plate goes down between the Vaginae, The Vaginae arc
marked as in y" figure, w'*' whitish or Straw colour. The Tail extends beyond y^ Ends of the
Vaginae. & hangs down towards y"^ End. it hath two Spots of y' Same straw colour; The LInder part
of the Thorax Shines also. & is between green & copper colour. & is thick set with brown short
hairs; The skirts of y*^ Tail is hairy, & so disposed as to imitate those white marks in y' common
brown one. The two first Joints of all y*^ Leggs are hairy, & large, with Several points or prickles on
them; the last joynts are Small & weak as in y"^ brown one aforesaid.

10

Scarabcus minor ovalis, aureus, splendens. tardipes. vaginis punctatis.

Taken in y^' beginning of July upon y"' Side of the water Tub in y^' Garden; It is an oblong Lady
bird. The head is small, & hangs downward. Shining green; The Thorax plate shines more gold
like, & the Vaginae between green & copper colour; the back rises round & gibbous; The Vaginae
by a Small assistance from a Glass appear pitted full of small holes, the horns are pretty long, & by
y' Same help pf a Glass appear joynted. The True wings under the Vaginae, are of a fine red.
except the Ends w'*' are transparent; The whole underside of y^' Animal is black; it goes Slowly.

II
Scarabcus parvus chalybis colore & Splendore, alls cocruleo tinctis.

Taken 9"^ July by the River Side. The whole upper Side shines blue like Steel. y° under part is
black. The horns grow thicker towards y' End: the Back rises round it being of y° Lady bird kind.
The True wings look bluish, w"" Rainbow colours in them, as they are differently objected to y"^
Light; Each hath a Small black Speck on y' outward Edge

12
Idem corpore oblongo, ex utroquc Splendens. cornubus ultiam \''\ longioribus
Taken with y' last. Both sides & every part of this Shines like Steel, only somewhat more greenish
It is made longer. & the horns longer also.

13
Scarabeus minor oblongus. vaginis nigris. Cauda aculeata gibbosus.

Taken y*^ beginning of June upon the Flowers of Panax Heracleum. When laid on a Table it leaps &
jerks about very often. The head is black, which hangs down as it goes along, by reason the back is
raised and gibbous. The horns arc Small & appear joynted in a glass, the head is slenderly Set on to
the Edge of the Neck. The Thorax plate is Orange. The Vaginae are deep Sad or rather black. & to
the Eye appear Smooth, but by y^ Aid of a Glass one sees them all over beset with innumerable
Small points: The whole Tail part is deep Orange, made up of ."i Rings inserted into ime another
Scalewise; & by y° Glass appears thick Set with down: The Tail ends in a long point like a Sting.
The Breast or under part of y'' Thorax is covered by a black Shell on each Side, under which y' Fail
part comes out. The hinder Legs arc Set on y"^ Edge of this Shell, with Strong Thighs, and arc
pretty long, by which it leaps so briskly; The Legs are of y''' Same colour w"' y' Vaginae.

14
Scarabeus medius, fuscus, corpore fulvo.
Taken 28"* of May upon Currans, where it is very Common The head is tlattish with small black

CHARLES DUBOIS' INSECT NOTES 39

Eyes, The Horns 1/2 an inch long, joyntcd all y'^^ way, & bending downwards towards y^' Ends, at y'
mouth arc Set 4 small short Feelers, the two outer ones longest, which 2 continually tremble; The
Thorax Plate is dark is Sad Orange, the Edges of it turn up a little: The Vaginae are dark musk
coloured, the True wings under but a little longer than their Cases; The Thighs arc orange
colour'd, the rest of y'^ Legs musk, y"' latter joints indented; Taken in Coitu June y"^^ P' the male &
female arc just alike but y"^ male is the lesser.

15

Idem omnino fulvus

Taken at y^ same time with the last, from w''*' perhaps it differs only in Sex, & colour; It is like y"^
last, only all yellow Tawny, It hath a Small black Stroke on the forehead a little above y*" Eyes; At
y'^^ mouth stands a Sharp pair of Forceps, wherewith it bites at every thing when it's held; The
Horns & y' joints of y*^ Legs are blackish.

16
Idem fulvus, vaginarum extremitatibus nigris.

Taken y*^^ 8"' of July in Coitu on y' Flowers of Levisticum, There is no visible difference between y"^
Male & Female. There is no difference between this & the last, except that this halh no black m y'^
forehead; & only the Toes, & y"^ Ends of y^ Vaginae are black in this.

17
Scarabeus minor oblongus, obscure viridis, & remisse Splendens

Taken y'^^ beginning of June upon y"' Flowers of panax Heracieum. The horns appear joynted to y'
naked Eye, the 2 feelers at y"^ Mouth have knobs at y^' Ends, & by y'' help of a Glass, one Sees y""
composed of i joynts; the whole is of a dull green, a little Shining, The toes seem to be white like
those of many Flyes.

18
Scarabeus minor rotundas, griseus, macules nigros [?maculas nigras] duobus insignioribus notatus.
Taken \5 June & 25"' May on Verbascum in Coitu; The male & female are perfectly alike. It is
about y^ bigness of a common Lady bird. The Head is long & Slender with 2 Small antennae. The
whole is grey with exceeding little Spots, One fair round black spot is placed on y' back, & another
near the Tail. These vary in their grey colour. Some almost black, i some fine speckt black &
white, y^' females are after some time exceeding turgid at the Tail part.

19
Scarabeus minor rotundus ruber, vaginis 2 maculis insignitis

Taken S"" July. It is a small Lady bird; The Thorax plate is black, w"' a Small white Spot on Each
Side, & an oblong one next y'^ Neck, & two very Small ones next y'" mouth, y" Vaginae red each
marked with one black Spot, y" true wings brownish, y' under side is all black. The Thorax Plate &
head appear as at (2) in y"^ Glass.

20
Scarabeus Maialis minor

Taken 28"' of May. It is just like y'^ great brown Dorrs or May buggs, save that it wants the white
marks on y"' Sides of its Tail, & is not 1/4"' so big. The Horns are only trihd at y" Ends, y^' head &
Thorax plate shine like Steel, in the male more purplish, & in the Female more blue. The Vaginae
are brown, as in y'' great Sort. The male is the less & rounder body'ed, y" female bigger & flatter.
This sort appear about y"" End of May, when the greater Sort go out, & eat y" young Leaves of
Trees as they do.

itus

21. Scarabeus minor oblongus fuscus lineis flavis notati:

Taken 28 May. It is about .V4 of an inch long, the head large & dusky, w"' a bright yellow ring

between y' fore part of y' neck & y" Eyes, y" horns are about 1/4 of an inch long. Orange near y'^

40 L. JESSOP

head. & growing darker to y' ends, the Vaginae dusky, elegantly marked with yellow lines cross
y"", the Legs dusky orange, the hinder ones very long, w'^ Strong Thighs as if designed for leaping.

22. Scarabeus aeruginosus D. Petiver.

Given mc In September by M' James Petiver. who took them in Coitu. the male Is y" lesser. The
whole except y'" under part of the Tall. & y' Legs, is of a dirty shining vertdigrease colour; The
Head Is long & issues out from under the Thorax plate Tortoise wise, on each Side of y'' middle
whereof is set a small Eye. & at y" F.nd two horns, divided into ?t joynts each; The Vaginae are
continued down y" Sides pretty deep. & to y"' end of y" Tail, w''' ends in a point; y"' under part of y"
Tail & y' Legs are black. The Thigh joynt in y" Legs In eminently swelled In y' middle.

23. Scarabeus domestlcus Impennis

Given me by M' Petiver. who salth That they are common in many Cellars In London; It is black all
over. The Vaginae adhere to y"' body, & have no parting, they are continued down the Sides &
leave about half the Tail open, w"" is composed of .'i annulary portions.

24. Scarabeus minor viridis splendens

Taken out of new dug Earth Apr. 211. The head is black. & y'= Eyes, v/''' are very small The Thorax
plate & Vaginae shining green, the Vaginae striate, y' horns & leggs brown, y"' whole under part
Sad dark colour'd.

25. Scarabeus minor obscure griseus ventre albente.

Taken on y' ground Apr. 21). The head & horns very small y' Eyes black, y' whole upper part Is
very Sad grey, as it were faintly chcquer'd. y"' under part whitish ash with an Eye of peach in it.
growing redder when dead, y"^ Legs black

26. Scarabeus minor unicolor, capite erectlore

Taken in a Spiders web May 3. It is all of one cloth colour, y' Eyes small & black, y' horns a
little thick at y" Ends, y" Legs pretty long, it walks slow but with its head more raised than
common

27. Scarabeus minor vaginis seminibus RicinI modo allquatenus notatls.

Taken with y' last. The head & Thorax is Shining black, y" Vaginae shining Sad towards chesnut
colour wth darker broad marks on y"', y" Legs horns & Eyes are very small y" whole under part
sad.

28. Scarabeus minor splendens capite ranino

Taken upon y'' Ground May 4. where it runs nimbly by starts, y"' whole on both sides is shining
copper colour'd. y" horns small y'' head Square with prominent Eyes, y"' whole looking like a Frogs
head

29. Scarabeus arantll colons, subtiis niger. cornubus cervinls.

Taken 9'" May on a Goosberry bush; The whole upper side is deep Orange, The whole under side.
Legs & horns are black, y'' horns have one row of small points their whole length.

30. Scarabeus niger vaginis strlatis

Taken on v" Ground 6 Mav. It Is somw'. like N" 1 . but bigger of a Shining black all over.

31. Scarabeus viridis maculis fusco-lutels.

Given me by Mr Petiver. The head is bold & full, y" black Eyes prominent, y'' mouth fueille = mort
y'^ feelers & forceps green. Lines of Sad part y'' neck & Thorax plate. & that & y'' Tail part, the
Sheath wings are Spotted with filemot & y' Ends tipt with y' Same The whole under part & y" Legs
are changeable green blue & copper colour, y' lower part of y' Tall blue. The Eyes in a glass
appear pitted as a Flyes.

CHARLES DUBOIS' INSECT NOTES 41

32. Scarabcus arborcus minor dilute Viridis splcndcns

Taken 16 May from an Apple Tree. The Eyes arc small & black, y^' neck long, y^' horns & Legs
brown y" whole (otherwise) light shining green, y' thigh eminently thick in y"' middle, in one of this
kind y"^^ thighs are green & Shining in another not.

3,^. Scarabcus minor rotundus ruber, vaginis 12 maculis nigris insignitis.

Taken 16 May. It is a smaller Lady bird than N" 19. The head & Thorax plate is white set with large

black spots y^' Vaginae red with 12 black spots thereon, the under side black.

34. Scarabcus minor, gracilis, longus, fuscus cornubus longis gcniculatis

Taken on y'^ flowers of Panax Hcraclcum May 26 in Coitu. Tis all of one Sad colour, long &
Slender, y' horns long ct jointed, y'^ legs long y" thigh thick in the middle, reddish towards the
body, the Vaginae Smooth & Shining, y"' true wings sad at y" Ends, y"' under part of y"' tail Shining,
greyish & divided into 6 rings, y*^^ female biggest, y'^ male in mounts on her back.

35. Scarabcus minor remisse splendens. Scapula lata.

Taken on y' ground May 19"' It shines all over of a faint copper above underneath black, as are y*^
Legs, y^" Eyes very small & y"' horns also, the Thorax plate is large, Ai Square at y' Setting on to y''
Sholdcrs. The Vaginae appear Striate by a glass

36. Idem nigrior.

Taken on y'^ ground about y'' Same time. There is little difference except y" horns are thicker, y"
Legs browner, & y'^ Vaginae more visibly Striate. I suppose this may be the male to y" last.

37. Scarabcus minor fere rotundus, viridis &. pulchrc Splendens acetosivora.
Taken 26 May upon Sorrel, where many are to be met in Coitu about this time, & some of the
females so big bcllyed that they can Scarce go. All the upper part is of a beautifull Shining green, y*"
horns w''' are thickest at y' Ends, & under y" Tail black, y"' Legs Steel & shining. The Vaginae in a
glass appear curiously pitted:

.38.

39. Scarabcus vaginis subviridibus. apicis coccineis.

Taken 26 May upon y" flowers of Panax Hcraclcum. It is much of y'= Shape & Size with n" 17. y'=
upper part greenish, & somewhat Shining, y" Ends of y" Vaginae are tipt with Scarlet the Tail is
greenish divided by whitish rings. The Sides are Scarlet just under y'' Setting on of the wings. The
true wings at y'' Ends have fair Sad spots on them.

4(1. Scarabcus niger Londinensis Scapula lata.

Taken on y"' CJround in y' Street in London about y"" middle of May It is all over black. The head is
small in proportion, y'' horns thick at y^' End, y'' Thorax plate is broad & hangs over y^ Sides. &
every way else The Vaginae are turned up at y" brims. & hang over y'' Tail. & have 3 raised Striae
lengthwise in each of them.

41 Scarabcus minor vaginis Testudinis . . . transparens & variegatus.

Taken in y" Ciravel pits. The head & Thorax plate Shine like Steel, y"' Vaginae very like Tortoise

shell, y"" Tail black & Shining, y'-' Legs brown, y' horns pretty long.

Scarabei aquatici.

1. Scarabcus minor aquatilis, fuscus compressus.

Taken in y^ water in a pond about the middle of June The whole is of a Sad colour, y'^ head not
distinguishable from y" Thorax part, having two very slender horns, w"'' by the help of a Glass
appear jointed. & by y"^^ Same aid two small black Eyes are seen on each side of y" head; The
Vaginae Shine. & are (especially near their Setting on) bent inwards with a fold to go under part of
y'^ Tail part. This contrivance seems designed to preserve the wings from being wetted when they

42 L. JESSOP

swim. The under part is Sadder than the upper The 4 forelegs arc brown & armed with 2 Claws
each at y' Toes to creep with. & issue out of y" Forepart of the Thorax together; The hinder Legs
issue out of the hinder part of the Tail pretty low, & end in fiat Fms to Swim with, which They do
very nimbly, diving down as soon as one aproaches them They will frequently lye at y' Top of y''
Water basking themselves in y' Sun.

Pseudo-Scarabei.
1

Blatta Mouffeti. p. 138

Taken about our house in London by night, where there are multitudes of them of various Sizes, so

that it appears they grow after exclusion, vide Swammerdam

Gryllotalpa

Muscae quadripennes

1
Musca quadripennis. capite hippocampoide. cauda Scorpii. an Musca Scorpiura Mouffeti p. 62
fig.ult

Taken 19 July on the Rasps. The head is small & chesnut colour'd. on each Side of w"*" is a large
chesnut colour'd Eye. in y" forehead are 2 Small yellow spots, out of w"'' come 2 horns about 3/4 of
an inch long. & appear joynted. by a glass, y"" mouth is a long brown beak, furnished at the bottom
with Small feelers; in the neck is a ring of yellow with a Small yellow line behind it one Scarce
discerns the Thorax from y" Tail, but from y"" head it Seems continued all y" way in sad rings with
yellow Edges & a yellow line on each Side, at y'' end of y'' Tailes arc 3 joints like a Scorpions Tail;
smooth. Shining & brown, y" last of w'^'' is thick & ends in a Strong forceps, this part of y' tail turns
up, & when one touches y"" Insect it endeavours to pinch one therewith; The legs arc yellow long.
& Slenders, sadder towards y" Ends, w"' 2 Stiff hairs Standing at each middle joynt. they arc Set
upon Strong thighs fixt to y" Thorax, the wings are large, prettily Spotted with black. Taken also
lO"' May on y" ground it could not yet fly
[figure on next page]

2
Chrysopis

Taken 22 July among thick bushes. It is all green, except y" nose w''' is yellowish, & they Eyes
standing out on each Side the head like Studs of Gold, y" horns are .3/4 of an inch long whitish, &
very Slender, the 4 wings are much of a Size longer than y" body, & turned to the light Shine finely
wth Crimson; I could smell it stank.

3. Chrysopis altere major foetida.

Taken 22"' July flying in y'' Evening, In all points like the former, but as bigg again. & one I took 4

times as big. these larger ones stank very rank of humane Excrements.

L Musca apiformis, cauda fulva nigro notata. Taken 15 July upon poppy flowers in my brothers
Garden at Hackney; The way of flying & looks of it would make one Suspect it a Bee, but that it
hath but two wings, & a head of y" make of a Fly, w"'out long horns, indifferently large, the large
Sad chesnut Eyes meet, the nose is furnisht wth y" 2 Small black horns common to tlyes, & is large,
downy, & ash colour'd. The Thorax & Tailc are cover'd all over cV: under with hne brown hairs, y'
back of y' Thorax is blackish & a little Shining, y'' Taile is marked as in y' figure, black where y' is
black. & orange where that is white, y'' under part of y^ Taile 2. is y' 2 tirst rings black, y" a white
small line between y' & the next ring w'-^ is bla. y" y"" rest up to y'' body is white w"* a black Spot in
y"" middle, y"^ legs are black, except 1/2 y" middle joynts, y" wings are Somewhat brownish.

CHARLES DUBOIS" INSECT NOTES 43

2. Musca apiformis Cauda fulva nigro notata altera, pulchri? annulata.

Taken 16 May & w"' y' last from w^'' it differs only in these particulars, y'-' Tail in y^ Cross mark,
varys a little in y" form. & the 3 last annulary portions of y" Tail are finely edged with white
Under y'" Tail, this is orange where y'^ former is white, & y" wings have a little Spot on y"^ outward
Edge.

3. Musca apiformis 3a Cauda tota annulis albis distincta. This differs from y'' first but y' y'^^ Tail hath
no Orange, but is marked only with 3 white rings both above & underneath; Taken with y*^ last.

4. Musca minor cauda eleganter annulata. Taken y' middle of July upon y'^ leaves of
Caryophyllata. The eyes meet, sad Chesnut y'^ little horns black, y"^ mouth Silvery, y'" back of y*^
Thorax sad & striped, y"' tail finely divided into black & w"^ rings crost by a line from end to end, y''
tail is thin & macilent. Sad underneath, y*^ wings Sad. especially at y"^ Setting on. & outward Edges,
y'" legs black, y'' Soles of y' feet white y'' Thorax i tail are hairy.

.S. Musca molendinaria minor; y^ Smaller Millers Fly. Taken on y'' Rasps, middle of July. The Eyes
are Chesnut, & almost meet. & have a Silver Edge round y"" backside, y" horns arc black, y*^ nose
Silver y*^ back Sad. & somewhat Shining. The Tail composed of 3 or 4 Rings, y' End black. & about
y'^ middle shining w"' white changeable Spots as it is differently turned to the light, the whole Tail is
Set w"' pretty Stiff black hairs. The wings pretty large. & longer than the Tail, brown at y' Setting
on, the membranes under y' wing, by w'^^'' perhaps they make their Noise is white & large, the
under Side of the whole body is black, the Legs are pretty long, a little hairy & black, y'' Toes
white.

6. Musca molendinaria major vivipara.

The greater Millers Fly. The Eyes are red or brick colour. & meet not. y" horns are black & pretty
large, between y'^^ Eyes. & the nose is Silver, the Thorax is grey, black & w"-' in Stripes, y'' Tail
appears checquerd of bla. & w'^' if differently objected to y" light, underneath less vividly, y'' legs
are somew' hairy, long. & black, y'' Toes w'". This will sometimes when taken let fall small white
worms out of y' anus, y'^ wings are large, & have a tincture of blewishness upon them.

7. Musca fusca media alis pulchra Splendentibus.

Taken 22 July upon Currans. y" head is pretty large, y" Sad Eyes meet, over y" Small black horns is
a shining Spot, y' mouth Shines also, y" Thorax is Sad & Shines remissly, y'' tail is Sad, underneath
black & Shinmg y" legs arc black, the wings lye over one another a little, & Shine vividly, y" inner
parts green, & outward Copper.

8. Musca fusca cauda subtus canaliculata. Taken 22 July upon y" Doronicum Americ. Park, a black
broad line parts y' chesnut Eyes, under y' Small black horns is y"" Silverd mouth the Thorax is
obscurely Stript next the head, y^' tail is sad made of 4

Rings, underneath black, w"' a furrow running lengthwayes narrow at y" tip, & broader towards y"'
body, y" legs are all black w"' white Toes, y'' wings Saddish transparent, & longer than y'' Tail.

9. Musca apiformis fusco = fulva. major.

Take in y'' beginning of September upon y" Flowers of Tagetes It much resembles a bee in its looks,
colour way of flying & feeding on Flowers, but wants the 4 wings & horns w^** 1 lake to be
Characteristick notes of a Bee. It is a large fly. of a dark sad. set with fine brown hairs, y' eyes are
dark sad pearced (in a glass) as in y' Common Fly. divided on y"^^ top of y" head by a black shining
knob. Two small black horns come out of another black knob, each Set w"' one fine hair y' face is
thick set w"' Small brown hairs, extends downward in a hard longish beak wherem lyes y'
proboscis. The Thorax is very hairy on all Sides, y" Tail less so. blackish & shming & when y" tly
alights it heaves up & down as if it helpt its respiration; it is somewhat compresst y*" Sides being
edged, upon pressing y'' End I could not discern any Sting. The Legs are Sad. on y'^ Edges hairy, y'
middle joints of y' 4 first legs whitish, y" hmdcr legs large strong. & having y'^ middle portion large
& flat as in y' hony bee The 2 wings arc long & large very transparent, having on each outward

44 L. JESSOP

edge a Sad Spot or Stroke, y" Rihs in y^ wing disposed unusually, y" wings lye a little over one
another. & not as in y^' figure.

1(1. Musea Splendens eauda compressa. alis ex fulvo fuscis.

Taken about y" middle of June upon y'' flowers of Podagraria. The head is wholK taken up hv the
Eyes, which ineet together. & Shine greenish, ct appear pearled in a glass; Two small horns come
out before, under which is a Small black Shming spot. The Thorax shines and is a vivid green. & by
y'' help of a glass appears full of brown hairs; The Tail shines also & is of a brown green appearing
to be full of brown down in the glass: it Spreads broad towards y'"' End, & comes off round. & is
made up of .> Rings; underneath it is flatfish. & y'" Edges round turn downwards. & y''" Glass shews
it to be finely punctate; The Legs are Sad brown. The wings are longer than y' Tail. & brownish all
over.

1 1. Musca longa gracilis. 3 Striis nigris in dorso notata. aliis fusco-fulvis.

Taken N"' May on y^' Flowers of panax Heracleum where many of y"' sit together ihrustmg down
their long proboscis into y'' hollow of y^' Flowers. The head is round & Small y*^^ Eyes not easily
discernable. being of y" Same sad colour with y" rest of y^' head. 2 small stiff horns come from one
Original in y' fore part of it. y' body is ash on y"' back are 3 fair black Stripes, y^' tail & Legs sad &
hairy, y^ wings long & brown, y" 2 parts under y"" wings common to all flyes are Small knobs set on
a slender thred.

12. Musca media fusca. cauda 4 maculis nigris notata.

Taken 19"' May upon y*^ Flowers of Panax Fleracleum; Its Eyes meet & are sad. y" nose Silverish.
w"* 2 small hairy horns thereat, y' body is dark grey, y" Tail Lighter w"' 4 fair black Spots thereon,
very hairy & underneath parted lengthwise with a broad black line, y" membranes under y"" wings
are whitish.

13. Taken 2.'^"' May on Apricock Leaves. The Head & back is Sad, y'^ Eyes large almost meeting.
The upper Side of y'^ Sharp pointed Tail black & shining, divided into 4 rings by white Circles, y''
belly yellow, at y"^ End black. The 4 Leggs before Yellowish, y^' hinder ones sad. with a brown Spot
in the midst of y"^ 2 upper joints. The division between the 2 Eyes white.

14. Musca apiformis velox luteo et nigro varius. Cauda Scorpii.

Taken L' June in y^' Lane near East Field. It is a very beautifull Fly. The head is large, y' Sad
Shining Eyes meet atop, between them in the fore part of y' face are 2 large long yellow Spots
parted by a black line y' 2 horns black, thick & indifferently long, y'' Thorax is black two small
yellow lines run down y'" Length of it in the midst. & on each side are 4 irregular yellow Spots, 2
about y'' Setting on of y^" wing & twii below it between y' thorax & y^' Tail is set a Small oblong
black body circled round with yellow, y' Tail hath .S Rings y' 3 Hrst have yellow rings upon black
but they meet not in y'' midst, y^ lowest most yellow, a broad list of yellow on y^ Sides divides y"
upper & under parts of y'-" Tail, under it is black & yellow in alternate rings, at y'' End of y'' Tail is a
yellow Scorpion like Tail w''' it clapt up to y^ under part of y" Tail, armed w"' brown Claws, visible
in a glass.

15. Musca pavonina gracilis splendens.

Taken y" beginning of June & 17 July on Rasps. & Curran bushes. It shines green all over, the Eyes
especially, between which is a white Spot. & just above that, come out 2 Short horns standing out
two ways. The wings are long & large towards y'' End sad. & while at y'' very end; The Legs are
brown; towards y'' Ends Sad. & pretty long.

16. Musca media tota viridis splendens.

Taken y" first of June on y"^ Hedges in y"" Lane near East Field, where were many of them. It is all
over green, except a Small white Stroke divides y'^ Eyes, y' horns are black & end in a hne hair, the
Thighs are brown y" rest of y^' Legs black.

CHARLES DUBOIS' INSECT NOTES 45

17. Musca fusca Nasicornis.

Taken w"' y" last. The Eyes arc reddish brown, parted on the top with a pretty black division, a
Streight brown shining horn goes streight out at y"' Nose under w^'' hangs a Streight black thickish
tongue, y" true horns are brown. The Thorax is Sad, with 3 black stripes thereon, y"^^ appendent
knob to y"' thorax between y"' Setting on of y'' wings, sad chesnut colour the Tail is chesnut, the
Edges of the Rings black, & divided lengthwise by a black Stroke, y^ Tail is almost circular, flat, &
sharp at y"" Edges, underneath brown in y"^^ middle, &. blackish at y' Edges the Legs arc Sad. The
wings arc brownish

Genus vespinum. The Wasp kind.
I reduce those Insects of my own observation to this kind, that have 4 wings, & whose Tailes or
hinder part of the body is joyned to y"' breast or chest by a Small thread, as Mouffet speaks page 42.
Corpus vesparum medio pectori tenuissimo quodam Hlo alligatur; whether they have Stings or not;

I.
Vespa minor duobus aculeis, annulis in cauda flavis, macula insigni tlava in fronte notata. Vespa
Brachmanica nobis. The Bramine Wasp.

Taken y'-' beginning of June, The Head is large & black, as also are y"' Eyes, w''' are black, the
Horns come out of y"' forehead, arising from two Originals. & seen in a Glass appear joynted, &
grow bigger & bigger from y'' head to y'' Ends, the Mouth is furnished with a Serrate Forceps, one
part of w"'' in Shutting goes over the other, & opens Sideways, & bites very hard; just above the
mouth & between y'' lower part of the Eyes, is a fair yellow Spot rising above the Surface like a
Studd. The Thorax or body is black; & that & the Tail are cover'd with a hard Shell, the Tail is
composed of 7 or 8 Rings of yellow upon black, w''' go one under another when it Shrinks in its
Tail, as the plates do in Armour; The Tail is Set to the body by a very Slender juncture, as in this
kind is common. The legs arc yellow & indifferently long. It hath 4 Wings, long & Slender, the
inner ones not above 1/2 the length of the outer ones. With much irritating at length it thrust out 2
Stings set at some little distance from each other, several times. I call it by this Name from y"
Bramine Custome of making a yellow Spot in the foreheads of their Votaryes.

1.
Vespa Brachmanica.

2
Vespa Brachmannica altera, ore aura micante The Golden mouth'd Bramine wasp.
Taken \9 July on y' Currans. The Eyes are larger than the former & black, between them are 2
Small lines of yellow, where y'' horns come out. y^' bottom parts of y"' stands up against y' Face &
arc yellow, & y' upper parts bend off forward & arc black. y° mouth Shines like Gold, under w'''
plate is a small forceps; In y'' hinder part of the head, stand 3 Small Shining knobs triangular-wise.
Scarce visible without a little Assistance from a Glass. The Thorax is all black on both Sides except
4 yellow spots next y' head; The Tail is slenderly Set on made of 6 yellow rings set upon black, w"''
appear but obscurely underneath. The Thighs arc black, y" rest of the Legs yellow, except y'' Toes,
w^ are black, the 4 wings are Sad transparent, & have a Shew of rainbow colours on them

3,
Vespa minor tota nigra The small black wasp.

Taken 19 July, It is all black, except a Small Silver plate at y*^^ mouth; & y" wings, w''' have a
Saddish tincture on y"', the inner ones are much less y" y'^ outer ones.

4. Vespa longa. pectore & dorso nigris, cauda & dorso macula alba notatis, cornubus trcmulis in

medio albis.

Taken in y" beginning of June on y*^^ flowers of Tithymalus Tingitanus lunato fl. Moris. The head.

46 L- JESSOP

Eyes. & Thorax are black, except one w"' Spot between y"' Setting on of y'' wings, on y'" back. The
Horns are more y" 1/2 an inch long, curled at y" Ends, & black except a portion of w"' in y" middle,
trembling incessantly when it goes; The Tail hangs on by a Slender thread, the first ring black, y'' 2
next Orange, y" remainder black, w"' a white spot at y^' End; when lirst taken, by thrusting the Tail
towards the Head, came out a black point or Sting from y' middle of y" under part of y"' Tail; The
under part of the body is colour'd like y" upper, but y' Tail is flatter, with a ridge in y"' midst of y''
rings running lengthways; The Legs are long, y"^ first joynts black, then lighter orange, then black.
then brown to v' Toes. Vide N" 7

5
Vespa longa pectore & dorso nigris, minor absque aculis albis.

Taken on y" Same flowers & at the same time with the last. The head Horns & Thorax arc black
the Tail long. & Slenderer than y"' last, made of 7 rings of w'*' y"' hrst is black, the .1 middle ones
Orange. & y' 3 at y' end black, the leggs are browner than the former, it hath not the Spot on y^'
back & Tail. & the Horns curie not so. The figure is a little bigger than y"' life & the Tail too thick.

6. Vespa nigra minor gracilis, eauda in 2 Setis aculcum inscrvicntibus desinentc. cornubus
praelongis tremulis

Taken w"' y' last; It is all black, save y' orange thighs; when it goes y' horns tremble exceeding
fast, feeling what is in y'' way; The outward edge of y" bigger wings hath a Small Spot on it. a long
Sting or point comes out under the tail about y'' midst, w'''' when y'' Tail lyes strcight remains
between y"' 2 Setae in w"" the Tail ends, w''' Seem a guard to it. & when y"' Insect pushes w"' it. in
bends y" Tail downward & towards y' head, & thrusts the said sting strongly towards y'' head, as
that N" 4 also doth.

7
Vespa oblonga maxima pecore & dorso nigris. cauda 4 & dorso tribus albis maculis
notatis.cornubus tremulis. in medio albo notatis

Taken 14 September. It is very like N" 4 but 3 or 4 times as bigg. & besides y^' Spot which that hath
in y'' middle of y" back, this hath one at y" Setting on of each of y' bigger wings; y'' white Spot at y''
end of y" Tail is here distinguish into 4. one on each of y" 4 last rings, in y" other y'' Tail is flatter, in
this very turgid, opening on each Side, which apperture or Slitt is supplyed by a thin yellow Skin, in
all other things this is like y'.

Vespa Cauda corpori Hrmius adhaerente

9. Vespa nigricans graculis N" 6 similis ast major, cauda absq Setis.

Taken 25''' May on y" Flowers of Panax Heracleum. It is every way like N" 6 but bigger. & hath not
the Sting, or Setae w"'' that hath; perhaps it is y" female to that.

10. Eadem fronte flava.

Taken in y'' Lane by East Field. June V . This differs in nothing from y'' last but in y'' Square yellow
Spot it hath between y" Eyes. & y" finely jointed horns are yellowish before, & black behind.

Apinum Genus
Bombylius Dni Purchas. Viviparus.
He describes it p. IKS. & gives an Anatomical account of it. & also of its being viviparous p. 191 .
Purchas's Theater of political flying Insects Anno lfi.S7. In y' figure y' first white ring is yellow in y''
Bee y^' w"' ring in y"' midst of the Tail is yellow also. Ji. the end white. The figure is a little loo big. I
took one of this sort May 10"' three times as big.

2. Apis fusca Cauda glabra.

Taken upon Poppy flowers 17"' July. It is all of a dark Sad colour, y" face & back, thick set with line

CHARLES DUBOIS INSECT NOTES 47

Brownish hairs, the horns short & strcight, y" Tail Smooth & Shining, under w'^'' was much yellow
matter like bee bread, y" wings brownish, w"' a deeper brown Stroke on y"-' outward Edge of each
of y'^ bigger wings near the End, y"' Legs middling; Just at y" Setting on y' wings, on each Side is a
remarkable small round black shining knob.

3. Apis minor fulva, alis praelongis, Iridis modo splendentibus

I have forgot when & where taken, & it is described dead. The head, horns, & middle of y'' back is
black. The Tail on both Sides Orange, & y*" Legs also except y'^ last Joints w'^ are speckt with black
All 4 wings are very large & much longer than the Tail, y*" outward Edge of y'= upper marked with a
black Stroke, They shine fmely with Rainbow colours.

4. Apis gloriosa

Taken on Cherry Leaves, May 24 The whole forepart & Legs is of a beautifuU bluish green; & y'
Tail especially y" upper part shining copper, on the Sides changeable into yellow, gold & green, all
foraminulous. when urged it puts forth a long flexible Sting. The wings are sad

Genus Cimicinum.

1.
Cimex subviridis variegatus, odorcm gravem spirans.

Taken in the beginning of June; It moves slowly, when it stands still the head is raised like y' of a
Frog, & if laid on its back, it can hardly recover its feet, which after much Struggling it does by
turning over its head. It smells very Strong, & very ill; & when dead turns all black, & shrinks up to
meer Skin. The head is like a Tortoises; y" two Small Eyes arc black; y' horns have three Joints,
white at y"-' Junctures, elsewhere blackish; The Thorax & Tail greenish; it hath neither Wings nor
Vaginae. Round y'' Skirt of y"' Tail part on both Sides it is marked with little V's The middle is
regularly mark'd wth Spots the 4 largest & middlemost are copper colour'd & in bas-relieve. y''
others black & not raised, the belly is green with a black line running cross its length. The legs are
greenish also, but blackish at y^ Ends.

Taken at Tunbridgc Wells 1695
1. Bombylius niger, eauda in acumen aurantii coloris desinente

Taken among y'' Corn upon y' flowers of Panax Coloni Aug. 3. The figure is too long; it is all over
black except the 3 last Rings of y' Tail, w'-'' are Orange, being thick set with hairs of y' colour,
deeper above, & more remiss underneath; A shining black Small knob on each Side of y" Thorax at
y' Setting on of y" wings, y"' legs arc Strong & hairy

2. Phalaena Splendens ex aureo-fulva

Taken flying in y" day 5 August, It is all of one light-brown colour Shining as if varnisht with a
dilute gold colour; The Eyes are round, prominent & very black, y'"' horns short & Slender; It hath
a particular way of flying, y*" wings moving fluttering, & by turns quicker & slower.

3. Papilio alba, alis maculatis corpore nigro. Taken 12"' Aug. flying, y' middle of y*^ Thorax black,
as is y'' upper part of y"' Tail, y^' Eyes very black & prominent, round y" Thorax &. about y^' head, is
set w"' w"' hair, y*^ under part of y'^ Tail & y" legs cover'd with a mealy whiteness, y"^ horns black
tipt at y'"' ends with white, y'"' wings on y" upper sides white with black as in y'' flgure. y" ribs of y'
wings blackish, y' under wings on y" under Side brimstone y'^ ribs large & blackish, y^ under Side of
y' upper wings w'" except y'^ Ends, w*^*" are also brimstone colour'd.

4. Papilio minor alis ex fulvo fuscis, macula nigra in media alba insignitis.

Taken 12 Aug. on y" Common, y*^ upper wings are pale orange for y'' most part, except round y"

Edges & in y" middle where they are Sad, y' under wings arc only orange in y' middle, &

48 L. JESSOP

underneath all Sad. Sadder towards y'' Setting on. & y^' lower 1/2 lighter, y'' upper wings have each
towards y"" End. a fair black spot wth a Small white Spot in y" midst of it, y' whole body head &
horns very Sad. y'' horns have not a knob set on y' End, but near y° End grow thicker only.

5. Scarabeus major terrestris ater splendens vaginis Striatis.

Taken on y'' Common 13"' August creeping in y^' paths There arc 2 Sorts, a less w*^"* I take to be y"
female, y' under part of w'*" is purple Shining as Steel, y" bigger Shining green, w*^^'' I suppose to be
y' male, y'^ first pair of Legs is set on y'^ Thorax, y'^^ Second on y' part of y" tail next y' Thorax. & y^'
S** pair in y^' midst of y" Tail, w"' Strong thighs.

Notes upon Insects &c. 1692 & \695
Their Genus
See under 1. Musca corpore & alis fuscis. cauda in longum acumen desinente, capite parvo,

4 bicorni. proboscidi recto, pedibus longis pilosis, this is a dull heavy fly taken 28 May.

on y'' Currans.

2. Eruca parva viridis striatus Geometer, this is that w'^ eats up y"^ Filbeard leaves, it
hath 3 pair of feet before. & only one pair behind, besides those holders at y' tail, by
which it will Stand erect & reach out its whole body to lay hold on what is in its reach,
v^' head is almost transparent; fine small whitish Striae run along y' length of y" back;
taken off y" Filberds 28 May.

3. Eruca viridis major se contorqucns &c. taken off y' grass in the common, its head is
green, hath 3 pair of feet before. 4 pair in y' middle. & y" 2 holders at y' Taile. on
each Side just above y'^ insertion of y"^ feet runs a pale pretty broad yellow stripe the
whole length of y^' body, along y'' upper part of this yellow stripe runs a fine line of
white Ai on \' top of y^' white a broader line of Cinamon colour, with white Spots in
it. w''^ Spots stand one in y" midst of each ring; On each side of y"^ back runs one
other Small pale yellow stripe y^' length of its body, in the middle of y^ back at y'
insertion of one ring into another is a Small spot of Cinamon colour, about fi or 7 in
all. those rings towards y" head & taile having none; when it creeps the body seems
to move within y^' Skins before y"^^ Skin, y^' rings are inserted almost Scalewise. when
'tis disturbed it roals it self round, falls on one Side. & puts y^' Taile over y"^ head by
way of security. I fed it with Aprccock leaves.

3. Eruca major fusca eaudii protubcrante. found under y" Coping of a brick wall, it
seemed near its change, (lost)
vide 66 4. Scarabeus medius fuscus Saltans, when taken it counterfeits its Self dead. A; when
& 67 turned on its back it will leap up. by a Spring in the neck; Mr Doody calls it y"

Castanet Fly, from y' Snap it makes, w" it Springs.
1. Adde to N" 1. y'^ Taile is bifurcate if narrowly viewed, it hath 3 black Stripes on the
back, y^ outward Edges of y" wings near y' insertion are brown, y'^ legs & back arc
furnished with small fine hairs, y"' back is gibbous, y'' head hangs lower y" it, y' Eyes
are larger & rather more chesnut cold than y^ rest of y^' head.

5. Musca flava corpore producto. capite. & dorso nigro. bicorni. taken .^ or 6 June, y" colour is a
vivid orange yellow, y^' 4 wings arc of y" Same colour only towards y'' Ends more transparent & y"
outward Edges of them black almost to y'' End. y" 2 under wings arc not black at all. y'' leggs are
yellow too. only y"^ lower parts spotted black, y' 2 horns arise not out of y*" Same origine as in some
others, 2 small yellow threds hang from y'" mouth y'' horns stand as in (ioats. y'' very point of y^
Taile is black. It is but a dull fly, or Bee rather

6. Scarabeus minor rotundus griseus macula nigra in dorso & altero in Cauda notatus, proboscidi
producto aniennis pra["***] I took it June l.'i on Verbascum. it is grey with exceeding little Spots,
on y'' back a fair round black Spot appears. & another near y*" Tail, it is about y*" bigness of a
common lady Cow they were in Coitu. the Male it Female are perfectly alike.

( H ARl.ES DUBOIS' INSECT NOTES 49

7 Eruca cicgantissima, flavjs & nigris maculis notata, iracundus The ground of their body is a pale
blewish white, the body is eomposed of 12 or 13 rings, on y'' top of the back, & in y"" middle of each
ring IS a large yellow spot, upon w'^'' yellow Spot are 4 small black spots set in a Square, on each
side of y" body along its length are smaller yellow spots one on each ring, upon & about w'^'' are
many bla spots of several figures & bignesses, y" head is bleak yellow spotted wth very small black
spotts, it hath 3 pair of Feet before, 4 pair in y^' middle & y" 2 holders at y' Tail, it feeds upon y"
leaves of Verbascum, I found many of them about y' End of June but not on any other plant,
when touched it Springs & jerks like a ttsh newly out of y'' water, & throws it body round Securing
its head with its tail, it is a little hairy, y'^^ hairs are long but thin set.

8. Eruca striata quasi oeulata, about 1 1/2 inch when at biggest Somewhat hairy, y^' head is blewish
with 2 black spots seated in y"^^ place of Eyes, a white line runs y'' length of it just in y" midst of y'
back, on each Side are slender Stripes of orange blew & Sad, y" blew y^ broadest, y' rings of y''
body are longer & flatter, it hath 3 legs before 4 in y' midst & 2 holders, I fed it with

Aprecock leaves, & after 20 dayes in y*^ middle of June it Spun a long hne white Silk web. See after

') Musca sanguisuga, y''" Horse fly, y" Eyes arc very like an Opal in y*^ fine changeableness of its
colours, y" head very wide, extending on each side beyond y" Sholders, y'^ wings grey, y" proboscis
blunt & flat at y" end as a leeches mouth

1(1. Musca minima viridis, saltans alis praelongis, this is y" production, y' appears upon y"" backsides
ol leaves & stalks in Clusters like Lice, it hath 2 very small black Eyes, 2 long horns & 4 wings, y'
outermost are as long again as y'' body, y'^ 2 innermost much less, it tlyes hovering in the Evening,
& when it lights if touched skips as a Grasshopper a great Length, probably it is necessary it Should
be thus furnished to throw it self into y'^ Air when it is about to fly, y'" length of y"^^ wings hindering
its more immediate flight from y"' place where it stands.

11. Phalaena media ex albo & nigro varia, alis ultrinquc eodem more notatis, y" head & Shoulders
are yellow w'*" bla Spots, y" Eyes black, y^' rings of y'' tail end in a yellow Circle going round it, y"^
legs are branch[ed] & ash colour'd Shining, y" antennae more than 1/2 an inch long Sordid, y'^
wings are finely marked with black or near it, y' ground w'", all four wings are nearly alike.

12. Phalaena tota alba plumata, y" body is slender, about 1/2 an inch long, y'^ legs very long &
branched, y'' wings each are composed of 2 perfect feathers joyned together near their Origine, y"
eyes very Small & black, y'^^ antennae about 1/8 of an inch long.

13. Phalaena fulva

14. Vespa minor duobus aculcis, annulis flavis in eauda, insigni macula flava in fronte notata.
Taken y" beginning of June, The body is black & y' tail also but divided in rings w"*" go one under
another when it Shrinks in y"' tail (y'' whole body being cover'd not w"' a thin Skin but a hard Shell)
as in y' joints of armour y'' rings are bright yellow, y' body is set to y"' tail by a very small juncture
as in wasps & hornets, y'' head is large as are the Ey's which are black, y'' horns come out of y"
forehead & Set before y" Eyes, arising from 2 originals, seen in a glass are jointed, but smooth, &
grow bigger to y" End, just above y'" mouth & between y'' lower part of the Eyes is a fair yellow
Spot, like a Stud, y' mouth is like a Lobsters Claws opening Sideways & one going over the other,
so y' it Seems to be an Insect of prey in armour, y'' legs are yellow and indifferently long, with much
irritating at length it thrust out 2 Stings at a distance from each other, several times, & bites hard
with its serrate Jaws, y"' hgure is not slender enough, & the wings to long. Its 4 wings are long &
Slender, y" under one but 1/2 the length of y" upper ones.

l.S. Cimcx sylvestris subviridis variegatus odorem gravem Spirans, taken y" beginning of June, it
smells very ill & very Strong, round y"' Skirt of y*" back marked with little u's on both its sides, y' 4
middle most of y" Spots on y" back appear like copper bullae y" belly is green a line of blackish
running through y'' midst of it from y"" tail, it has neither wings nor Vaginae, when it Stands Still y"
head is raised like a frog, & when turned on y"' back, it can hardly raise its self up, & then it turns

50 L. JESSOP

over its head, y" legs are of y'' colour of y" body, but more blackish towards y" end. y^' head like a
Tortoise, w"" 2 Small black Eys. y'^ horns are joynted w"" 3 joynts. white at y' junctures elsewhere
blackish, it moves not fast.

16. Musca pavonina gracilis Splcndens. it Shines green all over the Fycs especially between which
is a white spot. & just above that comes out two horns Short & standing two wayes. the legs are
brown, towards y° Ends Sad. & pretty long; taken beginning of June & 17 July on currans on y''
Rasps, y'" wings are long & lar[ger?] towards y" End Sad. & y' very End.

17. Scarabeus minor oblongus niger cauda aculeata. gibbosus. Taken y'' beginning of June, when
laid on a Table it leaps & jerks very often, the Vaginae are deep Sad or blackish. & to the Eye
appear Smooth, but by the Glass have innumerable small puncta all over them, y'' whole Tail is
deep Orange, made up of .'i rings inserted one under another Scale wise. & in y'' glass thick Set with
down, v'' Tail ends in a long point like a Sting y^ part between y'" head & wings is \° Same Orange
colour v'' head black like y" Vaginae, w^'' it goes hanging down perpendicularly, by the reason y''
back rises high. & gibbous y' horns are Small & appear joynted in y^ glass, the head is Set on to y'
Edge of y" Neck slenderly, a black shell covers y"^ breast on each Side from under w^'' y' Tail comes
out y'' hinder legs are Set on y*^ Edge of this Shell, with Strong thighs. & are pretty long, by which it
leaps, the legs are of y' Same Sad colour with y' Vaginae, taken upon Panax Heracleum.

18. Apis longa Subtus flavescens. Taken at \° Same time & place with y'' last y^' black Eyes arc large
taking up almost all y' head. & in y' Glass appear as a flyes pitted, y'' 2 bla indifferently long horns
appear jointed 1/2 way also, y'^ wings are 4 the 2 biggest lye over y"^ lesser, w^'' biggest reach beyond
y^ tail y' upper part of y' tail is black except where one ring of yellow crosses it. y° legs arc long, y'
upper part of w'^'' are bla. y"^ foremost least, y' middle ones more, y'' hindermost most the whole
under part of y" Insect is of a pale Yellow, between y'' Eyes hangs down a yellow part in w''' is y''
forceps. & behind it a Strange apparatus of parts for y'^ Service of y" mouth.

18. A rude draught of y"^ apparatus of y'^ foremention'd Bees mouth.

1 y'^ forceps

2 wipers

3 a kind of trifid tongue under w'^'' Seems to lye the Gula.

19. Scarabeus minor oblongus obscure viridis, & remisse splendens. Taken at y'' Same time & place
with y" last It is of y" duller green shiners, y' 2 feelers have knobs at y'^ Ends, & in y" glass appear to
have 3 joints y"^, the horns are jointed to y' naked Eye, the whole body & vaginae arc of one
colour, y' toes end as flyes. & appear a little white.

20. Vcspa pectorc & dorso nigro. cauda & dorso macula alba notatis. cornubus etiam in medio
albis. The head Eyes & body is black, save y' in y"" midst of y^' back between the Setting on y'' wings
is a white Spot, y' horns are more than 1/2 an inch in length curled at y'' ends, all black except in y*"
midst of each horn is a portion of w'", y" Tail is set on by a Slender black thred. & is black toy'' first
ring, y'' Second & third ring are Orange colour. & y" remainder to the End is black save a white
Spot at y*^ End. the legs are long y' first joints black, then comes a lighter orange, y" bla. y" brown
to y''" toes, when it goes y" horns move incessantly, taken y' beginning of June on y"^ Tithymalus
Tingit. lunato flore Mons. when first taken it thrust its tail towards y'' head & from y" under part of
y" Tail about y'' middle not y" End came out a long black point or Sting, but it Seemed black, y''
under part of the body is in coulour like y' upper, but y' tail is flatter under neath, with a Ridge
running in the midst of y"" rings length wayes

21 . Scarabeus minor oblongus fuscus lineis flavis notatus. Taken 28"" May, its length is about 3/4 of
an inch, y*^ head large, dusky, w"' a bright yellow ring round between y'-' fore pan of y' neck & y*^
Eyes, y"-' 2 homes about .3/4 of an inch long, orange near y' head, & growing darker to y" End, y'

t H ARLES DUBOIS' INSECT NOTES 5 1

Vaginae dusky prettily marked with yellow thus, the legs dusky orange, y' hinder ones very long,
w"' Stronger thighs as if designed for leaping, tho, I did not see it leap.

22. Scarabeus medius fuscus corpore fulvo. taken 2X May it's very common about Curran's y^' head
is flattish w"' Small blaek eyes, y'' horns arc 1/2 an inch long joynted all y'' way, & bending
downward towards y'^^ Ends, at ly"] mouth are set four small Short feelers y*" 2 outer ones longest
w^'' 2 continually tremble, between y' head & the setting on of y" wing is a dark orange colour'd
plate y'^^ edges of w'^'' turn up a little, y'' Vaginae dark musk colourd, y'' wings under but a little
longer than their cases, y' thighs orange, the rest of the legs musk, the latter joynts to y*" toes
jointed & indented on each side y" body

23. Idem fulvus. taken y*" Same time y" Same with y*" former only all yellow tawny, except y"^ horns
& the joints of y*-* Legs, it hath a Small black stroke on y^' forehead a little above y'' Eyes, w"
touched I****] from y*" place where it stood, it hath a Sharp pair of forceps w"' which it bites at
everything w" taken.

Scarabeus Maialis minor, taken at y'' Same time. It is just like y' may beetles save y' it wants |****]
Sides, y'^ male is the less & rounder bodyed, the female bigger & flatter [****] between y*" head &
wings is in y" male more purple, & in the female [****] at y" End of May when y" greater sort go
out, & eat young [****) are only trifid

[**•*] taken y"" Same time eating Curran Leaves, y" head black circled |****] but one next y*" tail
yellowish, y*^ rest of the body greenish, & almost [ ] small black spots are set on each ring & a
larger black spot in y" midst |****| it hath a few very short small hairs on y'^ body, it moves not as
the [****] a worm, it hath .3 pairs of Legs before, 6 pair beyond y" & the 2 holders at y"' tail [**'*| it
throws its body over its head standing on it 6 forefeet like y^ Tumblers (*••*] l & 1/2 inch in
Length, the fault in this picture is 1 pair of Legs too much, & too many rings, the last pair of Legs
being set on y*^ next ring but one to y' tail
this is y" better draught, only y*" legs are too long.

26. An Scarabeus ex minimis totus viridis imperfectus, taken y" Same time about 1/6 of an inch,
with very Small dark colour'd Eyes, long horns, & pretty long legs, imperfect wing stick upon y'
back about 1/2 way its length, tis nimble, qu" if of kin to y" Cuckow spit

this is somew' bigger y" the Life

27. Eadem alba, just y' Same only w'^ w"" a faint shew of greenish upon it, phaps not so ripe

28. Scarabeus ex minimis chalybis colore & Splendore, hypocritica, vel ex motu se mortuum
fingens taken 26 May, it retires into y" hollow recesses of Flowers. Dandelion, Hyacinth. Angl. &c
y'' Vagina are like Steel in colour & shining, the wings w" extended near as long again as y"
Vaginae, transparent, & as they are differently objected to y" light have a faint Shew of rain bow
colours, two small antennae w"' knobbs at y" Ends, w" toucht it falls out of y'' flower & counterfeits
its Self dead.

29. Vermiculus mihi punctum Saliens dictus. 26 May extending a Sheet of white paper near y" hot
beds, one may see Small black animals light on it, about the bignesses of these points which run
indifferently fast, if disturbed they Skip out of sight, viewed by a glass they appear worms annular
rings forming y' length, & at y'^^ head 2 horns feelers, they move with 6 legs in y' middle of y" body
or K they were too Small tV: nimble for observation

2S. Musca maxima quadripennis fulva, Labella taken 28 May on y" Rasps, this is y" 4th in Mouffet
p. 66. in his description y' wings are Said to be argentei coloris, but they are w" held on one Side
aurei coloris otherwise transparent.

29. Labella ex minimus, an 4a Mouffeti, taken y' Same time. If it be Mouffcts his description & ^
figure are not exact. It is blew y' head large & Eys prominent a broad bar of black cross y'' top of y'
head from Eye to Eye, 3 bars of bla. run lengthways from y"^ head to y*^^ Setting on of y" wings the
middlemost y' broadest, y' tail is divided into 6 or 7 joynts markt black as in y"' figure, on y' upper

52 L. JESSOP

side of the legs a bla slender stripe runs lengthwise, y" fibers of y" wing cross each other at right
angles.

30. Centipes lulus, about y' root of Tulips between y^ Coats of y^ rotten ones are many of | ' * * * |
Sizes. I am of opinion y' they are hatcht there of y' Eggs deposited by y-^ |*'**1 y' least are whitest,
they have 2 joynted antennae, their feet end in Sharp points

31. Scarabeus ex minimis, fuscus progressum analis imitans [****]

it light on my book as 1 was reading in y' Garden,

32. Scarabeus ex minimis capite Chalybcata ex fulvo fuscus pedibus fulvis agilis taken 27' May
digging it came out of y" ground, y'' head & sholders shine like Steel, it hath 2 long horns jointed
with long joints scarce to be Seen well but by a glass & 4 feelers about y" mouth, y^' legs
indifferently long, & pale [****] body almost black, y" vaginae towards y' Sholders fulvous
towards y' tail blackish Shining Steely, y' Vaginae appear Striate in a glass it runs very nimbly,

32. figure as it appears by a Glass

33. a Small fly in y" Gnat Shape but without featherd antennae, y' head almost all taken up by y"
Eyes, vi"'' are like a Common flyes. a Slender Neck, y"' back gibbose. & Elegantly marked with 4
black Spotts. of w'''' this is y"' better figure, y" body dark colour'd y" legs greenish. & long this hgure
is 6 times bigger than y^ life, this is to be referr'd to y^ brown long legs in y" meadows. & not to y^
Gnats, they are to be found on y" Cieling of y^ Necessary house. Musca Culiciformis dorso quatuor
maculis notato.

34. Vespa peetore & dorso nigro. minor, sine maculis. Taken on y" Same Tithymale at the same
time, the difference between these is, this wants y" Spot of white on y^' back. & taile, & y'' white on
y' horns, which are longer & not curled at y"' Ends, y'' legs are browner, perhaps this is y"' Male, v,""
is the lesser in many insects.

35. Vespa minor gracilis nigra cauda in duobus seris, aculeum inser\'ientib. desinente, cornubus
praelongis tremulis. Taken at y"' Same time on y'' Same Tithymale; It is all black, except y' thighs
w'-'' are Orange, when it goes y" horns by w"'' it feels are moved trembling exceeding fast, there is a
Small Spot on y" Edge of each of the bigger wings, a long kind of Sting comes out from near y''
middle of y*" tail underneath, w'^'' when the tail lyes Streight remains between y^ 2 Setae in w' the
tail Ends, w'"" Seem made for a Guard to it, & when y' Insect pushes with it, it bends its tail
inwards, & y" thrusts it very Strongly, as one may feel with a pin. See N" 2(1

36. Musca Vespoides nigra, capite magno, ore albo, cornuorum etiam extrcmitatibus albis.
Taken y' beginning of June on the Rasp bushes, y'' head wth y'' Eyes is large, y' 4 wings dusky, y"'
whole black, except y^' mouth, ends of y'' horns, which are white & two white Spots on each side
under y' wings at y'' juncture of y' taile & chest, this moves as y^' last with its horns tho' not so
quick, & would be nearer of kin but y' y" body is set on to y'^ tail more Strongly, & not by so
Slender a thread.

37. Musca Splendens cauda compressa, alls ex fulvo fuscis. Taken in y"' midst of June upon y"'
flowers of Podograria. The head is wholly taken up by the Eyes w"'' meet together, & shine
greenish, & appear finely pitted in a glass, 2 Small horns come out before under w''' is a Small
black shining Spot, y'' body is vivid green Shining & in a glass appears full of brown hairs, y' tail is a
brown green Shining, appearing to be full of brown down in y'' glass, it Spreads broad toward y*^
End, & comes off round & hath .S rings, underneath tis flattish. & y"' edges round turn down & in a
glass looks finely punctated, y" legs are Sad brown, y' wings are longer y" y^ tail. & brownish all
over

38. Musca fulva cauda villosa. alls in medio parva macula insignitis. Taken at y^' Same time &
place. The Eyes Stand prominent on each Side y' head of a Sad colour, w"' 2 paler edgings on y''

(HARLES DUBOIS' INSECT NOTES 53

inside, or before y"^ face, in y"-' middle of w"'' between y" Eyes is a reddish Spot, y'' body is
indifferently large, & somewhat gibbous, of a Sad grey mixt eolour inclining to brown, the Tail is
very thick Set w"' fine brown long hairs, as are the legs, & all y'-' under part of y' body. The wings
are pretty large, & longer than the body, with a Small Sad or brown Speck in y" midst of each.

39. Musca oblonga, cauda et alis nigrofulvis ore argenteo. Taken at y*" Same time & place. They
Eyes take up the whole head, in y' midst of y"" come out 2 blunt orange colour'd horns arising from
a black original, y^' mouth & parts under the horns arc white & Shine like Silver, the body is a dark
Shining copper colour, down y" length of y'-" tail runs a broad black line, y'' End of y^ tail above &
underneath is Sad & shining, & at y" End underneath stuck a flat substance like wax, y'' rest of y"
under part of y*^^ tail to y' body is yellowish white, the legs are all black, pretty long & thick, y""
inside of y'^ toes white y"^ wings lye over on another as it Stands, & are of

a blackish brown, shaded darker about y'' middle

40. Musca chalybeata, corpore caeruleo cauda viridi, Splendentibus, capite fusco. vide 4.S
Taken at y'= Same time & place with y" last the head is taken up wholly with y" Eyes w''' are Sad y^
nose or mouth whitish y'' 2 little horns black, y" body shines lively like Steel, & y" Tail is shining
green, & somewhat downy, y' legs are black, & not long.

41. Musca fusca, alis griseis, compressa lata, cauda lata obtusa. Taken at y'" Same time & place.
The head is dark, y" Eyes also about y"' on the back sides is a line of white y" body is Sad, y'' Tail
dark grey w'" Some more whitishness about y"' Setting on than towards y' End w"'' is blunt &
Squarish, under y'' Tail next y*^^ body tis yellow qu'' if y" colour or some waxy foreign matter Stuck
there for y'' flyes use, the legs are Small & black, y'' wings pretty broad, longer than the Tail, &
when y" fly sits they hang down a little on each Side, they are speckled Sad upon white y' Sad
thicker in two cross barrs on each wing.

42. Scarabeus fulvus oblongus, pedibus & Cornubus praelongis. Taken on a Road about y' middle
of June. The head is longish, y' Eyes on each side small & black between w'^^'' a furrow lyes on y'
top of y'' head below y'^ Eyes come out 2 long horns bending round towards y"' Ends Sad orage
towards y' head & growing Sadder upwards jointed all y' way, & growing more whitish at y' End,
y'= Scapula or body part is cloth colour & unequall, y" tail part is square at y" Setting on & broad &
tapers to y'" End where it is blunt the Vaginae are pale Chesnut smooth & Shining, the whole under
part is cloth colour & Shining except at y"" End of y" tail, where it is Sad Orange, as are the legs
except the joints of y"' four formost & y"" thighs of the hindmost, they are long & end in one long toe
at y^' end of each of w'*" are two crooked Claws.

43. Phalaena media grisea, alis maculis cruciformibus notatis, oculis atris.

Taken at the End of June on a Ladyes clothes. The head is short & pointed y'= Eyes prominent &
very black, from each runs a black stroke to the sholders, y" horns are white at y" Setting on, &
after black. Small, & ending in a point, y"" back between y'' head & wings is very hairy, y"' wings are
light grey with Cross like marks of sad which are edged with white, y' Ends are Scallopt, y' under
wings are white & Shine like Sattin, & Scallopt also, & Sadish at y" Ends, y" under Side of y" upper
wings, have Some Sad Spots on y"\ y' tail is large & very hairy, blunt at y'= End like y' of y"' papilio
of a Silk worm, & grey, but whiter along the middle of its underside, y' thighs are thick set with
white hairs, the legs black & white in small alternate spots.

44. Apis ex sordido virescens alis supernis variegatis, infernis ex albo transparentibus.

Taken y'' middle of June, the head is flat faced w'^'out horns, or other furniture but what is under y'
beak at y" mouth, 2 is y'' appearance the face makes in a Glass, out of y'^^ mouth come three Setae, it
looks of a greenish Sad colour, y"' upper part of the body & tail is black except just at y'' neck where
a pale or whitish Circle goes round it y' edges of y' Tail are fueillemort, the 2 upper wings w" are
longer than the body are Sad with 2 whitish marks on the outer edge as in 3 the 2 under wings are
whitish & transparent, y" leggs are greenish, & black points at y" Joints, prettily inserted as in 4.
The Glass discovers Short Setae at the End of the Tail.

54 L. JESSOP

45. Eaiiem (cum 40) tota viridis this differs in nothing but that is wholly green without any blew as
that (40) hath, perhaps the diversity of Sex in y" Same fly. Taken middle of June.

46. Taken y' Middle of June, This is very Near of kin to n° 39. The difference. The head of this is a
little rounder, y' back shines more blackish, the tail is slenderer & the whole is of one colour. & the
wings shine more with rainbow colours I suspect it the male to .^9. because tis less, y' nose is bla.

47. Taken at y' Same time. This is not much unlike y' last but not 1/2 so big. y" back is not so big in
proportion nor doth it Shine so. y" wings are not so long as y*^ tail & dusky

48. Musca fusca cauda fulva. Taken in y" middle of June, much of y" Shape of 40 & 49. & y"' wings
lye horizontal like them. The Eyes are Sad & take up all y^' upper part of the head, & meet the nose
is black with a white Edging. The body or Chest is Shining black, y'' wings Sad at y" Setting on, &
longer than the Tail, which is dark Orange with a black line down the length. & y"' Edges of y"-' rings
black. & underneath all sad yellow except y' tip w'" is black, the whole tail is downy, the legs are
black. & the toes white.

49. Scarabeus minor fuscus compressus aquatilis

Taken in y" water in our ponds, about y'' middle of June. The whole is of a Sad colour. The head
not to be discerned from the plate or Thorax having 2 very slender horns which by a glass appear
joynted. & by y^ Same help 2 Small black Eyes are Seen on each Side the head. The Vaginae
Shine. & are especially near y' Setting on bent inwards wth a fold to go under part of the body this
Contrivance is to preserve the true wings from being wetted when they swim, the under part is
Sadder than y'' upper, the 4 forelegs are brown & armed wth 2 Claws at y" toes, to Creep with. &
issue out of y' fore part of the Thorax together the hinder legs issue out of y' Tail pretty low & end
in flat fins, to swim with, w'*' they do very nimbly diving down to the bottom as soon as one
approaches them, they will lye frequently at y'^ top in the Sun, very still to bask.

50. Phalacna pratensis Mouffeti 3a p. 9H

Taken about y'' midst of June flying in y'' day w"*' it frequently does in meadows tho' in y' day. The
whole body head legs & horns are very black the wings extend beyond y' End of the tail; each of y"
upper wings is near black w"" a long scarlet streak where y" black is in y"" picture and 2 Scarlet spots
at y' end of each wing, y' inner spot biggest, y' inner edges are Scarlet also, y*" underwings are
Cherry colour, except y' edges v/'*' are Sad, all 4 wings are finely fringed at y" Ends.

51 . Phalaena pratensis Mouffeti prima p. 97. Taken 29 June in Coitu on a Stalk of Corn. There is
no visible difference between y'' male & female. It is like the last, but y" body & tail is much bigger,
y^ horns also arc thick at y' Ends, y" Sad of y' wings shines more greenish, & the Scarlet on y"
upper wings is disposed into 5 fair Spots, & 2 smaller on y'' Edges, w'*" last is not in all. y"
underwings are much less than y"^ upper, w"'' Mouffets figure observes not

the wings are pendulous & not extended as in y" figure

52. About y" End of June 1 found an Aurelia hanging upon a twig, w^*" I put into a box, & w" I
came to look on it. it had produced a Phalaena. v,'*' 1 call Phalaena albo fusca variegata. The whole
body is a pale cloth as arc y^' under wings, the upper ones are variegated as 1 w"'' is done by y' life,
y' Aurelia was left thus with a rictus where the fly comes out, & confirms me yet more in my
opinion y' v^ head of y'' Caterpillar is y' tail of y*^ Butterfly,

53. Scarabeus Maialis gloriosa Splendens Grenoviensis. Taken flying in Greenwich Streets, y"= end
of May; It Shines green all over y'' upper Side. & copper under y' Tail; It is of y'' May bug kind, y'
head is Small & square, y'' Thorax or Sholdcr plate larg & almost Shaped like an heart from y'
hinder part of w"'' in y" middle a triangular plate goes down between y'' Vaginae, these are marked
w"' 3 Strokes of a whitish or Straw colour each & reach not to y' End of y" tail w"" hangs down, y''
under part of y' Thorax shines between Copper & green, & is thick Set v,"' brown hair y^ under
part of y'' Tail is copper, & round y*" Edges hairy, vj'*' hairs imitate y' white marks in y' common

(HARLES DUBOIS' INSECTNOTES 5S

hrown May bugg. The 2 first Joynts of all y'^ legs are hairy & large with many points or prickles set
on y"', & y'^ last joynts are Small & weak as in y" common one.

54. Scarabeus minor Ovalis splendens, tardipes, vaginis punctatis. Taken y" beginning of July on y"
water Tub. It is an oblong Lady bird, y'' head is Small & Stands down & shines green, y' Thorax
plate Shines more gold like. & y' Vaginae between green & copper, y" back rises round & gibbous
y'' Vaginae appear w"" a Small help of a glass pitted full of small holes y" horns arc pretty long black
tV lointcd in a glass y^' true wings arc large, & of a fine red. except y"^ transparent ends, y'' whole
under part of y*" body is black; it goes slowly.

5.S. Musca media fusca; Taken y" middle of July upon y" flowers of Lcwage. The head is pretty
round y'^ Eyes reddish, & do not quite meet, a Small white Circle going round y' Inward Sides of
y"", y'" whole is of a Cloth colour body & tail, y'' legs are pretty long & black, y" wings somew'
brownish just at their Setting on.

.5(1. Phalaena fusca, alls 4 maculi insignioribus notatis. Taken flying about a Candle in y' Garden y'
beginning of July, It is all sad colour'd except y' under wings w"*" are ash, y" upper wings are
marked as in the figure with a Sadder colour y' Eyes are near black & prominent, when it Stands y"
wings lye horizontal, & y' under ones are quite cover'd by y' upper

57. Musca Major caerulescens. Dni Hook. Micrograph. Schem. 26. where there is a full description
Microscopical [****! |cut off)

58. Musca parva nigra Splendens. cauda tumida aculcata Taken about y" 7"' of July, y" head is
taken up by the Eyes w"" arc reddish Sad & meet, y' 2 little hanging horns are black, y"' whole is
black Steely shining, y*" tail swells out on each Side & ends in a Sharp point, y" wings are shining
with Iris colours.

59. Musca parva nigra Splendens sine aculeo, capite rotundiore, taken Same time, on y' flowers of
Levisticum.

This differs from y" last in being longer, y" head rounder & Set further from y" Sholders, y° Eys
Stand on each Side, & arc redder & Shining, the body or Thorax shines not so much, y'' tail is Set
more slenderly as in y" wasp kind, & Shines of a remiss copper colour, & hath no point at y'^ End,
y' legs are long, slender & browner.

60. Culex cornubus plumosis D. Hook Micrograph. Schem . . . where is a figure & Description

61. Papilio fusca, alls externis macula nigra quasi oculata insignitis. Taken y'^ beginning of July on
y'= Grass in y" field. Two Short brush come forth between y"^ Eyes, w"'' are redish Sad, the whole
head body horns & upper wings Sad, & Somewhat Shining, y' Under wings are orange in the
middle most parts Shaded & Clouded wth Sad, at y"' Corners Stands a full black Spot w"' 2 Small
white Specks in it, y" under part of y" inner wing 1 is y*" most vivid Side, as is the under part ot the
upper wings, finely parted in wavy w"" a lighter colour near y" Ends.

62. Scarabeus ex minimis, ex fusco aurantius, found y' beginning of July, a Small oblong dark
orange colour'd Slow paced Small Beetle, among Indian Seed Dustoa Vitlu

63. Scarabeus melanocyaneus Mouffeti p. 160

Taken in y' End of June, It is all over very black, the figure is sufficient for y'' rest, only tis made
not round enough.

64. Blatta Mouffeti p. I.^N ubi|?| icon habitur tarn maris quam faeminae.

Taken about our house in London, where are multitudes of various Sizes, so y' it appears they
grow after exclusion, vide Swammcrdam

65. Scarabeus minor rotundus ruber, vaginis 2 maculis insignitis. taken 8 July, a Small Lady bird, y""
Thorax plate is bla. w"' a white Spot on each Side, & an oblong one next y' neck & two very Small
ones next y' mouth as in 1. y" under side is all black, y" true wings brown.

56

L. JESSOP

66. Scarabeus elasticus major, this is imperfectly mentioned in N" 4 ot these papers taken in June,
y"^ whole is a dirty Sad colour, y" head Small, y" Eys Scarce discernable y" Thorax plate larger than
y" figure & pitted in next y"' body, y" Vaginae a little Striate, y" under part of y'' Tail, smooth &
strongly armed divided by ."^ or 6 Shells of armour y' legs of a middling length when toucht it falls
down as if dead. & when laid on y'' back will Spring up by a Spring Seated in the neck, w"*" Snaps
when put in action.

67. Scarabeus elasticus minor. This hath y" Same Springing property with y' last, y^ head very
Small, w"' 2 Small black Eys. y'' Thorax plate blackish, y" Vaginae chesnut. & reach all round
lower than y" edges of y'' body, y^' under pan of y" tail of y'' Same colour, y" Thorax plate is
continued part of y' way on y'^ Tail

68. Phalaena media Straminea. Taken at night by a Candle among nettles July 8. The whole is of a
Straw colour, y"' Eyes black, y'' upper wings have faint reddish undulated lines on v"'. y^ under
wings are as long & near as large as y"' upper, the legs are pretty large Stronger & brown, as I stuck
it down it laid many very Small round white Eggs, y' stuck not the tail is darker colour'd especially
towards y^' End. it sits w"' its wings hanging down in 2 or .^ houres the Eggs turned black.

69. Phalaena alis ex fusco virescentibus maeulis nigris insignitis. Taken by night in y'' Same
manner, the head is ash ending in a longish proboscis, y" Eyes Sadder y'^ horns pretty long, ash
colour'd & Standing at right angles w"" y"" head, y' upper wings are greenish towards y" upper
edges. & Ends w"' lines running toward y" End not colour'd but a wrinkle & end in a black Spot y'
ends fringed brown, y" middle parts of a Shining purplish Sad. on y^ upper part of w"'^ are 2 black
Spots, y'^ legs are branched, y" under wings ash Shining, y'' tail Sadder, as it was Stuck with a pin it
laid many oblong white Eggs, w''' was done by thrusting out a long Tube a good way from y" End
of its Tail, w'-''' it wriggled about & one might See y" Egg come through it. w"'' Stuck to y"' place
where it was laid, this Tube it pull'd in & put out many times before an Egg came.

70. Scarabeus medius fulvus. vaginarum extremitatibus nigris. Taken 8 July in coitu On y' flowers
of Levisticum. It agrees exactly with y" description of N" 23. e.xeept. y' in this y" toes are only
black. & the ends of y" Vaginae & it hath no black on y*^ forehead.

71. Musca alis subfulvis. Taken 9"' July by the River The Eyes almost meet, are of a Sad chesnut &
large, the nose is Steely shining, the Thorax is sad. the tail a little lighter & Shining remissly on
both Sides. & ending in a yellowish point underneath the wings are brown, especially near y^'
Setting on. y' legs Sad.

72. Musca media Cauda ex luteo & nigro variegata alis Iridis modo splendentibus. take w"' 71. The
head pretty large as are y'^ sad chesnut Eys y*^ parting between w"'' is Steel Shining, y"^^ back shines
blacker, y" upper part of y" tail is yellow crost with bla. y" underpt yellow . y' legs browner yellow .
the wings w" objected to y^ light Shine vivid w"" red & green

73. Musca fusca media, pedibus longis, alis macula insignitis. Taken with y" last, y^ head is not big.
y' Eyes reddish Chesnut w"' a large ash colour'd division between The Chest is gibbous Sad strip'd
wth Sadder, the tail lighter above & Shining ending in a point. & underneath almost wholly bla. y''
wings are pretty large brown & Shining with a black Spot in each as in v' figure this is verv different
from N" 38

74. Scarabeus ex minimus chalybis colore & splendore alter, alis caeruleo linctis Taken with y*"
last. The whole Shines blew as Steel, y'^^ under part black, y'' horns have no knoks but are somcw'
thicker at y"' End. y^ true wings look blewish. w"' Iris colours & have a Small black speck on y"
middle of y' outward Edge.

7.S. Idem longior ex utroque splendens cornubus longioribus. Taken with y" last both sides & every
part Shining the blew is Somew' greenish, it is longer, & the horns longer also.

76. Papilio fusca alis Subtus 16 maeulis oculatis notatis. Taken by the River w"' y' last. The upper
Side of y*= wings is all Sad, w"' long hair especially near y" head, the under Side of the wing is

I HARLBS DUBOIS INSHCI NOTES 57

marked as in y'' figure, 3 in each upper wing & 5 in each under wing, in these Spots y^' first ring in
orange, w"'in y'^ black, & in y"^^ Center a white spot, y'^^ body head & horns are Sad, & y^' legs a little
browner.

77. Papilio fusca alis internis oculatis 61 . quodammodo accedens. Taken by y' River with y'^ last,
This is darker all over than 61 . The Orange appears not so much on y' back of y" upper wings, but
more underneath, where it is almost all Orange The under part of y'-' under wings is y" greater 1/2
Sadder, & to y'' Ends lighter with .^ black Spots in each towards y"" bottom. The Eyes are black.
Edged w"' white backwards, & before just by y" Nose brown. 1 have one just like y^ Sort only w"" 2
Spots on each under wing

78. Musca bipennis ditricha; an an 3'' Mouffeti p. 63. Taken 22"' July floating on y" water, from
whence I suppose it was newly emerged, being produced as I guess in the water, y" whole is
greenish Orange, except y" end of y^' tail which is deeper, the Eyes are Small & black standing on
each Side of y' head before w"'' are 2 very small fine horns, the Thorax is pretty thick, paler on y'
Sides, as is also between y"' Thorax & y" tail the End of w"*' grows thicker, & at y'' Extremity come
out 2 long Small hairs a inch in length marked w"" Sad Specks upon white. Scarce visible without a
glass, (perdicei colons Mouffet) the under part of y"' body is brown; the legs are but 4 & green in y""
forepart of y' Chest under y'' head come 2 Small Stumps as if they were legs broken off. The wings
are very large, y" upper Edge greenish, y'' rest transparent.

79. Eruca elegans flavis striis.

Taken y"" End of Aug. in a Clover field a very Sad brown broad Stripe runs down y' length of y"
back on each Side of w^'' runs a narrow yellow Stripe edged with white, y*" on each Side another
broad lighter brown Stripe edged with black, under that on each Side a yellow Stripe like the
former, y^ upper part edged with white & y'' under edged with grey, y'' head & legs are of a reddish
flesh colour, y^ Legs are 6 Sharp ones at y" head, 8 flat ones in y" midst & y'" 2 holders at y" Tail,
after it had fed some time upon Lettuce it hid it self under one of the Leaves w''' it fasten'd to y^
box, & changed to a very dark brown Aurelia. w^'' in Some day turned black

Miscellany Thoughts about Vegetables.

The consideration ofthe Infinite Power, wisdome and goodness exhibited in the Immense Variety
of beings wherewith the Great Creator has furnished this world naturally leads us to y' admiration
of those adorable Perfections so eminently display'd in his works. Amongst others the Vegetable
Kingdome affords instances in as vast a Variety as the Plants are which He has made, whether we
consider their Numbers, differences. Figures diversity of ways of vegetation & producing their
kinds. Structures, Vertues & Uses, In all which Since a regular distribution of what might be said
will be operose & difficult to reduce to a good method. Such thoughts and Observations as occur
are here set down for y*^ present till they can be brought into a more just Order.

1. The universal [♦***] tends to preserve (****] & perhaps of all other Animals.

2. The flowers being of different colours does at a great distance direct Bees. & divers other flying
Insects, whither to repair for Food.

3. Perhaps Plants may serve amongst other Uses, to strain & correct some noxious Juyces before
they come abroad into y^' Air, by their passing through their Vessells.

4. I do not remember any Tree to have down on it's Seed, Such as pappescent Plants have , they not
needing such ways of Conveyance for their Seeds to be sown at a distance from them, their Tallness_
putting their Seeds so high into y"^ Air that y*^ wind can carry them remote enough

5. The same of water Plants, whose Seeds are Sufficiently dispersed by bare falling down into y"
water y'' flowing of which carryes them into distant places.

6. [**•"■] generally very smooth y' the water may slide easily off them without any way bruising
their Vessells

58 L. JESSOP

7. The flowers of water Plants stand above y^' Surface, & the Seed y' follows which would not
otherwise be dry to ripen.

8. Birds do often supply the place of a Sower in Berrys especially that have stonv seeds, which pass
through their Bodies, without losing their aptitude to grow again, & being dung'd into the Bargain.
y. The surface of the Leaves of Herbs good for Food are Smooth & free from down, which would
be unpleasant in the mouth, & not easy to digest, as Cabbage, Lettuce, Beets, purslane Parsley,
Endive &c

.

CHARLES DUBOIS INSECT NOTES

59

A^:^^..

" ' c ■*-■ "

60

L. JFSSOP

,vSv^

^\.--

.^^

6-

/i

CHARLES DUBOIS" INSECT NOTES 61

*:

.......x"- M .. O- 07^ I- ,1 / . - 1.-'

J\

62

L. JESSOP

i

CHARLES DUBOIS INSECT NOTES

63

n

" r/.. /,.?„.,, ^(,„„^ ^'^r,\, . '

/.

*?•» -«»-■ 5>r^^,-,,^ »»j4iA'

64

I,. JESSOP

^

T

i

V

..^/ i/Jy

reMf^^jl <■ «.>^

■t 'X4/r ^ s kf'^-^'Ctf A4r<

• r* I. • »-t

CHARLES DUBOIS INSECTNOTES

65

v

v-^ >=v

t ■ *■ 1 'JI//0 - / 1 „^ /•

l-Ct^M-./rf nil ran f I,-

/ ' , „\y J" •'.•»v w

,'„ -. ... ,*•. /I. 7/^

ti~/My><t f.tt^j. M ^^.

lvtr,.^J fiy}r<t y

/ .<■■

n4ior

^ tJ^.^4. /?V

66

L. JESSOP

> • •' ' t.

\j

i

CHARLES DUBOIS" INSECT NOTES 67

:>

\

\

v

,^-:^ >^.v..,.., 0./,..,^ ^^„,,,^^ •;/ jt:- -^-'■- ^-'^-^. •■'

'•" '■ ■■ •■'" v' ^ ■:..x /• ''/-—,, .■;.^.^,^, .>,w.:,

68

L. JF.SSOP

f

O y'.ipilio n'lA laeiiiia^tiJ

Zl .y J''rrt>.* Colour .jcf.'i»^,v f tf>a oj ^y kno(ri ix''^ are i>t(lti ,

»inffj c^n_ if titi}Ay fi^Tja^ 'i

(HARl.ES DUBOIS' INSECT NOTES

69

>

I , ,.f

f «t .K. t 'J

70

L. JESSOP

c?

'♦«->

i.«,jfA» v-Afi/J' •■ /i/.". c/j:^tl<t.Oriinn. .'•■■' . y^

H I'-' /

»i».^n /i«u'ty , V" A.-i-,w ika.el^ fi'bl- u-i^A ti-twU. a/

*C*%MJ ,

^»<»i«»ii, y 3 •./•n>,>>- i./in»S- tiiAT/tJ L.ra.'iji, 1,1 ^rn.e y>.'» -'.T") ■»»»

'»^ t</>/v.S-. wtVV.' o^j'V* ii«i.*T lifii'fJ ■'11 »/<« ? loil-A -tfrtiJt ' t'r. .
It :! Ota." 4"^ v'jx.M.*-!? ci'i/A ri.«r^, y n>. ^^V Jt'jLc i^ -fiU.X-v ti'"

*^

r-4

i^^

CHARLES DUBOIS' INSECT NOTES 71

'Ha

9

" /■' I II - Hi',,, I •

J.

^-'

. fj*,'!

72

L. JESSOP

I. ,

Hi."

I

jJtU'o -ItcJctL- , alio ^j(iS-rn.<.i>

Vii'ikA*;^-'

rt-rfi-*

fl'dOijfl JetX;*.'!^ n>A^^ ktnJ, fitrrnj

nc^cnxJ- H^ rrCnfiii of nu.m , tiMfn-r^/ y*^ Gyrn<>rj of 6a c A
. ^Ira.^^ -- y^./^ QCc^clZ S^otr, uAHl 2 X«// H^A^V^ ^,^.^

%

L

CHARLES DUBOIS INSECT NOTES

73

9^

■hue,: a.1,: ^Uitltii

JO »'.nf«Aj ociidilii ne>tn.ttj

t

r

74

L. JESSOP

12

~ >-/ ce. ,K, ,.., t.,, i„A... $Z. Tj ^•"'" '■ ' '•'■•

J

75

CHARLES DUBOIS' INSECT NOTES

'\

t 9c I

J^»

76

L. JESSOP

.^..j /yg.^ ^jr. 5^n.X!.<S <^^ ^ W^. *., ./^ tl>/2>-..r

'''i^'.W'

CHARLES DUBOIS' INSECT NOTES 77

'\

«^.

-jtijto f> I <^ /•' -'

V« /'.r^y «■• /*.? f.-i/?(. ^ji, ...•I'AC A i^lr^,, cC

f

! rtxAttyfii fa-r.-^''^ .!...<. . fl » r\

^t.

78

L. JESSOP

•,- o>

■.l,'.f' "^ ■""" '"■•"■• ■'^■^ --"V.y;...^ „;,,

^-'.;^ ;:./^.„ ^.^,, ^z:^..:., S *^-^.A f/!y ^../ .oc^fi'JZ

'J, y >f-^ ../^^ yV..>'.,: I.., ,/ ■ ' ^ •" --"•' '^-.Z' ^.„^A J'„.^

''■#»* flil|/|-

.^>- '.•;^ ^,, j-;;^ rt ,,.,/^

^, ^Ao .».„, „ „,; 7,,^^ ^ j^ ^^^

•^'/...v .•„,:., Ay ^,7, ^

CHARLES DUBOIS INSECTNOTES

79

, J c l\ <' C C.

' /« , *■<> A. nnK^r. vat A. Tim* y , »-^^t ftii«.'

'V

uHalj/nA It '(fa^ iJitifii,

^j,

tern), S' i/&>rvJjr. •./& ^^^•' '^^' *''''7}/ ^'*'-9 I ^ ^^nr/i.' c^ \ 2_^
« '<-i,nJ t.f^'^i-,^'"^'^^ tr y' f'-'-.f v-e-ri/ (*»i^. Cnr/T 0/-;^ ft« rivy/

Or> <*«*- 1 5

"J-

r<^?*«.-HV«'

K'Af-'f*''-'- 2-

80

L. JESSOP

u iPu...

•-^t £.^

"».," r«>X>- ^ ^ i^„ ^ ^ ^

^^i-//^.>.wL. .S,^,,^

'ff^ iTic/y "2^

I »'''£vi <./C^i. ,«-^.-?i,. ^ o> ^ / -^'^

''l<' Jln.< -/li^'^i

y ayi.

CHARLES DUBOIS' INSECT NOTES

81

£n'ij ifu ifa.ft 'f-^ tuintj jAt'n>J tnrtt:.- n

N ^

ifivr

^X f^pJ'^J' t^/'ff-^- on^'J-, tJ^i'i v-i o-C^tivT) ^, //;««^>/.--/7^»t,<

't ^"a^rfni a.l{ro~J\i4eA. ail

UCA. aUj v~a/r\y4 attJ

iydt

AuYttW (?^yin^ t,p,r^^ ^n'^f , i'>'<^J t,ut-

", li

^7

82

L. JESSOP

/.o

■^ ma cu lt4

f/;".- un>^^ tifittfj w^ich. <tre. a^>f f/u,
k ''pt''^ "'"'9'' "ri friA-r^O-r/ ivj |^ f^
/',.iT.. i..,7/^«. J'nclJ^ ^<rfo^-r^Hi^. ^^^^ ^^^ ^^^^. ^^„,/3,.

I lit

^ -.^.-...y /..„.. .^,_^^ '

CHARLKS DUBOIS' INSECT NOTES

83

, "17

nJ (nrfe- f^ tf"^ upp^<y^ ^ nCiraaj ate IJ'>''H^ Ltirae^ , kftrcn-a, i>'
(yien'ri. ; "-'"'■■i it n'aj tfttccK. dtrittn. trt, a. tiox Ufi)/i '^ /"" , «/ Irtii
Kir. 7i_./ sf-ini JtfUiU. , |-io-n>if\ »if/it/t. Cdo^, tu^' VhifK Hoi- /e,V* "^> , '•'"'

d

)8

fijh. cfttnAt'a V Oh<ni.fta ,■ *^/« vniL k'^c n^A- ^ tnt t^of #»r' lono, ti,i jCrcP^
y J^n.-u'lml-. OrAn K^.-^ . '^Inilt if nmJ jhic£ down n; / h ,« /../„ ij /ki)
•nn^.y, J„,,/(,' Wr/i^ «'/;A. ^y./, ...'•*■,, -rt^ /^.'r/r^m,? ^ «/., f/,l„j/,„^ „„y_

/,■./,

i/ .'/..^A /»

ir^

iiz-Aif r*'N

84

L. JESSOP

'.9

yaJitn „j C

In A I,

^"•^ "/""'. v"^--/;

1" r*' ?'r^ '^-^ -'^ - /"" -^

•" /.<■><■ y^x.-t h,/rA f in O ^ n f ■? /^ , ^ i'// '

HA^>f

^O.

^ -'^o-bi tin. ij fc,/9.v . /AT. -^ /"'■'. '*'<>>.•-, »!.>„//'

CHARLES DUBOIS" INSECTNOTES

85

',f'ix *-'^ *,"jtatL. nUhi .

^^"^y , ^Witf ^> S' U-.j^j^ fe,,^^ i),H>r, tn4 t- o^f 'fs ^*yf^ , -".j '.■'''*

0.2

\'h(tlcf no. aU All A.iJ*n lU* hi'f^jyuj ri-/r**/i,', ii.7ji"or*^

\WjUt,,y- 6*jll.nnims »f-A-'un^. Jh. fyjrf a.o-t Cfmr/.,

f"j .iiG.'wR.^t Z^?" ' -^'^ •'►'^ "f/"'^ '^'■^''■' ^^'-

'«^V , f^y* -'T^ f^^* '</>/».V •'i.V.V if- /^' 'i,,7>r Ti.',',,f4 .,>, „^^ tCufii^l

li^il !rr-ti>i„itJ .^(-t.,^ ^'-

"/'/'■■

•/«*-/«: '*' 4# I'A*" ^»:*r/>r.%

/■'

arc <-/- Vi

5(1

86

L. JESSOP

o,

-24

' ^ ""■*»«»- ^•"•-n itr-it's tmxnt'^rtlj i4^uCntiJ
»ori,J «x.y;;,><; m^nd'i ..N/jf .^kO V^.Vtj ^^ <i'^./< .rr-^rt/j.S . .-;4^

t<to

rn4

CHARLES DUBOIS' INSECT NOTES 87

■ ' -•' V '-' '"In r.tuf O^ Uttm ^' -l-f'-ti jM

^:iC' f^j, ,-/f ^->.v.//;V/, tS<^ .7 /CO Q«H^ \t- ^J-f-f v,\ ^ S.x

^ ./• fr^ . (Jrw. »i^V o^C Xrr.,,vl„f ^ *».- (^V j/«r^ ^y I^Wja^

:, < %rtym,-<.0 •^rrt ^*y^ «-*»- '^f* ti>^/A^ tOi. QoW •^^i-rc trr
I fi j^.K .-1 M^^ riv/ C*J€ fftly ai't t/'A^rrZ .

nvt-U^ri^f «'»♦ ^t«^ Crffr/^^-r^ * t^^)i4K t-»v«*»-Ti ^f*»*v- •V'lTtt O^-^/.V *«^^ /iG

/*

88 L. JESSOP

ay

• tl>^ » ,ij .a» •• fyf. y/J - f

m^'

2S

'Hum ■&irti>t tfft' IO^"~ i u>«» •'.•(/ /I'/uVo -U-tnt. on tarA*J<'rtc^ //.. ,

CHARLES DUBOIS' INSECT NOTES 89

^f^C^tk^fniJff- <,J^tM^e£-,^^4.sjf^»j cure KtWc^^itS.

3o

Pn-i^ev^y

•j^-^ jy^«/^'-.; ^./ /.^ ^^^^._^^ ^^^ .^y^/;,.,.^ ..

90

a**

i

>

• ' tAr ah i n'l m Ci eitu J.

L. JESSOP

/V-

CHARLES DUBOIS' INSECT NOTES

91

/.

Kak.'n iy^\'. lit-.Ht C>r ft'/ "/ y f>ir-i>ri^

y' /f.-.^rfj- !•/?.•/ ty^pt-cSntCy , lii^ rt->-« I't^/.T^* ■>-«»- />.'!<■/»

92

L. JliSSOP

3

T

^<2-'-' ^-^- -«A-r,.H,.-r.^.;r>f C«- c^.yf, <^/Vy „ /.O . /^'« .

/5r

CHARLES DUBOIS" INSECT NOTES 93

b- i6o. '

f

%) tJcaTao ,' nj S-y »,,

/n.y..:^ .o'^ u ^ S[;>^U-n */Cl^//.*^.5-

94 L. JESSOP

Va^tnrf Ch^n^ii- ec/'^n.t^, w''^ trtncA ri If re^nn) , C»t.oir f/tmiu
n^.V *i- i/JW^y ^J .27/, ^/ u»D^ 0«^f y!^*- .^/ rj «,/*,,•

8 Jc^ra.6*U^ :£<.i(x^cj t>^c-no„.t

CHARLES DUBOIS' INSECT NOTES

95

<. 5

uJt;-.

%

I.. JESSOP

fc.

'7

J

CHARLES DUBOIS' INSECT NOTES

97

7 2

' 7~r '

98 L. JESSOP

f3.

» <rav«^<?i<V mc'n^. O^^c-n^uj , x-t,^ ,^,

CHARLES DUBOIS' INSECT NOTES

99

S

<-<'^..,..c^ ^/-. V_,„a *^^r;^^y .^„l.v ^« A ^ /J'/^^i ^;„^.^_ //;^ ,^

4 '

^^..

>''./.;, J ^, /.,,,.

/i^

A^ /■

^''r/:.,,^ j^u i^j^rjr^' \Tr-' '^f^y'^'J ^r^.f

100 1-. jussop

f6~

\.'Ai-tTx.' -j-xi-'%rxij , \'-n<)i'tia.ri*ni Jr_y frerni Jn Ul'nJ

t-'*.A<-n ^ S op- Ju.^1) <A Co the <m y' >^loxo}-yj of- -^ ci'i.i 1 1 c n /,,

'7
i/i.r.S.' ai-^ '))l<r.j/2 fi^<^ .(...^Ci i./y F.Dl', I' ^JfJ/^oCp

'9

CHARLES DUBOIS INSECT NOTES

""<- ",.''*'» ''<-"<' '"'"« «>f^<V» /ii.r^D ,»>■ Al VniC b<,.ri'.

102 L. JESSOP

2o. .

^ceLra-bciw C iLainltj min.^r'

.'/■^/^ «« ^ ;;:/.v^ ^^y £^S,cf-C^ ^ ^.^^ y.l j/ZA^

(■4yn .

/

F
*-^''

CHARLES DUBOIS INSECT NOTES

103

^1.6

car<t

i>etu<

^••»?<na.,„j D.Peti

ver.

hu JZf .^A-, . ...... ,. -U.^ ^^, ^^^ ^^

104

L. JESSOP

■24 ^^^■■"-.lOcu.f tni„c-r viri,!i'f JlMnJi-rU
* <1 v'/lirnty fx«/«- 5»' l-**!*!/*. yfA*.ninf <ff**n^ hi t^

.^^.*„ ^ y^r^^O c^r.ao C^>r..O y-/c^,„ ,,.y ^,„^^

'r *'""" t''^'^-^' '""^ ^ i'-'^ ^^ ^i; ^.^s l^Xz:L

»•

CHARLES DUBOIS' INSECT NOTES 105

J.^_!iyi^-_.-_ :_[^jfiir!;:i'>'.',:i '.1.

106

L. JESSOP

^J "^^ralrtuj timnUi co^'ffri^ ,Ju(>U

J

%

y

Ja-ki-n. al^^ioAf on a. ^e-*tf ^.'rry tuxj/l ; J fit.

iO ^farAieiU ni^.<

tijini^ jfrt^itri

>.*

CHARLES DUBOIS INSECT NOTES

107

-> niacuU'j

fri2L4_l\

J A ^'cxr^enj arSx

''vrCicJ rn^'rin-Qi/tift.-

p9(

♦ <4u»it/t# "» <tnty/fiJ>- n^t-.

108

L. JHSSOP

33 OfarA^tnV minor rctuni

rtcStr

'^«.K>n. ffPf/l^j , St i'i

i> a. iltr^al

Jfu. kfj^i^ ■Jho-ra.je laLaJk-z. U mrUtrt^ ^tt- utt'ttZ tar^' > vCa.fA ^potj

3A-Sc^a/;^^ m^^_^^,^^ Cnj,^,^;^,^

3:

fl^ninff fl-n. A.*r t'l\f^

'^S- Sc^^r^euy „u„^ rcmz/Je y..„Q,«^, J-^,„l^

;«f«. .

§^

Jlr-.^U,. 9^„f.^„t, AG., .„^^ ^^ f^ ^^^^ f^y ^^

>-l

CHARLBS DUBOIS INSECT NOTES

109

3^

110 L. JESSOP

»'.< mn tk oj Jr ^ naat. ^^ Jiit^ id f/H -tto /7 . y^ i</y>»S- nit'' rfX'iff' ,
'if J<rTnci>rAAl- jAi'm'nf ,^ i,0/ef^y ^nfiutt n.x. /t/»^ |t>« /A \J.rn^U*h

jint-t<.n)yr \f''*f}Hln^ n. tf fA!ctvin«4 . ^-'Ac nut U-in*j /i / v If?.'

'>u£fn.t^tuy (^rt^ir^ tii y Jh*»i-M, tO-rOtnti- a^~.A^"- /TjQQ^i of f^Uy

^ (ni^y- 'Mm^ fCifc <> A^rvJ tr Hanf,/ rt'^i-^y* t^iUl*r, fr evfry <i-«^ cfi*.
'JJL. Va-j^nO. o^fx hvmjj up at- J, brtmz , S^ Kti^a ^vtr y~ i^t'H ^ U /taut.

I'T

.

CHARLES (DUBOIS' INSECTNOTES 111

Ocn.rnt'ei acitinHei.

•jy^^'i. -^in^ iv^H-iJ ftfktn. rn£t^ t/rt^ni . '■'nt. iiA?^'y /->«>■/ <j

^i,,tf^ud ^-fUt- ^nt ^ */JUm l«^//r, H-X'tcf^. ^cy c<ir.

I-^

112

L. JFSSOP

'J^JciLdo - bcarabei

1

^JjC.iUa. Mouffeli. h. \^S

\

rccfnida.

M

as.

?6

CHARLES DUBOIS INSECT NOTES

113

vjiry/fofalpa.

i7

114

L. JESSOP

{^ ILiLSctiC niLo^lrijy

LLScd^ <1U.(L^LrlpCn.*irJ

CHARLES DUBOIS' INSECT NOTES 115

''r
iM ■ uU. ' OJ I

>/ o,^,.M.*..-,y A, pi^f/cc^r^ ^/cr£a-,"/€'/ ^ ^c^^,/ «-»-«. yj//.^„

^-. r,_ ^ J^ r^o\^r, , J.y),^ ^.,,, P,, . ^,,^^ .,. /^^^ J^.^ £^^ , ^

A'''-,Vfy

116

L. JESSOP

CHARLES DUBOIS' INSECT NOTES

117

n

irvscioiJ

lyvict.

1/ i'fnn'A.

1 .''7'

<^i'j

«^-.

>V*c

''^' --C-rnJ-r

•/^^ 'J'?*^

<7

' '^'■'^•^ _4 ■-:.

118

L. JESSOP

..'Syr ■..r,h\^-fir^J>^^J,^^;^^.lip.y-C^^^^,^ ^r/,;./, g.- ./'

-»•..•. f

'i.; ys^j,**.-^

.-,7.4./ «i/»c. t <^».-i^ t</«a-'f" *

'2. ^'Jll«Jro. f^P'Jn-TTUd '-•t<<<>u •ji-Cfa

.c- A.:i

iir^j tn- ry • '»< ^ *•*( 7 ' ** *5'' ^''7*^ uyih uyA,t<

rv« « l4»-n*»«. yO^'^-c* r«^y t# t*»-ri4 ^-*— », .^

\

>i->Jn~+

< A< '•It'

V --.,1,, „•.? tVf/y

/:>.

SOul, •?

.'ff/..,

5S-

L jirsaiii__..

lU^

1

CHARLES DUBOIS' INSECT NOTES 1 19

:';f'-_jP''f^^lenarik.,n^„ ,.

•1^ TT,

V. ./".

% A.

- - . M .

■ f

/j L'ttLC.

'Th

tV ea /ri r ;

'• i^ / - /- '-' ?^ ' ~ '^'^ "'"•'* <- ' AC' f/??

120

L. JESSOP

<) C-Vtili»fl ixpi+e-f-trtiO -j-ii-^e o :-j til v-tL "'^r^''

,-/?^", ,<:?«. Oat A'.f.t,', .'-•/ (-''M-'j/Tn. 'ii-.'^r.,/ f'njtit,^'^ ty.\ .1,
\f'-*a.et.ii f^t'e/Z nfM- tu^ i^ti't ^rr^ti Ain't tr ^ ^ tffi^ 'r ■>■.■,

<' '-rnry /?„lry ^„ .. /t , /,'//. V , y* •^''^"^ (''^ ^^ ifo ^ i7i A , A ,.' .,.

fun yV^y rt^y-^"/^ •/ Ktno.^J '>f> V ^.w-'// aJ if it ^ \

Vfi ti xj c<r«.& fi'

.-XI "i-ff

••*y .

V /»

J « ^ ^ 14 / ^

n

V -y rnJ 1-1 in y ■^ ''

c ^■-<' r- r '/I /"a of- /•

»i

I

< HARLES DUBOIS' INSECT NOTES

121

/»

/''-^<'W^ ;,./, yA^.„,v-:< cz;, 'Xfi^ ^-'''- >s€?.^ r

122 L. JESSOP

tl

.\

.n !j) Jna^ ui>i>^i jf- tJrCm'.^r »(! \f^nny K.H *rn els ti,,, ■ i'trt
:..' m^y^ ,urt J^.yrvtn.*. StCvyr^)fi xv'^ ^ ^,„*& i^^ /?€rrr,j

,, -^^-o-rtJ S-CatK CcnA^.J/ /"iS/vAn^i .••/ ntt.}h ^IfttifJ /»r* !•■•/> i i.'jh.

uf>^ »v^ ^ry JT^-rj,'i,^\„K^ j^ie ^l y j^nc„^:X\^^^ ,nh

J^ 7.V.4/ ^ n-^iU, CytCiJ ,j^ -i^lfy y^fCtfu), rtA y f«0 i-CtLfj^ ^ ^ryia A-
'Ct^'tt ■^y^'- W^^trun'jX. ^ fu'nt'j-r- fnej j/H^, to^tiC it. i^oxi^r, Joeh

\

I4- L'liu>cn.ai}ifirrr„,'j v^leye {litre e^tiifrt, imn'tcj ,

• '»/./i Z-* ti'cifit. in jv" •C^'vM. nt^r i1*h i/ljCj . .i'f f'.. <, I'.Hy t>,r„^'/,..,

y 2 A-mV SCiLti., I^ie£ V i'^{f*'iKt(^ Cc^ _y i^Djc ,i <.'<ir« /t^-aJrn^.C

I

CHARLES DUBOIS" INSECT NOTES

123

J 6 ./'/(.,'f«. rjj^i'irt- tD^a viniu JpC^n'^Sii J.

(7 ''''■■.'CA^cjfrt. eNZjUtyn'i).

■ ^ :<^x%.„ ,«"ry ^^;.^ j^ ^-^^ _^^ .T^aPt «-...^, ^o.;^

//.;

124 L. JESSOP

' Auni, tf^ U^ 4. ^ P^^^e. <,;

J

.'n->

>

•

/

i

J.*-

J

1

1

4

1

11

LA

-i

CHARLES DUBOIS' INSECT NOTES 125

YeJpa-, tnlnor ^dm>^tu) mtu£*la^ a^rvu,£iU

t »v ca.<^ tv ,

■^ffoAf^ , >--j rt^c«/«r.; t«^t^/ri, ^fC^Z. l*t. -JrtfnJt^ tt^ttx/ti

TTO^m f /

126

I.. JESSOP

\

(^'^I'tl^

'A

CHARLES DUBOIS' INSECT NOTES

127

/ eJiOi\ I. v ) /

^^; 'y;^:"^•/^ -^r/^^' ^'rr^</^^^ -^--

// y^.i,'^ r,r^,,^ o^HCrr,. ^ ^

128

L. JESSOP

n

■/"

\

sz

CHARLES DUBOIS" INSECT NOTES

129

fh^ Vi

Lnrx^ ifntJ Ayrt. o-im.-/. Sfi^p ^ ^- o-«..l3^

r o-n->*-</.

'■\

1 V r

o^cLoi-sa n.i(fni, ccticia-

■ 'I KJti

e2 ic oAAri

.i

130

L. JESSOP

uJf9

«. ?.

^a. I^tcrt. 9 uc-r^o r^ljris ,nx<r,r^ '\.hqiiA'

orax ttft €:\nei_

ii alUi. U'^J^j.„ ^ ^^c j;

^^^- ii. « r^, /4 // .7-^-'- -11/-^ ^^"A€'. ./;;,.,,.

6"/-

CHARLES DUBOIS' INSECT NOTES

131

KJi^JliA. o^itL^ri^A. tnAyii'rt\/Ly t>%-cf'nrt^'
^ Aoi-Je n'lar^} cnnan. A- .S^ ttrr^o ,

»«J -iretnuUVj lii >itiLj(0 Alto n^ta-tlj

cr> o

\

^

132

L. JESSOP

lf*'VJ Cauca

corhX^rt

T'-^i

imtiuj

\

,'>

CHARLES DUBOIS INSECT NOTES

133

isvsfsrTST^; .^:

^

iM

134

L. JESSOP

^^fpthlf

m

^ • /. ' 6- ■"'' "" ^^-^-^ •'-'- '^^v /..< ^;^

a c-ii>c,j'uj.^ca.7ii.e^g^

2.

i

CHARLES DUBOIS" INSECT NOTES 135

-y C /^i'.> 9L

rce^a.

•--<.

/

136 L. JESSOP

[jCntlJ Citntc'inum

if

J

CHARLES DUBOIS" INSECT NOTES

v- Wi.'/ in the UC attimrio oj »,'«*»i.(t; Ut tn oi't>.( J Loi'^'^ly ,
' I, U Jl-fyii^j ^tifl tfijL /uia^ V rctij^A Cifie^-^Ki of a.^ai),
t' It InjOfrt i tj b^/iefi , il-eein Fmri'i, rCCc^vfr i tj —feel' ^ Ix'ht'efi.

•A U^i.'-ttsv.^ Jh-cn^ ,9/vytx, III ; S' nrJltri ^edll turn.i clIL
'■"««■, 0< J^iinfij till t-o mti£.r J/Im. • 'X< /•/<»•) ii uAx. £>_
I rtf iVt'^^-^V*" At^o ihtTit/L fl,f^ are ^Ca.cK.,\y hcrn^ Aatte. M rc^.

>• 'j^rny fr i/eiiC a-rec'.t'jj^ ; il- fieJn ncihtcr- fVtiioJ nor- Vtnft:t>C.
V i»t./i/ y JAiTt e- y t/ni'l hn^irt- <^n ihot-h t/i««'y it- IJ me^^tJtc^
t.-« *ft fV/HL v.'. i^« friT^S^^ li rt^nlarfy mAn-Ji'J ui"^ xft> oh
/fi-i 4 Ca^j.^j/- i/ ntTi'^UtriiSff- ate, {o'^b.'r- ctyfeni'tV ^ in &etJ -

137

ir-or/i

138

L. JESSOP

« A A .V , « rf^f/. /

;;^\:.:"^'-'^>;^<^?;i7^;'''^';,7^'^^'> .. ■

.'T. fe*'^. ^"^".'L^ v&c/i,.ri .; ^ /i^^^ . ;i ^ i^, ^^^ ^^^

iVvrrt^ <''' A^O 1,

I"

CHARLES DUBOIS' INSECT NOTES

139

m

o

A / /

I'^zr'p^

C -la ^~- >

'3 c/.T^^,//., ailfK,..L-4 tr,^,,.: vV"^"^<^^a>''''^'*/

.>-'.■' {.» . y -Did ,^\y ^/,',,,, J-,;, ^/

y <.^y.\r V-Sy

*^fl f- (•rr'f.in.^t, .,-..,,2 v' *■*'»■'« ^<t(r

,»•• ^.-..X'i •'.■/ •••"^ .-

t^U/ .^ ','--r^.wy;X,. .,..,.'■/. <..;Ar- ^fa,^ «y ,,r ,v'^,-/r^„-,^,v* >''/.;

C^ *y^ J /e f,

140

L. JESSOP

\

X

^'V^

■ ■?.

^^pr -..^y ^^-.v-i (^A^,y .^^.^ '.-.;..//::: J

'/w/«. 4^A ..;

."•^ •/-

CHARLES DUBOIS' INSECT NOTES

141

»-' « '<-,iriX '• (■ f<.' >>:ttl'^

■ ■ ft • I ' '

■ «!•»»« lit/ %^f/ I il 1 1^ ,

. ■ ')

../Ivi <-,t ,v* i2^^«i^,i /^ t^t.^i.^'- eyt'lf t'y ,'•' y ['"^

r * .1 * •

.'A .-•.., /■■..VA,

142

L. JESSOP

'7

/yr/'^oOy ^,,..v /.;»-.^* U.7...: vvx:.5/ "i/^,;,- -/-"v: ;^-«--

1

A

143

CHARLES DUBOIS INSECTNOTES

/ /^ . - /7 <i J . •^ . ^ 4-4- - ,
"'■t r-<- /V t^m^ ^*&^jJt- &-nX-jhnt»t^J .'^ CuJ^ t>2-aX. fy-a^U f^cvunl

?/^^ W A .u.,;? r;'^^^ ,Ji POr^ ^e^^ ^&r^J- io ^y- C^ ,^t ^yr-

aJ *" /t>-»iu rfnJTV , .'Z ftntL,tt. Af(U!«u> rhit^f Kj>.*^1^ rf^xrr'^^ trT^^xxJ-K-

'.Vv^<y,f in GiJi^fL. hc^J4^,i p^crfly^ci^i' t^fo^ae/n ■i/iL^nfiij

irf?^ t'l c»mp<f!!^ t>£. fZ, rr t/3 'yi-n*J , mv^y '^ ^ fni. (hlC/C, 3^in'u\

c/«<r/-<tT-<- 4 trnuJL oUck J'otrt^ jH-^n A-Jaua't^^ (tT,..-<eieA JitBu \
ifS ^^y *'^^ *'-^ ti-naf/ll Aya- tTt-fi^Ql^y- ■^tt{^o ^t>tr^ mi^ tyn/t
eAcK. -r mj, n»Wi. (^ o-QtuJ- u>^ a^y^. truly 1^6i. c^/r t^ ,f€i\K» al-^^

c>t> ^- &L.r.j»^ A^ ,i^;t ^v^_ „^^ f/ff^ ^>V^^y ««r/^rt fmtjjit)
/. alt-v I "^ niLtyi a^re. ti/rui, «>-uV- ffCt^i •/^er-.

'^'

144 L. JESSOP

Q b7l.u>ra. ^*«^,, ,l/«^«. , ^^Jhrf^j^y , / iy.Sr «t^ ^h yy C^/f^ ^A
Ce^hr^ 6.-^,.Mc^, 1-4- ka-fPz ■o^^y-jrr.^.rf'f fuel ^^v/'.' ^2^,V.'

i^l

CHARLES DUBOIS INSFXT NOTES

145

v^o^ fl-£l..«- JhCij y /n*-«/l

■*^.ru^A^., 9^ ti'<. jH^nfj A (i,i>.' .5^A/

» ^/7

upfi^ r rnJ.t,
1 .»)■ 'til f/yft/Kf kOt-c^nf, yx.ii «

ml j'-^'Q. V'T^' ^-''^ 'u:- >>i. <•

^"^ .«<f/^ ,V or"-"- i *''" "'

1 .'ji-^>-f CjIV.

•V 1^

/w-»-».

^^fj'

7/

64iu?/*ii>7r , »A/"|v^ HfJhiy*^^ -

146

L. JESSOP

f-

■IJaC

I

V

••4U

.^;Wy^ ^'^<-^^^ fAi^^^
''x^^itJ^yity ^ ^ 4^,i jl^c^it <^j^

f*.hi£2nf t^^^mtftf-iUi

' '>G^, ..,.'* ■^,-

'.'/

4/.

CHARLES DUBOIS' INSECT NOTES

147

Tg . 4 r:

'■'-t.

.,,ff^:;js^-

fij/u*.

A«<H u^

On •>J

*''n-»r<fj^/ri,jj*.e^-hj ,

V^ /y>-V 4»te! A,/ j^?^

' ' ' J''

»^^.^

/» n,c^rD, auuA.

6'

^^

r

■(^.'y w '.•'Ack.^ Ja.vy^ \ii ^^ J1->'^Ji- Of-^

.Tar • y

'f-9

'It %/.

».i<wV^/v. *'»"./,/ i-'.j//'- )..;;y/ » ■'' t* >-^^'' U^rirf/,. tt-n'jj^

. ^/- **t f^

•'X'j '"-^y-"--'^ »v«.^■*^>^^. ». ^;„,5 ASA .r-^t^j ,>fu,'

•/"^'f- i^^/-^— ;«".-v/v^,' -'''^.•'V^-^ >«4 .(t^fC^lrt.,.;^ tx^v^^'

■ »«i;-

/^r.-^'

«i4i-

«»Yi*. /» J. xa*/

26

' '^ . /■ ■•;' ■ -'' :^ ■

CHARLES DUBOIS' INSECT NOTES

149

29

A? eye, 5 *afl^ af ^Ql.. tun CSt^M ^'^

■V c/^

*»-»/ *i^/: /-<x-r ^^.'

50 U'niu»»V.,rfri-«f y

1 nv:

■J *r *lji-tit4-n -y

**^nl r/ni^^^f

'^ ^iMr.' A- Cf

''-7 '■'yf'^'f f""^ "■'''■' V '^-^'^tr-^cr^

•r>Arr^ ^ 1^ (^itx-zt tir.y Y?^J- ,;,-,' ,»;,. "»,»■/ i, ^^

150

L. JESSOP

3S-'">.o

*//ff:

irr. -i

^ .-/ . '- fa cfc. . T-' V X'A^. *^ l.,"' >6i^i^' ,„

U>r, ^/j-y' Jj^f. ^

l,t ^r -^^^, - » .. ^•^ >^^.^^ ^-^^K- <v/b2,
. . •ft<"Z0. • / *

(i

I

t4f.

0<:ci^z!>

27'^ '

CHARLES DUBOIS INSECT NOTES

151

'/y'cr^nu'

-<<f^'y t-nxA^^) A^t"-.

•nttJU Contra. tna-ttA-^ ■'i^'?^./^!* , ^>C^V -^ /' ^'

fl At ' * ^^""-'^ ^'"-''^ O^r...... t,Wr.-''

.^'/^<

'iTt-t/ /

152

I . JKSSOP

ffx^)ifXiL^,

^rt'-i '

J.-.'.,.t.. A^ i^.b£^tj-,ufitfi^^ ^1-

4/

J'

.J hjK. l^cA , >-- n»^ ^trn^_. - f J. -

., » ■ , .'> «/»mc Ufclj^ -frrtifh. trm ■(( ^y- u%lc^ f£ht- fny^

r r, 4 '

/jii Va^tnX ay^^p^ft- ChljnlU-i(i " if/cUxt^no , /)U_U'^V6l »i*C*J^ (Ia /

,1/ 0^ ^"^ ^in^tn^al-i jHa-j a-*-^ t*n..f S^ e

&nV

<-«-"f foij

CHARLES DUBOIS INSbCT NOTES

153

^/^•y"^;

yi yJtjA'£irp I ,

t>yi ■' '• '■■/-•/ '"' -

■ .^•h/'-lrj A (i CaJj ) r^tA~«J- ^ rrnruA'i. CM^xt. fn»i:t- ut^f-dl ,

•7

^

cr.'>pi Ui-*l~*.J^*^ ni5(

(>-<M>- •'- /^n-t 0-0(1 V

4^

4'.:

-iJ.J-J-i A.' 1^

'"<>»- ^-•

■fj- a/^e

I

A^

J ttCti

■^i 4

4o^ /"

■ c> t i

''my

V'

/^i

154

L. JESSOP

46 . cu^-

CCtt<>.' h^' ^"^^

,J.ff?^ u .t. ti'ftt^ rrvc^^jA^ , v^ dado, J, i^ tTx^^
, v^ w!c un^tfj JAA^nS rMOT-<_ UH/-fL. tTX^M ftM.u tf-t-tcijy

■;v/- e\* .uo^ -t v/o 1^ J y '^~'- li;w<r^ ^ ' "

. r,>c f^rAi em. nvr-Ooi£^ iMt^ ^»,^ urinifj .., »,,.^

, . *■ ,1. e T^ '^ /- ^\ "^ , // '^ ,

Vd

^

•c

^ri lt\ ^y

• bi».titnr %/hlinnt^ kmAfi^^ "Z I^mv jC~y^'^>T ^rrnj f'A~,'cA^ <c ■^ <* A
vctn art- tjieA. uitft- rrC»^ Ata.t

■.*-f^ a-^K

C^i^yut. «- ' /

Ait^*

»../ f-

'lA', "fit

tk

'ctn art- tjt.eA. i,iVt. ffCt^ Ata.J i/fit. K<>^<^e<L. u/ZX' , SO'*-' «■ x't"-*'*"

^. 7.tV«-fau_ur fv' tty^erv*. />t«-^ •••i; 'i>«Vi// ,-/*v»>t ^4.'nf Utiiti.

.,«<«^ i/lut- ^ ' -^ '■'■

CHARLES DUBOIS INSECT NOTES

155

joj'.',:,(\tr^ py,j,.^,, i |??^,,.'?>A-a<!c.;, ■^p

"A-C^

;:>^.^-.

C^yr^y CjrCyt^r. hraY^i y-Ol^^ . '"*^^*. vC"*, rt-'f

, , -• ^jiU/t aA-^ COj, ^)p^^ '/^W*- f "{»'/•' '^■^-'i*-'

I -f-^f^i ^ J, / , to ,

v •TV^;", '^'"\'^''i*y)fyNcliyu.t^,<'^.)r*f^ kii~_

m ^^^■'■^■

■%

>

J V

156

L. JESSOP

rrJh

Jld^ir^

^5-ii ../I/-

taJ'n

h--m.lt. *«>/ .Vu-a ^eAuctn, /y*' ^/ if'^'it.^ Kit^t- o.n.m^.vnS^

0l^/'J'.'-' !»'*■ ^Lyn^fO,,,^ ^ u 3 ^ p.Wt- .(Lf^ JtCn,^ Jj(L^^J <u:A.>f

&

//■ P^'il^n^iK. ifu

•fTTx'

■_>>.- >rij_.,jA.^ v-f -i-* rt*^ — ^^tK.nveti~^ W Jr,j^(t »tr/l'(t. it>-e*j. Q^>^j

«ilj 4

6 f 9 wi.n^v't^

t ^ fr/^f*

f > •"' 'Til

I

YyvV Itii'rL*/

rrr etSruU/lu^U ^ni fhn^4..k-f>',nt

li.

pa:

CHARLES DUBOIS INSECTNOTES

157

/

rr

V.^' ~e<.»-^^J.

r

^ U>^p it*d/ ?»■ »/C;...'v af'-'i^-'^^A ''-Jf-^ curti-uT-, y/uJ^ "«r f^e^rtt- *A-

■. c^^l&t ... '^w^f* ti «- ,y«^"*f l^-^tf- ■'-''.

: " -LfVy Ml'^ »- *^7"^-<'\ C-^-Qj-n/r "ntA/py^

vy

(y'Z, . JtMti^tiU iyfrl^^nl

63. tirnmi^ ,„.

(?

^- '^A?^.---/^;.^

vAs.T y,-;.

l^ \^^r ill

M"

I

158

L. JESSOP

rF4 1/31, itn. }n^, [[Mi fc . -o ^

• /«■'" «KM.>t« ^V«.*ri yjZrtitii

L.

•l»l^»

9,.

^<er>v«.

♦l^U.

.65-.

'et/^ti

. /^. ,v ,A^^ j^ ^t^^ jz..^ J f^^^ ^; ^^.

C7 ' J" **-♦' *^>>

\ii^

CHARLES DUBOIS INSECT NOTES

159

•-'»'a a./-

A. kI hrmAAj

k.

-^ , //T^ > , < ^.jtfy i,^ ^^ ^. j^ ^^;^_^

-a

•v^ .

f.^Ul^Qu^ rxl,>x'j , 'X£;

'%

••« C/»,' /„

//...,.,.

160

L. JESSOP

73

. fn*Vi«,-,

' C "iiicx ^^cc fn*Ji«.-, /»'«'fritj!^**P**'"J cotton f^tt4 -' 'jUkC-

/ ■,-^ii.'^''"Klj'ruJ- w*' ajAi 'o^UH itfhifi^n iA^KjdAK

/^

9»#|0l?tO ^

..y®'-?.

ifAcL

CHARLES DUBOIS' INSECT NOTES

161

-5 ^'^'^^"^ ^.v.^^ /^.-t^.,/, ,,

t'-'" ^""-^ V -cr' -^^„:^^ ^;^..,, .

^^^£ -5:f^;;^: %-^r^..: r^t^

,? ■'

f

<t5

162

L. JESSOP

"D

WhK'f-^

fi'-;jatf/>'t ■

lira

fCu Cin?/

n.i id V

«Q

mi ra / er^

"fi^xryA.' %.ntrttyn^j-t- o //i3rj trie L'fj^etat'^tt '
fp-z^/t. rt-r'ttr-o/ vn /r n?i e,*J tn n J itiyi- a L/rnriB/y

furt

h

^^TtJetti^ -{ I (i 'Af^ '■■in '^'^ l^ffni f/t/- ttrhci A f/jiyrc fuy?- \

CHARLES DUBOrs' INSECT NOTES

163

"TTICT^

*„ /'t iJ .

I- At trt,iA<t>rJ t-ft'rif flr ai'^ti i.,.c

fii/tl,<^ k'^TiJSel^, *\>/{t//Ceyr~ to re f,n/i

tr / V>

/y&y * ■^<f:;i »i //■ tntiy Jty-u^ a >rto-»g/t oM^*,

S. >■ <^e .r^'^ic />/" /in A*r- t.''t1t ni^^ , ■fi^/^'^ye. L^t^dj nye

** ^ /\6 • /? /* /^ Z ''^ *

164

L. JESSOP

/ n < ' 1/

*' 1.

.. ^^irnj do ot'I»n Jiif>f>€u the pilte^^ f - n i ><■".'»'
•^%?frryJ CJf>feJrt-fCy t/iff- Aaf* j/trny ^c'Ci}^, Ij'/'(f4.

1'^ m C\

y ir*4.f iXjBf a

■/<c

^

^-'

t?i , r~ V^i'Tta ^tt>i^'f> iM/r

A/)-if «n-rL

^7

CHARLES DUBOIS' INSECT NOTES

165

^

^

Revista Latinoamericana de Historia
de las Ciencias y la Tecnologia

Editor: Juan Jose Saldafla (University of Mexico)

Quipu (Latin American Journal of History of Science and
Technology), is devoted to the history of science and tech-
nology in Latin America. Founded in 1984. it is published
three times a year. Contributions are welcome and articles are
accepted in Spanish. English, Portuguese and French, Quipu
has become indispensable for all those who study Latin Ameri-
can science and technology as well as for scholars interested
in the diffusion of science in different cultural contexts.

Suscription rates for 1989,
including postage and handling:

Latin America:
Individual US $25
Institutional US $40

All other regions:
Individual US $25
Institutional US $60

A complementary collection of Quipu is:

QUIPU NOTEBOOKS
The price of each volume, including postage and handling:

Latin America: US$10 All other regions: US $ 1 5

El perfll
Jl de U clcncla
M «a America

S£

Orders and suscnptions by check or money order:

Quipu. Apartado Postal 21-873, 04000 Mexico, D F.MEXICO

CONTENTS

1 Notes on Insects, 1692 & 1695

By Charles duBois

Edited with an introduction by

L JESSOP

*'

9*tLt

^Bulletin British Museum (Natural Historyj
HISTORICALSERIES
Vol.17, No. 1, May 1989

Bulletin

British Museum

(Natural History)

BRITISH MUSEUM
NATURAL HISTORY)

1 8 DEC 1989

PPF/^E^ITF^

Historical Series

■-

VOLUME 17 NUMBER 2 30 NOVEMBER 1989

The Bulletin of the British Museum of Natural History, instituted in 1949,
is issued in four scientific series. Botany, Entomology, Geology
(incorporating Mineralogy) and Zoology, and an Historical Series.

The Historical Series is edited in the Museum's Department of Library Series
Head of Department: Mr R. E. R. Banks
Editor: Miss P. Gilbert

Papers in the Bulletin are primarily the results of research carried out on the
unique and ever-growing collections of the Museum, both by the scientific staff
and by specialists from elsewhere who make use of the Museum's resources.
Many of the papers are works of reference that will remain indispensable for
years to come.

A volume contains about 256 pages, made up of two numbers: published Spring
and Autumn. Subscriptions may be placed for one or more of the series on an
Annual basis. Individual numbers and back numbers can be purchased and a
Bulletin catalogue, by series, is available. Orders and enquiries should be sent
to:

Sales Department.

Natural History Museum Publications,

British Museum of Natural History,

Cromwell Road.

London SW7 5BD

re/e^one.- 01-938-9386
Telex: 929437 NH PUBS G
f^.v.- 01-938-8709

World List abbreviation: Bull. Br. Mus. iiat. Hist (hist. Ser.)
© British Museum of Natural History. 1989

ISBN 0 565 09012 7 Historical Series

ISSN 0068-2306 Vol 17. No. 2. pp 167 -258

British Museum (Natural History)

Cromwell Road

London SW7 5BD Issued 30 November 1 989

Typeset by J&L Composition Ltd, Filey, North Yorkshire

Bull. Br. Mus. nat. Hist. (hist. Ser.) 17(2): Ifi7-25X Issued 30 November 1989

Mrs Elizabeth Gray (1831-1924):
a Passion for Fossils

R.J. CLEEVELY j 118 DEC 1989

Department of Palaeontology, British Museum (Natural History)! prfiCC^f.jyCJ^

Cromwell Road. London. SW7 5BD ,, , , \;:;:\' ,'.:...

R.P.TRIPP L_

41. Kirk Drive. Thornhill. Ontario. UT 3KB. Canada
Y. HOWELLS

12. Ashmore Drive. Silverdale. Newcastle-under-Lyme. Staffs. ST5 6RL

CONTENTS

1. Introduction 169

2. Biography of Mrs Elizabeth Gray and her family 1 70

3. The Gray Collection 175

( i ) Collecting Methods 1 75

(ii) Mrs Gray's Localities 178

(iii) The Use and Users of the Gray Collection 180

(a) Thomas Davidson 180

(b) Charles Lapworth 183

(c) H. A. Nicholson and R. Etheridge. Jnr 185

(d) F. R. C. Reed 187

(e) Other Users:

W. K. Spencer 188

Mrs. J. Longstaff 189

W. H. Hind 190

T. H. Withers .A 190

(f) Visitors ■ 191

4. Biographical account of F. A. Bather 192

5. The Correspondence between Mrs Gray and Dr F. A. Bather ... 194

6. Aquisition of the various Gray Collections 204

(i) Original Collections 204

(ii) Subsequent Collections 209

7. The Girvan Fauna 210

(i)The Ordovician Age in relation to the Girvan Fauna 210

(ii) The Silurian Period & its relationship to the Girvan Fauna

jcontribution by Dr L. R. M. Cocks] 212

(iii) Interpretation of the Girvan Fauna 214

(iv) The Starfish Bed, Lady Burn 219

8. Conclusions 221

9. Acknowledgements 225

10. Footnotes '. 226

1 1 . References 234

Appendix 1

Letters between Mrs Gray and Thomas Davidson recorded in

Davidson's Letterbooks between 1847-1884 241

Letterbooks in Palaeontology Library Archives, British Museum

(Natural History) 241

Chronological summary of entries relating to Mrs Gray 242

168

R. J. CLEEVELY. R. P. TRIPP ANRY. HOWF.LLS

i^^iifi^^^^iO^,

Mrs Elizabeth Gray, still tollccting at the age ol 92, this photograph was taken on a family visit to
Balclatchie in September 1923.

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY 169

Appendix 2

Mrs Gray Correspondence in Palaeontology Library Archives,

British Museum (Natural History) 244

Summary of Contents 244

Mrs Elizabeth Gray Correspondence Vol. I, 1874-1914 245

Mrs Elizabeth Gray Correspondence Vol. 2, 1915-1923 248

Appendix 3

Alice Gray letters in General Files,

British Museum (Natural History) 251

Alice Gray — F. A. Bather Correspondence 253

Summary of All Alice Gray Correspondence 253

Appendix 4

List of Gray Localities in the Girvan district 254

1. INTRODUCTION

Amateur fossil collectors have always made a valuable contribution to palaeontology.
Inevitably, during the early days of the science their collections augmented the material
gathered by the professional geologists and made a substantial contribution to its
development. The various specialists and professional geologists were able to make only
occasional forays into the field and either employed local residents to gather specimens,
or had arrangements with quarrymen, or else had to rely upon the collections of
amateurs to resolve the problems they encountered. Other naturalists, like the Sowerbys,
who produced the early reference books encouraged such collectors to submit material to
them for determination with the hope that they might have "something new", which could
then result in recognition of their effort by being named accordingly (Allen, 1976;
Cleevely, 1983).

In his history of Scottish Palaeontology, Clarkson (1985: 1) has shown how the
discovery & description of the rich fossil assemblages of the Palaeozoic sedimentary rock
sequences of Scotland was largely conducted by self-taught amateurs. This was particularly
the case with the thick sequence of Ordovician rocks, mainly elastics and limestones of
shallow water origin with their rich, often unique faunas occurring around Girvan,
Ayrshire. Mrs Elizabeth Gray, wife of the ornithologist Robert Gray, amassed consider-
able collections from this district and has been described 'as one of the foremost fossil
collectors of all time' as a result of her redoubtable activities over a period of more than
fifty years (ibid: 1). Her initial efforts were encouraged by the research interest & need
for Palaeozoic brachiopods of Thomas Davidson and subsequently, by Charles Lapworth,
who utilised the fossil faunas she helped to reveal to interpret and correlate the
stratigraphy of the Girvan region.

Miss Etheldred Benett (1776-1845) is regarded as the first woman geologist (Cleevely,
1983: 54) through her wide involvement in collecting British fossils, particularly from the
Cretaceous exposures of Wiltshire. The Philpott sisters ( 1833-40) were amongst the first
to collect Jurassic fossils in Dorset on behalf of the specialists and were soon joined by
the more widely known Mary Anning (1799-1847), partly to provide themselves with
additional income. However, a decade later, Mrs Gray began a lifetime of collecting in
the Girvan district of Ayrshire solely out of interest. She was a woman of extraordinary
character and considerable determination, who as a result of these activities left a lasting
name in Scottish geology (see Flett, 1937).

170 R. J. CLEEVELY. R. P. TRIPP ANO Y. IIOWELLS

The Gray Collections have become of particular value because:

(a) a careful record as to the exact geographical location and geological horizon from
which each fossil was obtained had been maintained; [this was also augmented by
Mrs Gray"s phenomenal retentive memory of each specimen!]:

(b) it was also one of the earliest collections containing information as to the relationship
of the specimens to one another; or attempting to ensure that part/counterpart were
kept together;

(c) the collections formed the basis for many of the earlier descriptive papers and
monographs by significant Palaeozoic palaeontologists [principally owing to its
uniqueness]; this material also formed the basis of the fossil lists published by the
officers of the Geological Survey in their Memoirs. As a result, the Gray collection
contains many type specimens of British fossils and is also significant in the
nomenclature of higher taxa.

Together with her daughters, Mrs Gray formed three collections of Girvan fossils; the
first is now in the Hunterian Museum, Glasgow, the second in Edinburgh and the third,
by far the most significant, was purchased by the BMNH in 1920. Later, her daughters
contributed substantial material fo the BMNH to augment the original collection.

Apart from providing information on the accumulation of the fossils by the Gray
family and their subsequent acquisition by institutions and their use by palaeontologists,
the main purpose of this paper is to indicate Mrs Gray's relationships with these
scientists. The extensive correspondence now preserved in the Palaeontology Library of
the British Museum (Natural History) through the efforts of her daughter Alice and the
co-operation of two former Keepers of Geology. Dr W. D. Lang & Mr W. N. Edwards,
has enabled us to attempt this appraisal. In fact, examination of her lengthy correspon-
dence with Dr F. A. Bather over a period of thirty years, reveals Mrs Gray's single-
mindedness. To attain her objective of ensuring the description of 'her Girvan fossils" as
quickly as possible, ideally in a series of monographs based on the Gray Collection, she
somewhat overlooked the other tasks and difficulties that might beset the busy
specialists, whom she had persuaded to undertake the work.

Recognition of the significance of the Gray Collection and the qualities shown by
Elizabeth Gray in accumulating such a wealth of material, has led to several earlier
attempts to write a short biography and record the history of the collection. However,
neither the original attempt made by Alice Gray', nor a later effort by W. N. Edwards of
the Department of Geology. BMNH" was ever published'. Fortunately, although W. N.
Edwards' notes cannot be found. Alice Gray's earlier drafts have been preserved
amongst the Gray papers'*. In many respects, she might almost be considered as another
author of this paper, for in addition to her biographical account of her mother, Alice was
also responsible for the organisation of the Gray Correspondence, various family
photographs and other relevant material into several bound volumes before presenting
them to the BMNH in 1938. Furthermore, much of our own information on the Gray
family and their collecting has been gleaned from the occasional reminiscences that Alice
Gray made in her letters to the staff of the Department of Geology.

2. BIOGRAPHY OF MRS ELIZABETH (;RAY AND HER FAMILY

The little biographical information available was provided by her daughter Alice in a
brief account of Mrs Gray's life written at the request of the Geological Survey, after her
mother's death''.

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY

171

Elizabeth, the younger daughter of Thomas and Mary Anderson, was born at the
Burns" Arms Inn, Alloway, nr. Ayr on 21 February 1831 according to baptismal records
(pers. commun. Danielia Shippey, 17 October 1985). However, Elizabeth Gray and her
family always recognised 21 March 1831 as her birthday [see Biography MSS and letter
18 March 1913].

In 1836, her parents moved to the Girvan district when her father decided to leave his
occupation as an innkeeper and become a farmer. At the age of fifteen, after education

15

20

25

T 1 1 r

N

Shalloch Mlll^

Woodland Poinl.<
Whilehouse Bay.

Ardmillan Brae

v-S

>6S,

South Threaver

Drummuck

•^^ — — • Newlands
e^!5V Mulloch Hill •

Craighead Quarry^

a\e' ,

„t Gir>!25'

fNEW DAILLYV

Camregan Wood*

»GIRVAN

• Dow Hill

-^0. cTT-Af^-

'''fc^^^C^^Balclatchie

Benan Burn»
lUinuntion Quarry /

Aldons Quarryi

A714\

1 MILE
I 1

Map of the Girvan area.

172

R. J. CLEEVELY, R. P. TRIPP AND Y. HOWELLS

at a small private school in Girvan, Elizabeth was sent to a boarding school in Glasgow
for a year. She then returned to the farmhouse at Enoch to assist her mother in looking
after her six younger brothers. During this period, her interest in the local fossils was
aroused by her father, who gathered specimens when travelling around the neighbour-
hood, particularly material extracted from nearby sites used in repairing the roads.
Thomas Anderson was a keen naturalist, and in their monograph on the fossils of the
Girvan district, Nicholson & Etheridge (1879: 165) dedicate a trilobite BronieiLs andersoni
to this "intelligent and enthusiastic collector' and later named a coral after him (p. 273)*'.

Left: Robert Gray (1825-1887); pi. V from obituary published in Glasgow Naturalist. Vol. 4.
Right: Family photograph of Mrs Elizabeth Gray in iy()5 when she was 74 and there appears to
have been a lull in her geological correspondence.

When Elizabeth was twenty-four she met Robert Gray', at that lime a branch
inspector for the City of Glasgow Bank and one of the typical gentlemen-naturalists of
that era, whose interest in ornithology had brought him to Girvan to study the birds of
the Ayrshire coast. Much later, in 1869, he was to publish a joint paper with his falher-in-
law on the birds of Ayrshire and Wigtownshire. Robert Gray also assisted Elizabeth in
collecting her Girvan fossils, particularly from the easily reached Penkill and Balcletchie
localities and together they made a substantial collection. They were married in 1856 and
although living in Glasgow were able to continue their bird and fossil excursions by
visiting Girvan each summer. The scientihc partnership was helpful to both, for Robert
Gray became a keen fossil collector and from the evidence of Davidson's letlerbooks,
possibly the instigator of their family fossil forays. It would appear from the numerous
contributions that Robert Gray made to the Proceedings of the Natural History Society
of Glasgow, that he was frequently travelling throughout Scotland and Elizabeth had to
learn to skin and preserve the bird specimens required for their bird cabinet. In 1864,

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY 173

Robert Gray read a paper in Glasgow on 'Observations in various branches of Natural
History during the past summer", which referred to these fossils.

The original Gray Collection was presented to the Hunterian Museum, Glasgow
University in 1866. Various short papers and accounts of exhibits based on the joint work
of Mr & Mrs Gray were published in the Proceedings of the Natural History Society of
Glasgow between 1868 and 1878, several of them dealing with the fossils. It was shortly
after the first of these, in 1868, that Professor John Young, one of the authors, instituted
a class in geology for women at Glasgow University**, and presented a ticket to Mrs Gray.
Apparently, she greatly enjoyed this opportunity - her only formal geological education
- which provided some understanding as to the scientific value of the fossils she had
collected' [Alice Gray MSS: 3].

A mixture of collecting, field observation and participation in local society activities is
a predictable pattern of life for any young couple with a joint interest in natural history.
However, it would appear that the Girvan fossils gradually became an absorbing pursuit.
The growing family continued to spend its summer holidays at Girvan, presumably
benefitting economically from family associations in the area, and each of the children
were gradually introduced to assisting with gathering material for the collection. Alice
Gray in writing about her sister Agnes [16 October 1937] recounts:

Like all the other members of the family, she began to help our Mother in her
childhood; at the age of 5 or 6 years she was a trusted worker. It was this same sister,
who picked up the first Cothurnocystis ever found.

In another letter [18 March 1924], written after the death of her mother, Alice states:

We hope to carry on collecting as the work at Girvan has been our principal recreation
ever since we can remember.

It is not surprising that in such circumstances, with all the children occupied in finding
material, the Gray collection increased rapidly.

In retrospect it appears that Robert Gray may have shown good judgement when in
1874, he accepted a post at the head office of the Bank of Scotland in Edinburgh.
Although he eventually became their chief cashier, his decision to move was of more
significance in that his former employers the City of Glasgow Bank ceased business some
4 years later on 2 October 1878. The auditors reported that the Bank had lost its capital
amounting to £1 million, the Reserve Fund of £450,000 and a further sum exceeding £5
million. The Directors, Manager and Secretary of the Bank were committed for trial and
all were given periods of imprisonment.

The Gray's involvement with natural history and local societies was still continued for,
following the offices and role he had held with the Natural History Society of Glasgow,
Robert Gray became prominent in the various societies of Edinburgh (see Obituary
Proc. Roy. Soc. Edinb. 15, 1887 and DNB 23: 19). In particular, after being appointed its
Secretary, he was responsible for re-vitalising the Royal Physical Society, one of that
city's oldest scientific bodies.

About 1880, according to Alice Gray's account, Dr Traquair, Keeper of Geology at
the Royal Scottish Museum had suggested to Mrs Gray that she should describe her own
material and had offered to teach her to do such work. However, she declined his offer,
feeling that she could not hope to equal the authority of those who had devoted their
lives to investigating particular branches of palaeontology. Instead, she preferred to
devote her own energies to provide such specialists with ample material to complete their
descriptions and interesting specimens upon which they could conduct their research,
since her real enthusiasm lay in discovering and collecting fossils.

174

R. J. CLEEVELY. R. P. TRIPP AND Y. HOWELLS

Galleryl

No. 59, George Street, the home of Mrs Gray and her daughters from the 189()s until 1945. TTiis
photograph shows the property in 1971 when the premises were occupied by the Dunfermline
Building Society and the publishers T. & T. Clark (2nd floor). Alterations to the building had
been made to provide the necessary separate access. No. 59 extends from the drain pipes (right
centre) to a point above the doorway to the left of the Building Society's front. Reproduced with
the permission of The Royal Commission on Ancient & Historical Monuments of Scotland.

Map section showing part of central Edinburgh to indicate the relationship of George St. within the
city.

Robert Gray died in February 1887 having made his own particular contribution to
natural history with the pioneer work on Clyde ornithology The Birds of the West of
Scotland published in 1871. Unfortunately, its companion volume The Birds of the East
of Scotland which he was preparing with William Evans at the time of his death was never
published. Although ranging widely over the whole of the West of .Scotland, the bulk of
Gray's book provides the first genuine account of the birds of the Clyde area. The book
has become a minor classic and one to which modern ornithologists are indebted. J. A.
Gibson, to-day's specialist in Clyde ornithology, has written of the work (1981: 71): 'One
of the masterly bird books of all time. As the years pass, being more and more highly
regarded. . . . Gray brings the birds and bird-watching a century ago magically to life.'

It was only after her husband's death that the Gray family began their long residence at
what was to become the familiar address of 59. George Street . and which was occupied
by various members until 1944 (see p. 210). Mrs Gray survived her husband by thirty-
seven years and maintained an interest in the Girvan fossils throughout that time and
resolutely collected further material with the help of her daughters for all but the last few
months of her life'".

In 1903, she was awarded the Murchison Geological Fund by the Geological Society
for 'her great services to geological science". It was fitting that Professor Charles

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY 175

Lapworth was the President to do this for in his address he was able to record 'that Mrs
Gray had devoted the leisure hours of almost half a lifetime' to dealing with the fossils of
the Ordovician and Silurian rocks of the Girvan district. Lapworth himself had
accompanied her in the field, had benefitted from her collection and the precision of its
accumulation, all of which he personally acknowledged in his address. (Proc. Q. JI.Geol.
Soc, Lond., 59: xlvii-xlviii). In her letter of reply, Elizabeth Gray wrote that her work
had given her 'lifelong pleasure" and particularly the knowledge that it had been of
service to many geologists. She emphasized that initially, her husband had shared in the
pursuit of the fossils and in working them out, and greatly regretted that he too could not
share her satisfaction in the recognition of their joint work. Mrs Gray was elected an
Honorary member of the Geological Society of Glasgow, where she was regarded as the
first and foremost of all the 'Silurian' workers (MacNair & Mort, 1908: 122); she also
became a Fellow of the Royal Physical Society of Edinburgh.

Mrs Gray died of heart failure on 11 February 1924 following six days of acute
bronchitis and within six weeks of her ninety-third birthday, her elder daughter Mary
died the following week and in both death certificates bronchitis is given as the major
cause. Alice Gray writing to Dr F. A. Bather about her mother shortly afterwards wrote
{24 February 1924):

The last day she was downstairs she looked over some fossils that she thought it might
interest you to see . . . they were packed up ... a letter was drafted & she was to write
it next day. 1 now enclose a copy of it and hope to post the box of fossils tomorrow.

3. THE GRAY COLLECTION

(i) Collecting Methods

The methods adopted in collecting have been described in detail by Alice Gray (Mss p.
5). From the quarrying tools shown in the available photographs it would appear that
substantial digging operations were often undertaken. Although Alice has written: 'that
no rock was ever taken down needlessly and that every piece of rock was carefully
broken up and if a specimen was not found immediately, examined to the last fragment.'
Every effort was made to ensure that part & counterpart were kept together, particularly
after several of the specialists who had utilised the collection had emphasized this point
(see letters of Bather, 14 March 1900 & 31 July 1900). Alice Gray commented that they
considered that: 'a fossil without its counterpart was little better than half a fossil" and if
loose specimens were picked up, time was often spent searching for its other part. It may
be that Bather's comment to Mrs Gray on the need for having both parts had influenced
their practice, since in his view: 'having only one side merely raises the question without
affording the means of settling it!'

Certainly, the earlier descriptions based on Gray material do not contain many
examples of counterparts (see Nicholson & Etheridge, 1878-80, in which only 5% of the
trilobites described fall into this category). In another letter. Bather (14 March 1900)
comments on the particular value of specimens of starfish, where with impressions of
'both sides' available, excellent examples could be obtained in contrast to the material
described previously by those authors.

Every specimen found was, at once, firmly wrapped up in paper and placed into a bag,
or vasculum. In the evening, the day's work was not considered to be finished until that
day's collection had been packed into small parcels and labelled with a locality. When the
material was back in their home, the specimens were trimmed by means of fine chisels, or

176

R. J. CLEEVELY, R. P. TRIPP AND \. HOWELLS

f^.Bll.

^^

1. Alice & Agnes Gray at Threave Glen, below the farmhouse at South Threave in 1922.

2. TTie family at the Starfish Bed, Lady Burn in October, 1922; from left to right: an unknown
friend. Agnes, Mary, Mrs Gray, and Alice.

3. Alice & Agnes Gray at a roadside quarry, Balciatchie in October 1922.

a saw, so that space could be saved. All these trimmings were examined further in the
search for additional specimens; [ — in a letter to Bather (7 November 1907) she asks for
the return of any trimmings from a specimen of Cydocystoides he had agreed to develop
for her]. Later letters of Alice Gray (4 May 1937) and her sister Edith (4 August 1942)
mention boxes of un-examined material that they had been unable to process; the latter
asks the BMNH for help in dealing with this material, pointing out that her sister had
'often come across unknown treasures on splitting stones ... in the house".

Subsequently, each separate piece was then labelled with its locality and horizon —
often small printed tickets were used — , before the specimens were classifed and placed
in cabinets, or stored temporarily in boxes. Yet, for some reason, Mrs Gray had decided
not to resort to numbering her specimens. There is no indication why such normal
practice was not adopted and one can only assume that her phenomenal memory made

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY 1 77

this un-necessary. Evidence of her amazing recall of individual specimens is provided by
several letters (to Bather: 16 April 1904, 12 March 1914, 2 August 1915; to Lapworth: 20
November 1898, 30 September 1919) when she enquired after particular specimens that
they had not returned after their research, by describing distinctive features shown by
each of these specimens, which frequently enabled them to be recognised. Another
aspect of this, is the family's involvement with the collection through their use of 'pet
names' for particular forms e.g. 'the boot' was a reference to Cothumocystis (8
November 1911); 'the hat & feather' (11 August 1915); 'plated slugs' (4 May 1937);
'trumpet' for the columella of a gastropod (6 May 1937).

Elizabeth Gray had undoubtedly been encouraged by one of her advisers, or
companions to adopt meticulous methods in her collecting. It is possible that since such
information was so critical for Lapworth's research on the succession in Girvan, that he
was responsible for instilling the need for such precision. As a result the collection, in
addition to being relatively unique and one of the few available from the richly
fossiliferous deposits of that district, was scientifically reliable. Lapworth and Reed took
pains to praise Mrs Gray for this aspect of her collection arising from her thoroughness.
Much later, Lapworth (10 June 1914) when asked to advise over the value of the
trilobites stressed that:

It was the very first collection in which the exact localities and horizons of every
individual fossil . . . was written down at the time of collection . . .

Reed (23 February 1909 and 1909: 220) emphasized the value of having material, which
enabled him to describe things 'with much more minuteness' and also that the regular
visits and careful collecting over so many years enabled him to make conclusions as to the
relative abundance of the taxa occurring at the various localities. Spencer (1914: 2) also
echoed earlier remarks as to the value of having the counterparts, for . . . 'the casts are
usually much easier to interpret than the specimens preserved in original calcite".

After each Gray collection had been acquired by an institution, the family had
immediately renewed their collecting activities during their annual summer and autumn
visits to Girvan. In 1922, erect of figure and with sight undimmed, Mrs Gray was
photographed at all her favourite collecting spots (Balcletchie, Whitehouse Bay, the
Starfish Bed, Thraive Glen, Mulloch Hill, Woodland Point) and a last visit was even
made in September 1923 at the age of ninety-two. During her almost seventy years of
field collecting Mrs Gray had seen localities come and go; some became exhausted,
others became overgrown, or unworkable in other ways, or, as in the case of two
limestone quarries Craighead & Tramitchell commercialised beyond recognition so that
the fossils were lost in the processing.

The keeness of their collecting is demonstrated by an annotation made by Alice Gray
(Sheet LXVI NW) concerning the locality 'Bougang':

In 19(K), when my mother, her brother and I went there the quarry was almost full of
water. Having been forewarned by Dr. Home, we took a thin rope with us. It was then
attached to me, held by my uncle and lying flat on the brink, I was just able to reach
down and quarry stone to hand up to my mother to break up.

The stretch of time between 1855 and 1936 is a long one and it is safe to say that the
work . . . during that period has been carried on in the same way . . . (Alice Gray, letter
4th May 1937).

After Mrs Gray's death, the surviving daughters had made the annual pilgrimage to
continue their mother's work, — even during the difficult years of the Second World War.
From her letters, it would seem that the summer of 1940 was the last occasion they had

178 R. J. CLEEVELY, R. P. TRIPP AND Y. HOWELLS

made any real finds, when Alice recorded (15 June 1941) that their local driver had
promised to do his best to overcome the petrol shortage 'rather than see us beat". Eight
months later Alice died and her surviving sister Edith then wrote:

I fear the continuity of collecting must now stop, as I have not my sister's scientific
knowledge and was only her helper.

A family tradition from the summer of 1855 to September 1941 , had ended after eighty-
six years!

(ii) Mrs Gray's Localities

The first reference to the Gray's Girvan localities was that made by Mr J. Young (TD
notebook 25 January 1865) which tells of the Grays collecting from a site they had newly
opened near Penkill farm. Robert Gray adds further details in his own letter to Davidson
(29 July 1865) and later (17 September) refers to Balclelchie. Craighead, and Penkill".
Davidson mentioned each of these in his monograph on the brachiopods.

Another early indication of Mrs Gray's localities is obtained from a list she drafted for
Lapworth's approval (see Gray Correspondence, Vol. I, No. I), litis is also accompanied
by the draft of his covering letter which suggests that the information is provided for
Thomas Davidson's work on the brachiopods and also indicates their uncertainty as to
the precise age of the fossils.

Dear Mrs Gray. Nuneaton

Am writing this in train. Would have answered your former note but not a moment for
anything, just now — even sleep!

The above list is now correct. I should recommend you to ask Mr Davidson to use
I.landeilo — not Upper Llandeilo. — We don't know what Upper Llandeilo is just now.
The beds are Llandeilo but that is all we can be sure about. Will write whenever I've a
moment.

Kindest regards to all

Kindly excuse calligraphy.

Will post this at Atherstone

Yours very sincerely
Chas. Lapworth

P.S. Please be careful about Thraive Dyke bed. and sec that fossils from true Starfish
Bed arc not mixed with the Mcristclla beds. The former are Upper Bala. The latter are
Lower Llandovery.

The record of a letter from Lapworth (24 February 1882) in the Davidson notebooks
dates this list and confirms the reason for its compilation. The lengthy faunal list that Mrs
Gray provided later for inclusion in the memoir published by Peach & Home (1899)
contains more localities, while Nicholson & Etheridge (1880: 7) had referred to forty
localities in the Girvan district (see Appendix 4 for L,ist of Gray localities)'^. Owens
(1973: 3) pointed out that the main drawback is that all these original sites are only
vaguely localized and other recent workers (see Howells, 1982; Harper, 1984: 7) have
shown that these sites have often been confused, joined, or generally misunderstood by
the specialists describing the Gray Collection and subsequent collectors. Full detailed
lists of the localities for particular fossils have been provided in the monographic studies
made by Williams, 1962; Howells, 1982; Harper, 1982; and Paul, 1984, who have all
listed them under the relevant stratigraphic formation.
The first Gray collections were undoubtedly obtained from local sites around Girvan

Ji

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY 1 79

within walking distance of the home of their relatives. It must have taken at least an hour
to reach Drummuck, where many of the specimens described hy Nicholson & Etheridge
were found. Horse and carriage, and later rail were the only transport available for
longer journeys; later Alice Gray refers to their use of a hired car (see letters to W. N.
Edwards c. 1941 ). The lack of material from rich fossiliferous sites in the Stinchar Valley,
suggests that Mrs Gray did not venture into that area; there is only one trilobite from
Aldons [the unique harpid mentioned by Reed, 190.^], little from the highly fossiliferous
basal Superstes Mudstones, and only two pygidia of the trilobite Pliomerella craigensis
(Reed, 1906) in her collection from the enormously rich Auchensoul Quarry. She is
unlikely to have visited any of these sites without coming away with abundant material.
There is also only a handful of specimens from the localities of Benan Burn. Doularg,
Minuntion and Tormitchell, all of which were know to Lapworth (1882)". It is possible
that the Gray family were quite satisfied to concentrate on the places that they knew and
had always exploited. There was some sense in this for it is now known that the Gray
family's locality 'Bargany Pond Burn' was not that of other collectors, but a quite
different locality that they had discovered as a result of following and mis-interpreting
directions to the original site.

Mrs Gray never recorded her localities on any map, but in 1937 Alice Gray
endeavoured to record them all from memory on six-inch Ordnance Survey maps, which
she presented to the BMNH. In her letter to W. N. Edwards (4 May 1937) she wrote:

... I found that the present generation of geologists, who have worked in the Girvan
district, are not so well acquainted with some of the localities as we are . . .

She provided the set of maps'**

marked with all the localities from which my mother collected her fossils ... in case of
any doubt or dispute.

It would appear from her letter that comment by current geologists over Lapworth's
account of the exposure of a particular bed had prompted this action for Alice Gray
continued:

Professor Lapworth was right and to-day's geologists wrong! We worked at the bed in
question before to-day's geologists were born and for many years it has been
overgrown'^.

However, despite her own assurance, it would appear that at times her memory was at
fault, or more likely, that she was unfamiliar with reading maps to establish the sites of
localities, for several of those marked are quite impossible for the horizons of the
material (see Howells, 1972: 4, for several instances of this). Her annotations to the maps
indicate that she had considerable uncertainty: see sheet LVI NW where several
localities are marked 'to the best of my recollection' and Sheet LVI SE where she has
written against the locality 'Auchensoul':

on the Auchensoul Burn somewhere — I myself was never there!

Harper (1984: 7) has provided a method for differentiating between the localities
'Drummuck', 'South Thraive', 'Starfish Bed' and 'Cliff Section' as used by the Gray
family and subsequently treated as one by Reed. Howells (1982: 3) has shown how to
distinguish specimens obtained from several sites denoted as 'Mulloch Hill', the general
area from which they were collected, on the basis of their lithology and differences in

180 R. J. CLEEVELV. R. P. TRIPP ANfJ Y. MOWELLS

weathering. A photograph in the Gray Album of the three sea stacks at Whitehouse Bay,
enabled Ingham to identify the site despite its now being worked out.

(iii) The use and users of the Gray Collections

A glance at the accompanying bibliography will reveal the principal users of the material
that Mrs Gray and her family had collected. These were relatively few and somewhat
alarmingly, most were essentially institution-based palaeontologists. Only Lapworth had
any real interest in, or knowledge of the Girvan district and of the others perhaps only
Davidson & Nicholson (and later Spencer) had any real field experience, consequently
mistakes were made in naming taxa and determing relationships and age. Comparison of
Mrs Gray's relationship with the various users of her collection from the few surviving
letters and other records indicates that, in many respects, the degree of affability was
governed by the extent and speed with which these palaeontologists fulfilled her goals for
the determination and description of the fossils. Although obviously any personal, rather
than just scientific acquaintance, affected the level.

One of Mrs Gray's earliest correspondents was Thomas Davidson'*, who was probably
the first specialist worker to utilise her material when describing several new species from
her collection in his monograph on the British Fossil Brachiopoda (1866-71 ). Alice Gray,
in her biographical Mss states: 'as far back as . . . 1860, she was in correspondence with
Thomas Davidson'. This is unlikely, for as Mrs Gray herself apparently wrote in a later
letter to Davidson (8th April 1882): 'I may mention that it was in 1863, I first collected
fossils . . .' and in even later letters to Dr Bather (27 March 1913 & 15 October 1914) this
period is indicated! There is undoubtedly some confusion as to the time the collection
was begun, for in other letters Alice Gray refers (24 January and 4 May 1937) to 1855 as
being the year that the family custom of collecting fossils at Girvan was begun by her
mother, in fact this would be the year that she met her husband! It is possible that Mrs
Gray's comment quoted above referred to the time that she began to collect in a more
precise manner, for some of the Hunterian material was undoubtedly collected earlier.

(a) Thomas Davidson (1817-1885)

Davidson was born in Edinburgh (17 May 1817), the son of a wealthy Scottish
landowner, but was educated in Europe. His inclination for the fine arts was encouraged
through attending classes in Paris, while his interest in natural history was influenced by
access to the various institutions and the guidance of Constant Prevost'^ in accumulating
a collection of geological specimens from the Paris Basin. This new interest in geology
was maintained by his attending lectures in Britain, surveying in Scotland and sub-
sequent field work throughout Europe. After making the acquaintance of l.eopold von
Buch"* during a visit to Italy in 1837, Davidson was persuaded to undertake a
comprehensive study of both living and fossil Brachiopoda.

As a man with private means he was able to devote much of his time to such research
in his own home, first in London and subsequently at various places in Brighton.
Davidson's artistic abilities enabled him to overcome one of the main problems in
dealing with a wealth of material and ensuring its recognition. His working methods have
been described elsewhere (Cocks. 1978; Mancenido & Cocks, 1986) but the letterbooks
demonstrate that Davidson endeavoured to just concentrate on particular taxa at any
one time. For that period, his correspondence is only with other interested parties and
solely devoted to that subject until it had been resolved.

Davidson's role and scientific achievements were widely acknowledged during his
lifetime by numerous society awards. Professor Young (26 October 1882) had recognised
that it was Davidson's enthusiasm which encouraged everyone to assist in the provision
of material, particularly that from the strata of 'Dear Auld Scotland'!'''

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY

181

(S)-(^-^

A page from Davidson's notebook showing his notes on Triplesia grayii and other specimens
borrowed from the Gray collection during the preparation of his monograph; Mss held by the
Brachiopod section. Department of Palaeontology, BMNH.

Davidson's notebooks"", preserved in the Brachiopod section of the Department of
Palaeontology, [for further description see Cocks, 1978: 4) contain some indication of his
use of her material in the preparation of his monograph, through the annotations he
made to the drawings of the specimens he had borrowed, but give no clear evidence of
the dates. However, another series of letterbooks preserved in the Palaeontology
Library, in which Davidson listed all his correspondence and appointments, provides
definite evidence concerning his collaboration with Mrs Gray during the period between

182 R. J. CLEEVELY, R. P. TRIPP ANDY. HOWELLS

1867-1884 and an idea as to the frequency of their communications. These references
also indicate, not surprisingly, that "Mr." John Young"' provided the introduction
through his association with Robert Gray at the Natural History Society of Glasgow.
They also demonstrate that, initially. Robert Gray himself, was also more directly
involved in collecting the fossils than had been thought.

It was in January 1865. that Young informed Davidson of the Gray Collection in which
". . . many of the Brachiopoda were in a fairish state of preservation . . . only wanting a
little trimming & cleaning ... to make them worthy of figuring." Robert Gray confirmed
his readiness to let Davidson examine all their Girvan brachiopods (22 July 1865) and
gave an account of his activities in opening up various exposures to obtain the fossils (e.g.
Penkill: 29 July & 17 September). The promised box of specimens arrived on 13
September and Davidson promptly returned them a month later. This pattern was
repeated in subsequent years after the Grays had returned from their summer forays to
Girvan and. at that time, they willingly agreed to Davidson having any duplicate
specimens he required and undertook to search for anything else he needed. Virtually all
the references to this correspondence record the receipt, or despatch of specimens. The
year 1882 was particularly busy as Davidson borrowed many of the brachiopods in the
Gray collection in a series of Lots sent over a period of four months, during the
preparation of the Supplements to his Monograph. Contrary to Alice Gray's assertion,
the first letter written by Mrs Gray appears to be that of 7 October 1867. when from
Girvan, she sent a complete specimen of the Triplesia that was eventually named after her.

Left: Professor H. A. Nicholson. FRS (1844-1X99) photograph in Palaeontology Library Archives,

BMNH. Rif;hl: Thomas Davidson (1847-1885) photograph in Challenger Expedition Archives
held by the Mineralogy Library, BMNH.

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY 183

Thomas Davidson very probably set the pattern by which Mrs Gray subsequently
judged everyone else, while his research on the Palaeozoic brachiopods may also have
led to Mrs Gray devoting her life to the acquisition of the Girvan fossils. His prompt
treatment of the various consignments sent for examination in the preparation of the
Palaeontographical Society monograph on the Brachiopoda, gave her little anxiety; the
material was always sent back within a few months and usually a few weeks and
occasionally within days. The inclusion of several rare forms in the earlier samples
encouraged the Gray family to search for other examples e.g. Triplesia Grayi. As
pointed out above, initially Mrs Gray — or very probably her husband — was also far less
possessive over the material and their collecting activities were undertaken to provide
the specimens that might be of assistance to Davidson. The fact that he utilised their
observations also added to their pleasure and gave a feeling of involvement with the
science.

Impressed by the quality of Davidson's figures, Mrs Gray promised to supply him with
a set of duplicates. She repeated this promise frequently, until, in 1884, it was eventually
fulfilled and their correspondence apparently ended for there is no further reference to
her in his letterbooks. In view of her pleasure with Davidson's work and thoroughness, it
is odd that Mrs Gray did not preserve many of his letters - only a single example has
survived and that is not really of any consquence! The protracted promises about
duplicates made by Mrs Gray suggest that her acquisitiveness — even at that early stage —
was far stronger than any obligation she may have felt towards him. It is interesting to
note that although Davidson made frequent visits to Scotland and embarked on
occasional field trips, he seldom visited the Gray family.

(b) Charles Lapworth (1842-1920)"

In 1873, — a few years after Mrs Gray's introduction to Davidson and the subject of
geology, — Charles Lapworth began work in the Girvan District. Mrs Gray assisted in his
exploration of the area and provided many of the fossils cited in his faunal lists and upon
which his work of correlation was based. Often at Lapworth's instigation, her collecting
forays were in search of particular taxa that he predicted, or expected careful collecting
should reveal, as occurring at certain horizons. References in later letters indicate that
their association was enjoyable:

Those were happy days (in spite of the hard work) when the geology of the Girvan
district was being worked out . . . and your family put in such fine work among the
fossils; all of which was of the greatest service to myself then; and to the Geological
Survey and Geological science in general ever since. (Lapworth, 12 February 1917)

In other letters there are frequent reference to the 'dear old Girvan land' and Lapworth's
interest in particular beds. (T. Davidson: 26 October 1882).

Lapworth's early life was spent in the Home Counties, born at Faringdon, educated in
Buckland and then becoming a pupil teacher at his own school, before entering a training
college at Culham, near Oxford. In 1864, he chose to take an appointment at Galashiels
in the Border country and his first paper 'On the Silurian Rocks of Galashiels' was read
to the Geological Society in 1870. After being appointed to Madras College, St Andrews,
he became friends with Professor H. A. Nicholson and D'Arcy Thompson. Soon after,
he published ( 1879) the paper in which he founded the Ordovician System and which has
been considered to be a masterpiece of moderation and persuasive writing. In 1881, he
was appointed to the newly established chair of Geology at Mason College (now
Birmingham University), and this enabled him to undertake several seasons of arduous
field work, but his health suffered under the strain. He was able to complete a paper on
'The Girvan Succession' (1882), in which he made use of Mrs Gray's collection and also

184 R. J. CLEEVELY, R. P. TRIPP AND Y. HOWELLS

confirmed the zonal value of graptolites which he had established in his eadier paper on
the Moffat Series (1878). In due course, after considerable argument, the officers of the
Geological Survey adopted his structural interpretation in the preparation of their
memoir on the Southern Uplands (Peach & Home. 1899); Mrs Gray's collection was also
the basis for several of the lists given in this work.

Lapworth went on to investigate the Northwest Highlands and his work helped to
resolve the controversy over the structure of this area. In the last phase of his career, he
investigated the rocks around Birmingham, in particular the Cambrian of the Lickey
Hills. Although his field ability and interpretative insight enabled Lapworth to make
significant contributions to British structural geology, official recognition of his achieve-
ments has also emphasized the influence made by his teaching concluding that his
original ideas had fertilised the research of generations of geologists (1899; xl; Watts,
1939; 277).

His main characteristic was an intense mental and bodily energy, which were so great
that they frequently overtaxed his health. A burning enthusiasm to discover the truth and
a delight in overcoming obstacles contributed to this driving force. Having made a
substantial contribution to British Geology, he died on 13 March 1920 after another long
illness.

Undoubtedly, Mrs Gray"s contact with Charles Lapworth was conducted on a
friendlier level than most of her other correspondence. Their letters to one another are
much longer and frequently mention other personal matters. On each occasion that she
considered selling her collection to the British Museum, Mrs Gray sought advice from
Lapworth"'. He, in turn, went to a considerable amount of trouble to assist her and sent
a lengthy letter outlining all the possibilities but concluded with a suggestion as to the
course she should follow. Yet, despite their good relationship, when there were
problems over her specimens, Mrs Gray was still capable of chasing him for missing
material. Their last surviving letters concern Lapworth"s embarassment at the loss of
several graptolites over the years, probably occurring during the transfer of his
Department into new premises'^.

It would seem that Lapworth was also involved in Davidson's later arrangements to
use the Gray Collection, for he endeavoured to co-operate with Davidson's revision by
completing his own contribution on the geological succession occurring in the Girvan
district (see TD: 24 February 1882). Lapworth also wrote to Davidson (TD; 27 Febuary
1882) assuring him over certain specimens; T doubt not that Mrs Gray is right in her
locality'. Mrs Gray repeated this assurance herself (TD; 2 March 1882), when she
had;

. . . much pleasure in sending the rest of the Brachiopods Horizon by Horizon
according to Prof. Lapworth's work. You may feel assured I shall be the most
particular with respect to the localities of all the specimens I send you . . . and the plan
you have chosen . . . will I think, render mistakes impossible

Yet, a number of letters during September and October 1882 concern her finding a
specimen of Triplesia grayi at the locality of Minuntion, which Mrs Gray finally admits
was a mistake (TD; 26 October 1882).

Within a few months, Davidson had dealt with much of the material, for Professor
Lapworth wrote (TD; 25 May 1882) to congratulate him on the 'magnificient table of Mrs
Gray's shells' and declared; 'it is the most brilliant useful bit of work from another
palaeontologist that has ever fell to my assistance & benefit". According to later entries,
Davidson had completed his examination of the Gray material by the end of 1882; even
in June, Lapworth had written; 'I was certainly amazed at the work you had done during
the past 5 weeks."

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY

(c) H. A. Nicholson and R. Etheridge. Jnr

185

The three fascicules of the first major monograph (1878-80) on the fossils of the Girvan
district by H. A. Nicholson and R. Etheridge " were also largely based upon material in
the 'Gray Collection' as is indicated by the title of the work. The Preface acknowledged
their debt for 'the free and uncontrolled use of her cabinet' and 'for providing the most
complete series of the . . . fossils of Ayrshire". Subsequent collecting by Mrs Gray in the
succeeding summer seasons, often at new localities, led to description of the additional
material in a further fascicule (see Benton, 1979: 7).

It is not quite clear, how Nicholson & Etheridge became aware of the Gray collection,
but a clue is provided by their reference to her father's collection being well known to all
Scottish geologists (see p. 172) and a considerable number of the species are named after
members of the family"''. However, none of their correspondence has survived and the
only evidence for a visit to Mrs Gray is provided in a letter by Etheridge to Davidson
(TD: 22 November 1881) reporting that he had borrowed some brachiopods, which he
felt Davidson should also examine. Although, in their monograph, it is mentioned (1878:
p.vi) that: 'a visit to the ground in person has resulted ... in giving us a direct knowledge
of the rocks.'

^J^'^::-

PI, lit XII.

/!£i>

Left: Original figures of Proems girvanensis published by Nicholson & Etheridge (1880) in Silurian
Fossils of the Girvan District in Ayrshire, pi. XII, figs. 7, 8 & 9. Right: Lectotype of Paraproetus
girvanensis (N. & E.). BMNH In. 21926 x 1, Upper Ordovician, Ardmillan Series, Drummuck
Group Mudstoncs, Drummuck, Mrs R. Gray Coll'n. 1920.

Henry Alleyne Nicholson (1844-1899) had been appointed to the chair of Natural
History at St Andrews in 1875 and later, in 1882, became Professor at Aberdeen. His
palaeontological work ranged over most fossil invertebrate phyla and remains of
fundamental taxonomic importance; he specialized in stromatoporoids and corals (see
Benton 1979: iii-v; Cleevely, 1983: 214). Benton (ibid: iii) established that Nicholson

186 R. J. CLEEVELY, R. P. TRIPP AND Y. HOWELLS

was one of the earliest workers to use thin sections for determining internal structures of
bryozoans and corals and to then utilise this information for taxonomic work. Since it is
thought that Nicholson cut many of the sections himself, we can only assume that the
Gray material was dealt with at St Andrews.

His collaborator. Robert Etheridge. Jnr (1847-1920) had begun his career as a held
geologist in Australia with the Geological Survey of Victoria. When this organisation was
disbanded in 1873, he returned to the U.K. joining the Geological Survey of Scotland.
At the time of his work with Nicholson. Etheridge had been appointed to the staff of the
British Museum (Natural History) and both father and son were engaged in dealing with
the transfer of the collections from Bloomsbury to South Kensington. He worked
principally on Palaeozoic invertebrate fossils. Subsequently, in 1887. Etheridge returned
to Australia, holding several Survey and Museum appointments, before becoming the
Director of the Australian Museum, Sydney in 1917 (see Rec. Aust. Mus. 15: 1-27.
1926).

Their Girvan publication was supported by a grant from the Royal Society of
Edinburgh and in the Preface of the first Fascicule, the two authors also recorded their
gratitude to Robert Gray for providing additional financial help towards publication (see
p. vi). Later, in a letter (TD: 19 November 1881) Mrs Gray reported that progress on
'Nicholson's Ayrshire work' had stopped owing to lack of a further grant from the Royal
Society [of Edinburgh]. The following year, in another letter (TD: 25 March 1882) Mrs
Gray expressed her obligation to Davidson for having 'worked out' her Girvan material,
unlike Nicholson & Etheridge, who had decided not to continue. Mrs Gray seems to
have gradually become disenchanted with the progress of their monograph and its
eventual abandonment caused her to seek the help of other specialists to deal with the
undescribed mollusca.

Both Henry Woodward"^ and his friends Professor T. Rupert Jones'^ provided notes
to be used in the second fascicule (see pp. 211. 216) and as a result were later, briefly
involved again. Woodward (1885) described two specimens collected by Mrs Gray at

Left: Professor Charles Lapworth (1842-1920) portrait in Geol. Mag., 1901. Dec. IV. Vol.8:
opp. p. 289. Right: F. R. Cowper Reed (1869-1946) photograph in Palaeontology Library
Archives, BMNH.

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY 187

Thraive and named a new chiton after her in recognition of her contributions to
palaeontology; this species Helininthochiton Grayiae has since been recognised as the
type species of the genus Sepiemchiton Bergenhayn (see Rolfe, 1981). T. R. Jones dealt
with several of her specimens of Ostracoda in later papers (1886, 1893a, ft).

(d) F. R. Cowper Reed (\i(,9-\9A€)

It would appear that Bather was responsible for suggesting that Reed should deal with
Mrs Gray's trilobites, following Nicholson's reluctance to continue"''. Reed later
succeeded Davidson in dealing with her brachiopods and the high quality of his revision
of these Palaeozoic fossils is reflected in its relevance and acceptance to-day. A letter
from Mrs Gray (c. Feb. 1911) concerning her reluctance to allow the use of the Girvan
material by any researcher, mentions his involvement. Her reaction to the use of 'her
specimens' by O. T. Jones without 'her permission', prompted a stream of letters to
various geologists. By way of explanation, Mrs Gray argued that since the specimens
'were never trusted to him [O. T. Jones] ... for examination' she should refuse her
consent to any proposal that might rob Reed's future work of 'some of its interest' — by
this we infer she meant the chance of describing new taxa.

Reed spent the greater part of his life in Cambridge, arriving as an undergraduate in
1888, then later obtaining an appointment as an Assistant to the Woodwardian Professor
of Geology in 1892. He retained that post, essentially curatorial, for a further twenty-five
years while T. McKenny Hughes held that Chair. Reed's doctoral thesis (? 1890) was on
volcanic intrusives, and he received the Sedgwick Prize for work on the geological history
of the rivers of East Yorkshire. But, after writing on the geology of the Fishguard district
(1895), Reed appears to have concentrated on palaeontology. According to A. G.
Brighton (pers. commun.) his chief duties as assistant were the curation of the collections
at the Sedgwick Museum. When the Chair became vacant c. 1917, Reed was so
disappointed at J. E. Man's appointment that having independent means, he relinquished
all his official duties with the Sedgwick, but maintained his room for research work.

It was through earnings from his research and descriptive work, mainly undertaken for
the Geological Survey of India, that Reed was able to augment his private income.
Consequently, although he was primarily concerned with Palaeozoic fossils, in such
circumstances, he did not hesitate to investigate much younger faunas. As a result. Reed
covered a very wide field, dealing with many groups of invertebrates, but was especially
interested in the brachiopods and trilobites. He frequently sought advice from his
contemporaries, while correspondence with Dr Bather from 1904-1925, shows that they
collaborated in describing and obtaining foreign echinoderm material""'. During his life.
Reed made numerous journeys overseas, mainly visiting countries forming part of the
British Empire in collaboration with his work for the Colonial Survey and leading to the
publication of a textbook The Geology of the British Empire (1921).

Immersed in his work. Reed gave the impression that he lead a somewhat solitary
existence, e.g. James Begg considered him to be a recluse. Although married but with no
children, it may be that his wife's habit of kitting him out each day with a spare pair of
socks (carried in a binocolar case) and his practice of arriving and leaving his room in the
Museum without seeing anyone, contributed to this view. His use and knowledge of
geological literature was extensive; it is said that although he was seldom seen in the
Geological Society's library, he used and borrowed more of their books than anyone
else.

Over the years Reed produced a steady stream of papers describing Girvan fossils, but
it would appear that he never visited the area. In a letter to Mrs Gray (23 February 1909)
following the completion of a paper on hyolithids, he commented that her material had
enabled him to describe new species 'with much more minuteness than is generally
possible' and that the meagre accounts of other British species made comparison very

188 R. J. CLEEVELY, R. P. TRIPP AND Y. HOWELLS

irritating! He quickly dealt with all material, seldom developed a specimen and relied
upon his memory and previous publications; the ready availability of his own first rate
artist, who was experienced in presenting the essential features of any specimen
contributed to his quick turnover. Once he had "retired'. Reed's time was solely devoted
to such research. Inevitably, it was this fast rate of progress that led, in 1911 (see p. 198),
to Mrs Gray asking Reed to undertake the description of her cystids, after experiencing
years of exasperation with Bathers promises and the protracted loan of her material.
However, even Reed took time dealing with her specimens when preparing his various
contributions for his Palaeontogaphical Society monograph on the Girvan Trilobites
(1903-35).

Apparently, Mrs Gray had such a good impression of Reed, that in 1917, when his
position at Cambridge lapsed, she sought Lapworth's help to obtain another post for
him. Lapworth readily appreciated his palaeontological work and promised to bear him
in mind, musing that were he a millionaire Reed would be just the man to pay for as the
first Professor, researcher and lecturer in palaeontology in Britain (20 November 1917).

(e) Other Users

The problem of determining the starfish specimens is frequently mentioned in surviving
Gray correspondence. Nicholson & Etheridge (1880: 318) stated that her first starfish
specimens were found in 1879 at Thraive Glen. Initially, J. R. Gregory^' had undertaken
to deal with them, but upon leaving the BMNH in 1899 for a post in Melbourne he
returned everything to Mrs Gray (19 December 1899), suggesting that he would have
preferred to have dealt with a larger series in order to distinguish their specific
characters. Shortly after, Charles Schuchert then at the U.S. National Museum,
Washington used casts of new Gray material provided by Bather, which were far better
than those originally figured by Nicholson & Etheridge.

In 1908, after Mrs Gray had again raised the matter. Bather (1 December 1908)
suggested the names of W. K. Spencer (see below), a school inspector, and Dr F.
Schondorf of Hannover, but admitted that he did not have sufficient confidence in
Spencer's ability to tackle the difficult Palaeozoic forms. Schuchert. after having moved
to the Peabody Museum, Yale University, wrote (31 March 1911) that museum duties at
Washington had prevented him from producing a monograph on the Palaeozoic starfish,
but he now hoped to complete a descriptive list of their taxa'~.

The same year, following the cystid confrontation"". Bather also had occasion to
amend his opinion of Spencer's competence (8 April 1911) and considered that this
'seemed the best chance of getting the work accomplished" and it was arranged for Mrs
Gray's material to be sent to the BMNH on his behalf.

William Kingdon Spencer (1878-1955). On completing his degree, he had served as
demonstrator/lecturer at Oxford in 1903, and it was during this period he first became
interested in Palaeozoic echinoderms. Shortly after his marriage, and then lecturing at
Bangor, Spencer joined the Board of Education as an Inspector of Schools in 1904. and
was eventually appointed as Inspector for East Suffolk (1914-38), becoming a significant
figure in the world of education through his methods and schemes.

His research on Palaeozoic and Cretaceous starfishes was carried out during his leisure
and consequently, he had little opportunity for fieldwork. Spencer's ingenuity in
preparing the natural casts of the Palaeozoic material contributed to the success which
enabled him to become a world authority"''.

On being approached to deal with the Gray material, Spencer responded immediately
(15 May 1911) and gave his opinion that the valuable Gray collection was: 'in many
respects the best collection of Palaeozoic Asteroids in existence.' A few years later, Mrs
Gray wrote to Bather (27 March 1913) reporting that the Palacontographical Society had

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY 189

m^

W. K. Spencer, FRS. FGS (1878-1955) portrait I

in Biogr. Mem. Fell. Rov. Soc, London, 2,
1956: opp. p. 291.

accepted Spencer's monograph on British Palaeozoic Asteroidea and exclaimed: "I owe
you a debt of gratitude for introducing him to me."

Whether Mrs Gray remained pleased is doubtful, for Spencer emulated his sponsor
and never completed the monograph, although various parts were published between
1914—1940. Yet, he did fulfil his original promise to Mrs Gray by producing a general
paper to provide due recognition of her contribution to science (Spencer, 1929). From
correspondence with Bather, it would appear that much of Spencer's work was achieved
by means of casts made from the Gray material held at the BMNH, only ocasionally did
he find it necessary to see and ask for the originals (see FAB file: 16 September 1915, 12
October 1916).

Mrs. J. Longstaff (nee Donald) (1855-1935). Jane Donald was encouraged to undertake
research on Palaeozoic gastropods by J. G. Goodchild (1844-1906) of the Geological
Survey, who had incidentally provided Dr Bather with Mrs Gray's address in 1892.
L. R. Cox, in her obituary notice (Q.J.G.S. 91: xcvii-xcviii), wrote that 'possessing the
necessary means of leisure she was able to carry out her work in a painstaking manner'
and after marrying the entomologist Dr George Blundell Longstaff in 1906, she was still
able to find time to continue.

Consequently, in response to another plea from Mrs Gray (10 April 1904), Bather had
earlier provided the name of Jane Donald as the only possible person in the country who
could work on her large collection of Gastropoda, but again expressed doubts because
her previous work, although excellent, had been limited to a few genera ( 1 1 April 1904).
He also commented that inducements for palaeontological work were not very great
causing the few, who did undertake it for love, to be overburdened. Mrs Gray reported
that Miss Donald was already working on her Murchisonia specimens. In fact, she had
already published several other papers prior to this, all mentioning the Girvan material.
This association was also maintained after her marriage and move south to Sussex and
then on to various places in Surrey, in fact lasting until 1924, when Mrs Longstaff was

190 R.J. CLEEVELY, R. P. TRIPP AND Y. HOWELLS

nearly 70. Many of her papers dealt solely with material in 'the magnificient Gray
Collection'. Following Mrs Gray's death, she wrote:

I shall often think of the pleasant visits I paid . . . she always gave me such a hearty
welcome. . . . she has made the most wonderful collection . . . and being in the British
Museum it forms a grand memorial of her.

Many of her Girvan taxa were only represented by a few specimens, most were crushed,
some being founded on unique specimens, while some features that Jane Donald
described now appear to be questionable (see Brookes Knight, 1941: 298).

Wheelton H. Hind (186O-1920)-'\ Apart from a letter of J. Home's to Mrs Gray there is
no evidence as to how Wheelton Hind became involved in describing the bivalves from
Girvan. However, MacNair & Mort (1908: 138) mention his name in discussing the wide
influence of John Young; since they also refer to Hind's palaeontological work
elsewhere, and list his election as an Honorary member in 1909, it must be assumed that
Hind had a close link with the Geological Society of Glasgow. Home's letter (9 January
1908) informed Mrs Gray that Hind had virtually completed his examination of her
Girvan material and suggested that the Royal Society of Edinburgh should publish the
results. This idea was followed (Hind, 1910) and in his introduction, the author declared
that:

the task of . . . determining the fine series of lamellibranchs collected by Mrs Gray . . .
has been no light one! The number of specimens which I could refer to no known
species is comparatively large.

Hind went on to remark that he had been compelled to describe new taxa on single
specimens.

The indifferent preservation of this material undoubtedly contributed to his difficulty,
for comment by subsequent workers frequently alludes to this lack of features e.g. 'hinge
not visible', 'really unrecognisable!', only a shape'. In retrospect. Hind was less
successful in dealing with this Lower Palaeozoic material, and confused matters by
ascribing specimens from quite different ages and horizons to the same species e.g.
Goniophora antiqua (p. 539). Various letters in the Gray Correspondence relate to
material that Dr Hind had borrowed, shortly before his death, for comparison with
specimens in the BMNH and which Bather had to 'unearth' for return.

Thomas Henry Withers (1883-1953)''*'. Stearn (1981: 240) has briefly outlined the career
of this 'jaunty cockney character', who after entering the museum as a boy attendant in
1898 and later given encouragement by Bather, became a world authority on the virtually
neglected group of fossil barnacles. It took several years of negotiations by both Smith-
Woodward and Bather before the Treasury sanctioned his appointment to the scientific
staff as an Assistant in 1925.

Withers became another of Bather's later recommendations to Mrs Gray, although she
had been made aware of his presence in 1915 when Bather had borrowed a specimen on
Withers' behalf, as well as through replies by him to her letters whenever Bather was
absent. A joint work on the Palaeozoic Cirripedes was internipted by Withers' transfer
to the Ministry of Munitions for the duration of the war (7 December 1916). Withers
eventually completed a paper on the Ordovician specimens, naming a species Lepidocoleus
grayae (1922), which prompted an appreciative note from Mrs Gray to which a hard-
pressed chagrined Bather curtly replied (17 June 1922):

Mr Withers, not being Deputy Keeper, can find plenty of time to do scientific work. I
on the other hand can hardly get time at all, even by staying here all day!

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY 191

Later, Withers recognition that these 'strange-stalked" fossils warranted the establish-
ment of a new group, resulted in the publication of Catalogue of the Machaeridia
(1926)^^. This included further references to Gray material, (see p. 219). Subsequently,
Withers completed his Catalogue of Fossil Cirripedia. which dealt with all the material
held by the BMNH.

At the time the Gray Collection was purchased by the BMNH, Gregory"*** had
borrowed the coral & bryozoan material, including the specimens described by Nicholson &
Etheridge, but there is no evidence that he made any significant contribution with it
before it was retrieved (8 March 1921 ). Much earlier, Ida Slater utilised specimens from
Mrs Gray's collection for her monograph on the British Conulariae (1907) — another
bizarre columnar fossil invertebrate — describing three new species and figuring examples
of two other European species.

The eventual purchase of the Gray Collection overcame possible later problems from
figured material being in private hands, that could have resulted from Mrs Gray's policy
of encouraging specialists to undertake their research on her material and then insisting
that it was returned to her. Although the collection was adequately labelled and the
figured specimens marked, the fact that Mrs Gray did not always adopt a system of
numbering the specimens, meant that describers and subsequent users had no means of
referring to, or identifying particular specimens. Such practice would not have been
condoned by present-day editors of geological publications, nor the International
Commission of Zoological Nomenclature.

(/) Visitors

Apart from the specialists known to have worked on her material, there is documentary
evidence for only two other scientific vistors^^. The Gray/Bather correspondence reveals
that Miss Elsa Warburg, the eminent Swedish trilobite worker, visited her in Edinburgh
during 1913 (27 August 1913) but did not have time to go to Girvan. Another Girvan
fossil collector, A. S. Alexander, provided a colourful account of a visit during 1904 in
his autobiography (1939: 54):

Ouarrymen told me the aged widow might still be seen in early Spring sitting alone the
whole day, breaking the hard limestone of Craighead, and searching with unwearying
patience for fossils.

As I longed to see her collection, I called at 59. George Street; was welcomed and
ushered into her private 'sanctorum sanctorum', workshop, fossil store, and scientific
library — all in one compact form. The one back window looked North and down on
the grandly-wooded grey capital and over Forth waters to the green, sunny fields of
Fife — a quiet suitable room for microscope work. Cases of specimens, or cabinets
covered the greater part of available space of the other three walls. On the left, or
West wide of the window was a small but strong wooden bench, with a powerful winch
affixed in front. On the bench were rough specimens, hammers, chisels, and other
geological tools for dressing the specimens. She pointed to the winch [? = vice] and
said 'this has been of great service.' She opened a cabinet, fully taller than herself, and
there appeared a tier of drawers of various depths from one inch in the higher to two
or more inches in the lower Beginning at the top she pulled out a draw and placed this
on the broad window-sill which served as a table — there being a single chair in front
which she requested me to occupy. The specimens in the drawer were arranged in
rows. Each specimen, thinned and shaped, has a cardboard fastened on the lower
surface. On the cardboard was written the name of the specimen, the name of the
expert responsible for the naming, the locality where obtained, and other information
or remarks anent. Some very special specimens had notes of experts, correspondence,
illustrations, or publications in journals and science magazines. She directed my
attention to special points of interest, and chatted in a free, homely, humble, modest

192 R. J. CLEEVELY, R. P. TRIPP AND Y. HOWELl^

way about the specimen shown. Certain localities I had searched, but failed to find
fossiliferous beds, I inquired about. This she satisfactorily explained and rendered the
reason. The burn in once case had altered its course and grass now overgrows the
outcrop of the bed [Penkill. see note]. In another case, the locality should be searched
at low tide as the bed is covered with water and sea- weed every tide. She seemed to
know every curve and cranny of the Girvan district. We roamed in thought over the
old haunts; and she expressed a hope to revisit and continue to search for trilobites or
other. Drawer after drawer was placed thus on the window-sill for an hour without her
resting or sitting. Finally, she pointed to another cabinet and explained that it
contained the corals that my Professor Nicholson described in the Monograph of the
Silurian Fossils of Girvan. We chatted to the door and gratefully bade good-bye. but to
be held in memory while memory lasts.

There is a slight suspicion that this is not altogether an authentic account and could
represent a compression of events, whether real or imagined, for Mrs Gray continued to
visit Girvan most years and ocasionally went to London, even travelling to Europe in
1907. If the date is correct, only a few specialists had used the Gray Collection, at this
stage, although the significance of her work had been recognised by an award of the
Geological Society. Later (1 March 1914), Alexander requested Alice Gray for photo-
graphs of her mother for use in his book but before acceding to this she asked to see what
he had written.

4. BIOGRAPHICAL ACCOUNT OF F. A. BATHER

W. D. Lang in tributes to his predecessor (1934)'"' provided adequate evidence of the
multifarious interests and abilities of Francis Bather, in addition to recording the stages
of his professional career. Bather's personal qualities and characteristics may have
contributed to the difficulties in dealing with Mrs Gray and her material (see p. 198), for
his intellect appears to have required a wide range of activity. W. N. Edwards, writing
later (29 May 1937) to Alice Gray commented that: 'Dr. Bather was extremely able, but
had far too many irons in the fire.' This phenomenal range of interests led to
acknowledgement by his associates that he was an enjoyable companion; all accounts
mention his kindly, witty and urbane nature, but although it is said he was beloved by his
staff, there is a suggestion that Bather's occasional impishness, abruptness and precise
fussiness caused problems. His trait for establishing exactly the correct procedure for any
task'", whether sketching, making tea, an omelette, or to write a sentence, arrange an
index, or a collection, might be thoroughly commendable in theory for most museum
work, yet, could be very irksome to those who had to endure such tuition, or comply with
his succession of maxims, however pertinent and rewarding. Apparently, at times, the
Geology Department had the atmosphere of a schoolroom! It is conceivable that the
delays he experienced in processing specimens may have been the result of staff
relationships, even though discipline at that period was more severe. Several references
in surviving correspondence to mislaid specimens, or delays in dealing with other
matters, also imply that Bather may have ignored his own standards, although Raymond
(1953: 173)^" had vouched that every needed specimen was readily accessible.

All biographies of Dr Bather refer to his devotion to research on fossil Echinodermata
throughout his life, resulting in an acknowledged position as a world authority,
particularly on the Crinoidea, the group in which he became especially interested. He
made significant contributions to the understanding of the morphology of echinodcrms

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY

193

Dr F. A. Bather FRS. FGS (1863-
1934). From BMNH staff photograph
June 1924.

and, although not a field geologist, never lost sight of the effect of the environment, or
the role of palaeoecology. nor the fact that the organisms he dealt with were once living
animals. In some respects. Bather was an innovator of the current practice of applying
biological concepts and evidence to fossil studies''\ There is ample evidence of his willing
assistance for contemporary workers; frequent letters from both Reed and Spencer seek
Bather's valuable advice, help or comment on all aspects of their work. In addition to the
involvement with Mrs Gray, Bather had much friendlier correspondence with other
amateur collectors, notably W. R. Billings of Ottawa, who supplied most of the material
described in Bather's various shorter papers. Such correspondence was often the result
of Bather's immediate response to reports of new, or significant specimens, for he sought
to borrow anything that might be of assistance to his studies of the Echinodermata.

Lang has commented on Bather's talent and leaning for writing reviews and popular
articles — a task that he found more congenial since it enabled him to utilise a wide
knowledge of literature, art and language. The length of Bather's scientific bibliography
is adequate evidence of his prolific pen;'*'' with more than 212 papers, half of these on
Echinodermata, and more than half of those on the Crinoidea, several being significant
long-lasting contributions; this list alone would refute any contention as to the neglect of
his official duties! Other facets of Bather's aptitude for the written word was a
willingness to act as editor, both official and un-asked, or his co-operation in the
production of various journals. Finally, the evidence of countless index cards forming
part of several different systems — one the Catalogue of Cystids and Crinoids that caused
the reaction of Mrs Gray in 1911 — survived for many years and their compilation must
have occupied a considerable amount of his time'*'^.

194 R. J. CLEEVEl.Y, R. P. TRIPP AND Y. HOWELLS

His efforts to popularise geology and demonstrate the usefulness of palaeontology by
exhibition, arose from a lifelong involvement with most aspects of museum administra-
tion. Bather's realisation of the importance of informative exhibits to interest every
category of visitor, led to visits to most major museums in the world, in order to examine
their techinique and galleries. This concern for museum management & development,
together with his flair for writing, also led Bather to produce a defence against the
philistine political criticism of museums during the period of the First World War. In
many respects. Bather might be considered the most learned and versatile of those
appointed to the position of Keeper of Geology, being familiar with most of the different
aspects entailed in that office. Yet, his significant influence to the curation and
administration of the BMNH was achieved before his appointment to that post (in 1924),
which he was only to hold for four years'"'. The situation became even more difficult once
he was made President of the Geological Society of London in 1926, which imposed
further arduous duties upon such a responsible and dedicated individual. Although the
cause of Dr Bather's death in 1934 could be attributed to an illness arising from his
participation in a local dramatic production that winter, it was generally believed that his
health had suffered during these appointments and contributed to the situation, as well
as limiting his research output after retirement.

There is evidence that Bather attended almost every annual conference of the
Museums Association, participating as an able and witty debater, or a capable chairman.
He was keen on amateur dramatics; Bather is also known to have been a zealous
champion for the cause of Woman's Suffrage (very probably at the period Mrs Gray was
berating him for not dealing with her crinoids!); and also very involved with local matters
in the area of Wimbledon where he lived'*^. Two letters^** from Bather's home librarian
and secretary mention other occupations. These ranged from the compilation of an index
to the puns by Shakespeare, to the more practical tasks of binding the books in his library
and establishing a Private Press ['FABO'] to publish specialized reference works on
echinoderms.

Throughout his correspondence and publications, Dr Bather complained that his
'official duties' occupied most of his time and hindered scientific work, but our re-
appraisal suggests that it was very likely the range and volume of his interests and
activities that impeded progress. In our view, the papers he did accomplish, together
with his numerous professional achievements and official museum administrative function,
demonstrate that Francis Bather fulfilled every responsibility required by each of his
roles. The understandable chiding of an enthusiastic elderly Scottish gentlewoman,
although justified in part, was the result of her own anxiety and lack of understanding
about the environment of her eminent professional collaborator. In fact, the many facets
of Bather's life and work, as/well as the hints of his acquaintances concerning 'that
Lonely Intelligence' who had an impish personality, indicate that he probably warrants a
more detailed biography.

5. THE CORRESPONDENCE BETWEEN MRS ELIZABETH GRAY AND

DR F. A. BATHER

The correspondence between Dr Bather and Mrs Elizabeth Gray spans a period of over
thirty years, from October 1892 until her death in February 1924. It forms seventy
percent of the letters forming the two volumes of the Gray Correspondence and is
primarily concerned with the identification, borrowing and return of her numerous fossil
specimens belonging to the phylum Echinodermala in which Bather specialised However,

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY

195

1JPJTI8I1 MUaEUM (NATUliAL HLSTUiiY;,

^*t -

'"':::a?::^, tS^ f oSt U.?^ -despondence: D. Bather's request ,„ borrow .he Gray

196 R. J. CLEEVELY, R. P. TRIPP ANDY. HOWELLS

that Statement although broadly summarising the theme does not convey anything
of the difficult relationship produced by two such differently motivated people. Their
dissimilar environments, interests and responsibilities caused considerable friction and
the letters reveal a pattern of highs and lows in their working relationship, largely arising
from mis-understandings over comments and intentions. Although Dr Bather partly
understood Mrs Gray's wish to have various specialists examine and describe the
material in her collection, he had no conception that this was almost an obsession. Nor
did he realise that the need to relinquish her cherished specimens to achieve this caused
her considerable anxiety. In the circumstances, her patient forbearance of his, to her,
apparently dilatory approach in dealing with 'her fossils' can be appreciated. Equally her
own narrow outlook and selfish preoccupation led to her failure to fully realise that
someone in Bather's position'*'' — an administrative scientist at an intemationaly-renowned
museum — would have many other duties and calls on his time. Although, in part, this
complete lack of understanding by Mrs Gray can be excused by her age and social
background; while on Bather's side, Mrs Gray herself had encouraged him to examine
much of the material.

The tone of their correspondence is very polite, but although they exchanged greetings
and enquired after each others families, it cannot be considered really friendly. In fact,
the frequency of the letters reflects the current state of their 'business' relationship; only
occurring at close intervals during a period of difficulty, or on those occasions when Mrs
Gray's concern prompts her to seek drastic remedies to achieve her life-long aims. Such
alarums are in contrast to her more normal procedure of making brief periodic enquiries
as to the progress that Bather might have made with any of the main projects he had
undertaken. TTie letters convey the full nature of their reluctant collaboration and as
W. D. Lang has remarked (12 February 1938): "the complete sequence . . . makes an
interesting story'.

It began with Bather requesting the loan of the Ordovician and Silurian echinoderms
in the Gray collection (3 October 1892) and commenting that he: "would find much
pleasure and profit in their examination'. Mrs Gray responded immediately: 'Thank you
for your kindness in offering to examine the Echinoderms in my collection", but was
unable to despatch the material for several weeks owing to illness. Bather within weeks
of having asked for this material wrote (20 October 1892) that he had very little time
available owing to the approach of winter and the fewer hours of suitable daylight when
such private work could be accomplished. Two years later, Mrs Gray offers new crinoid
material for him to study, refers to her fossils and comments that she would be glad to
hear from him. Bather replied promptly, explaining that for almost all the intervening
time he had been unable to work, owing to an eye problem, but re-assured her that the
specimens were quite safe. In fact, during that period. Bather had taken a voyage to
Japan to recuperate and had also been to Scandinavia where he had met his future wife.
Next, presumably in an attempt to gain information, Mrs Gray used the pretext of listing
all her fossils from Girvan to make another request (17 May 1896) about the specimens
with Bather; which brought an immediate reply that he had not the time to deal with
them and since most were only fragments of crinoid stems, he would not venture to name
them. Thus the pattern of enquiry from Mrs Gray and the plea of 'too little time' from
Bather was established almost from the outset. The real practical problem of adequate
light in which to examine the specimens occurred again when Mrs Gray supplied
specimens of a new PIcurocystid in the early months of 1899''".

In March 19()0, a few months after J. W. Gregory had declined to undertake the
description of Mrs Gray's starfish. Bather wrote to ask her permission to send casts to Dr
Schuchert at Yale, since he had taken over responsibility for the Museum's starfish
collections following Gregory's departure for Australia. At the same time. Bather
informed her that he had begun a Catalogue of all Cystidea and Crinoidea and would

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY 197

work systematically through her collection (and many others), returning specimens when
they had been finished with. Mrs Gray took the opportunity and sent all the specimens of
starfish that she had, having concluded from his remarks that Bather had also taken up
their study. Although retaining this excellent new material. Bather pointed out she was
mistaken and asked: 'please remember, at present, my whole energies are — or should
be — devoted to the Cystidea?' That summer, Mrs Gray responded by sending her finds
of cystids and crinoids, asking that the latter should be placed with the others still with
Bather 'in the hope that they may ere long find an interpreter! ' To help her understand-
ing of these cystids. Bather referred Mrs Gray to his contribution on the Echinodermata
in Lankester's Treatise on Zoology, which had been his principal task during that period.

Over the next few years, it would appear that there were only brief exchanges between
them. In January 1901 , prompted by a request for a list of her fossils from the Geological
Survey to update their Memoir, Mrs Gray used this as an excuse to spur Bather, who
responded by suggesting that the best course was for him to update the Survey list
himself as conditions at the BMNH 'were getting much worse, not better as he had hoped!'
The following year, with F. R. C. Reed reporting that he had nearly finished dealing with
her trilobites, Mrs Gray was anxious to learn whether Bather had made any progress
with his examination of her Crinoids — (and starfishes!), stating that she also wished to
put her collection in order. Bather, having then just been appointed Assistant Keeper,
pleaded that his official duties did not allow time for private work, but promised to return
everything that was not of immediate use.

It was at this time that Bather had become fully involved with other facets of museum
work, introducing his ideas on curatorial practice into the Department of Geology,
establishing himself as an authority on zoological nomenclature, and eventually with his
active interest in the developing Museums Association, becoming that organisation's
President in 1903. Apparently, after explaining that pressure of work prevented him
from dealing with her material, — much of it in fact stemming from these additional
interests. Bather decided that the best course as Mrs Gray was so anxious about her
specimens, was to return all the Echinoderms and this was done in September 1903.
During 1904, Mrs Gray sought Bather's help over finding a specialist to deal with her
gastropods, but it transpired that Jane Donald, who Bather suggested as the only
possible person, was already working on part of the Gray collection. In 1906, Mrs Gray's
annual collecting trip to Girvan produced two possibly new cystids. which she asked him
to examine and in her single letter that year, added the inevitable enquiry about those he
already had. Bather replied at once asking her to wait as he wanted to complete a long-
term research project and avoid all other interruptions. Presumably, this was his Triassic
Echinoderms of Bakony (1909), for in its introduction Bather indicated that a long time
had elapsed between his receiving the fossils (in 1901, 1902 & 1903) and the completion
of that memoir. Over this same period Bather was also occupied in compiling the section
on the Department of Geology for A. S. Woodward's''' contribution to the museum's
History of the Collections (1906), but he would not have described this as a research
project.

In July of 1907, at the age of 76, Mrs Gray visited a friend in Dresden and she also
asked Bather to provide an introduction so that she could visit Prague at the same time,
in order to examine Barrande's collection in the Narodni Muzeum. On her return a
month later, and after leaving material at the BMNH on her way home, she enquired
about a specimen lent to Bather in 1899 that had not been returned to her, but with
which she wished to make some comparison. Bather only replied after she had written
again that October, informing him of the new season's fossil haul, when he encouraged
her to preserve every fragment of the various echinoid-like fossils she has found in the
Starfish Bed".

Their joint interest in the Pelmatozoan Cystids and other bizarre Echinodermata^',

198 R. J. CLEEVELY, R. P. TRIPP AND Y. HOWELLS

appears to have fostered an increase in her activity and their communication, which
persisted until its culmination in the memoir Caradocian Cystidea from Girvan that
Bather eventually produced in 1913. This episode opens with Mrs Gray musing
(21 November 1908): "I sometimes wonder if you have had time to do anything with the
fossils that I left with you . . ." and Bather replying with the dramatic opening
(1 December 1908)'"': 'I always see with fear and trembling an envelope addressed by
you". Both in that letter, and in his introduction to the cystid memoir. Bather explained
that his apparent procrastination was merely the result of other work preventing any real
progress: 'if only people would stop sending me all sorts of other fossils, I should have
some chance of getting on ! ""'^ and that it was necessary to study allied species and genera
before he could proceed with Mrs Gray's Girvan material. He expressed his gratitude to
her with the opening sentence of the memoir and underlined his indebtedness for
allowing her specimens to remain in his hands for such a lengthy period. Mrs Gray's keen
interest in the class may be explained by her comment: "every time I go to Girvan ... I
find specimens new to my collection . . .' for it was certainly this that induced her to
borrow Jaeckel's work on'*' Cystideans on several occasions. Although she apparently
enjoyed looking through that book (17 December 1910). Mrs Gray later conceded 'it was
to no great avail in determining her own material".

Mrs Gray's preoccupation with the cystids is apparent from her letters. Bather
mentioned that he was compiling a catalogue of all the cystids in the British Museum's
collection (25 November 1910); 'doing all he can on the Cystidea" by taking his holiday to
do so and working at home (17 December 1910). The first letter brought the comment
from Mrs Gray (1 December 1910): 'Of course, if you are not likely to be able to take up
my cystideans ... I need hardly continue to send specimens to you!" She explained that
being 'a long way past the allotted three score years and ten" she was anxious to see work
on her British fossils completed and reminded Bather that she had been sending him
fossils for 18 years. This was followed by a second letter (29 December 1910) enquiring
whether Bather intended working on her material as well as that of the BM?; was that
collection very large? had she omitted to see anything important'? was there a collection
as large as her own. or with a greater variety of species? Mrs Gray continued by
expressing her goal:

I know that you are the authority, but I am so anxious to know what mine are. & which
are new that 1 would willingly put them into the hands of any competent worker, who
would undertake to examine them at once! Every other group in my collection has
proved to contain new material.

These continual enquiries ought to have fore-warned Bather of a potential crisis.
However, he simply replied (2 January 1911) by describing the nature of the catalogue he
was compiling but compounded his error by inadvertently mentioning that, in common
with all other British Museum Catalogues, only their own material would be figured.
Misguidedly, by way of appeasing Mrs Gray, he suggested that descriptions of species in
the Gray Collection could be included in this Catalogue. His preoccupation with the
catalogue and in providing a straightforward answer to all her questions, caused Bather
to omit mentioning that his descriptive manuscript on the cystids was in an advanced
state of completion — that might have mollified her a little. Within three weeks, she had
acted and made other arrangements for her 'beloved specimens' and notified Bather
(21 January 191 1) that he should return them all as Mr Reed 'although diffident about
working on a group upon which you are the authority" was prepared to do so that
summer. Mrs Gray had effected the very situation outlined in her earlier letter and
though, in her opinion, 'the description will lack . . . high distinction ... I feel Mr Reed
will do excellent work".

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY 199

It was a complete and most unpleasant surprise to Dr Bather, particularly as he felt he
was taking a great deal of trouble over helping her. No doubt it was this event, more than
any other subsequent occasion, that led to his accurate and colourful description of his
position, or that of any specialist, at the British Museum:

A palaeontologist at the BM is often envied, much as Dionysius of Syracuse was
envied by Damocles. If any Damocles were to take my place he would sec. it is true,
a rich feast of Cystids and Crinoids laid before him. But the chains of Office would
perpetually hinder him from feeding, and every day he would dread the fall of the
sword in the shape of a peremptory letter demanding the immediate return of some
necessary specimens'''.

Replying immediately (23 January 1911), Bather gave a detailed analysis of the
situation over the cystids and pointed out that although 'Mr Cowper Reed will begin
work on them in the summer, ... he had begun work Already!' He acknowledged that
perhaps she had not appreciated the hours of work that had been spent preparing
specimens, or making notes and pointed out that "some of the more curious among them
have been perpetually in my mind's eye' and that he had been accumulating material
from all parts of the world for the necessary comparisons. Consequently, he would still
need to study her material, whoever described it, since he was compelled to complete the
task. Although Mrs Gray apologised for her misunderstanding over his original letter
and acknowledged Bather's need of her material, she was adamant about her request:
'Let me have my cystids soon — it will take me some time to look them over' — she even
reminded him of a single specimen left at the BM in 1907. She hoped he would
sympathise with her great desire to know just what her collection contained and would
endure the step she had taken with patience. She admitted (28 January 1911) that she
was quite unaware of the time he had spent working on them for: 'Indeed, I sometimes
wondered if you thought them as interesting as I did.'

Events took their course and produced what might have been a memorable confronta-
tion between Bather and Reed at the British Museum on 30th January, which resulted in
Reed's prudent withdrawal following his recognition of the considerable amount of work
that Bather had already accomplished. Apart from this. Bather was in a very strong
position, for he had a good working relationship with Reed, who was dependent upon
him for help with the numerous descriptive projects undertaken for other bodies with
which Reed augmented his university income. In a friendly letter''* to Bather (3 February
1911), Reed explained that he had pointed out to Mrs Gray that 'it is impossible for me
to deal with her collection' since he felt that under existing circumstances 'she was [not]
free to offer me the work'. However, he emphasized to Bather that 'mere reference to,
or description of her material would not satisfy' Mrs Gray since 'it is independent
treatment of her collection with figures which she requires'. Although appreciating
Bather's special difficulties. Reed advised him to propose a smooth and rapid course for
dealing with the material, although he realised such 'work cannot be hurried'.

Letters from the two protagonists crossed giving their interpretation of Reed's
conclusions. With Bather emphasizing (6 February 1911) the amount of difficult time-
consuming work involved in the preparation of such fossils (often between 60-120 hours
per specimen) but to allay Mrs Gray's fears of further delay, stating that progress should
now be quicker since most of this work had now been done. She, in turn (6 February
1911), confirmed Reed's opinion, and sought to defend her action as protection of her
material from its likely fate of becoming a mere mention in a BM Catalogue,
unrepresented and undignified by the illustration it deserved!

This did not end the issue between them, it dragged on for several months, reached
other identical crises as they tried to resolve their quite different objectives. Both plainly

200 R. J. CLEEVELY, R. P. TRIPP AND Y. HOWELLS

Stated their opposing views, Mrs Gray insisting on the early publication of any work on
'my Cystids" and that it should preferably be in the form of a Monograph. Bather on the
other hand, (15 Febuary 1911) felt that this was impractical and proposed the gradual
treatment of her fossils genus by genus and publication of their descriptions in a series of
papers. In that way. she would have the assurance of seeing her fossils dealt with and
returned to her as they were completed and he would have the satisfaction of seeing the
plates were published as they were produced. He felt that monographic treatment was
unsuitable for such a difficult group of fossils and that the difficulties and prohibitive cost
of ensuring satisfactory and adequate illustration made it even more so.

Mrs Gray at one point (19 February 1911) considered that their views on publication
were so widely divergent "that if it were carried out to the satisfaction of one, it could
only be to the dis-satisfaction of the other' and again called for the return of all her
specimens. In order to clarify matters further. Bather had explained (1.^ Febuary 1911)
that he had originally intended to utilise the Gray material 'to the best advantage of
science", but that he was not in a position to undertake a complete monograph on the
Cystidea, nor was he prepared to produce an inferior work. Despite having spent
considerable time dealing with the material and feeling that he had made enough
concessions. Bather began to arrange the re-packing of the cystid specimens for their
return to Edinburgh.

Very likely, Mrs Gray must have had second thoughts, realising that she would
probably never obtain the descriptions she so badly wanted since Bather was the only
person, who could provide them. The following day, as a conciliatory gesture, she sent a
token note suggesting that Bather might consider offering a paper to the Royal Society of
Edinburgh. Somehow Dr Home of the Geological Survey became involved and acted as
a mediator. He informed Bather that Mrs Gray was sending all her cystid material to
London for him to assess the size of the task involved in their description and then
suggest a possible time for its completion. After the allotted month. Bather duly made
his report (8 April 1911) and agreed to undertake the preparation of a memoir restricted
to the Starfish Bed Cystidea within a year, despite his reluctance previously to commit
himself on this point of completion, but would still not make any definite promise about
publication dates. He also pointed out that his own position could be made much easier.
if a selection of the material was presented to the BMNH, thereby enabling him to work
upon the task officially. Without openly agreeing to all these proposals. Mrs Gray
informed Bather that Dr Home, as editor, would apply for a grant to publish the plates if
he intended to submit the memoir to the Royal Society of Edinburgh. Bather replied that
he intended to do so and Mrs Gray expressed her pleasure that the work was to be
published by a Scottish Society. The following year, despite numerous distractions and
tasks during the preceding months. Bather presented a paper, as promised, at a meeting
of the Edinburgh Royal Society on 13 May 1912. By accident, Mrs Gray was unaware of
the meeting and had been at Girvan that week. However, as Bather pointed out to her,
the memoir itself still required to be 'knocked into shape' and this would take
considerable time; it was eventually received for publication in March 1913.

Having achieved her first objective. Mrs Gray ( 16 November 1912) immediately began
to bother Bather about her crinoids and other echinoderm taxa. particularly as she was
continuing to discover further material. After expressing her gratitude for his work on
the cystids she continually tried to needle him. in a succession of letters during the winter
months of the following years, into producing another monograph on the Girvan
crinoids. One letter (28 November 1912) probably demonstrates her great anxiety:

On thinking it over, I seem only to feel that I am likely to be deprived ... of seeing the
description of my Crinoids, which were first sent to you — at your request! in 1892 . . .
the cystids followed in 1899. Surely you have no other material with a claim prior to mine!

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY 201

At first, still trying to complete that on the cystids. Bather is compelled to use all
available time to fulfil his current commitment and attempted to dissuade her by
explaining (19 November 1912) that he had many other pressing tasks once the cystids
had been 'got rid of". After outlining his working methods. Bather endeavoured to
appease her further, by explaining that the bulk of the crinoids had been provisionally
examined and that he intended dealing with them in conjunction with his official task of
compiling a complete catalogue. Upon completing the Cystid memoir Bather wrote (19
March 191.^): "... if you have any idea of the work entailed . . . you can understand I am
in very urgent need of . . . the first holiday since starting the task.' but to ease her mind he
reported that the preliminary work on her edioasteroids had also been completed.

Having reached her 82nd birthday Mrs Gray responded (27 March 1913) with the
questions:

Can none of your . . . research be laid aside ... to let me have the satisfaction of
knowing after many years of patient waiting . . . the result of my 50 years work? Is
there anyone in the wide world who can do it? The other people . . . making demands
on your time are probably much younger . . . and can . . . afford to wait!

At the end of that summer, this is followed by the even more plaintive cry (27 August
1913):

I cannot refrain from writing again to ask if you . . . see your way to working on my
crinoids? . . . my reason for doing so always increases ... In the wakeful hours of the
night, I often wonder if I am ever to see my fossils again and think that I cannot let
them remain away from me much longer.

Bather fully sympathized with Mrs Gray (29 August 1912) and understood her anxiety,
but could only reasssure her that he was as equally anxious to proceed himself, while
emphasizing that the Palaeozoic echinoderms presented exceptional difficulties and
pointing out that it was necessary to consider her fossils together with others, for simply
describing 'what is new' as she requested, would scarcely produce a work intelligible on
its own. He ended by stating that: 'your echinoderms occupy a leading place among the
things I have set myself to do'. Later, that year, most of Mrs Gray's cystid material was
returned to her, an act which caused Bather a month of further problems, following his
recognition that several specimens belonged to other taxa upon which he was still
working and had led to their retention. His comment to Mrs Gray that she would find 'a
few missing' on this account, simply did not register with her. Much to Bather's
consternation, the possessor of that phenomenal memory was soon demanding the
return of individual missing specimens that she could recall. Although Museum staff had
numbered and labelled all the cystids that had been returned, there was no method of
recognising particular original specimens

I really do not know what I am to do . . .

I don't in the least know how you manage to identify particular specimens

. . . but it is certainly impossible for me to do so . . .

are some of Bather's responses, but fortunately for both of them matters were soon
rectified. An identical situation occurred the following year, after Bather had returned
other specimens and Mrs Gray expected to find a particular example showing both a
crinoid arm and a gastropod, known to the family as the 'hat and feather'.

Soon afterwards, the First World War caused various problems as many activities of
the Museum and its Departments had to be suspended. Bather completed a series of

202

R. J. CIEEVELY, R. P. TRIPP AND Y. HOWELLS

Terminology; Mrs Gray's sketch of the hat & feather' specimen see her letter of 2 August 1915
(p. 201); Bather's postcard concerning the 'boot' dated 7 Nov. 1911 (p. 218).

papers on the edrioasteroids. which he also published privately together as a book, and
this work pleased Mrs Gray to some extent (14 January 1915), although he was never to
produce the intended monograph on her crinoid material. At intervals throughout the
remainder of her life, Mrs Gray's letters ask whether there has been any progress and
Bather always pleaded pressure of other research, his daily routine of official duties, or
else too few staff. During the war, this became true and on several occasions Mrs Gray
considered requesting the return of her specimens (30 January 1915): "I feci that I cannot
allow my specimens to remain out of my possession for an indefinite period, and at limes
I feel very anxious about their safety.'

In his history of the Natural History Museum, Stearn (1981: 106-109) has described
the difhculties caused by the Government of the time, particularly the threat in January
1918 when it was proposed to take over both museums at Bloomsbury and South
Kensington to provide additional accommodation for use as Government offices.
Fortunately, this was averted by rcprescntalions from various scientific and professional
societies acting together with the 'media' of that period"'''. Naturally, since in response to

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY 203

Extracts from Mrs Gray's letter to Dr Bather concerning her collection, 22 November 1923 [aged 92].

her usual enquiry. Bather had reported (7 December 1916) that in the circumstances:
'not much progress is being made with scientific work and your specimens have to share
the fate of . . . others', Mrs Gray became very concerned. However, by the time that she
had decided to do anything, the Government had abandoned their attack and Bather was
able to report (10 January 1918) that staff had been engaged to remove specimens to
basement storage and re-assure her that: 'your specimens will be next to what we
consider the most valuable fossil in the world**'.

The war also affected*"' the normal scientific interchange of reference material. At one
period. Bather (4 Febuary 1915) explained to Mrs Gray that the reluctance of the
Americans to send specimens across the Atlantic had prevented him from making further
progress with his crinoid research. A few months later, on behalf of Professor Schuchert
at Yale, Bather requested the loan of a rare coral of hers from Girvan ( 16 October 1915).
After clarifying matters and only agreeing to this after imposing the condition that
everything should be returned to her afterwards, Mrs Gray commented that: 'as it now
seems to be safe for my corals to cross the Atlantic, I hope the crinoids you require are
being sent to you! ' Much earlier, she had vanquished another of Bather's excuses when
in response to his argument that expenditure resulting from the war made it more
difficult for him to undertake 'unpaid private work', she had riposted with the retort that
for 55 years she had worked as an 'unpaid fossil collector! '

The crinoid episode dragged on; Mrs Gray adopted the tactic of requesting all her new
finds to be returned immediately after their preliminary examination and identification

204 R. J. CLEEVELY, R. P. TRIPP ANOY. HOWELLS

(27 December 1912): "as I have not seen any of my crinoids for many years'. She also
tried to get Bather to inform her whether any of the specimens in her main collection
might be new species (17 June 1922). The last word might be said to have gone to Bather,
for the 'new finds' included examples of the Crinoid Herpetocrinus. which he reminded
her (23 January 1923):

'my first letter asked to lend specimens of this genus . . . unfortunately, for my
purpose, you sent me so much else, — for which I did not ask — , that 1 have never been
able to complete my paper! '

In some respects, it is surprising that this research was not completed, for the majority of
Bather's scientific papers dealt with crinoids and one can only assume that he was never
sufficiently satisfied with his results. Yet, Mrs Gray's "hounding' over the Girvan crinoids
was continued after her death in 1924, by her daughter Alice (see 23 February 1925),
even though by then most of the material really belonged to the BMNH.

6. ACQUISITION OF THE VARIOUS GRAY COLLECTIONS

(i) The Original collections

The material from the earliest Gray Collection accumulated by both Elizabeth and
Robert Gray as well as her father Thomas Anderson, was presented to the Hunterian
Museum in 1866. As discussed above, it formed the basis of several short papers, or was
used in other ways by the Natural History Society of Glasgow. The interest this aroused
led to the Gray family's pre-occupation with fossil collecting in the Girvan area on behalf
of known and unknown specialists and for the science in general. Donations of various
geological specimens were subsequently made to the Hunterian''''.

Letters of R. H. Traquair provide details of the transactions preceding the purchase of
a representative collection by the Royal Scottish Museum in 1889. It would appear that
Mrs Gray had offered a selection of her duplicates to Traquair for £60, but in a reply
(21 January 1889) he declined with 'unfeigned regret' since he could not recommend
paying 'so high a price for them'. Her immediate response was to write back to Traquair
and ask just what figure he would be prepared to pay? In an apologetic letter several
months later (24 May 1889), Dr Traquair explained his 'extreme discomfort of finding
myself involved in a dispute with a friend about money'. The long delay before replying
was solely due to his putting off the disagreeable duty of making an offer 'which from its
smallness' might be considered offensive to her. In quoting a figure of £3.5, in his view a
quite liberal price, Traquair declared that it was the highest he would acquiesce to and if
this did not suit the matter must be dropped. This ultimatum led to general agreement,
but in a subsequent letter (29 May 1889) Traquair mentioned that he had no objection to
any 'un-necessary duplicates' being excluded from the purchase and being returned to
Mrs Gray. This condition was apparently the lady's compromise in settling for the sum
offered.

Much later (21 Febuary 1920) when referring to the matter, Mrs Gray stated that she
had sold 750 specimens for the sum of £35. She also revealed that a year later \c. 189()?|
1 KM) specimens had also been sold to the Geological Survey for £50 and commented that:

these small collections contained . . . neither types nor figured specimens, nor my best
specimens, nor any of the rare species . . . and they were representative of my
collection only as it was .^0 years ago

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY 205

Several collections of Girvan fossils were presented to the Sedgwick Museum,
Cambridge by Mrs Gray between 1907 and 1910, and were identified by F. R. C. Reed.

A letter to Mrs Gray from D'Arcy Thompson at St Andrews (23 Febuary 1921),
mentions the donation of various items at this period. But, his particular reference to a
small collection of graptolites and its association with Lapworth marking them as a very
appropriate accession for St Andrews, raises an element of uncertainty as to their
source. However, his final comment: 'You have given away many things in your time,
and I know perfectly well that you will send us nothing which is not worth having . . ."
suggests that they are merely Gray specimens Lapworth had used, or examples of species
he had originally described.

After her negotiations with the Royal Scottish Museum, it is possible that Elizabeth
Gray had turned to another friend when considering further disposal. A letter from
Lapworth to her (12 April 1914) referring to the scientific reliability of her material,
regrets that his Department at Birmingham University 'living from hand to mouth" could
not afford a complete set.

Shortly after (20 May 1914), Mrs Gray wrote to Smith- Woodward at the BMNH, who
had earlier expressed an interest:

I write to inform you that I have decided to offer for sale the Trilobites in my collection
... It consists of 157 different species . . . and included the types of 53 new species . . .
described by Nicholson & Ethcridgc (1878) and Mr F. R. C. Reed (1903-1906, 1914).
. . . my collection represents in a very complete form the Trilobites of the Girvan
District and has therefore a special value!

This time after her experience with the RSM, Edinburgh from quoting a price, Mrs Gray
decided to seek an offer from the British Museum. Inevitably their response was that
they were unable to fix the price and asked her to name a figure for consideration. She in
turn, felt unqualified to do so and duly sought Lapworth's help (1 June 1914). He
hesitated, but a week later, after having fully investigated the matter, suggested a figure
of £300 based on a range of £250-£50(). He had arrived at this amount based on the
recent purchase of the Ketley Collection for a similar sum and various sales of specimens
from the Dudley area, including one collection of more that a thousand specimens that
was bought by the Natural History Museum for £550. However, in a detailed
explanation (10 June 1914) he stressed that although the Girvan specimens were less
beautiful and more incomplete, her collection contained more new species.

Presumably, this valuation satisfied Mrs Gray, for the next day (12 June 1914) she
wrote back to Smith-Woodward mentioning that she had consulted a knowledgeable
friend and offered the trilobites for £300. Her letter is annotated 'price much too high —
delay until Autumn" and it would appear that it was then intended to refer the matter to
the Trustees. In a reply to this refusal, Mrs Gray commented (29 July 1914) that she had
consulted two specialists and still believed the price was moderate. The matter
languished until she reminded Smith-Woodward (21 January 1915), who responded
(2 February)''' by an inferred reply that a more comprehensive offer of the whole
collection would be preferred at a later date. This was acknowledged (5 February 1914)
by everyone in the Gray family, who all wanted the British Museum to purchase the
entire collection, as the best way of dealing with the Girvan fossils.

Within a month or so of the war ending, Mrs Gray wrote (21 December 1918); asking
whether the British Museum still wished to purchase her collection. She expected a good
price, as apart from its being representative of the difficult Girvan District, she
maintained it was unique having been examined by various specialists, who had then
described her material. Her letter ended: 'In view of my advance age (I am in my H7th
year), I would like to have the disposal of my collection settled." and had begun: 'the

b

'T

J2^-

'*^^^,

-^

^<.

v^-

^

^ ^^*^
-^^

Letters concerning the sale of the Gray Collection to Dr Smith-Woodward (see pp 204 209).
Offer to sell trilobites— 20 May 1914; Comment on price offered 29 July 1914.

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY 207

British Museum ... is where I should hke it to be." Smith-Woodward asked (1 January
1919) for lists and separate estimates of the value of each group exclaiming that: 'we are
very anxious to acquire your collection if reasonable terms can be arranged, as soon as
we have funds again."

A year passed as each side clarified the position and Mrs Gray produced the requested
lists and the BMNH asserted that they wanted the total collection including all
duplicates. This preoccupation with numbers left considerable margin for adjustment,
particularly as the nature of the material and the inclusion of unseen duplicates left
uncertainty. In Febuary 1920, Smith-Woodward, after consulting Bather again, asked
Mrs Gray to provide her value for each group. She, understandably explained that with
her limited experience it was not possible for her to price the collection in sections. Her
letter (21 February 1920) continued:

In disposing of ... my material, I feel that 1 may reasonably look for a price that will in
some measure repay me for my life's work. ... I feci that I can price my collection only
as a whole . . . and that I should like to get £2,-'iOI) for it. ... I know that the Gray
Collection has for many years been regarded as a special collection and one of
importance. . . . therefore ... for such a special collection I am justified in asking a
special price!

A surviving internal memorandum (27 February), compiled by Dr Bather'''*, outlines
the basis for pricing Mrs Gray's collection and also emphasized that some allowance
needed to be made for potential types. After making due allowances for counterparts,
material on loan and applying his own unit figures to Mrs Gray's lists. Bather calculated a
figure of £1750; to ensure that every aspect was covered, including the possibility of
further material, he suggested the value of the whole collection might be estimated at
£2000. Smith-Woodward informed Mrs Gray of this figure (3 March) and enlarged on
the various matters that had been taken into account such as the rarity of some groups,
the lower value and fragmentary nature of others. He emphasized that Dr Bather had
added a liberal allowance to compensate for any failure to recognise important material,
or any mistake over numbers. Finally, in an effort to re-assure Mrs Gray that the figure
was in accord with established practice, he misguidedly explained that it corresponded
with "our usual rate' and with her previous sales to Edinburgh. By way of encourage-
ment, Smith-Woodward suggested that it should be possible for the Museum to make
the first of the three agreed part payments within the month.

Mrs Gray replied immediately with a lengthy letter (6 March 1920), underlining her
own view that the Gray Collection was a special collection of considerable scientific
importance and cited figures that she felt demonstrated its greater frequency of 'new
species". To justify her opinion she quoted comments made by several users as to its
special merits in comparison with other Museum collections. Understandably, she seized
upon the unwitting remarks made by Smith-Woodward and exclaimed:

I feel that I should like it to be valued at a somewhat higher rate that your "usual rate"
and that at which I sold small collections thirty years ago!

She concluded with the comment that: 'a collection such as mine can never be repeated".
Althought convinced of her own valuation, in the 'interests of Science", Mrs Gray agreed
to compromise on a figure of £2250''''.

In an effort to appease all parties and complete the transaction. Bather was prepared
to add a further comment to her letter acknowledging that his original estimate might be
wrong in the light of Mrs Gray"s fresh lists and recommending the agreement of the
Trustees to her figure. Smith-Woodward informed her of this decision (8 March) and

208 R. J. CLEEVELY, R. P. TRIPP AND Y. HOWELLS

IQ ... o '

- (DiOidcceU, (Ci^aCax^)

OAMi-nw .

The memorandum book containing details of the despatch of the Gray Collection to the BMNH in
1920 superimposed over a page of its contents.

asked for a selection of the 'choicest things' to tempt the Trustees. On the 29 March, he
was able to write that the purchase had been agreed and payment would be made during

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY 209

the next four years, but that he intended to arrange that most of the sum would be paid
within two.

Numerous letters over the next few years deal with a succession of problems and
details concerning the despatch and contents of the Gray collection. By May, the first
third of the collection had reached the Museum, entitling her to the first payment of £850
and Bather confirmed that well over this quota had been received. The major part of the
collection was installed at South Kensington within the year and only the various loans to
other specialists remained to be gathered in (see letter 26 October 1921). Inevitably, the
constant re-use of boxes and ropes etc. added to the confusion, and Mrs Gray found
some fossil shells belonging to the Lewis Abbott collection, which were duly returned*^.

Mrs Gray's peremptory concern over prompt payment as she fulfilled each of the
conditions laid down was warranted; the precision of the operation was only evident at
the Edinburgh end'''. Each payment had to be sought after promised fulfillment was
overdue, allegedly this was largely due to administrative oversight or intentional delay.
However, Smith-Woodward kept his own promise and managed to ensure that full
payment was made within his specified two years***. Finally, Mrs Gray wrote to him (24
March 1922) acknowledging the receipt of the final payment and thanking him for 'all the
consideration' during the purchase of her collection. She had achieved her object and
was able to say: "It is a matter of complete satisfaction to me to know that the result of
over sixty year's work is in safe keeping.'

With the money that she received Mrs Gray set up a fund for her unmarried daughters,
two of whom were simply referred to as fundholders on their later death certificates. At
the time the first payment was due to her from the BMNH, she had written to Smith-
Woodward (27 May 192U) asking that the money should be made payable to both her and
her daughters jointly, since they had always been her co-workers and collectors.
Unfortunately, this could not be effected as authority for the payment had only been
sought in her name.

(ii) Subsequent Collections

In January 1937, Alice Gray wrote to Dr Lang offering the BMNH all the fossil material
that the family had collected at Girvan since their earlier collection was purchased in
1920. Although several specialists*''' had since examined particular groups, most of the
16,000 specimens came into her 'un-examined' category. W. N. Edwards, in the absence
of the Keeper, hurriedly accepted what he described as their 'extremely generous offer'.
Lang, on his return, immediately repeated the Museum's appreciation of their gift. In
response to the request of Mrs Gray's daughters, that the additional material should be
added to the main Gray Collection and held under the same conditions, he explained
that: 'Mrs Gray's collection was purchased ... in normal circumstances, that is
unconditionally, as indeed all specimens . . . have officially to be.' Lang described the
procedures adopted by his Department for dealing with such material, at length. He
endeavoured to assure them that the practice of using distinctive printed labels to
identify the specimens, ensured that the source identity was maintained even when
particular groups were dispersed to the relevant sections. Commenting on Mrs Gray's
original request that her material should be retained as a single unit, Lang explained that
this was not possible for the methods adopted by the museum to assist research and
organise its collections, meant that the various parts had to be distributed amongst
different areas of the main Collection. However, Lang again re-assured Alice Gray that
there was never any problem in recognising material from a particular collection. He
undertook to pay the carriage and offered assistance with its packing.

Subsequent correspondence over the succeeding months dealt with matters of packing
and transport, and it was arranged to despatch it locality by locality. However, after

210 R. J. CLEEVELY, R. P. TRIPP ANDY. HOWELLS

dealing with the first consignment, Alice asked Lang for assistance since the time and
energy involved in packing the entire collection 'is more than we can undertake'. He
promptly sent two members of the Department to assist in its preparation and movement
down the flights of stairs at 59, George Street^". By the beginning of May, all the later
Gray material had reached the BMNH and Alice Gray asked that it should be
incorporated into her mother's collection: 'as our mother took part in the work for three
years . . . and we wonder, if this and our mother's collection should be regarded as a
whole?" The designation of 'Mrs Robert Gray Collection, 19.'^7" adopted to record this
donation delighted the family and satisfied the needs of curation.

The Sedgwick Museum, Cambridge also received various smaller donations from the
Gray Collection, as a result of Reed's publication of the descriptions of particular
groups^'. Further donations were made later by Alice Gray c. 1937-38 as Reed produced
other papers based on subsequent material (see Alice Gray's correspondence: Reed, 13
January 1938 Mss list) and this donation has been recorded in the literature as 'Coll'n.
the Misses Gray" (see letter 14 February 1938)^".

After the death of Alice Gray in Febuary 1942, Edith her surviving sister, wrote to
both Dr Lang and W. N. Edwards (4 August 1942) informing them of a further quantity
of material 'the results of their collection from time to time" that needed to be added to
the Gray Collection. Its despatch to London had to be left until the termination of the
Second World War when transport was more readily available. Unfortunately, Edith
Gray also died during this period and it was only through the astuteness of her solicitors
that the last phase of the Gray Collection was obtained by the BMNH^''. When the
premises at George Street had to be vacated quickly, the BMNH sought the assistance of
the Geological Survey staff in Edinburgh to pack and arrange the storage of this
material. Although this was achieved by April 1945, the matter was only finally resolved
at the end of June owing to a disagreement with the Survey by W. N. Edwards over the
wording of the bill, which mentioned the assistance and services of a firm of carriers and
cabinet-makers, to carry out the transfer.

7. THE GIRVAN FAUNA

(i) The Ordovician Age in relation to the Girvan fauna

The majority of the specimens in the Gray Collection are from a thick sequence of
Ordovician rocks occurring in the Girvan area, which are part of a chain of Palaeozoic
inliers stretching along the Midland Valley from Edinburgh to the coast. The basic
stratigraphical succession of the Girvan 'shelly faunas' was worked out with precise
geological mapping and palaeontological observation by Charles Lapworth (1882). He
used graptolitcs as biostratigraphic indicators, a method he had introduced when dealing
with the 'Moffat Series' (1878) for correlating the two sequences and recognised that an
immense thickness of rocks was present at Cjirvan, in contrast to that in the Southern
Uplands. Although his succession has been refined, it had never been seriously
questioned (Clarkson, /W.5: 4), but an alternative explanation for the structure present
in the latter area has now been established. Harper (1982/), 1984) has provided a revised
interpretation of the stratigraphy of the Upper Ordovician Girvan sequence and shown
that it is of late Caradoc (Onnian) to late Ashgillian (Hirnantian) in age.

The Ordovician Period is remarkable in earth history for a number of important
reasons (Jaanusson, 1984). Its most distinctive feature was the extent of the epicontinental
seas which covered a greater area of the globe than in any other geological period, with
the land areas mainly represented by small archipelagos rather than continents.

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY 211

Consequently, the supply of terrigenous material was very low and this favoured the
wide deposition of carbonate sediments suitable for marine organisms.

The period is also marked by considerable changes in both flora and fauna, particularly
in the composition of its marine faunas. One reason for this is that a number of major
invertebrate groups appear, become common, or more diverse for the first time. Among
the most important benthic groups are the slromatoporoids, corals, cystids, crinoids and
echinoids, although the bivalves and caphalopods also show significant changes — and of
even more significance, the planktic graptolites. Jaanusson emphasized that important
effects were produced amongst the skeleton-bearing associations and assemblages
resulting in the establishment of the characteristic Palaeozoic biotic organisation of the
epifauna. However, he also pointed out that the full explanation for many relationships
has not been established, owing to the difficulty of distinquishing between ecological and
geographical factors. The Ordovician is also characterised by extreme biogeographical
differentiation in its marine faunas, which occurs to a greater degree in the benthic
elements. Tlie classification and correlation of Ordovician deposits is further complicated,
since the benthic and planktic faunas are often not contemporaneous, features which
have led Jaanusson to conclude that it is, perhaps, the most confused of all periods.

Fortey (1984) by examining global Ordovician transgressions and regressions has
provided explanations for several of these aspects. Using a series of biogeographical
models to demonstrate the occurrence of trilobite and graptolite biofacies he showed that
the faunal changes that had occurred were as much the result of 'environmental shift as
of evolutionary novelty'. He also indicated that 'ancestral faunas" had often been over-
looked owing to the scarcity of the preservation of the relevant facies, but that these were
available in the correct situations. Brenchley (1984) has outlined the possible causes of
the significant Late Ordovician extinctions in many invertebrate families, genera and
species. He pointed out that the earliest phase affected the deep-shelf Trilobite —
Cystoid — Gastropod faunas that had already been displaced over the shelf edge by the
initial phase of falling sea-level. Many groups show a sharp decrease in numbers and the
gradual depletion of species richness in Trilobites, Brachiopods and Gastropods towards
the Ordovician — Silurian boundary had been demonstrated by Williams & Wright
(1981). Such changes were attributed to a drastic decrease in habitable area as a result of
successive changes in sea level, which resulted from the growth and decay of the
Gondwana ice cap. Associated changes in salinity and ocean temperature may have also
caused extinction in planktic faunas.

The historic Gray Collection, with its relatively well-localised Ordovician material has
considerable significance in resolving some of these questions of spatial distribution.
Although several Ordovician specialists have collected better and more reliably-zoned
specimens (see Harper, 1984: 12) the taxonomic importance of Mrs Gray specimens is
fundamental to their identifying such material. In addition, several of her sites are no
longer available, having been worked out, or even lost. Jaanusson concluded (p. 3) that a
solid taxonomic framework is a necessary foundation before stratigraphical, ecological,
or palaeogeographical conclusions can be made.

Ingham (1978) and others'"" have described the general palaeogeographical setting as
that of a proximal fore-arc basin occurring on the northwestern margin of the Palaeozoic
lapetus ocean. But Curry et a! (1984) have emphasized (quoting Dewey, 1982):

plate tectonism operates on such a vast scale that It becomes extremely difficult to deal
meaningfully with relatively minute Held phenomena

The Girvan succession has been interpreted as recording the development of two fan-
delta systems (Ince, 1984) with the Stinchar Limestone being a shallow marine fan-delta
abandonment facies. On the basis of such research, Clarkson (1985) summarised the

212 R. J. CLEEVF.I.Y. R. P. TRIPP ANDY. HOWFLUS

current picture of the Girvan Ordovician as an area of subsidence, in which the
sedimentation was controlled by a series of moving large strike faults. Several giant
alluvial submarine fans contributed sediment from the North and this spilled over the
edges of the fault-bounded shelves. As this model was based on palaeontological
research and biostratigraphy, it demonstrates the effective contribution that these
disciplines can still make to good geology.

(ii) The Silurian Rocks of the Girvan Area

By L. R. M. Cocks

(a) Summary of Silurian Stratigraphy

Silurian rocks occur in two main areas north and south of the Girvan valley, which is
occupied by Upper Palaeozoic rocks. These formations are nearly 30()()m thick and were
chiefly deposited in a turbidite environment. The initial indifferent work of the early
nineteenth-century geologists, including Murchison (1851), and Lapworth's classic work
(1882) was superceded by a revision carried out by the Geological Survey (Peach &
Home, 1899). This largely confirmed Lapworth's results and was reliable for the next
seventy years. However, at the end of that period it became clear from studies of Silurian
rocks in the Welsh Borderland and elsewhere, that the succession in the Girvan region
needed to be revised and that many of the stratigraphical formations devised by
Lapworth needed adjustment to modern standards. Thus the area was re-mapped, and
further fossils collected by Cocks and Toghill (1973), who devised a new stratigraphy,
made fresh correlations from their results, but endeavoured to conserve much of
Lapworth's terminology.

Cocks & Toghill found that the Silurian rocks were confined to the Llandovery, apart
from the very highest beds in the Knockgardner area which are of basal Wenlock age.
They established three separate stratigraphical successions (ibid, t.-figs. 8 & 9):

1. the Coastal region;

2. the Main Outcrop (which runs from Saugh Hill to Straiton); and

3. the Craig Head Inlier.

1. On the coast, south-west of Girvan there are two areas: The Haven (Shalloch Forge)
and Woodland Point. At these, the Craigskelly Conglomerate unconformably overlies
the Ordovician Shalloch Formation of Middle Ashgill age, and that conglomerate is
succeeded by the Woodland Formation, which in turn is overlain by the coarse turbidites
of the Scart Grits. The Woodland Formation yields abundant late Rhuddanian brachio-
pods, including Stricklandia lens lens, which are overlain by graptolites of the cyphus
Zone.

2. In the Main Outcrop all the beds are steeply inclined and often inverted, while they
underlie the older Ordovician rocks to the South, lliere is also a strong unconformity, but
with no conglomerate and only rare shells in the beds overlying it. The lowest Silurian
beds are the dark mudstones of the Tralorg Formation, which also yield cyphus Zone
graptolites. These are followed by the turbiditic Saugh Hill Grits and then the Pcncleuch
Shale yielding convolutus Zone graptolites of Aeronian age. These are overlain by
another unconformity, followed by the transgressive beds of the Lower Camregan Cirits
that contain a shelly-fauna, which includes the stratigraphically important rhynchonellide
Eocoelia curtisi in abundance; and then the deeper water, but still shell-bearing
mudstones of the Wood Bum Formation. A series of shales and turbidites, named in
succession as: Maxwellston Mudstones, Upper Camregan Grits, Penkill Formation,
Protovirgularia Grits, Lauchlan Formation, Drumyork Formation, and Blair Shale.
Successively, each of these yield graptolites that represent the complete Telychian

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY 213

sequence of turriculatus . crispus, griestoniensis and cremdata Zones, but with no shelly
faunas. After this there is a regressive sequence commencing with the conformable beds
of the Knockgardner Formation that yield basal Wenlock shelly faunas. The overlying
Straiton Grits carry a few ostracods and bivalves interbedded with 'Old Red Sandstone'
facies of presumably Wenlock age, representing the marine regression seen in other
inliers in the Midland Valley of Scotland. These Grits occur immediately below the
substantial unconformity overlain by the true Old Red Sandstone of Middle Devonian
age.

3. The Craighead Inlier is an assymmetrical anticline with a core of Ordovician rocks and
is completely surrounded by Old Red Sandstone and Carboniferous formations.
Lapworth (ibid) formulated the successsion of this inlier; Lamont (1935) augmented and
divided some of these terms; while Freshney (1959) replaced the latter's names for the
divided Mulloch Hill Sandstone and indicated that the inlier extended further to the
northeast. In ascending order, the basal Silurian unit — The Lady Burn Conglomerate —
rests on different Ordovician formations at different localities and only one of these
junctions is well exposed (C. & T., 1973: 213) with an unconformity being postulated for
the other. This massive conglomerate contains sandy lenses that can be fossiliferous with
a low diversity Cryptothyrella community (of Rhuddanian age) and sediments that
indicate deposition in shallow water. The successive Mulloch Hill Formation is the most
fossiliferous unit of the inlier and consists of green 'Rough Neuk" and buff Craigens'
sandstones, which are interbedded with each other. The faunas represent shallow water
to mid-shelf communities. However, near the top a quite different and richer fauna,
identified as a Clorinda community, suggests deposition at greater depths and is a
prelude to those occurring above. The succeeding laminated light and dark units of the
Glenwells Shale contain a graptolite fauna indicating the upper cyphus Zone. This is
overlain by the easily mappable, unfossiliferous, coarse and poorly sorted Glenwells
Conglomerate. The Newlands Formation, with its diverse fossil assemblages of Slrick-
landia and Clorinda communities, comprises the only shelly Middle Llandovery in the
whole of Scotland and was possibly deposited upon the deeper part of the shelf. The soft
thinly bedded shales of the Glenshalloch Shale have yielded well preserved graptolite
faunas at some localities of gregarius Zone age with two different Subzones. The Upper
Saugh Hill Grits comprise massive greyish-green turbidites, mostly coarse-grained and
unfossiliferous. The limited exposure of the overlying Pencleuch Shale has yielded a
graptolite fauna typical of the upper convolutus Zone, but which may be close to the
faunal boundary. Similarly, exposure of the Lower Camregan Grits is poor, but elements
from both Eocoelia and Pentamerus communities have been obtained from different
localities.

(b) The value of the Gray Collection

The Girvan fossils were known long before the Gray family came to prominence, but by
the time that Lapworth wrote his paper, their collection numbered 'between 20,000 and
30,000 specimens^ (Lapworth, 1882: 551) and has formed the basis for many palaeonto-
logical papers both beforehand and afterwards. However, the main disadvantage to
subsequent users is that the Gray collection is very biased towards the shelly fossils; there
are very few graptolites despite Lapworth's utilisation of such fossils and that 14 of the 23
Silurian formations commonly have graptolites. This is also in contrast to the greater
thickness of graptolite-bearing rocks occurring in the sequences of the Girvan area,
which amount to more than ten times the thickness of the shell-bearing formations. It
would appear that the Gray family were more interested in fossils that they could easily
recognise and preferred to work at a relatively small number of localities where they
could be sure to obtain them. This is borne out by the collections in the BMNH, for there

214 R.J. CLEEVELY. R. P. TRIPP AND Y. HOWELLS

are 23 closely-packed drawers of brachiopods collected from the Llandovery locality of
Woodland Point, but other equally rich localities are either entirely absent in the Gray
Collection, or merely represented by a handful of specimens. Nevertheless, the assiduity
of the Gray family meant that nineteenth-century palaeontologists had a valuable pool of
first-rate specimens available for their research. In turn these monographs were
extremely influential in making "Girvan" an international byword as a source of Lower
Palaeozoic invertebrate fossils.

(iii) Interpretation of the Girvan Fauna

In a presidential address, Robert Etheridge (1881) when emphasizing the importance of
fossils in interpreting the Palaeozoic rocks of Scotland, mentioned (p. 6) that the first
record of material from the Girvan strata was a short list provided by Professor Nicol
(1844)^'^. Apparently, Sedgwick had only briefly visited the district during his tour of
1841 and was not able to collect any material until a later visit in 1848^''. M'Coy described
this in a series of papers (1851-52), that must be regarded as containing the first
descriptions of Girvan fossils^^. These, together with others were subsequently included
in their joint publication on British Palaeozoic Fossils (1851-1855)™; Etheridge esti-
mated that thirty-four species were from the Girvan area. J. W. Salter^**, was another
responsible for the early description of Girvan fossils, his first contribution being
appended as a list to Murchison's memoir on the Silurian of southern Scotland ( 1 855 )'"".
These fossils had been obtained by Murchison in 1850 with the assistance of Alexander
MacCallum, a local weaver, who is said to have been the first person to collect fossils
from the area (ibid p. 9) and to have acted as a guide for all visiting geologists. Salter
described thirty-seven species some of which provided the first indication of the link
between the Girvan and North American faunas. More recent descriptive work has led
to the correlation of the dominant phylla in these Scottish faunas with those found in
North America. In particular, it has shown that the brachiopods had 'little in common
with Caradoc faunas found elsewhere in Britain and Europe" but that their Girvan
sequence is recognisable in the Mohawk stages of the southern Appalachians (Williams,
1962: 62).

Harper (1979) has established the faunal associations that occur throughout the Girvan
sequence and shown that brachiopods are frequently numerically dominant in many of
these. Trilobites occasionally dominate several of the associations found in the Upper
Whitehouse Group e.g. the 'Foliomena fauna' (ibid.: 440) and graptolites provide
adequate stratigraphical correlation. The later Drummock Group has a great many
distinctive faunal associations and in its upper part contains the very diverse and
abundant faunas of the Lady Burn Starfish Beds (Lamont, 1^35; also provided lists of the
fauna).

The majority of the earlier faunal studies were based upon the large collections
accumulated by Mrs Gray and the Misses Gray: John Smith of Dairy; and James Bcgg of
Glasgow. As these descriptions were produced by palaeontologists, who were strictly
museum specialists and who neither had the opportunity, or often the inclination to
conduct fieldwork"^', their results inevitably contained errors arising from confusion over
fossil relationships and occurrences. F. R. C. Reed, in particular, treated material from a
number of localities together and created a false homogeneity within his faunas and taxa
(see Harper, 1984: 22, for example of /,. mediostriata) . It is only with modern collecting
techniques ensuring precise stratigraphical provenance and descriptions based on the
numerical analysis of the fossils in certain groups (brachiopods, trilobites, cystoids and
graptolites) that their mistakes have been rectified. A cursory examination of the range
of the fauna's descriptive literature suggests that it was produced in three periods. An
"exploratory phase' arising from the work of Murchison, Sedgwick and others; then a

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY 215

more sustained 'accumulative' phase (c . 1870-1924) prompted by Mrs Gray's collecting
activities and her concern for the description of the material by experts to reveal the
number of 'new species" present, which then extended into a second stage (c. 1930-46)
partly as the result of the continued activity of the Misses Gray, but also from the interest
of other keen collectors such as Begg and Lament; and finally the present one (1956-84)
that might be termed the "authoritative, or interpretative' phase arising from the active
interest of a wide range of palaeontological and stratigraphical specialists investigating all
aspects of Ordovician invertebrate faunas [Harper, 1982/): 253-4, has summarised all
work on the Girvan fauna]**".

Understandably the numerically abundant brachiopods have been dealt with most
completely and provided much of our knowledge of these faunas. Ordovician brachiopod
workers have made considerable progress in revising the systematics of earlier workers
(Cocks, 1978); in addition, others have also interpreted the ecological associations and
environments in which the Girvan species lived (Harper, 1979, 1984); and their
stratigraphy (Cocks & Toghill, 1973). Williams (1962) used brachiopods as a further
stratigraphic key to unravel the structure of the area, since many of the species are
identical to those occurring in the undeformed platform carbonates of eastern North
America, where the succession is well-defined. Harper (1979, 1984) has also worked on
the formations of the Ardmillan succession, which form the sequence from which most
of Mrs Gray's fossils were collected and has shown that very few of the fossils occur in
indigenous situations. The changing composition and structure of these brachiopod
associations reflected an essentially unstable environment. He suggested (1979: 443) that
the predominantly common association of small dalmanellids and plectambonitaceans
occurred on an unstable offshore continental slope and as a possible site. Harper
envisaged a constantly changing submarine fan in relatively deep water. The damaged
condition of the majority of these brachiopods, which include individuals from both
presumed shelf and slope communities, indicated they had undergone transport from
their original site and the lack of juvenile forms tended to confirm this view.

Initially, the trilobites were dealt with by Nicholson & Etheridge in their general
description of the Girvan fauna. Reed (1903-35) subsequently revised and described
them more completely and apart from Howell's full treatment of all the Silurian species
(1982), the current approach has been for specialists to deal with particular families
(Whittington, 1950; Lane, 1971; Owens, 1973) after supplementing original material by
making personal collections. However, various authors (Tripp; Ingham; Hughes el al)
have examined other aspects of the Girvan trilobites.

In comparison with the other groups, the relatively rich British Ordovician fauna of
primitive echinoderms has been considered to be poorly known. One reason for this is
the rapid disarticulation of such animals after death (Donovan, 1986: 1) and Smith and
Paul (1982: 604) have indicated the relevant rate of this disassociation in the enigmatic
cyclocystoids. Without being suddenly overwhelmed and pinioned by debris, or sedi-
ment, the weak compound skeletal elements of echinodermata would soon begin to
separate as their skeleton disintegrates very rapidly after death. Goldring & Stephenson
(1972) in their discussion of the preservation of ophiuroids and echinoderms indicated
that the only chance for their fossilisation was instantaneous burial by slumped
sediment**'. Their conclusion that the Girvan Starfish Bed fossils had resulted from such
rapid entombment in a turbulent, shallow water environment was modified by Harper
(1982a: .30) to burial during sudden downslope movement of both sediment and fauna.

In part, the apparent abundance of primitive echinoderms can be explained by the
explosive radiation of echinoderm classes that occurred during the Lower Palaeozoic.
Paul (1973: 1; 1984) in his monograph of the British Ordovician Cystoids stated that it
was one of the richest cystoid faunas in the world, . . . and was the result of migration
from three separate faunal provinces into the area. He listed eleven taxa from Girvan

216

.?^==^-.

/;^"\~%

R. J. CLEEVELY, R. P. TRIPP AND Y. HOWELLS

4 ^/v/F

Echinodermata found in the Starfish Bed, Lady Burn.

1 . 5 & 6 Pleurocystis quadrata Bather

1 & 6: Part & counterpart of original specimen E 23298b x 1 ;
5: Latex pull from specimen x 1 ; Mrs. R. Gray CoH'n.. 1920.

2. Aulechinus grayae MacBridgc & Spencer. E 405522a x 1; Coll'd. Alice Gray. 1934.

3. Dendrocystis scolicus (Bather). A latex pull from E 237(X) x 1; Pres'd. Misses Gray, 1937.

4. Cnemidaclis girvanensis (Schuchert). E 5.3835 x 1; Purch'd. from Mrs R. Gray, 1920.
7. Cothurnocystis elizae Bather. E 23702b x 1 approx.

localities (p. 76) and suggested (p. 121) that ideal conditions for pleurocystids apparently
prevailed duinng Starfish Bed times, since three species are recognised; and their
preservation indicated that they were buried alive by a sudden influx of sediment.

Despite Bather's predominant interest in the Crinoidea, he made very little contribu-
tion to knowledge of the Girvan crinoids. Prior to Ramsbottom's monograph (1961).
only one of the five described Ordovician crinoids had been recorded from Girvan''^; he
increased the number of known species to twenty-three, with twelve of these being found
at Girvan'*''. Ramsbottom questioned the occurrence and identity of the material
previously described by Nicholson and Etheridge (1880) and Bather (1896); and in

Cothurnocystis elizae Bather.

1. Origmal' specimen BMNH E 23702b x

approx.. presented by 'The Misses Gray' in June 1937.

2. A latex impression taken from the original x 1.

3. Another Gray specimen depicted in a rough sketch showing Bather's interpretation (letter 16
January 1899):

The specimen . . . though so imperfect as to he scarcely recognisable . . . is, I think, different
from any previously described. But is hardly good enough to give a name. . . . We have no
British specimens . . . in this Museum !

4. Latex pull from E 23172 x 1, showing the fine detail that is preserved in some specimens.

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY

217

218 R. J. CLEEVELY, R. P. TRIPP AND Y. HOWELLS

recognising (p. Ill) that the latter had misinterpreted crinoid features incorrectly as a
result of the imperfect techniques available to him for dealing with difficult material, may
have given a reason for Bather's limited results. Later. Strimple (1972) and Donovan
(1983) made further nomenclatorial revisions and increased the number of crinoid
species (Brewer, 1974; Donovan, In Press) to thirty. Paul (1965) had earlier described
the only record of the class Paracrinoidea from Britain. Spencer's work on the Palaeozoic
starfishes is discussed elsewhere (p. 188).

The most significant element in the Girvan echinoderm fauna must be the specimens of
'carpoids' that Jefferies (1968, 1986) has now convincingly interpreted as calcichordates**.
These strange fossils, traditionally regarded as primitive echinoderms, were in fact
chordates, an idea that had first been postulated by Gislen in 1930. They have many
chordate, and sometimes vertebrate, characteristics, but they also possess certain
echinoderm-like features. The detailed analyses of these fossils by Jefferies et al are
based upon functional explanations for virtually all their anatomical features, particularly
their internal anatomy, and establish that they were ancestral to all modern chordates
including the vertebrates. Alternative theories on these "carpoid' groups (the solutes,
mitrates. cornutes) recognising them as echinoderms, founder on several aspects of
functional interpretation and always lack vital structures. The two cornutes Cothurno-
cystis elizae and Scoliaecystis curvata, both described by Bather from the Gray collection,
had an important role in the investigation, which led to the new theory and has solved
one of the problems of classical zoology. In his original paper, in fact. Bather too,
considered that Cothurnocystis might be a chordate, but rejected the idea (1913: 417).

Bather's paper has been recognised as an enormous advance in the knowledge of these
bizarre-looking fossils. Both he and the Gray family independently referred to Cothurno-
cystis elizae as 'the boot' (see letters 7 & 8 November 1911). The following year, in
recognition of her contribution. Bather named the species after Mrs Gray and decided to
use the form elizae because it made a 'pleasant sounding combination"**^. Jefferies
(1986), in his detailed and readable explanation, described this species as 'one of the
strangest-looking animals that ever existed' and acknowledged its companion cornute to
be a more specialized form (p. 207). We wonder just how Elizabeth Gray would regard
the first comment and the fact that Bather named such a creature after her! Perhaps, the
final sentence in that book would have convinced her that the effort was worthwhile, for
together with his predecessors. Jefferies acknowledges that 'the nub of the whole matter
is the extraordinary group of fossils called calcichordates'. Although the two Girvan
species do not occupy vital positions in the cladogram of the Dexiothetica, the
investigation of their features had a major part in the development of this research and
led to the development of new investigative techniques. That alone, we feel would have
pleased her, but the realisation that her beloved 'cystid' material**'' provided two British
scientists with a significant part of their life's work [she was somewhat patriotic!) and had
a substantial part in the development of a new theory, would we suspect, in Mrs Gray's
view, have been a reward equivalent to her recognition by the Geological Society in
1903.

It would appear that apart from the less numerically abundant elements of the faunas
e.g. sponges, conularids (see Slater, 1907). hyolithids etc. only the various classes of
mollusca have received less attention than they deserve, with the bivalves faring worst of
all; although treatment of the newly recognised classes of the monoplacophorans and
rostroconchs is equally poor**''. In many respects, aside from problems of preservation
(which can be overcome), this is due to the practice within molluscan taxonomy of
describing material on a zoological rather than a faunal, or siratigraphic approach'"'.

The 'strange-stalked forms' that initially were referred to as Cirripedia attracted the
interest of Woodward (1880); Bather ('see letters & 1926: vi); Reed (1901); and
ultimately after the Gray Colin, had been acquired by the BMNII, Withers (1922), who

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY 219

recognised their distinctive characters and estabhshed the Group Machaeridia (1926) to
accommodate them.

(iv) The Starfish Bed, Lady Burn

In a postscript of a letter to Professor Lapworth, Mrs Gray mentioned her 'discovery' of
the now famous Starfish Bed at Lady Burn (20 November 1898). A subsequent and much
later note by Alice Gray'" indicates the importance that the family attached to this
discovery, for the Grays were under the impression that their site was not the Starfish
band. West of Quarrel Hill described by Lapworth (1882: 619, fig. 21). This was thought
to have been in an old quarry, for which the family had searched in vain. However,
although Lapworth referred to a fossiliferous sandstone being found in an old quarry,
there is no precise evidence that he encountered these rocks in situ (see Harper, 1982a:
30), but merely correlated that bed with the similar sandstone occurring beneath the
waterfall at the head of the Lady Burn. In fact, in his letter to Mrs Gray, Lapworth
confirmed that his best specimens had been obtained from walls in the neighbourhood of
Quarrel Hill. In the Gray's opinion, Lapworth never saw their 'new' Starfish Bed.
However, we consider that this is a slight misapprehension and agree with Harper (ibid)
that the Gray's re-discovered the Starfish Bed and were probably the first to collect such
material in situ. The general photograph of Mrs Gray at the Starfish Bed locality [Fig. 2,
p. 176) shows a considerable exposure of rock, with the Starfish Bed near the piece of
newspaper at the top. The Starfish Bed is the hardest rock available for repairing a
drystone dyke and it is very likely that it would have been quarried here.

Lapworth's short faunal list is in accordance with the belief that only one Starfish Bed
locality is involved. However, Harper endeavoured to establish the occurrence of the
Bed at its type locality over several years and in 1978 successfully located three
fossiliferous sandstone beds, which in part substantiated Begg's documentation (1946) of
several fossiliferous units at this classic site. Harper concluded (1982a: 31) that the lowest
bed corresponded with the original Starfish Bed as its lithology and fauna was virtually
identical with material in museum collections. The excellence of preservation at all three
levels was unusual with most of the fossils being complete and breakage, or wear almost
negligible. He concluded that each bed had been deposited in slightly different
conditions on the indications of their faunal composition and agreed in part with the
opinions of Goldring and Stephenson (1972) but felt that there was no strong evidence to
deny that rapid entombment of the fossils followed sudden downslope movement.

Examination of current faunal lists reveals that a wealth of new invertebrate forms
have been described from this Bed since Mrs Gray provided Nicholson & Etheridge with
two new Star-fish (1879: 318)"". Collecting proceeded rapidly and her correspondence
with Bather and other palaeontologists continued in earnest to ensure that the exception-
ally large collections resulting from the relentless activity of the Gray family at this
locality were dealt with. [Gregory originally undertook to deal with the interesting
starfish and Bather requested the crinoids]. She herself expressed amazement in a letter
to Bather (12 March 1914): "I seem to have sent [you] an astonishing number of
specimens from the small Starfish bed.'

James Begg, a local property agent, magistrate and a renowned amateur fossil
collector, has related how the Grays regularly covered up the exposure of the Starfish
bed with rubble before they left the site each day, in an effort to conceal the exposure
from others. Begg obtained the assistance of a local poacher (and part-time miner) Tom
Mactaggart, who lived close by at New Dailly, to enable him to discover the site of the
bed and reach it at an un-worked level six feet deeper than the area cleared by the Gray
family.

The Starfish Bed at Threave Glen (NS 250037), now included in the Upper Drummuck

220

R. J. CLEEVELY, R. P. TRIPP ANI1Y. HOWELLS

^A:

,:".>^'

■r.i:*- •^^L^rkn:ii^^ -Tff

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY 221

Group is considered to be of Rawtheyan age (Williams el al, 1972). It has proved to be
the most productive locality in the Girvan District and this importance has led to its
registration as a site of Special Scientific Importance. Yet, information on the fauna is
insufficient to permit a succinct appraisal; trilobites are particularly abundant and
together with brachiopods numerically dominate the fauna, but bellerophontids may
locally dominate the rich shelly fauna (Harper, ihici: 32). Regrettably, in common with
much of the other molluscan material in the Gray Collection, these taxa need further
systematic treatment.

8. CONCLUSIONS

The importance of the Girvan fossils for understanding Ordovician geology and the
evolution of many invertebrate phyla, in addition to other palaeontological aspects, is
widely accepted. Yet. the significance of the Girvan material would certainly not have
been apparent at the time Mrs Gray began to collect. Why did she collect? It would be
interesting, at the very least, to know the answer to that question. We suspect that she
had several reasons and that these changed and developed over the years. Unfortunately, as
no member of the Gray family kept a journal, and their surviving correspondence is
essentially concerned with practical matters concerning the use of the collection, these
cannot be verified. Occasional glimpses of Mrs Gray's attitude can be obtained from
terse comments in her letters to Bather, or Davidson. While the much later accounts of
the family's activities over the years, provided by Alice Gray, yield more tangible
evidence.

In part, Mrs Gray's fossil collecting probably arose from her father's interest in local
natural history; her own activities certainly increased after meeting Robert Gray another
naturalist, but it is difficult to avoid the assumption that initially there would probably
have been no real purpose to their collecting, other than providing themselves with a
pleasant pastime. Many years later she acknowledged that such collecting had given her
'lifelong pleasure'.

The Gray family were fortunate, firstly, in that their collecting interest coincided with
[and possibly stemmed from?] the establishment of the Natural History Society in
Glasgow. Then, secondly, through the encouragement of its Secretary, Mr John Young
and his contacts, their collection was utilised by Thomas Davidson. As a result, Mrs Gray
was immediately provided with a particular objective and could contribute to the
development of scientific knowledge. It would appear from the records that Davidson

Various Ordovician invertebrate fossils from localities near Girvan, Ayrshire in the Mrs Robert
Gray Collection purchased in 1920.

1. Bivalve: Cuneamya grandis (Hind, 1910). L 49886, internal mould x 1 (the external impressions
of both valves are also preserved); Upper Ordovician, Starfish Bed, Drummuck Group, Thraive
Glen.

2. Gastropod: 'Loxonema' grayuimtm (t.ongstaff). Holotypc G 43539 x 2; Mulloch Hill.

3. Brachiopod: Fardenia (Fardenia) columbana (Reed). Lcctotype B 72928, brachial valve, x 2
approx; Lwr. Llandovery, Mulloch Hill Quarry |= Rough Ncuk|.

4. Gastropod: Cyclonema crebrkostata. G 47843 X 1; Upper Ordovician. Whitehousc Gp..
Shalloch Mill ■

5. A biscrial Graptolitc: Orlhogruplus tninccUus var. inlermediiis. H 1915 x 2; Llandcilo, Lwr.

Ordovician, Pinmore Cutting. S.E. of Girvan.
6. Brachiopod: Fardenia (Saughina) pertmax (Reed). B 72948 x 1.5; Middle Llandovery,

Woodland Point.

222 R. J. CLEEVEl.Y. R. P. TRIPP AND Y. HOWELLS

kept of his correspondence thai he provided no particular direction to her collecting
activities, but dealt with whatever was found. However, anything that was thought to be
unusual or rare by either party, obviously led to particular use of Mrs Gray's 'good
discriminating eye" on her next foray!

The unusual circumstances, which enabled Davidson to concentrate on his brachiopod
research, possibly influenced Mrs Gray's understanding of the nature of such work. Sub-
sequently, when allowing her material to be used by specialists such as Bather, or Lapworth,
who had other tasks to perform, she frequently felt that they took an excessive amount of
time to complete their research. Her view was also influenced by the fact that two other
specialists, Mrs Longstaff and F. R. C. Reed, who also dealt with the Gray material, were
able to determine the use of their own time and returned the fossils they examined quickly.

Through her contact with the needs of these workers, and her continuing field
experience, Mrs Gray and the various members of her family were able to increase their
knowledge of the various fossils they collected. Lapworth's field work resolving the
Girvan succession undoubtedly provided her with useful experience and insight as to the
significance of 'her fossils' at an opportune moment. Subsequently, the long association
with Bather's work on various fossil echinodermata provided the necessary continuation
of purpose and contact, even though ultimately it may not have been particularly
productive for either party with regard to their original objectives. However, this
particular link provided the majority of the other specialists who worked upon Mrs
Gray's material and probably led to the acquisition of her third and major collection by
the British Museum (Natural History).

In our view, the reasons that Mrs Gray and eventually her daughters collected the
Girvan fossils, developed over the years. As discussed above, Mrs Gray initially took an
interest partly through a family background of local natural history and the fact that it
gave her an interesting occupation. Indeed, there is no real indication as to the necessity
of her becoming involved in the more practical duties of house-keeping, or whether she
was able to avoid such tasks by her fossil collecting activities''''. Once becoming involved
in assisting specialists, an interest and awareness of the nature of fossil species led to
objectives of extending faunal lists, discovering new species and'''' establishing occurrences.
Her letters to Woodward (20 May 1914; 21 February 1920) emphasize the number of
different species, new species, rare species, and larger, or finer specimens present in the
Gray collection.

Eventually having acquired the necessary practical, technical, collecting and storing
skills their material became extremely useful and unique. Ultimately, as Alice Gray
recounted, the annual summer visits to relatives at Girvan were customarily spent
collecting fossils — it had become a family tradition! There is even a suggestion that it
had even become compulsive — almost an addiction — for immediately after each of the
Gray collections had been disposed of another was begun.

Apart from her interest in fossils, we have little real knowledge of Mrs Gray's life.
There is no information on the style in which the family lived; whether she had to carry
out the normal tasks involved in bringing them up, or whether many of these duties were
achieved by servants? The factual letters that survive provide no indication of other
interests, or her opinions on events of the period. Although the difficulties the Gray
family experienced during the Great War are briefly mentioned, these are relatively
minor and there is no reference to the more significant events of those years and their
consequences. The single surviving draft of a letter to another member of the Gray
family in Australia'*'' reveals that Elizabeth Gray was delighted to receive letters herself,
but that: 'I always seem to find something to do — or take a rest! ' and seldom wrote any
herself. Even much of that letter is concerned with the Gray Collection and her obituary
notice apparently confirms that all her leisure time, consistent with her limited domestic
duties, was spent in dealing with her fossils.

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY 223

At an early stage, Mrs Gray decided that she did not wish to acquire the necessary
scientific knowledge to describe some of her own fossil material, but felt that her best
role was to provide specimens for others*. However, her curiosity frequently compelled
her to seek advice, or references to fossil organisms to improve her understanding" and
on a few occasions to visit museums in order to examine comparative material*^**. At one
time she even enquired as to the possibility of borrowing specimens from the Barrande
collection herself. Several of her letters to Bather indicate that she had acquired
considerable knowledge concerning the relationships of her material and could under-
stand the problems they presented and realised the significance of slight differences in
ornament and size""'. It would also appear that Mrs Gray had an awareness of
brachiopod variability for many of the forms that she sent to Davidson have now
been recognised as belonging to several different species and her original queries
vindicated™'.

\
\

Part & counterpart examples of 'Lophosjnra ihraivensis Longstaff from the Starfish Bed. Thrcave
Glen, Girvan, Ayrshire, in the Gray Collection, 1920.

1. Block with External mould, G 25404 x 2.5;

3. its counterpart internal mould;

2. Another external mould, G 25407 x 2;

4. a latex pull taken from this mould showing shape and ornament of the shell, x 2.

224 R. J. CLEEVELY, R. P. TRIPP AND Y. HOWELLS

In common with the layman. Mrs Gray had little real idea of the technical skills
•needed to deal with her material, or the time that such preparation required: or the
difficulties involved in the illustration of such material. The inadequacy of the materials
and equipment available at that period'"" were another factor — this is indicated by the
subsequent re-interpretation of many Girvan taxa when techniques improved'"^.
Although her letters indicate some awareness of these problems, the initial objective of
having her material identified, ultimately became something of an obsession, and
influenced her relationships with the users of the collection. In later life. Mrs Gray
understandably became even more concerned to see the results of "her lifetimes work'
and was particularly exasperated that some of the earliest projects — those begun by
Bather on the crinoids and starfish — were not completed. Her fixation leading to her
comment (28 November 1912): 'surely you have no other material with a prior claim to
mine", is excusable in view of her considerable anxiety expressed in a later letter
(18 March 1913). According to Alice Gray (5 December 1937) the only letters of a
forceful nature that Mrs Gray ever wrote, were those to Bather on this subject of 'her
cystids and crinoids'. and some others concerning the 'mis-use" of brachiopods from her
collection by O. T. Jones without her sanction.

Although Mrs Gray undoubtedly obtained her main pleasure from the completion of
work on material in her collection, she always professed to enjoy being of 'service to
many geologists". However her constant assertion as to ownership of the fossils, suggests
that she did not fully ascribe to the view of other more philanthropic collectors, who
recognised that their specimens really belonged to science, (see letters from
W. R. Billings to Bather during the same period)"". Perhaps, it should also be asked
whether it is right for one individual to occupy all the attentions of the few available
specialist workers in a particular science at the same time? particularly as the object was
as much for her own satisfaction as the benefit to science. Still in mitigation, it has to be
acknowledged that Mrs Gray determinedly set out to ensure that the material should
ultimately be available in the principal insitutions holding similar palaeontological
collections.

Throughout her life. Mrs Gray appears to have had a close involvement with her
fossils, they are always referred to as 'my' specimens'"'", several had pet names and she
undoubtedly worried about them when they were away on loan and always insisted that
everything should be returned to her. It would have been difficult for her to insist on the
return of type and figured specimens to-day, for the ICZN Recommendation on type
specimens is that they should be lodged in a recognised Research institution. The extent
of her personal concern was demonstrated by an incident that occurred during the 1st
World War, when:

During a Zeppelin raid on Edinburgh . . . wc spent most of the night in a bank on the
opposite side of George St. — as being a nnuch stronger building than the house wc
live in, which is one of the original houses and dates from 1790 — My mother put into
a large handbag as many of her very best Cystids as it would hold and sat with it on her
lap for 3 to 4 hours until the danger was past. She had some anxious moments during
the War'"^.

This trait became more accentuated as she grew older. It is possible thai this
possessiveness in the later years, may have reflected a realisation of the commercial value
of her collection. Mrs Gray had certainly understood the significance of her collection
when she first offered the trilobites to the BMNH in 1914 and the various users had
always commented on the unique contribution it had made to their scientific work. Later,
when the sale of the entire collection was negotiated in 1920, she was thinking in terms of
obtaining a reasonable return for all her years of collecting the material. However, once
the sum had been decided her attempt to have part paid to her daughters indicates that

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY 225

she also had their welfare in mind. This is confirmed by the Fund that was set up after
investing the money on their behalf.

Whatever her motives, and despite some understandable quirks, Mrs Elizabeth Gray's
devotion to discovering the fossil faunas of the Lower Palaeozoic rocks of the Girvan
District made a substantial contribution to British geology. Her determination to ensure
that the material was adequately described by the most competent persons available was
an even greater achievement. She completed the task she had undertaken by ensuring
that the various collections she had accumulated were safely housed in the most
reputable establishments in existence. Their value is exemplified by the comment of one
of to-day's specialists: 'Anyone wanting to work on Ordovician faunas is compelled to
use the Gray Collection!'

It is unlikely that Mrs Gray had set out to disprove the widely held belief of the early
part of the nineteenth-century that 'Scotland was . . . poor in organic remains''"^ , but she
certainly ensured that no one could ever assert so again! Her achievement is commemo-
rated by the many Palaeozoic fossils that either bear her own surname, or that of one of
the localities in the Girvan area, while Bather's use of elizae for the type species of the
bizarre cornute Cothurnocystis makes a more personal tribute to her zeal" .

9. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

Inevitably, in a collaborative study that has been pursued over several years, its authors
will have incurred obligations to many individuals for help, advice and information. Our
appreciation and gratitude is owed to many of our colleagues at the various institutions in
which we have worked, or whose resources we have used. We trust that they will accept
this general acknowledgement of their help for a complete list would only antagonise our
editors.

Among those who services deserve special mention are:

at the Sedgwick Museum, Cambridge, Professor H. Whittington. David Price and the
late A. G. 'Bertie' Brighton, who contributed details of material and the Cowper Reed
reminiscences;

Isles Strachan, Department of Geology, Birmingham University, who kindly investi-
gated the Lapworth papers and provided confirmation of material in the BMNH;

Ian Rolfe of the Royal Scottish Museum, Edinburgh for his encouragement and interest
in the project over the years, and who, together with Bill Baird, provided information on
Robert Gray and obtained illustrations of the George Street house; the use of this print
with the permission of the Office of Ancient Monuments is also gratefully acknowledged;

Daniella Shippey, Edinburgh, who carried out various aspects of the genealogical
research into the Gray and Anderson families on our behalf and has been awaiting this
paper to satisfy the interest that aroused;

Dr J. A. Gibson (Scottish Natural History Library) for discussing the value of Robert
Gray's contribution to Scottish ornithology; and finally,

Mr Ilgars Steins, ROM, Toronto for preparing the Girvan locality map.

226 R. J. CLEEVELY, R. P. TRIPP AND Y. HOWELLS

The usual generous assistance provided by the staff of various units in the British
Museum (Natural History) deserves more than customary recognition. We are particu-
larly indebted to those in the Palaeontology Library, who allowed us access to the Gray
family Archive held there; to friends in the Photographic Studio, who contended with
assorted whims over possible illustrations, and produced admirable results from poor
beginnings; while our fellow invertebrate palaeontologists, answered our Gray-related
questions and assisted with their own literature resources and field knowledge. From
these Dick Jefferies, is owed a greater debt, for he willingly commented on a later
version of the manuscript and augmented our knowledge of the bizarre groups collected
by Mrs Gray on which he is the acknowledged specialist; and equally the involvement of
Sam Morris with the work of each of us requires similar recognition. Finally, we must
express our thanks to Rex Banks, Editor of the Historical Series, who was prepared to
accommodate the paper from the first and quietly ensured its realisation and to the
Keeper of Palaeontology, Dr L. R. M. Cocks, without whose permission the project
could not have even begun, for his contribution and approval.

10. FOOTNOTES

1. INTRODUCTION

!. Letter from Alice Gray to Dr Bather (14 July 1932) concerning a biography of her mother:

Mr Balsillie required an account of her life rather than an appreciation of her work. The
family [therefore] were the most appropriate people to write such a notice.

2. Wilfred Norman Edwards (1890-1956). The first palaeobotanist to be appointed by BMNH
(1913). His career was interrupted by both World Wars, but in the interval Edwards organised
the extensive collection of fossil plant remains and gained an encyclopaedic knowledge of such
forms and their literature.

W. N. Edwards was appointed Deputy-Keeper in 1931 and had succeeded Dr W. D. Lang as
Keeper in 1938 — virtually the time his correspondence with Alice Gray began. His plans for
the reconstruction of the Museum's exhibition galleries were thwarted by the 2nd World War
and he was made responsible for the evacuation of all the collections. After 1945. he then had
to arrange for their return and the repair of the damage suffered by the buildings.

Other refs. see: //. Soc. Biblphy. Nai. Hist. 3: 231-237; Steam (1981: 241-2).

3. It is thought that financial reasons were partly the cause in the case of the first; and the Second
World War prevented completion of the later attempt as Edwards was made responsible for
the evacuation of the Museum's collections in 1941^2.

4. see W. N. Edwards / Alice Gray Correspondence:
WNE letters dated— 14/1 1/38; 31/5/40; 19/8/41 ; 7/9/41 .
AG letters— 21/1 1/38; 21/.5/4(); 2/6/40; 15/6/41 ; 24/8/4L

2. BIOGRAPHY

5. See letter from Alice Gray 14 July 1932 for reference to Mr Balsillic. |MSS (c.l938) in Gray
Correspondence, Palaeontology Library, BMNM).

6. Pinnacopora andersoni. Nicholson & Etheridge. 1K80: 273, pi. 17, fig. 6, from Woodland Point
named in 1880 after the late Mr Thomas Anderson of Girvan, who was well known to Scotch
geologists as having made extensive collections of the fossils of the Girvan area.'

7. Robert Gray (1826-1887). For biographical references see DNB, 23: 19; I'roc. Roy. Soc.
Edinburgh., 15: 1-5; Proc. nat. hist. Soc, Glasgow, 2 (N.S.) 1888: xxii-xxiii.

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY 227

8. Lectures to Ladies — Session 1 869: Introductory Lectures to the classes of English Literature &
Physical Geography given in the Corporation Rooms, Glasgow by John Nichol, BA and John
Young, MD. James MacLchose, Glasgow, 1869.

9. 59, George Street. This property is situated in the centre of the city in a street that was once
said to have no rival in the world' as its breadth (115 ft.), space and magnificent vista was
considered to be unparalleled'. During the 18th, 19th and early 20th centuries it was
considered to be a prime residential area and also contained the offices and principal premises
of Scotland's insurance and banking businesses, (see James Grant, 1880-3: p. 139 in Old and
New Edinburgh: Its History, its People, and its places. Cassell & Co. Ltd., Edinburgh, Vol. 2
384 pp.

A letter of Alice Gray (10 October 1938) mentions that it was one of the original houses and
probably dated from 1790. The first use of this as an address occurs on Mrs Gray's first letter to
Bather dated 5 October 1892. The solicitors of Miss Edith M. H. Gray sold the house
sometime during 1945; the Geol. Survey were able to gain access in March 1945 to pack the
remaining fossil material. The house is now occupied by the Dunfermline Building Society
(59a) and by T. & T. Clark, Publishers and the premises have obviously been considerably
altered to permit present usage.

10. The 1891 census return records Mary and Alice as artists, Elizabeth as a daily governess, Edith
as a teacher of music, and Robert as an electrical engineer's apprentice; there was also one
resident general domestic servant, Edinburgh-born aged 22.

3. THE GRAY COLLECTION

11. Robert Gray (letter 17 September 1865). Balcletchic, 100yds below Penwhapple bridge (Mrs
Gray has been there daily for months); Craighead quarry long exhausted; Penkill the spot
opened first by myself.

12. Davidson (12 September 1879) records a letter from Mrs Gray that offers a few brachiopods
that she had collected from Doularg Barr, a locality that she had not previously examined.

13. Number of localities listed in Lapworth = 23; by Mrs Gray = 32; and by Nicholson &
Ethcridge = 40, but only 19 of these were included in the lists of the two others.

14. These are in the Map Room of the Palaeontology Library in a large folio labelled "Maps of
Girvan District Showing the Localities at which Mrs Robert Gray Collected Fossils'; Maps
with annotations by Alice Gray, 1937.

Include Ayrshire sheets of the 6" Ord. Survey, 1910 Edition: L SW: L NW; L NE; LV NE;
LV SW & SE; LVI NW; LVl SW; LVI SE; LVI NE; LXII NW; LXVI NW.

15. Penkill. This is the locality that was alleged to have been 'Lapworth's mistake'. The locality
map prepared by Alice Gray bears a note:

The rock showed on the E. bank of the Penkill Burn at this spot, where the bum is little larger than a
tield drain. For many years locality invisible because grass and soil have covered t)vcr the small fragment
of rock that could once be seen.

16. One of the earliest references to Mrs Gray's material in Davidson's Notebooks occurs under
his entry for Lingula ramsayi: 'among a large number of examples collected by Mrs Gray'.
Another is found under Triplesia Grayi: Mrs Gray considers this an uncommon species'.

17. Constant Prevost (1787-1856), the first Professor of Geology at the Sorbonne. 1831; his
Lyellian approach to geology placed him in an unorthodox position within French geology; he
was also among the first to stress the ecological significance of fossils.

see Did. Sci. Biogr. II: 1974: 133-4.

18. Leopold von Buch, German geologist (1774-1853), involved in all aspects of geology; he
published the first geological map of Germany and was also responsible for distinguishing
ammonites from nautiloids.

see Diet. Sci. Biogr. 2, 1970: 552-7.

19. — Yet, there is little evidence that such national fervour influenced Mrs Gray, although on one
occasion (1 December 1910) she did comment to Dr Bather:

228 R. J. CLEEVELY, R. P. TRIPP AND Y. HOWELLS

Pardon me for saying that I would prefer to see . . . your investigations on British specimens rather than
on Foreign!

— but that was solely due to her self-interest in getting her own material dealt with.

20. There are twenty-eight notebooks containing records of Davidson's correspondence between
1 January 1847 and 19 May 1884 in the Archive & MSS collections of the Palaeontology
Library. BMNH.

see List with dates in Appendix 1 p. 241. Dr C. H. Brunton and R J. Clcevcly intend to
compile and publish an Index to these in the near future.

21. Alice Gray (31 March 1938) distinguished the contribution of the two Youngs;

Professor John Young (1835-1902). Geological Survey of Scotland 1861-66; Professor of
Natural History at Glasgow University 1866-1902; Keeper of the Hunterian Museum. In 1864.
when crossing Girvan Water, he broke his knee after slipping on a boulder and as a result
remained slightly lame throughout his life.

Mr John Young (1823-1900). Assistant Keeper of flunterian Museum \H59 to 1899. For
biographical notices of both see p 210-12 & p 183-K7 in MacNair & Mort (1908) History of the
Geological Society of Glasgow.

22. For biographical references see: Proc. Geot. Assoc, London. 50 1939: 23.')-286. bibliogr.,
portr, pis. 19 & 20; Obit. Not. Proc. Row Soc. London.. Ser. B 92, 1921: xxxi-xl and others
given in CIcevely. 1983: 179.

23. Lapworth letters re Sale of Gray Collection: 12 April 1914; 10 June 1914.

24. Letters concerning missing graptolites: Mrs Gray: 9 February 1917; 20 September 1919.
C. Lapworth: 20 November 1898; 29 November 1989; 12 February 1917; 24 September 1919;
5 November 1919. Prof. Boulton: 12 October 1921; 8 November 1921.

25. H. A. Nicholson & R. Etheridge (1878-1880). A Monogruph of the Silurian Fos.uls of the
Girvan District in Ayrshire, with special reference to those contained in the Gray Collection' .
see Bibliography.

26. Benton (1979) listed all the species described in their monograph, but some of the species of
grayi listed in the work had been named earlier by other workers in recognition of John Gray
of Hagley Hall. nr. Stourbridge, who had made extensive collections from the Wenlock
Limestone.

27. Henry Woodward (1832-1921). Keeper of Geology 1880-1901; his chief contribution was on
Fossil Crustacea; for biographical refs. see Cleevely (1983: 316-17).

28. T. Rupert Jones (1819-1911). Palaeontologist who specialized in Entomostraca and Foramini-
fera; Q. Jl. geol. Soc, Lond. 68, 1912: Iviii-lxi; list of other biographical refs. in CIcevely
(1983: 166); a letter to Bather from W R Billings of Ottawa (26 June 1891) refers to that
'testy old Palaeontologist T. Rupert Jones!'.

29. See letters from Reed to FAB re study of trilobites in BMNH FR Cowper Reed Correspon-
dence file: 21 August 1901; and Mrs Gray to FAB 11 April 1904.

30. See BMNH Correspondence Archive. F. R. C. Reed file: 35 letters from Reed between 17/12/
1892 to 1.5/3/1920 & 17 letters from Bather in reply 22/7/1904 to 1.5/12/1925.

31 John Walter Gregory (27 January 1864-2 June 1932). FRS. FGS. An able and versatile
geologist and palaeontologist, who joined the staff of the BMNH with Bather in 1887.
Developed a keen interest in exploration following his immediate involvement in Museum
expeditions (1887) and effectively became an explorer-geologist visiting most parts of the
world. Resigned from BMNH when appointed to the Chair of Geology in Melbourne in 1901,
but returned to UK in 1904 when given the same position at the new Glasgow University.
Obit. Not. Fell. Roy. Soc, 1, 1932: 53-59.

32. In his review of .Schuchert's revision of the Palaeozoic Stelleroidea, Bather (1915: 425)
commented that this book is not what Prof. Schuchert intended when he began' and reflected

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY 229

something of his own feehngs with 'Congratulations ... on having at last got this laborious and
valuable piece of work into the world'.'.

33. It may have been quite coincidental that Professor Schuehcrt mentioned the difhculties of
identifying cystids when he wrote to Mrs Gray on 31 March 191 1 — but this was the period of
the Gray/Bathcr/Rccd controversy. Schuchert's complaint that his museum duties interfered
with his research and that as a result, instead of a monograph, he had had only sufficient time
to prepare descriptions of the genera and their species, ought to have provided some support
for Bather's position.

34. W. K. Spencer see Biogr. Mem. Fell. Roy. Soc, Lond. 2. 1956: 291-9; and Cleevcly, 1983: 273.

35. Wheelton Hind FGS (1860-21 June 1920). Eminent medical practitioner, who lived at Stoke-
on-Trent, Staffs. His research un-ravelled the succession of Carboniferous rocks in North
Staffs, and produced the standard monograph on the British Carboniferous Lainellibranchiu
(1896-1905). Q.JI. geol. Soc. Lond. 73, 1917: Ivii-xlix: 77, 1921: Ixviii-lxix.

36. T. H. Withers. BMNH: Boy Attendant, 1898; Assistant, 1925; Curator, Fossil Cirripcdia
1925-44. Proc. Geol. Soc. Lond., No. 1515, 1954: cxliii-cxliv,

37. Withers declined to deal with further machaeridian specimens offered by Alice Gray (14 May
1934) since he had to devote all his time to the preparation of a Catalogue of Cretaceous
Cirripedia .

38. For some reason. Bather always appears to have been ultra critical of J. R. Gregory's
nomenclature and frequently expressed these views in print beginning with a letter (1897: 381),
see also a paper on Eocidaris ( 1909). This antipathy towards Gregory may have been due to his
sudden emigration to Australia in 1901, having spent much of his tenure at the BMNH on
field-work, leaving Bather with additional responsibilities. However, it was very probably the
result of Gregory's careless scientific work!

39. Dr Bather makes occasional references to seeing Mrs Gray on his visits to Edinburgh; see
reference to his son's pleasure at Mrs Gray's interest in 'Rugger' (letters September 1921).

4. BATHER

40. W. D. Lang. 1934. Francis Arthur Bather (1863-1934).

Obit Not. Row Soc. London. No. 3: 303-314;
1934. Dr. F. A. Bather, FRS.

Nature. 133. (31 March 1934): 485-86

41. In addition of Lang's references, there are indications of Bather's relationship with his staff
and other professional colleagues in the various contributions made to the tribute published in
the Museums Journal. 34: 41^5.

42. P. E. Raymond, 1935. Memorial of F. A. BATHER. Proc Geol. Soc Amer. 1934: 173-186,
portr., bibliogr.

43. Bert Hansen in his article in the Dictionary of Scientific Biography 2: 507 has emphasized
Bather's use of the natural world to his fossil studies.

44. Bibliography: the only published bibliography Raymond (1935) is incomplete; this had been pre-
pared by Withers at Raymond's request. Apparently, Bather had distributed his own list in 1915,
but did not extend this further. My own [RJC] list comprises 258 publications: 18 of which were
reviews and only 7 of which dealt with Gray material. It is worth noting that Bather did not publish
anything at all in 1921 , the year he was dealing with the acquisition of Mrs Gray's material.

On Echinodermata = 4."^ Stratigraphy = 9

Crinoids = 67 Museology/Tcchniqucs etc. = 42

Edriiiasterdids = 10 Taxonomv/Nomenclature = 19

Cystoids = 7

127

70

Obituaries = 8

Other Phylla (mainly Palaeozoic) Bibliography = 7

= 46 —
15

173 =

230 R. J. CLEEVELY, R. P. IRIPPAND Y. HOWELLS

45. Although Bather made frequent mention of his involvement in producing a Catalogue of the
Cystoids & Crinoids for the BM material, this was never completed. The only evidence for this
work is a series of printed/mss index cards now dispersed throughout the main reference
collections of these groups in the Dept. of Palaeontology.

46. Aware of his reduced vigour, and knowing the customary slow rate of progress within the
Museum, Bather felt that he would be able to achieve very little in his remaining four years
before retirement.

47. Bather's involvement in local affairs is reported in his obituary published in the Wimbledon
Borough News, 23 March 1934.

48. See Letters from Margaret Grant dated 9 January 1935 & 12 January 19.\5. She refers to that
Lonely Intelligence' and also to the fact that he was known to them as 'the Dominic'.

5. BATHER/GRAY CORRESPONDENCE

49. Her daughter Alice, on the other hand, understood that Bather's museum duties prevented
him from attending to their queries; see her letter of 22nd Feb. 1925.

50. Bather (16 January 1899) 'Your two specimens arrived safely ... but there was no light
available for their examination till this morning.'

Steam (1981: 213) quoted Riley's account of conditions at the BMNII m 1911. which
mentioned that Electricity had been installed in the office studies in 1906.

51. A. S. Woodward, History of the Collections in the RMNH. p. ii of the Preface and the MSS.
Annual Report on Bather's work for 19((4 indicate that he was involved in its compilation
during this period. The correspondence tile with FRC Reed also shows that he was also
engaged in dealing with material from Burma (at least 16 letters).

52. Starfish Bed. encouragement to preserve every fragment' Bather letter (4 October 19(17)

53. It must be realised that 'cystids' for Bather at that time would have included forms that would
now no longer be called cystids, or cystoids. and have since been referred to chordates (see
discussion of Jefferies p. 218).

54. This expression 'in fear & trembling occurs in another letter (20 January 1897) written a few
years earlier by Mary Kingsley to Albert Giinther. a former Keeper of Zoology at the BMNH,
when she submitted an advance copy of her book Travels in West Africa seeking a positive
verdict for its publication.

55. Bather (1908: 76) referred to another aspect of this problem:

I am constantly favoured by correspondents with specimens for which Ihey desire a name. Unfor-
tunately. ... it is impossible to name them without spending mi>rc time in their preparation than we . . .
can spare! I . . . point out . . . that it is our duty ... to name and arrange the specimens already in the
museum. Consequently, unless our correspondents give us all pt)ssible help in the preliminary
preparation of their specimens, they cannot hope for very satisfactory replies

As one of the more enlightened palaeontologists of his time. Bather went on to vent his
exasperation at those who 'seem only anxious to load science with a new species and a new
name . . . they do not trouble about the lessons the fossil can teach!'.

56. This is a reference to the monograph Slammesgeschichte der Pelmalozoen. Erster Hand.
Thecoidea und Cystoidea. 1899: x = 442 pp.. 18 pis. published in Berlin by Otto Jaekel as part
of his synthesis of existing knowledge of fossil Crinoidea.

Jaekel. a vertebrate palaeontologist, became Professor at Berlin (1890-1903), Vienna
(1903), tireifswald (1904-28 and Pekin (1928). The 1899 work on the Cystoids is one of his
most significant contributions to palaeontology. Apparently, Jaekel's work was either
extremely thorough and of high quality, or else hastily put together, not particularly clear.
superficial and of little real value. Although even these cursory papers have value, for in one
he set up the Class Carpoidea (pers. commun. Dr R. P. S. Jefferies).

57. Part of Bather's replv to the Geological Societv when presented with their I.yell Medal. Proc.
Geol. Soc, Lond. 67 (1911): xlv.

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY 231

58. On the basis of Ihcir correspondence between 1892-1925, Bather and Reed nnaintained a
friendly working relationship, assisting one another with identifications, providing material for
research and collaborating in the preparation of papers.

59. In addition to the details provided by Steam, Dr Bather makes several references to the
situation in his correspondence, eg. see letters in Gray Correspondence of January 1918.

60. This is presumed to be a reference to the specimen of Archaeopleryx lithographica Meyer
found in the Upper Jurassic Lithographic Limestone of a quarry near Pappenheim in Bavaria.
It was purchased by the Museum from Dr Karl Haberlein in 1862 together with other material
in his collection. As an intermediate' between reptiles and birds this fossil has been the subject
of repeated investigation, and has recently been the subject of a wholly unjustified accusation
of 'fakery'.

An exhibition at the BMNH during 1987-88 demonstrated the scientific evidence for its
authenticity, showing that its essentially reptilian skeleton had several avian features as well as
the distinct impressions of feathers, (see Ostrom, J. H., 1984 In, Proceedings of the
International Archaeopleryx Conference, Eichstatt, 1984: pp9-19).

61 . Air-raids: FRC Reed in a letter to Bather ( 1 5 September 1917) asked that some figured cystids
belonging to the Geological Survey of India should be insured with Lloyds for £250 against the
'risk of air-craft' whilst they arc at the BMNH; he explains that he always takes out insurance
against fire & now air-craft when he borrows other people's fossils. After being told by the
Director (26 September) that no funds were available for such a course. Bather eventually
returned the specimens (26 November) to the relative safety of Cambridge.

6. ACQUISITION

62. Donations of 1867, 1868 & 1869 recorded in Hunterian Museum register GLI Catalogue A
numbers 30-89; other donations made in 1870, 1872 and 1873.

63. Smith-Woodward had annotated her previous letter with the comment Trustees . . . will not
consider it until after the war — so time to think over proposal'.

64. The basis of Dr. Bather's calculation as to the value of material in the Gray Collection was as
follows:

Type material of New species at £1

Type specimens of New Varieties @ 0-10-0

Figured specimens @ 0- 5-0

Specimens selected as Gray Coll'n @ 2-0

according to the character @ 1-6

of the group @ 1-0

Duplicate/or Un-examined specimens @ M)

or &' 0-6d

65. One wonders how much money the Grays would have spent travelling to Girvan over the
years and in staying with relatives in the area?

66. This refers to W. Lewis Abbott material from the Ightham Fissure pres'd by Sir H. Howarth to
British Museum.

67. The Gray's kept a detailed record of the despatch of each consignment and the cost of
carriage, which was used to settle their account. 68 boxes were despatched to the BMNH
according to their records. This book was presented to the BMNH by Alice Gray (2 June 1940)
and is now kept with the Gray Mss in the Palaeontology Library. In this context, it should be
noted that the BMNH paid for the carriage of all the material it acquired in I920's, 1937 and
1945. The costs for the despatch of other material sent by the Gray family to various specialists
over many years must also have amounted to a reasonable sum.

68. 1st payment of £850 received on 15 July 1920; 2nd payment of £518 (incl. carriage) on 10
March 1921 ; 3rd payment of £800 on 8 July 1921; final amount of £100 on 9 March 1922; with
various amount for carriage ending with that on 24 March 1922.

232 R. J. CLEEVELY, R. P. TRIPP ANHY. HOWELLS

69. W. K. Spencer apparently had seen all the starfish & echinoderm material; F. R. C. Reed had
been sent any trilobitcs and brachiopods that members of the family thought were new; &
Archie Lamont had looked over the gastropods.

70. Lang arranged (22 April 1937) for R. H. Spires and an assistant Mr Covington, to visit
Edinburgh and pack the collection; Alice Gray (4 May 1937) wrote; '. . . packing completed
with minimal inconvenience. Mr. Spires most kind & considerate'.

71. Sedgwick Museum, Cambridge. Donations made by Mrs Robert Grey: Trilobites in 1907;
Brachiopods & Rostroconchs in 1908; Machaeridians in 1909; Hyolithids and Machacridians in
1910. The BMNH presented duplicates of the algae Mastopora fava (Salter) in 1941

72. Amongst the material presented in 1937 was at least one specimen mentioned by Reed much
earlier — the only illaenid hbngena from the Stinchar Limestone, Mmuntion (Reed. 1904).
TTiis is of significance in extending the tvpe series bcvond that of the original purchase.
[R. Tripp)

73. Letter from Davidson & Syme. Edinburgh (2 December 1944) to W. N. Edwards in E. H.
Gray file.

7. GIRVAN FAUNA

74. Bluck (1985) considered the relationships of the Girvan sequence to the probable accrctionary
prism of the Southern Uplands in his examination of the tectonic history of the Calcdonides in
a wider context. Scott J. Geol. 21: 437^64.

75. James Nichol (1844) Guide to the Geology of Scotland . Edinburgh, see p. 261 for list of seven
species: 1 sponge, 3 brachiopods, 1 ptcropod.

76. An anecdote told in a letter (To Fanny Hicks, 21 August 1848) concerning Sedgwick's visit in
1848, indicates that many of these specimens were gathered by a young girl, who had first
shown them the quarry near Girvan. at a cost of Id each, see Clark & McKenny Hughes, 1890
The Life and Letters of the Rev'd. Adam Sedgwick, Vol. 2: 145.

77. F. W, M'Coy.

1851. On some New Silurian Mollusca. Pt. 1. Ann. Mag. nat. Hist. 7: 45-63. Orthoceras
politum (M'Coy) from Glenwhapple; Bellerophon suhdecussatus (M'Coy) from Mulloch;
Trochus Moorei (M'Coy) from Dalquharran.

On some New Silurian Mollusca. Pt. 2. Ann. Mag. nat. Hist. 7: 387-409. Hemilhyris
angustifrons (M'Coy) — Mulloch Hill; H. nasula (M'Coy) — Craighead Quarry; Orlhisina
scotica (M'Coy) — Craighead; Holopella cincta (M'Coy) — Mulloch.

1852. On New lower Palaeozoic Mollusca. Ann. Mag. nat. Hist 10: 189-195 Murchisania
cancellata (M'Coy) — Mulloch; M. simplex (M'Coy) — Craighead; Eccliomphaliis scotica
(M'Coy) — Mulloch.

78. Sedgwick, A. & M'Coy, F. W. 1855. A Synopsis of the Classification of the British Palaeozoic
Rocks, with a systematic description of the British Palaeozoic Fossils in the Geological
Museum of the University of Cambridge.

79. J. W. Salter (1820-1869). Britain's leading Palaeozoic palaeontologist during his lifetime and a
specialist on trilobites. He began his natural history career as an apprentice to James dc Carle
Sowerby — [and also married his daughter]. Salter also assisted both Murchison and Sedgwick
and later trained the young Robert Etheridge.

Difficulties over his position and status, partly arising from family matters, his health and
involvement with religion, led to his resignation from his position at the Geological Survey.
(See Secord, J. A., 1985 Spec. Puhl. Soc. Hist Mat. Hist, i 61-75)

80. Salter. J. W. 1855. List of some of the Silurian Fossils of Ayrshire pp. 170-178 |17
brachiopods; 1 bivalve; 13 gastropods; 6 Cephalopoda] with Murchison, R. I. 'On the Silurian
Rocks of the South of Scotland'. Quart. Jl. geol. Soc. Lond. 7: 1.39-169.

81. Of the earlier workers [= describers], it would appear that only Nicholson and Etheridge had
ever visited the Girvan District to make their own collections and observations. Virtuallv all

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY 233

post-1950 publications have been written by geologists with a good field knowledge of the area
and its formations.

82. Rough estimates of the Total number of Girvan species at each phase are: 1st exploratory"
phase = 40, (7; 34; 37 species]; 2nd 'accumulative/acquisitive' phase = 560 [see list in Peach &
Home]; 3rd 'interpretative" phase = c. 700.

83. To explain the presence of both internal and external moulds in many of these specimens,
Goldring & Stephenson ( 1972) have suggested thai several of the Girvan 'echinoderms' were
sediment-eaters and that the distortion of the moulds was compatible with measurements
made on the modern Echinocardium cordalum showing that 30% of its test is occupied by gut
contents.

84. Glyplocrinus globularis N. & E. 1881.

85. Ramsbottom recorded the following species from the Girvan district: A. thraivensis, A.
drummockensis . C. heterohranchia . C. gracilis, D. grandiluhiis, P. scolicus. Protaxocrinus
girvanensis. M. cirrifer, X. multiramus. X. sp., y4. elevatiis. D. craigheadensis. D. globularis.

86. The term 'calcichordate' is now thought to be inappropriate (see Jefferies et al 1987; 432).

87. Letter 14 June 1912.

88. See p. 224 for an account of Mrs Gray"s strong feelings for her cystids.

89. Girvan Rostroconch molluscs have been figured in Pojeta & Runnegar (1976: 54); no British
author has dealt with the monoplacophorans from Girvan, although Hind and Reed did
describe Tryblidium species as bivalves.

90. In his review of Ordovician pelecypods [= bivalves], Pojeta (1971) has explained that another
reason is the mistaken belief that adequate material is not available, since the majority of
Ordovician specimens are in the form of poorly preserved moulds and casts, which are only
found on exposed limestone and sandstone surfaces. His review also provides other informa-
tion on the motives and results of earlier workers on Palaeozoic bivalves.

91. Extract from Biography by Alice Gray [see Gray Correspondence, Vol. 1, 'letter" No. 23]:

The letter from my mother to Professor Lapworth (20 November 1898) and his reply (29 November
1898), are of importance because they show that the 'Starfish Bed' known to-day \c. Wii^] is not the
Starfish Bed described by him on p. 619 of the 'Girvan Succession'. I think I am correct in stating that
Professor Lapworth did not visit the Girvan District after my mother found her 'Starfish Bed' and that
he never saw her 'Starfish Bed'.

It ought, perhaps, to be placed on record that we, as a family, searched in vain for Professor
Lapworth's Starfish Bed in 'an old quarry'; also that the owner of South Threave Farm at the time, Mr
Patcrson, did not know of any old quarry, on cither his own properly or on neighbouring land,
answering to the description . . . although he knew Prof, Lapworth and saw him occasionally when . . .
working . . . the . . . geology of the Girvan District

Alice Gray also expressed doubts over any suggestion that nearby overgrown depressions
could once have been Lapworth's 'quarry' for the family had frequently worked in that
neighbourhood and would have found the site.

92. Reed's monograph on the Girvan trilobites (1903-6, I9I4) and Bather's work on the Cystoids
deal mainly with Starfish Bed material; Cocks (1978) in his review of Davidson's brachiopods
records more than 30 species from the Bed; and Jefferies (1986: 192)) referred to the two
species of cornutes that have frequently been preserved as the 'youngest cornutes known'.

8. CONCLUSIONS

93. The Edinburgh Census return for 1891 records I domestic servant in the household; in the
census returns for 1851 and 1861 her father's household at Girvan included several servants,
but only one in each census was listed as a house servant, the others were also farm labourers,
or dairymaids.

94. Mrs Gray in a letter to Davidson (2nd Nov. 1876):

. . . from what I hear from our Scotch geologists, it still seems an open question whether the
position, or sequence of the Girvan Beds is really determined.

234 R. J. CLEEVELY, R. P. TRIPP ANDY. HOWELLS

95. Letter to Rosic' dated 13 November 1921 in the Royal Scottish Museum, Edinburgh;
apparently in answer to a reference concerning certain books, probably by Mrs Asquith in the
light of the following comment.

Mrs Gray wrote: We arc all sick of Mrs Asquith!' and went on to mention a clever burlesque
in Punch of one of her books published under the heading A brilliant Little Innocent Abroad'.

96. Mrs Gray's reply to the .suggestion of Dr Traquair c. 1878-80 (see p. 4 of Alice Gray's Mss
biography of her mother)

97. See letters to Bather dated 23 November & 17 December 1910 re borrowing Jaeckel's work on
cystideans; and Bather's letter 31A7/1900 advising her to refer to Lankester's Treatise on Zoology.

98. Her visits to Prague and BMNH referred to in Bather correspondence (24 July 1907).

99. Bather's letter (22 June 1919) is in response to Mrs Gray's questions as to the function of some
unusual crinoid ossicles that she had found at Craighead.

100. 30 October 1876, puzzled over the difference in ornamentation shown by a large l.inguta
occurring at Baldatchie from others found at Craighead.

101. Orthis calligramma Dalman (see her letter of 1 1 February 1882); the material has since been
recognised as Orthambonites plavfairi (Reed), Hesperorthis criiigensis (Reed) and Dolerorthis
?sp.

Among other examples is Strophomena corrugatelta Davidson which included several
unrelated brachiopods that had independently developed strongly wrinkled ornament; these
are now described as: Gunnarella corrugatelta Davidson, Gunnaretla undulala (M'Coy);
Rafinesquina sp.. Palaeoslrophomena kilbuchoensis (Davidson); Ptychoglyptus ? sp., Lepto-
strophia jamesoni (Reed).

102. The old gutta percha rubbers used to produce casts of the Girvan fossils for Bather and
Spencer have been replaced by silicone and latex rubbers, which are far more fluid and
flexible, allowing more of the Hner details of ornament to be reproduced. It is also hoped that
such materials will provide more permanent replicas.

103. See the recent work of Jefferies on cornutes; Donovan on crinoids; and Paul on cystoids.

104. Walter R. Billings (7-1920). An amateur fossil collector in Canada, who was particularly
interested in crinoids. He worked in the Chief Architects Office. Ottawa and was able to
obtain material from various new fossil sites as they were discovered during excavations. He
corresponded with Bather about fossil echinoderms from 1890 to 1916; lent most of his better
specimens for description; provided the 'gossip of a superficial amateur' (see letter 14 May
1897) and acted as a reporter, mediator and link for Bather with specialists throughout North
America. Biogr. reference in Geot. Mag. 57, 1920: 287-288. The tile WR Billings' in the
BMNH Correspondence Archive has 56 letters from him with 13 draft replies from Bather.

105. The correspondence with Dr Bather contains many references to: 'my fossil', 'my cystids',
'my crinoids' etc.

106. described by Alice Gray in a letter to L. F. Bairstow ( 10 October 1938)

107. Davidson's quotation in the Geologist, Vol. 11, 1859: 461.

108. Alice Gray's letter (16 October 1937) indicates that this may have been unfortunate and the
wrong person commemorated, as the specimen had been found by her sister Agnes Gray!

11. REFERENCES

Papers that mention Mrs Gray and/or her collection are marked with an asterisk *

Alexander, A. S. 19.39. Across Watersheds, viii + 278 pp, 4 pis. Robert Maclehose & Co. Ltd.
Cjlasgow.

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY 235

Allen, D. E. \97b. The Naturatisi in Britain. A Social History, xii + 292 pp. Allen Lane, London.

* Arin.strong, J., Young, J., & Robertson, D. 1876. Catalogue of the Western Scottish Fossils, iii +

164 pp. Blackic & Son. Glasgow.

* Bather, F. A. 1913. Caradocian Cystidea from Girvan. Transactions of the Roval Society of
Edinburgh 49: 3.^9-530, 6 pis., 80 text tigs.

* 1915. Studies in Edrioasteroidca, VI. Pvrgocvstis n.g.. Geological Magazine, London Dec.

VI, Vol. n, 52: 5-12; 49-6(1, pis. 2 & 3.

* 1923. The shell of Cornulites. Geological Magazine, London 60: 542-5.

* 1925. Cothurnocyslis. A study in adaptation. Paldonlologische Zeitschrift Berlin 7: 1-15.

1926. Preface, pp v-xi. In Withers. T. H. (1926) Catalogue of The Machaeridia . . . in the

Department of Geology . British Museum (Natural History). London.

* Bather, F. A. & Spencer, W. K. 1934. A new Ordovician echinoid from Girvan. Ayrshire.
Annals and Magazine of Natural History (10) 13: 557-558.

Begg, J. L. 1946. Some new fossils from the Girvan district. Transactions of the Geological Society

of Glasgow 2\: 29^1.
Benton, M. J. 1979. H. A. Nicholson (1844-1899), invertebrate palaeontologist: bibliography and

catalogue of his type and figured material. Royal Scottish Museum, Information Series, Geology

7: vii + 94 pp.
Bluck, B, J, 19S5. The Scottish parateclonic Caledonides. Scottish Journal of Geology 21: 437-464.
Brenchley, P. J. 1984. Late Ordovician Extinctions and their Relationship to the Gondwana

Glaciation, pp 291-335. In Brenchley. P. J. (Ed). 1984 Fo.'isils and Climate 352 pp. John Wiley

& Sons Ltd., Chichester.
Brower, J. C. 1974. Upper Ordovician Xenocrinids (Crinoidea, Camerata) from Scotland.

Palaeontological Contributions. Papers University of Kansas Ps, 67: 1-25, 3 pis.

* Brookes Knight, J. 1941 . Palaeozoic Gastropod Genotypes. Special Papers. Geological Society of
America 32: vi + 510 pp, 96 pis.

* Clarkson, E. N. K. 1985. A history of Scottish palaeontology 1834-1984. Scottish Journal of
Geology 21 (4): 389^06.

* Clarkson, E. N. K. and Tripp, R. P. 1981. The Ordovician trilobitc Calyptaulax brongniarti
(Portlock). Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh (Earth Sciences), Edinburgh, 72:
287-294. 6 figs.

Cleevely, R. J. 1983. World Palaeontological Collections 364 pp. British Museum (Natural
History )/Mansell Publishing Ltd., London.

* Cocks, L. R. M. C. 1978. A Review of British Lower Palaeozoic Brachiopods. including a
Synoptic Revision of Davidson's Monograph. Palaeontographical Society. (Monographs), 256

PP
Cocks, L. R. M. & Toghill, P. 1973. The biostratigraphy of the Silurian rocks of the Gii^an

District, Scotland. Quarlerly Journal of the geological Society. London 129: 209^3.
Curry, G. B., Bluck, B. J., Burton. C. J., Ingham, J. K„ Siviter, D. J., and Williams. A, 1984.

Age, evolution & tectonic history of the Highland border Complex, Scotland. Transactions of

the Royal Society of Edinburgh, Earth Sciences 75: 1 13-133.

* Davidson, T, 1853-1883. Monograph of the British Fossil Brachiopoda. Palaeontographical
Society, (Monographs), 1-368, 42 pis.; Suppl: 242 pp, 17 pis. [for details see Cocks, L. R. M. C.
(1978)]

• 1877. Notes on four species of Scottish Lower Silurian Brachiopoda. Geological Magazine,

London. Dec. II, Vol. 4: 13-17, pi. 2.

* Dean, W, T, 1966. The lower Ordovician startigraphy and trilobite fauna of the Landeyran
Valley and the neighbouring district of the Montagne Noire, south-western France. Bulletin
British Museum (Natural History), Geology 12: 245-343, 21 pis.

Dewey, J. F. 1982. Plate tectonics and the evolution of the British Isles. Journal of the Geological
Society, London, 139: 371^12.

* Donald. J. [see also under Longstaff, Mrs. J.] 1899 Remarks on the genera Eotomaria Koken and
Hormotoma Salter with description of British species. Quarterly Journal geological Society.
London 55: 251-272, pis. 21-22.

* 1902. On some of the Proterozoic Gasteropoda which have been referred to Murchisonia

and Pleurolomaria with descriptions of new subgenera and species. Quarterly Journal geological
Society, London 58: 313-339, pis. 7-9.

236 R. J. CLEEVELY, R. P. TRIPP AND Y. HOWELLS

* 1905. Observations on some of the Loxonematidae, with descriptions of two new species.

Quarterly Journal geological Society, London 61: 564-6, pi. .^7.
* 1906. Notes on the genera Omospira. Lophospira. and Turritoma. with descriptions of the

new Proterozoic species. Quarterly Journal geological Society . London 62: 552-572. pis. 43-44.

* Donovan, S. F. 1983. Tetrameric crinoid columnals from the Ordovician of Wales. Palaeontology
26: 845-9. 2 t.-figs.

• 1986. Pelmatozoan columnals from the Ordovician of the British Isles. Pt. I. Palaeonto-

graphical Society, (Monographs), 11-68. 6 pis.
In Press. Pt. II.

* Elles, G. L. and Woods, E. M. R. 1901-1918. A Monograph of the British Graptolites.
Palaeontographical Society, (Monographs), pp a-m. |2). clxxi + 539 pp. 52 pis.

* Etheridge, R. (Jnr.) 1878. Notes on Silurian fossils from the neighbourhood of Girvan. Ayrshire.
Proceedings of the Royal Society of Edinburgh 4: 164-177.

* 1881. The Palaeozoic Conchology of Scotland. Proceedings of the Ro\al Physical Society of

Edinburgh 7: 1-94.
Flett, Sir J. Smith. 1937. The First Hundred Years of the Geological Survey of Great Britain. 280

pp. H.M.S.O.. London.
Fortey, R. A. 1984. Global earlier Ordovician transgressions and regressions and their biological

implications, pp 37-50 In Bruton. D. L. [Ed.) Aspects of the Ordovician System', Palaeonto-

logical Contributions University of Oslo 295: [vii] + 228 pp.
Freshney, E. C. 1959. An extension of the Silurian succession in the Craighead Inlicr, Girvan.

Transactions of the Geological Society of Glasgow' 24: 27-36.
Gibson, J. A. 1981. Regional Checklist of Clyde Birds. Second edition. Clyde Area Branch

Scottish Wildlife Trust. Glasgow.
Gislen, T. 1930. Affinities between the Echinodermata. Enteropneusta and Chordonia. Zoologiska

Bidrag Uppsala 12: 199-304.
Goldring, R. & Stephenson, D. G. 1972. The depositional environment of three Starfish Beds.

Neues Jahrbuch fiir Geologic und Paliiontologie. Monatshefie 1972: 449-64.

* Gray, R. 1868a. Specimens exhibited 29th Sept. 1864. Observations on various branches of
Natural History during the past summer. Proceedings of the Glasgow Natural History Society 1:
100-101.

* 1868b. Specimens exhibited 28th Nov. 1865. Notes on Silurian fossils [brachiopods] from

Girvan. ibid.: 124.
* 1868c. Specimens exhibited at meeting 7th Jan. 1868. Occurrence of Ischadites kanigi |sic]

in the Silurian rocks of the Gir\'an District, ibid.: 197-8.
* 1869. Specimens exhibited 27th Oct. 1870. Note on a new Silurian brachiopod. Leptaena

Youngiana Davidson (non Gray), from the Girvan District; and also the occurrence of

Leperditia in the district, ibid. 2(1): 229-30.
Gray, R. and Anderson, R. 1869. On the Birds of Ayrshire and Wigtownshire. Proceedings of the

Glasgow Natural History Society 1: 269-324.

* Harper, D. A. T. 1979. The environmental significance of some faunal changes in the Upper
Ardmillan succession (upper Ordovician). Girvan. Scotland pp 439—445 In Harris. A. L..
Holland. C. H. & Leake. B. E. (Eds.) 'The Caledonides of the British Isles — reviewed'. Special
Publication Geological Society of London 8: xii + 768 pp. Scottish Academic Press Ltd..
Edinburgh.

1981. The stratigraphy and faunas of the Upper Ordovician High Mains Formation of the

Girvan District. Scottish Journal of Geology, 17: 247-255.
1982u. The late Ordovician Lady Bum Starfish Beds of Girvan. Proceedings of the Glasgow

Geological Society. No. 122/123: 28-32.
19826. The stratigraphy of the Drummuck Group (Ashgill). Girvan. Geological Journal 17:

251-277.
* 1984. Brachiopods from the Upper Ardmillan Succession (Ordovician) of the Girvan

District. Scotland. Part. 1. Palaeontographical Society (Monographs), 1-78. II pis. |Publ. No.

565. part of Vol. 136 for 1982],

* Hind, W. 1910. The Lamellibranchs of the Silurian rocks of Girvan. Transactions of the Royal
Society of Edinburgh 47: 479-548. 5 pis.

Home, J. 1904. Obituary of R. H. Traquair. Proceedings of the Royal Society. Edinburgh 33: 4.

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY 237

1925. Obituary of Mrs Robert Gray. Transactions of the Geological Societv. Edinburgh II:

392.

* Howells, Y. 1982. Scottish Silurian Trilobitcs. Piilaeonlographical Society (Monographs). 76 pp.,
15 pis.

* Hughes, C. P., Ingham, J. K. & Addison, R. 1975. The morphology, classification and evolution
of the Trinucleidae (Trilobita). Philosophical Transactions of the Roval Society of London B 272:
537-607.

Ince, D. 1984. Sedimentation and tectonism in the Middle Ordovician of the Girvan district, S. W.
Scotland. Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh (Earth Sciences) 75: 225-237.

* Ingham, J. K. 196S. British and Swedish Ordovician species of Cybeloides (Trilobita). Scottish
Journal of Geology 4: 300-316, pis. 1, 2.

1978. Geology of a continental margin; 2: middle and late Ordovician transgression, Girvan.

In Bowes, D. R. & Leake, B. E. (Eds.) Crustal evolution in northwestern Britain and adjacent

areas. Geological Journal (Special Issue). 10: 163-176.
Jaanusson, V. 1984. What is so special about the Ordovician? pp 1-3. In Bruton, D. L. (Ed.)

1984. Aspects of the Ordovician System. Palaeontological Contributions University of Oslo No.

295: [vii] + 228 pp, Oslo Universitet.
' Jefferics, R. P. S. 1967. Some fossil chordates with echinodcrm affinities. Zoological Society of

London. Symposium, 20: 163-208.
* 1968. The subphylum Calcichordata (Jefferics, 1967) — primitive fossil chordates with

echinoderm affinities. Bulletin British Museum (Natural History). Geology 16: 243-339.
* 1986. The Ancestry of the Vertebrates. 300 pp, illus. British Museum (Natural History),

London.
Jefferies, R. P. S. & Lewis, D. N. 1978. The English Silurian fossil Placocystites forhesianus and the

ancestry of the vertebrata. Philosophical Transactions of the Roval Society of London (B) 282

(990): 205-323.
Jefferies, R. P. S., Lewis, M. & Donovan, S. K. 1987. Protocystites menevensis — A stem group

chordate (Cornuta) from the Middle Cambrian of South Wales. Palaeontology 30: 429-484, pis.

54-60.

* Jones, O. T. 1928. Plectamhonites and some allied genera. Memoirs of the Geological Survey of
Great Britain. Palaeontology . London. Vol. 1(5): 367-527, pis. 21-25.

* Jones, T. R. 1886. On the genus Bevrichia and some new species. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History (5) 17: 337-63, pi. 12.' (Gray CoH'n p. 356]

' 1893a. On some Palaeozoic Ostracoda from the Girvan District of Ayrshire. Quarterly

Journal geological Society, London 49: 296-307, pis. 13 & 14.
* 1893/). On some Palaeozoic Ostracoda from the Girvan District of Ayrshire. Geological

Magazine. London, Dec IIL vol. 10: 285 (A report of above paper].

* Jones, T. R. & Woodward, H. 1895. On some Palaeozoic Phyllopoda. Geological Magazine,
London, Dec. IV, vol. 2: 539-45, pi. 15.

* Lament, A. 1934. Lower Palaeozoic Brachiopoda of the Girvan District: Suggestions on
Morphology in relation to Environment. Annals and Magazine of Natural Historv (10) 14: 161-
84. [Gray Coll'n refd. p. 183].

* 1935. The Drummuck Group, Girvan: A Stratigraphical Revision, with Descriptions of

New Fossils from the Lower Part of the Group. Transactions of the Geological Society of
Glasgow 19: 288-334, pis. 7-9. [Gray Coil'n. refd. p. 291]

* 1946. Lamellibranchs from the Lower Drummuck Group (Ashgillian), Girvan, Scotland.

Cement, Lime and Gravel 20: 364-6, 1 pi.

* Lane, P. 1971. The British Cheiruridac (Trilobita). Palaeontographical Society, (Monographs).
195 pp, 16 pis. [Makes no reference to Gray CoH'n. at all, although the material dealt with had
originally been described by Reed]

Lapworth, C. 1878. The Moffat Series. Quarterly Journal Geological Society, London 34: 24-343;

345-6.
' 1882. The Girvan Succession. Quarterlv Journal Geological Society, London 38: 537-666,

Pis. 24-25.
* 1899. [Review of] The Survey Memoir on the Scottish Uplands. Mem. Geol. Surv. U.K.

'The Silurian Rocks of Bntain. Vol. 1 . Scotland". Geological Magazine. London, Dec. IV, Vol.

6: 472-9; 510-20. ]Gray colPn. refd. p. 518].

238 R. J. CLEEVELY. R. P. TRIPP ANOY. HOWELLS

1903. Presidential Address. Quarterly Journal Geological Society, London 59: xlvii-xlviii.
Longstafr, (Mrs) J. [nee Donald] 1899. see under Donald

1902. see under Donald

1903. see under Donald

1905. see under Donald

1906. see under Donald

* 1924. Descriptions of Gasteropoda [sic] chiefly in Mrs Robert Gray's collection from the

Ordovician and the Lower Silurian of Girvan Quarterly Journal Geological Society. London 80:

408-M6. pis. 31-3K.

* MacBride, E. W. & Spencer, W. K. 1938. Two New Echinoidea, Aulechinus and Ectinechinus ,
and an adult-plated Holothurian, Eolhuria from the Upper Ordovician of Girvan. Scotland.
Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London Ser. B. , Biological Sciences, 229 (No.
558): 91-136. jp. 92: This paper owes much to the careful collecting of the Misses Gray, who arc
continuing the work commenced by their mother.]

Macnair, P. & Mort, F. 1908. History of the Geological Society of Glasgow. 1858-1908. with
Biographical Notices of Prominent Members. [viii[ + 304 pp. Geological Society of Glasgow,
Glasgow.

Mancenido, M. O. & Cocks, L. R. M. 1986. Thomas Davidson 1817-1885. In Racheboeuf, P. R.
and Emig, C. [Eds] Les Brachiopodes Fossiles et Actuels'. Actes du 1"^' Congres International
sur les brachiopodes. Brest 1985. Biostratigraphie du Palcozoique, Univ. Bretagne Occidentale.
4: 23-25.

* Morris, S. F. & Fortey, R. A. 1985. Catalogue of the Type and figured specimens of Trilobite in the
British Museum (Natural History), iv + 182 pp. 8 pis. British Museum (Natural History). London.

Morris, S. F. & Tripp, R. P. 1986. Lectotype selections for Ordovician trilobites from the Girvan
District, Strathclyde. Bulletin British Museum (Natural History. Geology 40: 161-76.

* Nicholson, H. A. & Etheridge, R. (Jun.) 1877. Contributions to micropalacontology — H. On
Prasporae Gravae. a new genus and species of Silurian corals. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History i-i) 20:388-92.

• 1878-80. A Monograph of the Silurian Fossils of the Girvan District in Ayrshire, with special

reference to those contained in the Gray Collection' . Blackwood & Sons. Edinburgh & London.
Fasciculus 1. (Rhizopoda, Actinozoa, Trilobita), 1878: ix + 1-135, pis. 1-19; Fasiculus II.
(Trilobita, Phyllopoda. Cirripcdia and Ostracoda). 1879; vi + 137-234. pis. 10-15; Fasciculus
III. (The Annelida and Echinodermata. with Supplements on the Protozoa. Coelenterata. and
Crustacea). 1880: vi + 23.5-341. pis. 16-24.

Nicol, James. 1844. Guide to the geology of Scotland, 272 pp. Oliver & Boyd. Edinburgh. JN.B.
2nd edit. 1864],

* Owen, H. G. 1965. The British Palaeozoic Asterozoa. Tabic of Contents, Supplement and Index.
Palaeontographical Society (Monographs), xii + 54I-5H.^ pp.

* Owens, R. M. 1973. British Ordovician and Silurian Proetidae (Trilobita). Palaeontographical
Society (Monographs), 98 pp. 15 pis.

* Paul, C. R. C. 1965. On the occurrence of Comarocyslites. or Sinclaiocystites (Paracrinoidea.
Comarocystidae) in the Starfish Bed. Threavc Glen, Girvan. Geological Magazine. London 102:
474-7, pi. 20.

1967. New Ordovician Bothriocidaridae from Girvan and reinterpretation of Bothriocidaris

Eichwald. Palaeontology, London 10: 52.5-541.
* 1973-84. British Ordovician Cystoids. Pt. 1.: Introduction etc. and Class Diploporita.

Palaeontographical Society (Monographs) 1973: 1-64. 11 pis. Pt. 2.: Class Rhombifcra.

Palaeontographical Society (Monographs) 1984: 65-182. pis. 12-26.

* Peach, B. N. and Home, J. 1899. The Silurian Rocks of Britain. Part I. .Scotland. Memoirs of the
Geological Survey of Great Britain, xviii + 749. ]More than 24 references to (iray CoH'n. in the
Index; pp. 686-97 a 'List of Fossils prepared by Mrs. Gray from the collections made by her from
the Silurian Rocks of the Girvan District]

* Peach, B. N., Home, J. and Macconochie, A. 1901 . The Silurian Rocks in the South of Scotland.
In Elliott. G. F. Scott, Laurie, M & Murdoch. J. Barclay. Fauna, Flora and Geology of the
Clyde Area. British Association Handbook, Glasgow: pp 42.3^i4 [Gray CoH'n. p. 428[

* Peel, J. S. 1975. Arjamannia a new upper Ordovician —Silurian pleurotomariacean gastropod
from Britain and North America. Palaeontology , London. 18: 385-390.

MRSEl IZABETHGRAY 239

Pojeta, John 1971. Review of Ordovician Pclecypods. Professional Papers U.S. Geological Survey
695: 46 pp. 2(1 pis.

* Pojeta, J. & Runnegar, B. 1976. The Paleontology of Rostroconch Mollusks and the Early
History of the Phylum Mollusca. Professional Papers U.S. Geological Survey 968; iv + 88 pp. 54
pis.

* Ramsbottom, W. C. H. 1961. A monograph of British Ordovician Crinoidea. Palaeonlographical
(Monographs), 37 pp, K pis.

* Reed, F. R. C. 1903^1935. The Lower Palaeozoic Trilobites of the Girvan District, Ayrshire.
Palaeonlographical Socielv (Monographs): Parts 1-3, 1903-^: 1^8, 6 pis.; 49-96, pis. 7-13; 97-
186, pis. 14-20; Supplement I, 1914: .% pp, 8 pis; Supplement II, 1931: 30 pp; Supplement III,
1935; 64 pp, 4 pis.

* 1907. Sedgwick Museum Notes. Crustacea etc. from Girvan. Geological Magazine,

London, Dec. V, Vol. 4; 108-1 16, pi. 4.
* 1908(3. Sedgwick Museum Notes. New fossils from Girvan, Ischadiles Konigi Murchison.

Geological Magazine, London, Dec. V, Vol. 6: 291-296, pi. 12.
' 1908b. The structure of Turrilepas peachi and its allies. Transactions of the Royal Society of

£rf/>!b«rg/!46; 519-28, I pi.
* 1910. Lower Palaeozoic Hyolithidae from Girvan. Transactions of the Royal Society of

Edinburgh 47: 203-222, pis. 1-3.
* 1911. Sedgwick Museum Notes. A new fossil from Girvan. Geological Magazine, London,

Dec. V, Vol. 8: 337-9, pi. xv. \Helminlhochilon thraivensis].
* 1912. Sedgwick Museum Notes. Notes on the Genus Trinucleus. Pts. 1 & 2. Geological

Magazine, London, Dec. V, Vol. 9: 346-53; 385-94; pis. 18, 19.
* 1914. Sedgwick Museum Notes. Notes on the genus Trinucleus. Pt. III. Geological

Magazine, London, Dec. 6, Vol. 1: 349-59, pis. 28, 29.
* 1917. The Ordovician and Silurian Brachiopoda of the Girvan District. Transactions of the

Royal Society of Edinburgh 51: 795-998, pis. 1-24.
* 1920-21 . A Monograph of the British Ordovician and Silurian Bellerophontacea. Palaeonl-
ographical Society, (Monographs), viii + 92 pp, 13 pis.
* 1923. New Fossils from Girvan \Cornulites]. Geological Magazine. London 60; 268-276, pi.

12,
* 1924. Some New Ordovician and Silurian Fossils. [Tryblidium girvanense] Geological

Magazine, London 61: 25-31, pi. 3.

* 1925a. Some New Silurian Trilobites. Geological Magazine, London 62: 67-76, pi. 2.

* 1925fc. The Classification of the Acidaspidae. Geological Magazine, London 62: 416-30.

* 1926. Some New Ordovician and Silurian Fossils from Girvan. Transactions of the Royal

Society of Edinburgh 54: 735-9, I pi.

* 1928. Notes on the Family Encrinuridae. Geological Magazine, London 65: 51-77.

* 1931. A Review of the British Species of the Asaphidae. Annals and Magazine of Natural

History (m) 7: 441-472.
* 1935a. Some new brachiopods from Girvan. Annals and Magazine of Natural History (10)

16:1
' 19356. Palaeontological evidence of the age of the Craighead Limestone. Transactions of

the Geological Society of Glasgow 19: 340-72.
* 1940. New Ordovician Fossils from Girvan, Ayrshire. Annals and Magazine of Natural

Hi.Uory{]\)6: 154-69, pi. 8.

* Regnell, G. & Paul, C. R. C. 1981. Echinoderms from the Ordovician of the Girvan district,
Scotland, with the description of two new species. Transactions of the Royal Society of
Edinburgh (Earth Sciences) 72: 49-56.

* Rolfe, W. D. I. 1981 . Seplemchiton—A Misnomer. Journal of Paleontology 55(1): 675-678, 3 t.-
figs.

Salter, J. 1855. List of some of the Silurian Fossils of Ayrshire. Quarterly Journal of the geological
Society of London 7: 170-178. pis. viii-x.

* Shirley, J. 1931. A redescription of the known British Ordovician species of Calymene Is. I.).
Memoirs and Proceedings of the Manchester Literary and Philosophical Society 75: 1-33, 2 pis.

* Sinclair, G. W. 1949. The Ordovician Trilobite Eobronteus. Journal of Paleontology, Menasha.
23: 45-56, pis. 12-14.

240 R. J. CLEEVELY, R. P. TRIPP ANDY. HOWELLS

* Slater, I. L. 1407. A Monograph of British Conulariae. Palaeonlographicat Society, (Mono-
graphs). |ii] + 41 pp. 5 pis.

* Smith, A. B. 1980. Floridiscus girvanensis a new Edrioasteroid from the Ordovician of Ayrshire.
Scottish Journal of Geology. Edinburgh, 15: 275-279.

' Smith A. B. & Paul, C. R. C. 1982. Revision of the class Cyclostoidea (Echinodermata).
Philosophical Tran.'sactions of the Royal Society of London, Ser. B, Biological Sciences 296 (No.
1083): 577-684.

* Smith, S. 1930. The Calostylidac Roemer: A Family of Rugose Corals with Perforate Septa.
Annals and Magazine of Natural Wutorv (10) 5: 257-78, pis. 10-12. [Gray ColPn. p. 265-6]

* Spencer, W. K. 1914-1940. A Monograph of the British Palaeozoic Asterozoa. Palaeontographical
Society (Monographs). 540 pp. 37 pis. [for further details see Owen, H. G. 1965]

* 1929. The Starfish of the Scottish Palaeozoic Beds. Reports of the Briti.<ih Association.

Glasgow, 1928: 550. 567. 655
Steam. W. T. 1981. The Natural History Museum at South Kensington. A History of the British

Museum (Natural History) 1753-1980. 414 pp Heinemann/BMNH British Museum (Natural

History).
Strimple, H. Concerning Ordovician Neoarchaeocrinus. Journal of Paleontology 46: 450-1 , 1 t.-fig.

* Teichert, C. 1940. Cephalopoda from the Drummuck Group of the Girvan District. Transactions
of the Geological Society of Glasgow 20: lO.Vl 15, pis. 5 & 6.

' Tripp, R. P. 1954. Caradocian trilobites from mudstoncs at Craighead Quarry near Girvan,

Ayrshire. Transactions of the Royal Society' of Edinburgh 62: 655-693, pis. 1^.
* 1957. The trilobite Encrinurus multi.'segmentatus (Portlock) and allied Middle and Upper

Ordovician species. Palaeontology 1: 60-72, pis. 11. 12.
* 1958. Stratigraphical and geographical distribution of the named species of the trilobite

superfamily Lichadacea. Journal of Palaeontology 32: 574-582, pi. 85.
* 1967. Trilobites from the Upper Stinchar Limestone (Ordovician) of the Girvan District.

Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh 67: 43-93, pis. 1-6.
* 1979. Trilobites from the Ordovician Auchensoul and Stinchar Limestones of the Girvan

District, Scotland. Palaeontology 22: 339-361. pis. 37-40.
* 1980. Trilobites from the Ordovician Balclatchie and lower Ardwells groups of the Girvan

district. Scotland. Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh 71: 12.3-145. 4 pis. [other refs.

1962. 1965, 1976 also deal with Girvan taxa]

* Tripp, R. & Howells, Y. 1981. Catalogue of the described, figured and cited Ordovician and
Silurian Trilobites from the Girvan district. Scotland, in the British Museum (Natural History) . 2
Microfiche: 6 pp, British Museum (Natural History), London.

Watts, W. W. 1939. The Author of the Ordovician System: Charies Lapworth M.Sc, LL.D. F. R.
S.. F. G. S. Proceedings of the Geological Association. London 50: 235-286, 2 pis.

* Whittard, W. F. 1952. Cyclopygid Trilobites from Girvan and a note on Bohemilla. Bulletin
British Museum (Natural History). Geology 1: 305-24. pis. 32. 33.

* Whittington, H. B. 1950a. A Monograph of the British Trilobites of the family Harpidae.
Palaeontographical Society. ^5 pp. 7 pis.

19506. Sixteen Ordovician genotype trilobites. Journal of Paleontology. Tulsa 24: 531-565.

pis. 68-75, 9 t.-figs.

* Williams, A. 1959. A Structural History of the Girvan District, S.W. Ayrshire. Transactions of
the Royal Society of Edinburgh 63 ( 3 ) No . 27 : 629-67 .

1962. TTie Barr and Lower Ardmillan Series (Caradoc) of the Girvan District, south-west

Ayrshire. Memoirs of the Geological Society. London 3: 1-267, 25 pis.
Williams, A., Strachan. I., Basset, D. A., Dean, W. T., Ingham. J. K.. Wright. A. D., Whittington,

H. B. 1972. A correlation of Ordovician rocks in the British Isles. Special Report of the

Geological Society. London 3: 74 pp.
Williams, A. & Wright, A. D. 1981. The Ordovician— Silurian boundary in the Ciarih area of

southwest Powys. Wales. Geological Journal 16: 1-.39.

* Withers. T. H. 1922. The Cirripedia' I.epidocoleus in the Upper Ordovician Rocks of Scotland.
Annals and Magazine of Natural History (9) 9: 65.3-56, pi. x.

* 1926. Catalogue of the Machaeridia (Turrilepas and its allies) in the Department of Geology

XV + 99 pp, 8 pis. British Museum (Natural History).
Woodward, Henry. 1880. Notes on the Anomalocystidae, A remarkable family of Cystoidca found

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY

241

in the Silurian rocks of North America and Britain. Geological Magazine, London, Dec. II, Vol.
VII (No. V): 193-201.

1885. On a new species of Helminthoehiton from the Upper Bala (Silurian) of Girvan.

Ayrshire. Geological Magazine. London, Dec. 3, vol. 2: 352-8, pi. 9.

Young, J. 1868u. Specimens exhibited 26 March 1867. Remarks on four species of Silurian
Brachiopoda, new to Ayrshire. Proceedings of I he Glasgow Natural History Society 1; 169.

1868/). Specimens exhibited 31 March 1868. Note on a new brachiopod shell, Triglesia [sicj

gruyiana Davidson recently discovered in the Silurian strata of the Girvan valley, by Mrs Robert
Gray, ibid.: 207.
1875a. Notes on the Genera of extinct Fossil shells, Bellerophon and Porcellia; their classifi-
cation amongst the Mollusca, and their distribution in the Silurian and Carboniferous, ibid.: 16.

1875/). Specimens exhibited. 29 March 1870. Note on a small collection of Fossil

Brachiopoda from the neighbourhood of Girvan. Proceedings of the Glasgow Natural History
Society 2: 21-22.

1876a. Specimens exhibited 3 October 1871. Notes on a series of fossils from the Silurian

rocks of the Girvan Valley. Proceedings of the Glasgow Natural History Society 2: 166. [general
remarks on Gray Coll'n.]

1876/). Specimens exhibited 30 January 1872. Notes on a series of trilobites of Caradoc age

from the Silurian of the Girvan Valley, ibid.: 179-180.

1876c. Specimens exhibited 26 March 1872. Note on a series of graptolites from the Silurian

strata of the Girvan Valley, ibid.: 182-3.

1876(/. Specimens exhibited 29 April 1873. Record of Crinoid remains from the Silurian of

the Girvan district, ibid.: 216.

Young, (Professor) J. 1868. Specimens exhibited 26 March 1876 On new forms of Crustacea from

the Silurian rocks of Girvan. Proceedings of the Glasgow Natural History Society 1: 169-173.

1875. Specimens exhibited 19 December 1870. Note on a new species of Crustacean,

belonging to the genus Solenocaris. from the Silurian strata near Girvan, and on fragments,
probably the appendages of a trilobite or Limuloid Crustacean. Proceedings of the Glasgow
Natural History Society 1: 66-7.

1876. Specimens exhibited 28 October 1873. Note on Slenotheca Salter, a Silurian Fossil

from the Girvan district, ibid.. (2): 223.

APPENDIX 1

Letters between Mrs Gray and Thomas Davidson recorded in the Davidson's Letterbooks
between 1847-1884

Letterbooks in Palaeontology Library Archives, British Museimt (Natural History)

Period from 1st January 1847 to 19th May 1884

1. I January 1847 lo 11 May

2. 11 May 1X48 lo 31 December

3. 2 January 185(1 lo 31 December

4. 2 January 18.S1 to 23 July

5. 23 July 1852 to 15 August

6. 15 August 1853 to 17 November

7. 17 November 1X54 to 7 December

8. 10 December 1X55 lo W September

9. 19 September 1X56 to 111 October
10. 11 November 1X57 to 20 August
U. 20 August 1X59 lo 24 October

12. 27 October 1X6(1 lo 31 July

13. 7 August 1X62 lo 30 September

14. 2 October 1X63 lo 4 November

* These Letterbiioks were bequeathed to the BrUish Museum (Natural History) in ISS6 with the Davidson's Library and
Archive see Clecvely (IfS-l: %), Cocks (197S: 4).

184X

15

4 Novembc

1864 to 27 March

1867

1849

16

27 March

1867 to 20 April

1S6X

1850

17

23 April

1868 to 16 April

186*)

1852

18

19 June

1869 to 3 June

1X71

1853

19

9 June

1871 to 10 April

1X72

1854

20

10 April

1872 to 18 June

1873

1855

21

24 June

1873 to 31 August

1874

1856

22

2 September 1874 lo 29 January

1877

1857

23

29 January

1877 to 31 May

1878

1859

24

1 June

1878 lo 4 October

1879

1860

25

6 October

1879 lo 21 November

1880

1862

26

23 Novembc

1X80 to 24 November

1X81

1863

27

29 November 1881 to 3 July

1X83

1865

28

4 July

1883 to 19 May

1X84

242

R. J. CLEEVELY, R. P. TRIPP AND Y. HOWELLS

Chronological summary of entries relating to Mrs Gray

Date From Davidson's note

25 January I8hS Mr J. Young
5 March Mr J. Young

22 July Robert Gray
2y July Robert Gray

29 August Robert Gray
9 September Robert Gray

13 September Rec'd. Box of Silurian Brathiopods

17 September Robert Gray

16 October Ret'd. Mr Gray's box to Mr Young

21 October Mr Young writes he paid 3/- carriage for box

No letters recorded from the Grays after November 1865 and during 1866

1 December 1866 Mr Young but no reference to Grays

23 August 1867 Mr Young
28 August Mr Young

2y August Ret'd. 4 Girvan brachs from Hunterian

1 September Mr Young

18 September Robert Gray

7 October Mrs Gray Tripksia
15 October Mr Young

22 October Mrs Gray 'Triplesm' & Dacina perrugata

Dr. Young

1 November Robert Gray

4 November Rec'd box — 'some good things'

8 November Robert Gray Sent fossil / Ret'd. same day

11 December Mr Young Selected material from Gray Coll'n.

19 July 1868 Mrs Gray Sends 3 species / Ret'd. same day
15 September Mr Young Ref. to Mr & Mrs Gray collecting

9 December 1869 Mrs Gray Sent box of summer's collecting

15 February 1870 Ret'd. Mrs Gray's specimens

23 March Mrs Gray Rec'd. box back

23 November Mrs Gray Sent box of summer's collection; Keep good

specmns. of Siroph. Grayi

13 December Mis Gray Lept. Grayi

13 June 1871 Mrs Gray Rec'd. box back

27 June Davidson visited Robert Gray (a St. Vincent Str Branch. City of Glasgow Bank.

Nothing further durmg 1871. 1872. 1873

22 April 1874 Ret'd. box of Ayrshire Brachiopods

8 November Mrs Gray

1 September 1875 Mrs Gray Sends Siphoruiireiii &• l.ingula'
7 September Rec'd. Siphonolrela & 'I.ingulu

23 January 1876 Ret'd. Stphimotreia & l.ingula

24 August Mr Etheridge Mrs Gray has some more Girvan fossils

16 October Mr Young Brit Assoc Western Scolltsh Fossils

20 October Mr Young ? draw Mrs Gray's LiriguUi

30 October Mrs (iray Sends 5 Siphonotreta

2 November Mrs Gray Sends 4 I.inyiild

26 November Mr Young

mrs elizabeth gray 243

Date From Davidson's note

17 January 1877 Mrs Gray ? re her specimens

22 January Ret'd. Mrs Gray's specimens

29 January Mrs Gray Rec'd. specimens; asks for paper '!

23 February Davidson send copies of paper

5 April Mrs Gray Asks Davidson to determmc brachs.

25 July 1878 Davidson visited Mrs Gray fa' 13, Inverlcith Road

29 August Mrs Gray Sent 4 Brachiopods

23 September Ret'd. 4 specimens to Mrs Gray

12 September 1879 Mrs Gray Asks Davidson to determine specimens from

Doularg Barr; reports successful collecting season.

10 October Mrs Gray Sent fossils from Doularg

5 November Ret'd. all specimens to Mrs Gray

9 November Mrs Gray Rec'd. all specimens safely

4 June 1881 Mr Young Mrs Gray has gone to Ayrshire

7 November Mrs Gray Triplesia grayi; Nicholson's grant

19 November Mrs Gray Atrypa incerta. Girvan brachs.

Davidson Rec'd. box safe.

22 November Mr R. Etheridge Mrs Gray has given him her Lingula & Piscina

specimens

28 November Davidson ret'd. Triplesia specimens.

29 November Mr R. Etheridge Will forward Mrs Gray's specimens to Davidson
2 December Mrs Gray Rec'd. specimens safely

6 February 1882 Mrs Gray

11 February Mrs Gray Sent box oi Rhynchonetta

Davidson commenced his examination of Gray coll'n.

20 February Rec'd. box from Mrs Gray; 'very fine series'

24 February C. Lapworth re Girvan succession & Mrs Gray's coll'n.
27 February C. Lapworth

2 March Mrs Gray Send material horizon by horizon

13 March Mrs Gray Sent parcel: Whitehouse Bay fossils

14 March Mr Young

15 March C. Lapworth

20 March Mrs Gray Rec'd. box safe; preparing next

1 April Ret'd. 3rd lot of Girvan fossils

8 April Mrs Gray Rec'd. 3rd lot safe; prep'n. of 5th

12 April Ret'd. 4th lot of Girvan fossils

15 April Rec'd. 5th lot; 'large & very fine series'

17 April Mrs Gray Rec'd. |4th| lot safe; two more to send

27 April Mrs Gray Sent 6lh lot; large No. of specimens
8 May Mrs Gray Prep'n of 7th lot; Penkill material

17 May Note

22 May Davidson entry: 'I finished . Mrs Gray's collection'

24 May Ret'd. 7th lot of Girvan Brachiopoda

25 May C. Lapworth Rec'd. 'magnificient table'

26 May Mrs Gray Rec'd. list

14 June Mrs Gray

15 June C. Lapworth

30 June Mrs Gray Sends M. cymbula

10 July Ret'd. Merista cymbula

13 July Mrs Gray Sends 3 Leptaena

18 July Mrs Gray Rec'd. 3 Z-epWena back
10 August (Girvan) Mrs Gray

10 September Mrs Gray Removed to Bank of Scotland House

28 September Davidson sends PI. proofs

244

R. J. CLEEVELY, R. P. TRIPP AND Y. HOWELLS

Date

21 October
26 October
28 October
3 November
6 November

13 November

14 November

15 November
25 November

25 March

1883

Nothing further until;

3 September (Girvan)
28 November

25 January

26 January

1884

From

Mrs Gray
Mrs Gray
Mr Young
Mrs Gray
Mrs Gray
C. Lapworth
Mrs Gray
Mrs Gray
Mrs Gray

Mrs Gray

Mrs Gray
Mrs Gray

Mrs Gray

Davidson's note

Sends parcel of summer's specimens

Sends box of this year's fossils

Promises Ayrshire locality information
Preparing localily list

Locality list + Lapworth's comments

re mistake in list

Rec'd. box of fossils safely back

Appr'n. for his work on her coll'n.: Nicholson cS:
Etheridge have given up; she needs someone for
rest, especially Mollusca.

Apologies for not sendmg duplicates
Promise of a series of Duplicates

Sends box with a few duplicates

promise of more after Autumn visit

Rec'd. a small selection of Girvan Sil. fossils

Apparently nothing further for there are no other entries re Mrs Gray in the remaming volumes of Davidson's
letterbooks.

APPENDIX 2

Mrs Gray Correspondence in Palaeontology Library Archives,
British Museum (Natural History)

Summary of contents
Letters from

Mrs Elizabeth Gray

F. A. Bather
Smith- Woodward
Charles Lapworth
Robert Etheridge
Prof. T. Rupert Jones
JR. Gregory

F R. C. Reed
Thomas Davidson
J. Barrandc
J F. Blake
J. Home
Dr Pemer
Charles Schuchcrt
W K. Spencer
W. S. Boulton

G. F Herbert Smith
Frank H. Mclj;arn
Darcy W. Thompson
T. H. Withers

Vol. 1

86
65

Letters TO

Vol.2

9(1

Mrs Elizabeth (jray

41

F, A Bather

12

Dr. Smith-Woodward

4

Charles Lapworlh

-

Henrv Wot)dward

-

Prof. Fntsch

2

Dr Schondorf

-

F R. C Reed

-

Dr Wheellon Hmd

Vol. I Vol. 2

81

65

79

52

3

.39

2

2

1

_

1

-

1

-

mrs elizabeth gray
Letters from

F. A. Bather To:

Mrs Gray
Smith-Woodward

Fritsch
Schondorf

245

Vol. 1

Vol. :

Letters TO

Mrs Elizabeth Gray To:

Vol. I Vol. 2

3

38

DrF. A. Balher

79

51

2

Smith-Woodward

3

36

Charles Lapworth

-)

2

1

-

Henry Woodward

1

-

1

-

F R.'c Reed

1

-

Wheelton Hind

_

1

65

40

86

90

Mrs Elizabeth Gray Correspondence Vol. 1, 1874-1914

Date Writer

Mrs Gray
R. Etheridge
J. Barrande
T Davidson
J F Blake
R Etheridge
Mrs Gray
T. Rupert Jones
F. A. Bather
Mrs Gray
Mrs Gray
F. A. Bather
Mrs Gray
F. A. Bather
T. Rupert Jones
Mrs Gray
F A Bather
F. A. Bather
T Rupert Jones
Mrs Gray
F. A. Bather
Mrs Gray
Charles Lapworth
Alice Gray
Mrs Gray
F. A. Bather
Mrs Gray
F. A Bather
J. W. Gregory
J. W. Gregory
F. A. Bather
Mrs Gray
F. A. Bather
Mrs Gray
F A. Bather
Mrs Gray
F. A. Bather
F. A. Bather
Mrs Gray
Mrs Gray

No. 1

No. 2

24 November 1X74

No. 3

23 May 1876

No. 4

18 January 1877

No. 5

24 August 1878

No. 6

8 January 1881

No.GLm*

6 December 1884

No. 7

26 August 1885

No. 8

3 October 1892

No. 9

5 October 1892

No. 10

18 October 1892

No. II

20 October 1892

No. 12

26 October 1892

No. 13

29 October 1892

No. 14

5 June 1893

No.15

20 August 1894

No. 16

21 August 1894

No. 17

27 August 1894

No. 18

11 October 1895

No.19

17 February 1896

No.20

18 February 1896

No.21

20 November 1898

No.22

29 November 1898

No.23

?datef. 1938

No.24

11 June 1899

No,25

16 January 1899

No.26

28 June 1899

No.27

29 June 1899

No.28

19 December 1899

No.29

22 December 1899

No.30

9 March 1900

No.31

12 March 19(H)

No.32

14 March 1900

No.33

30 July 19IK)

No.34

31 July 19(K)

No.35

19 January 1901

No.36

22 January 1901

No.39

2 July 1901

No.37

19 June 1902

No.38

26 June 1902

To

Dr Charles Lapworth

Rbt. Gray

Mrs Gray

Mrs Gray

Mrs Gray

Mrs Gray

[Dr Henry Woodward]

Mrs Gray

Mrs Gray

DrF. A. Bather

Dr P. A. Bather

Mrs Gray

Dr F. A. Bather

Mrs Gray

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Mrs Gray

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Charles Lapworth

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Mrs Gray

Mrs Gray

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Dr Bather

246

Date

r. j. cleevely, r. p. tripp and y. howells
Writer To

No.40

5 July 1903

No.41

18 August 1903

No.42

19 August 1903

No.43

2 September 1903

No.44

3 September 1903

No.45

10 Apnl 1904

No.46

11 April 1904

No.47

14 April 1904

No.48

16 April 1904

No.49

25 June 1906

No.50

26 June 1906

No.51

4 July 1906

No.52

24 July 1907

No.53

26 July 1907

No.54

No.SS

27 August 1907

No.56

2 October 1907

No.57

4 October 1907

No.58

31 October 1907

No.59

1 November 1907

No.60

4 November 1907

No.61

6 November 1907

No.62

7 November 1907

No.63

2 December 1907

No.64

3 December 1907

No.65

9 January 1908

No.66

4 May 1908

No.67

6 May 1908

No.68

29 November 1908

No.69

1 December 1908

No.70

5 December 1908

No.71

? December 1908

No.72

23 February 1909

No.73

8 December 1909

No.74

15 December 1909

No.75

20 December 1909

No.83

8 July 1910

No.76

23 November 1910

No.77

25 November 1910

No.78

I December 1910

No.79

17 December 1910

No.80

17 December 1910

No.81

29 December 1910

No.82

2 January 1911

No.84

5 January 1911

No.85

21 January 1911

No.86

23 January 1911

No.87

28 January 1911

No.88

5 February 1911

No.89

6 February 1911

No.90

6 February 191 1

No.91

7 February 1911

No.92

10 February 1911

No.93

13 February 1911

No.94

14Februarv 1911

Mrs Gray
Mrs Gray
F. A. Bather
F. A. Bather
Mrs Gray
Mrs Gray
F A. Bather
Mrs Gray
F. A. Bather
Mrs Gray
F A. Bather
Mrs Gray
Mrs Gray
F. A. Bather
F. A. Bather
Mrs Gray
Mrs Gray
F A Bather
Mrs Gray
F A Bather
Mrs Gray
F. A. Bather
Mrs Gray
Mrs Gray
F A. Bather
J. Home
Mrs Gray
F. A. Bather
Mrs Gray
F. A. Bather
Mrs Gray
F. A Bather
F. R. C Reed
Mrs Gray
F A. Bather
Mrs Gray
Dr Pemer
Mrs Gray
F. A. Bather
Mrs Gray
Miss Mary Gray
F A Bather
Mrs Gray
F A Bather
Mrs Gray
Mrs Gray
F. A. Bather
Mrs Gray
Mrs Gray
F. A. Bather
F. A. Bather
Mrs Gray
Mrs Gray
F A Bather
Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Prof Dr. Anton Fritsch

Dr Bather

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Dr. F. Schondorf

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Mr Bather

Miss M. Gray

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY

Date

No. 95

15 February 1911

No.96

19 February 1911

No. 97

20 February 1911

No.98

23 February 1911

No. 99

25 February 1911

No. 100

February 1911

No. 101

7 March 1911

No. 102

7 March 1911

No. 103

7 March 1911

No. 104

9 March 1911

No. 105

31 March 1911

No. 106

8 April 1911

No. 107

13 April 1911

No. 108

17 April 1911

No. 109

29 April 1911

No. 110

15 May 1911

No.lll

30 October 1911

No. 112

30 October 1911

No. 113

31 October 1911

No, 114

7 November 1911

No. 115

8 November 1911

No. 115a

9 November 1911

No.116

18 May 1912

No.117

27 May 1912

No.118

29 May 1912

No.119

31 May 1912

No. 120

14 June 1912

No.121

17 June 1912

No. 122

9 November 1912

No. 123

11 November 1912

No. 124

16 November 1912

No. 125

19 November 1912

No.126

28 November 1912

No.127

6 December 1912

No.128

6 December 1912

No. 129

14 January 1913

No. 130

19 January 1913

No. 131

21 January 1913

No. 132

23 January 1913

No. 133

24 January 1913

No. 134

30 January 1913

No.135

1 February 1913

No.136

12 February 1913

No.137

19 February 1913

No.138

18 March 1913

No. 139

19 March 1913

No. 14(1

27 March 1913

No.141

27 August 1913

No. 142

29 August 1913

No. 143

3 December 1913

No. 144

4 December 1913

No. 145

12 February 1914

No. 146

14 February 1914

No. 148

16 February 1914

No. 1 47

3 March 1914

247

Writer

F. A, Bather
Mrs Gray
Mrs Gray
F. A, Bather
Mrs Gray
Mrs Gray
Mrs Gray
Mrs Gray
Mrs Gray
F. A. Bather
Charles Schuchert
F. A Bather
Mrs Gray
F. A. Bather
Mrs Gray
W. K. Spencer
Mrs Gray
Mrs Gray
F. A Bather
F. A. Bather
Mrs Gray
F. A. Bather
Mrs Gray
F. A. Bather
Mrs Gray
F. A. Bather
F. A. Bather
Mrs Gray
Mrs Gray
F. A. Bather
Mrs Gray
F. A. Bather
Mrs Gray
F. A. Bather
Mrs Gray
F. A. Bather
Mrs Gray
F. A. Bather
Mrs Gray
F. A Bather
Mrs Gray
F. A. Bather
F. A. Bather
F. A. Bather
Mrs Gray
F. A. Bather
Mrs Gray
Mrs Gray
F. A. Bather
Mrs Gray
F. A. Bather
Mrs Gray
F. A. Bather
Mrs Gray
Mrs Gray

To

Mrs Gray
Dr Bather
Dr Bather
Mrs Gray
Dr Bather
Mr Reed
Dr Bather
Dr Bather
Dr Bather
Mrs Gray
Mrs Gray
Mrs Gray
Dr Bather
Mrs Gray
Dr Bather
Mrs Gray
Dr Bather
Dr Bather
Mrs Gray
Mrs Gray
Dr Bather
Mrs Gray
Dr Bather
Mrs Gray
Dr Bather
Mrs Gray
Mrs Gray
Dr Bather
Dr Bather
Mrs Gray
Dr Bather
Mrs Gray
Dr Bather
Mrs Gray
Dr Bather
Mrs Gray
Dr Bather
Mrs Gray
Dr Bather
Mrs Gray
Dr Bather
Mrs Gray
Mrs Gray
Mrs Gray
Dr Bather
Mrs Gray
Dr Bather
Dr Bather
Mrs Gray
Dr Bather
Mrs Gray
Dr Bather
Mrs Gray
Dr Bather
Dr Bather

248

Date

r. j. cleevely, r. p. tripp andy. howells
Writer To

No. 149

4 March 1914

No. 150

12 March 1914

No.151

13 March 1914

No. 152

17 March 1914

No. 153

19 March 1914

No. 154

12 April 1914

No. 155

20 May 1914

No. 156

10 June 1914

No. 157

12 June 1914

No. 158

27 July 1914

No. 159

29 July 1914

No. 160

9 October 1914

No.161

10 October 1914

No. 162

13 October 1914

No. 163

15 October 1914

No. 164

19 October 1914

No. 165

14 December 1914

No. 166

18 December 1914

No. 167

20 December 1914

F. A. Bather
Mrs Gray
F. A. Bather
Mrs Gray
F. A. Bather
Charles Lapworth
Mrs Gray
Charles Lapworth
Mrs Gray
Mrs Gray
Mrs Gray
Mrs Gray
F. A. Bather
Mrs Gray
F. A Bather
Mrs Gray
Mrs Gray
F A Bather
Mrs Gray

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Mrs Gray

Dr Smith Woodward

Mrs Gray

Dr Smith Woodward

Dr Bather

Dr Smith Woodward

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

• GUH = GENERAL LIBRARY HandwntTng colleclion

Mrs Elizabeth Gray Correspondence Vol. 2. 1915-1923

Date Writer

F A. Bather

F. A Bather

Mrs Elizabeth Gray

Mrs Elizabeth Gray

Mrs Elizabeth Gray

F A. Bather

Mrs Elizabeth Gray

Mrs Elizabeth Gray

Mrs Elizabeth Gray

F A. Bather

Mrs Elizabeth Gray

F. A, Bather

Mrs Elizabeth Gray

F. A. Bather

F. A. Bather

Mrs Elizabeth Gray

F A Bather

Mrs Elizabeth Gray

F A. Bather

F A Bather

Mrs Elizabeth Gray

Mrs Elizabeth Gray

F. A. Bather

Mrs Elizabeth Gray

Mrs Elizabeth Gray

T. H Withers

Charles Schuchcrt

Mrs Elizabeth Gray

Charles Schuchert

No. 1

12 January 1915

No. 2

12 January 1915

No. 3

14 January 1915

No. 4

21 January 1915

No. 5

.30 June 1915

No. 6

4 February 1915

No. 7

5 February 1915

No. 8

9 February 1915

No. 9

28 July 1915

No. 1(1

-30 July 1915

No. 11

2 August 1915

No. 12

5 August 1915

No. 13

11 August 1915

No. 14

21 August 1915

No.15

16 October 1915

No. 16

20 October 1915

No.I7

21 October 1915

No. 18

25 October 1915

No.19

26 October 1915

No.20

6 November 1915

No.21

8 November 1915

No.22

9 November 1915

No.23

10 November 1915

No.24

13 November 1915

No.25

16 November 1915

No.26

17 November 1915

No.27

28 November 1915

No.28

13 December 1915

No.29

13 January 1916

To

Mrs Gray

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Dr Smith Woodward

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Dr Smith Woodward

Dr Bather

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Mrs Robert Gray

Dr Bather

Mrs Elizabeth Gray

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY

Date

No, 30

20 January 1916

No. 31

22 January 1916

No. 32

31 January 1916

No.33

4 February 1916

No. 34

6 February 1916

No. 35

111 February 1916

No. 36

14 February 1916

No. 37

21 June 1916

No. 38

6 December 1916

No. 39

7 December 1916

No. 40

10 December 1916

No.41

31 January 1917

No. 42

9 February 1917

No. 43

12 February 1917

No. 44

16 April 1917

No, 45

2(1 November 1917

No. 46

7 January 1918

No.47

11 December 1917

No. 48

111 January 1918

No.49

24 January 1918

No.50

25 October 1918

No.51

26 October 1918

No.52

16 December 1918

No.52a

21 December 1918

No.53

21 December 1918

No.54

1 January 1919

No.55

9 January 1919

No.56

13 January 1919

No.57

22 January 1919

No.58

10 February 1919

No.59

4 March 1919

No.60

19 June 1919

No.61

22 June 1919

No.62

24 September 1919

No.63

20 September 1919

No.64

5 November 1919

No.65

13 January 19211

No.66

16 January 1920

No.67

9 February 1920

No.68

10 February 1920

No. 69

14 February 1920

No.7l)

12 February 1920

No.71

21 February 1920

No.72

25 February 1920

No.73

26 February 1920

No. 74

27 February 1920

No.75

2 March 1920

No.76

6 March 1920

No.77

8 March 1920

No. 78

8 March 19211

No.79

10 March 1920

No.80

22 March 19211

No.81

24 March 1920

No.82

25 March 1920

No.83

29 March 1920

249

Writer

Mrs Elizabeth Gray
F. A. Bather
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
F. A. Bather
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
F. A. Bather
Mrs E. Gray
Charles Schuchert
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
F. A. Bather
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
Frank H. McLearn
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
Chas. Lapworth
Charles Schuchert
Chas. Lapworth
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
W. K. Spencer
F A. Bather
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
F. A. Bather
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
F. A. Bather
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
A. Smith Woodward
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
A. Smith Woodward
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
F. A. Bather
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
F. A. Bather
Chas. Lapworth
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
Charles Lapworth
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
F. A. Bather
F. A. Bather
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
A. Smith Woodward
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
A. Smith Woodward
F. A. Bather
A. Smith Woodward
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
A. Smith Woodward
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
A. Smith Woodward
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
A. Smith Woodward

To

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Mrs Elizabeth Gray

Dr Lapworth

Mrs Gray

Mrs Gray

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Dr Woodward

Mrs Gray

Dr Woodward

Mrs Gray

Dr Woodward

Mrs Robert Gray

Dr Bather

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Mrs Gray

Dr Lapworth

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Mrs Gray

Dr Woodward

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Dr Woodward

Dr Woodward

Mrs Gray

Dr Woodward

Mrs Gray

Dr Woodward

Dr Woodward

Mrs Gray

Dr Woodward

Dr Woodward

Mrs Gray

Dr Woodward

Mrs Gray

250

Date

r.j. cleevely, r. p. tripp andy. howells
Writer To

No.84

31 March 1920

No.85

5 April 1920

No.86

9 April 1920

No.87

22 April 1920

No.88

22 April 1920

No.88a

No.88b

No.89

21 May 1920

No.90

27 May 1920

No.91

27 May 1920

No.92

3 June 1920

No.93

15 June 1920

No.94

16 June 1920

No.95

23 June 1920

No.%

23 June 1920

No.97

23 June 1920

No.98

29 June 1920

No.99

6 July 1920

No. 100

8 July 1920

No. 101

12 July 1920

No. 102

15 July 1920

No. 103

20 July 1920

No. 104

2 August 1920

No. 105

3 September 1920

No. 1 05a

8 September 1920

No. 105b

13 September 1920

No. 106

21 October 1920

No. 107

25 October 1920

No. 108

3 November 1920

No. 109

4 November 1920

No.llO

29 November 1920

No. HI

1 December 1920

No.112

4 January 1921

No. 113

31 January 1921

No.114

3 February 1921

No.115

23 February 1921

No. 116

8 March 1921

No.117

9 March 1921

No. 118

10 March 1921

No.119

10 March 1921

No. 120

14 March 1921

No.121

14 March 1921

No. 122

1 June 1921

No.123

6 June 1921

No. 124

8 July 1921

No. 1 25

3 September 1921

No. 126

21 September 1921

No. 127

23 September 1921

No. 128

8 October 1921

No. 129

12 October 1921

No. 130

17 October 1921

No.131

18 October 1921

No. 132

25 October 1921

No. 133

26 October 1921

No. 134

8 November 1921

Mrs Elizabeth Gray
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
F. A. Bather
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
Mrs E. Gray
Mrs E. Gray
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
Mrs E. Gray
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
F. A Bather
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
F. A. Bather
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
A. Smith Woodward
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
Mrs E. Gray
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
Mrs E. Gray
Mrs E. Gray
Mrs E. Gray
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
F. A. Bather
Mrs E. Gray

F. A. Bather

A. Smith Woodward
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
Mrs Elizabeth Gray

G. F. Herben Smith
Darcy W. Thompson
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
F. A. Bather

Mrs Elizabeth Gray
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
F. A. Bather
F. A. Bather
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
W. S. Boulton
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
A. Smith Woodward
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
A. Smith Woodward
W S. Boulton

Or Woodv^ard

Dr Woodward

Mrs Robert Gray

Dr Woodward

Dr Woodward

Dr Woodward

Dr Woodward

Dr Bather

Dr Bather

Dr Woodward

Dr Bather

Dr Woodward

Dr Hind

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Dr Woodward

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Dr Woodward

Dr Bather

Dr Woodward

Dr Bather

Dr Bather

Dr Bather

Dr Bather

Dr Bather

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Mrs Gray

Dr Woodward

Dr Woodward

Dr Woodward

Dr A. S. Wtxidward

Mrs Gray

Dr Woodward

Dr Bather

Mrs R. Gray

Dr Woodward

Dr Bather

Dr Woodward

Dr Woodward

Dr WtHKlward

Dr Woodward

Mrs Gray

Mrs Gray

Dr Bather

Dr Bather

Mrs Gray

Dr Woodward

Mrs Gray

Dr Woodward

Mrs Gray

Mrs 'Bray'

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY

Date

No. 135

21 February 1922

No. 136

9 March 1922

No. 137

HI March 1922

No. 138

13 March 1922

No. 139

1 March 1922

No. 14(1

24 March 1922

No, 141

17 June 1922

No. 142

17 June 1922

No. 143

19 December 1922

No. 144

27 December 1922

No. 145

23 January 1923

No. 146

23 January 1923

No. 147

No. 148

26 January 1923

No. 149

29 January 1923

No. 150

22 November 1923

No. 151

23 November 1923

No. 152

12 December 1923

No. 153

14 December 1923

No.154

21 December 1923

No. 155

28 December 1923

251

Writer

J. W. Gregory
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
F. A. Bather
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
J W Gregory
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
F. A. Bather
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
F. A Bather
F. A. Bather
F. A. Bather
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
F. A. Bather
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
F. A. Bather
Mrs Elizabeth Gray
F. A. Bather
F. A. Bather
F. A. Bather

To

Dr Bather
Dr Woodward
Mrs Gray
Dr Bather
Mrs Gray
Dr Woodward
Dr Bather
Mrs Gray
Dr Bather
Dr Bather
Mrs Gray
Mrs Gray
List of Fossils
Dr Bather
Mrs Gray
Dr Bather
Mrs Gray
Dr Bather
Mrs Gray
Mrs Gray
Mrs Gray

APPENDIX 3

List of Alice Gray letters in General File, British Museum (Natural History)
Date Writer To

No. 1

1 March 1924

No. 2

3 March 1934

No. 3

|7 May 1934)

No. 4

14 May 1934

No. 5

24 January 1937

No. 6

26 January 1937

No. 7

29 January 1937

No. 8

7 February 1937

No. 9

11 February 1937

No.lO

2 April 1937

No. 11

22 March 1937

No.l2

23 March 1937

No.13

25 March 1937

No.l4

28 March 1937

No.15

31 March 1937

No.16

22 April 1937

No.l7

4 May 1937

No.18

6 May 1937

No. 19

11 May 1937

No.20

25 May 1937

No.21

29 May 1937

No.22

29 July 19.37

No.23

30 July 1937

No.24

16 October 1937

No.25

19 October 1937

A. S. Alexander
Alice Gray
T H Withers
Alice Gray
Alice Gray
W. N. Edwards
W. D. Lang
Alice Gray
W. D. Lang
Alice Gray
Alice Gray
Alice Gray
W, D. Lang
Alice Gray
Alice Gray
W. D Lang
Alice Gray
Alice Gray
W. N. Edwards
Alice Gray
W. N. Edwards
Alice Gray
L. Bairstow
Alice Gray
L. Bairstow

Miss Alice Gray

T. H Withers

Miss Alice Gray

Mr Withers

Dr Lang

Miss Alice Gray

Miss Alice Gray

Dr Lang

Miss Alice Gray

Dr Lang

Dr Lang

Dr Lang

Miss Alice Gray

Dr Lang

Dr Lang

Miss Alice Gray

Dr Lang

Dr Lang

Miss Alice Gray

W. N. Edwards

Miss Gray

Dr Lang

Miss Alice Gray

Mr Bairstow

Miss Alice Gray

252

Date

r. j. cleevely, r. f. 1 ripf and y. howells
Writer To

No.26

29 October 1937

No.27

29 October 1937

No.28

30 October 1937

No.29

5 December 1937

No.30

8 December 1937

No.31

10 December 1937

No.32

12 December 1937

No.33

1? December 1937

No.34

17 December 1937

No.35

13 January 1938

No.36

1 February 1938

No.37

2 February 1938

No.38

3 February 1938

No.39

8 February 1938

No.4()

12 February 1938

No.41

14 February 1938

No.42

17 February 1938

No.43

21 February 1938

No.44

23 February 1938

No.45

27 February 1938

No.46

1 March 1938

No.47

14 March 1938

No.48

23 March 1938

No.49

31 March 1938

No.5U

28 April 1938

No.51

5 May 1938

No.52

9 May 1938

No.53

24 May 1938

No.54

26 May 1938

No.55

27 May 1938

No.56

13 August 1938

No.57

16 August 1938

No.58

19 August 1938

No. 59

27 August 1938

No.6()

17 September 1938

No.61

7 October 1938

No.62

31 October 1938

No.63

4 November 1938

No.64

8 November 1938

No.65

11 November 1938

No.W)

11 November 1938

No.67

14 November 1938

No.68

21 November 1938

No.69

5 December 1938

No.70

6 December 1938

No.71

21 May 194()

No.72

31 May 1940

No.73

2 June 1940

No.74

4 June 1940

No.75

19 August 1940

No.76

7 June 1941

No.77

15 June 1941

No.78

19 August 1941

No.79

24 August 1941

Alice Gray

Alice Gray

L. Bairstow

Alice Gray

W. D. Lang

Dr H. H Muir-Wood

Alice Gray

Alice Gray

W. N. Edwards

F. R. C. Reed

Alice Gray

F. R. C. Reed

W. D. Lang

W. D. Lang

W. D. Lang

Alice Gray

W. N. Edwards

Alice Gray

W. D. Lang

Alice Gray

W. D. Lang

L. F. Bairstow

L. Bairstow

Alice Gray

Leslie Bairstow

Alice Gray

Leslie Bairstow

Alice Gray

WD. Lang

Leslie Bairstow

W D. Lang

Alice Gray

Alice Gray

W. D. Lang

L. F. Bairstow

L. F. Bairstow

Alice Gray

Alice Gray

H. H Muir-Wood

Alice Gray

Alice Gray

W N Edwards

Alice Gray

Alice Gray

W. N. Edwards

Alice Gray

W. N. Edwards

Alice Gray

W. N. Edwards

Alice Gray

W. N. Edwards

Alice Gray

W N. Edwards

Alice Ciray

Mr Bairstow

Dr Lang

Miss Alice Gray

Dr Lang

Miss Alice Gray

Miss Alice Gray

Dr Muir-Wood

Dr Lang

Miss Alice Gray

Miss Gray

Dr Lang

Miss Gray

Miss Alice Gray

Miss Alice Gray

Miss Alice Gray

Dr Lang

Miss Alice Gray

Dr Lang

Miss Alice Gray

Dr Lang

Miss Alice Gray

Miss Gray

Miss Alice Gray

Mr Bairstow

Miss Alice Gray

Mr Bairstow

Miss Alice Gray

Dr Lang

Miss Gray

Miss Alice Gray

Miss Gray

Dr Lang

Dr Lang

Miss Gray

Miss Gray

Miss Gray

Dr Lang

Miss Wood

Miss Gray

Miss Muir-Wood

Leslie Bairstow

Miss Alice Gray

Mr Edwards

Mr Edwards

Miss Alice Gray

Mr Edwards

Miss Gray

W. N. Edwards

Miss Gray

W. N. Edwards

Miss Gray

W. N. Edwards

Miss |Alice| Gray

W. N. Edwards

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY

Alice Gray — F. A. Bather Correspondence

Date

253

No. 1

February 1924

No. 2

24 February 1924

No. 3

27 February 1924

No. 4

18 March 1924

No. 5

19 March 1924

No. 6

22 February 1925

No. 7

23 February 1925

No. 8

29 January 1926

No. 9

31 August 1926

No. 10

12 September 1926

No. 11

14 September 1926

No. 12

14 July 1932

No.13

12 December 1932

No. 14

13 December 1932

No. 15

14 March 1933

No. 16

19 March 1933

Writer

Alice Gray
Alice Gray
F A Bather
Alice Gray
F. A Bather
Alice Gray
F. A Bather
Alice Gray
F A. Bather
Alice Gray
F A Bather
Alice Gray
Alice Gray
F. A Bather
L. Bairstow
Alice Gray

To

Dr Bather
Dr Bather
Miss Alice Gray
Dr Bather
Miss Alice Gray
Dr Bather
Miss Alice Gray
Dr Bather
Miss Alice Gray
Dr Bather
Miss Alice Gray
Dr Bather
Dr Bather
Miss Alice Gray
Miss Alice Gray
L. Bairstow

Summary of all Alice Gray Correspondence [95 letters]
Letters from Letters To

Alice Gray =

48

Alice Gray =

47

F. A. Bather

6

F. A. Bather

8

Dr. W. D. Lang =

13

Dr. W. D. Lang =

21

W. N. Edwards =

11

W. N. Edwards =

8

L. F. Bairstow =

11

L. F. Bairstow =

6

F. R. C. Reed

2

T. H. Withers

1

T. H. Withers

2

H. U. Muir-Wood =

2

H. H. Muir-Wood =

3

A. Alexander =

1

254

R. J. CLEEVELY, R. P. TRIPP AND Y. HOWEl.LS

S >

n
X

c
o
N

< <

m
z

>

i
f

3
O

a

r^2 ■^ot^NC>%— >>oc

m*^ tuwtuiuo wo2

z< zzzzSzSz

2 UJ o O Sj
ifl Z S 2 Z

< Z Z < I

Q
Z

a.

z z

> >

>

_1

z

■a
c

C

-1

£

o

-•£

-a

^

C

c/i

cx

c

n

rr

t

C

s

CZ

i

"O

o

i

C

i/"i

o

"^

6

t

3

'c

i

o

E

^

C/)

11

C3

<

-1

E

6
E

E

-^ i^ -^ ,

: 2 "^^

5 E
< <

3^2

3- E X

111

^ ^1

1, ■■ 5 ^
d • X Z

0 <L» ™ ^

lllg

■2 = S i-
^ 9 5 Q

S
O

o
z

o
u

3 ill

UJ

< < < < <

o -1
ra <
CO CD

E
m

3 E

CD f ,

Z

T3 '^

T3 >.

c t:

° Z a. g

CO ? CO

LU UJ

C

5

JS o 2

ffl CQ ffi

o

»

tn

c

E

«

£

at

O

OC

t: E

W •§ _^

■- o p -o

S>

-i' «A, iS

„ J3 i 5 o
3 a. y r__

^ p-- = .^

E II

II !=

■" E

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY

255

z z

ID

z

O £ r~

i/i 5 ""■

p ID -

■B ja n

O "c t/5
« ly-, O

3 - '&

|lo

s = y.

j; I ?:

^ ii II

_• c Z

Ij ,/ W

c c O

o u —

e .S'<
o S a:
u u o

I =

E S

P i-J

& a.
D. a.

z z

• a

^t

O g

= 5- -

73 O ^ E

£ >. 3

"x 2 i:
Z. P

cm -o

si

o o

o^ o r1 r^l
'T. 'J-i 00 oc

^ ^ i i

'u <

ra > -yi ?3

J J < b:

o o 2 g.
S S z I

I

on =

£

Z 1

u o o o

Z 2

uj (2 w

2

13

S

^^^

1

0

z z z

I

X

c
6

z

t -a

eg U
Ot3

•o 5

§-^
a: u

I ;;

— 1^

; I S

•o

T3

ra

cfl

0

O

o

O

It

u

•o

T3

sz z

ra c c

Woo

i 5 E

E :a

5^

O 1,

U. ;3

ra O
Q Q

, CO

z ^

- — i

^ E E D
O 5 2
Q Q Q

5 - .5 =

8u

^- <
.E O

■5,0
1 1

= U. ^ E
j: ,S O " *

:2s £

^ -c i»

II ^ -o

_!

_o _0

O U CJ

s <

^ I if I
c^ "if "2 ■£
S 12 12 i2

f*~i t w"i 'O r-- X

u 1) 1* o a> w

S S S

X X X X I X

o &■

o
I £

^ ?

E =

.2 -3 ■g'.S =

256

R. J. CLEEVEIY, R. P. TRIPP AND Y. HOWELLS

o

X

S

s *

0 o

1 I

3S

12 u

v-1 t^

E/10
E/11
E/16

=a

^ 1

=a =a

^ =« =a

z

Z X

z z

z z z

o o

13 ti) aj

I Z z 2 2

:SO

_^

1 a

5

o

z <

i <

I

£

£

5

o

0

o

z

UJ

^

z

ii

E

I I

0^1

5 E ^

_ O <
U y, ■

•o 5 —
n -^ —

£• B

£
5

o

E -d
S OS

2 .E

c

o
c

MRS ELIZABETH GRAY

257

i

Jo

S D

>,

>> -^

>^

« ON

^. td —

«

rs Gra;
lice Gr
Dwells/

< I

S < I

2

<

z

>

9

•C

T O

w

c

o

iS

C

■U 3

w

■o

>

ra (U

DO

c

-> z

■o

<n

O

c x:

CI

s

•*-

^ ^

QJ

1)

0

o

0 o

c

o

z

UJ

o

S U

Q

Z

1 o

c

UJ

(A

f^

Q

c/^

11

3
"O

1

I

|E

Z

<

1

z

E

r^i

8

3

s

s 2
o

_1
PJ

z

ir,

C

z

w
a.

E « n 2 g 5>

= T3 3 -; a. -^

C Z .5 .

1* .C

E

S = '" ^

o

c

'o

E

OJ

>,

3

3

Ot)

03

o

<u

i.

0

a.

X

^

a

It

«j

z

x:
c

E

o — ™ =

00 2

r-j P3 y-, ^

_w

jc

OJ

<u

»

S

o

o

X

X

z <

■jl^tijUJO WW W

i<zzS zz z

E

s

z

5

O B

o

■ w

o
s

z

Z Z I

258

R. J. CLEEVtLV, R. P. TRIPP AND Y. HOWIXLS

^

3
O

Vi

4i

>^ 3C O^ >»

O W UJ o

o

Gray
Gray
ler 198

Gray
Gray

'clls/18

U

£■=« ^ c

'->

•- ^ ra

M 'H

IC V. *

Di

S Z Z 5

<

SSI

< z

SSI

I

e-
I

§■

i

■«

s

tu
z

z

£

.^;-

3

^

a

d

3

3
0

c

o

«

c5

CD

E

£

oo

>

(J

0

0

u

X

>

^

U.

flj

73

~J

0

E

>.

u

5!

UJ

L/"(

^

:::

C/)

U

S

1

2

.2^

c

Si

3
0

0

O
a:
O

E

3

E

d

3

0

a.
c
c

z

LU

c/i

>
c

i

3

u.

y)

UJ

UJ

0

■^

'c

0

I

— '

CQ

z

[f

5

r3

"*

ra

0

U
o

d

i ii

I

IT

tu
E

3

UJ

>

<

UJ

>

<

E

B

0

0

f2

<

=

<

5>

a:

o:

E

u

E

II

I

j=

C13

^^

I

I

1

M

t«

on

C/5

[«

f-

h

H

<5§

UJ

=3 =a

C/5 C/5

>

_1

>

C/5

wo

>■ Ir -o

< Z a

ffl O g.

UJ 0- g

go >,

O < o

•E _J n

W Q .2

Get;

xo ^

I!

— ^

oj . .
J= c

— c

c —
■- 3-

> —

'■J C

(/I u
O c

■e I

id «

E b, 1^

— ■> s-
= =s

.■5 ^ ;,

i

U — rt

i> p- ^

I

W ^ o

>■

=« o 5

u 0 ^- >-.

- z -g 55 3 ■■

II S 1 1 -

=

—

re

re
0

?

>%

y

^

<

E

"ra

J

II

>

0

II

>.

2

>,

re

CL

II

nj

0

II

0

LU

0

0

O^

H

^

^

_u

y/'t

-]

z

s <?

e-
I
(-
d

4 (^i

o ?>

1 1

^

Revista Latinoamericana de Historia
de las Ciencias y la Tecnologia

Editor: Juan Jose Saldana (University of Mexico)

Quipu (Latin American Journal of History of Science and
Technology), is devoted to the history of science and tech-
nology in Latin America, Founded in 1984. it is published
three times a year. Contributions are welcome and articles are
accepted in Spanish, English, Portuguese and French, Quipu
has become indispensable for all those who study Latin Ameri-
can science and technology as well as for scholars interested
in the diffusion of science in different cultural contexts.

Suscription rates for 1989,
including postage and handling:

Latin America:
Individual US $25
Institutional US $40

All other regions:
Individual US $25
Institutional US $60

A complementary collection of Quipu is:

QUIPU NOTEBOOKS
The price of each volume, including postage and handling:

Latin America: US $10 All other regions: US $15

4T€lro»« Cull HI al

m\L

Orders and suscriptions by check or money order:

Quipu. Apartado Postal 21-873,04000M^xico,DF. MEXICO

CONTENTS

Mrs Elizabeth Gray (1831-1924):
a Passion for Fossils

R. J CLEEVELY, R. P. TRIPP & Y. HOWELLS

bulletin British M...;P..m /Natural Hi>»tnrv^

HISTORICALSERIES

Vol.17, No. 2, November 1989

"»-C ->{'■>■ , i > <■ ■K».T.>< '.'!! V,^^.'

Bulleti
British IVIusi
(Natural History)

r>Y

Historical Series

VOLUME 18 NUMBER 1

31 MAY 1990

The Bulletin of the British Museum of Natural History, instituted in 1949,
is issued in four scientific series. Botany, Entomology. Geology
(incorporating Mineralogy) and Zoology, and an Historical Series.

The Historical Series is edited in the Museum's Department of Library Services
Head of Department: Mr R. E. R. Banks
Editor: Miss P. Gilbert

Papers in the Bulletin are primarily the results of research carried out on the
unique and ever-growing collections of the Museum, both by the scientific staff
and by specialists from elsewhere who make use of the Museum's resources.
Many of the papers are works of reference that will remain indispensable for
years to come.

A volume contains about 256 pages, made up of two numbers: published Spring
and Autumn. Subscriptions may be placed for one or more of the series on an
Annual basis. Individual numbers and back numbers can be purchased and a
Bulletin catalogue, by series, is available. Orders and enquiries should be sent
to:

Sales Department,

Natural History Museum Publications,

British Museum of Natural History.

Cromwell Road.

London SW7 5BD

r^/ep/jow.- 01-938-9386
Telex: 929437 NH PUBS G
fa.v.- 01-938-8709

World List abbreviation: Bull. Br. Mus. nat. Hi.'it (hist. Ser.;
® British Museum (Natural History). 1990

ISBN 0 565 09013 5 Historical Series

ISSN 0068-2306 Vol 18. No. 1, pp 1 - 1 13

British Museum (Natural History)

Cromwell Road

London SW7 5BD Issued 3 1 May 1 990

Typeset by J&L Composition Ltd, Filey, North Yorkshire

Printed in England by Henry Ling Ltd, The Dorset Press, Dorchester. Dorset

^liiA?

Riill Hr Mils. Nut. Hisl (Hisl. Scr ) 18(1) 1-23 Issued 31 M;iv IWll

i" ' P

collected during the cruises of ~ 7 JUN 1990
HMS Porcupine in 1869 and! ^J^W^^
1870, with notes on the Norman
collection of invertebrata and its /
acquisition by the British ^y ^^'^ ^0^5^
Museum (Natural History)

A. L. RICE ,

Institute of Oceanographic Sciences Deacon Laboratory, Wortnley,
Godalming, Surrey, U.K.

CONTENTS

Introduction 1

The Porcupine cruises 3

The fate of the decapods 8

The Norman Collection' and its acquisition by the British Museum

(Natural History) 17

Acknowledgements 20

Appendix. Authorship attribution of the species 20

References 21

INTRODUCTION

In preparation for a report on the decapod crustaceans collected during recent I.O.S.
investigations in the Porcupine Seabight to the southwest of Ireland, previous collections
from the same region have been reviewed. The earliest of these was obtained during a
series of oceanographic cruises to the west of the British Isles made in the paddle gun
vessel H.M.S. Porcupine (Fig. 1) in the summer of 1869. These cruises were very
significant in the development of deep sea biology since they included the collection of
the deepest dredge samples obtained prior to the Challenger Expedition of 1872-76.

The 1869 cruises, along with the short cruise of H M.S. Lightning the previous year
and that of the Porcupine to the Mediterranean in 1870, were the subject of Charles
Wyville Thomson's classic volume, The Depths of the Sea, published in 1873 shortly after
the Challenger began her epic voyage. Thomson's book summarised the slate of
oceanographic knowledge at the time and reviewed the main results of the Lightning and
Porcupine cruises. However, despite the uniqueness of the deep biological samples, large
parts of the collections were never worked up adequately. In particular, with the

A. 1 . RICE

Fig. 1 HMS Porcupine. A wooden, two-masted paddle gun-vessel, built at Deptford Dockyard in
1844, the Porcupine was 141 feet long and had a displacement of 490 tons. This rather poor
photograph, apparently the only one of the ship in existence, is reproduced by kind permission
of the Hydrographcr to the Navy.

parts of the collections were never worked up adequately. In particular, with the
exception of the isopods. very few of the crustaceans were reported upon at all except in
The Depths of the Sea. In the case of the decapods, Thomson mentioned three previously
undescribed crab species. DorhyrKhus thomsom (as Doryrichiis. see Holthuis, 1962).
Rochinia carpenteri (as Amalhia) and Cymonnmus granulatu.s (as Ethu.sa). Thomson
made it clear that he had been furnished with these names by A. M. Norman to whom
the study of the crustaceans had been entrusted. Norman had recognised these species as
new. but neither before the appearance of Thomson's book, nor subsequently, did he
publish descriptions of them. The Porcupine collections also included a fourth un-
described crab species, Ebalia nu.x. which was not mentioned by Thomson and first
appeared in print as a nomen nudum in a preliminary account of the voyage of the
Travailleur (Norman. 1880) and was subsequently figured in Milne-Edwards (1883) and
described in Pocock (1889). In the ensuing confusion the names have been variously
attributed to Norman, Thomson. Norman in Thomson. Milne-Edwards, and Norman in
Milne-Edwards (see Appendix I). Phis paper attempts to explain how this confusion
arose and to establish the correct authorship of the species concerned.

In dealing with these questions I have inevitably become embroiled with the "Norman
Collection", a large collection of crustaceans and many other invertebrate groups, which
came to the British Museum (Natural History) around the turn of the century. The
origins and history of this important collection do not seem to have been properly
documented in the past; brief details, particularly of the chronology of its acquisition by
the Museum, are therefore provided.

NOMENCLATURE OF CRABST

THE PORCUPINE CRUISES

Following the success of the short cruise of the Lightning in 1868, the larger and more
suitable Porcupine made three separate cruises during the summer of 1869, the first
under the scientific direction of J. G. Jeffreys, the second under C. W. Thomson and the
third apparently under the joint leadership of Thomson and W. B. Carpenter (see
Thomson, 1873; Deacon, 1971; Rice, 1986).

Fig. 2 Track of the first cruise of HMS Porcupine in 1869, with the station positions marked.
Redrawn from Thomson, 1873, plate II.

The first cruise (Fig. 2) lasted from 18 May to 13 July during which the Porcupine
worked along three loops to the west and north of Ireland; one across the northern part
of the Porcupine Seabight and back to Galway, a second running west from Galway
across the Porcupine Bank into the Rockall Trough and back to Killibegs, and a third

4 A. 1,. RICK

across the northern part of the Rockall Trough to the Rockall Bank and back to Lough
Swilly, after which the ship docked in Belfast. A total of 32 official dredging stations were
worked, down to 808 fathoms ( 1480m) on the first 'loop', to 1230 fathoms (2250m) on the
second, and to 1476 fathoms (27(K)m) on the third. An additional even deeper dredge
haul (station 11, 1630 fathoms) was apparently not successful since although Thomson
(1873, p. 142) included it in a table of dredging stations, neither he nor Jeffreys (1869)
mention it in their respective narratives. A number of dredge hauls, mostly in rather
shallow water but including the first haul of the cruise at a depth of 1 10 fathoms (200m)
some 40 miles off Valentia, were not given station numbers.

10' 5^

Fig. 3 Track of the second cruise of HMS Porcupine in 1869. Redrawn from Thomson, 187.^, pl.itc
III

Following the arrival of the Porcupine in Belfast. Thomson took over the scientific
direction from Jeffreys and the ship sailed once more on 17 July for the second cruise
(Fig. 3). The original intention had been to continue the work of the first cruise to the
east and north of Rockall to join up with the work in the Faeroe-Shetland Channel
accomplished from the Lightning the previous year. However, since dredging had
already been accomplished successfully down to almost 1500 fathoms, with abundant
animal life having been found at this depth, a new plan was adopted. Instead of
proceeding to the northern area where only relatively modest soundings were known to
occur, Thomson successfully applied to the Hydrographer. G. H. Richards, for permis-
sion to work to the south-west of Ireland where, some 250 miles west of Ushant. a
sounding of 25(K) fathoms was shown on the chart. Since there were few reliable
soundings deeper than about 3000 fathoms anywhere in the ocean, Thomson reasoned
that if they could demonstrate the existence of life down to 2500 fathoms '. . . the general
question would be virtually solved for all depths of the ocean, and any further

NOMENCLATURE OF CRABS 5

investigation of its deeper abysses would be mere matter of curiosity and of detail'
(Thomson, 1873, p. 93).

After calling at Queenstown to coal and to pick up Carpenter's son, P. H. Carpenter,
the Porcupine sailed once more on 19 July and proceeded in a roughly south-westerly
direction, dredging at relatively shallow depths as she crossed the Great Sole Bank and
the unsuspected very rough topography of the upper parts of King Arthur Canyon to the
south of the Goban Spur. Finally, on 22 and 23 July two successful dredge hauls were
obtained on the abyssal plain south of the Pendragon Escarpment at 2435 and 2090
fathoms respectively (stations 37 and 38), depths which were not to be exceeded until
February 1874 as H.M.S. Challenger saiicd from the Canaries towards the Antilles.

The Porcupine now steamed northwards once more, towards the southwestern tip of
Ireland, taking a series of four dredge samples on the Goban spur (Stations 39^2) and
three (43^5) on the eastern flank of the Porcupine Seabight. After coaling at
Haulbowline on 2 August the vessel reached Belfast on Wednesday 4. On August 7
Thomson summarised the results of the cruise in a letter to A. M. Norman (see Mills.
1980) which was presented at the annual meeting of the British Association in Exeter and
published in the Annual Report (Rep. Brit. Ass. 1869(1870): 1 15). That Norman should
work on the crustaceans collected was already decided, for Thomson ends his letter T
trust to your contributing the Crustacea, which will be sent to you as soon as possible.'
10' 5' 0"

Fig. 4 Track of the third cruise of HMS Porcupine in 1S69. Redrawn from Thomson, 1873, plate
IV.

Having been joined by W. B. Carpenter, and having had her boilers cleaned out, the
Porcupine sailed from Belfast on August 1 1 , making for Stornoway from where she was
to begin the third and final cruise of 1869 to extend the work of the Lightning the
previous year (Fig. 4). The ship left Stornoway on August 15 and returned three weeks

A. L. RICE

/Tr^

)r

NOMENCLATURE OF CRABS

Fig. 5 The Rev. Canon Alfred Merle Norman. 1831-1918. Both from undated portrait photo-
graphs: (left) published in f'roceedings of The Royal Society of London 1919 (Obituary Notiees)
B 90: xlvi-1 (see Stebbing, 1919); (right) from portrait collection of Library Services BM (NH).

8 A. I.. RICE

later, having called at Thorshaven and Lerwick and having worked 41 dredgingstations
between the Faeroes and Shetland and four to the east of Shetland. Finally,
on September 15 the Porcupine returned to Belfast where the scientists left her.

Following the success of the 1869 cruises the Porcupine was made available once more
in 1870. this time for work in the Mediterranean. As before, the total time available was
to be divided into separate cruises, the first part, from Falmouth to Gibraltar, to be
under the scientific direction of Jeffreys, and the Mediterranean cruise to be overseen by
Carpenter and Thomson. In the event Thomson was taken ill and did not participate in
the 1870 cruises.

The ship left Falmouth on July 4 and, after experiencing fog and contrary winds in the
western Channel, eventually reached the continental slope to the south of the Great Sole
Bank three days later. Between 7 and 1 1 July a series of nine dredge hauls were taken in
the region between 48°06' and 48°38'N and ^^l 1' and Kfl.S'W. This region is now known
to be highly dissected by canyons where a modern oceanographer would be very
reluctant to shoot a dredge or trawl for fear of losing the gear. In the relative ignorance
provided by traditional rope soundings the Porcupine seamen and scientists cheerfully
fished their gear repeatedly in the area at depths ranging between 93 and 717 fathoms
(170m and 1312m), apparently retrieving the dredge safely on each occasion and only
twice obtaining an unsatisfactory catch!

Jeffreys was now anxious to obtain some dredge hauls in the neighbourhood of the
very deep stations sampled the previous year. Unfortunately, however, the ship
encountered bad weather and had to make for Vigo, all of the remaining Porcupine
samples being from off the Iberian Peninsula and within the Mediterranean. Before
reaching Gibraltar Jeffreys worked a further 30 'official' dredge stations together with u
number in shallow waters which were not given station numbers. At Gibraltar he handed
over to Carpenter who took a total of 23 hauls in the western Mediterranean before
returning to Cowes on October 8.

THE FATE OF THE DECAPODS

In accordance with the intention expressed in Thomson's letter mentioned above, the
vast majority of the Lightning and Porcupine crustaceans were sent to the Rev. A.M.
Norman (Fig. 5). then serving as Rector of the coal-mining parish of Burnmoor in the
dioceses of Durham (Stebbing. 1919; Mills. 1980). Most of this material remained in
Norman's care for at least 28 years, eventually reaching the British Museum (Natural
History) in the 'Norman Collection" between 1898 and 1911.'

By the time Thomson was preparing The Depths of the Sea, Norman had obviously
carried out at least a preliminary examination of most of the decapod material collected
and had apparently begun to prepare some descriptive texts which were made available

' Perhaps not surprisingly. Norman, and probably the other specialists to whom the samples were sent, did not
receive all of the material collected. P. Herbert Carpenter, for instance, presented tive Dorhxmhits thommni.
four Mufttda teriuimana. and one Rtxhiniti ctirpenteri Ui the Museum in 1S82 (registered under H2 14). These
specimens are labelled as collected from the Pi)nupim' in the ■Ni)rth Atlantic, warm area', and must therefore
have been taken during the third cruise in l,Sb'> in which Carpenter participated. He presumably took them for
his own collection as souvenirs of the cruise and i1 is very likely that other material similarly fouiul its way into
private collections. Some of the material that followed the more ofhcial routes similarly failed to hnd its way
into the national collectums. the classic example being the molluscs which went to Jeffreys anil were ultimately
purchased by the .Smithsonian Institution ahmg with the rest of Jeffreys' collection (Waren. WKO).

NOMENCLATURE OF CRABS 9

to Thomson. On the basis of the information provided to him, Thomson recorded the
discovery of the following three new crab species."

Dorhynchus thomsoni Thomson, 1873

Thomson's treatment of this species consisted of the following short passage (p. 175). "A
pretty little stalk-eyed form Dorynchus ihomsoni, Norman (Fig. 34), small and delicate,
and very distinct from all previously described species of the genus, is very widely
distributed. This crab, from its long spiny legs and light body, very often comes up
entangled on the part of the rope which had been passing over the ground.'

Fig. 6 Thomson's original, and rather poor, illustration of Dorhynchus ihomsoni. (From The
Depths oflhe Sea. tig. .^4, p. 174).

This is a rather curious statement since this was the first mention of the genus
Dorynchus (later corrected to Dorhynchus (see Holthuis, 1962), so that there were no
'previously described species of the genus'. This almost certainly indicates that Norman
had initially intended to place the new species in an existing genus, probably Inachus. but
decided to establish the new genus after Thomson had already incorporated the original
concept. Alone, the text would certainly not establish the identify of the species beyond
doubt, but the illustration (Fig. 6), while not good, is certainly identifiable and can be
associated with the specimen (B.M.(N.H.) reg. no. 1907.8.28.5) on which the figure is
based. Following Thomson, the authorship of this species was consistently attributed to
Norman for almost a century until its correct attribution, to Thomson, was established by
Holthuis (1962) and the illustrated specimen was designated as the lectotype in
Christiansen (1969). The species is thus one of the few examples of a specific epithet
which is legitimately based on the same name as that of its author.

' From the preliminary account of the 1S7(I Porcupine cruise by Carpenter and Jeffreys (1870) it is clear that
Norman originally intended to give quite different names to two of these species; Elhusa granulaiu was to have
been /:'. mirahilis. while Amalhia Carpenleri was to have been A. Jeffreys:. However, since neither of these
original names were accompanied by descriptions they are both nomina nudii.

10

A. L. RICE

Rochinia carpenteri (Thomson, 1873)

Following on from the Dorhynchiis passage, Thomson wrote (p. 176) "Another handsome
new species, Amathia carpenteri. Norman (Fig. 35), was common in the sandy chalk-mud
of the "Holienia ground". The genus ha<J previously been familiar as a Mediterranean
form." As in the case of Dorhynchiis. this statement would clearly not identify the species
but. as before, the illustration (Fig. 7), which in this case is good, is readily identifiable
and can again be linked with the specimen on which it was based (B.1VI.(N.H.) reg. no.
1907.8.28.3). Again as in D. ihomsoni. the authorship of this species was consistently
attributed to Norman until its correct attribution was established by Sivertsen and Holthuis
(1956) and the illustrated specimen was selected as the lectotype by Christiansen (1969).

Fig. 7 Thomson's original illustration of Rochinia carpenteri (From The Depths of the Sea. fig. 35,
p. 17.5).

Cymonomus granulatus (Norman in Thomson, 1873)

The third new crab species is more problematical. Thomson did not illustrate this species
and mentions it in the following passage following directly on from the reference to
Rochinia carpenteri .

1 quote from a preliminary notice of the Crustacea by the Rev. A. Merle Norman:
"Ethusa granulala (sp. n), the same species as that found off Valentia, hut exhibiting

NOMENCLATURE OF CRABS 11

a most extraordinary modification of structure. The examples taken at 110-370
fathoms in the more southern habitat have the carapace furnished in front with a
spinose rostrum of considerable length. The animal is apparently blind, but has two
remarkable spiny eye-stalks, with a smooth rounded termination where the eye itself is
ordinarily situated. In the specimens however from the north, which live in 542 and
705 fathoms, the eye-stalks are no longer moveable. They have become firmly lixed in
their sockets, and their character is quite changed. They are of much larger size,
approach nearer to each other at their base, and instead of being rounded at their
apices they terminate in a strong rostrate point. No longer used as eyes, they now
assume the functions of a rostrum; while the true rostrum so conscpiuous in the
southern specimens has, marvellous to state, become absorbed. Had there been only a
single example of this form procured, we should at once have concluded that we had
found a monstrosity, but there is no room for such an hypothesis by which to escape
from this most strange instance of modification of structure under altered conditions of
life. Three specimens were procured on two different occasions, and they were in all
respects similar."'

Thirty years later Lankester (1903) maintained that two distinct species had been
confused in this statement. Accordingly, he proposed the retention of Norman's specific
name for the apparently shallow-living form, and named the more modified form
normani in Norman's honour. In the meantime, E. gramdata had been transferred to the
genus Cymonomus, established by Alphonse Milne-Edwards (1880) for C. quadratus, a
species collected from the Blake in the West Indies. The transfer was first reported by
Milne-Edwards (1881) in a preliminary account of the results of the Travadleur
expedition of 1881 in which C. gramdciitis was recorded from the Mediterranean, though
it was neither described nor illustrated. Norman (1880) had himself already reported the
species from the Travadleur collections made off the north coast of Spain in 1880, a
cruise in which both he and John Gwyn Jeffreys had been invited to participate. At the
same time Norman noted that the species had also been taken off Portugal during the
1870 cruise of the Porcupine, along with Dorvnclnis Thomsonl. Amathia Carpenlerl and
Eballa nux.

Up to this time no illustration of a Cymonomus species had been published, but in
1883 a Travadleur specimen of Cymonomus granulalus appeared on a plate in Milne-
Edwards' privately printed Recueil de figures des Crustaces nouveaux ou peu connus (see
Fig. 8). Parts of this plate were reproduced or redrawn for Filhols (1885) semi-popular
account of the Travadleur and Talisman cruises, and later in Milne-Edwards and
Bouvier's (1900) detailed account of the decapods collected during these expeditions. At
the same time, C. granulalus was reported from as far south as 21°53'N, off the coast of
north-west Africa.

At this point there had been no suggestion that two species might be involved, but
Lankester's interest was aroused by a reference to Norman's account in Lubbock's book
The Beauties of Nature (1893), in which Ethusa granulata is cited as an example of a
species with a wide bathymctric range in which there is a progressive modification and
reduction in the eyes with increasing depth. Initially, Lankester thought that the species
might form the basis of an instructive public exhibit in the British Museum (Natural
History) of which he had been director since 1898. But as he investigated this possibility
he concluded that two distinct taxa were involved and he also uncovered what he thought
were a series of errors which had led to considerable confusion in the interpretation of
Norman's original notes.

First, it was clear that Lubbock had wrongly attributed Norman with referring to three
forms, including one 'living near the surface' in which well-developed eyes are present; in
fact, Norman referred to only two.

12

A. 1 . RICE

#■*
1-"^^^

Fig. 8 The plate illustrating Cymonomus f'rcmulaliis in Milnc-Hdwards ( IK83). Kecueil dc figures
dcs Cruslaccs nouvcaux ou peu coniius.

NOMENCLATURE OF CRABS

13

\

m Mm:., f^

ff^v^^^>^^^^

.1

V

F.JI

'id Sy

./v-

/

/T'

Fig 6

^

Fig. 9 Illustrations of Cymonomiix normani (Fig. I) and Cymonomus j^ranulalus (Figs. 2-6) by
Albany Hancock whichi appeared in l.ankcstcr (1903).

14 A. L. RUE

Second, Lankester pointed out that Norman's quoted passage was somewhat
misleading. Norman had intimated that the two forms were hathymetritally separated,
the 'modified' form being the deeper living. But Lankester demonstrated that the
specimens which Norman had available to him from the Porcupine cruises of 1869
came from overlapping depth ranges, the normal form having been taken at stations
in depths ranging from 106 to 808 fathoms (I93-I471m), while the three specimens
of the modified form were from 542 and 705 fathoms (986-1 283m). Instead, llankester
thought that the two forms were geographically separated. All of the known examples
of the modified" form at the time of Lankester's study were from northern localities,
the three specimens collected from the Porcupine being from the 'Holienia ground'
at about 59°30'N, while a single specimen had been taken by the Ingolf south west
of Iceland at a depth of 486 fathoms (885m) and was dealt with later in Hansen
(1908). The 'normal' form, on the other hand, had been encountered only at much
more southerly localities, from south-west of Ireland to off north-west Africa and the
Mediterranean. Furthermore, Norman's quoted text had included the statement that
the eyes in the modified form 'terminate in a strong rostrate point. No longer used
as eyes, they now assume the functions of a rostrum.' This, wrote Lankester, had
naturally led to the assumption that 'their terminations become combined into a strong
pointed beak'.

Third, Lankester claimed that the specimen illustrated in Milne-Edwards" 'Recueil
. . .", and later in the Travailleur and Talisman report, had had the eyes removed before
being given to the artist. While these illustrations are not very clear, and are certainly
very inferior to the excellent ones by Hancock reproduced in Lankester"s paper (Fig. 9),
I believe that Lankester was mistaken and that the eyes are included. In any case, this
point is relatively unimportant to the general problem of the nomenclature and
authorship of the two Cymonomus species since Milne-Edwards' illustrations clearly
show the normal form with a well-developed rostrum.'.

Having thus carefully examined the published data and the available material,
Lankester provided an excellent comparison of the species concerned, including C.
quadratus, clearly describing his new species C. normani. This description was based on
the three Porcupine specimens taken at stations 47 and 88 though Lankester did not
designate a holotype.

However, Lankester introduced an element of confusion himself, for in two places
(pp. 444 and 455) he refers to a description of granulalus supposedly published by
Norman in the Annual Report of the British Association for 1873. Even if such a paper
had been published it would have been pre-dated by The Depths of the Sea which was
published earlier the same year. In fact, however, the paper does not appear to have
been published, even by title only as was not unusual at that time. The quotation from
Thomson's book, reproduced above, must therefore be considered the first published
description associated with the name F.thusa granulaui. This passage clearly associates
Norman's name with the form taken off Valentia. with a well-developed rostrum and
well-separated eyes with smooth corneal regions. Since this unequivocally identifies the
species concerned, and is equally unequivocally in the words of Norman rather than
Thomson (see Article 50, p. 91 in the Inlernalional Code of Zoological Nomenclature,
Third Edition, 1985) its correct attribution should be Cymonomus granulali4s (Norman in
Thomson, 1873).

' Similarly irrclcvanl. though nevertheless remarkable, was the erroneous depiction of chelate fourth and fifth
pcreiopods, pointed out by Lankester, in the first published illustration of Cymnnomm quadmins which
appeared in Milne-F.dwards and Bouvier (19()2).

NOMENCLATLIREOFC'RABS 15

Kbalia nux Milne-Kdwards, 1883

This fourth crab species in the Porcupine collection which Normun recognised as
previously undescrihed was not mentioned in The Depths of ihe Sea. The Hrst published
indication that the species had been taken from the Porcupine was in Norman's (1880)
Travailleur report where 'Ebalia nux, Norman' was mentioned in a list but was not
accompanied by a description. The species similarly appeared as a nomen nudum in
Milne-Edwards (1881) and in Marion (1883). In 1883 a Travailleur specimen was
illustrated in Milne-Edwards' 'Recueil . . .' and was labelled Ebalia nux (Norm.)
(Fig. 10).

The first written description was provided by Pocock (1889) in an account of the
crustaceans collected off the coast of Ireland in the Flying Fox (= '? Flying Falcon, see
Rice, 1986) in July 1889. Pocock had joined the staff of the British Museum (Natural
History) in 1885 and had siicceeded E. J. Miers in charge of the Crustacea Section, being
himself succeeded by W. T. Caiman in 1903. During his period at the Museum, Pocock
worked mainly on the arachnids and myriapods, writing very few papers on the
crustaceans. He was therefore not part of the rather close-knit marine biological
establishment of the time, nor of the international carcinological community, whereas
Norman was a central figure in both groups. This almost certainly contributed to the
acrimonious series of published exchanges between the two men which followed the
publication of the Flying Fox report.

In dealing with Fhalia nux, Pocock was unaware of any previous descriptions but had
before him material of the species collected from the Porcupine in the Mediterranean in
1870 and already deposited at the B.M.(N.H.) by Norman. He accordingly referred to
the species as 'F.balia nux, Norman, MS', described it and designated as types 'an adult
male and female specimen belonging to the series dredged in the Mediterranean.'

Only a week or two after the Flying Fox cruise, the hydrographic survey vessel HMS
Research, with G. C. Bourne aboard, had obtained a series of trawl samples in the same
general area. When Bourne (1890) reported the results of this cruise he enlisted
Norman's assistance and quoted some of the notes provided. These included a list of
Porcupine and Travailleur localities at which E. nux had been obtained and the remarks
that "Mr. Pocock seems to have been unaware that F.balia nux had been admirably
figured by Prof. A. Milne Edwards', and that Profs A. Milne Edwards and Marion
courteously recognised my MS. name F.balia nux, but if that is rejected it will stand as
Ebalia nux. A. Milne Edwards' and not, bv implication, Ebalia nux Pocock.

Pocock (1890a) saw this as a charge of 'lack of courtesy for not giving what he
[Norman] considers due acnowledgement to the name he applied to the above Crustacean'
(somewhat provocatively referred to in the title of Pocock's note as 'F.balia nux, Milne-
Edwards.') He went on to claim that in an effort to locate the original description of
Ebalia nux he had written to Norman but received no reply, thus turning the charge of
discourtesy back onto Norman, but carefully avoiding saying so.

Norman's (1890) response was swift and severe. After reproducing both Pocock's
original reference to E. nia and his own notes quoted by Bourne, he suggests that
Pocock had over-reacted to the latter due to his own guilty conscience. He goes on to
admonish him as an Assistant at the British Museum, who has a magnificent library at
his elbow', for failing to refer to Milne-Edwards' (1883) illustration of the species in the
'Recueil . . .' 'If he did not consult that work [wrote Norman], he ought to have done so.
If he did consult it ... he had no excuse for writing Ebalia nux, n. sp," instead of either
'Ebalia nux. Norman, MS., or 'Ebalia nux, A. Milne-Edwards." Now Norman takes
exception lo Pocock's designation as the type material specimens collected from the
Porcupine which had been sent to the Museum when E. J. Miers had been writing up the
Challenger brachyurans. 'Whether this was a courteous act [wrote Norman] let others
judge'. Finally, Norman deals with the problem of Pocock's letter rather lamely.

16

A. L. RICE

Fig. 10 The plate illustrating F.halm mix in Milnc-F.dwards (1883), Recueil de figures des Cruslaces
nouveaux ou pen connus.

NOMENCLATURE OF CRABS 17

claiming that if he did not reply to it this was not through lack of courtesy but simply
because he was too busy with his professional duties as a cleric.

In reply, Pocock {\H90b) rejected the suggestion that he had a guilty conscience since,
he wrote, he had had no idea that Norman would take exception to his treatment of the
species. Far from a discourtesy, he felt that his designation of Norman's specimens as
types of the species was 'both expedient and just.' Finally, he dealt with his own failure to
refer to Milne-Edwards' illustration of E. nu.x in the 'Reciieil . . .' (1883), pointing out
that despite Norman's reference to the Museum's 'magnificent library" neither it nor the
libraries of the Royal, Linnean or Zoological Societies contained a copy of this work.
Furthermore he quoted a letter from Milne-Edwards stating that only 50 copies of the
'Recueil . . .' had been produced, that most of these had been sent to naturalists then
working in carcinology (not including Pocock, of course), that only a few copies had been
offered for sale and that the work had consequently become almost unobtainable.'^
Under the circumstances, suggested Pocock, he could hardly be blamed for not having
referred to it.

As far as I am aware, this was the end of the published exchanges, for in the next
volume of the Annals and Magazine both protagonists published on other topics.
Norman continued to be attributed consistently with the authorship of E. nux for a
further 86 years (see Turkay, 1976), though as early as 1918 Pesta had suggested that it
should really go to Milne-Edwards. Whether or not this is so depends upon whether
Milne-Edwards (1883) counts as a true publication, for if it does not, Pocock is the
author and the types are the Porcupine specimens which he designated. However,
although Milne-Edwards' action in producing the 'Recueil . . .' would be deplored today,
the fifty copies produced were 'obtainable, when first issued, free of charge or by
purchase', therefore fulfilling the criteria for publication in Article 8(a)(2) of the
Inlernalional Code of /.oological Nomenclature. Moreover, Dr. L. B. Holthuis pointed
out to me that the 'Recueil' has already been recognised nomenclaturally since at least
two names published in it {Panlomus and P. parvulus) have been placed on the Official
List. Consequently, the correct attribution of the species is F.halia nux A. Milne-
Edwards, 1883, and the type must be a specimen from the Travailleur material in Paris,
preferably that on which Milne-Edwards' illustration was based.

THE 'NORMAN COLLECTION' AND ITS ACQUISITION BY THE BRITISH
MUSEUM (NATURAL HISTORY)

As a young Curator of Crustacea Malacostraca at the British Museum (Natural History)
in the mid 196()s, 1 was aware of the 'Norman Collection' as one of the larger 'named'
collections within my care. The specimens were distributed through the sectional
collection, but the most tangible evidence of its original unity was, and is, a single large
ledger in which some 50,000 specimens were registered under the general accession
number 1911:11:8. A much smaller number of specimens identified as having been
purchased from Norman appear in the general register at various times between 1898 and
191 1 , and a few even before this period. The official History of the Collections up to 1900
(British Museum (Natural History) 1906) contains a reference to the purchase of the
Norman Collection in 1898 and this is repeated in Steam's (1981) excellent general
account of the history of the Natural History Museum. Otherwise, the acquisition of the

■" A note lo this effect, apparently in Pocock's handwnting and with a reference to Milnc-Hdwards' letter, is
attached lo the British Museum (Natural History) copy of the Recueil . . .' which was obtained subsequently.

18 A. L. RICE

collection does not seem to have been documented and the following notes are an
attempt to rectify this.^

Alfred Merle Norman was born at Exeter in 1831 and was educated at Winchester and
Christ Church, Oxford, where he obtained a B. A. in 1852 and was ordained in 1856. Asa
cleric he worked almost entirely in the Durham diocese, being Curate at Houghton-le-
Spring from 1864 to 1866 and Rector of the coal-mining parish of Burnmoor from 1866 to
1895. He had been appointed Hon. Canon of Durham in 1885 and returned to Houghton
in 1895 as Rector and Rural Dean. He retired on medical grounds in 1898, moving to
Berkhamstead where he lived until his death in 191S.

Norman had already shown an interest in natural history during his school days and
published an account of the molluscs of Oxfordshire in 1851 while he was still an
undergraduate. The two years before his ordination were spent on the Isle of Cumbrae
and here he began his lifelong interest in marine biology.

During the 186()s he was active in the British Association Dredging Committees,
publishing many of the results of dredging in northern waters and dealing with a wide
range of taxonomic groups. In the final Shetland dredging report published in 1868, for
instance. Norman dealt with the Crustacea, Tunicata. Polyzoa, Echinodermata,
Actinozoa, Hydrozoa and Porifera.

In 1882 he completed Bowerbank's unfinished Ray Society volume on the sponges,
based partly on his own collection, and in 1890 he published a "Revision of the British
Mollusca", having been at one time the President of the British Conchological Society.

Norman"s main interest, however, was in the crustaceans and he published numerous
papers on a wide range of crustacean groups, including an account of The Crustacea of
Devon and Cornwall published in collaboration with Thomas Scott in 1906.

Norman was a central figure in British marine science from the 1860s to the end of his
life. He also had strong contacts with foreign specialists, particularly in France, being
invited to participate with John Gwyn Jeffreys in the cruise of the Travailleur in 1<SS().

In common with many of his contemporaries, Norman amassed a biological collection
both from his personal collecting excursions and by purchase and exchange. To
encourage and solicit exchanges he published catalogues of his collection, including two
lists of his crustacean holdings. The first of these, which appeared in 18H6, listed 1.362
species, while the second, published in 1905, listed 2808 species. He was thus clearlv still
actively adding to his collection well into his 70s, despite having arranged to sell it to the
Natural History Museum, and part of it having been already received by the Museum
and paid for!

Norman offered his collection to the British Museum (Natural History) in a letter to
the Director Sir William Flower, dated 2 February 1898, explaining that he was due to
retire in April and would be moving to Berkhamstead. Asked for an indication of the
extent of the collection on March 1 Norman sent a manuscript list and a copy of his
printed catalogue. After some deliberation Flower offered Norman a total of £2,000 for
the collection but explained that such a sum could not be found out of the funds available
for purchase in a single year. Instead, he suggested that both the transfer of the collection
to the Museum, and the payment, should be spread over a number of years, the first
payment of £500 being paid on receipt of the first part of the collection.

On 31 March 1898 Norman wrote his acceptance of the general offer. But he pointed
out that the first instalment would be worth much more than £5(K) and suggested that a

^ In this section the details of Norman's career are taken from fiis ofiituaries by Stebbing (19iy« and /)). and
from the excellent account of Norman's life and work bv Mills ( UJHO) The references to the ac()uisition of the
Norman Collection by the Natural History Museum are from the Director's letter lilcs and the oflicial mmulcs
of the Trustees meetings in the Museum archives. I am grateful to the Museum authorities fi>r permission to
consult and quote from these dt)cumcnlary sources.

Nf)MENrLATURnOFCRABS 19

guarantee should be drawn up to protect both parties, arranging for a second £500
to be paid 3 years later, if Norman was still alive, and the balance to be paid on his
death.

Flower was not keen on such an arrangement and pointed out that, having paid for the
first part of the collection, the Museum had no guarantee that the remainder of the
material would remain in its current state and not deteriorate for various reasons.

On April 16 Norman replied somewhat defensively. He admitted that his catalogues
may not be absolutely correct since some of the listed material might already have
become dried up or lost. However, such possible losses would be more than compen-
sated for by the fact that he intended to continue amassing material as long as he was
able. Moreover, he wrote, the collection already contained items not in the catalogues -
including Molluscs dredged by the French expedition in the 'Talisman' purchased [for
£14] from the Marquis de Folin."

Two days later he wrote to Flower yet again, still concerned that he should have some
guarantee that the Trustees of the Museum would not renege on the agreement. In
Flower's reply, dated 21 April, the Director still resisted having a formal guarantee,
saying that he was sure that Norman 'will find the Trustees as safe as the Bank of
England, even when not prompted by me'. This was somewhat prophetic, for Flower's
Directorship was to last only a further four months. He was already 66 years old and his
by no means robust constitution had suffered a collapse the previous October. He
resigned his post in August 1898, to be succeeded by E. Ray Lankester, and died the
following July. The arrangement of the purchac of the Norman collection was therefore
among his final official acts, the results being presented at two of the last few monthly
Trustees meetings that he attended.

At the first of these, on 23 April 1898, Flower simply reported that Norman had
offered his collection of more than 10,000 species of mainly marine invertebrates for a
total of £2000, to be paid for in instalments as they were delivered to the Museum. This
was approved by the Trustees and Norman's letter to Flower accepting the arrangement
was written the same day. At the next meeting, on 25 June 1898, Flower was able to
report the receipt of the first instalment of the collection, including some terrestrial and
freshwater molluscs, totalling some 26,191 specimens. The Trustees approved the
payment of the first £500.

The receipt of the second instalment was reported to the Trustees by Lankester on 24
March 1900. This instalment included the remainder of Dr. Norman's collection of
British Echinodermata, 3000 species of Entomostraca, 49 species of Mediterranean
Copepods, 925 microscopic preparations of Entomostraca, a large series of Polychaeta,
and collections of Tunicata, Mollusca, Crustacea, Cirripedia, Anthozoa etc.' The
Trustees approved the payment of a second £500.

No further Norman material came to the Museum during Lankester's turbulent
Directorship and, as noted above, the publication of the second edition of the 'Museum
Normanianum' in 1906 suggests that Norman was actively increasing his collection at this
time. However, In January 1910. Sydney Harmer, the Keeper of Zoology, was able to
report to Lankester's successor, Lazarus Fletcher, the receipt of the third instalment of
the Norman collection, consisting of 'about 3,290 specimens of sponges (including 195
types and 185 co-types), and of a number of specimens of Hydrozoa, Anthozoa,
Crustacea, etc'

At the Trustees meeting of 22 October 1910 approval was given for the payment of
£200 for this third instalment, the Trustees presumably being made aware that the
outstanding instalment was much larger.

This fourth and final instalment was received in November 1911 and included the
50,000 crustaceans mentioned above. A payment of £500 was authorized immediately
and the payment of the final £300, being the balance of the originally agreed £2000, was

20 A. L. RICE

approved in June 1912, presumably after the extent and state of the fourth instalment
had been ascertained.

ACKNOWLEDCEMENTS

1 am very grateful to Dr. L. B. Holthuis of the Rijksmuseum van Natuurlijke Historie,
Leiden, for his valuable constructive criticism of an early draft of this paper. I am also
grateful to the Trustees of the British Museum (Natural History) for permission to
consult, and quote from, the Museum's archives, and to the staffs of the libraries and the
Crustacea Section of the Museum for their unstinting assistance.

APPENDIX. AUTHORSHIP ATTRIBUTION OF THE SPECIES

The following restricted synonomics of the four crab species dealt with gives an indication of the
range of authorship attribution in the literature.

Doryhnchus thom.soni

Dorynchus ihnmsoni. Norman (Thomson, 1873)

I.ispognalhus ihomsoni. Norman (Milne-Edwards. 1881).

Lispognalhus ihompsoni. (A. M. F.dw.) (Anon, 1884)

I.ispognalhus Thomsoin (A. M.-Edw.) (Filhol, 1885)

Lispognalhus Thomson!. A. M. F.dw. (Pcrricr, 1886)

Dorynchus Thomsoni. Norman (Pcrricr, 1886)

I.ispognalhus Thomsoni (Pocock. 1889)

I.ispognalhus thomsoni. Norman (Bourne, 1890)

Lispognalhus thomsoni. Norman (Milne-Edwards and Bouvier, 19(X))

Lispognalhus Thonusoni l^orm. (Hansen, 1908)

Lispognalhus Thomsoni. Norman (Bouvier. 1922)

Archacopsis ihomsoni (Norman) (Rathbun. 192.5)

Dorhynchus Thomsoni Norman (Bouvier. 1940)

Archaeopsis ihomsoni (Norman) (Barnard, 19,50)

Dorhynchus ihomsoni Thomson (Holthuis, 1962)

Dorhynchus ihomsoni Thomson (Zariquiey, 1968)

Dorhynchus ihomsoni Thomson (Christiansen, 1969)

Dorynchus thomsoni Thomson (Ingle, 1980)

Dorhynchus ihomsoni Thomson (Manning and Holthuis, 1981)

Archaeopsis thomsoni (Thomson) (Grifhn and Tranter, 1986)

Rochinia carpenter!

Amathia carpenteri . Norman (Thomson, 1873)

Scyramaihia carpenwri Norman (Milnc-Fdwards. 1880a)

Scyramaihia Carpenteri (A. M.-Edw.) (Filhol. 1885)

Scyramaihia Carpenteri, Norman (Pcrricr. 1886)

Anamathia Carpenteri (Pocock. 1889)

Anamathia Carpenteri, Norman (Bourne. 1S90)

Scyramaihia Carpenteri. Norman (Milnc-Fdwards and Bouvier. 19{K))

Scyramaihia Carpenteri (Norman) (Dotlcin. 1904)

Scyramaihia carpenteri NoTirtdn (Rathbun. 1925)

Rochinia Carpenteri Norman (Bouvier, 1940)

Rochinia carpenteri (Norman) (Monod. 1956)

NOMENCLATURE OF CRABS 21

Rochinia carpenleri (Thomson) (Sivertscn and Holthuis, 1956)
Rochinia carpenleri (Thomson) (Zariquicy, 1%X)
Rochinia carpenleri (Thomson) (Inglc. IW(I)

Cymonomus granulatus

Elhiisa granittala ns. (Thomson, 1873)

F.lhiis graniilala. Norman (Norman, 18S(I)

Cymonoinus granidalus (Norm) (Milnc-Fdwards, 1883)

Cymonomus granutaliis (A. M.Hdw.) (Filhol, 1885)

Cymonomus granuUiliis . Norman (Pcrricr, I8f))

Cymonoinus granulaiits . Norman (Milnc-F.dwards and Bouvier, 1900)

Cymonomus graniilaliis (Norman) (Doflcin, 1904)

Cymonomus granulaiits (Norman (Ihlc, 1916)

Cymonomus granulaliis Norman (Bouvier, 1940)

Cymonomus granulaiits (Norman ex Thomson) (Monod. 1956)

Cymonomus granulaiits (Thomf,or{) (Zariquicy, 1968)

Cymonomus granulaliis (Thomson) (Tiirkay. 1976)

Cymonomus granulaiits (Thomson) (Inglc. 1980)

Cymonomus granulaliis (Thomson) (Manning and Holthuis, 1981)

Rbalia nux

Ehalia nux. Norman (Norman, 1880)

F.balia nux (Norm.) (Milnc-F.dwards. 1883)

Ehalia mix. Norman, MS (Pocock, 1889)

Ebalia nux. Norman (Bourne, 1890)

Ehalia mix. Norman (Milnc-F.dwards and Bouvier, 1900)

Ehalia nux Norman (Pesta, 1918)

Ehalia mix Milnc-F.dwards, 1881 (in note in Pesta, 1918)

Ehalia mix. Norman (A. Milnc-F.dwards, 1881) (Bouvier, 1922)

Ehalia mix Norman (Nobre, 1931)

Ehalia nux Norman (mss) (Bouvier, 1940)

Ehalia mix Norman ex Milnc-Hdwards, (Monod, 1956)

Ehalia mix Norman en Milne-Fdwards, 1883 (Zariquicy, 1968)

Ehalia mix Norman 1883 (Tiirkay, 176)

Ebalia nux A Milne-Fdwards (Inglc, 1980)

REFERENCES

Anon, 1884. Nature, l.ond.. 29: p. 531.

Barnard, K. H. 1950. Descriptive catalogue of South Alriean Decapod Crustacea (Crabs and

Shrimps). Annals of the Soulh African Museum 38: 1-837.
Bourne, G. C. 1890. Report on a trawling cruise m M.M.S. 'Research' off the south-west coast of

Ireland. Journal of ihe Marine Biological Associalion of ihe United kingdom I: 306-323.
Bouvier, E. L. 1922. Observations complementaircs sur les Crustaccs Dccapodes (abstractions

faites des Carides), provenant des campagnes de S.A.S. le Prince dc Monaco. Resultats des

Recherches Scientifiques accomplies par le Prince Albert I. Monaco 62: 1-106.

1940. Dccapodes Marcheurs. Eaiine de France 37: 1-404. Paris.

Carpenter. W. B. and Jeffreys, J. C. 1870. Report on deep-sea researches carried on during the

months of July, August and September 1X70, in 11. M. Surveying-ship 'Porcupine'. Proceedings

of the Royal .Society of London 19: 146-221.
Christiansen, M. E. 1969. Crustacea Decapoda Brachvitra. Marine Invertebrates of Scandinavia,

No. 2, Univ. Oslo, 143pp.
Dollein, F. 1904 Brachvura Wissenschaflliche Ergehnis.se der Deulschen Tief see- Expedition auf

dem Dampjer Valdivia' I8^8-I8'J9, Jena 6: I, XIV, 1-314.

22 A. L. RICE

Filhol, H. 1S85. l.a vie au fond des mers. Les explorations sous-marins I't k's voyages du Travailleiir

et du Talisman. Masson. Paris, VIII + 3()lpp.
Griffin, D. J. (;. & Tranter, H. A. 1986. The Dccapoda Brachyura of the Siboga Fxpedition. Part

VIII. Majidac. Sihoga Expedition 39: 1-335.
Hansen, H. J. 1908. Crustacea Malacostraca. I. The Danish Ingolf Expedition 3 (2): 1-120.
Holthuis, L. B. 1962. Fortv-sevcn genera of Dccapoda (Crustacea); proposed addition to the

Official List. Z.N.fS.) 1499. Bulletin of Zoological Nomenclature 19: 232-253.
Ihle, J. E. W. 1916. Die Dccapoda Brachyura der Siboga Expedition. II. Oxystomata.

Dorippidae. Siboga Expeditie 39(by. 97-158.
Ingle. R. \V. (1980) British Crabs. 222pp. Oxford and London. Oxford University Press and

British Museum (Natural History).
Jeffreys. J. G. f869. The deep-sea dredging expedition in ll.M S. Porcupine". Nature. London

1869, 135-137.
Kemp, S. 1910. The Dccapoda collected by the 'Huxley' from the north side of the Bay of Biscay

in August, 1906. Journal of the Marine Biological Association of the United Kingdom 8: 407—120.
I.ankester, E. R. 1903. On the modiheation of the eye peduncles in crabs of the genus

Cymonomus. Quarterly Journal of the Microscopical Society 47: 439—463.
Lubbock, J. 1893. The Beauties of Nature and the Wonders of the World we live in. XIV + 427pp.

London.
Manning. R. B. & Holthuis, L. B. 1981. West African brachyuran crabs (Crustacea: Dccapoda).

Smithsonian Contributions to Zoology 306: XII + 379pp.
Marion, .\. F. 1883. Considerations sur les fauncs profondes de la Mcditcrrancc. Annales du

Musee d'Histoire Naturelle de Marseille - Zoologie I (2): 1-50.
Mills, E. L. 1980. One 'different kind of gentleman': Alfred Merle Norman (1831-1918),

invertebrate zoologist. Zoological Journal of the I.mnean Society 68: 6'>-98.
Milne-Edwards, A. I880u. Comptc rendu sommairc d'une exploration zoologique faite dans le

golfe dc Gascogne a bord du navire dc I'F.tat Ic Traveilleur. Compte rendiie hebdomudaire des

Seances de T Academic des Sciences, Paris 91 : 355-360.
1880/>. Reports on the results of dredging under the supervision of Alexander Agassiz. in the

Gulf of Mexico, and in the Caribbean Sea. 1877. '78. '79, by the U.S. Coast Survey Steamer

'Blake'. Lieut. Commander C. D. Sigsbce, U.S.N. , and Commander J. R. Bartlctt. U.S.N. ,

Commanding. VIII. Ftudes preliminaires sur les Crustaccs. Bulletin of the Museum of

Comparative Zoology. Harvard College S: 1-68.
1881 . Comptc rendu sommairc d'une exploration zoologique faite dans I'Atlantiquc au bord

du Navire le Talisman. Compte rendu hebdomudaire des Seances de TAcademie des Sciences.

Paris 93: 931-936.
1883. Recueil de figures de Crustaces nouveaiix ou pen connus. Part I, pp. 1-3. plates 1—44.

Paris.
& Bouvier, E. I,. 19(H). Brachyures at Anomoures. In. Crustaccs Deeapodes, Premiere

Partic. Expedition Scientifiques du Travailleur et du Talisman pendant les annees IKHO, IHSl .

IHH2. /««.?. 396pp. Paris.
& 1902. Reports on the results of dredging under the supervision of Alexander Agassiz

in the Gulf of Mexico (1877-78), in the Caribbean Sea (1878-79), and along the Atlantic Coast

of the United States (1880). by the U.S. Coast Survey Steamer Blake'. Lieut. Com. C. D.

Sigsbce U.S.N. . and Commander J. R. Bartlctt. U.S.N., Commanding. XXIX. Les Dromiaccs

et Oxystomes. Memoirs of the Museum of Comparative Zoology. Harvard College 27 ( 1): 1-127.
Monod, Th. 1956. Hippidea et Brachyura ouest-africains. Memoires de Tlnstitul Francois

d'Afrique Noire, 45: 1-674.
Nobre, A. 1931 . Crustdceos Deeapodes e Stomatopodes marinhos de Portugal. 307pp.
Norman, A. M. 1869 Shetland hnal dredging report. Pt. II. On the Crustacea. Tunicata, Polyzoa,

F.chinodcrmata. Actinozoa, llydrozoa and Porifera. Report of the British Association for the

Advancement of .Science 38: 247-336.
1880. Notes on the I'rench exploring voyage of 'Le Travailleur' in the Bay of Biscay. Annals

and Magazine of Natural History 6: 430-456.
1886. Museum Normanianum or a Catalogue of the Invertebruta of Europe, and the Arctic and

North Atlantic Oceans, which are contained m the collections of the Rev. Canon A. M. Norman,

M.A.. D.C.L.. F.I..S. HI. Crustacea. Houghton-I.e-Spring. 26pp.

NOMONCLATURC OF CRABS 23

1890. Ebalia nux: a reply to Mr. R. I. Pocock. Annals and Magazine of Natural Hislorv 5:

342-346.

1905. Museum Normanuiniim, or a catalogue of the Invertcbrata of the Arctic and North

Atlantic Temperate Ocean and Palenarctic Region, which are contained in the collection of the
Rev. Canon A. M. Norman. M.A.. D.C.I... LL.n.. F.R.S.. F.I.S.. Ac. Ill Crustacea. Second
Edition, Durham, 47pp.

& Scott, T. 1906. The Crustacea of Devon and Cornwall. I-XV + 232pp. London.

Perrier, E. 1HS6. I. es explorations sous-marines, iv + 352pp. Paris.

Pesta, O. 1918. Die Decapodenfauna der Adria: Versuch einer Monographic. Leipzig and Wien. X

+ 50()pp.
Pocock, R. I. 1889. Report of a deep-sea trawling cruise oil the S.W. coast of Ireland, under the

direction of Rev. W, Spotswood Green. Annals and Magazine of Natural History 4; 425^31.
Pocock, R. I. 1890«. On Ebalia nux. Milnc-F.dwards. .Annals and Magazine of Natural History 5:

101-103.

I890fc. On Ebalia nux. Milnc-F.dwards: a reply to the Rev. Canon Norman. Annals and

Magazine of Natural History 5; 469-472.

Rathbun, M. J. 1925. The spider crabs of America. Bulletin of the United States National Museum

129; XX + 613pp.
Rice, A. L. 1986. British Oceanographic Ve.f.^els. lHOO-1^50. 193pp. London.
Sivertsen, E. & Holthuis, I,. B. 1956. Crustacea Dccapoda (the Penacidea and Stenopodidca

excepted). Report on the Scientific Results of the 'Michael Sars' North-Atlantic Deep-Sea

Expedition 1910. Bergen 5 (12); 1-54.
Steam, W. T. 1981. The Natural History Museum at South Kensington. A history of the British

Museum (Natural History) 1753-Wm.X\/m -t- 414pp. London.
Stebbing, T. R. R. 1918-1919. Obituary of A. M. Norman. Proceedings of the l.innean Society of

/.omimi 131: 58-60.

1919. Alfred Merle Norman, 1831-1918. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London (B) 90:

xlvi-1.

Thomson, C. W. 1873. The Depths of the Sea. 527pp. London.

Tiirkay, M. 1976. Dccapoda Reptantia von der portugiesischen und marokkanischcn Kiiste,

Auswertung der Fahrten 8, 9c (1967), 19 (1970), 23 (1971) und 36 (1975) von F.S. 'Meteor',

'Meleor' Forschungsergebnisse. Reihe D Biologic 23: 23—44.
Waren, A. 1980 Marine Mollusca described by John Gwyn Jeffreys, with the location of the type

material. Special Publication. Conchological Society of Great Britain and Ireland. 60pp.
Zariquiey Alvare/., R. 1968. Crustaceos Decapodos Ibcricos Investigacion Pesqiiera. (Barcelona)

32: XV -¥ 510pp.

IhilL Br. Mils. Nul. Hist- (Hist, Ser) 18(1): 25-113 lssueiJ31 May IWO

A memoir and bibliography of

Michael Rogers Oldfield Thomas,

F.R.S. ,Xgi2»o ^\7U

J. E. HILL_,

Department of Zoology . British Museum (Natural Historv). Cromwell
Road. London SW75BD

CONTENTS

Biography 25

Bibliography 35

Index to names proposed by Oldfield Thomas 85

Acknowledgements Ill

Appendix I Unofficial workers 112

Appendix 2 Mammals named after Oldfield Thomas 112

References 113

BIOGRAPHY

Michael Rogers Oldfield Thomas served the Trustees of the British Museum and
subsequently of the British Museum (Natural History) from 1H76 until his retirement in
1923, continuing to work at the Museum almost until his death in 1929. Joining the staff
of the Department of Zoology in 1878 as the Assistant in charge of mammals, he devoted
the following fifty one years to the development and increase of the mammal collections,
to a voluminous correspondence, and especially to a prodigious output of papers and
writings that without doubt establishes him as the most prolific of mammalogists in
variety and number of publications, and in numbers of newly described taxa. His
contribution to the then emergent science of modern mammalogy is so great that few
taxonomic or systematic studies of mammals written since his era can fail to include at
least one name that he proposed, and modern faunal studies, revisions and monographs
almost invariably include several and sometimes many references to his writings.

Despite this prodigality, there exists no published bibliography to document his
achievements, and, unlike the present age when no doubt his contemporaries and peers
might be invited to produce a commemorative volume or Festschrift, the end of his career
was marked only by relatively brief obituary notices (Hinton, 1929; Pocock, 1930). While
it might be said that the mammalian collection of the British Museum (Natural History)
is in itself a memorial to Oldfield Thomas', who did so much to create and shape it, at a
distance of some sixty years from his death it seems opportune to review the contribution

Always known among his family as Oldfield (his mother's maiden name), he invariably styled himself Oldheld
Thomas, ignoring his other given names. His full name or his full initials are only rarely cited, and then chiefly
by the pedantic.

26 J. fi. mi I

made by this most remarkable of mammalogists, and to document the vast output of
papers, reports and other pubhcations that won him world-wide recognition as a leader
and innovator in his chosen field.

Oldfieid Thomas was born on 21 February, 1858 at Millbrook in Bedfordshire.
England. The son of a clergyman, the Reverend J. H. Thomas, who was subsequently
appointed to the Archdiaeonate of Cape Town, Thomas spent several of his early years
in South Africa, where he displayed a youthful interest in natural history by collecting
insects on the slopes of Table Mountain. When his father returned to England to become
Vicar of Hillingdon. near Uxbridge in west London. Thomas was sent to Haileybury.
then a relatively recently founded public school (in England in fact a more or less
exclusively private establishment) at Hertford, but apparently did not prove to be a
promising scholar. At the age of eighteen he secured a clerkship in the office of the
British Museum at Bloomsbury. of which at that time the natural history collections
formed an integral part, but his interest in this field led him to hope for a post as an
Assistant in the Department of Zoology, under the formidable Dr. Albert Gunther. then
its Keeper. With this in mind. Thomas attended a course of lectures by T. H. Huxley at
South Kensington for the next two years. In 1878 his hopes of a zoological career were
fulfilled by a transfer to the zoological staff with an Assistantship that he was to hold until
his official retirement on 21 February, 1923.

At first interested in invertebrate animals and especially in Echinoderms with which
rumour had already suggested he would work, he was dismayed when after a short
period Gunther assigned him to the study and curation of mammals. In later life Thomas
would recount how despite his protestations, the autocratic Keeper insisted that he
should 'do the mammals', and he would aver that the vision of the countless sheep and
goats that passed through his mind had led him to hate these animals for ever. Perhaps it
is significant that subsequently he did ignore their systematics to a large extent, leaving
this work to others, except possibly when impelled by his enthusiasm to write a
description of one hitherto unknown, and so add another new name to his ever
increasing total. One can only speculate to what extent he would have influenced the
classification of any other group of animals had Gunther decided otherwise: his career
suggests that in the Mammalia Thomas found one to which his talents were admirably
suited.

Some impressions of Thomas survive in the obituary notices by his contemporaries M.
A. C. Hinton(1929) and R. I. Pocock (1930). and in the personal recollections of the late
R. W. Hayman. who joined his small staff in the Mammal Room as a very young man in
1921. Pocock. who knew Thomas from his early days in 188.^ provides a vivid pen picture
of this dedicated worker. He was. Pocock remarks, like any average young Englishman
of the period who had been reared in a well-ordered household, found his level at public
school, learnt the bad taste of self-advertisement, and had acquired the qualities of "fair
play': in fact, an exemplar of the typical upper middle class virtues of the age.

A single-minded man almost wholly devoted to his work, Thomas had a practical and
methodical nature, with few intellectual pretensions and little aesthetic appreciation.
Although Pocock remarks that he had gained little profit from the educational systetn
then in vogue, his impeccable coinings of new names in profusion indicates at least a
reasonable understanding of Greek and Latin, and the quality of his writing shows a
more than passing grasp of English grammar and composition. He had, acct)rding to
Pocock, no appreciation of art or literature, classical or otherwise, yet his choice of
names shows a wide acquaintance with the legendary figures of classical mythology, and,
in one little known instance, some knowledge of painting in his proposal (0432) of the
name Fornarina for a naked mole-rat, after a celebrated nude by Titian. He had some
liking for music, but appears to have gained no real pleasure from reading, confining
himself to the daily newspaper, an occasional magazine, or to travel books. He was by all

M. R. O. THOMAS 27

accounts an eminently sociable person, preferring conversation to books, and with an
aversion to solitude that amounted almost to pathological dislike. When working he had
a strong preference for the presence of another person: the late G. W. C. Holt fulfilled
this need for company in Thomas' later years, carrying out his clerical duties in the same
room and being there, when required, to undertake small tasks or errands.

In his earlier years Thomas engaged in a variety of games and sports, such as billiards,
cricket and lawn tennis: he played lacrosse for a while and was a passable marksman, as a
volunteer in the Artist's Corps. Almost to the end of his life he played that most
Victorian and sometimes vicious of games, croquet, devoting his summer holidays to
tournaments at various seaside resorts. Although he had travelled quite widely in Europe
in the early days of his career and indeed engaged in some minor collecting expeditions,
he seems to have had little interest in the countryside and its scenery, or even in its flora
and fauna. Collecting seems to have interested him as a means to the essential objective
of providing specimens. On an occasion in later life when his attention was drawn to the
beauty of the night sky he is reputed to have observed that it was a great pity that one
could not collect the stars!

Quite unconcerned with social importance or professional advancement within the
Museum, Thomas also lacked any conceit in his own achievements. Although for many
years he maintained a personal record of the Latin names that he had proposed, it was
kept more probably to avoid the risk of pre -occupying his own coinings, or of using the
same name too frequently, rather than from vanity, but from time to time he did add a
cumulative total. Eventually it seems that the task became too wearisome and he ceased
to keep this record, relying instead upon his memory. He declined the opportunity of
promotion to higher, mainly administrative posts so that he might remain unfettered in
his work with tfie collection, and refused to be drawn into controversies such as that
surrounding the relics of Piltdown Man, even when his friend and colleague, the
American mammalogist G. S. Miller correctly surmised (1915, 1918) that the jaw was
that of a chimpanzee and so came under lire from more immediate colleagues in the
Museum.

Thomas' pragmatic approach to life, tempered by shrewd commonsense and judge-
ment, led him to choose his friends and associates wisely, or to select loyal and trusted
collectors with whom he would have only sporadic contact once they were in the field. At
the same time, by persuasion and perseverance he was able to interest wealthy or
influential sponsors in his collecting projects, sometimes with the promise of nomencla-
tural immortality when their patronyms would appear as the names of the new species or
subspecies that inevitably would be discovered. Others he would convince that their best
interests lay in furthering the progress of the National Collection, as he liked to call it,
perhaps by working as his largely unpaid assistants at South Kensington. No doubt these
unofficial workers' found inspiration in the very considerable determination and
prodigious capacity for work shown by the 'Boss', as he was known to his intimates in his
middle years. Such qualities had brought him professional recognition in his election to
the Fellowship of the Royal Society in 1901, an honour he valued greatly, and, although
he was not one to seek public office, his election to the Council of the Zoological Society
of London in the latter part of the nineteenth century.

His marriage in 1891 to Mary Kane, the daughter of Sir Andrew Clarke, marked a
watershed in his career. His wife, similarly Victorian, was in many ways everything that
Thomas was not: a good amateur pianist, with literary tastes, and a follower of orthodox
religion, she was in some respects almost his opposite. There were no children of the
marriage, and when after a few years his wife infierited a small fortune. Thomas found
the independence that was to enable him to stand aloof from the office-seeking, lecturing
and popular writing that many of his generation and others since have found necessary to
supplement an official stipend. More than that, his wife herself became interested in

28 J. E. HILL

natural history, and, devoted to her husband and his work, readily agreed that as mueh
money as could be spared should be diverted into supporting mammal collectors in manv
parts of the world, or into financing expeditions with such collecting as their principal
objective.

Thomas' correspondence survives in the Museum, although only of the incoming
letters, there being no copies of his replies. It shows him to have been a voluminous
correspondent, in touch with all of his prominent colleagues at home and abroad. It is
almost a roll call of the height of Empire, with letters from famous explorers, hunters and
colonial officials that ITiomas had enlisted as part-time collectors. Many letters are
concerned with others whose collecting he financed from his own pocket, some quite
amusing when read today and throwing an unexpected light on the way that Thomas built
the collection in his charge. Always careful in laying out his money, he occasionally met
his match: letters from Knud Andersen, for example, show that when offered employ-
ment he too could drive a hard bargain.

Occasionally Thomas would write letters to newspapers and magazines: cuttings of
some that evidently he valued or thought might interest posterity he added to his
personal volumes of his writings. His pragmatic outlook characterises his suggestions for
an easily made ear-plug for soldiers in the firing line (0751). that pedestrians should use
the road and footpath in a disciplined fashion to avoid collisions with traffic or with
bearers of advertising sandwich-boards (0844), or his proposal after the First World War
that the German Fleet should be sunk in such a way and position that the wrecks would
provide a breeding ground for fish (0848). Interested in the merits of simplified spelling
(0684, 0700. 0813), he also enthused over starvation as a cure for influenza (1005). and
advocated the learning of Braille by the sighted as an aid to sleep: in this way it was
possible to read in bed in a darkened room, or with arms, hands and book or magazine in
the warmth under the bed linen (1017). He had pronounced views on 'legalised suicide'
as a form of euthanasia (0507) that eventually he was to carry to their logical conclusion.

For many years Thomas seemed unduly concerned with his health, soon after his
marriage experiencing heart palpitations and other unexplained symptoms. As time
passed he gave up strenuous games and drifted slowly into a condition bordering on
semi-invalidism. apparently convinced that he had only a short time to live. He was
advised that a mainly vegetarian diet might improve the situation, and with typical
determination and tenacity he adopted this new regime. The results were so beneficial,
for whatever reason, that he soon became an ardent advocate of this new way of life.
Probably very unfairly his friends regarded him as a hypochondriac, perhaps even
something of a crank: he was, it seems, a valetudinarian, highly solicitous of his health,
and especially concerned with the effects of diet and sometimes other unconventional
treatments, such as daily massage. A wider interest in subjects beyond the narrow field of
systematic mammalogy might have helped but without these broader horizons he had
little beyond his work and in later life would occupy himself at home in knitting, or in
listening to the radio when regular broadcasting began. Always a man of precise and
ordered methods when studying specimens or writing, he carried routine into his daily
activity: after a midday snack he would retire to a private darkened room, there to sleep
for an hour in an old armchair before returning to work for the afternoon, a practice not
unknown among his successors. During this rest period the wrath of the mighty would
descend upon any unwise person who disturbed him, unless perchance they brought
news of fresh funds becoming available for collecting expeditions, or of new mammals
that he might describe.

He continued after his official retirement in 1923 to work as though nothing had
happened. His wife, upon whom he had become increasingly depentlent, predeceased
him in May, 1928. For some while he carried on unchanged, but as the months went by
he clearly missed her more and more, becoming less interested in his work, her death

M. R. O. THOMAS 29

having been a severe blow from which he was unable to recover. The deliberate
termination of his life by his own hand in June, 1929 came as a great shock to his many
friends and admirers, although no surprise to those close to him: the note that he left
revealed his inner stresses and made it plain that he could no longer face life alone
without his partner.

Thomas left the greater part of his fortune and that of his wife as a collecting fund for
the Museum, but it is characteristic of this modest and unassuming man that to the last he
thought of the comfort and convenience of others. For most of his working life he had
ascended (and descended) four long flights of stairs from the Main Hall of the Museum to
the Mammal Room, then on the third floor and now part of the Department of Botany.
Shortly before his death he paid for the installation of a lift to relieve the staff by
overcoming this climb, and which bears a plaque (PI. 3) commemorating his generosity.

The Department of Zoology when Thomas joined it in 1878 was housed in the British
Museum at Bloomsbury, with the other natural history collections, the Waterhouse
building in South Kensington being then incomplete and not ready for occupation. The
mammal collections had from 1837 to 1874 been the responsibility of the eminent
naturalist John Edward Gray, among many other duties. Gray had established a system
of accession and registration, and had assembled a substantial nucleus of the study
collection. He produced a number of catalogues of the material under his care, these
gradually taking on a monographic nature going beyond simple listing. His successor as
Keeper of Zoology, Dr. Albert Gunther had for a short while taken charge of the
mammal collection and had intended to prepare a catalogue of the Marsupialia and
Monotremata. However, with the appointment of Thomas, it seems that Gunther soon
realised that he had made a wise decision, and relinquished the task to this energetic and
painstaking newcomer. Once the move of the collection to South Kensington was
completed in 1882, Thomas began seriously to continue the work of cataloguing and
monographing the collection after the fashion of the time. The Catalogue of the
Marsupialia and Monotremata appeared in 1888 (0065); that this was to be the precursor
of similar catalogues of the entire collection seems evident from the manuscript listings of
the Museum holdings of mammals that Thomas prepared about that time and which even
today are valuable in tracing the history of early material. Other papers in this period
quickly established Thomas as a rising mammalogist, and it soon became evident that in
one way or another he would make a significant contribution to this field of science.

The final decade of the nineteenth century saw a profound change in mammalogy.
Until then the subject had been dominated by a largely typological concept, more often
than not based on very small numbers of specimens, most of them indifferently
preserved, and often without reliable locational data. However, a number of American
mammalogists, led by Dr. C. Hart Merriam and charged with a survey of the mammalian
fauna of the United States, realised that the species concept in this sense had limitations
when such large faunal areas were studied. In its place, they began to study variation by
collecting widespread series of carefully prepared specimens, complete with skulls, and
labelled with accurate details of locality, altitude, date and gender. Much interesting
information was soon obtained, and in particular the details of local variation became
clear, leading to the recognition not only of further species but also of many previously
unsuspected local races or subspecies.

The publication of such results immediately alerted Thomas to the implications of this
new approach to his subject. Very quickly he realised that what was true of North
America must apply equally to the rest of the world, and offered almost unlimited
opportunities of augmenting the collection in his charge with new and exciting represen-
tatives of other mammal faunas. He began to apply these new ideas to the fauna of
the Old World and of South America, encouraging collecting by local residents,
colonial officials and sportsmen, financing independent collectors from his own now not

30 J. E. HILL

inconsiderable means, and by finding wealthy sponsors. His decision to undertake what
was effectively almost a survey of the mammals of the world led to a complete change in
the nature of his work which became increasingly concerned with the identification of the
many specimens that flowed into South Kensington, and with the preparation of short
papers that for the most part consisted of the descriptions of the wide variety of new
mammals that this private army of collectors discovered. The effect on the collections
and on his output of published work was dramatic: the sudden upsurge in accessions in
the years 1891-1910 is reflected in the 555 papers that he published during this period
(Tables 1,2).

In all, Thomas was responsible for some 1090 items of published work, including a
small number of letters to newspapers and magazines but otherwise without exception
concerned with professional topics and usually with the descriptions of new mammals.
He proposed some 2900 new names for genera, species and subspecies and is without
doubt the most prolific of all mammalogists. While it can be said that most of his papers
are short, by the standards of the time they are terse, effective accounts unburdened by
superfluous detail. He might well have written more, but in the context of the numbers of
specimens that passed through his hands (Table 1 ) nothing can belittle his achievement in
describing and naming the vast undiscovered faunas that his collectors revealed. His
practical mind and prodigious memory enabled him to come very quickly to the
essentials of mammalian systematics as reflected by the steadily increasing collections,
and he worked rapidly, moving unhesitatingly from one topic to another. This became
his occupation for the remainder of his career: in carrying it out he so augmented his
beloved National Collection to the extent that it remains one of the leading collections in
the world in variety and numbers of specimens, and especially in its content of original
material, reflecting the vast number of new taxa that he and his helpers described during
this period.

Despite this new and absorbing interest, Thomas did not entirely desert the catalogu-
ing of the collections. In 1904 he persuaded and at least in part financed a young Danish
zoologist, Knud Andersen to come to London and prepare a monographic catalogue of
the Chiroptera. This decision proved wise and apart from a succession of shorter papers
incidental to the work the first volume on the Megachiroptera appeared in 1912. The
preparation of a second volume on the Microchiroptera was cut short by the sudden and
hitherto unexplained disappearance of Andersen in 1918.' Similarly Thomas encouraged
his friend and colleague G. S. Miller to prepare a catalogue of the mammals of western
Europe which was published in 1912.

No memoir of Thomas can omit his part with R. C. Wroughton and W. S. Millard in
setting up the Bombay Natural History Society's Mammal Survey of the Indian sub-
continent in the early part of this century. The application of Thomas" by then well-tested
methods of engaging and financing collectors soon resulted in the arrival of huge packing
cases of specimens at the British Museum (Natural History), all to be unpacked and their
contents laid out for study by Thomas and by members of the band of unofficial workers
(Appendix 1) that he had gathered together. The magnitude of the collections obtained
by the Survey is known only too well to the present writer, who soon after appointment
to the staff of the Museum in 1948 was responsible for re-packing most of the material for
return to India: the many publications resulting from this accumulation remain a basic
source and a tribute to the foresight of Thomas and Wroughlon.

Thomas had a formidable grasp of nomenclature and its niceties, realising early in his

' Andersen disappeiircd without warning or any public explanation, giving rise to much speculatitm at the time.
even that he might have been a secret agent. The truth is more prosaic: a letter from Andersen found m 1949
among some of Thomas' effects explained that Andersen's domestic circumstances had become so mtolerable
that he had resolved to end a situation that he could no longer endure. Nothmg further was ever heard of him.

M. R. O. THOMAS 31

career that basic stability could be obtained only by attaching the many names that
abounded in the nineteenth century literature to the original specimens that by then had
found their way into the collections at South Kensington. With this in mind he designated
lectotypes from many of the collections on which earlier naturalists had based their
observations and descriptions. Possibly his most spectacular achievement in so doing was
to recognise among the many specimens from the Lidth de Jeude collection that the
Museum had purchased in 1867 were some that had been formerly the property of Albert
Seba. Figured in his 'Thesaurus' of 1734, many were in fact the types of names proposed
subsequently by Linnaeus and based on Sebas illustrations (OK)").

Ever practical, he produced one of the first attempts to standardize basic skull
measurements and tooth nomenclature (0486) and devised a simple instrument for
measuring the incisive index in rodents (0862). Realising that his collectors would benefit
from clear instructions, he wrote a leaflet giving directions for the preparation of small
mammal skins (0147) but was forced to issue it at his own expense since Dr. Gunther, the
Keeper of Zoology, did not think that it would be of any use to the Museum. In one
modification or another it has continued in print to the present day.

No less than two genera and thirty eight species and subspecies were named after
Thomas (Appendix 2), an indication of the esteem in which he was held by his
colleagues. Such dedications are sometimes accompanied by tributes that acknowledge
the generous help that he provided to others. It is equally apparent from the numerous
unofficial workers and volunteers that Thomas encouraged to work in the Mammal Room
that he was able to inspire others with his vision of a great National Collection, served by
a willing band of helpers.

His own names (Index) explore almost every basis for a scientific epithet. Many
commemorate his sponsors, collectors, friends and relatives, or are geographical in
origin. Others are classical, Thomas having dredged deeply among the mythology of the
Ancient Greeks and Romans. Yet more are derived directly from Greek and Latin,
impeccably constructed and usually descriptive. Not lacking humour, he proposed la io
(a bat, 0377) reputedly in response to a challenge from G. S. Miller to coin the shortest
name in mammalogy. Occasionally his enthusiasm ran away with him and he proposed
one new name (Talpa milleri, a mole, 0665) that remained still-born: it reached the page
proofs of the Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and
Geology, London, but was then withdrawn. Another such name (Cervus spatulatiis. a
deer) escaped: based on a set of much deformed antlers from Borneo, it similarly
reached the page proofs of the Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London (0330),
at which point Thomas decided to abort it. Unfortunately, he had overlooked its
publication in the Minutes of the Proceedings (0329) of the meeting at which he had
exhibited the specimen, and the name remains available in the literature, although
undiscovered.

Obviously, much of Thomas' classification has been superseded in the sixty years since
his death. Indeed, many of the names that he proposed have been reduced in rank or
have passed into synonymy, some the victims of his own methods as the increasing
numbers of specimens in collections have led to a wider understanding of population
structure and variation. It is true, too, that late in life his use of the terms species and
subspecies became erratic. His vast output of new names has led some to regard him as a
mere museum systematist with little understanding of natural history, or even as one to
whom the description of new taxa had become an overwhelming obsession, however
flimsily these proposals might be based.

None of this, however, can detract from an achievement that can only be described as
monumental. The Mammal Section of the British Museum (Natural History) contains
many reminders of Oldfield Thomas, from his portraits (Pis. I, 2) to his crabbed
handwriting (PI. 4) scattered throughout catalogues, the Accession Registers, on the

32 J. E. HILL

labels of innumerable specimens, and as annotations in the margins and text of his own
publications. No worker in this collection can fail to see and wonder at the results of the
undertaking to which Thomas set his hand and which he carried forward with such single-
minded determination. He created a foundation for his successors to build upon, a
tradition that they have followed, and was truly a pioneer and founding father of modern
systematic mammalogy.

Table 1 Accessions of specimens of mammals to the British Museum (Natural History),
1837 - 1988, excluding Cetacea, domestic animals, and skeletal material.

1837-1840 647 1911-1920 25137

1841-1850 6802 1921-1930 21699

1851 - 1860 4614 1931 - 1940 19826

1861-1870 3135 1941-1950 8098

1871 - 1880 3642 1951 - 1960 12065

1881 - 1890 4341 1961 - 1970 26673

1891 - 1900 13277 1971 - 1980 27731

1901 - 1910 3345S 19S1 - 1988 16987

Following the custom of his time. Thomas made many imperfect or apparently superfluous specimens mto
"duplicates'. Some were donated to other institutions, but the greater part of this so-calied duplicate collection
was retained, and eventually accessed and incorporated into the study collections, chiefly [n 1965 and 1966, by
which time it also included a number of specimens added since Thomas" day-

Table 2 Totals of publications by Oldfield Thomas; two items (0330, 0665) that he carried
to proof stage and subsequently withdrew have been omitted. There is a close relation
with the volume of accessions to the collections (Table 1 ) during his working life.

1879-1880 7

1881 - 1890 81

1891 - 1900 220

1901 - 1910 335

1911-1920 247

1921 - 1929 :(K1

M. R. O. THOMAS

33

Plate 1 A portrait of Oldfield Thomas, F. R. S., by J. E. Braun, dated 1904. bequeathed
by Thomas to the British Museum (Natural History).

34

J. E. HILL

Plate 2 A portrait of Oldlield I'homas. F. R. S.. artist and date unknown, bequeathed by
Thomas to the British Museum (Natural History).

M. R. O.THOMAS

35

OJ":

z/he c/nsialLalibn or zkis lifz was re tzcle red possible in /^2,C)
ou a generous S^ifi from Kjlafiela cJnomas. a. cf\^c7.,
who was in She serOice of 2vie cJrusS'ees from )'i>76 Sof^l^-

*3

.^^-L.

Plate 3 Commemorative plaque in the lift in the Main Hall of the British Musem (Natural
History).

V— ^"^

) '

\_ •war

/. Ad. St., (J & 7 yg.

Lidtb de Jeude

CoU,
Lidtb de Jeude
CoU.
(Deiwribed by Wftterboiue.}

fl. Didelphys lepida. (I'L^ri! III. fig. 1.)
DldeJphjTi (Miueureui) lepids, T^m. ^nu. .«n^. JK If. (6) i. p. 158

Si7.o very small. Fur soft, cloao and straight. GetietuI colour
deep rich rufoue, much deeper then in the ntUod species. Rhinarium
apparently aa in iJ. muriita. Centre o( face pole rufous ; crown deep
nifoua, like buck ; black patchca round eyes strongly marked, con-
tinued forwards on the sides of the muuKlo nearly to the rhinariura,
Imt not continued back wards towards the car. Chin, chest, and belly
dirty n'hito, with a (nint rufoua tinge, the lino of demarcation not
nt all stronRlv marked. Kant vcrv small, laid forward thee reach

Plate 4 Oldfield Thomas" handwriting: a sample taken from an interleaved copy of his
Catalogue of the Marsupialia and Monotremata (0065, 1888) which he amended as
further specimens were added to the collection.

BIBLIOGRAPHY

The order of listing of references within the year in this bibliography does not imply any
priority of publication and no publication dates beyond the year have been established
except where these are relevant to instances of multiple description. Titles in square
brackets have been compiled to indicate the content of articles lacking any formal
heading.

Thomas published the greater part of his work in the Annals and Magazine of Natural
History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London, and in the Proceedings of the
Zoological Society of London, the latter consisting in part of the amplified formal
versions of papers initially delivered verbally at the regular Scientific Meetings of the
Society. As a rule, both journals present little difficulty for the bibliographer. The
volumes of the Annals have been presumed here to have appeared in the year to which
they refer: the dates of issue of the parts of the Proceedings can be obtained from Martin
Duncan (1937).

However, a brief account of announcements, specimens exhibited, and papers
presented was issued shortly after each of the Scientific Meetings of the Zoological
Society, from 1867 to 1904 as the 'Minutes of the Proceedings of the Zoological Society
of London' and from 1904 to 1936 in a more formal style and titled 'Abstracts' rather
than 'Minutes'. These antedate the corresponding parts of the Proceedings, sometimes
by many months, or even appearing in the previous year, and often contain newly

36 J. K. HILL

proposed names. Some of these are nomina nuda and of no nomenclatural consequence
but many seem quite validly proposed: although certainly in the "Minutes' each account
is a summary of the describer's remarks by another hand, it is clearly ascribed to the
originator. Where any of Thomas' names have first appeared in this way, with a
description, the relevant reference has been treated as a formal paper and included as
such in his bibliography. Where the entry in the 'Minutes' or 'Abstracts' relates only to a
report of specimens exhibited but not formally named, or mentioned with a iwmen
nudum, the reference has been listed separately in a terminal supplement, its serial
number prefixed 'A'.

Evidently Thomas was instrumental in changing the rather informal 'Minutes' into a
more obviously accredited publication. A printed version of a letter (0309) that he wrote
in 1901 to P. L. Sclater, then the Secretary of the Zoological Society survives in his
collected works and was apparently circulated as a broadsheet. In this Thomas suggested
that henceforward the publication should be called the Abstracts of the Proceedings; it
should be continuously paginated; sufficient should be printed to satisfy foreign libraries
and museums; it should be issued to all Fellows of the Society; new species should date
from the Abstracts, for which authors should prepare their own accounts; and that these
submissions must be an abstract of a paper already with the Society. Most if not all of
these proposals seem to have been adopted, and the Minutes' terminated on 13
December. 1904: meanwhile the "Abstracts' began on 13 January of the same year, being
issued on the Tuesday following the Meeting to which each referred, and also being
placed on sale at the Society's Offices.

1879

0(X)1 On Robert Kerr's translation of the "Systcma Naturae' of Linnaeus. Annals and Magazine
of Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (5) 4: 397.

1880

(KX)2 Description of a new species of Mas from the Fiji Islands. Proceedings of the Zoological
Society of London 11-13, 1 fig.

0003 On the M\oxus elegans of Temminck. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 40-
4L

0004 On mammals from Ecuador. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 393-403, figs
1-3, pi. 38.

0005 Description of a new bat from Java, of the genus Kerivoula. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (5) 5: 472—473, 1 fig.

t)006 On bats from Old Calabar. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology,

Botany and Geology. London (.5) 6: 164-167, 2 figs.
0007 Description of a new species of Arvicola from northern India. Annals and Magazine of

Natural History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (.5) 6: 332-333.

1881

(KX)8 Description of a new species of Reiihrodon. with remarks on the other species of the genus.

Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London (1880): 691-696, figs. 1^.
(XK)9 Account of the zoological collections made during the survey of fL M.S. 'Alert' in the Straits

of Magellan and on the coast of Patagonia. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London

3-6, figs. 1-2.
(K)10 Description of a new species of Mus from southern India. Annals and Magazine of Natural

History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (.5) 7: 24.
(K)l 1 On the Indian species of the genus Mus. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London

.S21-5.'>7, pis. .SO-.SL
0012 Description of a new species of mole from China. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;

including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (.5) 7: 469^71 .
(K)13 Description of a new species of Alactaga from Mesopotamia. Annals and Magazine of

Natural History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (.5) 8: 1.5-16.

M. R. O. THOMAS 37

1882

01)14 On the African mungooses. Proceedings of the Zoological Socien of London 59-93, fig. 1,

pi. 3.
Olll.'i On a collection of rodents from nortti Peru. Proceedings of the Zoological Socielv oj

Lw!(/f«i 9K-lll.pl. 4.

0016 On a small collection of rodents from South-Western Africa. Proceedings of the Zoological
Society of London 265-267. pi. 14.

0017 Description of a new genus and two new species of Insectivora from Madagascar. Journal of
the Linnean Society of London 16: 319-322. 1 fig.

coin On a small collection of Mammalia from central Mexico. Proceedings of the Zoological
Society of London 371-372.

0019 On two new Muridac from Tasmania. Annals and Magazine of Natural Hisiorv: including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (5) 9: 413-416. tigs. 1^.

0020 Description of a new species of rat from China. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of
London 587-588. pi. 44.

1883

(X)21 Description of two new species of Pteropus from the Caroline Islands. Proceedings of the
Zoological Society of London (1882): l^^l^l , pis. 54-55.

0022 On Mustela alhinucha. Gray. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology,
Holany and Geology, London (5) 11: 370-371. 1 fig.

1884

0023 On a collection of Muridae from central Peru. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of
London 447-458, pis. 42-44.

0024 Description of a new species of Microgate. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (5) 14: 337-338.

0025 Report on the zoological collections made in the Indo-Pacific Ocean during the voyage of
H.M.S. Alert 1881-2. Pari I. The collections from Melanesia. Mammalia. Pp. 5-10. London:
Trustees of the British Museum (Natural History).

1885

(K)26 Report on the mammals obtained and observed by Mr. H. H. Johnston on Mount Kilima-
njaro. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 219-222, pi. 12.

0027 Notes on the characters of the different races of Echidna. Proceedings of the Zoological
Society of London 329-339, pis. 23-24.

0028 Account of a collection of human skulls from Torres Straits. Journal of the Anthropological
Institute of Great Britain and Ireland 14: 328-343, pis. 14-15. tabs. 1-3.

0029 [Remarks on a burrowing rodent, Heterocephalus phillipsi, n. sp.|. Proceedings of the
Zoological Society of London 61 1-612.

1886

0030 Notes on the rodent genus Heterocephalus. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London
(1885): 845-849, pi. 54, [figs. 1-5|.

0031 Diagnoses of three new Oriental mammals. .Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (5) 17: 84.

0032 On the mammais presented by Allan O. Hume, Esq., C.B., to the Natural History
Museum. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 54-79, pis. 5-6.

0033 Description of a new Brazilian species of Hesperomys. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (5) 17: 250-251.

0034 Notes on a striking instance of cranial variation due to age. Proceedings of the Zoological
Society of London 125-127, 1 pi.

0035 Diagnosis of a new species of Phascologale. Annali del Museo Civico di Storia Naturale di
Genova (2a), (O.S. 24) 4: 208.

0036 Note intorno ad alcuni Chirotteri appartencnti al Museo Civico di Genova c descrizionc di
due nuove specie del genere Phvllorhma. Annali del Museo Civico di Storia Naturale di
Genova (2a), (OS. 24) 4; 201-207, 1 fig. [With G. Doria).

38 J. E. HILL

1887

{KI37 On the wallaby commonly known as Lagorchestes fasciativi. Proceedings of the Zoological

Society of London (1S86): 544^547. pi. 59.
0038 Note on Hesperomys pyrrhorhimts. Pr. Max. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;

including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (5) 18: 421-423.
(K)3y Diagnosis of a new species of Hesperomys from North America. Annals and Magazine of

Natural History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (5) 19; 66.
1)040 Description of a new Papuan phalanger. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including

Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (5) 19: 146-147.
0041 Diagnoses of two new fruit-eating bats from the Solomon Islands. Annals and Magazine of

Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (5) 19: 147.
IK)42 List of mammals from the Cameroons Mountain, collected by Mr. H. H. Johnstim.

Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 121.

0043 On the small Mammalia collected in Demerara by Mr. W. L. Sclater. Proceedings of the
Zoological Society of London 150-153. pi. 19.

0044 On the bats collected by Mr. C. M. Woodford in the Solomon Islands. Proceedings of the
Zoological Society of London 320-328. figs. 1-3, pis. 25-26.

0045 On the milk-dentition of the koala. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 338-
339. 1 hg.

0046 On the homologies and succession of the teeth in the Dasyuridae, with an attempt to trace
the history of the evolution of mammalian teeth in general. Proceedings of the Royal Society
o//.OA!(/o« 42: 310-312. [Abstract).

0047 On the homologies and succession of the teeth in the Dasyuridae, with an attempt to trace
the history of the evolution of mammalian teeth in general. Philosophical Transactions of
the Royal'Society of London (B) 178: 443-462, tigs. 1-5, pis. 27-28.

0048 On the specimens of Phascogale in the Museo Civico, Genoa, with notes on the allied
species of the genus. Annali del Museo Civico di Storia Nalurale di Genova (2a), (OS. 24)
4: 502-511.

0049 Description of a second species of rabbit-bandicoot (Peragale). Annals and Magazine of
Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (5) 19: 397-399.

(X)50 Report on a zoological collection made by the officers of H.M.S. "Flying Fish' at

Christmas Island. Indian Ocean. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 51 1-514.

pis. 41-42.
0051 Description of two new squirrels from North Borneo. Annals and Magazine of Natural

History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (5) 20: 127-129.
(X)52 Description of a new rat from North Borneo. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;

including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (5) 20: 269-270.
0053 Diagnoses of two new central African Mammalia. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;

including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (5) 20: 440.

1888

(X)54 On a collection of mammals obtained by Emin Pasha in equatorial Africa, and presented by

him to the Natural History Museum. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London .^17,

pis. 1-2.
0055 List of mammals obtained by Mr. G. F. Gaumer on Cozumel and Ruatan Islands, Gulf of

Honduras. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 129.
(X)56 Diagnoses of six new mammals from the Solomon Islands. Annals and Magazine of Natural

History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (6) 1: 15-5-158.
0057 Diagnoses of four new species of Didelphys. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:

including Zoology, Botany and Geology. Londim (6) 1: 158-159.
tX)58 On a new and interesting annectant genus of Muridae. with remarks on the relations of the

Old and New World members of the family. Proceedings of the Zoological .Society of

/.o/irfoAi 1.30-1.35, pi. 5.
0059 Description of a new genus and species of rat from New Guinea. Proceedings of the

Zoological Society of London 237-240, 2 figs.
(X)60 On F.upetaurus . a new form of flying squirrel from Kashmir Journal of the Asiatic Society of

Bengal. Calcutta 57: 256-260.

M. R. O. THOMAS 39

0061 Description of a new bat of the genus Nyctophilus. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
inducting Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (6) 2: 226.

0062 On a new species of Loncheres from British Guiana. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (6) 2: 326

0063 Diagnoses of four new mammals from the Malayan region. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (6) 2: 407^09.

0064 On the small mammals of Duval County, south Texas. Proceedings of the Zoological Society
of London 44i~i50.

0065 Catalogue of the Marsupialia and Monotremata in the collection of the British Museum
^Natural History). London: Trustees of the British Museum (Natural History).

1889

0066 The mammals of the Solomon Islands, based on the collections made by Mr. C. M.
Woodford during his second expedition to the Archipelago. Proceedings of the Zoological
Society of London (1H8K): 470-4X4. pis. 20-22.

0067 On the mammals of Christmas Island. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London
( I S«8): 532-534.

0068 Exhibition of a new species of muntjac, from Tenasserim, proposed to be called Cervulus
feae. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London ?,5 . [1 August 1889].

0069 Diagnosi di una nuova specie del genero Cervulus raccolta da L. Fea nel Tenasserim. Annali
del Miiseo Civico di Storia Naturale di Genova 2a, (O.S. 27) 7: 92. (With G. Doria]. [No
exact date).

(HI70 Description of a new Bornean monkey belonging to the genus Semnopithecus. Proceedings
of the Zoological Society of London 159-160. pi. 16.

0071 Description of a new bat from the Gambia. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (6) 3: 362-364, 1 fig.

0072 Preliminary notes on the character and synonymy of the different species of otter.
Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 190-200.

ti073 On the mammals of Mount Kina Balu, North Borneo. Proceedings of the Zoological Society
of London 228-236. pi. 24.

0074 Description of a new species of Mus. from South Australia. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (6) 3: 433-435. 1 fig.

0075 Description of a new genus of Muridae allied to Hydromys. Proceedings of the Zoological
Society of London 247-250, pi. 29.

0076 On the dentition of Ornithorhynchus. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London 46: 126-
131, pi. 2.

0077 Description of a new stenodermatous bat from Trinidad. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (6) 4: 167-170, 3 figs.

0078 The zoology of the Afghan Delimitation Commission. Mammals. Transactions of the
Linnean Society of London (2) Series Zoology S: 55-65.

0079 Note on the nomenclature of the short-eared New-Zealand bat. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (6) 4: 462.

1890

0080 O.i a new mungoose allied to Herpestes albicaudatus. Proceedings of the Zoological Society
of London {\Hm): 622-624, pi. 62.

0081 "A milk dentition in Orycteropiis". Proceedings of the Royal Society of London 47: 246-248,
pi. 8.

0082 On a collection of mammals from central Veracruz, Mexico. Proceedings of the Zoological
Society of London 71-76, pis. 6-7.

0083 Description of a new Scotophilus from the Gambia, with remarks on some of the
allied species. Annali del Museo Civico di Storia Naturale di Genova (2a), (O.S. 29) 9:
84-88.

(K)84 Diagnosis of a new Cynopterus from Borneo. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;

including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (6) 5: 235-236.
0085 On a collection of mammals obtained by Dr. Emin Pasha in central and eastern Africa.

Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 443-450, 1 fig., pi. 40.

40 J. E. HILL

(K)86 Description of a new squirrel from Borneo. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;

including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (6) 6: 71-72.
(HIS7 Remarks on Dr. Schlosser's "Ucber die Deutung dcs Milchgebisses dcr Saugeticre".

Biologisches Zentralhlall. Erlangen & Leipzig 10: 216-219.
(K)88 Muridae. In Milne-Edwards, A., Mission scientifique du Cap Horn 1882-1883. 6. Zoologie.

Mammiferes 1-32, pis. 1-8 (pp. 22-30, pis. 2-6. 8].

1891

0089 Preliminary diagnoses of four new mammals from East Africa. Annals and Magazine of

Natural History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (6) 7: 303-304.
(K)90 Note on Chiroderma villosum Peters, with the description of a new species of the genus.

Annali del Museo Civico di Sioria Naturale di Genova (2a). (O.S. 30) 10: 881-883.
(K)91 Diagnoses of three new mammals collected by Signor L. Fea in the Carin Hills. Burma.

Annali del Museo Civico di Storia Naturale di Genova (2a), (O.S. 30) 10: 884.
(K)92 On a collection of small mammals made by Mr. F. J. Jackson in eastern Africa. Proceedings

of the Zoological Society of London 181-187, 1 tig., pi. 15.
(K)93 On some antelopes collected in Somali-land by Mr. T. W. IL Clarke. Proceedings of the

Zoological Society of London 206-212. pis. 21-22.
(K)94 Descriptions of three new bats in the British Museum collection. .Annals and Magazine of

Natural History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (6) 7: 527-530. I fig.
0095 Notes on some ungulate mammals. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London

384-389.
(X)96 Description of a new vole from China. .Annuls and Magazine of Natural History; including

Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (6) 8: 117-118. 1 fig.
1K)97 Diagnosis of a new species of Procavia. Annali del Museo Civico di Sioria Naturale di

Genova (2a), (O.S. 30) 10: 908.

1892

(K)98 Descriptions of three new gerbilles in the British Museum collection. Annals and Magazine

of Natural History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (6) 9: 76-79.
0099 On the species of the Hyracoidea. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 50-76,

pi. 3.
(IKK) Note on the gibbon of the island of Hainan (Hylobates hainanus sp. n.). Annals and

Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (6) 9:

145-146.
(1101 Diagnosis of a new subspecies of hare from the Corea. Annals and Magazine of Natural

History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (6) 9: 146-147.

0102 Description of a new species of Meriones from Palestine. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology. l,ondon (6) 9: 147-149.

0103 On some new Mammalia from the East Indian Archipelago. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (6) 9: 250-254.

0104 Exhibition of, and remarks upon, a mounted head of an apparently new East-African
antelope (Oryx callotis). Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 195-196, pi. 14.

0105 On some mammals from Mount Dulit, North Borneo. Proceedings of the Zoological Society
o/Lon(/o« 221-227, pis. 18. 19 (figs. 1-6].

0106 Notes on Dr. Kukenthal's discoveries in mammalian dentition. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (6) 9: 308-313.

0107 On two new Central-African antelopes obtained by Mr. F. J. Jackson. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (6) 9:
385-388.

0108 Description of a third species of the genus Nyctophilus. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (6) 9: 405—106.

0109 On the probable identity of certain specimens, formerly in the l.idth de Jeude Collection,
and now in the British Musem, with those figured by Albert Seba in his Thesaurus' of 1734.
Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 309-318.

01 10 On the antelopes of the genus Cephalophus. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of
/,o/k/o« 413-430.

M. R. O. THOMAS 41

0111 On the insectivorous genus Echinops. Martin, with notes on the dentition of the allied

genera. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 5(K)-505.
112 Description of a new species of Acomys. Annals and Magazines of Natural History:

including Zoology. Botany and Geology, l.ondon (6) 10: 22.
1113 Descriptions of three new African Muridae. Annals and /Magazine of Natural History:

including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (6) 10: 179-183.
)114 Diagnosis of a new Mexican Geomys. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including

Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (6) 10: 196.

1115 Descriptions of two new Borncan squirrels. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (fi) 10: 214-216.

1116 Note on the Steatomys of Angola. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (6) 10: 264-265.

1117 Description of a new bat of the genus Artiheus from Trinidad. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (6) 10: 4(18-410.

11 18 Note on Mexican examples of Chilonycteris davyi Gray. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (6) 10: 411).

11 19 Description of a remarkable new Sernnopithecus from Sarawak. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (6) 10: 474-477.

1120 Description of a new Mexican bat. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (6) 10: 477^-478.

1121 On the Mammalia collected by Signor Leonardo Fea in Burma and Tenasserim. Annali del
Museo Civico di Storia Naturale di Genova (2a), (O.S. 30) 10: 913-949, pis. 10, 1 1 (figs. 1-7].

1893

)122 On mammals from Nvassaland. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London (1892):

546-554.
1123 Description of a new monkey of the genus Sernnopithecus from northern Borneo.

Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London (1892): 582-583, pi. 41.
)124 Description of a new baboon from East Africa. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:

including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (6) 11: 46-47.

1125 On a new Cephalophus from Mount Kilima-njaro. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (6) 11: 48-49.

1126 On the Mexican representative of Sciurus aberti. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (6) 11: 49-50.

1127 Description of a new species of Sminthus from Kashmir. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (6) 11: 184-186.

1 1 28 Further notes on the genus Chiroderma. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London, (6) 11: 186-187.

0129 Description of a new porcupine from East Africa. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (6) 11: 229-231.

0130 Exhibition of, and remarks upon, a specimen of Nannotragus livingslonianus from northern
Zululand. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 237-239, 1 fig.

0131 Suggestions for the definite use of the word "Type" and its compounds, as denoting
specimens of a greater or less degree of authenticity. Proceedings of the Zoological Society
of London 24i-242.

0132 A fish-eating rodent. Natural Science. London 2 (14): 286. |April 1893: British Museum
(Natural Flistory) copy stamped 29 March].

0133 Description of two new "pocket-mice" of the genus Heteromys. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (6) 11: 329-332.

0134 On some mammals from central Peru. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London
333-341, pis. 28, 29 [figs. 1-10]. [August 1893).

0135 A preliminary list of the mammals of Trinidad. Journal of the Trinidad Field Naturalists'
Club, Port of Spain 1: 158-168.

0136 On a second collection of mammals sent by Mr. H. H. Johnston, C\B., from Nyasaland.
Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 5(X)-504.

0137 On some new Bornean Mammalia. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (6) 11: 341-347.

42 J. E. HILL

0138 Notes on some Mexican Oryzomys. Annuls und Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (b) II: 402^05.

0139 Description of a new species of Perognathus from Colorado. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (h) II: 405—406.

0140 Description of a new Sciuropterus from the Philippines. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (6) 12: 3(>-31.

0141 Description of a new Bornean Tupaui. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (6) 12: .'i3-.'>4.

0142 Description of a second species of the carnivorous genus Nandinia. from southern
Nyasaland. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology. Botany and
Geology. London (6) 12: 205.

0143 Descriptions of two new North-Bornean mammals. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (6) 12: 230-232, pi. 7.

0144 On two new members of the genus Heteromys and two of Neoloma. Annals and Magazine
of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (h) 12: 23.^235.

0145 Descriptions of two new rodents from the Victoria Nyanza. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (6) 12: 267-264.

0146 On some of the larger species of Geomys. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London '6) 12: 269-273.

1894

0147 Directions for preparing small mammal skins. [With a manuscript note by Oldtield
Thomas "The first edition of the directions printed privately as Dr. Gunther [then
the Keeper of Zoology] did not think that any such issue would be of use to the
Museum"].

0148 Descriptions of two new species of Macroscelides. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (6) 13: 67-70.

0149 On a new species of armadillo from Bolivia. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (6) 13: 70-72.

0150 Description of a new species of reed-rat (Aulacodus) from East Africa, with remarks on the
milk-dentition of the genus. .Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology,
Botany and Geology. London (6) 13: 202-204.

0151 Note on Mus burtoni Thomas. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology,
Botany and Geology. London (6) 13: 204-205.

0152 Description of a new bat of the genus Stenoderma from Montserrat. Proceedings of the
Zoological Society of London 132-133.

0153 Exhibition of. and remarks upon, a skin of a giraffe from Somaliland Proceedings of the
Zoological Society of London 135-136.

0154 On the mammals of Nyasaland: third contribution. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of
London 136-146.

0155 Diagnosis of a new Pieropus from the Admiralty Islands. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (6) 13: 293.

0156 On two new Chinese rodents. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology,
Botany and Geology, London (6) 13: 363-365.

0157 Preliminary description of a new goat of the genus Hemilragus, from south-eastern Arabia.
Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London
(6) 13: .365-366.

0158 On the Palawan representative of Tupaia ferruginea. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History, including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (6) 13: 367.

0159 On the dwarf antelopes of the genus Madoi/ua. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of
Lom/wi .32.3-329. tigs. 1-3.

0160 On some mammals from Engano Island, west of Sumatra, .'\nnali del Museo Civico di Storia
Naturale di Genova (2a). (O.S. 34) 14: 105 1 10.

0161 On two new Neotropical mammals. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (6) 13: 436-439.

0162 Preliminary diagnosis of a new ga/clle from Algeria Annals and Magazine of Natural
History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (6) 13: 452.

M. R. O. THOMAS 43

1)163 On some specimens of mammals from Oman, S.E. Arabia. Proceedings of the Zoological

Society of London 44K— IS5, pi. 31.
(1164 On a new African genus of Mustelidae. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including

Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (6) 13: 522-.'i24.
Olfi.S On some gazelles brought by Sir Edmund Loder from Algeria. Proceedings of the

Zoological Society of London 467—472. pi. 32.

0166 On Micoiireits griseits Desm., with the description of a new genus and species of
Didelphyidae. Annals and Magazine of Natural Historv: including Zoologv. Botan\ and
GcoH'V, London (6) 14: 1«4-1«8.

0167 First glimpses of the zoology of the Natuna Islands. III. List of the Hrst collection of
mammals from the Natuna Islands. Novitales Zoologicae 1: 652-66(1. [With E. Hartert].

0I6H Description of a new species of Vespertilio from China. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (6) 14: 300-301 .

(1164 Descriptions of some new Neotropical Muridae. Annals and Magazine of Natural Historv:
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (6) 14: 345-366.

0170 A preliminary revision of the Bornean species of the genus Mas. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (6) 14: 449—460.

0171 Description of two new bats of the genus Kerivoula. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (6) 14: 460-462.

0172 The book of antelopes. London: R }i. Porter. [With P. L. Sclater: 4 vols., published
1894-1901].

1895

0173 On the brush-tailed porcupine of central Africa. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (6) 15: XH-89.

0174 On some mammals collected by Dr. E. Modigliani in Sipora. Mcntawei Islands. Annali del
Museo Civico di Storia Naturale di Genova (2a). (O.S. 34) 14: 660-672.

0175 On the proper specific names of the common shrews of England and the Continent.
Zoologist. London (3) 19: 62-64.

0176 Diagnoses of two new East-African mammals. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (6) 15: 187-188.

0177 An analysis of the mammalian generic names given in Dr. C. W. L. Gloger's Naturgeschichte
( 1841 ). Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology.
London (6) 15: 189-193.

0I7S On the long-lost Putorious africaiius Desm., and its occurrence in Malta. Proceedings of the
Zoological Society of London 1 28- 131.

0179 Revised determinations of three of the Natuna rodents. Novitates Zoologicae 2: 26-28.

0180 Yellow-tailed squirrels. Zoologist. London (3) 19: 103-104.

0181 Esplorazionc del Giuba e dei suoi Affluenti compiuta dal Cap. V. Bottego durante gli anni
1892-93 gotto gli auspicii della Societa Geographica Italiana, - Risultati Zoologici. 1.
Mammiferi. Annali del Museo Civico di Storia Naturale di Genova (2a). (O.S. 35) IS: .3-6.

0182 The Irish stoat distinct from the British. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (6) 15: 374. [With G. E. H. Barrett-Hamilton].
[April: "A fuller account . . . will appear in the 'Zoologist' for April"'].

0183 The Irish stoat distinct from the British Species. Zoologist. London (3) 19: 124-129 [With
G. E. H. Barrett-Hamilton]. [April].

0184 Description of a new species of Helictis from Borneo. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (6) 15: 331-332.

0185 On the proper specific name of the weasel. Zoologist, London (3) 19: 177-178.

0186 The proper specific name of the weasel. Zoologist, London (3) 19: 225-226.

0187 The Irish stoat in the Isle of Man. Zoologi.st. London (3) 19: 226-227.

0188 On the representatives of Putorius ermineus in Algeria and Ferghana. Annals and Magazine
of Natural History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (6) 15: 451—454.

0189 ]The Pacific rat ^Mus exulans) from Sunday Island, Kermadec Group.] In Sclater, PL.,
Remarks on the Pacific rat (Mas exulans). Proceeding's of the Zoological Society of London
3.38.

0190 On a special mountain race of the plantam squirrel from Mount Dulit, E. Sarawak. Annals

44 J- E. HILL

and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology. Hotanv and Geology. I.ornlon (fi) IS:
529-531.

0191 On a new banded mungoose from Somaliland. Annal.s and Magazine of Natural Hi.'itory:
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (6) IS: 531-532.

0192 On some mammals collected by Mr. Albert Meek on Fergusson Island, d'Entrecasteaux
Group. Novitates Zoologicae 2: 163-166.

0193 On the mammals of Aden. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 542-555. [With
J. W. Yerbur>l.

0194 The Assoguc (Putorius hihernicus): a peculiar British mammal Natural .Science. London 6
(40): 377-378, pi. 4.

0195 Descriptions of five new African shrews. Annuls and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology. Botany and Geology, l^ondon (6) 16: 51-55.

0196 On small mammals from Nicaragua and Bogota. Annals and Magazine of Natural History,
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (6) 16: 55-60.

0197 Preliminar\- diagnosis of new mammals from northern Luzon, collected by Mr. John
Whitehead. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology. Botany and
Geology, London (6) 16: 160-164.

0198 On a new species of Eliurus. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology.
Botany and Geology. London (6) 16: 164-165,

0199 Description of a new Chinese squirrel. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (6) 16: 242.

0200 On African mole-rats of the genera Georhychus and Myoscalops. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (6) 16: 238-241.

0201 Descriptions of four small mammals from South America, including one belonging to the
peculiar marsupial genus "Hyracodon." Tomes. Annals and Magazine of Natural History,
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (6) 16: 367-370.

0202 On a second collection of mammals from the Natuna Islands. Novitates Zoologicae. 1: 489-
492. [With E. Hartert].

0203 Land mammals. In The Scientific Results of the 'Challenger' Expedition. Natural Science,
London 7 (41): 73-74.

1896

0204 On Caenolesles, a still existing survivor of the Epanorthidae of Ameghino, and the
representative of a new family of recent marsupials. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of
London {]m5). 870-878, pi. 50 (figs. 1-9).

0205 On a wild living mouse of the Mus rnusculus group in Portugal. Zoologist. London (3) 20:
137-139.

0206 On mammals from Celebes. Borneo and the Philippines recently received at the British
Museum. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and
Geology. London (6) 18: 241-250.

0207 Description of a new Acomys from Somaliland. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (6) 18: 269 270.

0208 On new small mammals from the Neotropical region. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (6) 18: .^01 314

0209 The seasonal changes in the common squirrel. Zoologist. London (3) 20: 401—407.

0210 On Capt. Bottego's second collection of mammals from central and southern Somaliland.
Annali di Museo Civico di Storia Naturale di Genova (2a). (OS. 37) 17: 105-107.

0211 On mammals collected by Mr. Albert Meek on Woodlark Island, and on Kiriwina in the
Trobriand Islands. Novitates Zoologicae 3: 526-529.

1897

0212 On the mammals of Nyasaland: fourth notice. Proceedings of the Zoological .Society of
London (1896): 788-798. pis. 38-39.

0213 On the genera of rodents: an attempt to bring up to date the current arrangement of the
order. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London ( 1896): 1012-1028.

0214 On the Tsu-shima representative of the Japanese sable. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (6) 19: 161 162.

M. R.O.THOMAS 45

0215 On a new gazelle from central Arabia. Annals and Magazine of Naliiral History: including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (6) 19: 162-163.

0216 On a new dormouse from Mashonaland. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (6) 19: ,■^88-389.

0217 On a new .species of Lagidium from the eastern coast of Patagonia. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (6) 19: 466—167.

0218 Notes on some South American Muridae. I. On three new species from the Lower Amazon
[pp. 494—497]. II. The species of the genus Nectomys [pp. 497--'iOO]. III. A peculiar genus
for "Oryzomys" instans [pp. 5(H)-501[. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (6) 19: 494- .SOI.

0219 [Exhibition of a selection of mammals recently collected by Mr. A. Whyte during his
expedition to the Nyika Plateau and the Masuku mountains, north Nyasa.) Minutes of the
Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 4 May: 1 . [7 May[.

0220 [Account of the mammals obtained by Mr. John Whitehead during the last three years in
the Philippine Islands.] Minutes of the Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London \5
June: 1.

0221 Exhibitionof specimens and descriptions of new species of mammals from north Nyasaland,
with a note on the genus Petrodromus. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London
430-436. [October].

0222 On the number of grinding teeth possessed by the manatee. Proceedings of the Zoological
Society of London 595-600, pi. 36 (figs. 1-5|. [With R. Lydekker|.

0223 Notice of a memoir on the mammals obtained by Mr. John Whitehead in the Philippines.
Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 722.

0224 On some new phalangers of the genus Pseudochirus. Annali di Museo Civico di Storia
Naturale di Genova (2a). (O.S. 38) 18: 142-146.

0225 Description of a new rat from China. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (6) 20: 1 13-1 14.

0226 On some small mammals from Salta, northern Argentina. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (6) 20: 214-218.

0227 Descriptions of four new South-American mammals. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (6) 20: 218-221.

0228 On two new rodents from Van, Kurdistan. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (6) 20: 308-310.

0229 Types in natural history and nomenclature of rodents. Science, New York, (N.S.), 6:
485-*87.

0230 On some bats obtained in the Surat and Thana Districts by Mr. R. C. Wroughton. Journal
of the Bombay Natural History Society II: 274-276.

0231 On the dwarf mungoosc (Helogale) of Somaliland. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (6) 20: ytl-yi').

0232 Diagnosis of a new subspecies of gazelle from British East Africa. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (6) 20: 475.

0233 Descriptions of new bats and rodents from America. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (6) 20: 544-553.

0234 Viaggio di Lamberto Loria nella Papuasia Oricntale. XIX. On the mammals collected in
British New Guinea by Dr. Lamberto Loria. Annali di Museo Civico di Storia Naturale di
Genova (2a), (O.S. .38) 18: 606-622, pi. 2.

0235 [Exhibition of a skin of a new skunk of the genus Spilogale from Sinaloa, Mexico, proposed
to be termed Spilogale pygmaea.j Minutes of the Proceedings of the Zoological Society of
Lon(i(«i 30 November: 1.

0236 [Exhibition of a badger from Lower California, proposed to be termed Taxidea taxus
infusca.] Minutes of the Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 30 November: I.

1898

0237 Note on their recently published paper on the dentition of the manatee. Proceedings of the
Zoological Society of London (1897): 814. [With R. Lydekker].

0238 In Waite, E. R.. On the habits of the Sydney bush-rat (Mus arboricola). With a note by
Oldfield Thomas. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London (1897): 857-860.

46 J. L. llll.L

0239 Exhibition of. and remarks upon, specimens of an antelope of the genus CervUapra
obtained by Mr. F. V. Kirby in the Transvaal. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of
London ( 1,S97): 894-898. [Thomas read this contribution by Kirby, and remartced upon the
status of Kirl> 's newly proposed name Cervicapra fidvoriifiilti siibulpinu].

0240 Exhibition and description of a specimen of a new skunk. Spilogutc pvgmaeu. from Mexico.
Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London (1897): 898-899.

0241 Exhibition and description of a specimen of a new badger, Taxidea iaxii.s infiisca. from
Lower California. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London ( 1897): 899.

0242 On the mammals obtained by Mr. A. Whyte in Nyasaland, and presented to the British
Museum by Sir H. H. Johnston, K.C.B.; being a hfth contribution to the mammal-fauna of
Nyasaland. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London ( 1897): 92.'S-939, pi. 54.

024.3 On new mammals from western Mexico and Lower California. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (7) 1: 40-46.

0244 On indigenous Muridae in the West Indies: with the description of a new Mexican
Orvzornys. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoologv. Botany and
Gt'o/f)gv, London (7) 1: 176-180.

0245 [Exhibition of the skull of a giraffe from the Niger region. | Minutes of the Proceedings of the
Zoological Society of London 1 February: 1.

0246 Exhibition of. and remarks upon, the skull of a supposed new subspecies of giraffe from
West Africa, proposed to be named Giraffa camelopardalis peralta. Proceedings of the
Zoological Society of London 39-41 .

0247 On the mammals collected during Captain Bottegos last expedition to Lake Rudolf and the
Upper Sobat. Annali di Museo Civico di Storm Naturale di Genova (2a), (O.S. .38) 18:
676-679.

0248 Description of a new bat from North Borneo. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (7) 1: 243.

0249 Description of a new Echimys from the neighbourhood of Bogota. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (7) 1: 243-245.

0250 Descriptions of three new mammals from East Indian Archipelago and Australia. Novitates
Zoologicae. London 5: 1—4.

0251 The technical names of British mammals. Zoologist. London (4) 2: 97-103.

0252 On some mammals obtained by the late Mr. Henry Durnford in Chubut. E Patagonia.
Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 210-212.

0253 On some new mammals from the neighbourhood of Mount Sahama. Bolivia. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History; includini; Zooloe.y. Botany and Geology. London (7) 1:
277-283.

0254 Descriptions of two new Argentine rodents. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (7) 1: 283-286.

0255 Exhibition of. and remarks upon, a series of a Siamese squirrel showing variability in
coloration. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 245-246.

0256 [Description of a new dik-dik allied to Madoqiia kirkii.l Minutes of the Proceedings of the
Zoological Society of London 5 April: 1 .

0257 Description of a new dik-dik antelope [Madoqua) discovered In N.E. Africa by Mr H S.
H. Cavendish. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 278-279.

0258 Viaggio del Dott. A. Borclli ncl Chaco Boliviano e nella Republica Argentina. XII. On the
small mammals collected by Dr. Borelli in Bolivia and northern Argentina. Bollettino dei
Musei di Zoologia ed Anatomia Comparata della R. Univerista di Torino 13 (315): 1 4.

0259 Description of a new bat from Selangore. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (7) 1: 360-362.

0260 On a small collection of mammals obtained by Mr. Alfred Sharpe. C.B., in Nyasaland.
Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 391-394.

0261 Viaggio di Lamberto Loria nella Papuasia Orientale. XX. Descriptions of two new cuscuses
(Phalanger) obtained by Dr. Loria in British New Guinea. Annali di Mu.'ieo Civico di Storia
Naturale di Genova (2a). (OS. .39) 19: 5-8.

0262 On seven new small mammals from Ecuador and Venezuela. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (7) 1: 451^57.

0263 On the mammals obtained by Mr. John Whitehead during his recent expedition to the

M. R. O. THOMAS 47

Philippines. With ticid notes by the collector. Tninsuclions of the Zoological Socielv of

London 14: 377-412, pis. 3()-36.
0264 Descriptions of two new cuscuses (Phalanger). Novilales Zoolof>icae, 5: 433—134.
(1265 Descriptions of new Bornean and Sumatran mammals. Annals and Magazine of Natural

Hislorv: including Zoology. Botany and Cieology, London (7) 2: 245-251.
(1266 Descriptions of new mammals from South America. Annals and Magazine of Natural

History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (7) 2: 265-275.
(1267 On the Zululand form of Livingstone's antelope. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;

including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (7) 2: 317.
(I26S Notes on various American mammals. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including

Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 2: 318-320.

0269 The scientific names of the badger and the common vole. Zoologist, London (4) 2: 263-264.

1899

0270 On mammals collected by Mr. J. D. La Touche at Kuatun, N.W. Fokicn. China.
Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London ( 1S9X): 769-775.

0271 On some small mammals from the District of Cuzco, Peru. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 3; 40-44.

0272 On a new species of Marmosa. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology,
Botany and Geology, London (7) 3: 44-45.

0273 On new small mammals from South America. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 3: 152-155.

0274 Description of a new Phascogale from British New Guinea, obtained by Dr. L. Loria.
Annali di Museo Civico di Storia Naturale di Genova (2a), (O.S. 4(1) 20; 191-192.

0275 [Exhibition of the skull of a baboon recently obtained at Aden by Messrs. Percival and
Dodson]. Minutes of the Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 28 November: 7.

0276 Descriptions of new Neotropical mammals. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 4: 278-288.

0277 Descriptions of new rodents from the Orinoco and Ecuador. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 4: 378-383.

1900

0278 Exhibition of the skull of an apparently new species of baboon from Aden, proposed to be
named Papio arabicus. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London ( 1899): 929.

0279 A new bat from the Key Islands. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 5: 145.

0280 The geographical races of the tayra (Galictis barbara). with notes on abnormally coloured
individuals. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and
Geology, London (7) 5: 145-148.

0281 New South-American mammals. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (7) 5: 148-153.

0282 Description of a new fruit-bat from New Guinea. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (7) 5: 216-217.

0283 Descriptions of new Neotropical mammals. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (7) 5: 217-222.

0284 [Possible invalidity of Thylacoinys.\ [p. 223]. In Waite. E. R., The generic name Thylacomys.
Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London
(7) 5: 222-223.

0285 [Exhibition of a kangaroo from northern Australia allied to Macropus eugenii] Minutes of
the Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 20 February : 23.

0286 [Exhibition of a kangaroo from western Australia, apparently referable to Macropus
robustus.l Minutes of the Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 20 February: 23.

0287 [Enumeration of species obtained by Mr. H. J. Mackinder during his recent expedition to
Mount Kenya, British East Africa] Minutes of the Proceedings of the Zoological Society of
London 20 February: 24-25.

0288 Exhibition of, and remarks upon, some mounted heads of antelopes from Fashoda and the
Sobat River. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 84-85.

48 J. E. HILL

0289 On the mammals obtained in south-western Arabia by Messrs. Percival and Dodson.
Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 95-104.

0290 Exhibition of, and remarks upon, a skin of a new species of kangaroo, proposed to be called
MacTopiis bedfordi. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 112-113.

0291 Exhibition of. and remarks upon, a skin of a new subspecies of kangaroo from western
Australia, proposed to be named Macropus robustus cervinns. Proceedings of the Zoo-
logical Society of London 113.

0292 List of mammals obtained by Mr. H. J. Mackinder during his recent expedition to Mount
Kenya. British East Africa. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of iMndon 173-18(1. 1 lig.

0293 Descriptions of new Neotropical mammals. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 5; 269-274.

0294 Descriptions of two new Sciuropteri discovered by Mr. Charles Hose in Borneo. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History: including Zooloi;y. Botanv and Geology. London (7) 5:
275^276.

0295 Descriptions of two new murines from Peru and a new hare from Venezuela. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (7) 5:
354-357.

0296 A new skunk from Peru. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology,
Botany and Geology. London (7) 5: 499-5(X).

0297 On giant squirrels from the Amazonian region. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 6: 137-139.

0298 List of the mammals obtained by Dr. G. Franco Grillo in the Province of Parana, Brazil.
Annali di Mtiseo Civico di Storia Naturale di Genova (2a), (O.S. 40) 20: 546-549.

0299 Descriptions of new rodents from western South America. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7)5: 294-302.

0300 On the "Tohi", the East African reedbuck currently known as Cervicapra bohor. Annals
and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 6:
303-304.

0301 Descriptions of new rodents from western South America. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7)6: 383-387.

0302 A new dassie from north Nyasaland. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, l-ondon (7) 6: 387.

0303 On Equus penricei , a representative of the mountain zebra (Equus zebra L.) discovered by
Mr. W. Penrice in Angola. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology,
Botany and Geology, London (7) 6: 465—466.

0304 New Peruvian species of Conepatus. Phyllotis, and Akodon. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 6: 466-469.

0305 The white rhinoceros on the Upper Nile. Nature. London 62: 599.

0306 The red flying squirrel of the Natuna Islands. Noyitates Zoologicae 7: 592.

0307 [Review of P. Matschie's "Die Fledermause des Berliner Museums fur Naturkunde" |

0308 [On mammals obtained by Dr. Donaldson Smith during his latest expedition from
Somaliland by Lake Rudolf to the Upper Nile j Minutes of the Proceedings of the Zoological
Society of London 20 November: 4.

1901

0309 [Letter to Mr. P. L. Sclater regarding Thomas' proposals for formalizing the ■Minutes" and
"Abstracts" of the Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London. | Evidently printed by
the Zoological Society of London as a broadsheet for circulation.

0310 List of mammals obtained by Dr. Donaldson Smith during his recent journey from Lake
Rudolf to the Upper Nile. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London (I9(kl): 8(M> 807.

0311 New mammals from Peru and Bolivia, with a list of those recorded from the Inambari
River, Upper Madre de Dios. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology,
Botany and Geology, London (7) 7: 178-190.

0312 A new free-tail bat from the Lower Amazons. Annals and .Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, Uindon (7) 7: 190 191.

0313 The generic names Myrmecophaga and Didelphis. The American Naturalist, Boston 35:
143-145.

M. R. O. THOMAS 49

0314 New South American Sciuri, Heleromys. Cavia, and Caluromys. Annals and Magazine of
Naliiral History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (7) 7: 192-196.

11315 On the mammals of the Balearic Islands. Proceedings of the Zoological Societv of London 1:
3.S-;4.

0316 [Spanish article ("Una Traduccion") on collections from the Balearic Islands.] 'El Bien
Publico' . Mahin, 26 August.

0317 A new scotophiline bat from British East Africa, with the description of a new genus of the
group. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology.
London (7) 7: 263-265.

0318 New species of Saccopteryx. Sciurus. Rhipidomys. and Tatu from South America. Annals
and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (7) 7:
366-371.

0319 The name of the ogotona. Proceedings of the Biological Society of Washington 14: 24.

0320 The name of the aard-vark. Proceedings of the Biological Society' of Washington 14: 24.

0321 The name of the viscacha. Proceedings of the Biological Society of Washington 14: 25.

0322 A new spiny rat from La Guaira, Venezuela. Proceedings of the Biological Society of
Washington 14: 27-28.

0323 On a new genus and species of vespertilioninc bat from British East Africa. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (7) 7:
46I.M62.

0324 [On the more notable mammals lately obtained by Sir Harry Johnston in the Uganda
Protectorate.] Minutes of the Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 21 May: 45.

0325 On the more notable mammals obtained by Sir. Harry Johnston in the LIganda Protectorate.
Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 2: 85-90, pi. 5.

0326 New Myotis. Artibeus. Sylyilagus. and Mctachirus from central and South America. Annals
and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (7) 7:
541-545.

0327 [History of a specimen of Rhinoceros lasiotis in London Zoo; generic nomenclature of
Rhinoccrotidae] Minutes of the Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 4 June:
49-50.

0328 Notes on the type specimen of Rhinoceros lasiotis Sclater; with remarks on the generic
position of the living species of rhinoceros. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London
2: 154-158.

0329 [Exhibition of a pair of antlers which had been sent home by Mr. Charles Hose, who had
obtained them from central Borneo. [ Minutes of the Proceedings of the Zoological Society of
London 18 June: 54.

0330 [On Cervus spatulatus. sp. n.) [An unpublished proof, with three illustrations of the antlers,
intended for the Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London. In Thomas' collected
works|.

0331 Some new African bats (including one from the Azores) and a new galago. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (7) 8: 27-34.

0332 On a collection of mammals from the Kanuko Mountains, British Guiana. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (7) 8:
139-154.

0333 List of small mammals obtained by Mr. A. E. Pease, MP., during his recent expedition to
Abyssinia, with descriptions of three new forms of Macroscelides. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (7) 8: 154-156.

0334 On a new form of puma from Patagonia. .Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (7) 8: 188-189.

0335 On a collection of bats from Para. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (7)8: 189-193.

0336 New Neotropical mammals, with a note on the species of Reithrodon. Annals and Magazine
of Natural History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (7) 8: 246-255.

0337 New species of Macroscelides and Glauconycleris. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Z.oology, Botany and Geology. London (7) 8: 255-257.

0338 New insular forms of Nasua and Dasyprocta. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (7) 8: 271-273.

50 J. E. HILL

0339 On a collection of small mammals from the Upper Nile obtained by Mr. R. M. Hawker.
Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London
(7) 8: 273-278.

0340 On a collection of bats from Paraguay. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (7) 8: 435^43.

0341 On mammals obtained by Mr Alphonsc Robert on the Rio Jordao. S.W. Minaes Gcraes.
Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London
(7) 8: 526-536.

0342 New species of Oryzomys. Proechimys, Cavia, and Sylvilagits from South America. Annals
and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 8:
5.36-539.

0343 On some kangaroos and bandicoots from Barrow Island and the mainland. Novitates
Zoologicae. London 8: 394-396.

0344 Antilope nouvelle. Cephalophus weynsi. Annales du Musee Royal du Congo Beige,
Bruxelles. Tervuren, (C), Zoologie 2; 15-16. pi. 6.

0345 [On a five-horned giraffe obtained by Sir Harry Johnston near Mount Elgon.] Minutes of
the Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 19 November: 4.

1902

0346 On the five-horned giraffe obtained by Sir Harrv Johnston near Mount Elgon. Proceedings
of the Zoological Society of London ('1901) 2: 474-483. figs. 42-48.

0347 Remarks on the reproduction of the duckbill. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of
London (1901) 2: 624-625. [With G. Metcalfe].

0348 A new blue duiker from Nyasaland. .Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (7) 9: 58-59.

0349 On mammals from the Serra do Mar. Parana, collected by Mr. Alphonsc Robert. Annals
and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (7) 9;
59-64.

0350 On mammals from Cochabamba, Bolivia, and the region north of that place Annals and
Magazine of Natural History; includini; Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (7) 9:
125-143.

0351 [A description of two new rodents discovered by Mr. P. O. Simons near Potosi, Bolivia.)
Minutes of the Proceedings of the Zoological .Society of London 18 February: 24.

0352 [On some new mammals from northern Nyasaland] Minutes of the Proceedings of the
Zoological Society of London 18 February: 24.

0353 Exhibition of. and remarks upon, the skin and skull of a yellow-backed duiker {Cephalo-
phus sylvicultrix) from N.E. Rhodesia. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 1:
1-2.

0354 On two new genera of rodents from the highlands of Bolivia. Proceedings of the Zoological
Society of London 1: 114-117, pis. 8. 9 Jfigs. 1-12].

0355 On some new mammals from northern Nvasaland. Proceedings of the Zooloi;ical Society of
London I: \\S-\2\.

0356 On the bear of Ecuador. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology,
Botany and Geology, London (7) 9: 215-217.

0357 On two new species of Mus discovered by Mr. S. L. Hinde in British East Africa. Annals
and Magazine of Natural History; including Z.oolovy. Botany and Geology, London (7) 9:
218-220.

0358 On a new genus of vcspertilionine bat from New Guinea Annals and Magazine of Natural
History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (7) 9: 22l>-222.

0359 On mammals collected by Mr. Perry O. Simons m the southern part of the Bolivian Plate:iu
Annals and Magazine of Natural History; mcludini; Zoology, Bolanv and Geoloi;y. I.oniloii
(7) 9: 222-230.

0360 On mammals collected at Cruz del Ejc. central Cordova, by Mr. P. O. Simons. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (7) 9:
237-245.

0361 On the geographical races of the kinkajou. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 9: 266 269.

M. R. O. THOMAS 51

0362 On a new species of Alheriiru discovered by Capt. Guy Burrows on the Congo. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (7) 9: 269-271 .

0363 A new Hipposiderus from Borneo. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (7) 9: 271-272.

0364 New species of Dipodillus and Psammomys. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 9: 362-365.

0365 A new genet from British East Africa. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 9: 365-366.

0366 [On the mammals obtained during the Whitaker expedition to Tripoh.] Minutes of the
Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 6 May: 39.

0367 On the mammals collected during the Whitaker expedition to Tripoli. Proceedings of the
Zoological Society of London 2: 2-13.

0368 The Lvcaon and Pedeles of British East Africa, and a new gerbille from N. Nyasa. L Lycaon
[pp. 438-140|. 11. Pedetes [pp. 440-441|. III. Tatera liodon sp. nov. [pp. 441^42]. Annals
and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (7) 9:
438-442.

0369 On the species of Mydaus found in Borneo and the Natuna Islands. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 9: 442-444.

0370 On a new marmot from north Siberia. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (7) 9: 444-445.

0371 Description of a new Uromys from the Solomon Islands. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (7) 9: 446^47.

0372 The generic names of the peccaries, northern fur seal, and sea leopard. Proceedings of the
Biological Society of Washington 15: 153-154.

0373 Notes on the phyllostomatous genera Mimon and Tonatia. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (7) 10: 53-54.

0374 A method of fixing the type in certain genera. Science, New York (N.S.), 16: 114-115,
[With numerous others[.

0375 On Marmosa marmota and elegans. with descriptions of new subspecies of the latter. Annals
and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (7) 10:
158-162.

0376 The genet of the Balearic Islands. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (7) 10: 162-163.

0377 On two new mammals from China. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 10: 163-166.

0378 A new vole from the Lower Yang-tse-kiang. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 10: 166-169.

0379 Diagnosis of a new Central American porcupine. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 10: 169.

0380 A new dik-dik from British East Africa. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 10: 242-243.

0381 On a new monkey from Nyasaland. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (7) 10: 243-244.

0382 On two new hares allied to Oryctolagus crassicaudatus. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (7) 10: 244-246.

0383 New forms of Saimiri, Phyllolis, Coendou, and Cyclopes. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 10: 246-250.

0384 On the panda of Sze-chuen. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology,
Botany and Geology (7) 10: 251-252.

0385 On the East-African representative of the bongo and its generic position. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 10:
309-310.

0386 On some new forms of Oloniys. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (7) 10: 311-314.

0387 [Exhibition of, and remarks upon, the East African representative of the bongo antelope,
Boocercus euryceros isaaci.j Minutes of the Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London
18 November: 7.

52 J- E. HILL

0388 A new Rynchocyon from Nyasaland. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (7) 10: 403-404.

0389 On five new mammals from Arabia and Persia. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (7) 10: 487— 49L

0390 Two new Australian small mammals. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (7) 10: 491^92.

0391 On Azara's "Chauve-souris onzieme" (Myotis ruber. Geoff.) and a new species allied to it.
Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London
(7) 10: 493-494.

0392 On the mole of the Roman district. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (7) 10: 515-517.

0393 On the generic names Notophorus, Alces. Dama. and Cephalotes. with remarks on the
"one-letter rule" in nomenclature. Proceedings of the Biological Society of Washington 15:
197-198.

0394 On some mammals from Coiba Island, off the west coast of Panama. Novilates Zoologicae
9: 135-137.

1903

0395 On a collection of mammals from Abyssinia, including some from Lake Tsana. collected by
Mr. Edward Degen. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London (1902) 2: 308-316.

0396 Exhibition of, and remarks upon, some specimens of the East-African bongo antelope
(Boocercus eurvceros isaaci). Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London (1902) 2:
319-320.

0397 On a remarkable new hare from Cape Colony. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (7) 11: 78-79.

0398 On two new squirrels of the Funisciurus pyrrhopus group. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (7) II: 79-81.

0399 New species of Oxyniycterus. Thrichomys. and Ctenomys from South America. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology (7) 11: 226-229.

04(K) Two new glossophagine bats from Central America. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (7) 11: 286-289.

0401 Note on the technical name of the Tasmanian devil. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (7) II: 289.

0402 A new duiker from West Africa. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (7) 11: 289-291.

0403 On a collection of mammals from the small islands off the coast of western Panama.
Novitates Zoologicae 10: 39—42.

0404 [Exhibition of the skin of a monkey from Kweichow. China.) Minutes of the Proceedings of
the Zoological Society of London 17 March: 29.

0405 [Exhibition of adult and young examples of a new bush duiker from British East Africa.]
Minutes of the Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 17 March: 29.

0406 New mammals from Chiriqui. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology,
Botany and Geology, London (7) 11: 376-382.

0407 Two South American forms of Rhogeessa. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 11: 382-383.

0408 [On some mammals collected by Capt. H. N. Dunn. R.A.M.C. in the Egyptian Sudan.)
Minutes of the Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 21 April: 33.

0409 On three new forms of Peromyscus obtained by Dr. Hans Gadow, F.R.S. , and Mrs. (iadow
in Mexico. Annals and Magazine of Natural History including Zoology, Botany and
Geology, London (7) 11: 484-487.

0410 New forms of Sciurus, Oxyniycterus, Kannabateomys, Proechimys, Dasyprocia, and
Caluromys from South America. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) II: 487—493.

041 1 Two new dormice of the genus Eliomys. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) II: 494-496.

0412 On the species of the genus Rhinopoma. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 11: 496-499.

M. R.O.THOMAS 53

0413 [Exhibition of the skull of a remarkable form of Gazella granlij Minutes of the Proceedings

of the /Mological Society of London Ifi June: 44.
f)414 On two new Muridae from Smyrna. Annals and Magazine of Natural Hisiorv; including

Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (7) 12: KSX-mO.

0415 Note sur les rongeurs de Tunisie recueiilis par M. Marias Blanc. Bulletin de la Societe
Zoologique de France. Paris 28: 171-174. [With E. Trouessartj.

0416 On a small collection of mammals from the Rio de Oro, western Sahara. Novitales
Zoologicae 10: 3(K)-302.

1)417 Notes on Neotropical mammals of the genera Felis. Hapale. Oryzomys. Akodon, and
Ctenomys. with descriptions of new species. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (7) 12: 234-243.

0418 Exhibition of a skin and description of a new species of monkey. Rhinopithecus brelichi.
Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London I: 224-225, pi. 21.

0419 Exhibition of specimens and description of a new species of duiker, Cephalophus ignifer.
Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 1: 225-226.

0420 On some mammals collected by Capt. H. N. Dunn, R.A.M.C., in the Soudan. Proceedings
of the Zoological Society of London 1 : 294-30 1 .

0421 New African Mammalia of the genera Petrodrornus. Dendromys, Mas and Lepus. Annals
and Magazine of Natural Hisiorv: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 12:
339-344.

0422 Notes on South American monkeys, bats, carnivores, and rodents, with descriptions of new
species. Annals and Magazine of Natural History, including Zoology, Botany and Geology,
London (7) 12: 455-464.

0423 A new mungoose from Namaqualand. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (7) 12: 465-466.

0424 Exhibition of, and remarks upon, the horns of a new form of Grant's gazelle, proposed to
be named Gazella granti robertsi. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 2:
119-121.

0425 Three new species of Nyctinomus. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 12: 501-505.

0426 Three new bats from the Cameroons, discovered by Mr. G. L. Bates. Annals and Magazine
of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 12: 633-635.

0427 [Exhibition of three new mammals from British New Guinea, collected by Mr. A. S. Meek.]
Minutes of the Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 3 November: 4.

0428 (On mammals collected at Chapada by Mr. A. Robert during the Percy Sladen Expedition
to Central-Brazil.] Minutes of the Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 3
November: 4-5.

1904

0429 Exhibition of specimens and descriptions of new species of mammals from New Guinea.
Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London (1903) 2: 196-202, pi. 23.

0430 On the mammals collected by Mr. A. Robert at Chapada, Matto Grosso, (Percy Sladen
Expedition to Central Brazil.). Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London (1903) 2:
232-244, pi. 27.

0431 Exhibition of, on behalf of Mr. W. E. de Winton, F.Z.S., a drawing of a female gazelle
bearing a hair-whorl on the withers. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London (1903)
2: 317-318, tig. ,\5.

0432 Exhibition of, and remarks upon, a specimen of the rodent Fornarina (gen. nov.) phillipsi
and description of Heterocephalus ansorgei (sp. nov). Proceedings of the Zoological Society
of London (m)}.) 2: yyty-T^yi .

0433 [Exhibition of a gazelle obtained by Mr. A. E. Butter in N.E. Africa.] Abstracts of the
Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 19 January, No. 1: 1-2.

0434 [A collection of mammals from Namaqualand presented to the British Musem by Mr. CD.
Rudd] Abstracts of the Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 2 February, No. 2:
5-6. (With H. Schwann],

0435 Two new mammals from South America. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 13: 142-144.

54 J. E. Hll.L

0436 On a collection of mammals made by Mr. J. T. Tunney in Arhcm Land. Northern Territory
of South Australia. Novilales Zoologkae II: 222-229.

0437 On a new rock-wallaby from north-west Australia. Novilales Zoologkae II: 365-366.

0438 [Exhibition of the skull of a buffalo obtained by Col. Delmc-Radcliffe in Ankole. S.W.
Uganda.) Abstracts of the Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 1 March, No. 4:
13.

0439 [Exhibiton of a rare fruit-bat of the genus Scotonycleris obtained in Fernando Po.) Abstracts
of the Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 1 March. No. 4: 13-14.

0440 New bats from British East Africa collected by Mrs. Hinde and from the Camcroons by Mr.
G. L. Bates. Annals and Magazine of Natural History, including Zoology, Botany and
Geology, London (7) 13: 206-210.

0441 New forms oi Saimiri, Saccopteryx, Halantinpteryx, and Thrichomys from the Neotropical
region. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology,
London (7) 13: 250-255.

0442 [Exhibition of skulls of a small North Australian rock-wallaby (Peradorcas concinna
Gould.).) Abstracts of the Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 19 April. No.
6:21.

0443 [Exhibition of the skin and skull of a hartebeest shot by Mr. F. J. Jackson in Uganda.)
Abstracts of the Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 19 April. No. 6: 21-22

0444 (An account of the mammals obtained by Mr. W. G. Doggett on the Anglo-German
Boundary Commission.) Abstracts of the Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London
19 April, No. 6: 22-23.

0445 A new bat from the United States, representing the European Myotis (Leuconoe)
daubentoni. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology. Botany and
Geology, London (7). 13: 3S2-384.

0446 Three new bats. African and Asiatic. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 13: 384-3H8.

0447 On mammals from northern Angola collected by Dr. W. J. Ansorgc. Annals and Magazine
of Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 13: 405^21 . 2 tigs.

0448 Exhibition of a skin and skull and description of a new subspecies of gazelle. Gazella
soemmerringii butteri. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 1 : 4-5 .

0449 On a collection of mammals from British Namaqualand. presented to the National Museum
by Mr. C. D. Rudd. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London I: 171-183, pi. 6 [Hgs
1-2). [With H. Schwann).

0450 New Sciurus, Rhipidomys, Sylvilagus, and Caluromys from Venezuela. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History: including Zootogv, Botany and Geology. London (7) 14:
33-37.

0451 Ergebnissc zoologischer Forschungsreisen in Sumatra O. K. Zoologischer Anzeiger 27: 722-
724. [With G. Schneider).

0452 On a collection of mammals obtained in Somaliland by Major M.N. Dunn. R.A.M.C.. with
descriptions of allied species from other localities. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, Ix)ndon (7) 14: 94-105. 1 Hg.

0453 On some small mammals collected by Mr. A M. Mackilligin in the Eastern Desert of
Egypt. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology,
London (7) 14: 155-159.

0454 Exhibition of. and remarks upon, the skull of a new form of buffalo from Uganda.
Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 1 : 37 1 .

0455 Exhibition and description of a new species of fruit-bat from Fernando Po. Proceedings of
the Zoological Society of London 1: 371-372.

0456 Exhibition of a skin and description of a new subspecies of hartebeest from Uganda.
Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 1 : 455^56.

0457 On mammals collected during the Uganda Boundary Commission bv the late Mr. W G.
Doggett, and presented to the British Museum by Col. C. Delme-Radclifle. Proceedings of
the Zoological Society of London 1 : 459-465, fig. 95.

0458 New species of Pteropus, Mas and Pogonomys from the Australian region. Novilales
Zoologkae 1 1 : 597~«X).

0459 New Callilhrix, Midas. Felis. Rhipidomys, and Proechimys from Brazil and Ecuador.

M. R. O. THOMAS 55

Annals and Magazine oj Natural Histnr\; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London
(7) 14: 188-196.
()4M) New bats and rodents from West Afriea, the Malay Peninsula, and Papuasia. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 14:
196-202.

0461 On shrews from British East Africa. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 14: 236-241.

0462 On the osteology and systematic position of the rare Malagasy bat Myzopoda aurita.
Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 2: 2-6, pi. 1 [tigs. 1-8).

0463 The forest pig of Central Africa. Nature, London 70: 577.

0464 [Mammals obtained in the island of Fernando Po by Mr. E. Seimund.J Abstracts of the
Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 15 November, No. 10: 12.

0465 [On Hylochoerus, the forest-pig of Central Africa.) Abstracts of the Proceedings of the
Zoological , Society of London 15 November, No. 10: 12-13.

0466 On some mammals from British New Guinea presented to the National Museum by Mr. C.
A. W. Monckton, with descriptions of other species from the same region. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 14:
397^03.

0467 [Exhibition of a pair of gazelles from Jerusalem.) Abstracts of the Proceedings of the
Zoological Society of London 13 December, No. 12: 19.

1905

0468 On mammals from the island of Fernando Po. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of
London (1904) 2: 183-193, pi. 13.

0469 On Hylochoerus. the forest pig of central Africa. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of
London H9i)4), 2: 193-199, pi. 14 )ligs. 1-3), 15 jfigs. 1-5).

0470 Exhibition of specimens and description of a new gazelle from Palestine. Proceedings of the
Zoological Society of London (1904) 2: 347-349.

0471 New African mammals of the genera Glauconycteris, Lutra. Funisciurus, Arvicanthus,
Lophiomys, and Procavia. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology,
Botany and Geology, London (7) 15: 77-83.

0472 )An account of a second collection of mammals made by Mr. C. H. B. Grant for Mr. C. D.
Rudd's exploration of South Africa.) Abstracts of the Proceedings of the Zoological Society
of London 21 February, no. 15: 10. [With H. Schwann).

0473 A new Cricetuliis from Mongolia. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 15: 322-323.

0474 New ground squirrels of the Xerus erythropus group. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 15: 387-390.

0475 [Account of a third collection of mammals made by Mr. C. H. B. Grant for Mr. C. D.
Rudd's exploration of South Africa.) Abstracts of the Proceedings of the Zoological Society
of London 18 April, No. 18: 23. [With H. Schwann).

0476 On some new Japanese mammals presented to the British Museum by Mr. R. Gordon
Smith. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology,
London (7) 15: 487-495, 1 fig.

0477 [Exhibition of a new golden mole obtained in connection with Mr. C. D. Rudd's exploration
of South Africa. Abstracts of the Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 16 May,
No. 20: 5.

0478 New Neotropical Molossus, Conepatus, Nectomys, Proechimys, and Agouti, with a note on
the genus Mesomys. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology, Botany
and Geology, London (7) 15: 584-591.

0479 The Rudd exploration of South Africa. IL List of mammals from the Wakkerstroom
District, south-eastern Transvaal. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 1: 129-
138. [With H. Schwann|.

0480 [Exhibition of a new bushbuck.[ Abstracts of the Proceedings of the Zoological Society of
London 6 June, No. 21 : 9.

0481 [Exhibition of mammals and birds from Japan.) Abstracts of the Proceedings of the
Zoological Society of London 6 June, No. 21: 9-10.

56 J. E. HILL

0482 On a second collection of mammals obtained by Dr. W. J. Ansorge in Angola. Annals and
Magazine of Natural Histon; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 16: 169-
178. [With R. C. Wroughton).

0483 The Rudd exploration of South Africa. III. List of the mammals obtained by Mr. Grant in
Zululand. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 1; 254-276. pi. 16. [With 11
Schwann|.

0484 New Neotropical Chrolopterus. Sciurus. Neacomys, Coendou, Proechimys, and Marmosa.
Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London
(7) 16: 308-314.

0485 On a remarkable new squirrel from Borneo. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (7) 16: 314-315.

0486 Suggestions for the nomenclature of the cranial length measurements and of the cheek teeth
of mammals. Proceedings of the Biological Society of Washington 18: 191 -196. 1 fig.

0487 On some Australasian mammals. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (7) 16: 422—428.

0488 The generic names given by Frisch in 1775. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (7) 16: 461—464.

0489 Description of a new golden mole (Amblysomi4S corriae) from Cape Colony. Proceedings of
the Zoological Society of London 2: 57-58.

0490 Description of a new bushbuck ( Tragelaphus haywoodi) from British East Africa. Proceed-
ings of the Zoological Society of London 2: 180-182.

0491 Exhibition of specimens of mammals and birds from Japan and description of a new
marten (Muslela melampus bedfordi). Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 2:
182-183,

0492 A new genus and two new species of bats. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (7) 16: 572-576.

0493 [Paper on mammals collected in Japan by Mr. M. P. Anderson for His Grace the Duke of
Bedford.] Abstracts of the Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 28 November.
No. 23: 18-19.

0494 [Exhibition of the tail vertebrae of a dormouse of the genus Eliomys.J Abstracts of the
Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 12 December, No. 24: 2L

0495 [On a collection of mammals obtained by Col. A. C. Bailward in Persia and Armenia,]
Abstracts of the Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 12 December, No. 24:
21-22,

1906

0496 The Duke of Bedford's zoological exploration in eastern Asia, I. List of mammals obtained
by Mr, M, P, Anderson in Japan. [With Appendix [pp. 357-363] on collections from the
islands of Oki, Yakushima, and Tanegashima], Proceedings of the Zoological Society of
London (1905) 2: 331-363, pi. 9.

0497 Exhibition of, and remarks upon, tails of dormice showing regeneration of vertebrae.
Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London (1905) 2: 481—494, figs. 70-71.

0498 On a collection of mammals from Persia and Armenia presented to the British Museum by
Col. A, C. Bailward. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London (1905) 2: 519-527,
pi. 16.

0499 On the generic arrangement of the Australian rats hitherto referred to Conilurus. with
remarks on the structure and evolution of their molar cusps. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History; including /.oology. Botany and Geology. London (7) 17: 81-85.

()5(K) A new aquatic genus of Muridae discovered by Consul I.. Soderstrom in Ecuador. Annals
and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (7) 17:
86-88,

0501 On a second species of Lenothrix from the Liu Kiu Islands. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (7) 17 88-89,

0502 [Exhibition of the skull of a forest-pig (Hylochoerus) sent by Mr. G. L, Bates from the
Cameroon.] Abstracts of the Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 16 January,
No, 25: 1-2,

0503 New African mammals of the genera Cercopithecus, Scotophilus, Miniopterus, Crocidura,

M. R. O. THOMAS 57

Georychus, and Heliophobius. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology,
Botany and Geology, London (7) 17: 173-174.

0504 |An account of a collection of mammals made by Mr. C. H. B. Grant at Knysna, Cape
Colony. I Abstracts of the Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 20 Februarv, No.
27: W'. [With H. Schwann].

0505 New mammals from the Australian region. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 17; 324-332.

0506 [Exhibition of a brown bear from the Shan States.] Abstracts of the Proceedings of the
Zoological Society of London 20 March, No. 29: 17.

0507 "Legalised murder". Evening Standard and St. James Gazette, Londor. 27 March. [Signed
'Euthanasia' but bound into Thomas' collected works. In favour of 'legalised suicide'].

0508 New insectivores and voles collected by Mr. A. Robert near Trcbizond. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 17:
415^21.

0509 A third genus of the Ichthyornys group. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 17: 421-^23.

0510 New Asiatic mammals of the genera Kerivotda, Eliomys, and Lepus. Annals and Magazine
of Natural History, including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 17: 423-426.

051 1 On a new genus of free-tail bat from N.E. Africa. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 17: 499-501.

0512 [Exhibition of the skin of a remarkable new duiker from Nyasaland, which had been
presented to the British Museum by Mr. S. W. Frank. | Abstracts of the Proceedings of the
Zoological Society of London I May. No. 31: I.

0513 [On mammals collected in south-west Australia for Mr. W. E. Balston.| Abstracts of the
Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 1 May, No. 31: 1-2.

0514 [On a collection of mammals made by Mr. W. Stalker in the Northern Territory of South
Australia and presented to the National Collection by Sir William Ingram. Bart., and the
Hon. John Forrest.] Abstracts of the Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 15
May, No. 32: 6.

0515 [On mammals collected by Mr. C. H. B. Grant in the Zoutpansberg District of the
Transvaal, and presented to the National Collection by Mr. C. D. Rudd] Abstracts of the
Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 29 May, No. 33: 10.

0516 A new vole from Spain. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology,
Botany and Geology, London (7) 17: 576-577.

0517 Exhibition of, and remarks upon, the skull of a new forest-pig. Proceedings of the
Zoological Society of London I: 2-3. fig. 1.

0518 The Rudd exploration of South Africa. — IV. List of mammals obtained by Mr. Grant at
Knysna. Cape Colony. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 1: 159-168.

0519 Descriptions of new mammals from Mount Ruwenzori. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (7) 18: 136-147.

0520 On a new pygmy antelope obtained by Col. J.J. Harrison in the Semliki Forest. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 18:
148-150.

0521 Description of a new subspecies of bear. Ursus arctos shanorum. Proceedings of the
Zoological Society of London 1: 231-232. fig. 58.

0522 Three new Palaearctic mammals. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 18: 220-222.

0523 Two new genera of small mammals discovered by Mrs. Holms-Tarn [spelt Holms-Tarn in
title and in text, but with manuscript correction to Holmes-Tarn by Thomas in his collected
works| in British East Africa. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology,
Botany and Geology, London (7) 18: 222-226.

0524 On some African bats and rodents. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology, Botany and Geology (7) 18: 294-299.

0525 New mammals collected in north-east Africa by Mr. Zaphiro, and presented to the British
Museum by W. N. McMillan, Esq. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 18: 300-306.

0526 A new species of duiker. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 2: 463-464. pi. 35.

58 J. E. HILL

0527 On mammals collected in southwest Australia for Mr. W. E. Balston. Proceedings of the
Zoological Society of London 2: 468-478.

0528 On mammals from northern Australia presented to the National Museum by Sir. Wm.
Ingram. Bt.. and the Hon. John Forrest. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 2:
536-.S43. pi. 37 |tigs. 1^2).

0529 The Rudd exploration of South Africa. — V. List of mammals obtained by Mr Grant in
N.E. Transvaal. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 2: ."iyS-Syi |With H
Schwann].

0530 [Suggested amendments to the report of the Committee on Zoological Nomenclature laid
before the International Congress on Zoology, held at Boston, Mass. in 1907.\ Linnean
Society of London: 1—4.

0531 Notes on South-American rodents. I. — A new name for Sciurus roherti, Thos. |p. 442). IL -
On the allocation of certain species hitherto referred respectively to Oryzomys, Thontasomys.
and Rhipidomys |pp. 442—445]. IIL - A new Oecomys and two new species of Holochilus
1pp. 445-448]. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and
Geo/ogv. London (7) 18: 442-448.

0532 Note on Limnomys. Proceedings of the Biological Society of Washington 19: 199.

0533 1 . Mammals. In: The history of the collections contained in the Natural History Departments
of the British Museum 2: 3-66. London: Trustees of the British Museum (Natural History).

1907

0534 List of further collections of mammals from western Australia, including a scries from
Bernier Island, obtained for Mr W. E. Balston; with field notes by the collector. Mr. G. C.
Shortridge. JWith an appendix on a collection from Bernier Island, pp. 772-777). Proceed-
ings of the Zoological Society of London (1906): 763-777.

0535 The Rudd exploration of South Africa. — VI. List of mammals obtained by Mr. Grant m the
eastern Transvaal. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London (1906): 779-782. JWith
H. Schwann].

0536 The Duke of Bedford's zoological exploration in eastern Asia. II. — List of small mammals
from Korea and Quclpart. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London (1906):
858-865.

0537 On further new mammals obtained by the Ruwenzori Expedition Annals and Magazine of
Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (7) 19: 1 18-123.

0538 [Exhibition of the skin of a new monkey from the Ituri Forest, obtained during the recent
Ruwenzori Expedition.] Abstracts of the Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 15
January. No. 38: 1.

0539 [On mammals collected in Mindanao, Philippines, by Mr. M. P. Anderson, for the Duke of
Bedford's exploration of eastern Asia.) Abstracts of the Proceedings of the Zoological
Society of London 5 February. No. 39: 5.

0540 New mammals from Lake Chad and the Congo, mostly from the collections made during
the Alexander-Gosling Expedition. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: iruluding
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 19: 369-387.

0541 On a remarkable mountain viscacha from southern Patagonia, with diagnoses of other
members of the group Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology, Botany
and Geology. London (7) 19: 3.39-444'

0542 On the occurrence of the edible dormouse (Glis) in Sardinia. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (7) 19: 444-445.

0543 New mammals from Lake Chad and the Congo, mostly from the collections made during
the Alexander-Gosling Expedition Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (7) 19: 519-521.

0544 On Buffon's "Pore-Epic de Malaca " Proceedings of the Biological Society of Washington
20: 65.

0545 A new monkey from the Ituri forest. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 2-3,
pi. L

0546 Exhibition of a collection of mammals and birds from the islands of Saghalien and
Hokkaido. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London UK).

0547 TTie Duke of Bedford's zoological exploration in eastern Asia — IIL On mammals obtained

M. R.O.THOMAS 59

by Mr. M. P. Anderson in the Philippine Islands. Proceedings of ihe Zoological Society of
London 140-142.

0548 On three new mammals from British New Guinea. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (7) 20: 70-74.

0549 On Neotropical mammals of the genera Callicebus. /Grisonj. Reithrodontomvs, Ctenomvs,
Dasypus, and Marmosa. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology.
Botany and Geology, London (7) 20: 161-168. \Grison omitted from title but added in
manuscript by Thomas in his collected works].

0550 The Rudd exploration of South Africa. — VIL List of mammals obtained by Mr. Grant at
Coguno, Inhambane. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 285-299. [With R.
C. Wroughton).

0551 The Duke of Bedford's zoological exploration in eastern Asia. — IV. List of small mammals
from the islands of Saghalien and Hokkaido. (With appendix on the cold-blooded
vertebrates, by G. A. Boulenger |p. 414]). Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London
404-414.

0552 On mammals from northern Persia, presented to the National Museum by Col. A. C.
Bailward. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology. Botany and
Geology. London (7) 20: 196-202.

0553 A subdivision of the old genus Nesokia. with descriptions of three new members of the
group, and of a Mus from the Andamans. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (7) 20: 202-207.

0554 On the occurrence of Acanthoglossus in British New Guinea. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (7) 20: 293-294.

0555 The Duke of Bedford's zoological exploration in eastern Asia. — V. Second list of mammals
from Korea. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 462^66.

0556 On a new dormouse from Asia Minor, with remarks on the subgenus "Dryomys". Annals
and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (7) 20:
406-107.

0557 A new Acanthoglossus from the island of Salawatti. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (7) 20: 498-499.

0558 A new flying squirrel from Formosa. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (7) 20: 522-523.

1908

0559 The Rudd exploration of South Africa. — VIII. List of mammals obtained by Mr. Grant at
Beira. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London (1907): 774-782.

0560 The genera and subgenera of the Sciuropterus group, with descriptions of three new species.
Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London
(8) 1: 1-8.

0561 The species of the genus Dactylopsita. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 1: 122-124.

0562 On a new oribi obtained by Major Powell-Cotton in British East Africa. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 1: 177-
178. [With R. C. Wroughton].

0563 On the large flying squirrels referred to Petaurisla nilida. Desm. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (8) 1: 250-252.

0564 The nomenclature of the flying-lemurs. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) I: 252-255.

0565 The missing premolar of the Chiroptera. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 1: 346-348.

0566 A new deer of the brocket group from Venezuela. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 1: 349-350.

0567 On the generic position of the groups of squirrels typihed by "Sciurus" berdmorei and
pernyi respectively, with descriptions of some new oriental species. Journal of the Bombay
Natural History Society 18: 244-249.

0568 On certain African and S. — American otters. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) I: 387-395.

60 J. E. HILL

0569 New Asiatic Apodemits. Evotomys. and Lepus. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. lAindon (8) 1: 447—150.

0570 [On mammals collected by Mr. C. H. B. Grant near Tette, Zambesia, and resume of the
results of the Rudd exploration of South Africa.] Abstracts of the Proceedings of the
Zoological Society of London 26 May, No. 59: 27-28.

0571 The nomenclature of certain lorises. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 1 : 467-469.

0572 [On mammals from the Provinces of Chih-li and Shan-si. N. China, collected by Mr. M. P.
Anderson for the Duke of Bedford's zoological exploration of eastern Asia] Abstracts of
the Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 16 June. No. 60: 32.

0573 The Duke of Bedford's zoological exploration in eastern Asia. — VI. List of mammals
from the Shantung Province, north China. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London
5-10.

0574 The Duke of Bedford's zoological exploration of eastern Asia. — VIL List of mammals from
the Tsu-shima Islands. Proceedings of the Zoological .Society of London 47-54.

0575 The Duke of Bedford's zoological exploration of eastern Asia. — IX. List of mammals from
the Mongolian Plateau. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 104-110.

0576 Four new Amazonian monkeys. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 2: 88-91.

0577 The Psammomys of the alluvial soil of the Nile Delta. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 2: 91-92.

0578 Note on the squirrel genus "Zetis" . Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 2: 136.

0579 On mammals from the Malay Peninsula and Islands. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (8) 2: 301-306.

0580 A new jerboa from China. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology,
Botany and Geology. London (8) 2: 307-308.

0581 The Rudd exploration of South Africa. — IX. List of mammals obtained by Mr. Grant on
the Gorongoza Mountains. Portuguese Southeast Africa. Proceedings of the Zoological
Society of London 164-173. [With R. C. Wroughton).

0582 New bats and rodents in the British Museum collection. .Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (H) 2: 370-375.

0583 A new fruit bat from Sierra Leone. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 2: 37.5-376.

0584 The Rudd exploration of South Africa. — X. List of mammals obtained by Mr. Grant near
Tette. Zambesia. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 535-553. [With R. C.
Wroughton).

0585 The Duke of Bedford's zoological exploration in eastern Asia. — X. List of mammals from
the Provinces of Chih-li and Shan-si. northern China. Proceedings of the Zoological Society
of London 63.^-646. p].2,2.

0586 On mammals collected by Mr. H. C. Robinson on Tioman and Aor Islands. South China
Sea. Journal of the Federated Malay States Museums. Kuala Lumpur 2: 101-1(16

0587 A new tree kangaroo from British New Guinea. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 2: 452—453.

0588 A new species of the Mascarene genus Eliurus. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 2: 45.3-454.

0589 A new Pogonomys presented to the British Museum by Sir William Ingram. Annuls and
Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology Botany and Geology, London (8) 2:
495^96.

0590 A new Akodon from Tierra del Fuego. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 2: 496-497.

0591 The squirrels described as Sciurus sleerii from Balabac and Palawan. Annals and Magazine
of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 2: 498.

0592 [On mammals collected in the Provinces of Shan-si and Shen-si. northern China, by Mr
M. P. Anderson, for the Duke of Bedford's zoological exploration of eastern Asia.]
Abstracts of the Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 15 December. No. 63:
44-45.

M. R. O. THOMAS 61

1909

0593 On mammals from Inkerman, north Queensland, presented to the National Museum by Sir
William Ingram. Bt., and the Hon. John Forrest. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of
London (1908): 788-794, pi. 43. [With G. Dollman].

0594 The Duke of Bedford's zoological exploration in eastern Asia. — XI. On mammals from the
provinces of Shan-si and Shcn-si, northern China. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of
LonJon (1908): 963-983.

0595 Some mammals from N.E. Kimberley, Northern Australia. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 3: 149-152.

0596 On mammals collected in Turkestan by Mr. Douglas Carruthers. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 3: 257-266.

0597 "On a collection of mammals from western Java, presented to the National Collection by
Mr. W. E. Balston". Abstracts of the Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 15
March, No. 68: 18-19. [With R. C. Wroughton).

0598 On the N. Australian rats referred to the genus Mesembriomys. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 3: 372-374.

0599 New species of Paradoxurus of the P. philippinensis group, and a new Paguma. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History, including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 3:
374-377.

0600 New species of Oecomys and Marmosa from Amazonia. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 3: 378-380.

0601 Two new macaques from western Java. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (H) 3: 380-381. [With R. C. Wroughton).

0602 Diagnoses of new mammals collected by Mr. H. C. Robinson in the Malay Peninsula and
Rhio Archipelago. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and
Geology, London (8) 3: 439^*41. [With R. C. Wroughton).

0603 The generic arrangement of the African squirrels. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 3: 467^75.

0604 [Exhibition of specimens of a new rat which had been obtained by Mr. G. C. Shortridge
during the Society's collecting expedition to Central America] Abstracts of the Proceedings
of the Zoological Society of London 15 June, No. 73: 32.

0605 New African small mammals in the British Museum collection. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 4: 98-1 12.

0606 A new gibbon from Annam. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology,
Botany and Geology. London (8) 4: 1 12-1 13.

0607 On a collection of mammals from western Java presented to the National Museum by Mr.
W. E. Balston. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 371-392. [With R. C.
Wroughton).

0608 Two new mammals from northern Australia. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 4: 197-198.

0609 Notes on some South American mammals, with descriptions of new species. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 4:
230-242.

0610 A new rat from Guatemala. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 669-670.

061 1 Four new African squirrels. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology,
Botany and Geology, London (8) 4: 476-479.

0612 A collection of mammals from northern and central Mantchuria. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 4: 500-505.

0613 Diagnoses of new mammals collected by Mr. H. C. Robinson in the islands of the Straits of
Malacca. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and
Geology, London (8)4: .S34-.536. [With R. C. Wroughton[.

0614 New African mammals. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology,
Botany and Geology, London (8) 4: 542-549.

0615 On mammals from the Rhio Archipelago and Malay Peninsula collected by Messrs. H. C.
Robinson, C. Bodcn Kloss, and E. Seimund, and presented to the National Museum by the
Government of the Federated Malay States. Journal of the Federated Malay States Museums
4: 99-129. [With R. C. Wroughton[.

62 J. E. HILL

1910

0616 New African mammals. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology,
Botany and Geology. London (K) 5: 83-92.

0617 Further new African mammals. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (K) 5: 191-202.

0618 A collection of mammals from eastern Buenos Ayres. with descriptions of related new
mammals from other localities. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 5: 2.39-247.

0619 Further New African Mammalia. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 5: 282-285.

0620 [Exhibition of the skin of a new potto from British East Africa.] Abstracts of the Proceedings
of the Zoological Society of London 15 March. No. 81: 17.

0621 Ruwenzori Expedition reports - Mammalia. Transactions of the Zoological Society of
London 19: 481-518. pis. 30-34. [With R. C. Wroughton].

0622 A new Chinese mole of the genus Scaplochirus. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (8) 5: 350-351 .

0623 Three new West African mammals. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 5: 351-354.

0624 New mammals from the East Indian Archipelago. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 5: 383-387.

0625 [Exhibition of a new monkey from the Malay Peninsula.) Abstracts of the Proceedings of the
Zoological Society of London 19 April No. 83: 25.

0626 [Exhibition of a further consignment of mammals from China, collected by Mr. Malcolm
Anderson for the Duke of Bedford's exploration of eastern Asia.] Abstracts of the
Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 19 April. No. 83: 25-26.

0627 Three new African rodents. Antials and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology,
Botany and Geology, London (8) 5: 419^22.

0628 Two new mammals from the Malay Peninsula. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (8) S; 424—126.

0629 Three new Asiatic mammals. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology,
Botany and Geology, London (8) 5: 534-536.

0630 A new genus of fruit-bats and two new shrews from Africa. Annuls and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 6: 111-114.

0631 Mammals from the River Supinaam. Demerara, presented by Mr. F. V. McConncll to the
British Museum. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and
Gco/ogv. London (8) 6: 184-1X9.

0632 Notes on African rodents. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology,
Botany and Geology. London (8) 6: 221-224.

0633 A new potto from British East Africa. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London
536-537.

0634 List of mammals from Mount Kilimanjaro, obtained by Mr. Robin Kemp, and presented to
the British Museum by Mr. C. D. Rudd. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 6: 308-316.

0635 New African mammals in the British Museum. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 6: 426-432.

0636 A new monkey from the Malay Peninsula. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London
634-635.

0637 A collection of small mammals from China. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of
London 636-<)38.

0638 On mammals collected in Ccara. N.E. Brazil, by Fraulcin Dr. Snethlage. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 6:
500-503.

0639 Four new South-American rodents. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 6: 503-506.

0640 New genera of Australasian Muridae. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 6: 506-508.

0641 The generic arrangement of the Australian murines hitherto referred to "Mus". Annals and

M. R. O. THOMAS 63

Magazine of Natural Historv; including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (X) 6:
603-607.

0642 New Australian Muridae of the genus Pseudomys. A nnals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (X) 6: 607-610.

0643 A new genus for Daclylopsila palpator. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 6: 610.

0644 "The mammals of the Tenth Edition of Linnaeus: an attempt to hx the i .ipes of the genera
and the exact bases and localities of the species." Abstracts of the ,'roceedings of the
Zoological Society of London 13 December, No. 89: 50. |A preliminary version].

1911

0645 Three new South American mammals. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (8) 7: 1 13-1 15.

0646 New Asiatic Muridae. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany
and Geology. London (8) 7: 205-209.

0647 [On mammals collected in the Provinces of Kan-su and Szc-chuan, western China, by Mr.
Malcolm Anderson, for the Duke of Bedford's exploration of eastern Asia. Abstracts of the
Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 1 February, No. 90: 3-5.

0648 The mammals of the Tenth Edition of Linnaeus; an attempt to fix the types of the genera
and the exact bases and localities of the species. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of
London I2(V-1.S8.

0649 The Duke of Bedford's zoological exploration of eastern Asia. — XIU. On mammals from
the provinces of Kan-su and Szc-chuan, western China. Proceedings of the Zoological
Society of London 158-180.

0650 On new African Muridae. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology,
Botany and Geology. London (8) 7: 378-383.

0651 A new vole from eastern Asia. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology,
Botany and Geology. London (8) 7: 383-384.

0652 Three new mammals from Dutch New Guinea. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 7: 384-387.

0653 |On mammals collected in southern Shen-si, central China, by Mr. Malcolm P. Anderson,
for the Duke of Bedford's exploration of eastern Asia.] Abstracts of the Proceedings of the
Zoological Society of London 25 April, No. 95: 26-27.

0654 On mammals collected by the Rev. G. T. Fox in northern Nigeria. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (8) 7: 457-463.

0655 New mammals from tropical South America. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (8) 7: 513-517.

0656 A new murine genus and species from Sind, with diagnoses of three other new genera based
on previously known species of "Mus". Journal of the Bombay Natural History Society 20:
996-9y9a.

0657 Three new African rodents. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology,
Botany and Geology. London (8) 7: 590-593.

0658 Three new mammals from the lower Amazons. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 7: 606-608.

0659 A new kangaroo from the Northern Territory of Western Australia. Annals and Magazine
of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 7: 609-610.

0660 List of small mammals obtained by Mr. G. Fenwick Owen on the Upper Gambia and in
Fouta Djallon. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and
Geology, London (8) 8: 117-124.

0661 New rodents from S. America. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology,
Botany and Geology, London (8) 8: 250-256.

0662 New African mammals. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology,
Botany and Geology. London (8) 8: 375-378.

0663 Two new eastern bats. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany
and Geology, London (8) 8: 378-380.

0664 The Duke of Bedford's zoological exploration of eastern Asia. — XIV. On mammals from

64 J. E. Hll L

southern Shen-si. central China. Proceedings oflhe Zoological Society of London 687-695.
pi. 21.

0665 [On Talpa milleri sp. n.]. |An unpaginated proof from the Annals and Magazine of Natural
History^ including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London, incorporated into Thomas"
collected works and marked by him in manuscript as unpublished].

0666 [On mammals collected in the Provinces of Sze-chuan and Yunnan, western China, by Mr.
Malcolm Anderson, for the Duke of Bedford's exploration of eastern Asia.] Abstracts oflhe
Proceedings oflhe Zoological Society of London 24 October, No. UK): 4S-5().

0667 Three new rodents from Kan-su. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 8: 720-723.

0668 Four new African carnivores. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology,
Botany and Geology, London (8) 8: 724-726.

0669 New rodents from Sze-chuan collected by Capt. F. M. Bailey. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 8: 727-729.

0670 New mammals from central and western Asia, mostly collected by Mr. Douglas Carruthers.
Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London
(8) 8: 758-762,

1912

0671 On small mammals from the Lower Amazon. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 9: 84-90.

0672 Notes on Phascogale and Chaelocerciis. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 9: 91-92.

0673 Revised determinations of two Far-Eastern species of Myospalax. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 9: 93-95.

0674 A new genus of opossums and a new tuco-tuco. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 9: 239-241 .

0675 XXVIL — Mammals of the Panyam Plateau, northern Nigeria. — II. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 9: 269-274.

0676 Two new Asiatic voles. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology.
Botany and Geology, London (8) 9: 348-350.

0677 [Exhibition of the skull of a German wild boar from Buden and of a Hungarian wild boar
from Kolozsvar] Abstracts of the Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 5 March.
No. 105: 13-14.

0678 [Exhibition of the skin and skull of a viverrine carnivore from Tonkin] Abstracts of the
Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 19 March. No. 106: 17-18.

0679 The Duke of Bedford's zoological exploration of eastern Asia. — XV. On mammals from
the Provinces of Sze-chuan and Yunnan, western China. Proceedings of the Zoological
Society of London 127-14L

0680 On mammals from central Asia, collected by Mr. Douglas Carruthers. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 9:
391-408.

0681 Three small mammals from S. America. Annals and Magazine of Natural HisU>ry; including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 9: 408-410.

0682 Descriptions of two giant rats from New Guinea, presented to the British Museum bv the
Hon. Walter Rothschild, F.R.S. Novilales Zoologicae 19: 91-92.

0683 On insectivores and rodents collected by Mr. F. Kingdon Ward in N.W. Yunnan. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, Ixindon (8) 9: 513-519.

0684 Ecsthitisizm in speling with a pie for lienal I. The Pioneer ov Simplified Speling 1 : (3): 33-
34. (May, 1912).

0685 List of a third collection of mammals from Panyam, N. Nigeria, presented by the Rev. Cj. T.
Fox. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology,
London (8) 9: 683-686.

0686 New species of Crocidura and Pelaurisla from Yunnan. .Annals and Magazine of Natural
History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 9: 686-688.

0687 The races of the European wild swine Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London
390-393.

M. R.O.THOMAS 65

0688 Two new genera and a new species of viverrine Carnivora. Proceedings of the Zoological
Sociely of London 4y8-.S()3, figs. 61-^3.

0689 The generic names Cercomvs and Proechimys. Proceedings of ihe Biological Society of
Washington IS: W^-We,.

0690 The technical name of the Tasmanian Devil. Proceedings of the Biological Society of
Washington 25: 116.

0691 Mammals from the Ja river, Cameroons. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 10: 41^3.

0692 Small mammals from South America. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (8) 10: 44-48.

0693 A new vespertilionine bat from Angola. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (8) 10: 204-206.

0694 Two new species of Nasua. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology.
Botany and Geology. London (8) 10: 228-230.

l)69.'i Two new West-African mammals. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 10: 280-282.

0696 On a collection of small mammals from the Tsin-ling Mountains, central China, presented
by Mr. G. Fcnwick Owen to the National Museum. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (S) 10: 39.^-403.

0697 New bats and rodents from South America. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 10: 40.3-41 1 .

0698 Two new races of mongoose. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology,
Botany and Geology, London (8) 10: .S88-.S89.

0699 New Centrnnycteris and Ctenomys from S. America. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 10: 638-640.

07(K) Simplifcid |sic] speling. Evening Standard, London 18 December.

1913

0701 Two new Australian mammals. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 11: 79-80.

0702 On some rare Amazonian mammals from the collection of the Para Museum. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (8) 11:
1.30-1.36.

0703 On small mammals collected in Jujuy by Senor E. Budin. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 11: 136-143.

0704 On some specimens of Glauconycteris from the Cameroons. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 11: 144-145.

0705 Notes on South American Leporidae. ( 1 ) The small "tapeti" of Rio Janeiro [pp. 209-210].
(2) The hare of eastern Peru [pp. 210-211[. (3) The mountain hares of the Sylvilagus
andinus group [pp. 212-214). Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology,
Botany and Geology, London (8) 11: 209-214.

0706 Four new shrews. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology. Botany and
Geology. London (8) II: 214-218.

0707 Ernst Hartert's expedition to the central western Sahara. IL Mammals. Novitates Zoologicae
20: 28-33.

0708 On African bats and shrews. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology,
Botany and Geology, London (8) II: 314-321.

0709 New forms of Akodon and Phyllotis, and a new genus for "Akodon" teguina. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) II:
404-409.

0710 [Exhibition of a specimen of the Amazonian monkey, Callinxico snethlageri. Proceedings of
the Zoological Society of London 3-4.

071 1 On a remarkable new free-tailed bat from southern Bombay. Journal of the Bombay
Natural History Society 22: 87-91, 2 figs.

0712 A new shrew from the Andaman Islands. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (H) II: 468-469.

66 J. E. HILL

0713 New African Epimys and Jaculus. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (K) 11: 482-485.

0714 On some mammals from Bali and Mysol. collected by Mr. E. Strescmann during the
■"Freiburger Molukken Expedition." Annals and Magazine of Natural History, including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 11: 504-507.

0715 On certain of the smaller South American Cervidae. A. Brockets [pp. 585-588). B. The
Ecuadorean pudu (Pudua mephistopheles. de Wint.) (pp. 588-589|. Annals and Magazine
of Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (8) II: 585-589.

0716 Some new Ferae from Asia and Africa. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 12: 88-92.

0717 On new mammals obtained by the Utakwa Expedition to Dutch New Guinea. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (8) 12:
205-212.

0718 Some new species of Uromys. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology.
Botany and Geology. London (8) 12: 212-217.

0719 A new genus of glossophagine bat from Colombia. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 12: 270-271.

0720 Scientific results from the Mammal Survey. IV. A new species of Leggada from Mysore.
Journal of the Bombay Natural History Society 22: 242. [With K. V. Ryley].

0721 The geographical races of the woolly opossum (Philander laniger). Annals and Magazine of
Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 12: 358-361.

0722 A new species of dwarf potto. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology,
Botany and Geology. London (8) 12: 387-388.

0723 List of mammals obtained by the Hon W. Rothschild. Ernst Hartert and Carl Hilgcrt in
western Algeria during 1913. Novitates Zoologicae 20: 586-591.

0724 New mammals from South America. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 12: 567-574.

1914

0725 The tree shrews of the Tupaia helangeri - chinensis group. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 13: 243-245.

0726 On various South-American mammals. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 13: 345-363.

0727 Note on the genus Leggada. Journal of the Bombay Natural History .Society 22: 682.

0728 A new Soriculus from the Mishmi Hills. Journal of the Bombay Natural History Society 22:
683-683a.

0729 On mammals from Manus Island, Admiralty Group, and Ruk Island, Bismarck Archipelago.
Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London
(8) 13: 434^-439.

0730 New Asiatic and Australasian bats and a new bandicoot. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (8) 13: 439^44.

0731 New Callicebus and Eumops from South America. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 13: 480-481.

0732 "On a remarkable case of affinity between animals inhabiting Guiana. W. Africa, and the
Malay Archipelago." Abstracts of the Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 5
May. No. 133: 36. [A preliminary version).

0733 Nomina conservanda in Mammalia. Zoologischer Anzeiger 44: 284—286.

0734 Rectification. Zoologischer Anzeiger 44: 528. [Corrections to 0733).

0735 On small mammals from Djarkent. central Asia. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, U)ndon (8) 13: 563 573.

0736 Three new S. -American mammals. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 13: 573-575.

0737 Report on the mammals collected by the British Ornithologists' Union Expedition and the
Wollaston Expedition in Dutch New Ciuinea. Transactions of the Zoological Society of
London 20: 31.5-324.

0738 On a remarkable case of affinity between animals inhabiting Guiana. West Africa and the
Malay Archipelago. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 415-417.

M. R. O. THOMAS 67

0739 Scientific results of the Mammal Survey. No. VII. [Notes on the mammals collected by Mr.
G. C. Shortridge from Mount Popa and other parts of central Burma.] Journal of the
Bombay Natural History Society 23: 23-31 .

0740 New Nasuti, Lulra. and Proechimys from South America. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (K) 14: 57-61 .

0741 New South-American rodents. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology,
Botany and Geology, London (K) 14: 240-244.

0742 A new genus of bats allied to Nyctophilus. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 14: 381-383.

0743 Four new small mammals from Venezuela. Annals and Magazine of Natural History,
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 14: 4UI-414.

0744 Scientific results of the Mammal Survey. No. VIIL On Upper Burma squirrels referable to
Sciurus sladeni and haringloni |pp. 197-199]. A new Leggadilla from Kumaon (p, 200].
Notes on Vandeleurui ]pp. 200-203]. Two new flying squirrels ]pp. 204-205]. Journal of the
Bombay Natural History Society 23: 197-205.

0745 On small mammals collected in Tibet and the Mishmi Hills by Capt. F. M. Bailey. Journal
of the Bombay Natural Hi.story .Society 23: 230-233.

0746 Second list of small mammals from western Yunnan collected by Mr. F. Kingdon Ward.
.Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London
(8) 14: 472^75.

1915

0747 Notes on Emballonura. with descriptions of new species. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 15: 137-140.

0748 Two new species of Leuconoe. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology,
Botany and Geology, London (8) 15: 170-172.

0749 On bats of the genera Nyctalus, Tylonycteris, and I'ipislrellus. Annuls and Magazine of
Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 15: 225-232.

0750 Scientific results of the Mammal Survey. No. IX. A new pipistrelle bat from Tenasserim
]pp. 413-414]. A new murine genus and species from Ceylon [pp. 414-416]. Journal of the
Bombay Natural History Society 23: 413-416.

0751 An easily made ear-plug for soldiers in the firing line. Land and Water, London 13
February.

0752 A new shrew of the genus Blarinella from Upper Burma. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (8) 15: 335-336.

0753 Determination of Vesperugo vagans Dobson from "Bermuda". Proceedings of the
Biological Society of Washington 28: 69.

0754 The generic name Connochaeles of Lichtenstein. Proceedings of the Biological Society of
Washington 28: 69.

0755 The penis bone or "baculum" as a guide to the classification of certain squirrels. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (8) 15:
383-387.

0756 On some pteropine bats from Vulcan and Dampier Islands, off the N.E. coast of New
Guinea. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology.
London (8) 15: 387-389.

0757 The geographical races of Citellus fulvus. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 15: 421—424.

0758 Notes on the genus Nyctophilus. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 15: 49.V499.

0759 On a minute shrew from Lake Baikal. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 15: 499-5(K).

0760 Scientific results from the Mammal Survey. No. X. A. — The Indian bats assigned to the
genus Myotis. I. Myotis proper jpp. 607-610]. II. Leuconoe [pp. 610-612). B. — Some notes
on the viverrine genus Hemigalus ]pp. 6l2-613a]. Journal of the Bombay Natural History
Society 23: (A)l-6\?,a.

0761 On three new bats obtained by Mr. Willoughby Lowe in the Sudan. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 15: 559-562.

68 J. n. iiiLi.

0762 Notes on bats of the genus Coleura. Annals and Magazine of Naiurut History: including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 15: 576-579.

0763 Notes on the Asiatic bainboo rats (Rhizomys. etc.). Annals and Magazine of \atiirat
History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 16: 56-6L

0764 On bats of the genus Promops. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (8) 16: 61-64.

0765 New African rodents and insectivorcs. mostly collected by Dr. C. Christy for the Congo
Museum. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology. Botany and
Gco/ogy. London (8) 16: 14'6-I52.

0766 Scientific results from the Mammal Survey. No. XL A. — C)n pipistrelles of the genera
Pipistrellus and Scotozous |pp. 29-34|. B. — The giant squirrels of Ceylon |pp. 34-37|. [With
R. C. WroughtonJ. C. — The Singhalese species of Funamhulus (pp. 37-41]. [With R. C.
Wroughton|. G. — A second species of Coelotnys from Ceylon |pp 49-50]. I. — On some
specimens of Vandeleuria from Bengal, Bihar and Orissa |pp. 54-55]. K. — Notes on
Taphozous and Saccolaimus ]pp. 57-63|. Journal of I he Bombay Natural History Society 24:
29-41.49-50.54-55.57-63.

0767 Richard Lvdekker (1849-1915). [Obituary]. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London (B)
89: iii-vi.

0768 A special genus for the Himalayan bat known as Murina gri.<:ea. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 16: 309-310.

0769 A new genus of phyllostome bat and a new Rhipidomys from Ecuador. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 16:
310-312.

0770 Further notes on Asiatic bamboo-rats. .Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 16: 313-317.

0771 A new bat from northern Nigeria. .Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 16: 447—448.

0772 Phacochoerus as the generic name of the warthogs. Proceedings of the Biological Society of
Washington 2»: 181.

0773 List of mammals (exclusive of Ungulata) collected on the Upper Congo by Dr. Christy for
the Congo Museum, Tervuren. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 16: 465—481.

1916

0774 The porcupine of Tenasserim and southern Siam. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 17: 136-139.

0775 On the grouping of the South-American Muridae that have been referred to Phyllotis,
Eunomys, and Eligmodontia. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology,
Botany and Geology. London (8) 17: I.W-143.

0776 Scientific results from the Mammal Survey. No. XII. A. — On squirrels obtained in Burma
by Messrs. Shortridge and Macmillan on the Chindwin River, Upper Burma [pp. 224- 239, 1
pi.]. [With R. C. Wroughton| B. — Notes on the genus Cremmomys [pp. 239-243]. Journal
of the Bombay Natural History Society 24: 224-243, 1 pi.

0777 A new marmot from Chitral. Journal of the Bombay Natural History Society 24: 341-342.

0778 On the generic names of certain Old World monkeys. .Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 17: 179-181.

0779 Notes on Argentine, Patagonian and Cape Horn Muridae. [The mice of the Hesperomys
laucha group pp. 182-185; The Cape Horn Euneomys pp. 185-186; The Oryzomys of the
extreme south of South America pp. 186-187; The Cape Horn .Akodon p. 187]. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 17:
182-187.

0780 [r.xhibition of the scalp and frontlet with horns of a male sable anielope from the l.uando
River, Angola, which had been presented to the National Museum by Mr II (■ Varian.
together with a female mask and horns] Abstracts of the Proceedings of the Zoological
Society of London 8 February. No 151: 1-2.

0781 A new binturong from Siam. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology,
Botany and Geology, London (8) 17: 270 271.

M. R. O. THOMAS 69

1)7X2 A new genus for Sciuriis poensis and its allies. Annals and Magazine of Natural Hislorv;

including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (S) 17: 271-272.
(1783 Notes on bats of the genus W/.vf/od/.s . Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including

Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 17: 272-276.
(1784 A new sable antelope from Angola. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 298-

301,1 fig.

0785 The raees of Drernoinys pernyi. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (8) 17: 391-394.

0786 A new rat from Tcnasserim. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology,
Botany and Geology. London (8) 17: 425.

0787 Note on the name Corynorhiniis megalotis. Proceedings of the Biological Society of
Washington 29: 127.

0788 Scientific results from the Mammal Survey. No. XIII. A. — On Muridae from Darjiling and
the Chin Hills. 1 . — A new genus of giant rat from Sikkim | pp. 404-^07. 1 fig.]. 2. — A new rat
allied to Epimys sabanus. from Darjiling |pp. 407^09. 1 tig ] 3. — On the large rats allied to
Epimys bowersi [pp. 409^12]. 4. — The rats of the Epimys berdmorei group |pp. 412-414).
5. — A new mouse from Sikkim |pp. 414-415]. B. — Two new Indian bats |pp. 415^17). C. —
On squirrels of the genus Dremomys [pp. 417—118]. D. — The squirrels of the Torncutes
lokroides and mearsi groups [pp. 419— 422[. [With R. C. Wroughton[. E. — A new flying
squirrel from Tenasserim [pp. 422—423]. Journal of the Bombay Natural History Society 24:
404-423, 2 figs.

0789 On the rats usually included in the genus Aryicanlhis. .Annals and Magazine of Natural
History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (8) 18: 67-70.

0790 On Raltus as a generic name, with a note on the nomenclature of Echimys and Loncheres.
Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London
(8)18:70-72.

0791 On the generic names applicable to the chevrotains (Tragulidae). Annals and Magazine of
Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 18: 72-73.

0792 On small mammals obtained in Sankuru, south Congo, by Mr. II. Wilson. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (8) 18:
234-239.

0793 On the generic names Rattus and Phyllomys. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 18: 240.

0794 Three new African mice of the genus Dendromus. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 18: 241-242.

0795 List of Microchiroptera, other than leaf-nosed bats, in the collection of the Federated Malay
States Museums. Journal of the Federated Malay States Museums, Kuala Lumpur 7: 1-6.

0796 Some notes on the Echimyinac. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 18: 294-301.

0797 On the classification of the cavies. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 18: 301-303.

0798 Two new Argentine rodents, with a new subgenus of Ctenomys. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (8) 18: 31)3-306.

0799 Two new species of Akodon from Argentina. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 18: 334-336.

0800 The grouping of the South American Muridae commonly referred to Akodon. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (8) 18:
336-340.

0801 Scientific results from the Mammal Survey. No. XIV (A) A new bat of the genus Marina
from Darjiling ]pp. 639-640]. (B) The bandicoot of Mount Popa, and its allies [pp. 640-
643]. (C) On the rat known as Epimys jerdoni from LIppcr Burma ]pp. 643-644]. Journalof
the Bombay Natural History Society 24: 639-644.

0802 A new bamboo rat from Perak. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 18: 445-446.

0803 Two new Muridae from South America. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (8) 18: 478-480.

0804 [Note on Anourosorex squamipes and assamensis.] [p. 766]. In Wroughton, R. C, Bombay

70 J. E. HlLl

Natural History Society's Mammal Survey of India. Burma and Ceylon Report No. 25.
[Chin Hills]. Journal of the Bombay Natural History Society 24: 758-773

1917

0805 Notes on the species of the genus Cavia. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 19: 152-lf)0.

0806 A new bat of the genus Scotaecus |sic]. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 19: 280-281 .

0807 A new species of Aconaemys [sic] from southern Chile. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (S) 19: 281-282.

0808 Some notes on three-toed sloths. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (8) 19: 352-357.

0809 Preliminary diagnoses of new mammals obtained by the Yale - National Geographic
Society Peruvian Expedition. Smithsonian Miscellaneous Collections 68: (4), (Publication
2447) : 1-3.

0810 A new vole from Palestine. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology,
Botany and Geology, London (8) 19: 450-»51.

081 1 On the small hamsters that have been referred to Cricetulus phaeus and camphelli. Annals
and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 19:
452-457.

0812 The grey squirrel in England. Field, London 129, (3357): 625.

0813 P-L-\-G. The Pyoneer 27.

0814 The geographical races of Galago crassicaudatus. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 20: 47-50.

0815 On small mammals from the delta of the Parana. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 20: y5-KKl.

0816 On the arrangement of the South American rats allied to Oryzomys and Rhipidomys.
Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London
(8)20: 192-m8.

0817 Two new rats of the Rattus confucianus group. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. Londtm (8) 20: 198-200.

0818 A new agouti from the Moon Mountains, southern British Guiana Annals and Magazine of
Natural History, including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 20: 259-261.

0819 A new mink-like Mustela from Java. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (8) 20: 261-262. [With H. C Robinson[.

0820 Scientific results from the Mammal Survey. No. XVI. (A)— The tupaias of south Tenasserim
[pp. 199-201|. (B)— Notes on MillardiasnA its allies [pp. 2()1-203|. (C)^A new genus of
Muridac [pp. 203-205[. (C) — The spiny mouse of Sind [pp. 205-206]. Journal of the
Bombay Natural History Society 25: 199-206.

0821 Notes on agoutis, with descriptions of new forms Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 20: 310-313.

0822 A new Heliophobius from north-eastern Rhodesia. .Annuls and Magazine of Natural
History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 20: 314-315.

0823 The Spalax of the Grecian Archipelago. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 20: 315-317.

0824 A new rat of the genus Mylomys from the Upper Nile. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (8) 20: 362 363.

0825 Notes on Georychus and its allies. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (H) 20: 441—444.

0826 On the allocation of the name Sciurus finlaysoni, Horsfield. Journal of the Natural History
Society of Siam 2: 343-346.

I9IS

0827 On the striped squirrels hitherto referred to the genus Paraxerus. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 1: 33-38.

0828 Two new tuco-tucos from Argentina Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 1: 38-40.

M.R.O. THOMAS 71

0829 The nomenclature of the geographical forms of the Panolia deer (Rucenus elili and its

relatives). Journal of the Bombay Natural History Society 25: 363-367.
()K30 A selection of lectotypes of Indian mammals, from the co-types described by Hodgson.

Gray, Elliot and others. Journal of the Bombay Natural History Society 25: 368-372.
0831 On small mammals from Salta and Jujuy collected by Mr. E. Budin. Annals and Magazine

of Natural History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (9) 1: 186-193.
0X32 The generic division of the hedgehogs. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including

Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) I: 193-196.

0833 Four new species of hedgehog. Annuls and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology,
Botany and Geology, London (9) I: 230-233.

0834 Some notes on the small sand-foxes of North Africa. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 1: 242-245.

0835 On the arrangement of the small Tenrecidae hitherto referred to Orvzoricles and Microgale.
Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London
(9)1:302-307.

0836 Moles and mosses. Notes to Exeter Natural History Society.

0837 Notes on Petrodromiis and Rhynchocyon. .Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (9) 1: 364-370.

0838 A new wild dog from the Bogota Cordillera. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) I: 370-371.

0839 New forms of Dendromus, Dipodillus, and Gerbillus. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (9) 2: 59-64.

0840 New species of Gerbillus and Taterilliis. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (9) 2: 146-151.

0841 A new duiker from Zanzibar. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology,
Botany and Geology, London (9) 2: 151-152.

0842 A revised classification of the Otomyinae, with descriptions of new genera and species.
Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London
(9)2:203-211.

0843 The hedgehog of Palestine and Asia Minor. .Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (9) 2: 21 1-213.

0844 Rule of footpath and road. Our Post Bag' Express and Echo [Exeter local paper], October.

0845 A new species of Eligmodontia from Catamarca. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (9) 2: 482—184.

0846 Two new forms of Leggada. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology,
Botany and Geology. London (9) 2: 484-486.

0847 Natural history collections made by the late Major H. S. Toppin. Description of the new
monkey. Peru-Bolivia Boundary Commission. Appendix : 9-10, 1 pi. [Repeated from
073 1 [.

0848 North Sea fisheries. The Times. London, December.

1919

0849 On some small mammals from Catamarca. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (9) 3: 1 15-1 18.

0850 The white-toothed shrew of Palestine. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (9) 3: 199.

0851 On small mammals collected by Senor E. Budin in north-western Patagonia. Annals and
Magazine of Natural Hi.story; including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (9) 3: 199-212.

0852 Two new Argentine species of Akodon. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (9) 3: 213-214.

0853 Notes on gerbils referred to the genus Meriones. with descriptions of new species and
subspecies. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology. Botany and
Geology. London (9) 3: 263-273.

0854 On small mammals from "Otro Cerro", north-eastern Rioja, collected by Sr. E. Budin
(north-eastern Rioja deleted from copy in Thomas' collected works, Catamarca substituted
in manuscript by Thomas). Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology,
Botany and Geology, London (9) 3: 489-500.

72 J. E. HILL

0855 Scientific results from tfie Mammal Survey. No. XIX. A synopsis of tfic groups of true mice
found witliin the Indian Empire. Journal of the Bombay Natural History Society 26:
417^21.

0856 A new species of Nesokia from Mesopotamia. Journal of the Bombay Natural History
Society 26: 422-t23.

0857 Two new gerbils from Sinai. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology,
Botany and Geology. London {^) 3: 554-560.

0858 On a small collection of mammals from Lumbo, Mozambique. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History: including Zoology. Botany and (Jeology. London (9) 4: 29-34.

0859 A new species of Euneomys from Patagonia. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (9) 4: 127-128.

0860 List of mammals from the highlands of Jujuy. north Argentina, collected by Sr. E. Budin.
Annals and Magazine of Natural History; includint; Zoology, Botany and Geology. Londi>n
(9)4: 128-135.

0861 Two new rodents from Tartagal. Salta. N. Argentina. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (9) 4: 154-156.

0862 The method of taking the incisive index in rodents. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 4: 289-290, I fig.

0863 Scientific results from the Mammal Survey. No. XX. A. — Notes on the genus Cheliones.
Journal of the Bombay Natural History Society 26: 726-727.

0864 Some new mammals from Mesopotamia. Journal of the Bombay Natural History Society 26:
745-749.

0865 The types of the mammals described by M. Fernand Lataste. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (9) 4: 349-354.

1920

0866 Two new species of Syhilagus from Colombia. Annals and .Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 5: 31-33.

0867 A new shrew and two new foxes from Asia Minor and Palestine. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (9) 5: 1 19-122.

0868 The generic positions of "Mus" nigricauda. Thomas, and woosnami, Schwann. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (9) 5:
140-142.

0869 A new Taphozous from the Sudan. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (9) 5: 142-144.

0870 A new marmoset from the Peruvian Amazons. Annals and Magazine of Natural History
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (9) 5: 144.

0871 Scientific results from the Mammal Survey. No. XXI. A. — Some new mammals from
Baluchistan and northwest India |pp. 933-938]. B. — Two new species of Calomyscus |pp.
938-940], Journal of the Bombay Natural History Society 26: 933-940.

0872 Some notes on Babirussa. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology,
Botany and Geology. London (9) 5: 185-188.

0873 A further collection of mammals from Jujuy. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (9) 5: 188-196.

0874 Two new Asiatic bats of the genera Tadarida and Dyacopterus. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (9) 5: 283-285.

0875 Four new squirrels of the genus Tamiops. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (9) 5: 304-308.

0876 On Neotropical bats of the genus F.ptesicus. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (9) 5: 360-367.

0877 On the group of African zorils represented by Ictonyx libyca [altered to tibycus in
manuscript by Thomas in his collected works). Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (9) 5: 367-369.

0878 New species of Reithrodon, Abrocoma, and Scapleromys from Argentina. A, A further
collection from Sr. Budin |pp. 47.3-477]. B. The Scapteromys of the Parana Delta Jpp 477-
478]. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology,
London (9) 5: 47.3-478.

M. R. O. THOMAS 73

1)879 A new fat-tailed gcrbil iRcichyiiromvs) from western Algeria. Ni>vitiile.s Zoologicae 27:

313-314.
DHKO Captain Angus Buchanan's Air Expedition. I. On a series of small mammals from Kano.

Novilatcs Zoologicae 27: 315-321).
DSm Nolorycles in nortfi-wcst Australia. Annals and Magazine of NaUiral Hislory; including

Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (9) 6: 1 1 1-1 13. [With M. A. C. Hinton].

0882 A new genus of Echimyinae. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology.
Botany and Geology. London (9) 6: 1 13-1 15.

0883 On mammals from near Tinogasta, Catamarca, collected by Sr. Budin. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (9) 6:
116-120.

0884 Scientific results from the Mammal Survey. No. XXll. A. — A new bat of the genus
Rhtnopoma from southeast Persia. Journal of the Bombay Natural History Society 27: 25.

0885 A new tuco-tuco from Tucuman. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 6: 243-244.

0886 On mammals from the Lower Amazons in the Goeldi Museum, Para. Annals and Magazine
of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 6: 266-283.

0887 On small mammals from the Famatina Chain, north-western Rioja. Annals and Magazine
of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 6: 417—122.

0888 On mammals from Ceram. Annuls and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology,
Botany and Geology, London (9) 6: 422—431.

0889 A note on the type locality and geographical races of the gundi {Ctenodactylus gundi
Rothm.). Novitates Zoologicae 11: 506-507.

0890 New small mammals from New Guinea. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9)6: 533-537.

0891 Scientific results from the Mammal Survey. No. XXIII. A new bat of the genus Myotis from
Sikkim. Journal of the Bombay Natural History Society 27: 248-250.

0892 Report on the Mammalia collected by Mr. Edmund Heller during the Peruvian expedition
of 1915 under the auspices of Yale University and the National Geographic Society.
Proceedings of the United States National Museum, Washington 58: 217-249. pi. 14-15.

1921

0893 Some new insular squirrels of the Callosciurus caniceps - concolor group from Peninsular
Siam. Annuls and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology.
London (9) 7: 1 18-123. [With H. C. Robinson).

0894 A new tuco-tuco from Bolivia. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology.
Botany and Geology. London (9) 7: 136-137.

0895 Two new Muridae discovered in Paraguay by the Marquis de Wavrin. Annals and Magazine
of Natural History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (9) 7: 177-179.

0896 A new mountain vizcacha {Lagidium) from N.W. Patagonia. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (9) 7: 179-181 .

0897 A new monkey and a new squirrel from the Middle Mekong, on the eastern frontier of
Siam. Annals and Magazine of Natural Hislory; including Zoology. Botany and Geology.
London (9)7: 1X1-183.

0898 New Rhipidomys, Akodon, Ctenomys. and Marmosa from the Sierra Santa Barbara. S.E.
Jujuy. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology.
London (9)7: 18.V187.

0899 On a new genus and species of shrew, and some new Muridae from the East-Indian
Archipelago. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology. Botany and
Geology, London (9) 7: 243-249.

090(1 [A new vole from Shiraz.] |pp. 58(K581|. In Cheesman, R. E.. Report on a collection of
mammals made by Col. J. E. B. Hotson in Shiraz. Persia. Journal of the Bombay Natural
History Society 27: 573-581.

0901 On small mammals from the Kachin Province, northern Burma. Journal of the Bombay
Natural Hislory Society 27: 499-505.

0902 Scientific results from the Mammal Survey. No. XXV. (A). On jungle mice from Assam

74 J. F. HILl

|pp. 596-598]. (B). The brush-tailed poreupine of Assam |pp. 59X-599|. Journal of the
Bombay Natural History Society 27: 596-599.

0903 New foxes of the genera Cerdocyon and Pseudalopex from northern Argentina. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 7:
381-385.

0904 On cavies of the genus Caviclla. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (9) 7; 445—148.

0905 New Sigmodon. Oryzomys. and Echimys from Ecuador. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (9) 7: 448-450.

0906 Captain Angus Buchanan's Air Expedition. II. On the mammals (other than nmiinants)
obtained during the expedition to Air (Asben). Noyitates Zooloi^icae 28: 1 1.^ |With M A.
C. Hinton].

0907 Three new species of Marmosa. with a note on Didclphys waterhintsei. Tomes. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (9) 7:
519-523.

0908 The tuco-tuco of San Juan. Argentina Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (9) 7: 523-524.

0909 The Arctonyx of Annam. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology,
Botany and Geology. London (9) 7: 524.

0910 Choiropotamus versus Koiropotamus. Proceedings of the Biological Society of Washington
34: 135.

0911 The geographical races of Herpestes brachyurus Gray. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (9) 8: 134-136.

0912 A new genus of opossum from southern Patagonia. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (9) 8: 136-139.

0913 A new bat of the genus Promops from Peru. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. I^ndon (9) 8: 139.

0914 On spiny rats of the Proechimys group from southeastern Brazil. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (9) 8: 140-143.

0915 Scientific results from the Mammal Survey. XXVII. The geographical races of Scotomanes
ornalus. Journal of the Bombay Natural History Society 27: 772-773.

0916 The "Huron" of the Argentine. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (9) 8: 212-213.

0917 On mammals from the Province of San Juan, western Argentina Annals and Magazine of
Natural History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (9) 8: 214-221.

0918 Two new Argentine forms of skunk. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (9) 8: 221-222.

0919 New Cryptotis. Thomasomys. and Oryzor?iys from Colombia. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (9) 8: 354-357.

0920 New Pseudochirus and Phascogale from N.W. New Guinea. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (9) 8: 357-359.

0921 Notes on Australasian rats, with a selection of Icctotypcs of Australasian Muridae. Annals
and Magazine of Natural History: includim; Zoology. Botany and Geoloi;y. London (9) 8:
425-133.

0922 The jerboa of Muscat. Annuls and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology. Botany
<;«(/ Gc«/o,i;y. London (9) 8: 44(M41.

0923 A new short-tailed opossum from Brazil. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (9) 8: 441—442.

0924 A new cotton-tail (Sylvilagus) from Colombia. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (9) 8: 442—143.

0925 Notes on the species of Notomys. the Australian jerboa-rats. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (9) 8: 536-541.

0926 A new hedgehog from the island of Djerba. Tunis. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (9) 8: 570.

0927 On a further collection of mammals from Jujuy obtained by Sr. Budui Annals and
Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (9) 8:
608-617.

M. R. O. THOMAS 75

()92K The masked civets {Pagiima) of western China. Annuls and Magazine of Natural History;

including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (9) 8: fil7-618.
0929 On three new AustraMan rats. Annals and Magazine o] Natural History: including Zoology,

Botany and Geology. London (9) 8: 61S-622.
09.^0 New Hesperomys and Galea from Bohvia. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;

including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (9) 8: 622-624.

093 1 Two new species of slow-loris. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology.
Botany and Geology. London (9) 8: 627-628.

0932 Scientific results from the Mammal survey. No. XXX. The mungooses of the Herpestes
smithii group. Journal of the Bombay Natural History Society 28: 23-26.

0933 Scientific results from the Mammal Survey. No. XXXL Two new rats from Assam. Journal
of the Bombay Natural History Society 28: 26-27.

0934 A new Arabian hare. Journal of the Bombay Natural History Society 28: 28-29.

0935 On a collection of rats and shrews from the Dutch East Indian Islands. Treubia. Buitenzorg
2: 109-114.

1922

0936 On some interesting hedgehogs from the Persian Gulf. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (9) 9: 142-144.

0937 The mammals of the 1921 Mount Everest Expedition. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (9) 9: 178-186. [With M. A. C.
Hinton).

0938 On some new forms of Ochotona. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 9: 187-193.

0939 Some notes on ferret-badgers. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology,
Botany and Geology, London (9) 9: 193-196. '

0940 On the systematic arrangement of the marmosets. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 9: 196-199.

0941 A subdivision of the genus Uromys. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (9) 9: 260-261.

0942 New mammals from New Guinea and neighbouring islands. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (9) 9: 261-265.

0943 A new marmoset from the Lower Amazons. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (9) 9: 265-266.

0944 The generic classification of the Taphozous group. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (9) 9: 266-267.

0945 Scientific results from the Mammal Survey. No. XXXII. (A) New and interesting mammals
from the Mishmi Hills |pp. 428-431]. (B) The porcupine of Assam [pp. 431-432]. (C) A new
forest badger (Helictis) from the Naga Hills ]p. 432]. Journal of the Bombay Natural History
Society 28: 428-432.

0946 Note on the nomenclature of the northern slow loris. Journal of the Bombay Natural History
Society 28: 433.

0947 The forms of Jaculus jaculus in Egypt and Syria. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (9) 9: 295-297.

0948 Two new jerboa-rats (Nolomys). Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (9) 9: 315-317.

0949 On the animals known as "Ground-hogs" or "Cane-rats" in Africa. Annals and Magazine
of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 9: 389-392.

0950 On mammals collected by C. Keysser in the Saruwaged and Rawlinson Mountains region of
N.E. New Guinea. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany
and Geology, London (9) 9: 669-676.

0951 The generic name of the tinlcss-backed porpoise, formerly known as Neomeris phocaenoides.
Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London
(9)9:676-677.'

0952 The bandicoots of Nuyts Archipelago, S. Australia, and of Cape York, N. Queensland.
Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London
(9)9:677-679.'

76 J. E. HIl.L

0953 Two new subspecies of Phalanger orienlalis. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (9) 9: (i79-6Xl).

0954 A new rock-wallabv (Petrogale) from the islands off South Austraha. Annals and Magazine
of Natural History: including Zoology. Botany and (ieology. London (9) 9: 681-683.

0955 A selection of lectotypes of the typical Australian marsupials in the British Museum
collection. Annals and Magazine of Natural Historv; including Zoology. Botany and
Geo/ogv, London (9) 10: 127-128.

0956 On a new subspecies of Zaglossus. with remarks on other species of the genus. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (9) 10: 129-
131. [With Lord Rothschild.]

0957 On bandicoots allied to Perameles bougainvillei. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, l.ondon (9) 10: 143-145.

0958 On mammals from New Guinea obtained by the Dutch Scientific Expeditions of recent
years. Nova Guinea 13: 723-740.

0959 A new hedgehog from Aden. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology,
Botany and Geology, London (9) 10: 307-308.

0960 On mammals from the Yunnan highlands collected by Mr. George Forrest and presented to
the British Museum by Col. Stephenson R. Clarke, D.S.O. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 10: 391-406.

0961 A new species of Mastacomys from a cave in South Australia. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 10: 550-55 1 .

0962 A new jird (Meriones) from southern Palestine. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 10: 552-553.

0963 A new bat of the genus Miniopterus from northern Australia. Annuls and Magazine of
Natural History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (9) 10: 616-617.

0964 Scientific results from the Mammal Survey. No. XXXV. Two new rodents from the Mergui
Archipelago. Journal of the Bombay Natural History Society 28: 1067-1068.

1923

0965 The Godman Exploration Fund: List of mammals from north Oueensland collected by Mr
T. V. Sherrin. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology; Botany and
Geo/ogv. London (9) 11: 170-178.

0966 [Exhibition of a new rock-kangaroo from north Oueensland] Abstracts of the Proceedings
of the Zoological Society of London L3 February, No. 235: 13.

0967 [Exhibition of the skull of a pygmy fruit-bat from Sumatra! Abstracts of the Proceedings of
the Zoological Society of London 13 February. No. 235: 14.

0968 On some Oueensland Phalangcridae. [The Taguan flying-phalangcrs pp. 246-249; A new
Pseudochirus from N. Oueensland pp. 249-250; The rock Pseudochirus of the Northern
Territory p. 250. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and
Geology, London (9) 11: 246-250.

0969 On some small mammals, chiefly bats, from the East Indian Archipelago. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 11:
250-255.

0970 [Letter objecting to possible entrance fees to public institutions, notably the British
Museum (Natural History), with reasons]. The Times, London 19 March.

0971 Some new African squirrels. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology,
Botany and Geology, London (9) 11: 518-523.

0972 The West African forms of Heliosciurus rufohrachium. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (9) 11: 523-526.

0973 New subspecies of Protoxerus stangeri. the giant squirrel of Equatorial Africa. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) II:
527-529.

0974 The geographical races of l.utreolina crassicaudata. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (9) II: 583-585.

0975 The native rat of Pearson's Islands, S. Australia. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, lA)ndon (9) 11: 601-602.

M. R. O. THOMAS 77

0976 New subspecies of Melachinis. Annuls unci Magazine of Natural Hislorv: including /.oology ,
Botany and Geology. London (9) II: 602-607.

0977 Two new guenons from the Ivory Coast. West Africa. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 11: 607-608.

097S On mammals from the Li-kiang Range, Yunnan, being a further collection obtained by Mr.
George Forrest. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and
Geo/ogv, London (9) 11: 655-663.

0979 Exhibition of a new rock kangaroo from north Queensland. Proceedings of the Zoological
Society of London 1 77.

0980 Exhibition of the skull of a pygmy fruit-bat from Sumatra. Proceedings of the Zoological
Society of London 178.

0981 On the mammals obtained in Dartur by the I^ynes-Lowe Expedition. Proceedings of the
Zoological Society of London 247-271. [With M. A. C. Hinton).

0982 Scientific results from the Mammal Survey. No. XXXVIL On tree shrews from the Mergui
Archipelago. Journal of the Bombay Natural History Society 29: 84.

0983 Scientihc results from the Mammal Survey. No. XXXVIIL The mouse deer {Tragulus] of
the Mergui Archipelago. Journal of the Bombay Natural History Society 29: 84-85.

0984 Scientific results from the Mammal Survey. No. XXXIX. On the large squirrels of the
Ratufa gigantea group. Journal of the Bombay Natural History Society 29: 85-86.

0985 Scientific results from the Mammal Survey. No. XL. A new mouse from Madura, S. India.
Journal of the Bombay Natural History Society 29: 87.

0986 Scientific results from the Mammal Survey. No. XLI. On the forms contained in the genus
Harpiocephalus. Journal of the Bombay Natural History Society 29: 88-89.

0987 A new short-tailed opossum from Marajo, Amazonia. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 12: 157.

0988 On the ring-tailed phalanger of South Australia, and a new rat from north Queensland.
Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London
(9) 12: 158-160.

0989 Gcograhical races of Petaurista alborufus. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 12: 171-172.

0990 Notes on some spiny mice (Acomys). Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 12: 173-174.

0991 A new Uromys from the Kei Islands. Treubia, Buitenzorg 3: 442.

0992 Scientific results from the Mammal Survey. No. XLII. The distribution and geographical
races of the Gulandi bush rats (Golunda ellioti). Journal of the Bombay Natural History
Society 29: 373-376.

0993 Scientific results from the Mammal Survey. No. 43. On some squirrels from the Mergui
Archipelago. Journal of the Bombay Natural History Society 29: 376-377.

0994 A new ratel from British East Africa. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 12: 340.

0995 Two new mammals from Marajo Island. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 12: 341-342.

0996 On mammals collected by Captain Shortridgc during the Percy Sladen and Kaffrarian
Museum Expedition to the Orange River. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London
483-499. [With M. A. C, Hinton].

0997 On some mammals from Simalur Island, west of Sumatra, collected by Mr. E. Jacobson.
Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London
(9) 12: .591-593';

0998 Three new mammals from Peru. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 12: 692-694.

1924

0999 A new pika from the Altai. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology;
Botany and Geology, London (9) 13: 16.3-164.

1000 On a fish-eating rat from Bogota. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 13: 164-165.

78 J. E. HILL

1001 New South American small mammals. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (9) 13: 234-237.

1002 Some notes on pacas. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including 7.oolog\'. Botany
and Geology. London (9) 13; 237-239.

1003 On some Ceylon mammals. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology,
Botany and Geology. London (9) 13: 239-242.

1004 Some new Australasian Muridac. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (9) 13: 296-299.

1005 Starvation for influenza. Truth 5 March.

1006 Scientific results from the Mammal Survey. No. XLIV, On a new field mouse from Nepal,
with a note on the classification of the genus Apodemus. Journal of the Bombay Natural
History Society 29: 888-S89.

1007 On a collection of mammals made by Mr. Latham Rutter in the Peruvian Amazons. Annals
and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (9) 13:
530-538.

1008 A new Scoteiniis from Queensland. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 13: 540.

1009 A new fish-eating rat from Ecuador. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 13: 541-542.

1010 A new short-tailed opossum from Ecuador. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 13; 586.

1011 The geographical races of Oryzomys ralticeps. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 14; 143-144.

1012 Nomina conservanda in Mammalia. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 345-
348. [With 25 other European mammalogists].

1013 New Callicehus. Conepatus, and Oecomys from Peru. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 14; 286-288.

1014 A new subspecies of Nyctinomus australis. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 14: 455-456.

1015 A new genus and species of shrew from Ceylon. Spolia Zevlanica (Ceylon Journal of
Science. B), Colombo 13 ( 1 ) ; 93-95.

1016 A new pouched mouse {Phascogale) from northern New South Wales. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (9) 14;
528-529.

1017 On learning Braille. The Times, London 21 November.

1925

1018 A new genus of cavy from Catamarca. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (9) 15: 418-420.

1019 On mammals collected in 1923 by Captain G. C. Shortridge during the Percy Sladen and
Kaffrarian Museum Expedition to Southwest Africa. With field notes by the collector.
Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 221-246. [With M. A. C. Minton).

1020 The Spedan Lewis South American Exploration. — I. On mammals from southern Bolivia.
Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London
(9) 15: 575-582.

1021 On some Argentine mammals. 1. Two new rodents from Tucuman Province |pp. 582-584.]
IL A special genus for Eunemomys fossor [pp. 584-585]. 111. A second species of
Spalacopus [pp. 585-586). Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology,
Botany and Geology, London (9) 15; 582-586.

1022 A new genus of African Muridac allied to Leggada. Annuls and Magazine of Natural
History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 15: 667-669.

1023 A new Australian mouse of the genus Pseudomys. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology. Botany and Geology. Ixjndon (9) 15: 669^71 .

1024 On the mammals (other than ruminants) collected by Captain Angus Buchanan during his
second Saharan expedition, and presented by him to the National Museum. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology. Botany and Geology. London (9) 16:
187-197.

M. R. O. THOMAS 79

1025 On some of the species of Psammomys found in Algeria, Tunis and Tripoli. Annals ami
Magazine of Natural Hislory; including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (4) 16:
197-199.

1026 On some mammals from the New Hebrides, Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 16: 240-241.

1027 The mammals obtained by Mr. Herbert Stevens on the Sladen-Godman Expedition to
Tonkin. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 495-506.

1028 The garden dormouse of Formentera. Balearic Islands. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 16: 389-?V(i.

1029 The generic position of Gerhillus przewalskii Buchncr. Annals and M'lgazine of Natural
History: including Z.oology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 16: 548.

10.^0 The generic name of the finless-backed porpoise. .Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 16: 655.

1926

1031 The generic position of certain African Muridae. hitherto referred to Aethomys and
Praomxs. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and
Geology, London (9) 17: 174-179.

1032 Some new African Mammalia. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology,
Botany and Geology, London (9) 17: \H0-\H4.

1033 Two new rock-wallabies (Pelrogale) discovered by Captain G. W. [sic, G. FL| Wilkins in
northern Australia. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology, Botany
anJGVo%,v, London (9) 17: 184^187.

1034 A ready method of repairing small mammal skulls. Museums Journal, I,ondon 25: 209.

1035 On some small mammals from Madagascar. [The races of Ericulus setosus pp. 250-251 ; Two
new species of Microgale pp. 251-252|. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including
Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (9) 17: 250-252.

1036 On mammals from Gorgona Island, with the description of a new sloth. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 17:
309-311.

1037 Two new mammals from north Argentina. Annals and Magazine of Natural History:
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 17: 311-313.

1038 The Godman-Thomas Expedition to Peru. — I. On mammals collected by Mr. R. W.
Hendee near Lake Junin. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology,
Botany and Geology, London (9) 17: 313-318.

1039 The Spedan Lewis South American Exploration. — IL On mammals collected in the Tarija
Department, southern Bolivia. Annais and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology,
Botany and Geology, London (9) 17: 318-328.'

1040 On mammals from Ovamboland and the Cuncne River, obtained during Captain Shortridge's
third Percy Sladen and Kaffrarian Museum Expedition into South-west Africa. Proceedings
of the Zoological Society of London 285-312.

1041 The Spedan Lewis South American Exploration. — III. On mammals collected by Sr. Budin
in the Province of Tucuman. Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology,
Botany and Geology, London (9) 17: 602-609.

1042 A new Myotis from Ladak. Annals and Magazine of Natural Hislory: including Zoology.
Botany and Geology, London (9) 17: 609-610.

1043 The Godman-Thomas Expedition to Peru. — II. On mammals collected by Mr. R. W.
Hendee in north Peru between Pacasmayo and Chachapoyas. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 17: 610-616.

1044 On various mammals obtained during Capt. Wilkin's expedition in Australia. [On rock-
wallabies of the Petrogale penicillata - assimilis group pp. 625-630; Peradorcas pp. 630-631 ;
Pseudochirus pp. 631-633; Trichosurus pp. 633-635]. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 17: 625-635.

1045 On some mammals from the Middle Amazons. [The giant Amazonian squirrels of the
subgenus Urosciurus pp. 63.5-637; The acouchis of the Myoprocta prutti group pp. 637-639].
Annals and Magazine of Natural History: including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London
(9) 17: 635-639.

80 J. E. HILL

1046 Two new subspecies of Callosciuriis quinquestriatus. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (*)) 17: 639-641.

1047 The Godman-Thomas Expedition to Peru — III. On mammals collected by Mr. R. W.
Hendce in the Chachapoyas region of north Peru. Annals and Magazirw of Natural History;
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 18: 156-167.

1048 The Spedan Lewis South American Exploration. — IV. List of mammals obtained by Sr.
Budin on the boundary between Jujuy and Bolivia. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History; including Zoology, Botan\ and Geology, London (9) 18: 193-195.

1049 Scientific results from the Mammal Survey. No. XLV. Two new pygmy squirrels from the
Mergui Archipelago. Journal of the Bombay Natural History Society 31: 23.

1050 A new long-eared bat from central Asia. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 18: 306-307.

1051 Two new Australian Muridae. [A new insular rat from Western Australia pp. .WH-309; A
rat from Moreton Island, S.E. Queensland pp. .309-310|. .'\nnals and Magazine of Natural
History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (9) 18: 308-310.

1052 The zoological names Simla, S. satvrus, and Pithecus, and their possible suppression.
Nature, London 118 (2968): 411. [With M. A. C. Hinton).

1053 The Godman-Thomas Expedition to Peru. — IV. On mammals collected by Mr. R. W.
Hendee north of Chachopoyas, Province of Amazonas, north Peru. Annals and Magazine
of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (9) 18: 345-349. [With
J. St. Leger].

1054 The local races of Dasyrus hallucatus. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (9) 18: 543-544.

1055 The Spedan Lewis South American Exploration. — V. Mammals obtained by Senor E.
Budin in Neuquen. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology. Botany
and Geology, London (9) 18: 635-641 . [With J. St. Leger].

1927

1056 A remarkable new monkey from Peru, Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (9) 19: 156-157.

1057 The Godman-Thomas Expedition to Peru. — V. On mammals collected by Mr. R. W.
Hendee in the Province of San Martin, N. Peru, mostly at Yurac Yacu. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 19:
361-375.

1058 On the Titi monkeys of the Callicehus torquatus group. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 19: 509-510.

1059 The Delacour Exploration of French Indo-China - Mammals. Proceedings of the Zoological
Society of London 41-58, pis. 1-2.

1060 A selection of lectotypes of American rodents in the collection of the British Museum.
Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London
(9) 19: 545-554.

1061 A new bat of the genus Myotis from Abyssinia. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 19: 554-555.

1062 The octodon of the highlands near Santiago. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 19: 556-557.

1063 On a further collection of mammals made by Sr. E. Budin in Neuquen, Patagonia, Annals
and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 19:
650-658.

1064 A new subspecies of Bassaricyon from Colombia. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, Ij.)ndon (9) 20: 80.

1065 On mammals from the (iobabis district, eastern Damaraland, South-Wcst Africa, obtained
during Captain Shortridge's fourth Percy Sladcn and Kaffrarian Museum Expedition With
field notes by the collector Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 371-398

1066 On further Patagonian mammals from Neuquen and the Rio Colorado collected bv Senor
E. Budin. A.— Neuquen [pp. 2(K)-202|. B.— Pichi Mahuida [pp. 202-2()5[. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 20:
199-205.

M. R. O. THOMAS 81

1067 Scientific results from the Mammal Survey. No. XLVII. On the generic position of the
Afghan jerboa (Alaclagii indicu). Journal of the Bombay Natural History Society 31; 22.

1068 On further monkeys of the Callicehu.s lorquatus group. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History^ including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 20: 2iS7.

1069 On Bornean specimens of the teledu (Mydaus). Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (9) 20: 288.

1070 The Godman-Thomas Expedition to Peru. — VL On mammals from the Upper Huallaga
and neighbouring highlands. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology,
Botany and Geology, London (9) 20: 594~60H.

1071 The late Sir Harry Johnston. Nature. London 120: 339.

1072 A new genus and species of glossophagine bat, with a subdivision of the genus ChoeronycterLs.
Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London
(10) 1: 120-123.

1073 A new Thomasomys from the Rio Grande dc Sul. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (10) 1: 154-155.

1074 Some rarities from Abyssinia, with the description of a new mole-rat (Tachyorycles) and a
new Arvicanthis. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and
Gratogy. London (10) 1: 302-304.

1075 A special proodont race of water-vole, occurring in Northumbria. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (10) 1; 316-318.

1076 The Transvaal race of the common S. -African wild cat. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (10) I: 318-319.

1077 On the East-African mungoosc described as Galeriscus jacksoni. Annals and Magazine of
Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (10) 1: 344-345.

1078 Size differences in the little "Pichi" armadillos. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (10) 1: 526-527.

1079 The Delacour Exploration of French Indo-China. — Mammals. II. On mammals collected
during the winter of 1926-1928. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 139-150.

1080 The generic name Delphax in mammalogy. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London ( 10) I: 623.

1081 A remarkably coloured squirrel from N. Siam. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (10) 2: l(X)-101.

1082 The South Tenasserim race of Paguma leucomystax . Gray. Annals and Magazine of Natural
History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (10) 2: 101-102.

1083 The Godman-Thomas Expedition to Peru. — VII. The mammals of the Rio Ucayali. Annals
and Magazine of Natural History; including Zoology. Botany and Geology, London (10) 2:
249-265.

1084 The Godman-Thomas Expedition to Peru. — VIII. On mammals obtained by Mr. R. W.
Hendee at Pebas and Iquitos, upper Amazons. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London ( 10) 2: 285-294.

1085 Two new S.W. African mungooses. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London ( 10) 2: 408.

1086 A new Ecliimys from eastern Ecuador. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (10) 2: 409—110.

1087 Note on Sciurus splendidus . Gray. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (10) 2: 590.

1929

1088 The Delacour Exploration of French Indo-China. — Mammals. III. Mammals collected during
the winter of 1927-28. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London (1928): 831-841.

i089 A new bandicoot-rat from western Siam. Annals and Magazine of Natural History;
including Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (10) 3: 205.

1090 A new mole from western Siam. Annals and Magazine of Natural History; including
Zoology, Botany and Geology, London (10) 3; 206-207.

1091 On mammals from the Kaoko-Veld, South West Africa, obtained during Captain Shortridge's
fifth Percy Sladen and Kaffrarian Museum Expedition. Proceedings of the Zoological
Society of London 99-1 1 1 .

82 J. E. HILL

1092 The mammals of Senor Budin's Patagonian Expedition. 1927-1928. Annals and Magazine
of Natural History; including Zoology, Botany and Geology. London (10) 4: 35— 15.

Reports, brief accounts of papers presented, or of specimens exhibited at the Scientific
Meetings of the Zoological Society of London, and published (1880-1903) in the
'Minutes' and later (1904-1919) in the 'Abstracts" of the Proceedings of the Society, but
not including any validly proposed names.

1880

AOl [Description of a new species of Mus. obtained from the island of Ovalau. Fiji] 6 January.
A02 [Note on a specimen of Myoxus elegans.] 3 February: 1.

A03 [On a collection of mammals brought from Ecuador by Mr. Clarence Buckley! ■* Miiy: 3.
A04 [A new species of Reilhrodon obtained in Venezuela by the late Mr. D. Dyson. | 14
December: 2.

1882

A05 [On the African mungooses (Hcrpestinae).| 3 January: I .
A06 [Account of a series of rodents from Northern Peru.| 17 January: 1.
A07 [Descriptions of a small series of rodents from Damara Land] 21 February.
A08 [Account of a small collection of mammals from Durango.] 18 April: 1.
A09 [Description of two new species of fruit bats of the genus Pteropus from the Caroline
Islands] 19 December: 3.

1885

AlO [Mammals obtained and observed by Mr. [H. H] Johnston.) 3 March: 1 .

All [Exhibition of. and remarks upon, a rare burrowing rodent (Heterocephalus glahcri).] If)

June: 1.
A12 [A description of Heterocephalus phillipsi.] 17 November: 2.

188(i

A13 [List of mammals collected by A. O. Hume] 19 January: 2.

A14 [On the wallaby commonly known as Lagorchestes fasciatus.] 7 December: 2.

1887

A15 [Mammals obtained by Mr. H. H. Johnston on the Cameroons Mountains] I February: 1.
A 16 [Small mammals collected in British Guiana by Mr. W, L. Sclater.] \^ February: 1.
A17 [Bats collected by Mr. C. M. Woodford in the Solomon Islands] 15 March: I.

1888

A18 [A collection of mammals obtained by Emm Pasha in central Africa] 17 January: I.

A19 [A new genus and species of Muridae obtained by Mr. H. O. Forbes in New Guinea] 17

April: 2.
A20 [A collection of small mammals obtained by Mr. William Taylor in Duval County. Texas.]

20 November: 2.
A21 [The mammals obtained by Mr. C. M. Woodford during his second expedition to the

Solomon Islands.) 4 December: 1.

1889

A22 [A specimen of a new muntjac from Tenasserim.) 5 March: 1 .

A23 (Description of a new Bornean monkey] 19 March: I.

A24 [Preliminary notes on different species of otter] 2 April: I .

A25 [Mammals from Mount Kina Balu obtained by Mr. John Whitehead] Id April: 1.

1891

A26 [A collection of small Mammalia made by Mr. F. J. Jackson. F.Z.S.. in eastern central
Africa.) 3 March: 1.

M. R.O.THOMAS 83

A27 [Antelopes procured by Mr. T. W. H. Clarke in Somali-Land. J 17 March: 1.
A28 [Notes on various species of ungulates. | 16 June: 1.

1892

A29 [Account of the species of the Hyracoidea.] 5 January: 2.

A30 [A head of the East African oryx.| 15 March: 1.

A3I (Probable identity of Lidth dc Jeude specimens. I 3 May: 1.

A32 (Review of antelopes of the genus Cephalophus] 17 May: 2.

A33 [On the genus Echinops.] 14 June: 2.

A34 [a collection of mammals from Nyassa-land.| 1 November: 2.

1893

A35 [Examples of a Bornean monkey.) 17 January: 1 .

A36 [Use of the word "type".) 14 March: 1.

A37 [Kcmarks on Nanotragus livingstonianus] 14 March: 1.

A38 [a second collection of mammals sent by Mr. H. H. Johnston.) 16 May: 1.

1894

A39 (The skin of a giraffe from Somaliland.) 2(1 February: 1.
A40 [Dwarf antelopes of the genus Madoqiui.]. 3 April: I .
A41 [Account of the gazelles of Algeria.) 5 June: 1.

1895

A42 [On Piilorious africanus.] 5 February: 1.

A43 [Mammals from Aden.| 18 June: 3. [With J. W. Yerbury).

1896

A44 [On further collections from Nyasa-land.) 17 November: I.

1897

A45 )A remarkable partially white antelope of the genus Cerricapra.] 30 November: 1.
A46 )On the mammals obtained by Mr. A. Whyte in north Nyasaland. and presented to the
British Museum by Sir H. H. Johnston, K.C.B.) 14 December: 1.

1898
A47 )On some mammals collected by the late Mr Henry Durnford in 1877-8 in Chubut,

Patagonia.) 15 March: 2.
A48 [Remarks on Sciurus fintaysoni.] 5 April: 1.

A49 [Mammals collected by Mr J. D. D. la Touche near Kuatan, N.W. Fokien.) 15 November: 4.
A50 jLetter from Senor Ameghino. C.M.Z.S.. on Neomylodon.] 29 November: 7.

1900

A5I [Exhibition of mounted heads of Nile antelopes.) 6 February: 19.

1901

A52 [Exhibition of the skull of a common fox {Cunis vulpcs) with supernumerary upper incisors. )
15 January: 15.

1903

A53 (Exhibition of a drawing of a skin of a female gazelle with a perfect hair-whorl on the
withers.) 17 November: 8.

1904

A54 jExhibition of a new subspecies of Ga;e//o .sofmmfrrmg/.) 19 January: 15.
A55 [A collection of mammals from Namaqualand.) 2 February: 19. )With H. Schwann).
A56 [A communication on a new subspecies of duiker.) )On behalf of W. Rothschild). 16
February: 21.

84 J. F.. HILL

A57 [Exhibition of. and remarks on. the skull of a buffalo] 1 March: 25.

A58 [Exhibition of a specimen of a fruit bat.| I March: 25.

A59 [Mammals obtained by the late Mr. W G. Doggctt on the Anglo-German Boundary

Commission.] 19 April: .''3.
A60 [Exhibition of skulls of north Australian rock-wallaby (Peradorcas concinna).] 19 April: 33.
A61 [Osteology and systematic position of the rare Malagasy bat Myzopoda uurim.\ 3 May: 37.
A62 [Sketch of hind and fawn of Pere David's deer {Elaphunis davidianiLs).] 1 May: 39.
A63 [Exhibition of a new species of pig from central Africa.) 15 November: 4.
A64 [On the mammals collected by Mr. E. Seimund in Fernando Po.] 15 November: 4.
A65 [Exhibition of specimens of a gazelle from Palestine, described as a new species] 13

December: 11.

1906

A66 [A second collection of mammals made in Western Australia for Mr. W. E. Balston.] 13

November, No. 35: 18.
A67 [Sixth instalment of the results of the Rudd Exploration of South Africa.] 13 November, No.

35: 18. (With H. Schwann].
A68 [On mammals collected in Korea and Quclpart Island by Mr. Malcolm P Anderson.] 27

November, No. 36: 22.

1907

A69 [Exhibition of a collection of mammals and birds from the islands of Saghalien and

Hokkaido, N. Japan, made by Mr. Malcolm P. Anderson] 5 February. No. 39: 5.
A70 [List of small mammals which had been obtained in the islands of Saghalien and Hokkaido

by Mr. M. P. Anderson for the Duke of Bedford's exploration of eastern Asia] 23 April.

No. 44: 24.
A71 [Fifth of the series of papers on the mammals collected by Mr. M. P. Anderson during the

Duke of Bedford's exploration of eastern Asia.) 7 May, No. 45: 28.
A72 [Mammals collected at Beira by Mr. C. H. B. Grant, being No. VIII of the scries of papers

on the Rudd exploration of South Africa.) 12 November, No. 48: 39.

1908

A73 [On mammals obtained in the Shantung Peninsula, N. China, by Mr. M. P. Anderson, for

the Duke of Bedford's exploration of eastern Asia] 14 January, No. 51 : 1.
A74 [On mammals from the islands of Tsu-shima. between Korea and Japan, collected by Mr.

M P. Anderson, for the Duke of Bedford's exploration of eastern Asia] 4 Februarv, No.

52: 3.
A75 [On mammals collected bv Mr. M. P. Anderson during a trip to the Mongolian Plateau,

N.W. of Kalgan.] 18 February, No. 53: 6.
A76 [On "Mammals obtained bv Mr. C. H. B. Grant in the Gorongoza Mountains, Portuguese

S.E. Africa".] 17 March. No. 55: 12. (With R. C. Wroughton).
A77 [On mammals from Inkerman, near Townsville, north Queensland, collected by Mr. W.

Stalker.) 3 November, No. 61: 35.

1912

A78 [Exhibition of, and remarks upon, a peculiar Amazonian monkey (CaUimico goeldii).] 26
November, No. 114: 49.

1914

A79 [Report on the mammals collected by the British Ornithologists' Union and Wollaston
Evxpedition in Dutch New Guinea.) 7 April, No. 131: 24-25.

1919

A80 [Exhibition of three interesting mammals obtained bv Dr Aders. F.7..S., in Zanzibar.) 21
October, No. 196: 27.

M. R. (). THOMAS

85

INDEX TO NAMES PROPOSED BY OLDFIELD THOMAS

This Index associates the serial number of each of Thomas' pubhcations as listed in this
Bibhography with the page in that paper on which any new name is proposed, and gives
details of plates and figures where appropriate. In a few instances where a brief diagnosis
precedes the formal description . as for example when a new name is initially diagnosed in
a key and described in full later in the paper the pagination for both has been given.

uhrocodon, Phyllotis. Ul.tS: 31h

abyssinicus. Cephalophiis, (H 10; 415, 427

achates, Tuphozoiis. 0766: 60

achilles. Rhmolophus, 0279: 145

achrotes. Tints inesomelas, 1040: 295

acticola. Gerhillus. i)SW: 147

acticola, Heliosciurus rufobrachium, 0972: 525

acticola. Mits ciirysopiiilus. 05S4: 547

adamsoni. Dremonys rjufigenisj, 0739: 25

adersi. Cepiiaiopiiiis, 0H41: 151

admiralilatum. Pteropus, 0155: 293

adusta. Piiascogaie fiavipes. 0965: 175

adustus, Peramys, 0227: 219

adustus, Pitascolarctos cinereiis, 0968: 246

adventor, Cricetomys gambiamts. 0550: 295

adversus, Urotricitiis taipoides, 0574: 49

aello. Cepitaiotes. 02K2: 216

aemitli. Mus. 0206: 249

Aepomys, 0262: 452

aerosus, Akodon, 0709: 406

aerosus. Uromys. 0888: 428

aerula, Hystrix. 1024: 196

aeta, Epimys, 0657: 591

Aetiiaiodes. 0967: 14; 0969: 251 ; 0980: 178

Aelliaiops. 0967: 14; 0980: 178

Aetiteciiinus. 0832: 194

Aetiiomys. 0773: 477

Aetitosciurus. 0782: 271

affints, Scaptotiyx fitstcaudatiis, 068.^: 514

afgltanus. Microliis (Pitaiomys), 0676: 349

agadiiL\, Euxerus ervlhropiis, 091)6: 6

agag. Gerhiilus. 0408: 33; 0420: 296

agneiia. Kenvmda. 0582: 372

ainu, Micromys speciosiis. 0496: 349

airensis. Acnmys, 0906; 8

airensis, Jacuius /aculus. 0906: 10, 11

ajax, Conepalm. 0703: 137

ai<.lia. Anicaniiits maccuius, 0773: 479

aiiodontius. Oxymycterus, 0927: 615

alacris, Sciurus nibinsnm. 0579: 306

aladdin, Pipistrelim. 0495: 23; 0498: 521

alhalus. Myopierus. 0773: 469

albatus. Paraediinivs dnrsaiis. 0936: 144

aibojubatus. Connociuieies taiirinus. 0107: 388

aiberti, Mviomvs. 0765: 148

albicatus. FMobius. 0680: 401

albigula. Scotoecus, 0614: 544

aibipmrus, Taphozons iortgimamis, 0265: 246

aibiventer, Aiiodon, 0226: 217

aibiventer, Scoteinus sciiiieffeni. 0584: 540

aibofuscus. Scotopiiiius. 0083: 84

aicinous, Mtcrolus (Caryomys), 0666: 50; 0679: 140

aiecto, Aecltalodes, 0967: 14; 0969: 251; 0980: 178

aiccto. Aetltalops. 0967: 14; 0980: 178

aii'clo. Cyllarops. 0702: 134, 135

alexandri, Crossarciius, 0540: 373

aiexandri. Funisciurus. 0540: 376

alexi. Notomys. 0948: 316

algiricus. PsfammomysJ. 0364: 363, 364

algtricus, Putonus ernimeus. 0188: 451

aiienus. Hisliotus. 0783: 276

aiienhyi. Gerhiilus. 0840: 146

aiieni. Bassaricyon. 0004: 397; figs. 1-3, pi. 38

aiieni. Bassaricyon. A03: 3 (nomen nudum)

aiiem, Rhogeessa. 0120: 477

aiiigatoris, Macropus robuslus. 0436: 224

aiplionsei. Sciurus. 0531: 442 (nomen novum fi>r

Sciurus robertt, 0422: 463)
aistotti. Reitiirodon. 0008: 691, figs. 1-4
aistoni, Reitiirodon. A04: 2 (nomen nudum)
aisus, Euneorttys micropus. 085 1 : 202
altaina. Ociiolona daurica. 0670: 761
altanum. Myotis. 0647: 3; 0649: 161
allerus. Aliodon. 0854: 496
allicola. Cricetuius, 0811: 455
allicola. Mus. 0063: 408; 0073: 2.34
ailorum. Aiiodon moHLs. 0709: 404
aitorum. Lagurus lagurus. 0680: 401
aiuco. Sciuropterus, 0555: 464
ambrosius, Menones. 0853: 270
amicus. Pliyllotis. 0295: 355
amir. Paraeciiinus, 0833: 232
Ammodiiiu.s. 0452: 102, fig
Ammodorcas. (X)93: 207
Ammodorcas. All: 2 (nomen nudum)
Ammomys. 0499: 84
amoenus. Aiiodon. 0304: 468
amoenus. DLstochoerus pennatus, 0890: 537
amoenus. Neacomvs spinosus. 0430: 239
amvgdaii. Sciuropterus momonga. 0496: 344
anoA, Uromys. 0528: 72
anatolica. Vulpes vuipes, 0867: 121
Ancltotomys. 0842: 204, 208
ancilla. Myotis myosotis, 0626: 25; 0637: 636

86

J. E. HILL

ancilla. Promops. 0764: 62. 63

anderseni. Dobsonia, 0729: 435

anderseni. Rhinolophus. 0453: 156

andersoni. Cricetulus. 0585: 642

andersoni, Epimys, 0647: 4; 0649: 171

andersoni, Evotomys. 0493; 18; 0496; 354

andersoni. Rhynchonax. 0666: 49; 0679: 130

andersoni. Sits. 0602: 441; 0615: 127

andina. Felis pardinoides. 0417: 238

andina. Galiclis. 0422: 462

andina. Pseudalopex culpaeus, 0726: 357

Andinomys. 0351: 24; 0354: 116

andima, Lepits, 0233: 551

andiunt. Phyllotis. 0697: 409

aneryihnis. Sciurus pyrrhopus. 0085: 447. pi. 40

an^elus, Eliomys (Dryomys), 0510: 424

angolae. Aeihechinus. 0833: 230

angolae. Aonyx capensis, 0568: 388

angolae. Thryonomys swinderianiis. 0949: 392

angolensLs. Lepiis. 0447: 420. fig,

angonicus. Heliophobius. 0821: 314

angularis. Oxymyxterus. 0609: 237

angulensis, Canis ihous. 0422: 460

angustus. Chelemys. 1063; 654

anguslus, Microtus. 0575: 108

Anisomys. 0427: 4; 0429: 199

ankoliae. Tachyoryctes. 0614: 545

anna. Chiropodomys, 0597: 19; 0607: 390

annaeus. Arclonvx. 0909: 524

atmalium. Sciurus boolhiae. 0484: 309

annamensis. Petaunsta. 0744: 204

anneitens. Rhizomys. (K)89: 304; (M192: 186

annectens. Rhizomys. A26: 1 (nomen nudum)

annellaiiis. Callosciurus ferrugineus. 1088: 839

annexus, Sorex. 0536: 859

Anolomys, 0500: 86

ansorgei. Arvicanlhis, 0623: 353

ansorgei. Cricetomys. 0447: 412

ansorgei. Crossarchus. 0617: 195

ansorgei. Dendromus, 0482: 173

ansorgei. Georychus, 0482: 175

ansorgei. Heterocephalus. 0432: 336

ansorgei, I.epus. 0482: 176

ansorgei, Nyctinomus. 0708: 318

Anlhops, 0056: 156; 1M)66: 477

anlillarum. Oryzomys, 0244: 177

antoniae, Funisciurus, 0540: 377

anionii, Ctenomys talarum. 0618: 242

apiculatus, Midas. 0459: 190

apoUinaris. Cerdocyon. 0837: 371

apoHinaris. Sylvilagus. 0866: 31

aqualicus. Scapleromys. 0878: 477

aquilo. Lepus capensis, 0550: 297

aquilo. Meriones erythroums, 0680: 395

aquilo, Steatomys, 0981: 264

aquilus, Notomys, 0925: 540

arahica. Vttlpes vulpes. 0389: 489

arabicus. Papio. 0275: 7; 0278: 929; 0289: 96

arabnon. Dipoddlus. 0839; 61

arabium. Rhinopoma cystops. 0716: 89

arcium. Uromys. 0718: 214

arcturus, Microtus. 0680: 398

ardens, Arvicanlhis pulchellus, 0634: 313

arenalis, Oryzomys. 0724: 571

arenarius. Phyllotis. 0359: 224

arequipae. Conepatus, 0304: 466

arequipae. Viscaccia. 0541: 442

ar^f. Nycteris. 0426: 633

argens, Potomogale velox, 0773; 470

argentinius. Scit4rus (Mesosciurits). 0927: 609

argentintts, Dasypterus ega. 0336: 247

argentinus, Eptesicus. 0876; 365

ar gurus, Hesperomys carillus, 0860: 130

argurus, MicrotiLs (Alticola). 0596: 264

argurus. Mus. 0074: 433. fig.

argynnis. Casinycteris, 0630: 111

rtnV/u/fl. Crocidura, (t981: 252

aridulus. Grammomys. 0981: 268

rtr/>/. Pipistrellus. 0453: 157

ar/V/. Plecolus. 0647: 3; 0649: 160

armenius. Microtus terrestris. 0552; 201

armillatus. Petauroides volans. 0968: 248

arrogans. Sienomys. 0942: 263; 0958: 728

aruma. Ph\'lloslomu.s hastalus. 1(K)1:236

Ascopharynx. 0284: 223

asper. Limnomys. 0505: 326

asper. Sorex. 0735: 565

aspera. Phascogale murex. 0717: 211; 0737: 324

assamcnsts. Atherurus. 0902: 598

athcnc, Sciuropicrus russicus. 0551: 409

atkmsom. Hclogale. 0231: 378

atlantis. Elcphaniulus rozeti. 0723: 587

(//raw. Pteralopex. 0056: 155; (K)66: 475. pL 20. fig. 3,

pL 21. figs. 4-7
atratus. Nyctinomus ausiralis. 1014:456
(/mVt;. .Sh.5. 0677: 13; 0687: 391. 393
auceps. Kerodon, 0661: 255
auceps. Meriones. 0585: 640
audax. Tachyoryctes. 0627: 421
auramii, Lepus saxatilis, 0996: 497
aurex. Tylonycteris, 0749: 228
auratus. Mungos. 0584: 543
aurillus. Oryzomys (Microryzomys). 0809: 1 ; 0892:

228. pi. 14. fig. 2
auritiis. Pseudomys, 0642: 607
aunventer, Oryzomys. 0276: 379
aurora. Cercopithecus leucampyx. 0621: 485
australis. Chrotoptvnvi auritus. 0484: 308
australis. Cremnomys, 0776: 242
australis. Heterornys, 0314; 194
australis. Melomys. 1004: 298
australis. Scoteinus schlieffeni, 0584: 539. 540
austrinus. Raltiis culmorum. 0921: 427
austrinus. Rhipidomys, 0898: 183

M. R. O. THOMAS

87

avarillus. Mus. 11584: 547

avarus. Pseudochirtui. 0505: 32^

aviator. Nyclalus. Ilh63: 380

avunculus. Micro.u'iuru.s. 0736: 574

avunculus. Mus, 0447: 417

azarae. Cienomys. 0399: 228; 0417: 243

azarica. Pseudalopex, 072ft: 360

azaricus. Metachirus opossum. 0976: 604

azoreum. Pterygistes. 0331: 33

azlecus. Philander laniger. 0721: 358. 359

aztecus. Polos flavus, 0361: 266, 268

bahylonicus. Taphozous kachhensis, 0766: 58

hahu. Pipislrelliis. 0766: 30

hacchanle. Akodon. 0350: 138

bacchante. Mus hvpoxanthus. 0421: 342

hadiatus, Petaurisia lylei. 1027: 501

hadius. Tachyoryctes ruddi. 0614: 546

baeodon. Mus. 0170: 452. 458

baeticus. Sus scrofa. 0677: 14; 0687: 391 . 393

baileyi. Myospalax. 0669: 727

baileyi. Soriculus. 0728: 683

bailwardi. Calomyscus. 0495: 23; 0498: 524, pi. 16

bailwardi. Nesokia. 0552: 199

bakeri. Pteropus. 1026: 240

balearica, Genetta genetla. 0376: 162

haliensis. Ralufa hkolor. 0714: 505

halina, Tupaia javanica, 0714: 505

hulnearuin. Holochiliis. 0531: 447

balneator. Oryzomys. 0293: 273

balsloni. Murina. 0582: 370

balstom. Scoleinus. 0513: 2; 0527: 472

ballina. Ochotona roylei, 0938: 188

baluchi. Calomyscus. 0871: 939

haluensis. Crocidura (Croc), 0265: 247

baluensis. Mus. 0170: 454, 458

bandarum. Funisciurus anervthrus. 0765: 146

bandiculus. Ratlus. 0942: 262; 0958: 728

bangueyae. Sciurus lowi, 0624: 387

baptistae, Meriones persicits. 087 1 : 934

barbarus, Ctenomys budini. 0898: 185

barnesi. Molossus. 0478: 585

barrowensis. Perameles. 0343: 396

barton!. Acanthoglossus bruijnii. 0554: 294

bartoni. Sciurus sladeni. 0744; 197, 199

basUUcus. Pteropus. 0756: 387

bat'is. Sorex, 0706: 214

Batomys. 0197: 162

ballyi. Didelphis marsupialis. 0394: 137

Beamys. 0605: 107

bealae, Peromyscus. 0409: 485

beatrix, Glauconycteris. 0337: 256

beatrix. Marmosa, 0638: 502

beatus, Akodon. 0851: 204

beatus, Funisciurus auriculatus. 0617: 196

beauforti. Pseudochirus. 0958: 734

bechuanae, Isomys plumilioj, 0122: 551

bcdfordi. Budorcas. 0653: 27; 0664: 693, pi, 21
bedfordi. Capreolus. 0572: 32; 0585: 645. pi, 32
bedfordi. Macropus. 0285: 23; 0290: 112
bedfordi. Muslela melampus. 0481: 10; 0491: 183;

0496: .M3, pi. 9
bedfordi. Ochotona. 0592: 45; 0594: 981
bedfordi. Proedromys. 0647: 4; 0649: 177
bedfordi. Scotonycteris. 0439: 14; 0455: 372; 0468:

187, pi. 13
bedfordiae. Cricelidus. 0592: 45; 0594: 974
hedfordiae. Evotomys. 0493: 18; 0496: 338
bedfordiae. Sorex. 0647: 3; 0649: 164
bedouin. Scoteinus schlieffeni. 0584: 540
beirae. Georychus. 0559: 780
bella, Leggada. 0616: 87
bella. Phascogale. 0436: 229
bclhssima, Kerivoula picta. 0510: 423
bellona. Tomeutes mearsi. 0788: 419, 420
Belomys. 0560: 2

belone. Sciuropterus (Hylopetes). 0579: 305
benefactus, Akodon. 0852: 214
benevolens. Rhipidomys. 0318: 369
bentleyae. Mus (Dasymys), 0113: 179
bergi, Ctenomys, 0360: 241
berlepsclui. Akodon, 0253: 280
bernieri. Lagorchestes hirsutus. 0534: 775
bettoni, Genetta, 0365: 365
bettoni. Procavia. 0444: 23; 0457: 463
bhotia. DIremomysl l/okriahj. 0788: 417
bicolor. Coelomys. 0766: 49
bicolor. Colomys. 0691: 42
bicolor. Kerivoula. 0460: 199
bicolor. Nyctophilus microtis, 0758: 498
bidens, Corvira. 0769: 311
bifax. Nyctophilus. 0758: 496
biologiae. Galictis barbara. 0280; 1 46
birmanicus. Herpestes auropunctatus. 0031: 84:0032:

58
blackleri. Meriones. 04U: 189
blancalis, Paraechinus deserti, 0926: 570
bUmfordi. C>iopfm«, (X)91; 884; 0121: 921, pi. 11,

figs. 1-2
bUmfordi. Mus, 0010: 24
blarina. Myosorex. 0519: 139
Blarinella. 0649: 166
B/flrOT(»nvs,0208: 310
bocagei, Herpestes, 0482: 170
bocagei, Mus, 0447: 416
bocagei, Steatomys, 01 16: 264
boeops, Oryzomys, 0273: 152
bogotensis, Acodon. 0201 : 369
boliviae. Dasyproclu variegata, 0821: 312
boliviae. Dasypus sexcinctus. 0549: 165. 166
boliviae. Eligmondontia callosa, 0336: 253
boliviae. Oryzomys, 0342: 536
boltvianus, Proechirnys, 0342; 537
Bolomys. ()8(K): 337, 339

88

J. E. HILL

bombax. Golunda ellioti, 1)992: 375

bombimis. M\otis natteren. 0496: 337

bomhyx. Rhof^eessa, 1)724: 569

bonaria. Lfulreolinaj cfrassicaudataj. 0974: 585

bonhoiei. Gerbillus. 0857: 560

bontamts. Rattus, 0899: 245

boranus. Macroscelides. 0308: 4; 0310: 802

borneanus. Pleromyscus, 0560: 7

borneoensis. Sciuroptents genibarhis. 0579; 304

bottegi, Crocidura (Cr.). 0247: 677

bovalli. Rhipidumys. 0M5: 114

boxi. Lagidium. 0896: 180

bovdi. Funisciuriis attriculatus. 0617: 196

Brachiones. 1029: 548

bracteator. Macropus robuslus. 0659: 609

brahma, Epimys. 0745: 232

brelichi. Rhinopiihecus. 0404: 29; 0418: 224. pi. 21

breviceps, Pteropiis. 0021: 756, pi. 55

breviceps. Pteropits. A09: 3 (nomen nudum)

bricenii. Mazama. 0566: 349

briganlium. Anicola amphibiiis, 1075: 318

bhghn. Gazella granli. 0308: 4; 0310; 805

hrockmani, Dipodillus. 0627: 420

brockmani. Mus, 0524: 298

brockmani. Rhinolophns, 0617: 192

brookei. Cepfwlophus. 0402: 290

brookei. Sciurus. 0103: 253; 0105: 225. pi. 19. fig. 6

brooksi, Dyacopterus, 0874: 284

broomi, Gerbillus paeba. 0839: 64

broomi. Otomys. 0386: 313

brucei. Rucervtts thamin. 0829: 366

bruihi.Marmosa. 0907: 519

bruchiLS, Praomys collinus. 1019: 238

brunello. CalUcebus personatus, 0724; 568

brimella,Helogale. 1040: 293

brunetla. Tupaia belangeri, 0982: 84

brunnea. Galera barbara, 031 1: 180

bnmnea, Helogale. 0515: 10; 0529: 581

brunni'its. Lophuromys aquihis, 0525: 305

brunneus, Vesperugo (Vesperus), (K)06: 165. tig.

brunneus. Zygodontomys, 0266: 269

buchanani, Cricetonns. (1906: 7

buchanani. DesmoddlisciLs, 0880: 317

buchanani. Mellivora. 1024: 190

buchanani. Procavia. 0906: 13

btichneri, Menones, 0596: 262

budini. Abrocoma. 0878: 475

budini, Conepalus, 0854; 490

budini. Ctenomys. 0703: 141

fru^im/. Hypsimys, 0831: 190

ftM(/(>». M(;rmr«fl. 0873: 195

/>u/o. Leggada. 0519: 145

/>H//er/. Geomys. 0114; 196

fru//cr/. Heteromys. 0133: 330

hunguranensis. Sciurus bicolor, 0167: 658

Runolagus. 1091: 109

Bunomys, 0640: 508

buntmgi. Thamnomys, 0650: 381

burnesi, Molossus, 0478: 584 (lapsus tor barnesi, see

p. 585)
burneyi. Sorex. 0759: 499
^HrroK-j;/. Alherurus. 0362; 269
burioni, Mus, 0113: 182 (preoccupied, see 0151: 205,

where renamed)
buriom, Oiomys. 0842: 210
/JHM/. .V/fm^«c5. 0389: 488
bulleri, Crocidura, 0662: 375
bulleri. Jaculus jaculus. (1947: 296
butleri. Gazella snemmerringi. (M33: 1 ; 0448: 4, fig.
buxtoni. Nesokui. 0856: 422

cabrerae. Microtus. 0516: 576

cachinus. Microlits (Eothenotnys). 0901: 5(W

cadornae. Pipislrellus. 0788: 415

caecias. Pseudochirus corinnae. 0950: 674

Caenolesles, 0201: 367; 0204: 870. pi. 50. tigs. 1-9

caenosus. Crernmomys medius. 0776: 241

caesia. Vulpes ruppclli. 0906: 5

calamorum. Microtus. 0378: 167

calarius, Aelhom\s namaquensis, 1032: 184

caldaltts. Herpesles caiLxi, 1065: 374

calidior. Arvicanthis dorsalis, 0584: 545

calidior. Dremomys pernyi, 0785: 394

calidwr. Proechimys semispinosus, 0661: 254

calidior, Uromys stalken. 0652: 387; 0737: 321

calidus. Gerbillus. 0839: 63

calidus. Hesperomys venuslus, 0779: 182

callewaerti. Hvlenomys. 1022: 668

Calluebus, 0422:456

calloiLS. Oryx. 0104: 195

callous. Orvx, A30: 1 (nomen nudum)

Calomyscus, (W95: 23; (W98: 524

calurus. Conepalus. 0854: 491

calurus, Gerbillus. (K)98: 76

campbelli, Cricetulus. 0473: 322

canarius. Sylvdagus. 0705: 213

canaster. Heliosciurus bongensis. 0981: 256

candace. Nasua. 0694: 228

(■«Hem. Herpestes smithii. 0932: 24, 25

cflnc.?cf^u. Dactylomys dactylinus. 0671: 87

caHe.vcc'm. Georychus capensis. 0518: 165

fflne.vcenj. Murina. 0969: 254

(■ane.5(rn.s. Peradorcas concinna, 0608: 198

cancvceav, Saccopteryx. 0318: 366

caniculus. Erinaceus algirus. 0765: 152

(unnomvA. 0763: 57

canopus, Eepus. 0906: 12

canonis. Epimvs confucianus. 0664: 690

cansulus. Sorex. (►696: 398

ajn«r/. Rhinolophus. 0597: 18; 0607: 378

capitis, ParaxeriLS jacksoni. 0605: 105

capricornis. Raphiceros neumanni, 0529: 584

capsalis. Sylvilagus. 0705: 213

caracciolae. Vampyrops. (X)76: 167, figs. 1-3

M. R. O. THOMAS

89

airacolus, Oryzomys, 0741: 242

carbo, Presbytis ohscura. 0613: ?34

careyi, Callosciurus sladeni. 0776: 225.233

carilla, Eligmodontta, 0350: 133

canllus. Mas. 0447:418

carissima, Myotis (Leuconoe). 0445: 383

tarmelitae, Phalanger. 0261: 5

caroli, Pseudochirus. 0920: 357

Carpomys, 0197: 161

carruthersi, CileUns. 0690: 393

carruthersi, Funisciunis. 0519: 140

canuthersi, Microtus (Pitymys). 0596: 263

Cflrv(3W.v.s\ (t647: 4; 0649: 175

Casinycleris, 0630: 111

caspica. Crocidura russula, 0552: 197

casta. Marmosa mills, 0655: 516

castaneus. Cephalophns dorsalts. 01 10: 421

caslaneus. Pelaurisla alboruftis. 0989: 172

castilianus. Sus scrofa, 0677: 13; 0687: 391.392

castas, Sciun4s. 0410: 488

catellus, Cyclopes didactylus. 1084:293

calellus. Eurozygomalornys, 0790: 301

cathermae. Oecomys. 0609: 234

catrinae. Dasyprocta azarae, 0821: 311

caucae. Marmosa. 02K3: 221

caucinus. Pronolagus. 1091: 109

caudalus. Pronolagus guereza. 0026: 219, pi. 12

caudatiis, Meriom's lihvcus. 0853: 267

caurina. Dorcopsis hageni. 0942: 264; 0958: 732

caurinits, Eplesicus pumilus. 0730: 439

caurinus. HeUoscmrus rufohrachium. 0972: 523

caurinus, Hvdromvs chrvsogasler. 0608: 197

caurinus. IchthvoniYs. 1009: 541

caurinus, Mungos, 1032: 182

caurinus. Nolorvctes. 08S1: 111

caurinus, Reilhrodon. 0878: 473

caurinus. Scotozous dormeri. 0766: 33

caurinus. Steaiotnvs, 0675: 271

caurinus. Uromys, W?>5: 112

caurinus. Zaedyus picliiy. 1078: 526

cavendishii. Madoqua, 0256: 1;0257: 278

cayennae. Dasyprocta lucifer. 0410: 492

cayllomae. Akodon pukhernmiLS, 0311: 185

caymanum. Myoprocla pralti. 1045: 638

cearanus. Rhipidomvs. 0638: 501

cecilii, Peromyscus. 0409: 486

celaeno. Nyctimene. 0942: 262; 0958: 724

Celaenomys, 0263: 390

celalus. Micromys geisha, 0496: 359

centralis, Arctomys. 0596: 260

centralis, Atherura. 0173: 89

centralis. Ccnlronycterts, 0699: 638

centralis. Coendou. 0428: 5; 0430: 240

centralis. Diphylla, 0406: 378

centralis, Echmomys. 0208: 312

centralis, EUgmodontia griseoflavus, 0359: 240

centralis, Jaculus jaculus. 0906: 11

centralis. Lepus capensis. 0421: 344

centralis. Protnops. 0764: 62

centralis, Saccoplervx bilineata. 0441: 251

centralis, Smmthopsis crassicaudata. 0390: 492

centralis. Sorex. 0670: 758

centralis, Urotrichus talpoides. 0574: 50

centricola. Dolichotis magellamcus. 0360: 242

centricola, Sciurus stangen. 0524: 295, 297

ceramicus, Stenomys, 0888: 425

cerastes. Molossus, 0340: 437, 440

cervinus. Melornys robustus, 0286: 23; 0291: 113

chacarius. Holocfulus. 0531: 446

chadensis, Lepus. 0540: 384

chadensis. Xerus ervthropiis, 0474: 387

Chakomys. 0800: 337, 338

chapadae. Sylvilagus minensis. 0430: 241

chapmani. Orvzomvs. 0244: 179

charon. Meriones, 0853: 269

cheesmam, Gerbillus. 0864: 748

cheesmani, Lepus otnanensis, 0933: 28

cheesrnani, Tachyorycies, 1074: 302

Chelemys, 0417: 242

Chelemyscus. 1021: 585

cherriei. Echimys, 0277: 381

chihliensis, Rattus confucianus. 0817: 199

<r/i/W/. Orv2omy5. 0196: 59

Chilomys. 0218: 501

chimbanus. Sylvilagus andinus, 0705: 212

Chinchillula. 0253: 280

chinensis, Microtus, 0096: 117

chinensis. Miniopterus schreibersi. 0585: 638

chinensis, Ochotona roylei. 0669: 728

ihintalis, Dremomvs pernyi. 0785: 394

chirtquinus, Eptesicus. 0876: 362

chinquiniLs. Proechimys centralis. 0283: 220

Chiromyscus, 1027: 503

chiropus. Mas. (X)91 : 884; 0121 : 935, pi. 11. figs. 4-7

Chiruromys. (K)59: 237

chisai. Crocidura dsi-nezumi. 0496; 340

chloe. Marmosa. 0549: 167

Choeromys, (»949: 390

Choeroniscus, 1072: 122. 123

chorensis. Conepatus. 0350: 126

Oiorrrwiyj. 0792: 238

christyi. Deomys. 0765: 150

christyi. Mylomys, 0824: 362

Chroemys, 08tM): 337. 339

Chrotogale. 0678: 17; 0688: 499

Chrotomys. 0197; 161

chrysaeolus, Echimys. 0249: 244

chrysillus. Amblysomus, 0483: 261, pi. 16. tigs 2a-b

chrysippus. Eunisciurus carruthersi. 0971: 522

Cinderella. Crocidura. 0660: 119

Cinderella, Cynictis bradfieldi. 1065: 375

Cinderella, Marmosa elegans, 0375: 159, 161

cinerea. Abrocoma, 0860: 132

cinereus. Anomalurus. 0176: 188

90

J. E. HILL

cinereiLs, Arvicanthis pumilio, 0434: 5; 0449: 179

cinereus. Eupetaurus. 0060: 258. pi. 22

cinereus. Hesperomys iRhipidomys). 0015: 108, pi. 4

Cistugo, 0693: 205

cisturiLs, Syclinomiis. 0425: 502

citeila. Marmosa, 0681: 409

cilrinelltLS, Saimiri oerstedi, 0441: 250

citrimis. Anomalunts beecrofti, 0792: 236

ciarissa. Titpaia. 0820: 2(K)

clarkei. Cervicapra, 0089: 304; 0093: 207. pis. 21. 22

darkei. Petaurista. 0960: 396

clarkei. Tamiops. 0875: 304

claudi, Cephalophus, 0540: 386

claudi. Rhynchocyon. 0540: 370

clavium, Emballonura meeki. 0747: 137

cliftoni. Arctomys. 0370: 444

cUvorum. Eiephantulus deserti, 0723: 588

clivorum, Ociodon degiL-i, 1062: 556

ciivosus. Taierillus. 0981: 258

Cloeous. 0331: 28

clunii4s. Zaglossus harioni. 0956: 129

Clyomys. 0796: 300

cocalLs. Sciurns. 0297: 138

coccygis. Phalanger. 0950: 673

cockerelli. Callosciurus. 1081: 100

coecata. Tadarida teniotis, 0960: 392

coelestis. Mus. 0206: 248

Coelomys, 0750:414

coenorum. Ratios, 0942: 262; 0958: 727

coenosa, Golimda elHoli, 0992: 376

coenosus, Akodon puer, 0831: 189

coenosits. Elhbius. 0680: 402

coenosus, Heliosciur us multicolor. 0605: 104

coenosus. Otomys irroraius, 0842: 208

coibae. Dasyprocla. 0394: 136

coibensis, Ahuatta palliata. 0394: 135

colias, Scolophilus nigriia. 0440: 207

collega. Marmosa, 0886: 281

co//em. Mus. 0458: 599

collinus. Akodon iniscatus. 0851: 206

collini4s, Cheliones hurrianae, 0863: 726

collinus. Delomys dorsalis, 0816: 197

collimts, Pipistrellus papuanus. 0890: 533

collinus, Praomys, 1019: 237

colliniLS, Rhipidomys. 1020: 578

colombiae. Histiotus, 0783: 274

colombianus, Proechimys centralis. 0740; 60

Colomys. 0540: 379

coloniae. Caracal caracal. 1032: 181

colonicus. Nyciinomus plicatus, 0528: 537

coloniciL'i. Raphiceros sfuirpei, 0529: 583

CY>/u(/r^. OfMomw. 0883: 119

colurnus, MicrotiLs (Eoihenomys) melanogaster,

0646: 209
comw. Ga/ea. 0860: 134
cometes. Thamnomys. 0584: 549
cona/uA. /?am«. 0988: 159

concinniLS, DendromiLS (Poemys). 1040; 299

concinniis, Sciurus. 0063: 407

concisa. Mellivora, 0540: 376

congicus, Choeromys harrisoni, 0949: 390

congicus, Chrysochloris, 0616: 84

congictis, Scutisorex, 0773: 470

congicus, Talerdlus, 0765: 147

constantiae. Marmosa, 0428: 5; 0430: 243

consularis. Mfenetesf bferdmoreij, 0739: 24. 25

conlinenlis. Phodotes tumidirostris. 0655: 513

continentis. Ptilocercus lowi. 0628: 426

conlinenlis. Symphalangus syndactyliLs. 0579: 301

conlumax, Callosciurus fiavimanus, 1059:52

coolidgei, Peromyscus leucopus. 0243: 45

coppingeri, Hesperomys iCalomys), (KX)9: 4. figs. 1-2

cor. Emballonura. 0747: 139

coracius. Rallus assimilis, 0965: 173

coraginis. Golunda ellioti, 0992: 375

cordovensis. Hesperomys, 0779: 184

coreae. Apodemus agrarius. 0573: 8

coreae, Crocidura (Cfrociduraj). 0536: 860

coreana, Mogera wogera, 0555: 463

coreanus. Lepus sinensis. 0101: 146

corinnae, Pseudochirus, 0224; 142; 0234: 619, pi. 2

coronalus, Pseudochirus albertisi, 0224: 144

corriae, Amhlysomus. 0477: 5; 0483; 267. pi. 16. figs.

3a-c; 0489: 57
cortensis, Hesperomys musculinus. 0873: 190
Corvira. 0769: 310
cottoni, Ourehui, 0562: 178
couesi. Hesperomys. 0138: 403
coxi, Pipistrellus, 0864: 747
crassa. Carponycleris. 0192: 163
crassulus, Pipistrellus, 0440: 206
cra.ssus. Lagoslomiis, 0618: 246
Crateromys. 0197: 163
crawshayi. Procavia (Oendrohyrax), 0287: 25; 0292:

178
creaghi. Rhinolophus. 0206: 244
rr(rc«"A(M.v. 0811:456
crossei, Crocidura iCr.). 0195: 53
Crossogale. 0899: 243; 0935: 113
Cros.somys. 0548: 70

crolalis. Callosciurus erylhraeus. 0776: 225. 239
cruceri. Akodon pulcherrimus. 0311: 186
crucialis. Meiachirus opossum. 0976: 604
cruciger. Semnopithecus. 0119: 476
crucina. Felis pajeros, 0336: 247
rrwrn/Ji. Diomys. 0820: 204
C>«nomy.v. 0220: 1; 0263: 393
culex. Pipistrellus, 0654: 458
cH/morwm. Mils. 0593: 790
culpaeola, Pseudalopex. 0726: 359
culluratus. RalULS. 0817: 198
cumananus. Rhipidomys venezueiae, 0293: 271
cumanicus, Lepus. 0233: 552
cunciator, Cricetomys gambianus, 0581; 171

M. R. O. THOMAS

91

cunealis. Pelriimys. 1(140: 3(17

cuninghamei, Crocidttra. 0461: 237, 240

cuninghamei, Mylomys, 0523: 225

cuppedius, Stcatomys, 0880: 318

cupreolus, Myotis hocagel. 0447: 407

cupreiis, Pseudochirus, 0224: 145

cuprosa, Kerivoula, 0691: 41

currentium, Molossiis ohscurus, 0340: 438

currentium, Reithrodott typicus, 0878: 475

curryi, Oryclolagus crassicaudariis. 0382: 245; 0483:

pi. 16, fig. 5
ctinala. Bandicola savilei. 1084: 205
ctiscinits, Cebiis flavescens. 0311: 179
citscinus, Sciurus aestuans. 0271: 40
cttsctis. Viscaccia. 0541: 443
custos. Microtus (Anwliomys). 0683: 517
Cyclops, PeronymiLs, 1007: 531
Cynomops. 0873: 189
cypseliniis, Diaemus voungi, 1084: 288
Cyromys. 0640: 507
cyslops, Rhtnopoma, 0412: 496
Cvttarops. 1)702: 134

dahbenei. Eiimops, 0731: 480

dabhenei. Eimeomys. 0859: 127

Dacnomys. 0788: 404

dactytiniis. CaUosciurus flavimantis. 1059: 52

Dactylimax. (1643: 610

daedahis. Nyctopliilus, 0758: 498

daemon, Procavia. 0617: 199

daemon, Tachyoryctes, 0614: 545

daemonellus, Dasyurus, 0466: 402

dii/((-ni. Mi«. 0113: 181

daman-nsis, Scolophihis, 0503: 175

dammermam, Pseudochirus. 0942: 264; 0958: 736

dammermam, Ratlus, 0899: 247; 0935: 110

dandoU-na. Rautfu macroura, 0766: 36

daphaenodon, Sorex, 0551: 407

daphne. Thomasomvs, 0809: 2; 0892: 235, pi. 15,

fig. 1
darfurea, Crocidura. 0981: 251
darlingi. Georychus, 02(K): 239
darimouihi. Otomys. 0519: 141
darwint. Dusicyon. 0726: 352
daucinus. Heliosciurus undulatus. 0605: 101
d«i7(//, Rhizomys. 0647: 5; 0649: 179
davisnni. Promops. 0913: 139
davisom. Sciuropterus. 0031: 84; 0032: 74
davisoni. Scmropu-rus. A13: 2 (nomen nudum)
deceplor. Hypsimys. 0927: 613
decoratus.MjenelesI h/erdmoreil. 0739: 24
deeumanm. Echimys. 0276: 282
degem, Oiomys. 0395: 311
delacouri. Hapalomys. 1059: 55
delamerci. Macroscehdes. 0333: 155, foDtnolc
delator. Oxymclerus. 0410: 489
deleclorum. Epimys, 0635: 430

Delomys. 0816: 196

Dellamys, 0815: 98

dellHola, Oryzomys. 0815: 96

dellicus. Eumops. 0995: 341

demerarae, Marmosa ctnerea. 0484: 313

demissa. Galea holiviensis. 0930: 623

demisstt. Tupaia ferrugmea. 0451: 723

demonstrator. Nyctinomus. 0425: 504

denniae. Mus. 0519: 144

<;«!». Cercopithecus. 0538: 1:0545: 2, pi. 1

dcn/i. Otomys. 0519: 142

(fcvir/. Rhinolophiis. 0466: 386

Deamys. 0058: 130

Depanycleris. 0886: 271

Dephomys. 1031: 177

deserii. Leggada. 0616: 90

deserti. Macroscehdes rozeli. 0333: 155, footnote

deserii. Pipistrellus. 0367: 4

Desmonys. 0619: 284

dichrura. Tatera. 0765: 147

dictator, Arctonyx, 0628: 424

dimidiatus, Nectomys, 0478: 586

diniinutus. Isomys purnilio. 0122: 551

dirnissus. Eptesicus. 0795: 1

f/i>if///i, MyoHs, 0391: 493

Diomys, 0820: 203

Diplogale. 0678: 18; 0688: 499

discolor. Thamnomys. 0619: 283

dissonus. Protoxerus slangeri. 0973: 527

diversus. Funamhulus insignis. 0265: 248

dtvtnorum. Otomys. 0634: 311

dobsoni. Microgale. 0024: 337

dobsoni. Rhinolophus. 0153: 156, footnote

dodsoni. Dipodilhis. 0367: 7

doggetli. Poecilogale. 0444: 22; 0457: 460

<io/ora. .4A:odon, 0799: 334

dolosus. Heliosciurus undulatus. 0605: 1(X)

domina. Marmosa. 0886: 280

dominalor. Raltiis. 0899: 244

domorum. Eligmodontia. 0350: 132

doriac Chiroderma. (KI90: 881

(/oriae, Phascogale. 0035: 208

dor/.v, OvvmvffcrHi. 0803: 478

dorothea. Marmosa. 0655: 516

dorreae. Lagorchestes hirsutus. 0534: 775

dorsalis. Ctenomys, 0301: 385

donafc. Hylomys suillus, 0063: 407; 0(.)73: 229

dorsalis. Perorycles. 0942: 264; 0958: 737

dorsalis, Vampyrops, 0293: 275

draconilla. Nyctimene, 0958: 725

dracula. Crocidura. 0686: 686

Dromiciops. 0166: 186

Drosornys. 0532: 199 (nomen novum for Ijmrtomys.

0505: 325)
dryas. Distoechurus pennatus, 0890: 537
dryas. Marmosa. 0262: 456
dryas, Oryzomys. 0266: 267

92

dryas. Pogonomys, l)45K: 6U0

dry as, Rhipidomys, 0293: 271

drvas, Thamnomys. 0537: 123

Dryomys, 0496: 34K

ducatoris. Phalanger orientalis, 0953; 680

ducilla. EUgmodonua. 0311: 182

f/H(7or. Uromys, 071K: 213

(iHn«i. /lm(d«f/i/.v. 040S: 33: 0420: 297

dunni. Gerbilhis {GerbiUusj. 0452: 101

dunni. Heterocephalus, 0605: 109

ditrangi. Sc turns aherti. 0126: 50

dyacorum. Herpestes brachvurus. 0911: 134. 135

dvacorum. Hipposideros. 0363: 271

Dyromys. 0556: 406 (nomcn nt^vum for Dryomvs.

0496: 348)
dzunganae. AUaciaga elater. (kiSO; 4tJ6

eaioni. GerbHUis. 0367: 6

eboreus. Melomvs cervinipes, 1004: 297

ebnosus. Neoiomys. 0169: 348

frfa.v. 4"(/momv5. 035 1:24; 0354: 1 16. pi. 9. figs. 1-4

6
edax. Thrmacodits. 0796: 299
edithae. Graomys. 0854: 495:
edithae. Trogoplents. 0978: 658
edilus. Oenomys bacchanie. 0621: 509
edusa, Psammomys vexdlaris. 1025: 199
edwardsi. Mils, 0020: 587. pi. 44
edwardsii. Hesperomys (Notiomys), 0088: 24. pi. 3

fig. I. pi. 8, fig. 1
ega. Scleronycteris. 0697: 405
egeria. Callicehus, 0576: 89
egeria, Glauconycleris. 0704: 144
egeria, Malacolhrix, ItWO: 301
electus, Paraxerus ochraceus, 0605: 106
elegans, Heliusciurus multUolt>r. 0605: 103
elegans, Leptomvs. 0234: 610

elegans. Saccoslomus. 0219: 1; 0221: 431; 0242: 937
eleganlulus. Phylhlis. 0703: 139
Elephanlulus. 0515; 10; 0529: 577
eleusis. MicroHis (Eothenomys) melanogasler i)()(r6:

50; 0679: 139
eleusis. Thomasomys ischyrids. 1043:614
elgonis. Cricetomys gartibianus. t)617: 198
elgonis, Thamnomys surdasler. 0619: 282
emerila, Felis pardinoides, 0692: 44
emeritus, Thomasomys taniger. 0803; 479
fmi//ac. Caliicebus. 0658: 606
fm/7/ae. /■>/«. 0726: 348
emdiae. Hapale. 0886: 269
emiliae. I.onchothrix, 0882: 114
emdiae. Marmosa. 06(X): 379
emdiae. Pcramvs. (1671: 89
emdiae. Pelaurdlus. 0560: 8
emdiantLS, Ctenomys, 1055: 637
(•mm/. Dendrohyrax. (M)53: 440; 0054: 15. pi. 2
emm/. Dendrohyrax. A 18: 1 (nomcn nudum)

cm/>i/. GerbdUis. (K)98: 78

emirita. Lulra, 0568; 390

emissus. Heliosciurus rufobraehium. 0971; 520

emuhus. Conepatus suffocans. 1063:651

Eomops. 0492: 572

EptxeriLs. 0603: 469, 472

epsdanus. Myospalax. 0673: 94

equalons. RIarina. 0681: 409:

equatoris. Rhipidomys. 0769: 312

esmeraldum. Nectomys, 0336: 250

c.vav. Hvdromvs, 0505; 324

EupelauriLs. (H)60: 257

euphralica. Alacfaga. 0013; 15

Euxerus. 0603: 469, 473

cvd, Cyclopes didactylus. 0383: 250

cvfl. Microlus {Caromysf. 0647: 4; t)649: 175

era. Peromyscus. 0243: 44

^vaf. Reithrodon. 1063: 652

everesti. Phaiomys. 0937: 182

(•vert-m. HW/ca?. 0184: 331

evereni. .Sciuropierus. 0179: 27

everelti. Sciurtis. (XJ86: 71

evereni. Semnopithecus, 0123: 582, pi. 41

evereni. Tupaia, 0103: 250

excelsior. Epimys, 0647: 4; 0649: 170

c.t/7t5. Dasyurus halhtcatus. 0595: 152

exoneranis. Dendromus (Poemys). 0839; 59

fagani. Lepus. 0395: 315

falabae. Scoloecus, 0771: 447

/fl//fl.x. Cnmomyj. 0220: 1; 0263; 394, pi. 33. fig. 1.

pi. 35, figs. 5-6
/fl//fl;c. Tatcra. 0444: 22; 0457: 461
famatina. Abrocomu. 0887: 419
famalinae. Lagidium. 0887: 421
famuUis. Gerbillus (" Hendacapleura" ), 0193: 551
faroulti. Pachyuromys duprasi. (W79: 313
faustus. Perodicticus. 0635: 426
favonicus. Funambuliis palmarum. 0766: 38, 39
favonicus, Jaculus jacidiLs. 0713: 483
favonicus, Myttlis beclisleini. 0522: 220
/('at'. CVnw//w. 0068; 95; 0069: 92; 0121; 945. pi, 10
/cat'. Cervulus. A22: 1 (nomcn nudum)
/cac. Epimvs mackenziei. (1788; 410, 412
feae. Harpiocephalus. CKWl: 884; 0121: 926
fecundus. tiesperomvs. 1039: 321
federatus. Mvolvi peyloni. 0795: 3
feliceus, Ranus, 0888: 423
felicia, Dasyprocta. 0821: 310
fellii. Rauifa. i)17f): 226
ferculinus. Miis. 0390: 491
ferghanae. Putorius ermineus. 0188; 452
fergussoni. Apodemus. 0647: 4; (►649: 172
ferrugineus. Deomys. {M)58: 130. pi. 5. tigs 1-10
ferrugineus. Oryzomvs. 0169: 352
fervidiLs. Philander laniger. 0721: 358. 359
jervidiL\. Rhipidomys venezuelae. 0450: 34

M. R. O. THOMAS

93

fesrimi. Cavia Isclniitii. 1(J70: hll4

fidelis. r.plesuus. 0X76: 366

jiammarum. Reilhrodon cunicuhndes, 0697: 41 1

ftummifer, Sciurus, 0450: 33

flavescens. Dasyprocta rubrata. 0266: 274

flaviceps. Hapale. 0417: 240

flavicans, Orvzomys, 0169: 351

flavnlior. Phyllotis holiviemis. 0383: 248

fiiividttla. Crocidura flavescens. 0483: 261

flavidits. Acomys. 0820: 205

fiavimts, Funisciurus congicus, U447: 411

flora. Kerivoida. 11730: 441

flormm. Murma, 0582: 371

flowen. Gerbillus. 0857: 559

fochi. Ctemimys. 0849: 117

fodax. Clenomys. (1618: 243

fontanus. Myospalax. 0673: 93

forhesi, Chiriiromys. 0059: 238, 239. figs. 1-2

forhesi. Chiriiromys. A19: 2 (nomen nudum)

forbesi. Pseudocheirus. (1040: 146

formosits. Lepus. 0569: 449

Fornarma. 0432: 336

forresli. Mm, 0514: 6; 0528: 538, pi. 37, fig. 1

forresti. Ocholona. 11978: 662

forresti. Rupesles. 0960: 398, 399

forresti. Tamiops rmiritimtts, 0875: 305

fors, Leggada. (1614: 548; 0621: 506

foriior. Olomys lypus. 0525; 302

fortis. Dasyiirits geojfroyi, 0527: 476

fossa. Reilhrodon. 0276: 280

fossor. Geoxus. 0851: 208

fosteri. Molossiis. 0340: 437. 438

fosleri. Monodelphis. 1010: 586

fosleri. Thrkhomys. (1399: 227

fouriei. Pipistrellus. 1040: 288

foxi, Dasymys. 0685: 685

foxi. Georychus. 0654: 462

foxi. Rhinolophiis. 0708: 314

foxi, Uranomys, 0675: 273

francei, Akodon. 0590: 497

francescae. Cercopithecits. 0381: 243

/ra(cr, CVfnomys. 0359: 228

fraler, F.votomys. 0569: 448

frater, Pelomvs. 0447: 415

fralerculum, Uromys. 0888: 428

fralercuhis. Gerbillus {GerhiUiscus}. 0260; 392

fralerculiis. Miniopterus. 0518; 162

fraterculus. Sciurus, 0174; 669

fralerniLs. Thomasomys. 1070: 602

fralrorum. Mus. (1206: 246

frelensis. Raiiifu melanopepla. 0613: 535

fretensLs. Taphozous melanopogon, 0795: 5

/ridu. Hesperomys. 11809; 1 ; 0892; 230, pi. 14, fig. 3

/rrwH. Bubirussa bahirussa, 0872; 187

fryanus. Callosciurus sladeni. 0776; 225, 232

fulgens. Oryzomys. 0138: 403

fulgens. Uromys. 0888; 426

lulnunans. Nvclinomus. 0425; 501

fulminaUts. Sciurus igniventris. 1045: 637

fulvidma. Fetis affims. 1088; 834

fulvulior. Herpestes ochraceus. 0452: 97

fulvior. Xenix microdon, 0474: 387, 389

fiilvnenler. Rhipidomys. 0208; 304

fiilvimis. Neclomys. 0218; 499

ftilvus. ChfilonycterisI davyi. 01 18: 410

fiirnatiis. Cricetulus griseiis. 0612: 503

fiimeolus. Sorex wardi. 0666; 49; 0679; 132

fiimeiis. Akodon. 0350; 137

fumidus. Soriculiis. 0706; 216

ftimosa. Crocidura. 0461: 236, 238

fiimosiis. Chelemys vestitus. 1063: 654

funiosils. Clenomys. 0887: 420

fumosus. Mystromys albicaudutiis. 0479: 137

/ura.v, Flmbalhmura. 0652: 384; 0737; 318

/Hra,v, CrKon, 0549: 162

fuscata. Marmosa, 0208: 313

fuscaliLs. Dasvplerus ega. 0336: 246

fuscaltis. Pipislrellia kiihlii, 033 1 : 34

fusciceps. FMobiiis. 0596: 265

fusciruis. Akodon, 0218: 496

fuseipes. Macroscelides, 0148: 68

fuscipes. Pipistrellus, 0708; 315

fuscosa, Crocidura doriana, 0716: 90

fusculus, Sciurus (Microsciuriis) similis. 0639: 503

fuscus. Mastacomys. (X)19; 413, figs. 1-3

gabriellae, Hylobales, 0606: 112

gadovii, Peromyscus leucurus. 0409: 484

gairdneri, Arctictis. 0781: 270

ga/ra/a. Hystrix. 0129: 230

Galenomys. (1775; 143

Galeoplerus. 05(>4: 254

Galeriscus, 0164; 522

gallariim. Coleura, 0762: 576, 577

gallarum. Galago, 0331; 27

gallarum, Leggada bella, 0616: 88

gambiana, Tatera, 0635: 428

gambitmiis, Epimys. 0660: 122

garganttia, Echymipera, 0730; 443; 0737; 323

garleppi. Phyllotis (?}. 0253; 279

garleppii, Nectomys. 0271: 41

garorium. Dremomys lokriah, 0945: 430

garoniim. Rattits listen. 0933; 27

gaiicho. Conepatus proteus. 1066; 203

gazeltae. Stealomys. 0981: 265

gazeliae. Tamiscus emini. 0827: 34

gazellae. Thamnomys macmillani. 0619; 282

geisha. Microtiis. 0476: 491

genoyensuirn. Platalina. 1072: 121. 123

gentiliilus. Mus. 0855:421

georgianus. Taphozous australis, 0766: 62

Geoxus, 0851: 207,209

gerbillus. Phyllotis. 0281; 15i

Gerhilliscus. 0219; 1; 0221; 4.33; 0242; 935

94

J. E. HILL

^ermana. Marmosa, 0435: 143

gerrardi, Nundinia, 0412: 205

gesln. Mus. 0234: 611

gibsoni, Conepuuts,. 0618: 571

gihsoni. Sylvilagiis brasUiensis. 0831: 192

giliacus, Micromys speciostts. 0551: 411

gilliesi. Scaptochirits, 0622: 350

glaucinivi, Akodon, 0849: 116

glaucinus. Sciunis pusilhts, 0736: 575

glauiula. Felis. 0417: 235

glauais. Arlibeus. 0134: 336, pi. 29, figs. 7-9

glattctts. Pseudor7iys (Gyomys). 0642: 609

glauerli. Ratius. 1051: 308

Glaucomys. 0560: 5

Gliriscus. 1019: 232

gliroides. Dromiciops. 0166: 187

Glirnma. 0674: 239

Glinilm. 0496: 347

ghveri, Callosciurus castanenventris, 0901: 502

gloved. Oclunona. 0938: 19(1

Glyphonyaeris. 0208: 301

Glypholes. 0265: 250

godmani, Chaemnycteris. 04t)0: 288

gudmani. Pelrogale. 0966: 13:0979: 177

godmani, Phascogale. 0965: 174

goeldii. Cailimico. 0726: 345

goWAV. Wicia.5, 0459: 189

goMlii]. Oryzomys. 0218: 494

gofWii, Proechimys. 0478: 587

goeldv, Oryzomys, 0218: 494 (misprint for goeldii)

golialh. Crocidura. 0503: 177

goodfellowi, Acanthoglossus, 0557: 498

goodfellowi, Ctenomys, 0894: 136

goodfellowi, Dendrolagiis, 0587: 450

goodfellowi. Rhipidomys. 0293: 270

gordoni. Jaculus. 0408: 33; 0420: 299

gorgon, Bradypits. 1036: 309

goslingi. Colomys. 0540: 380

goslingi. Ourebia. 0540: 387

goslingi. Procavia. 0471: 82

go.v.5C(. Akodon. 0887: 418

gracilior. Vespertilio capensis. 0483: 257

Srarifc, Gerhillus. (K198: 77

grao/iv, Nasillus. 0666: 49:0679: 130

gracilis. Oryzomys. 0169: 358

gAflo/iv. Thomasomys. 0809: 2:0892: 234, pi. 14, fig, 5

gracilis. Tupaia, 0141: 53

gracifa. Uromys. 0505: 328

gracillimus, Sorex minutus, 055 1 : 408

Grammomys, 0765: 150

grandis. Geomys, 0146: 270

grandu. Herpestes. 0080: 622, pi. 62, figs. 1-5

grandis. Nectomys. 0218: 498

grandis. Pleropus. 0041 : 147; 0044: 320, fig. 1 , pi. 25;

0066: 470
grant/, Galago. 0550: 286
granii, l.epus capensis, 0434: 6; 0449: 182

granH. Syhisorex. 0537: 118

gran». Taphozous. 0663: 378:0737: 319

granm, fla/omys, 0197: 162; 0263: 405, pi. 33, fig. 2,

pi. 36, fig. 5
graniii. Genella. 0389: 487
grantii. Ot(tmys unisutcatits. 0386: 312
Graomys. 0775: 141
grafa. Leggada. 0621: 507
,?ra(H/a. Pachyiira. 0535: 781
gregorianivi. .Aulacodus. 0150: 202
grenadae. Marmosa. 0655: 514
griselda. Arx'icanthis dorsalis. 0447: 414
griselda. Blarinella. 0696: 4(H)
griselda. Dremomys pernyi. 0785: 392
griselda. h'elis ocreala. 1032: 180
grisonax. Mangos mungo. 1040: 294
Grypomys. 0656: 999
guairae. Proechimys. 0322: 27
gualei'iilae. Olotylomys. 0604: 32; 0610: 669
guayanas. Philander laniger. 0276: 286
guayanus. Sciurus stramineits. 0281: 150
guentheri. Madoqua. 0159: 324. figs. 1-2
guentheri, Madoqua, A40: 1 (nomcn nudum)
guentheri. Trichys. (K)73: 235
guianae, Cavia porcellus. 0332: 152
guianae. Neacomvs. 0484: 310
guianae. Holochilus. 0332: 149
guianae, Loncheres. (M)62: 326
guianae. Oecomys. 063 1 : 1 87
guineae. Talera. 0623: 353
gujerati. Golunda ellioli. 0992: 374
gularis. Proechimys. 0661: 253
gHn«/, Millardia meltada. 0820: 202
Gunomys. 0553: 203
gurkha. Apudemus. 1006: 888
guri/ia, Leggadilla. 0744: 2(KI
Guy/a, 0820: 201
gyas, Talerdlus. 0840: 150
gymnesicus. Elioniys, 041 1: 494
gymnolis. Peromyscus, 0169: 365
gymnura, Saccopteryx. 0318: 367
gymnurus, Echirnys, 0233; 550
Gyomy.s, 0641: 607
gyrator, Pseudochirus canescens, 0466: 401

hackelli, Pelrogale lateralis. 0487: 425
Hadromys. 0656: 999
haedinits. Taphozous perforatus. 0766: 62
Hacromys. 0646: 207
haggardi. Neotragus. 0176: 187
haggardi. Phylloits. 0266: 270
hahni. Suricata suricatta. 1065: 376
/wig;. fVfiomy.v. 0851: 210
hairtana. Mogera. 0629: 535
hainana. Pagttma larvata, 0599: 377
hainanus. Hvlohates. OHIO: 145. 146
hainanus, Rucervus plalyceros. 0829: 364

M. R. O. THOMAS

95

halli. Notodelphys. 0912: 137

hallucalis. Evolomys nageh. 1)520: 221

Immua. Ochouma (Ogolona). 0680; 407

hamiltoni, S/urictitaj slurictittaj. 0474; 134

hantilloni. Taphoztnts, OSfiy; 142

hammondi. Nectomvs, 0724; 570

hamptoni. Muslelii. (NOl; 500

Hciplomys. 0798; 304

hardvi. Hfliosciurus rufttbritchtum, 0971; 519

harin^toni, Sciurus. 04S5; 314

Imrpax. Cynopierus (Niadius). 0602; 439; 0615; 108

Hurpiola. 0768; 309

Harpvumycleris, 0206: 243

hcirringtont, Pelomvs, 0395: 313

harringtoni. Talera. 0525: 303

liarrisoni. Hylarnus. 0520: 149

harrisom, Kevivouta. 0310: 802. footnote

harrisoni, Thryononiys, 0540: 384

harierti. Lepus, 0416: 301

harterti, Massoutit'ra. 0707: 31

harlerli. Vulpes pallida, 0906: 4

luini. Mas. 0270; 774

hard. Mas, A40; 4 (nomen nudum)

hand. Ardheiis. 0117:409

harveyi. Cfphalaphtis, 0125; 48

harwoodi. Gerbdlus (Dipoddhi.s). 0339; 275, footnote

hasulis. Callosciurus epomophorus. 0993: 377

hauxsa. Fells. 0906: 2

haiissa. Leggada, 0880: 319

hawkeri. Lepus. 0339; 277

hawkeri, Snrex. 0496: 339

haywoodi. Trageluphus. 0480: 9; 0490: 181

helvescens. Cercopilhecus pygerylhriis. 1040: 286

hendeei. Lagothnx (Oreonax). 1056: 156; 1057: 362

hendeei. Proechtmvs. 1047: 162

hendersoni. Rhvtichocyon, 0388: 403

/l(7isc/;. nidflphys (Peramys), (K157; 158

herberd. Petrogale. 1044: 626

hercules. Malhmys. 0682: 92

herero, Lepus caperisis. 1040: 308

herero. Scotophilus nigrlla. 0503: 174

AfrfTO. Thallomys. 1040: 303

hermard. Mvods. 0969: 252

hihemicus. Pulorim. 0182: 374; 0183: 125

lii/Ja. Dipoddhis. 0839: 62

/ii'Wu, Pmechimys. 1(K17; 534

hddegardeae. Crocidura, 0461; 237. 240

hildegardeae. Mus. 0357; 219

hddegardeae. Myolis, 0440; 209

hddegardeae. Taphoznus, 0605; 98

Ai7/jcr/. Phascugale. 0487; 427

himlakus. Trugoplerus, 0745; 231

/lindfi. Beamys. 0605; 107

/i/ni/o. Crocidura. 0461: 236. 237

/iinrfpi. Erinaceus. 0617: 193

hindei. Lophiomys iheanus. 0632: 223, 224

hindei. Lutra capensis. 0471; 78

/i/;i(/i-/, Madoqua kirku. 0380; 242

/imJn, MiK. 0357: 218

;»>i</rt, Nycdnotruis, 0440; 210

hindei. Scofoecus. 0317; 264

hingstord. Eptesicus. 0864; 745

hirdpes. PhyUolis. 0359: 225

hirtipes. Sndnthopsis. 0250; 3

;»/•(«/(/, Helogale. 0452; 97

/»r(m. /IcKrfon. 0201:370

hispida. Croiidura. 0712: 468

hoffnumsi. Calhcebus. 0576; 89

hoffmeyri. Antidortas angoletisis. 1040: 311

hokkaidi, Micromys geisha. 0496: 350

homericus, Acomys dimidiatus, 0989; 173

hondonis. Urotrichus talpoides, 0574; 50, 51

hopkttisoni. Talera. 0662: 375

hosei. Crocidura (Pachyura). 0137: 343

/losfi, Hemigale. 0103; 250; 0105; 222. pis. 18. 19,

figs 1-3
hosei. Sciuropterus. 0294: 275
hosei, Sciurus. 01 15; 215
;i(«f(. Semnopithecits. 0070; 159; 0073: 228
hotsoni. Allaclaga, 0871; 936
hotsoni. Calomyscus. 0871; 939
howelli, Dremomys pernyi, 0960: 400, 401
/iHei;f/i, M/«. IK)02: 13

huegeli. Mus. AOl : unpagin;itcd (nomen nudum)
/iHg/ii, Erinaceus. 0592; 44; 0594; 966
/i»m«, /W«,v. (K)31; 84; 0032; 63
hitmii. Mus. A13; 2 (nomen nudum)
humilior. Oryzomys dryas, 0266; 268
humeri. Akodon arenicola, 0815; 97
hunlii. Conepalus, 0422; 461
hurcmax, GrisoneUa, 0916; 213
Hvhomys. 0616: 85
Hylarnus. 0520; 149
Hylenomys, 1022: 667
Hylomyscus, 1031: 178
Hylonycleris. 0400: 286
Hylopeles. 0560: 5,6
Hyomys, 0427:4,0429; 198
Hypsimys. 0831: 190

/u. 0377; 163

iheanus, Lophiomys, 0632; 223, 224

iheanus. Papio iholh. 0124: 47

iheanus, Perodicdcus. 0619: 17; 0633; 536

iheanus. Tachyoryctes splendens. 0292; 179, tig.

Ichihyomys, 0132; 286; 0134: 337

(du. (>c-/o/>c.s didactylus, 0299: .■(02

/gni/er, Cephalophiis, 0405: 29; 0419; 226

igndus, Callicehus lorqiialiis, 1068; 287

iheringi. Didelphys (Peramys). 0057; 158

iheringi. Oxymycterus. 0208; 308

iheringi, Proechimys, 0661; 252

i/aciis. Microlus. 0676; 348

t/ex, Apodemiis, 0960; 404

96

J. E. HILl.

illulea. Abrolhrix. 1021: 582
illuleus. Hydromys esox. ()942: 264; 0958: 731
iltuteits, Lepiis oistolits, 0745: 233
imago. Aeihumys chrysophilus. 1065: 387
imarius, Callosciurus quinquestriants. 1046: 640
imhrertsis. Sfcoutntanesj t/rnalus. 0915: 772
imhulus, Meiachirus nudicaudalus, 0976: 605
imitator. Anisomys. 0427: 4; 0429: 200, pi. 23.

figs. la-c
imitator. CallosciuriLS. 1027: 502
imitator. Cehu.^. 0406: 376
imogene. Pharotis. 0742: 382
imperaior. Miis. (H)56: 157; (K)66: 489. pi. 22,

figs. 2-3
imus. Dremomys pernvi. 0960: 400, 402
inambarii, Akodon pulcherrimus. 03111: 185
inca. Chaeronycteris. 0697: 403
inca. Conepaliis, 0296: 499
inca. Eptesicus, 0876: 363
inca. Orolestes. 0809: 3; 0892: 244. pi. 15, fig. 5
inca. Oxymyctenis, 0299: 298
inca. Pseudalopex. 0726: 361
inca. Sylvilagus brasiliensis, 0705: 210
inca. Viscaccia. 0541: 442
incanens, Pseudochirus laniginosus. 0968: 249
incaniLf. Cricetuliis tnton, 0592: 45; 0594: 973
incaniis. Nyclicebus. 0931: 627
incaniis. Oryzomvs, 0169: 350
incamis. Pelauroides volans. 0968: 247
incarum. Hohchilus. 0892: 226. pi. 14. fig. 1
incarum. Lutra. 0568: 392
incarum, Vampyrops zarhinus, 0681: 408
inclamax. Alouatta. 0724: 567
inclusa. Tatera. 0581: 169
incoTLStans, Tamiops. 0875: 306
incullus, Arclonyx ohscurus. 0960: 395
incursor. Hermgalus derbianus. 0760: 613
indefessiis. Oryzomys, 0276: 280
mdus. Dipodiilus. 0871: 935
indula. I.eggada bella. 0616: 88
mdulus, Mesemhriomys argurus. 0595: 151
inepltis. Mils chrysophilus. 0584: 546
irtepiiis, Tachvglossus aculeatus. 0513: 2. 0527:

477
inez. Microtus, 0592: 45; 0594: 976
infiatus, Miniopterus. 0426: 634
infiuatus. Scotinus. UK)8: 540
infrahiteiLs. Mus. 0063: 409; 0073: 232
infraluteus, Perognalhus, 0139: 406
infusca. Saccopteryx, 0233: 546
infusca. Tax idea fax us. 0236: 1;0241: K99
infuscus. Metachirus nudicaudatus. 0976: 606
infuscus. Sylvisorex gemmi'us, 0765: 152
ingrami, Macropus ualabalus. 0593; 792. pi. 43
ingrami. Phascogale. 0514: 6; 0528: 541. pi. 37. fig.
ingrami. Sciurus. 0318: 366
iniscatus. Akodon. 0851; 205

Inomys. im\&. 197

mornatits, Chroemys, 0809: 2; 0892: 238. pi. 15.

fig- 3
inquinatus, Sciurus pryeri, 0567: 247
insignis, Bubalis jacksoni, 0443: 22; 0456: 455
insignis, Dendrornys. 0421: 341
inslans. Oryzomys. 0201: 368
inslans. Zelotomys. 0773: 480
insularn. Cercopilhecus preussi. 0617: 191
insularis. Nyclocleplcs. 0763: 58
insulans, Spalax monticola. 0823: 315
intectus. Oryzomys, 0919: 356
intensus, Xerus ruiilans. 0452: 100
intercastelhmus. Phalangcr orientalis. 0192: 165
inlerces.sor, Eutamias asiaticus. 0592: 44; 0594: 969
interior, Funisciiirus congicus. 0792: 236
investigator, NasiUus. 0960: 393
io. Balantiopteryx, 0441; 252
io. la, 0M7: 164
lomys. 0560: 1
lo. Rhogeessa. (U07: 382
irani. Microius. 0900: 580, 581
irene. Microius. 0647: 5; 0649: 173
irene. SoncuUis. 0666: 49; 0679: 132
Irene. Sylvisorex gemmeus, 0765: 151
Irenomys, 0851:201
irex. Dirias. 0886: 273
iris, Amblysomus. 0475: 23; 0483: 259; pi. 16. figs.

la-c
iris, Oxymycterus. 0311: 183
isaaci. Boocerciis euryceros. 0385: 309; 0387: 7; 0396:

319
isabella. Depanycieris. 0886: 271
isis. Meriones. 0853: 271
ituricus, Epimys Umgicaudatus, 0765: 149
ivori, Helogale. 0858: 31

jabouillei. Bandicota. 1059: 54
jacenlior. Oxymycterus paramensis, 1020:580
jacksoni. Bubidus. 0107: 386
jacksoni, Crocidura. 0461: 237, 238
jacksoni, Galeriscus, 0164: 522
jacksoni, Otomys, 0089: 304; (M)92: 184. pi. 15
jacksoni, Otomys, A26: 1 (nomcn nudum)
jacksom, Procavia, 0287: 25; 0292: 176. footnote
jacksoniae, Leggada, 0902: 596
jacobs(mi, Cheiromcles, 0997: 592
janetta. Bathyergus, 0434: 6; 0444: 180. pi, 6. fig. 2
fanetia, Marmosa, 1039: 327
lanetta, Paguma leucomystax. 1082: 101
janetta, Sciurus pygcrythriLS, 0744: 203
japoniae. Miniopterus schreibersi. 0496: 338
japonicus, Micromys minutus, 0496: 351
javuna, Kcrivoula, (KMI5: 472. fig.
javana, I.aria tnsignts, 0597: 19; 0607: 389
jayakan, Hemitragus. 0157: 365; 0163: 452. figs. 1-2.
pi. 31

M. R. O. THOMAS

97

jelskii. Acodon. 0169: 360

jenlinki. Cephalophus. 0110: 415. 417

jenunki. Cephalophus. A32: 2 (nomen nudum)

lemmki. Sciurus. 0()5I: 128; 0073: 230

jivaro, Nasua quichua, 0740: 58

jivaro. Philander lamger. 0721 : 358. 360

joanae, Talerona, 1040: 299

joarmia, Caviella australis, 0904: 446

joanniits, Octomys, 0917: 217

ioffrei. Nycialus. 0749: 225

Johannes. Microlus. 0626: 26: 0637: 637

johannis. Acomys. 0675: 272

johannis. Ctenomys colitdo, 0908: 523

johnstoni. Aepyceros melampus. 0122:553

johnstoni. Cephalophus. 0324: 45; 0325: 89

johnstoni. Graphiunis, 0242: 934

johnstoni. Graphiurus. A46: 2 (nomcn nudum)

johnstoni. Procavia. 0154: 142

jonesi. Leporittus, 0929: 618

jordani. Callithrix penicillata, 0459: 188

yorrfam, Dipodillus. 0839: 60

fucunda. Ehgmodontia hirtipes. 0860: 131

jucunda, Mazatna amerieana, 0715: 587

jucundus. Akodon. 0703: 140

jucundus. Cerdocyon thous. 0903: 382

judaica. Crocidura russida. 0850: 199

/Hde.v, /Vusua. 0740: 57

judex. Oxymycterus. 0609: 238

/w-yu- Perodicticus. 0623: 351

juralis. Sciurus pvrrhonotus. 1045: 636

yuns, Clenomvs. 0873: 194

luvencus. Sfciurus]. 0591 : 498

kalinowskii. Dasyprocta. 0227: 219

kalinowskii, Nyctinomus. 0134: 334. pi. 29. fig. 10

kalinowskii. Oryzomys. 0169: 349

Aanai. Mogera wogura. 0496: 361

kangeanus. Paradoxurus, 0624: 385

kashtchenkoi. Ellobius. 0680: 404

kalhleenae, Funamhulus. 0766: 37. 38

kalhleenae. Mdlardia. 0739: 29

/tempi. Dellamys. 0815: 98

kempi. Procavia hrucei. 0617: 2W1

kempi. Ruusetlus. 0614: 543

kilirnanus, Alelerix. 0833: 232

kinneari. Callosciurus erylhraeus, 0776: 226. 229

kiriwinae. Phalanger orientalis. 0211: 528

kilcheneri. Pipisirellwi. 0749: 229

fc/v'U, Dendromus insignis. 0794: 242

klagest. Sciurus griseogena, 074 ! : 240

i/<Mii, Acanlhion. 0774: 139

i/oMi. .Sr«'«omvs, 0717: 207. 0737: 320

*/»ssi. Ta/pu. 1090: 206

Armg/ir/, Clenomys. 0854: 498

koheae. Mogera wogura. 0476: 487

kummi, Georychus. 0657: 592

*ura, Thamnomys, 0540: 381

lacernata. Tupaut. 0613: 535

tavras. Akodon, 0831: 188

lacuslris. Talera. 0540: 378

lacuslris. XeriLs erythropus. 0474: 387. 388

laenatus. Coendou. 0406: 381

Laephotis. 0323: 460

laephotis, Histiolus. 0783: 275

laephotis. Tonatia. 0631: 184

lamia. Oryzomys. 0341: 528

lamia. Pogonomys. 0234: 615

laminatus. Otomys. 0475: 23; 0483: 267

Lamolomys. 0842: 204. 208

/umu/fl. Chodsigoa. 0696: 399

lanaceus, Myotis. 0871: 933 (cmcndmcnt. see

lanceus. Myotis)
lanarum. l^elornys. 0796: 297
lanalus. Macropus keysseri, 0950: 670
lanceus, Myotis. 0871: 933 (lapsus for lanaceus.

emended, sec Journal Bombay nal. Hist. Soc. 27:

24-25. insert)
laniger, Oryzomys, 0196: 59
lanosa. Murina. 0629: 534
lanosus. Melomys, 0942: 263; 0958: 729
lanosus, Oxymycterus. 0227: 218
lancjsus. Rousettus. 0519: 137
laomache. Dremomys rufigenis. 0897: 182
Laomys. 0598: 373

laotum. Melogale personata. 0939: 194
/flomm. Pithecus. 0897: 181
laotum. Sciuropterus phayrei, 0739: 28
laotum, Tupaia belangeri, 0725: 244
Lanscus, 0607: 389
larseni, Felis servalina, 0716: 91
larvartim, Chodsigoa, 0666: 49; 0679: 133
/fliia. Crocidura leucodon, 0508: 416 (emendment,

see lasius, Crocidura leucodon)
lasius, Crocidura leucodon, 0508: 416
/ai///, Funisciurus palliatus, 0524: 297
/a(ai(e/. /'rofavia. («99: 69
lalaslei, Procavia, A29: 2 (nomen nudum)
lateris, Heliosciurus multicolor, 0605: 102
laiiceps, Echimys, 0609: 240
laticeps, Lophuromys, 0540: 383
latifolium, Phyllostoma, 0332: 142
latouchei, Mogera wogura, 0555: 463
laumchei. Mus, 0225: 113
latouchei. Rhizomys. 0763: 59
lalouchei. Tadarida, 0874: 283
latrator, Procavia emini, 0619: 285
/a(rci. tfe-nomvi. 0828: 38

lalronum, Apodemus speciosus, 0666: 49; 0679: 137
laurenttus, Thrichomys, 0441: 254
/funi/iT. /^n<)(»wivi. 0500: 85. 86
leander, Chimmarogale, 0377: 165
leathemi, Smintlius, 0127: 184
/ec/id, Georychus, 0200: 241
/(•gaw. Lenothrix. 0501: 88

98

J. F. HIM

legattvi, Chiropodomys, 0646: 206

legalus. Oryzomys. 1020: 577

Leggadilla. 0727: 682

Leggadina. 0641:606

lena. Pelaurisla. 0558: 522

lenguarum. Akodon. 0266: 271

leniceps. Mesomys. 1053: 348

lenis. Kerivoula. 0788: 416

Lenomys. 0263: 409. footnote, pi. 36. fig. 1

Lenoxus. 0609: 236

lentulus, Ctenomys haigi, 085 1:211

leo. Rhmosciurus. 0602: 440. 0615: 121

teonardi. Pleromys (Hylopeles). 0901: 501

leonensis, Heiiosciurus rufohrachium. 0972: 523

leonis, Fttnisciunts pyrrhopits, 047 1 : 79

leonis. Nyctinomus, 0582: 373

lepcha, Tupaia helangeri. 0945: 428

lepkla. Didelphys (Micoiireus). (K)57: 158

lepidu. Seotoma, 0144; 235

lepidus, Hesperomys (Calomys) bimaculauis

var. 0023: 4.54, pi. 42, tig. 2, pi. 44, figs. 10-13
lepidus, Leuconoe. 0748: 171
lepidiis. Pogonomys, 0234: 614
Lepordhis. 0499: 83
Leplogale. 0835: 303, 306
lepliira. Talpa. 0012, 470
lelabae. Genetta. 0529: 578
leucanthiis. Gerbillits swalUts, 1065: 382
leucastra. Marmosa. 1070: 607
leucippe. Mko. 0940: 199
leucippiis. Phalanger, 0261: 6
leuconoe. Thallomys. 1040; 303
teiicura. Peragate. 0049: 397
letteurits. Caluromys trinitatis. 0450; 36
leitcurus, Euneomys (Auiiscomys}, 0860: 129,

footnote
leitcurus. Peromyscus. 0169: 364
levantis, Talpa caeca, 0508: 416
tevipes. Oryzomys. 0350: 129
levipes, Vromys. 0234: 617
lewlsi. Ctenomys. 1039: 323
lichiensis, Dremomys pernyi. 0960: 401. 403
I.Uhonycleris. 0196: 55
limae. Marmosa. 0806: 282
liniana. Myoprocta praui. 0886; 279 (emendment, sec

limanus. Myoprocta pratti)
limanus. Myoprocta pratti. 0886: 279
limatus. Phyllotis darwini. 0697: 407
limitaneus. F.uxerus erythropus. 0981; 255
limitaris. Golunda ellioti. 0992: 373
l.imnomys. 0505: 325
linutus, Arvicanthis, 0635: 429
tiodon. Tatera. 0368: 441
Lionycieris. 0719: 270
/(o/).s. Pteropus. 0624: 383
Uotomys. 0842: 204. 205
LiponycterLs. 0944: 267

/ufm, Epimys. 0788; 407

liitledalei. Arctomys. 0596; 259, footnote

litttedalei. Parolomys ILiotomys), 0842; 205

liitoralts. Cavia holivien.sis. 0314; 195

/««. Croculura (Pachyura). 0242; 930

/urfl. Crocidura. A46; 2 (nomcn nudum)

too, Gerhdlus (Dipodillus). 0193; 550

loandae. Herpestes alhicaudus, 0447; 408. fig.

loandae. Scturus stangeri. 0524; 295. 296

loandicus. Heiiosciurus rhodesiae. 097 1 : 521

/oiam.s, Nyctinomus. 0089; 303; (K)92; 102. fig.

lohatus. Nyctinomus. A26; 1 (nomen nudutn)

lockwoodi. OVaomy.v. 0K31; 187

hckwoodi. Lagidium. 0854; 499

locusta. Emballonura mecki. 0890: 534

/oi/cn, Gazella. 0162: 4.52; 0165; 470. fig. 2. pi. 32

loderi. Gazella. A41: 1 (nomen nudum)

Lonchophylla. 0422; 458

Lonchothrix. 0882: 113

longicauda. T[hallomysl. 0996: 493 (lapsus for

nigricauda. Mus. (X)16: 266. pi. 14. fig. 1. corrected

in MS in collected works)
longicaudatti. Microgale. (M)17; 320. fig.
longipes. Tupaia ferruginea. 0137; 343
longmani. Hydromys, 0965; 171
longmani. Petrogale. 1033; 186
lonnhergi. Sigmodon. 0905; 448
lopesi. Procavia. 0543: 519
lophiirus, Pipislrellus. 0750: 413
lophurus. Sjuricataj sfuricatta]. 0479; 133
loriae. Nyctinomus. 0234: 609
loriae, Pogonomys. 0234; 613
louisae, Acomys. 0207; 269
loveridgei, Steatomys. 0858: 33
lowei. Cercopithecus campbelli. ^11: 608
lowei. Dipodillus. 0981; 261
lowei. Rhinoplerus. 0761; 559
lowei. .Sciurui. 0103: 253

lualabae. Heiiosciurus rufobrachium. 0971; 520
liicida. Tupaia splendiditla. 0202; 490
lucifer. Callicebus. (1726; 345
lucifer. Dasyprocla. 0410; 491
/ua/cr, Mydaus. 0369; 442

(uci/cr, A'crui, 0219: 1 ; 0221 ; 430: 0242; 934. pi. 54
luculliis. Rhipidomys, 0645; 115
India. Genetta. 0529; 579
ludlowi, Paraechinus. 0864; 748
lugenda. Marmosa noctivaga. 1057; .373
lugens. Cephalophus, 0260: 393
lugens, Oryzomys (?). 0208: 306
lugens. Sciuropterus. 0174: 666
lullulae, Nyctymene major, 0460; 197
lullulae. Phalanger. 021 1: 528
lunaris. Cerdocyon thous, 0726; 356
lunaris, Da.typrocta aguti, 0818; 259
lunaris, Mus univittatiis, 0519; 145
lunaris, Sylvisorex, 0519; 139

M. R. O.THOMAS

99

lunaris. Tamiscus vulcanorum, 0827: 36

lupinus. Lycaon picttts. 0368: 439

laUistei, Gerhillus, 0415: 172

lutea, Viscaccia, ()54\: 44?>

luleola. Nycteris aethiopica, 0331: 30

luleoUis. Ctenomys opimus. 030i: 384

litleolus. Gerhillus stigmonyx. 0339: 275

lutfolus, Grison fttrax, 0549: 163

lutescens, FJlobius. 0228: 308

lutescens. Helogale hirtula. 0668: 725

lutescens. Mylomys. 0765: 149

lulescens. Phyllolis. 0350: 131

luticolor. Mus confuciantis. 0592: 45; 0594: 972

lulillus. Uromys. 0718: 216

Lutreolina, 0618: 247

lutreolma. Mustela. 0819: 261

lulhlla. Lfutreolinaj cfrassicaudalaj. (.t974: 585

luirma, Ratufa giganlea, 0776: 226

luzonicus. Mus. 0197: 163

lycaon. Meriones blackleri. 0853: 272

lylei. Hipposuieros, 0716: 88

lylei. Tamiops. 0975: 307

lynesi, Lenmiscomys. 0981: 267

macconnelli. Mesophvlla. 0332: 143. 145

macconnelli, Orvzomvs, 0631: 186

macconnelli. Sciurus. 0332: 148. footnote

macculus. Arvicanthis. 0621: 515. pL 34, |Hg. I|

mackenziei. Epimys. 0788: 410. 41 I

mackilligini. Dipodtllus, 0453: 158

mackinderi. Procavia. 0287: 25; 02^2: 176

macleari. Mus. (K)50: 513, pi. 42

macmdlani. Dremomvs, 0776: 226, 238

macnullani. Helogale, 0525: 300

macmillani. Platymops, 0511: 5(X)

macrodon, Bradvpus, 0808: 356

macronyx, Acodon, 0169: 362

macropus. Notomys mitchelli, 0925: 540

macrotis. Neoloma, 0144: 234

macrotis. Notomys. 0925: 538

macrurus. Crossarchus fasciatus, 0537: 120

maculatus, Cynopterus, 0137: 341

madeirae, Saimiri, 0576: 90

madrassitis, Harpiocephalus harpia, 0986: 88

madurae, Scutrus notatus. 0624: 386

maestus. Euxerus erylhropus, 0627: 419

magdelenae. Nectomys. 0218: 499

magister, Phyllolis. 0697: 406

magna. Dobsonia, 0487: 423

mayor, Chiropodomys. 0137: 344

mayfjr. Lophuromys. 0540: 382

majori. Eltunis. 0198: 164

majori. Microgalc. 0835: 305

majori, Microtus (Piiymys). 0508: 419

majori, Miniopterus. 0503: 175

majori. Tremarctos ornatus. 0356: 216

Majoria, 0763: 57, tootnolc

malaccanus. Sciuropterus genibarbis, 0579: 304

tnalcolmi. Microius. 0647: 5; 0649: 174

Mallodelphys. 0873: 195. footnote

Mallomys. 0250: 1

malosae. Macroscelides brachyrhynchus, 0242: 928

malosae. Macroscelides brachyrhynchus, A46: 2

(nomen nudum)
mambatus, Pogonomys forhesi, 0890: 536
manarius. MicrosduriLS. 0886: 275
manavi. Miniopterus, 0503: 176
rnanchu, Mus nagnen, 0612: 502
rnandatus, Lepus capensis. 1040:309
mandmgo, Funisciurus. 0398: 79
rtuinipulus. Epimys, 0788: 413
manium. Nasua, 0694: 229
mansuetus. Potos flavus. 0726: 362
mantchurica, Ochotona (Pika) hvperborea. 0612: 504
manfchuricus, Mus agrarius, 0270: 774. footnote
manlchuricus, Sciurus vulgaris. 0612: 501
mamiselae, Rattus, 0888: 424
mapravi. Callosciurus epomophorus, 0893: 120
rnarana, Ratufa phaeopepla, 0776: 227
maranu. Marmosa, 1007: 537
maraxica. Dasyprocla aguli. 0995: 341
maraxina. Monodelphis. 0987: 157
tnarcarum. Hesperomys carillus, 0809: 1;0892: 231
marchio. Petaurista nitida. 0563: 251
margarettae, Mus, 0137: 346
marica. EHgmodontia. 0845: 483
marica. Gazella. 0215: 162
marica. Leggada hella. 0616: 88
marica, Marmosa. 0262: 455
marica, Petaurista. 0686: 687
marica, Vandelauna oleracea. 0766: 54
marinus, Rcithrodon auriius, 0878: 474
marita, Crocidura. 0981: 253
maritimus. Phyllotis amicus. 0299: 296
rnarmorae. Or\zomvs (OecomysK 0531: 445
marmosurus, Rattus. 0899: 246
marmosurus. Rhipidomys, 0277: 378
marmota. Procavia. 0324: 45; 0325: 88
marrensis. Cercopithecus tantulus. 0981: 248
marrensis. Crocidura hindei. 0981: 252
marrensis. Pipistrellus. 0981: 249
marrensis. Procavia ruficeps, 0981: 27!
martinsi. Leontocebus, 0671: 85
ma.shonae, Otomys, 0842: 210
Mastacomys, 0019: 413:
mastivus. Molossops. 0645: 113
Mw.v^jm.VA. 0773: 477
matroka. Vespertilio. 0483: 258
matschiei. Vespertilio. i)A92: 573
mattensis. Nectomvs sifuamipes. 0430: 238
maurisca. Crocidura, 0461: 237, 239
maurus. Molossus, 0332: 141
maxwelli, Mellivora. 0994: 340
mayori. Coelomys. 0750: 415

100

J. E. HILL

mediliinus. Cryptomys, 0919: 354

mediiis. Blassaricyonj, ()609: 232, 233

meditis. Cremnomys, 0776: 240

meditis. Dasymys. 0519: 143

meditis. Graomys. 0854: 494

meditvi. Hemigaiago demidoffi, 0773: 466

meditis. l.oncheres. 0609: 239

meditis. Minioplerus. 0607: 382

meeki, Embalkmura. 0211: 527

meeki, Hyomys. 0427: 4; 0429: 198. pi. 23. figs. 2a-c

meeki. Phalanger orientalis, 0264: 434

meinertzhageni. Hylochoeriis. 0463: 577; 0465: 12;

0469; 193. pis, 14-15
meinertzhageni. Myotis, 1042: 609
melampus. Dactylopsila, 0561: 122
melantus. Crunomys, 0539: 5; 0547: 141
melanuis. Nectomys sqimmipes, 0631: 185
melannis. Phyllotis. 0709: 407
melanochra. Ratiifa macrotira, 0766: 36
melanogasler, Sciunis. 0174: f>68
melanotis. Oryzom\s, 0138: 404
melanotis. Phalanger. 0250: 2
melanotus. Sciiirus niger, {X)82: 73, pi. 6
melantho. EricuUis setosus. 1033: 250
melanlho. Felts yagttarondi, 0726: 350
melantho, Metachirns oposstim. 0976: 602
melanura. Phascogale. 0274: 191
melamira. Tupata. 0103: 252; 0105: 224. pi. 19. figs.

4-5
melanurus. Carpomys. 0197: 162; 0263; 407. pi. 34.

fig. 2, pi. 36. fig. 6
melanurus. Metachirus opossum, 0276: 285
melihius. Conilunis. 0921: 431
melicertes. Hydromvs. 0921: 430
meltcus. Uromys, 0718: 215
melinus. Grison furax, 0692: 47
melissa. Vampvressa. 1047: 157
mellandt. Georychus. 0503: 178
Melomys. 0941: 261
melonit. Glis, 0542: 445
melvtlleus. Rattiis. 0921: 427
menadensis. Boneia, 0206; 242
menamicus. Callosciurus ferrugineus. 1088: 839
mendostis, Conepatus stiffocans, 0918: 222
meneliki. Lutra capensis. 0395: 309
Menetes. 0566: 244

mensalis. Lama vicugna. 0809; 3; 0892: 243
mentostis, Dremomys pernyi, 0960: 400, 401
mentosus. Rattus. 0801: 643
mephisto, Sasua nasua. 1057:367
mergultvi. Petaurista. 0964: 1067
mergultis. Tragultis raviLS, 0983: 85
meridensis. Blarina, 0262: 457
meridensis. Nasua olivacea, 0336: 249
meridensis. Oryzomys. 0169: 351
meridensis. Polos f I lav us j. 0361; 267. 268
meridensis, Sciurus griseogena, 0314: 192

meridensis. Sylvilagus. 0450: 36

merriami, Geomys, 0146: 271

merrilli. Gazella. 0467: 19; (W70: 347. fig. 90

Mesoctenus. 0837: 366

Mesophylla. 0332; 143

messoritis, Dendromys, 0421: 340

messorius. Oryzomys navus. 0332: 151

messoritis. Psetidomys (Leggadina), 1023: 670

mesurtis. Trichostirus vtilpecula, 1044: 633

micans. Mystax devillei, 1083: 256

micfitanus. Callosciurus erythraetis. 0960; 397

muonax. Aolus, 1057: 365

MtcrodilltLs. 0616; 197

microdon, Xerus, 0474; 387. 389

Microgale. 0017: 319

M/rmrvJom.v'v, 0809: 1

microtimis. Oryzomys, 0169; 358

microtis, Nyctophilus, 0061; 226

microtis, Rhipidomys, 0208: 304

M/t-mtitv. 0609; 237

muias, Sciurus sladeni, 0744: 197, 198

mikado. Evolomys, 0493: 18:0486: 352

miletus. Microtus (Fothenomys) melanogasler. 0746:

474
millardi. Calloscttirus sladeni. 011&. 225, 234
millardi. Dacnomys. 0788: 405
Millard ta. 0656: 998:
miV/^n. DvTomyj. 0680; 394
millicens. MtcrotiLS. 0666: 49; 0679: 138
millsi. Acanthton. 0945: 431
mdlsi, Helictis. 0945; 432
mima. Procavia, 0302: 387
mimax. Cerdocyon, 0726: 355
mimtix. Octomys. 0883: 117, 118
mtmetes. Phascogale swainsoni, 1016:528
Mimetillivi. 0464; 12; 0468: 188
mimetra. Helogale. 1032; 183
mimetra. Marmosa. (t907: 521
mimicus, Phalanger orienlalis, 0953: 680
rnimulus, Dipodtllus. 0364; 362
mtmulus, Phascogale. 0525; 540
mtmultis, Pseudomys (Leggadina) deltcaiiilus. 1(>44:

634
mimulus, Sciurus (Microscitirus). 0266: 266
mimus. Oxvmyctertis. 0311; 183
minahassae. Mus. 0206; 247
minax. Paradoxurtis. 0599: 375
minax. Trogoptertis. 0978: 660
rrundorensis. Mus. 0220: I ; 0263: 402
minensis. Sylvilagus, 0341: 534
mmtitus. Steatomys. 0482; 174
miodon. EnnacetLs, 0592; 44; 0594: 965
miotis. HistiotiLS velatus. 0783: 273
nurae. Tvlnmys. 0276: 278
mirandiLs. Hipposideros demitsus. 0729: 437
mitis, Herpestes galera. 0395: 309
mitis, Lutra, 0568: 393

M. R. O. THOMAS

101

miurus. Hesperomys frida. 1038: 314
mizurus, Orvzomys tna^ellanicus. 0779: 186
modesta. Heliclis suhauranliaca, 0939: 196
modesta. Phascogale tnelanura. 0672: 92
modesta, Vandeleuna oleracea. 0744: 202
modestior. Abrothrix suffusus, 0851: 202
modestus. Dremomys pernyi. 0785: 393
modestus. Metachirus nudicaudalus, 0976: 606
modestus. Potos fflavusj. 0361: 267, 269
modesliis. Pseudochirus lamginosus. 1044: 362
modestus, Reilhrodontomys, 0549: 163
modicus. Rhipuiomys. 1047: 161
modigliami. Pleropus, 0160: 106
moemis. Cavia. 0254: 284
moerens. Abrolhnx suffusus, 0851: 203
moerens, Oenomys bacchante , 0650: 379
moerens. Proloxerus stangeri, 0973: 527
moerescens. Mfenetes} hferdmoreij. 0739: 24
moerex. Or\zom\s albigularis. 0741: 241
moheuis. Callosciurus. 0893: 122
mohdlius. Callosciurus moheius. 0893: 122
molliae. Isothrix vdlosa. 1007: 534
mollis. Acodon. 0169: 363
mollis. Lagostomus maximus, 0618: 245
mollis. Uromys, 0717: 210; 0737: 322
moloneyi. Vesperugo (Vesperiisi. 0094: 528, fig.
moluccarum. Leuconoe. 0748: 170
monacha. Crocidura russula, 0508: 417:
numastria. Peradorcas concinna, 1044:630
monax, Crocidura. 0634: 310
monckloni. Crossomys. 0548: 72
moncktoni. Uromys, 0466: 399
mondraineus. Rattus, 0921: 428
mongol, Mwrotus agrestis. 0670: 759
mongolium. Mus wagneri, 0575: 106
montana. Tupaia. 0103: 252; 0105: 223
montamis, Dasymys, 0519: 143:
montamis, Phyllolis amicus. 0299: 297
montensis. Akodon arviculoides, 0709: 405
Monticavia, 0797: 303
monticularis. Lepus, 0397: 78
monticularis. Praomys. 1019: 238
montis, Crocidura fumosa, 0519: 138:
montis, Mus jacksom, 0621: 503
montosus, Eptesicus, 0876: 363
montosus, Gliriscus rupicola. 1019: 233
montserratense. Sfenoderma, 0152: 133:
mordax. Arvicanthis. 0654: 460
mordax. Bandicota, 0801 : 642
mordax. FAineomys, 0697: 410
mordax. Harpiocephaius, 09H6: 88
mordax. Lonchophylla. 0422: 459
mordax, Macaca. 0601: 380
mordax. Mungos paludinosus. 0698: 588
mordax, Mus. 0466: 398
mordax, Notomys. 0946: 317
mordax, Plecotus. 1050: 306

mordax. Trogopteriis. 0745: 230

mordtcus. Mastacomys, 0961: 551

mordosus, Ctenomys sylvanus. 1039: 325

tnoreni. FAigmodontia, 0208: 307:

morem, Lagidium. 0217: 467

morosa, Ochotona cansa, 0696: 403

mossambicus. Paraxerus flavivittis. 0858: 31

mossambicus. Petrodromus (Mesoctenus). 0837: 369

moslellum. Hipposideros commersoni, 0446: 385

mounseyi. Leontocebus, 0870: 144

mullah, Acomys. 0452: 103

mullulus. Epimys berdmorei, 0788: 413

murex, Phascogale, 0701: 80

Munculus, 0395: 314

muriculus. Dipodtllus, 0981: 263

munculus. Hesperomys, 0930: 623

munlla. Leggada triton, 0616: 91

murillus, Hesperomys, 0779: 183

murinus. Uromys, 0718: 216

murrayi, Raltus. 0975: 601

muscalis. Uromys. 0718: 217

muscatellum. Rhmopoma, 0412: 498

musciculus. Pipislrellus. 0708: 316

muscilla. Kerivoula. 0524: 294

muscina, Phyllorhina. 0036: 201

musculma. Eligmodontia laucha. 0103>: 138

Mylomys. 0523: 224

myoides, Xeromys, 0075: 248, pi. 29. figs. 1-12

Myomys, 0773: 477

Myonax, 1085: 408; 1091 : 102

Myoprocta. 0422: 464

Myoscmrus. 0603: 469, 474

Myotomys. 0842: 204, 206

myrella. Kerivoula. 0729: 438

Myrsilus, 0603: 469. 470

mysoliae, Dorcopsis. 0714: 507

my«/"(ts, Elephanlulus rupeslris, 0529: 586

nagarum, Callosciurus erythraeus. 0716: 225, 228

nagarum, Leggada, 0902: 597

naivashae, Tachyoryctes. 0614: 547

nakanus, Callosciurus epomophorus. 0893: 120

namaquana, Felis ocreata, 1032: 180

namaquensis. Sfuricataj s/urtcattaj. 0479: 134

/m^m. C'rfvm, 0805: 158

nancillus, Gerbillus. 0981: 260

nandia, Crocidura, t*605: 99

Nanocavia, 1018: 418,419

nanogigas. Sciurus bicolor, 0202: 490

nanopardiLs. FelLs pardus. 0452: 94

nanulus. Pipislrellus. 0460: 198

«a«u,v. Holochilus. 0218: 495

«ap/, 5r/Hriiy (Microsciurus} peruanus. 0299: 295

narranus, Lfepusj capensis. 1040:309

/Vu.?///(>, 0515: 10:0529: 578

Nasillus. 0666: 49; 0679: 130

naso, Lophuromys, 0650: 381

102

J. E. HILL

naso. Uromys. 0652: .■(86; 0737: 321

nalalis. Pleropus. 0050: 511. pL 41

nationi. Dasypus. 0149: 70

naliviialis. Mus. 0067: 533

natunae, Semnopithecus, 0167: 652

natttnensis. Sfciunisj lowi. 0179: 26

nauticits, Hydromys, 0921: 429

nauticus. Isoodon. 0952: 678

namicus. Philander laniger. 0721: 358. 359

navigator. Micromys speciosus, 0496: 358

Neacomys. 0281: 153

neavei, Leggada, 0616: 90

negrensis. Galea, 085 1:211

negrensis, Isolhrix bistriata, 0886: 277

negrinus, Mus ephippium, 0263: 403

neg.ito, Bolomys. 1037: 312:

nemuhts, Calluehus. 0576: 88

neocenus, Akodon. 0852: 213

Neoaodim. 0351: 24; 0354: 114

Neotomys. 0169: 346

nero. Helogale parvula. 1085: 408; 1091; 104

nero. Uromys. 0717: 208; 0737: 320

nesaea. Marmosa. 0655: 515

nesaeus, Dasyurus hallttcatus, 1054: 544

Nesictis. 0939: 194

nesioles. Sciuriis villatus, 0602: 439; 0615: 1 15

Nesogale. 0834; 303

Nesonycteris. (KMl; 147; (X)44: 323; (K)66: 476

Nesoromys. 0942: 263

Nesoryctes. 0835: 303, 307

nestor, Cricetulus. 0555: 466

n/a/fl. Cfliifl. 0253: 282

nicaraguae. Marmosa cinerea, 0484; 313

nicefori, Ichlhyomys. 1000: 165

nicefori, Svlvilagits, 0924: 442

nieefori, Thomasomys. 0919: 355

nichollsi. Slenoderma. 0094; 529

nicolli. Psammomys ohesus. 0577; 92

nigeriae. Arvicamhis harharus, 0675: 272

nigeriae. Chaerephon. 0708; 319

nigeriae. Gerhillus. 0880: 317

nigeriae, Sciurus slangeri, 0524: 295. 296

nigeriae, Talcrillus. 0654; 459

nigerianus, .Mungo.s na,«<. 0698; 588

nigralus. Melachirits opossum, 0976: 603

nigraius. Myimux. 1085; 408; 1091: 103

nigrensis. Anomalurus fraseri, (M64: 12:0468; 190

nigrensis, Funisiiiirus mandingo. 061 1: 477

nigrescens, Heteromxs salvini. 0144: 234

nigriana, Caviella aiisiralis. 0904; 446

nigricans, Tragulus, 0103: 254

nigricauda. Mils. (X)I6: 266. pi. 14. tig. 1

nigricauda. Mus. A07; unpaginalcd (nonien nudum)

nigriceps. Clenomys opimus, 0301; 383

nigriceps, Saimiri holiviensis, 0383: 246

nigripes, Sciuroplerus. 0140; 30

nikkonis. PjelaurLstal l/eucogenysl. 0476: 488. 489

nilosa. Coleura gallarum. 0762; 576. 577

nilolica. Lutra maculicollis. 0668: 726

ninus. Rallus elm. 0960; 404

niobe, Crocidura. 0519; 138

niobe. Funambulus, 0265: 249

niobe, Mus. 0505: 327

niiedulus. Oecomys. 0639; 505

miela. Klupidomys. 0332: 148

nuWu. Tlhallomysl. 0996; 493

nilidula. Pelaurisla. 0306: 592

nitidus. Hesperomys laticeps var.. 0023: 452. pi. 42.

fig. I
niveatus. Funiseiurus leucostigma, 097 1 : 522
niveipes. Oryzomys. 0208; 305
nogulari.t. Phyllolis. 0927: 611
norae, Surdisorex. 0523: 223
notabilis. Protoxerus slangeri. 0973: 528
notata. Gazella granti. 0232; 475
no;a»«. Thomasomys. 0809: 2; 0892: 233. pi. 14.

fig. 4
nolialis. Pseudochirus laniginosus, 0988: 158
notina. Perameles myttsura. 0957: 144
noiinus. Passariscus sumichrasti, 0406; 379
Notiomys. (Xi88; 23
Notodelphys. 0912: 137
Nolotragus. 0504; 10; 0518; 168
Noioxus. 0851: 209 (nomen nudum, lapsus lor

Geoxits. substituted in MS in collected works)
nubalis. Lemniscomys dunni, 098 1 ; 267
nubila. Abrothrix hirla, 1092; 40
nuhrica, Ocholona. 0938; 187
nucus. Akodon. 1055; 636
nudaster. Taphozous kachhensis, 0766: 59
mix. MicroliLs. 0626: 26; 0637: 636
mix. Scotoplulus nignta, 0440: 208
nyasae, Cephalophus. 0348: 58
nyasae, Dendromus. 0794: 241
nyikae. Mus. 0219: I; 0221: 431; 0242: 936
nyikae. Oryctolagits crassicaudatus. 0382: 244
nymphaea. Vampyressa. 0609: 230

obfuscatus. Helioscutrus rufobrachium. 0972; 526
obiensis, Uromys. 0646; 208
obscura. Lichonycteris. 0196; 56
obscurior. Oryzomys phaeopus. 0169: 356
obscurus. Caenolestes, 0201: 367
omisius. Fchimys. 0905; 450
occidentalis. Eliomys lerotiniLS, 0416: -3(M)
occullus. Clenomys. 0885: 243
occullus. Promops. 0764: 62
ochracea. Itelogale victorina, 0617: 194
oihracea, Poiana richardsoni, 0540: 372
ochraceiventer. Mils. 0170: 451. 456
ochraceus. Paraxerus. 0605: 106
ochraspis. Pelaurisla. 0989: 172
ot7ir*'sc*'«.?, .Sciurus ciLscinus. 0726; 362
ochrinus, Oryzomys harbacoas, 0905; 449

M. R. O. THOMAS

103

Ochromys. 0K6S; 142

Oclomys. 0883: 117

Oecomys. 0531: 444

oemmthe. Callicehus, 1013: 286

oenax. Thomasomys. 1073: 154

oenone. Funiscitdrus congicus. 1040: 297

okiensis, Lepiis brachyums, 0496: 359

olga. Claviglis. 1024: 191

olga. Lenmiscomys, 0906: 9

olilor. Microtus {Eothenomys), 0666: 50; 0679: 139

olivellus. Funisciurus congicus. 0447: 410. 411

itlivinus. Oryzomys phaeopus, 0383: 247

idlula. Mydaus. 0369: 443

oUiila. Sylvisorex. 0708: 321

olympius. Funambidus palmarum. 0766: 38.41

omanensis. Lepus. 0163: 450

omari, Myotis myotis, 0498: 521

omensis. Cercopithecus, 0308: 4; 0310: 801

omensis. Helioscturns multicolor, 0605: 104

oncilla. Felis panUnoides. 0417: 237

oniscus, Microtus, 0667: 723

oniscus, Oryzomys, 0435: 142

oniscus, Paraechinus. 0959: 307

ophmsae, FJiomys. 1028: 389

opimus, Dremomys rufigenis. 0776: 225, 237

oralis. Gerbillus swalius, 1019:236

oralis. Pfoecilictisf, mil: 368

oralis. Pseudochirus laniginosus. 1044:631

oralis, Pseudomys australis, 0929: 621

oratus. Vampvrops. 0743: 411

orbus. Akodon. 0854:497

ordinalis. Eutamias asiaticus, 0592: 44; 0594: 968

oreas. Pfetauristuj Ifeucogenysj, 0476: 488, 490

Oreonax. 1056: 156; 1057: 362; 1070: 596

oresles. Apodemus speciosus. 0666: 49; 0679: 136

Orestes. Arctonyx leucolaemus. 0653: 27; 0664: 688

Orestes. Nyctereutes procyonoides, 0978: 657

Orestes. Otomvs irroratus. 0292: 175

orestes. Sciurus notatus. 0190: 530

orianae. Mimopterus. 0963: 616

orientis. Neomys fodiens. 0735: 564

orientis, Sciurus vulgaris, 0496: 345

orinoci. Loncheres (Isolhrix) bistriatus, 0277: 382

orinoci, Peramys hrevidaudatus, 0273: 154

orinoci, Sylvilagus i)295: 356

oris. Oenomys, 0650: 380

oris. Proechimys, 0459: 195

ornata, Perameles, 0427; 4; 0429: 201

ornatus, Anthops, (X)56: 156; 0066: 477. pi. 22. fig. 1

ornaius, Dremomys rfufigenis}. 0739: 26

ornatus, Nycticehus, 0931: 627

ornatus. Oenomys. 0650: 378

ornatus, Vampyrodes, UK)7: 532

Orolesies. 0809: 3

osgoodi. Oecomys. 1013: 287

otinu.s, Sciurus (Microsciurus), 0314: 193

Otomops. 0711-91

oweni. Arvicanthis. 0660: 120

oweni, Procavia. 0660: 123

oweni, Scapanulus, 0696: 396, 397

oweni, Uranomys, 0635: 431

owensi. Tomeutes similis. 0776: 225, 236

owstoni. Chrotogale, 0678: 17; 0688: 500, figs. 61-63;

1059:47. pis. 1-2
owstoni, Zetis, 0567: 248
oxianus, Citellus fulvus. 0757: 422

pacator. Lfeontocebus}, 0726; 346

pachita, Proechimys. 0998: 694

pacipcus. Akodon. 0350: !35

paeze, Phvllostomus hastatus, 1(K)1: 235

pahari. Mus. 0788: 414

palaestina, V'ulpes vulpes, 0S67: 122

palawanensis. Tupaia ferruginea. 0158: 367

pallescens, Callicebus, 0549: 161

pallescens. Nyctophilus geoffroyi, 0701: 79

pallescens. Perameles nasuta. 0965: 173

pallida. Procavia. (K}97: 908; 0099: 67. pi. 3

pallidior. Apodemus agrarius. 0573: 7

pailidior, Cavia tschudii, 0805: 158

pallidior. Cynictis penicillata, 0434: 5; 0449: 175

pallidior, Dasyuroides hvrnei, 0505: 330

pallidior, Kannabateomys amblonyx. 0410: 489

pallidior, Kerodon niata, 0359: 229

pallidior, Lagorchesles conspicillatus. 0593: 793

pallidior. Marmosa elegans, 0375: 159. 161

pallidus. Mimopterus schreibersi. 0552: 197

pallidas. Philander laniger, 0276: 286

palmeri, Oecomys, 0661: 251

palmeri, Sciurus (Microsciurus). 0609: 234

palnica. Leggada. 0985: 87

pahistris. Kerodon. 0658: 608

pampanus. Conepatus suffocans. 0918: 221

pampanus. Reithrodon cuniculoides, 0798: 304

pamparum. Cavia rufescens. 0342: 538

pamparum, Eligmodontia morgani. 0724: 572

panamensis, Dasypterus ega. 0336: 246

panamensUi, Oryzomys, 0336: 252

panamensis. Proechimys centralis. 0283: 220

pandora, Dasyprocla, 0821: 313

panjioli, CallosciuriLs epomophorus, 0893: 120

panjius. Callosciurus epomophorus. 0893: 119

pannosus, Dasypus vellerosus. 0360: 244

pannosus, Rhizomys, 0763: 60

/ja/>H«. Phyllorhina. 0036: 204

papuana, Emballonura, 0730: 443; 0737: 318

paraganus. Oryzomys ratticeps, 1011: 144

paraguensis, Sylvilagus. 0342: 539

Paralomys, 1038: 315

paramensis. Oxymycterus, 0350: 139

paramorum, Thomasomys. 0262: 452

paranalis, L/utreolinaJ cfrassicaudataj. 0974: 584

paranus, Molossus planirostris, 0335: 190

parata, Marmosa. 0655: 517

104

J. E. HILL

Pardiais. 1027: 498

paricola. Rhipidomys. ()459: 194

parilina. l.ulra. 0740: 59

Parolomys. 0842: 204. 205

parthianiis, Citelltis fulvus. 0757: 423

pasha. Leggada. 0616: 89

pasquieri. Hapalomys. 1059: 57

pastasae. Talu. 1)318: 370

paiagomctts. Eitmops, 1001: 234

pater. Cannomys. 0770: 315:

paterculus. Pipislrellus. 0766: 32

patrius. Mus. 0593: 791

paulina. Leggada. 0846: 485

paupera. Golunda ellioti. 0992: 374

pearsoni. Felis concolor. 0334: 188

pearsoni, Petrogale. 0954: 682

pearsoni. Solisorex. 1015: 94. 95

peasei. Macroscelides, 0333: 154

pebilis. Mystax nigrifrons. 1084: 286

pedester. Epimys walamhae. 0662: 376

peterimts. Meriones. 0853: 266

pelliceus. Arvicanthis abyssinicits. 1074: 303

pelticeus, Eptesicus fttscus. 0876: 361

pelliceus. Microttis. 0651: 383

pellucens. Vespertilio matschiei. 0498: 520

penicillatus. Eliurus. 0588: 450

peninsulae. Galeopterus. 0579: 303

peninsulae. Isoodon. 0952: 679

peninsulae. Micromys speciosus, 0536: 862

peninsulae. Oryzoniys. 0233: 548

peninsularis. Lynx rufus. 0243: 42

peninsularis. Vespertilio fuscus. 0243: 43

penricei. Equus. 0303: 465

papilio. Glauconycteris. 0471: 77

pequinius. Myotis (Leuconoe), 0585: 637

peracer. Rhinosciurus. 0602: 440:0615: 120

Peradorcas. 0436: 226

peralta. Giraffa camelopardalis. 0245: 1:0246: 40

percivali. CIneotis. 033 1 : 28

percivali. Helogale. 0668: 724

perfulvidus. Herpestes ochraceiis. 0452: 96

perfusca. Marmosa. 1(X)1: 236

perlutea. VLscaccia. 0541: 443

perluleus. Talerillus. 0981: 259

perlulus. Epimys whiteheadi. 0646; 205

Peroryctes, 0527: 476

perrensi. Ctenomys. 0208: 31 1

persica. Crocidura leucodon. 0552: 198

peruana, Anthorhina. 0998: 693

peruanus, Cehus fatuellus, 0311: 178

perustus. AnomaluriL'i jacksoni. 0792: 235

pervalens. Akodon sylvanus. 1020: 579

peshwa. Leuconoe, 0760: 61 1

pesliculus. Raltus. 0899: 248, 0935: 111

Petaurillus. 0560: 3

Petinomys. 0560: 5. 6

petrina, Saimiri sciurea. 1057: 364

PcfromviTiu. 1031: 174, 179

Petropseudes. 0968: 250

peucinus. Sorex araneus. 0706: 216

phaea. Marmosa. 0272: 44

Phaenomys. 0816: 196

phaeocephttlus. Pteropus. 0021: 756, pi. 54

phaeocephalus. Pteropus. A09: 3 (nomen nudum)

phaeopus. Oryzomys. 0169: 355

phaeotis. Arvicanthis dorsalis. 0635: 429

phaeotis. Rhipidomys. 0311: 181

phaeura, Chimarrogale, 0265: 246

phaeunis. Carpomys. 0197: 162; 0263; 408, pL 34, fig

l,pL 36, fig. 7
phaeurus, Metachirus nudicaudatus, 0326: 545
phalaena. Glauconycteris. 0761: 560
phataena. Kerivoula. 0695: 281
phalaena, Paraxerus cepapi, 1040:296
Pharotis, 0742: 381
Phaulomys, 0476: 493
P/ii7fWr, 0358: 220
philistinus. Microtus. 0810; 450
phillipsi. Herpestes flavidens. UKI3: 239
phillipsi. Heterocephalus. (X)29: 612, footnote; 0030:

854, pi. 54, tigs. 1^
phillipsi. Madoqua. 0159: 327; fig. 3
phillipsi. Madoqua. A40: 1 (nomen nudum)
phipsimi, Pteromys (Petinomys}, 0788: 422
phoenicurus. Mangos, 0695: 280
phoeniura, Tupaia gILs, 0969: 255
phoxinus. Ornithorhvnchus anatinus. 0965: 176
phrygius. Dyromys nitedula, 0556: 407
picata, Anthorhina. 0422: 457
p/cflla. Dactvlopsila. 0561; 122. 123
picia. Tupaia, 0103: 251
pictor, Chiropodomvs, 0646: 207
p/rtor. Rhipidomys, 0459: 193
ptclus, Heteromys. 0144: 233
p/cnu, Philander laniger, 0721: 358, 360
p/cri«. Rheithrodon. (K)23: 457, pL 43, fig. 2. pi. 44.

figs. 19-21
pipidonis. Callosciurus epomophorus. 0893; 121
pirata. Callosciurus flavimanus. 1088; 836
pirata. Phascogale penicillata. 0436: 229
Platalina. 1072; 120
platensis. OxymycteriLs. 074 1 ; 244
Platymops. 0511:499
platvops. Graphiurivi, 0216; 388
platyops. Uromvs. 0505; 327
platyops, Vespertilio. 033 1 : 31
plumbescens. Cannomys ca.staneus. 0770: 315
Poeciliclis. 0777: 367

poecilops. GerhilluK (Dipodillus). 0193: 549
poecilotui. Caracal caracal. 0906: 3
/"oemy.?. 0792: 238

pnemis. Galago demidoffi. 0464: 12; 0468; 1X6
poliurus. Colohus ahyssinicus. 0.308; 4; 0310; 800
pondoliac, Ambly.somus hottentotus. 0483: 260

M. R. O. THOMAS

105

ponticiis, Evotomys, 0508: 417

pontifex. Cienomys. 0828: 39

popaea, Leggada nitidula, 0855: 420

porcinus. Conepatus. 0350: 128

ponuliis, Uromys, 0466: 400

portali, Crocidura, 0867: 119

porteousi, Cienomys. 0798: 303

porleri. Aconoemys. 0807: 281

posticalis. Phyllotis darwini, 0697: 406

praeconis, Pseudomys (Thetomys). 0642: 608

praedax. Crocidura, 0978: 656

Praesorex, 0708: 320

praetor. Mas. (M1S6: 158; 0066: 481, pi. 22. fig. 6

praetor. Oryzomys. 0295: 354

Praomys, 0173: 477

pratti, Hipposideros. 0094: 527

prattorum. Rhynchomek'S. 0888: 429. 430

predator. Dasvurus hallucalus. 1054: 543

presina. Pardictis pardicolor. 1027:499

pricei, Ochotona (Ogotona), 0670: 760

prieslleyi, Pyromys. 0656: 997

primrosei. Petaurista merguhis. 1049: 22

primula. Myolis, 0891: 248

prmceps. Geosciurus. 1091: 106

prmceps, Oryzomys, 0196: 58

princeps, Procavia brucei, 0617: 199

principula. Microgale. 1035: 251

principulus. DipodiUus. 0981: 262

principulus. Pipislrellus. 0749: 231

prittiei, Lophuromys, 0662: 377

prohus. Sciuropterus phayrei, 0739: 28

Proedromys, 0647: 4; 0649: 177

profusus. Rattus villosissimus, 0929: 620

proiixus. Uromys. 0718: 213

proteus. Conepatus. 0359: 239

proteus. Mungos gracilis, 0537: IJ9

provocax. Crocidura turba. 0630: 1 12

provocax. Lulra. 0568: 391

pruinosus. Coendou. 0484: 310

pruinosus. Papio. 0212: 789. pi. 38

pruinosus, Papio. A44: 1 {nomen nudum)

pryeri, Sciurus, 0115: 214

Pferalopex. (K)56: 155; (X)66: 473

Pteromyscus, 0560: 3

puella, Petrogale. 1044: 627

pwer. Akodon. 0350: 136

pulcher. Chiruromys. 0192: 164

pulcher. Macroscelides. 0148: 69

pulcher rmuLs. Akodon, 0233: 549

p«//ara. Presbytis cristata. 0602: 439; 0615: 106

pumila, Procavia. 0617: 20!

putnila, Saccopleryx. 0743: 410

pumilio, Arlibeus. 1007: 531

punctatus. Loncheres. 0273: 153

punctulatus, Acodon. 0169: 361

punensis, Viscaccia. 0541: 443

punicus. Eplesicus. 0876: 364

puralis, Myoprocla pratti. 1045:639

purgatiis, Sylvilagus, 0865: 32

purillus, Lfeontocebus}. (1726: 347

purinids. Callicehus torquatus. 1058: 509. 510

pusaea. Felis pardalis. 0726: 347

pusilla. Kenvoula. 0171: 461

pusUlum, Rhinopoma. 0884: 25

pusillus. Anomaiurus, 0053: 440; 0054: 8. pi. 1

pusillus. Anomalurus. A18: 1 (nomen nudum)

pusillus. Chiropodomvs. 0137: 345

pusillus. Mus margareilae. 0143: 232

pvgmrtfrt. Spilogale. 0235: 1 ; 0240: 898

pygrius. Cercopithecus biittikoferi, {y^ll: 607

Pvromvi'. 0656: 996

pyrrhinus. Sciurus. 0266: 265

pyrrhomerus. Sciurus. 0199: 242

pyrrhotis. Acodon jelskii. 0169: 361

pyrrhus. Caluromys laniger, 0314: 196

quaestor, Oxymycterus. 0399: 226

quantulus. Callosciurus fiavimanus, 1059:51

quelchii, Sciurus. 0332: 147

quelpartis. Lulreola. 0574: 53, footnote

quichua, Alouatta pidUata, 0724: 567

quichua, Coendou. 0276; 283

quichua. Marmosa, 0271: 43

quichua. Nasua, 0336: 248

quichua. Tamandua telradactyla. 1057: 371

radcliffei, Bfubalus} caffer. 0438: 13; 0454: 371; 0457:

464. fig. 95
ra(/«/ui, Soriculus. 0945: 429
rajah, Herpestes brachyurus, 0911: 134. 135
ra/a/i. A/».9. 0170:451.454
rafah, Petaurista nitida, 0563: 251
rajput. Cremmomvs medius, 0776: 241
ramosus, Citellus mongoUcus, 0612: 501
rapposa, Marmosa. 0271: 42
raptor. Pipislrellus. 0446: 387
raptorum. Funisciurus, 0398: 80
raptorum, Thryonomys swinderianus. 0949: 392
ralalina. Grisonella. 0917: 215
rattinus, Proechimys. 1047: 164
rattoides, Melomys. 0942: 263; 0958: 729
ratloides, Mesembriomvs hirsutus. KX)4: 296
r?ce5.v/ii-. Ctenomys talarum. 0674: 241
recifinus, Vampyrops, 0335: 192. footnote
regina. Marmosa, 0266: 274
regina. Ochotona rufescens. 0670: 762
reginae. Hydromys chrysogaster. 0593: 789
reginae. Petaurus australis. 0968: 249
reguli. Petaurista mergulus, 1049: 22
regulus. Callicebus torquatus, 1058: 509. 510
regulus. Craseomys, 0536: 863
regulus. Pipistrellus. 0527: 470
rendalli. Vesperugo (Vesperus). 0071: 362, fig.
resima. Macaco, 0601: 381

106

J. E. HILL

retectus, Nannosciurus exilis, 0624: 387

rex. Anicanlhis. 0525: 304

rex. Conepattts. 0253: 278

rex. Meriones. 0193: 552

rex. Mus. (X)56: 157; (K)66: 480. pi. 22. figs. 4-5

rex. Oecomys. 0639: 5(M

rex. Rhipidomys. 1070: 600

Rhahdomys. 0789: 69

Rhagomys. 0816: 192

Rheomys. 0509: 421

Rhinonax. 0837: 370

r/i/onu. Mu.i mHi«. 0602: 441; 06L5: 123

rhionis. Rhinosciurus leo. 0602: 440; 0615: 121

rhipidunis. Echimys. 1084: 291

Rhynchogale. 0154: 139

Rhynchomeles. 0888: 429. 430

Rhynchomys. 0197: 160

Rhynclumax. 0666: 49. 0679: 130

ncardulits. Phyllolis. 0854: 493

rickelti. Vespertilio (Leuconoe). 0168: 300

rid/cyi. Pipistrellus. 0259: 361

riggenbachi. Gerbillus. 0416: 301

rimator. Hylochoerus. 0502: 1; 0517: 2, fig. 1

rivalis. Embailonura monticola. 0747: 140

nva/ir. Plagumaj llar\aliisl. 0928: 618

roberti. Coendou. 0349: 63

rofecrtt. Microtus. 0508: 418

roberti, Oxymycterus. 0341: 530

roberti. Proechimys. 0341: 531

rohcrn, Rhipidomys. 0428: 5; 0430: 237

roberti. Sciurtts. 0422: 463:

roberlsi. Gazella granti. 0413: 44; 0424: 119. figs.

10-11
rohinsoni. Nyciymene. 0460: 196
rohinsoni, Presbytis. 0625: 25; 0636: 635
robinsoni. Rhinosciurus. 0586: 104
robitstula. Tylonycteris. 0749: 227
robustulus. Melanomys. 0741: 243
robtLstiis. HeUophobius. 0503: 179
robustus. Petroaromits. 0837: 367
rogersi, Chalinolohtts, 0595: 150
TOgeri/, ,Mi«. 0553: 206
m/iui. Philetor. 0358: 220
romana. Taipa. 0392: 516
raw, Proechimys. 0283: 219
rosatia. ArvicanthLs dor satis. 0447: 414
rosatinda, Thomasomys. 1053: 347
rosenbergi. Artibeus (Dermanura ?). 0233: 545
ro.H(/a. Caiifl, 0805: 154
rosilla. Rhipidomys, 0450: 35
roszikac. Dipndillus campestris, 0582; 374
rollischildi. Coendou. 0379: 169; 0403: 41
rolhschildi. Dama. 0394: 136
rothschildi. Dorcopsulus. 0950: 672
rollischildi. Mallomys. 0250: 2
rolhschildi. Massoutiera. 0906: 1 1
roikschildi, Myospalax. 0667: 722

rollischildi. Pelrogale, 0437: 366

rolhschildi. Phalanger. 0264: 433

rothschildi, Poecilictis, 0880: 316

rothschildi. Uromys, 0682: 91

roitii. R/imo/op/iiiv a^J'i''"' "121: 923. pi. II. fig. 3

rovttmae. Plelrodromusj, 0221: 434

TOiv/fvi. Otomys. 0842: 209

ruatanica. Dasyprocta, 0338: 272

rubella, Murina huttoni. 0730: 440

ruhellus, Mungos paludinosus. 0581: 166

raftcv. Me/om.vi. 0942: 263; 0958: 7.30

rafter, MMrmo. 0801:639

rabct. .Sciurus sladeni, 0744: 197. 198

ruhicola. Melomys. KKM: 298

rubida. Tylonycteris. 0749: 228 (nomcn nudum.

lapsus for Scotophiltts Id TylonyclerisJ fulvidus

Blyth, 1859)
rubida. Vandeleuria. 0744: 202
rubidior. Cephalophus rufilalus. 0540: 385
rubidits. Cephalophus, 0325: 89
rubidus. Peramys, 0273: 155
ruhrala, Dasyprocta, 0266: 273
ruhrata. Phascogale venusta. 0958: 739
ruckheih, Allactaga, 0735: 571
ra(/(/i. Herpestes. (M23: 465

ra^yrf/. Pronolagus. 0475: 23; 0483: 272. pi. 16. fig. 4
ruddi. Tachyorycles, 0614: 546
rurfd/, Thamnomys. 0584: 549
rudolfi, Procavia pumda, 0617: 202
ridfescens, Hesperomys. 0033: 250
ruficeps. Arciocebus, 0722: 387
rufigenis. Sminthopsis. 0942: 265; 0958: 7.39
ra^nu. Ga;e//u. 0615: 467. fig. 1
rufula. Hehgale undulata, 0617: 194
rufidus, .Slenomys. 0950: 669
Rupesles. 0960: 398
rupestris. Sciurus vulgaris, 0551; 410
rupicola, Gliriscus. 1019: 232
rusantis, Herpestes smithii, 0932: 24. 25
ru.\seltiana, Miatela, 0647: 4; 0649: 168
russulus. Nectomys. 0233: 547
rusticana. Felis ocreata. 1076: 319
rHKccj, Callicebus, 0998: 692
rutieri, Marmosa, 1(K)7: 536
ranc/ijora. Colohus. 0324: 45; 0325: 85
ruwenzorii. Talera. 0621: 5(K)

sabaeus. Paraechinus niger, 0936: 143
sabanus. Hipposidcros. 0248: 243
5abaoi«. ,Miu. 0052: 269; (X)73: 233
.sabanus. Paradoxurus, 0599: 376
sabanus. Semnopilhecus. 0143: 2.30. pi. 7
sabulala. Lemniscomys griselda. 1065:385
sacana. Muslela, 0735: 566
sacana, Ochotona, 0735; 572
sacer. Erinaceus roumanicus. 0843: 212
sacer. Mus confuciamts, 0573: 6

M. R. O. THOMAS

107

sacramenti. Meriones. 0962: ?52

sacraria. Ocholona ihiheiana, 097K: 663

sacratus. Soriculus. (1647; 4; 0649: 165

sacrillus, Vampyrops linealus. 1001: 236

saevtis. Sorex shinio. 0551: 408

sagitla. Thalacomys. 0487: 426

sahamae. Chinchilluh. 0253: 280

saharae. Herpestes phoenicurus. 1024: 189

saianicus. Evolomvs glareolus, 0670: 759

saUnae. Lasiurus horealis. 0359: 238

satinia, Caviella australis. 0904: 447

salinarum, Felis. 0417: 239

sallarius. Ctenomys, 0699 639

salulans. Paraxerus ochraceus, 0605: 106

salvini. Heteromys, 0133: 331

samaricus, Nannosciurus, 0220: 1; 0263: 389, pi. 30.

fig. 2
sannio. Cercopithecus palas. 0503: 173
sapientis, Uromys, 0371: 446
sarae. Lagidium. 1055: 639
sarae, Mazama. 1020: 581
saianicus. Sarcophihis, 0401: 289
saturaia, Viscaccia, 0541: 442
saturatus. Neclomys. 0233: 546
salurnus, Echimys. 1086: 409:
savannarum. Canis cancrivorus, 0032: 146
savannarum. Sigmomys, 0332: 150
savamuus. Heliosdurtds punctatus. 0971: 521
saviU't. Bandicota. 0801: 641
scalops, Didelphys (Peramys). 0057: 158
scalops, Geomys. 0161: 437
Scapanulus. 0696: 396
scaphax, Uromys. 0717: 209; 0737: 321
schistacea. Ahrocoma. 0917: 216
schneideri. Hipposideros. 0451: 722
.vc/ivi'rtAJw/. Petrodromus, 0550: 298
ScumUus. 0732: 36; 0738: 416
sclaleri. Hesperomys (Rhipidomys), 0043: 152
sclateri. Hesperomys (Rhipidomys), A16: 1 (nomen

nudum)
5c/mer/. Mvo,soreA. 0472: 10; 0479: 131
5c/aref/, Thryonomys. 0219: 1; 0221: 432, 0242: 937
Scleronycteris, 0697: 404
Sco/momyx. 0709: 408
5a;roec(w. 0317: 263
scotti, Myotis. 1061: 554
.?com. Tfhallomys}. 0996: 493. 494
scythicus. Arvicola lerrestris. 0735: 568
seabrae, Cistugo, 0693: 205
secatus, Taphozous theohaldi. 0766: 60
sechurae. Canis. 0281: 148
securus, Proechimys. 0350: 140
sefranus. Lepiis. 0723: 590
se frills, Jaculus jaculiis, 0906: 10
seiana, Ochotona curzoniae, 0938: 189
seianum. Rhinopoma muscatellum, 0716: 90
seimundi, Sciurus. 0602: 440; 0615: 117

semlikii. Sciurus rufobrachiurn, 0537: 120

semotus. Apodemus. 0569: 447

jfnesccnx, Crossarchus fasciatus. 0550: 291

5fne5fe/i.s, Heliosciurus gambianus. 0614: 544

i^rtf.v. Galictis barhara, 0280: 146

i'enex, Philander laniger. 0724: 573

5enf.v. Rhizomys, 0770: 313

seniculus. Paraechinus niger. 0936: 142

sericeus. Phalanger. 0548: 74

serrensis. Akodon. 0349: 61

sertonius, Proechimys albispinis. 0914: 141, 142

shanorum. Pipistrelhis. 0766: 29

shanorum. Ursus arctos. 0506: 17; 0521; 231, fig. 58

shanseius. Craseomys, 0585: 643

sharica. Procavia. 0543: 520

sharicus. Lycaon pictus. 0540: 375

5/mr/?f(. Colobus. 0352: 24; 0355: 118

sharpei. Raphiceros. 0212: 796. pi. 39

shurpei. Raphiceros. A44: 1 (nomen nudum)

j/in/a, Mazama. 0715: 587

shenseius. Myospalax cansiis. 0647: 5; 0649: 178

sherrini. Nyctophdits. 0758: 495

sherrini. Uromys, 0965: 171

s/imto, 5orf.v. 0493: 19; 0496: 338

shiptoni. Grisonella. 1037: 311

shiptoni, Nanocavia, 1018: 419

shoae, Iclonyx capensis, 0525: 301

shorlridgei, Callosciurus sladeni. 0776: 225, 232

shortridgei. Chaerephon (Lophomops), 1040: 289

shorlridgei, Leggadilla, 0739: 30

shorlridgei, Mus. 0534: 765

shortridgei. Pelromyscus. 1040: 302

shortridgei. Rousettus. 0597: 19; 0607: 374

shortridgei. ThaUomys. 0996: 492

5//i>V/d. Vandeleuria. 0774: 202

sicarius. Myotis. O760: 608

siccatus. Tupaia helangeri, 0725: 243

siccatus. Aethomys namaquensis. 1040: 304

siccatus. Bassaricyon rnedius, 1064: 80

siccati4S. Herpestes fiavidens, 1003: 240

siebersi, Uromys. 0991: 422

sierrae, Agouti. 0478: 589

signala. Petrogale brachyotis. 1044:629

signalus. Funamhulus layardi, 1003:241

signalus. Protoxerus stangeri, 0616: 85

sikimaria. Ochotona. 0938: 191

silacea, Crocidura (Cr.}, 0195: 53

silaceus, Xeromys (?), 0197: 161 ; 0263: 391 , pi. 31 .

fig. 1, pi. 35. figs. 11-12
sUhouettae. Coleura. 0762: 576. 578
simaUtrus, Pteropus hypomelanus. 0997: 592
simonsi, Coendou. 0350: 141
simonsi, Marmosa, 0276: 287
simonsi, /Veoc/orfori. 0351: 24; 0354: 115. pis. 8. 9.

figs. 8-12
simonsi. Proechimys. 0299: 3(H)
sim<msi. Sciurus (Microsciunis), 0299: 294

108

J. E. HILL

simpsoni. Cephalophus, ()616: 92

simulator, Akodon, 0799: 335

simus. Ghphotes. 0265: 250

simus. Myotis, 0326: 541

Jinufa. Sorex. 0696: 398

sindi. Funisciurtis cepapi. 0584: 543

sinensis. Sfcotomanesl ornatus, 0915: 772

sinualis, Phasco^ale minutissima, 1044: 634

siporanus. Mtts. 0174: 670

siva. Cremmomys australis, 0776: 242

siva. Leggada. 0720: 242

sladeni. Canis. 0428: 5; 0430: 235, pi. 27

sloggeni. Otomys. 0386: 311

smithersi, Pseudalopex, 0736: 573

smilhii. Chodsigoa. 0647: 4; 0649: 166

smithii, Crocidura (Croc.}. 0195: 51

smithii. Evotomvs (Phaulomvs), 0476: 493. fig.

smithii. Glazellaj glraniij. 0310: 806 (lapsus for

brighti. see 0424: 120. footnote)
smithii. Kerivoida. (KK)6: 166. fig.
smithii. .Madoqua guentheri. 0308: 4; 0310: 8(M
smithii. Myospalax. 0667: 720
smithii. Myoxus (Eliomys). 0145: 267
smithii, RouseniLS. 0583: 375
smitianiis. Miniopterus. 1065: 373
smyrensis, Miis mystacinus. 0414: 188
sobrina. Marmosa. 0724: 573
sodalis. Akodon bacchante, 0703: 141
sodalis. Cavia tschudii. 1041:607
sodalis. Choilsigoa, 0706: 217
soderstromi, Reithrodontomys. 0262: 451
solatiis. Anicanthis lesticidaris. 1024: 194
soleatiis. Graphiurus. 062 1 : 499
solomonis. Emballonura nigrescens, 0460:

200
solomonis. Pteropiis. 0458: 597
Sotomys. 0941: 261
Sotisorex. 1015: 94

solulus. Scturiis hartingtoni. 0744: 198, 199
somaliae, Vulpes riippelli. 0834: 244
somalica, Crocidura (Cr). 0195: 52
somalica, Procavia hrucei, 0099: 71
somalicus. Anicanthis. 0395: 312. footnote
somalicus, Crossarchus, 0191: 531
somalicus, Dipodillus. 0617: 197
somalicus. Lycaon pictus. 0452: 98
somalicus, Macroscelides, 0337: 255
somalicus, Vespertilio minutus. 0331: 32
somereni, .Sylvi.sorex, 0630: 113
sorcHfl. Eligmodontia. 0299: 297
sorella, Leggada, 0614: 548
sorella. Microgale, 1035: 252
JorcHa. M>o.wr« r'). 0242: 930
,so/-c//a, Ochotona, 0592: 45; 0594: 982
soricoides. Rhynchomys. 0197: 160; 0263: 389.

pi. 31. fig. 2. pi. 35. figs. 7,9
soudanicus, Canis anthus. 0408: 33; 0420: 295

soulla |sic|, Myosorex. A46: 2 (nomcn nudum.

lapsus for sorella. 0242: 930)
sowerhyi. Dipus. 0580: 307
spadiceus. Cynopterus, (K)84: 235
spalaciniLS, Tachvorxctcs, 0614: 547
spalax, Heliophohitis, 0634: 315
spatulaiiLS, Cervus. 0329: 54; 0330: unpaginated
spegazzini. Akodon. 0226: 216
spencei. Tamiops. 0901: 503
spenceri. Antechinomvs, 0505: 331
spicatus. Mesomys ferrugineus, 1007: 535
spiculus, Erinaceus. 0540: 371
spinifex, Atelerix, 0833: 231
spinosus. Hesperomys (Calomys). (KI15: 105
splendens. Vulpes vulpes. 0389: 489
spoliatus. Glis glis. 0520: 220
sponsoria. Marmosa elegans. 0898: 186
sponsus. FunLwiurus, 0550: 292
spurrelli, Crocidura, 0635: 427
spurrelli, Eionvcteris, 0719: 271
squalorum, Miis albocinereus. 0534: 776
stalkeri. Funisciurus. 0460: 201
stalkeri. Myotis (Leitconoe), 0624: 384
stalkeri. SminthopsLs. 0525: 543
stalkeri. Uromys. 0460: 202
stannarius, Epimys, 0713: 482
steinbachi. Ctenomys, 0549: 164
,«(f//a, £/Hmv5. 0657: 590
stellae. Zygodontomys, 0277: 380
Sfraomv.v. 0640: 507
stenotis. liipposideros. 0717: 206
stephanicus. Xerus rutilus. 0525: 301
stevensis, Atherurus, 1027: 505
stevensi, Sciurus, 0567: 246
Stictomys, 1002: 238
stigmosa, Ratufa gigantea, 0984: 86
stimulax. Mesomvs. 0658: 607
sitrlingi. Marmota. i)lll: 341
Stochomys. 1031: 174, 176
stolida, Cavia lichudii, 1047: 106
stolzmanni, Ichthyomys, 0132: 286:0134: 339.

pis. 28, 29, figs. 1-6
stolzmanni, Oryzomys, 0169: 357
storeyi, Tachyoryctes, 0614: 547
.tfrar/iey/, Ar\icola, (KKI7: 332
stresemanni, Emballonura, 0730: 442
stresemanni, .Sciurwi notatus, 0714: 505
sturdeei. Pipistrelliis, 0749: 230
.v(ur(/. .Vodimvi. 0925: 537
styani, Ailurivi fulgens, 0384: 251
styani. Sciurus. 0156: 363
suahelica. Leggada tenella. 0634: 312
subcanuA. Pipistrelliis cevhinicus. 0766: 30
sublimis. Phvllotis. 0304: 467
sublineatus. Oryzomys. 0417: 240
subluteus. Alticola worthingtoni, 0735: 570
subluteus. Lepus swmhoei. 0592: 45; 0594: 979

M. R. O. THOMAS

109

subluteus. Oryzomys fiavicans. 0266: 268
subluleiis, Sciurus viualus. 0602: 440; 0615: 1 16
subrosea, Viscacfia, 0541: 442
Sudani, Taphozous, 0761: 561
sitdanicus, Ictonyx striatus, 0981: 254
suffusus. Akodon. 0417: 241
siiilla. Nesokia. 0553: 203
sultam. Pelrodramiis. 0219: 1:0221: 235
sumatrae, Rhinopoma, 0412: 497
sumalrana, Crossogale. 0899: 244; 0935; 113
superans, Oecomys, 0661: 250
superans, Vespertdio murimts. 0270: 770
superans, Vespertdio murinus. A49: 4 (nomen

nudum)
superus, Micronts calamorum, 0653: 27; 0664: 691
surdasler. Pedetes. 0368: 440
surdaster, Sylvilagus, 0326: 543
surdasler, Thaninomvs. 0584: 550
surdaster, Viierra zibetha, 1059: 46
Surdisorex, 0523: 223

surdus. Akodon. 0809: 2; 0892: 236, pi. 15, fig. 2
sushkini. Ochotona (Ogolona), 0999: 163
sumatrius. Herpestes brachvurus. 0911: 134
swalius. Gerbillus, 1019: 235
swalius, Herpestes cauiti, 1040: 292
swalius, Steatomys, 1040: 300
swaynei, Madoqua, 0159: 328
swaynei, Madoqua, A40: 1 (nomen nudum)
swinhoei. Lepus, 0156: 364

swynnertoni, Petrodromus tetradactytus. 0837: 368
sybylla, Leggada hella, 0846: 484
sybylla, Petaurista. 0788: 423
s,v/i'ani«, Akodon. 0898: 184
sylvanus, Ctenomys, 0861: 155
sylvaticus. Rhtpidomvs, 0293: 272
5>'/ve.y/^r. Catlosciurus quinquestrtatus. 1046: 641
sylveslris. Glyphonyeteris. 0208: 302
sy/vesr™, Pogonomys. 0890: 534
Jv/vM, Croadura. 0529: 586
sylvia, Molossops lemmincki, 1001: 234
5>'/v«orf.v. 0464: 12:0468: 190
s>rm.v. Ochotona, 0653: 27; 0664: 692
s>iriuj, Jaculus laeulus, 0946; 296
s>'rius, Meriones, 0853: 268

tabanus, Spalacopus. 1021: 585

tttbaudius. Catlosciurus epomophorus. 0964: 1067

tacopius. Callosciurus epomophorus. 0893: 121

taczanowskii. Hesperomys (Rhipidornvs). (K)I5: 109

taedifer, Sciurus ignnenlris, 0410: 487

tatvana, Mustela (Lutreola), 0716: 91

lalarum, Ctenomys, 0254: 285

talaudium, Uromys, 0899: 248; 0935: 112

(a/fto(i, Crossarchus. 0540: 374

lalboti. Funisciurus leucosiigma, 0611: 478

lalpoides, Geurychus capensis, 0518: 166

Tamisciis, 0827: 33

tanganyikae. Funisciurus carruthersi, 0611: 477

tanganyikae, Tanu.scus vukanorurn. 0827: 36

tapajinus. Oecomys. 06(K): 378

taparius, Sciurus (UrosciurusI pyrrhtmotus. 1045: 635

lapetillus, Sylvilagus. 0705: 210

larabuli. Gerbillus pyramidum. 0367: 5

larquinius, Microtus (.Antelionn <) chinensis, 0683:

517
tartareus. Akaodon. 0861: 155
Taterillus. 0632: 222
taterona, Graomys. 1039: 320
ta.i(7/fl, He/iCM. 1027: 5(K1
laxinus. Conepatits inca, 1013: 286
laylori, Galeopterus. 0586: 102
taylori, Hesperomys {Vesperimus), 0039: 66
taylori, Petaurista. 0744: 205
tectiis. Oryzomys. 0336: 251
telibius, Callosciurus concolor, 0893: 121
lenaster. Epimys. 0786: 425
tenaster. Tupaia belangeri. 0820: 201
ffnf//a, Leggada, 0408: 33; 0420; 298
tenuipes, Neacomys spinosus. 0281: 153
«■«««, Bdeogale. 0581: 168
terrae-sanctae. Pslammomysj, 0364: 363, 364
/frim'. A/i« vociferans, 0613: 535
terutavensis, Sciurus concolar, 0613: 535
terutiis. Tragulus canescens, 0613; 536
lesludo. Lophiomys. 0471; 80
Thallomys. 0868: 141
Thallomyscus. 1043: 612
Thalpomys. 0800: 337. 339
thamin. Riicenus. 0829: 364
Thamnomys. 0537: 121
Thaptomys. 0800; 337, 339
theresa. Monodelphis. 0923; 441
thersites, Nasita. 0338; 271
thersites. Nyctinomtts, 0426: 634
Thetomys, 0641:606
thomsoni, Sciuropterus. 0294; 275
thyone. Vampyressa. 0609; 231
tibetanus, Cricetidus aticola. 0937; 180
riomi, Atherurus. 0586: 105
(ohu, Akodon. 0895: 178
tobagi. Marmosa, 0655: 515
tobagi. Zygodontomys brevicauda. 0293: 274
tolduco. Ctenomys. 0917: 218
tolteca. Felis yaguarondi. 0243: 41
tomesi. Hesperoptenus. 0492: 575
tonquinia. Melogale. 0939: 195
tonquinia. Tupaia belangeri. 1027: 497
lonlalis. l.agtdiiim. 0917; 219
foppmi. Callicebus. 0731; 480; 0847: 9. pi
tordayi, Petrodromus. 0616: 83
Ior(;He.s. Microxus. 0809: 3; 0892: 239, pi. 15, fig. 4
torrentium. Protoxerus stangeri, 0973: 529
torvus, Paradoxurus, 0599: 375
rosfle, P/elauristal lleucogenys] . 0476: 488, 490

no

J. E. HILL

toxopei, Murina, 0969: 254

tramatus. PipistreUus coromandtvi. 1079: 144

tramiiius. Rattus mordax. 0942: 262; 0958: 727

iranscaspiae . Ellohiits talpinus, 0680: 405

irichotis. Belomys. 0560: 7

irichutis, Ichlhyomys. 0227: 220

trichurus. Conepatus tropicalis, 0478: 585

trinitalLs. Dtdelphis {Philander), 0161: 438

trinitatis. Galictis barbara, 0280: 148

tripoliianus. Psammomys. 0367: 9

iripoliits, Meriones pallidiis, 0853: 265

trislrami, Meriones, 0102: 148

iriton. Leggada, 0614: 548

tropicalis, Otomys irroratiis, 0386: 314

tropicalis, Pedeles typicits, 1019: 241

tropicius, Oryzomys ralticeps. 1011: 143

trumbulli, Promops. 0312: 190

tsuensis. Miistela melampiis, 0214: 161

tuareg. Meriones schousboei, 1024: 193

tuconax, Ctenomys. 1021:583

tucumana. Viscaccia. 0541: 444

tucttmanus. Cerdocyon. 0903: 382

tucumanus. Ctenomys. 0299: 301

tucumamis. Dasypus sexcinctiis, 0549: 165, 166

tucumanus. Phyllolis darwini. 0697: 408

tullbergi. Mus. 0151: 205

tunetae, Eliomys lerotinus, 04 11: 495

tunneyi. Mus, 0436: 223

Typomys, 0650: 382

ucayali, Cacajao rubicundus. 1083: 252
ultimiLs, Euneomvs. 0779: 185
umhrata. Cavia tschudii. 0805: 157
umbrata. Leggada minutoides. 1)616: 86
umhraius. Acomys louisae. 0990: 174
umbratus. Cttellus mongolicus. 0592: 44, 0594: 970
umbratus. Myslax ursulus. 0943: 265
umbratus. Steatomys swalius. 1040: 301
umbriceps, Rhizomys. 0802: 445
umbrosa, Dobsonia viridis. 0624: 384
umbrosus. Gfalagoj cfrassicaudatusj. 0814: 49
underwoodi. Hylonyctens. 04(K): 286. 287
underwoodi. Rheomvs, 0509: 421. 422
ursulus, Ellobius fu.sciceps, 0680: 403
unyori. Mils hypoxanthus, 0421: 343
utibilis, Ctenomys sylvanus, 0873: !93

vaccarum. Abrocoma, 0917: 217
vaa-urwm. Phyllolis. 0697: 408
vacillalor. Proechimys. 0410: 490
vagans, Erinaceus algirus. 0315: 38
valenciae, Sylvilagus. 0743: 413
va/i, CtenodactyliLs. 0366: 39; 0367: 1 1
vallesius, Rattus culmorum, 0920: 426
vallinus. Gerbillus. 0840: 148
vanheurni, Dorcopsis, 0942: 264; 0958: 733
varennei. Chimmarogale, 1059: 45

rar/fl. Helogale. 0352: 24; 0355: 1 19

iarm«/. Hippotragus niger. 0780: 1 ; 0784: 3(M). fig. 1

varilla. Crocidura iPachyura), 0195: 54

varilliLs. Gunomys. 0553: 205

vanm. /U'0(/r^«. 0350: 134

varius, Gunomys, 0553: 204:

vrt55a/i. /.e/7m. 0510: 425

vu/e,s. P<)^(>nrjmys. 0589: 495

ve/(7/rt. Rhogeessa, 0407: 383

vehmnt4s. Mus. 0019: 415. fig. 4

vrna^^m, Chalinolobus gouldi. 0582: 372

venester. Signiomvs. 0743: 412

venezuelae. Caluromys trinitatis, 0410: 493

venezuelae. Rhipidomys, 0208: 303

venilla, Vampyressa, 1{M)7: 523

venningi, Petaurista lylei, 0739: 27

vrfi/ww. Glironia. 0674: 240

v'c«m7a, Marrnosa elegans. 0375: 159, 160

vc/ijww. Phascogale lorentzi. 0920: 358

venustula, Petrogale. 1044; 628

v'en«.v/ii,v. Arvicanlhis strialus, 0654: 461

vr/J«J/iw. Orvromv5 T-*). 0169: 359

venustus, Petrodromus. 0421: 339

venustiLs. Rhipidomvs. 0281: 152

venustiis. Thamnomys, 0537: 122

verae-crucis. Lepus, 0082: 74, pL 7

verax, Marrnosa. 0907: 520

verecimii/w. Mus, 0458: 598

vermicultis. Chrysochloris, 0616: 84

vernula, Cfncetulusj nugratorius, 0811: 453

versicolor, Scntrus. 0301: 385 (preoccupied by

Zimmerman, 1777, renamed inconstans Osgood.

1921. J. Mammal. 2:40)
versicolor. Tragulus. 0629: 535
versteegi, Pseudochirus, 0958: 735
versurae. Tupaia belangeri. 0945: 428
vestttus. Akodon (Chelemys). 0417: 242
vestitus. Coendou, 0276: 284
vestitus. Oryzomys, 0262: 454
vetula, Helogale. 0868: 724
vexillaris, Psammomys, 1025: 198
viator. Acomys. 0367: 10
viator, Cricetomys gambianus. 0447: 413
viator. Epimys jacksoni, 0654: 461
viatorum, Lagidium, 0917: 220
vicina. Leggada bclla. 0616: 88
i'(r;>iw.v. ZapiL\ (Eozapus) setchuaniLS, 0696: 402
victoriae, Genetta. 0324: 45; 0325: 87. pL 15
victoriae. Lepus. 0145: 268
victorina, Helogale. 0352; 24; 0355: 120
victits. Oryzomys. 0244: 178
vi^cn-v, fWu wiedii. 0459: 192
v'/V>/cw. Rradypus. 0808: 357
viperinus. Ctenomys. 1041: 605
i7>j?r>. Diclidurus, 0406; 377
i7>g/>. Tomeutes mearsi, 0788; 419, 421
y/voj;. Dipodilhvi. 0367: 8

M. R. O. THOMAS

111

vizcaccia. Nyctimene. 0729: 436

vizier. Ochotona rufescens. 0670; 762

vocalor. Jaiuliis luftiisi. 0922: 441

viilairti, Aepontys, 0262: 452

vutcani. Lagidittm, 0860: 133

vulcaniiLS, Pteropus hypomelanus, 0756; 388

viilcanius, Sciurus ritwenzorii. 0611; 476

vukitnoriim, Tatnisctts. 0827; 35

vulturna. Ochotona rufescenx, 0871; 937

vulturntis, Dendromus {Poemys) nignfrons. 0794: 242

vulturnus. Eptesicits caurinus, 0730; 440

vuhiirnits, Jacultts jacitliis, 0713; 485

vuliurniis, Neotomys, 0927; 612

vulturnus, Pogonomys forbesi, 0890: 535

walkcn. Cephalophus. 0512: 1. 0526: 464, pi. 35

Katkeri. Nvctophthis. 0108; 406

walli. Eplesicus. 0864: 746

nartli. Bhirindttt. 0752; 336

wardi, Cervictipru reduncu, 0300: 304

wardi, Microtus (Antelioniys), 0683; 516

wardi. Ptecotus. 0646; 209

wcirdi. Rhizomys. 0901; 504

wardi. Sorex, 0647: 3; 0649; 165

warreni. Petrodrotnus tetradactytus, 0837; 364

warreni. Proechimys. 0484: 312

watsoni. Artibeus. 0326: 542

watsoni, Tylomys. 0276: 278

wavrini. Oryzomys. 0895: 177

welki. Rattus. 0933: 26

weynsi. Cephalophus. 0344; 15. pi. 6

whitukeri. Lepus. 0366; 39; 0367: 12, pi. !

whitehead!. Chrotomys. 0197; 161; 0263; 391, pis. 32,

35, figs. 8-9
whitehead!. Harpyionycteris. 0206; 244; 0263: 384, pi.

30, fig. 1, pi. 35, figs. 1-4
whileheadi. Kerivuula. 0171: 460
whileheadi. Mus, 0170; 452, 457
whileheadi. Sciurus. 0051; 127:0073: 231, pi. 24
whitesidei. Cercopithecus ascanius, 0614: 542
whytei. Georychus. 0219; 1; 0221: 432; 0242: 937
whytei. Lepus. 0154; 142
wilkmsi. Petrogale. 1033: 185
willianui. AUactaga. 0228: 309
wilsoni, Acomys. 0112: 22
wilsoni. Malacomys. 0792: 238
wintimi. Laepholis. 0323: 460

wilherbyi. Mus sylvaluiis. 0389: 490

wolffsohni. Phyilotis. 0350: 131

wolffsohni. Vi.icaccia. 054 1 : 440

wollasloni. Hipposideros. 0717: 205:0737: 318

wollastoni. Ochotona. 0937: 184

woodfordi. Nesonycteris. (K)41: 147: 0044: 324, figs.

2-3, pi. 26; (K166: 476
woodfordi. Nesonycteris. A 17: 1 (nomen nudum)
woodfordi, Pteropus. 0056: 156; 0066: 472, pi. 20, fig.

l,pl. 21, fig. 1
woodi. Scotoecus. 0806: 280
woodwardi. Laomys. 0598: 373
woodwardi. Macropus robustus. 0343: 395
woodwardi. Mus. 0582: 374
woo.mami. Ellobius. 0495; 23; 0498: 526
woosnami. Lophuromys. 0519: 146
wroughtoni. Arvicanthis. 0616; 85
wroughtoni. Dacnomys. 0945: 430
wroughtoni. Nvctinomus. 0711; 87, 2 figs.
wroughtoni, Scotophilus, 0230; 275

xanthella, Felis ochreata. 1040; 291
xanthinus. Dasypterus ega, 0233: 544
xanthoeolus. Oryzomys, 0169: 354
xanti. Lepus californicus. 0243: 45
Xeromys, 0075; 248

yakai, Micrornys geisha. 0496: 362
youngi. Rallus. 1051: 309
yucataniae. Coendou mexicanus. 0383: 249
yulei. Funisciurus. 0352: 24; 0355: 120
yunalis. Pfagumaj Ifarvatusj. 0928: 617
yunalis. Tupaia belangeri. 0725: 244
yungimus. Oryzomys. 0350; 130
vungarum. Dasvprocta variegata. 0639: 505

zaphiri. Lophuromys. 0525: 304

zappeyt, Ochotona. 0938: 192

Zetis. 0567: 245

zetta. Mazama. 0715; 586

zevlanicus. Herpestes smithii. 0932: 24

zurUla. Conepatus. 0283: 217

zorrida. Pseudatopex. 0903: 383

zuluensis. Lycaon pictus. 0452: 98, footnote

zuluensis. Mus coucha. 0483: 268

zuluensi.s. Njesotragusl livingstonianus, 0267; 317

Zyzomys. 0598; 372

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

My thanks are due to the sometime Keeper of Zoology at the British Museum (Natural
History), Mr. J. F. Peake, who has provided facilities that have enabled me to carry out
and complete this essay into the past, and to the Head of Library Services, Mr. R. E. R.
Banks, who has made available the resources of the library in his charge, and who has

112

J. E. HIIL

been a constant source of encouragement. Mr. R. A. Fish. Librarian at the Zoological
Society of London was able tt) produce copies of some of the Society's less well known
publications. The staff of the Mammal Section at the Museum have as always extended
numerous courtesies to an erstwhile colleague, and I am grateful also to my wife for her
support and especially for the arrangement of the inde.x.

APPENDIX 1

Unofficial workers or volunteers during Thomas' service as Assistant in charge of
mammals at the British Museum (Natural History).

K. Andersen ('The Viking')

G. Barrett-Hamilton

Dorothea M. Bate

J. L. Bonhote

Winifred Davison

W. de Winton

D. G, Elliot

T. B. Fry ('Brother Tom')

M A C Hinton
R. Lvdekker
G. S. Miller
R. I. Pocock
Kathleen V. Rylcy
li. Schwann
Jane St. Leger
R. C. Wroughton

APPENDIX 2

Mammals named after Oldfield Thomas.

Microgate thomasi Forsyth Major. 1896
Sorex ihomasi Ogne\ , 1921
Btarina ihomasi Merriam. 1897
Crocidura thomasi Sowcrby. 1917
Rhinolophus thomasi Andersen. 1905
Lonchophylla ihomasi J. A. Allen. 1904
Uroderma thomasi Andersen. 1906
Myolis thomasi Cabrera. 1901
Mimetilhts ihomasi Hinton. 1920
Tadarida thomasi Wroughton, 1919
Opotemur thomasi Forsyth Major. 1894
Gala^o iHemigalago) thomasi Elliot, 1907
Midas thomasi Goeldi, 1907
Lagothrix thomasi Elliot, 1909
Cercopithecus thomasi Matschic, 1905
Ursus ornaliis thomasi llornaday, 1911
Lyncodon patagimicus thomasi Cabrera, 1928
Crocula thomasi Cabrera, 1911
Felis pajeros thomasi I.onnberg, 191.1
Felis (Microfelis) nigripes thomasi Shortridge.

1931
Sciuri4s ihomasi Nelson. 1899
Funamhulids thomasi Wroughton & Davison,

1919

Pelaiirisla thomasi Hose. I9(K)

Pelaunsta leucogcnys ihomasi Kiiroda & Mori,

1923 (renamed Pctaiinsla leucogenvs hinloni

Mori. 1923)
Oldfieldthomasia Ameghino. 1901
Procavia thomasi Neumann, 1901
Odocoik'us thomasi Merriam. 1898
Cephatophus thomasi Jcntink. 1901
Cobus ihomasi Sclater. 1896
Rhymhotragus thomasi Neumann. 1905
Thomasomys Coucs. 1884
PcmmvsciLS iMcgadontomys) thomasi Merriam.

1898
Zygodontomys thomasi i . A. Allen. 19(11
Rheomys ihomasi Dickey. 1928
l.ophiomvs ihomasi Heller. 1912
Otomys thomasi Osgood .1910
Microtus (Pilvm\'s) thomasi Barrett-Hamilton.

1903
Mus thomasi de Winton, 1897
Salpingotus thomasi Vinogradov, 1928
Mesomys thomasi Ihering, 1897

M. R. O. THOMAS 113

REFERENCES

Andersen, K. 1412. Cuhitogue of the Chiroplera in the collection of the lirilisb Museum. 2nil ed. I.

Megtichiropterii. London: British Museum (Natural History).
Hinton, M.A.C. 1929 Mr. M. R. Oldficld Thomas. Nature. London 124 (31 16): 101-102.
Martin Duncan, F. 1937. On the dates of publication of the Society's 'Proceedings', 1859 - 1926.

With an appendix containing the dates of publication of 'Proceedings', 1830 - 1858, compiled by

the late F. H. Waterhouse, and of the 'Transactions', 1833 - 1869, by the late Henry Peavot,

originally published in P. Z. S. 1893, 1913. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London

71-84.
Miller, G. S. 1912. Catalogue of the mammals of western Europe. London: British Museum

(Natural History).

1915. The jaw of Piltdown Man. Smithsonian Miscellaneous Collections 65 ( 12) : 1-31 , 5 pis.

1918. The Piltdown jaw. American Journal of Physical Anthropology. Washington I : 25-52,

4 pis.
P|ocock], R.I. 1930. Obituary notice of Michael Rogers Oldficld Thomas. (With portrait).

Proceedings of the Royal Society of London (B) 106 : i-v, I pi.
Seba, A. 1734. Locupletissimi rerum naturalium thesauri accurata descriptio, et iconibus artificio-

sissimus expressio, per univcrsam physices historiam .... Amsterdam.

wm

"^

"^

Revista Latinoamericana de Historia
de las Ciencias y la Tecnologta

Editor: Juan Jos^ Saldafia (University of Mexico)

Quipu (Latin American Journal of History of Science and
Technology), is devoted to the history of science and tech-
nology in Latin America. Founded in 1984. it is published
three times a year. Contributions are welcome and articles are
accepted in Spanish, Enghsh, Portuguese and French. Quipu
has become indispensable for all those who study Latin Ameri-
can science and technology as well as for scholars interested
in the diffusion of science in different cultural contexts

Suscription rates for 1989,
including postage and handling:

Latin America:
Individual US $25
Institutional US $40

All other regions:
Individual US $25
Institutional US $60

A complementary collection of Quipu is:

QUIPU NOTEBOOKS
The price of each volume, including postage and handling:

Latin America: US$10 All other regions: US $ 1 5

Orders and suscriptions by check or money order:

Quipu. Apartado Postal 21-873, 04000 Mexico, D.F. MEXICO

CONTENTS

1 The nomenclature of crabs collected during the cruises of HMS Porcupine in
1869 and 1870, with notes on the Norman collection of invertebrata and its
acquisition by the British Museum (Natural History)

A^ L. RICE

25 A memoir and bibliography of Michael Rogers Oldfield Thomas, FRS

J.E.HILL

8

Bulletin

British Museum

(Natural History)

BRmSH MUSEUM
(NATURAL HISTORY)

- 6 DEC 1990

PRESENTID

7001 (>«Y ueaARY

Historical Series

VOLUME 18 NUMBER 2

29 NOVEMBER 1990

The Bulletin of the British Museum of Natural History, instituted in 1949,
is issued in four scientific series. Botany, Entomology, Geology
(incorporating Mineralogy) and Zoology, and an Historical Series.

The Historical Series is edited in the Museum's Department of Library Series
Head of Department: Mr R. E. R. Banks
Editor: Miss P. Gilbert

Papers in the Bulletin are primarily the results of research carried out on the
unique and ever-growing collections of the Museum, both by the scientific staff
and by specialists from elsewhere who make use of the Museum's resources.
Many of the papers are works of reference that will remain indispensable for
years to come.

A volume contains about 256 pages, made up of two numbers: published Spring
and Autumn. Subscriptions may be placed for one or more of the series on an
Annual basis. Individual numbers and back numbers can be purchased and a
Bulletin catalogue, by series, is available. Orders and enquiries should be sent
to:

Sales Department,

Natural History Museum Publications,

Cromwell Road,

London SW7 5BD

Te/ep/jow.- 071-938-9386
fa.v.- 07 1 -938-8709

H'orWZ.wr abbreviation: Bull. Br. Mu.s. nat. Hist {hist. Ser.)
© British Museum (Natural History), 1990

ISBN 0 565 09014 3 Historical Series

ISSN 0068 - 2306 Vol 1 8, No. 2. pp 1 1 5 228

British Museum (Natural History)

Cromwell Road

London SW7 5BD Issued 29 November 1 990

Typeset by J&L Composition Ltd. Filey. North Yorkshire

Printed in England by Henry Ling Ltd. The Dorset Press, Dorchester, Dorset

Bull Br. Mus. Nat. Hist (hisl. Ser.) 18(2): 115-143

IsMcd 24 November 1 W(l

The Challenger Expedition I ^niSH museu

(1872-1876), Henry Bowman (pjatukal H8ST0R

Brady (1835-1891) and the "6 DEC 1990

Challenger Foraminifera -^ o/i y 8 leRA?

ROBERT W YNN JONES l

Chertsey Road. Sunhiiry-on-Thames, Middlesex,

HI' Research Centre.
TWI6 7LN

CONTENTS

Introduction 115

The Challenger Expedition ( 1872-1876) 116

Prelude to the Expedition 116

Aims of the Expedition 122

Dcep-Sea Sediments 1 23

Oceanic Circulation 1 24

Life in the Deep Sea 1 25

Achievements of the Expedition 1 26

'Reports of the Scientific Results of the Voyage of H.M.S.

Challenger' 128

Henry Bowman Brady (1835-1891) 128

Brady Library 133

Brady Family Photograph Album 134

The Challenger Foraminifera 135

Foraminiferal Slides 135

Raw Material 136

Planned Revision to the Taxonomy of the Challenger Foraminifera . . . 138

Acknowledgements 139

Cited References 140

INTRODUCTION

It is now over a hundred years since the cruise of H.M.S. Challenger (1872-1876) and the
subsequent publication of the report on the Challenger foraminifera by Henry Bowman
Brady (1884); indeed, 1991 marks the centenary of Brady's death. So why the interest?
The answer is two-fold but simple.

Firstly, because the Challenger expedition fundamentally and significantly advanced
numerous fields in the earth, life and ocean sciences, and indeed has been described as
representing 'the greatest advance in the knowledge of our planet since the celebrated
geographical discoveries of the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries" (Linkiater, 1972). It
also heralded the dawn of a new, modern, multi-disciplinary era of oceanography, such
that its significance may be justly compared with that of the voyage of the Beagle (made
famous by Charles Darwin) in other areas of scientific interest and endeavour.

116 R. W. JONES

Secondly, because Brady's work on the Challenger foraminifera detailed for the first
time the dominant microfaunal element in the largest biotope on the face of the earth —
the abyssal plains of the deep sea — until shortly beforehand thought to be incapable of
sustaining life. The Challenger Report (Brady. 1884) features 915 (15% of the total
number of extant) species belonging to 368 (44% of the total number of extant) genera,
including the type-species of 284 genera (34%). The comprehensiveness and attention to
detail exhibited in this work is such that it remains the most famous of the classic
monographs of foraminiferal studies and the most often cited. Also, of all the collections
in the British Museum (Natural History), none is more important or more frequently
consulted than the Challenger coWecUon.

This paper consists chiefly of historical notes on the Challenger expedition, bio-
graphical notes on H. B. Brady and curatorial notes on the Challenger foraminifera. The
concluding part outlines plans for a taxonomic revision of the Challenger foraminifera.

THE CHALLENGER EXPEDITION (1872-1876)

Prelude to the Expedition

The reasoning behind the commissioning of the Challenger expedition is best understood
in its historical context. Britain in the latter half of the last century was at her mightiest as
an imperial power. She was above all a maritime power, proud of her naval achievements
at war and in peace-time.

When the news of impending American and German voyages of scientific exploration
broke in London in 1871. William Benjamin Carpenter (1813-1885) urged prompt action
to maintain Britain's leading position in marine science. In an address to the Royal
Institution and later in a letter to G. G. Stokes (Secretary of the Royal Society, of which
Carpenter was President). Carpenter suggested the draughting and submission to
parliament of a joint plan for a circumnavigation of the globe which would take the
concepts and techniques developed and pioneered on the North-East Atlantic voyages of
the Lightning ( 1868) and Porcupine (1869. 1870) and put them to work on the oceans of
the world. In further correspondence with George Goschen (First Lord of the
Admiralty), Carpenter received assurances that the government would give favourable
consideration to such a proposal.

Carpenter was a remarkable man who held a number of honorary positions and titles
and was at various times Lecturer on Medical Jurisprudence at the Bristol Medical
School, Lecturer on Physiology at the London Hospital, Fullerian Professor of
Physiology at the Royal Institution and Professor of Forensic Medicine at University
College, London and Registrar of the University of London. In the words of the
Dictionary of National Biography (Lee. 1898), he was "... a man of no ordinary mental
grasp and range of study . . .' and '. . . one of the last examples of an almost universal
naturalist . . .'. He published variously on physiology, behavioural psychology, evolu-
tionary theory (a deeply religious man who played the organ at the Unitarian Church in
Hampstead, he was a rather reluctant ally of Darwin) and microscopy, always in a lucid
and often ratiocinative style. He was a particular authority on oceanography, marine
biology and foraminiferology (see, for instance. Carpenter, 1862. 1883; Murray. 1971.
1981, 1989; Murray & Taplin. 1984a-b).

Once Carpenter's circumnavigation plan had been tacitly approved by the Admiralty,
and the approval communicated to the Royal Society, a committee was set up under the
auspices of that august body which comprised Carpenter himself, J. D. Hooker.

THE CHALLENGER EXPEDITION

117

J,''l,. .^-tvl,^,

'},.'&' .«<>^Cj.v. X\{.h

.V ,,-;.jd„ .''!.., 1 ... ':' iv! J

;>r«s.^ .5 ^1^.^ '5^

Plate I Top left:Carpenter Top right: Hooker Bottom left: Huxley Bottom right: Jeffreys. From the Brady
Family Photograph Album. Reproduced by kmd permission of Newcastle-upon-Tyne City Libraries & Arts.

118

R. W. JONES

mm

Plate 2 Top: H M.S. Challenger in starboard view with funnel lowered. Middle: Plans for her refit Bollom:

Port view with funnel raised. Sydney approaches. June 1874. Reproduced by kind permission of the trustees of

the National Maritime Museum, (ireenwich

THE CHALLENGER EXPEDITION 1 1 9

T. H. Huxley, J. G. Jeffreys (see Plate 1), Captain Richards. Professor Charles Wyville
Thomson and Sir William Thomson (later Lord Kelvin). On the recommendation of
these eminent personages, the Council of the Royal Society made a formal request to the
government to send out an expedition to undertake a scientific study of the oceans. The
request was granted in April, 1872, and preparations for departure began immediately.
The organisation of the voyage (Burstyn, 1968, 1972) proceeded remarkably swiftly and
efficiently, due doubtless in part to previous experience in similar ventures but probably
also in no small measure to political factors (it is noteworthy that Carpenter had social
contacts with the then Prime Minister Gladstone).

A suitable vessel, H.M.S. Challenger (Rice, 1986; Plate 2) was chosen in the summer
of 1872, and a schedule for her voyage drawn up for which the Navy Hydrographer G. H.
Richards was largely responsible. Challenger was a 226', 1462-ton (builder's measure-
ment) or 23()6-ton (displacement) 'Pearl" class steam-assisted screw corvette. Her
engines were nominally of 400 h.p. but capable of 1234 h.p., and she also carried 16000
square feet of sail. She had been built at Woolwich in 1858 and had seen naval service off
the Americas and later in Australasia before returning to England in 1871. Preparatory
to what was to become her most famous voyage, she was fitted out at Sheerness, where
all but two of her twenty-two cannon were removed to make way for a dredging platform
over the upper deck forward of the main mast, extra laboratories, work-rooms and
storage space.

The Aberdonian Captain (later Rear-Admiral Sir) George Strong Nares (1829-1915)
was chosen by the Admiralty to take the helm. Under him were some score of officers
and crew (see Plate 3), including Paymaster R. R. A. Richards, Lieutenant P. Aldrich,
Lieutenant A. Balfour, Sub-Lieutenant Campbell and Navigating Sub-Lieutenant
Swire, all of whom kept journals (Swire's being memorable for some less than reverential
references to Wyville Thomson's appearance and manner!) Nares left Challenger in 1874
to lead the Alerl and Discovery Arctic expedition, and was replaced by Captain Frank
Tourle Thomson. Aldrich left with him and was replaced by a Lieutenant A. Carpenter.

Wyville Thomson (see Plate 3) was appointed by the Royal Society as head of the
civilian scientific team. Carpenter at 59 having decided he was too old to put to sea again.
He was to be assisted on board by secretary and ship's artist John James Wild, chemist
John Young Buchanan (see Plate 3) and three naturalists, Henry Nottidge Moseley,
Rudolph von Willemoes-Suhm (whose promising career was cut short when he died on
board Challenger) and John Murray.

Wyville Thomson was born in 1830 at Linlithgow in Scotland and received his early
education at Merchiston Castle School. He matriculated at the age of sixteen as a student
of Medicine at Edinburgh University, where he seems largely to have pleased himself in
the choice of lectures he attended, taking in such subjects as zoology, botany and
geology; he was also active in his role as Secretary of the Royal Physical Society. He gave
up his medical studies in 1850 on the grounds of ill health and embarked instead on a
career in natural science, succeeding to the posts of Lecturer in Botany at King's College,
Aberdeen in 1850, Professor of Botany at Marischal College, Aberdeen in 1851,
Professor of Natural History at Queen's College, Cork in 1853, Professor of Mineralogy
and Geology at Queen's College, Belfast in 1854, Professor of Zoology and Botany at
Belfast in 1860 and Allman Professor of Natural History at Edinburgh University in
1870. He was reputedly a delightful and instructive lecturer on a variety of scientific
subjects, speaking without notes but with constant reference to the profusive array of
specimens on his table.

Wyville Thomson was, with Carpenter, instrumental in setting up the Lightning and
Porcupine expeditions, the results of which were published in his book The Depths of the
Sea (Wyville Thomson, 1873). He was widely recognised on account of this work as an
active instigator and leading spirit of new and successful investigations. It was natural

120

R. W. JONES

-#

Plate 3 Top left: The crew of H M.S. Chiillcnf;er. Slaniliiif; (left lo right): Balfour. Buchanan, Willcmoes-

Suhm, Aldrich, Ass. Engineer W. A. Howlelt, Wild, Swire, Ass. Paymaster J. Hynes, Moseley, Sub.-l.ieul. A.

Channer, Richards. Sub.-Lieul. H. H. Harslon. Murray, Lieut. A. C. Bromley Sealed (left lo ri);hl): ("dr. J. F

1.. P. Maclear, Surgeon (i. Maclean, Nav. Sub.-l.ieul. A. Havergal. Wyvillc Thomson, l^ngineer W, J, .1. Spry.

Nares, Staff Surgeon A. Crosby, l.ieut. G. R. Bethel, unknown Bultnm left: Pen and wash sketch by l-li/abelh

Gulland showing Wyville Thomson (left) and Buchanan (right) at work on board (hallrnurr Right: Original

drawing made by Wild on board Challcnfier ol the planklonic foraminifer lllnhii^vrina hiilloulfs d'Orbigny,

subsequently used in the Challenf;er Report (Brady, 1XX4; PI. 77). Signed bottom left Reproduced by kmd

permission of Edinburgh University Library.

THE CHALLENGER EXPEDITION

121

.V *i -Ml

■f/J'%.

,;f^^' MOO

therefore that he should be appointed as chief naturalist on the Challenger expedition. It
is unfortunate that his heahh broke down in the wake of the expedition and that he did
not have the freedom to finish his original research on the Challenger crinoids and
sponges, having to concentrate instead on his administrative responsibilities. None-
theless he received international recognition for his career on the Challenger, which he
wrote up in the form of the scholarly and erudite book The Voyage of the Challenger . . .
(Wyville Thomson, 1877). For instance, he received a Royal Society Gold Medal in 1876
(having already acceded to the fellowship of that institution in 1869) and was made a
Knight of the British Empire in 1876 and a Knight of the Polar Star (an honorary title
bestowed at the University of Uppsala on the occasion of its quatercentenary celebra-
tions) in 1877. He died in 1882, wherepon a memorial window was installed in the
Linlithgow Cathedral and a bust in Edinburgh University. Further details of his life are
given by Herdman (1923).

Moseley was a no less able or enthusiastic fellow, of whom it was once said that 'you
had only to put him down on a hillside with a piece of string and an old nail, and in an
hour or two he would have discovered some natural object of surpassing interest'
(Herdman, 1923). He wrote up his experiences on board Challenger in the lively and

122 R- W. JONES

enjoyable book Notes by a Naturalist . . . (Moseley, 1879). the enduring popularity of
which is evident from the fact that it was reprinted as recently as 1944 in a series entitled
Live Books Resurreciedl He went on from his Challenger exploits to become a Fellow of
the Royal Society and Linacre Professor of Human and Comparative Anatomy at
Oxford.

Murray (see, for instance, Herdman, 1923 & Boog Watson, 1967) was Canadian-bom
but of Scots ancestry. He registered as a medical student at Edinburgh University, where
one of his fellow students, Robert Louis Stevenson, came to criticise him for failing to
pursue his studies in orderly, purposive and profitable fashion'. Rather like Wyville
Thomson before him. he attended lectures not strictly connected with his course-work,
for instance on chemistry, natural history, literature, law and theology. He spent his
summer vacations indulging his interests in marine biology and oceanography in
dredging trips off the Scottish coasts (on one such occasion meeting Sir William Thomson
on Skye) and had enterprisingly enrolled as a surgeon aboard the whaler Jan Mayen in
1868, spending 7 months in the Arctic. Enough was known of the rare talent of this
remarkable man even by 1872, when he was only 31, that he was appointed to the
prestigious post of Challenger naturalist (albeit as a replacement for William Stirling,
who had resigned his appointment) on the recommendation of the eminent Edinburgh
University physicist Professor Peter Guthrie Tait. He is acknowledged as the "father of
modern oceanography" on account of his many achievements in the wake of the
Challenger cruise. He went on to be made a Fellow of the Royal Society in 1896 and was
knighted in 1898.

By December, 1872, the scientists and crew were assembled and all the necessary
equipment was on board. Most of the equipment had been tried and tested on earlier
voyages. Nets, trawls and dredges were to be put out on hempen lines. Temperature
measurements were to be taken with Miller-Casella thermometers (appropriately
compensated for pressure), though some Siemen's and Johnson's instruments were also
taken (as was Siemen's photometric apparatus). Intermediate depth water samples were
to be collected by a stopcock water bottle designed by Buchanan and deep water samples
by a slip water bottle used by the German North Sea expedition. Bottom sediment
samples were to be brought up from the sea floor using a Hydra sounding tube, modified
in 1873 by Lieutenant C. W. Baillie. Only Sir William Thomson's sounding device,
comprising piano-wire wound around a drum, was an unknown quantity. This had
proved successful in trials aboard the Lalla Rookh in comparatively shallow water, but
when it was tried aboard Challenger its drum collapsed; hence, depth measurements
aboard Challenger came to be taken with hempen lines and are inaccurate. Many of the
instruments used aboard Challenger arc figured by McConnell (1981).

Challenger finally set sail from Portsmouth on 21 December 1872. Her three-and-a-
half year long voyage covered some 68890 nautical miles and involved sampling at 362
stations, besides coaling stops or more protracted periods ashore at a great many ports-
of-call (at many of which her crew attended or organised lavish social functions). She
returned to Spithead on 24 May 1876, and was broken up at Chatham in 1921. Only her
figurehead survives to this day, outside the Institute of Oceanographic Sciences in
Wormley, Surrey.

Aims of the Expedition

Challenger was confidently expected to bring back the answers to all the questions posed
by earlier studies of the North-East Atlantic. These were concerned largely with the
nature and distribution of bottom sediments, with problems of oceanic circulation and
with the very existence of life itself in the deepest parts of the oceans.

THE CHALLENGER EXPEDITION 123

Deep-Sea Sediments

With regard to the nature of bottom sediments, important new discoveries were made
almost from the outset of the voyage. The first samples recovered from the sea bed
proved, as expected, to be of pale grey 'Globigerina ooze'. It had been predicted that this
would cover the entire sea floor. However, as the cruise progressed westward on the leg
from Teneriffe to the West Indies and into ever deeper waters, the nature of the
recovered sediments was observed gradually to change. They became darker and darker
in colour, and upon microscopical examination proved to comprise fewer and fewer
foraminiferal remains.

On 18 February 1873, deep-water samples from Station 3 (24 deg. 45'N; 20 deg.,
14'W) were observed to contain "a number of very peculiar black oval bodies about an
inch long". These were first thought to be fossils or lumps of pitch, but Buchanan's
chemical analyses showed them to be composed of almost pure manganese peroxide.
They were the first recorded examples of what we now term manganese nodules.

On 26 February 1873. a sample brought up from 3150fm. proved to comprise, in
Wyville Thomson's words 'a perfectly smooth red clay, containing scarcely a trace of
organic matter'. Wyville Thomson's initial surmise was that this would turn out to be a
local phenomenon. This seemed to be borne out when, from the shallower Dolphin Rise,
more 'Globigerina ooze' was recovered. However, the passage into the deeper waters of
the Western Atlantic again saw clay return as the dominant substrate.

The widespread distribution of clay on the sea floor was confirmed on the leg between
the West Indies by way of the Puerto Rico Trench to Bermuda. This necessitated a
reconsideration by Wyville Thomson of its significance. He came to regard it as typical of
deep areas, supposing these areas to be too deep to sustain the 'Globigerinae' that made
up shallower sediments. As Murray had by this time shown that 'Globigcrinae were
planktonic organisms ubiquitous in surface waters and raining down upon the whole sea
floor upon death, a problem arose. What could account for their absence in deep areas?
Close inspection of samples from progressively deeper waters showed a progressive
disappearance not only of foraminifera but also of all other calcareous organisms.
Wyville Thomson came to the conclusion that a chemical reaction was removing calcium
carbonate at depth and that the product of this reaction was clay. Buchanan invoked
carbonic acid as responsible for the carbonate dissolution, and modelled the reaction in
his laboratory. The 'snow line' below which calcite passes into solution was first
described by Murray and the Belgian Abbe Renard. It was with this that the modem idea
of the calcite compensation depth was conceived, though it was not until the latter half of
this century that it was named as such and fully quantified.

In 1875 Challenger set out into the Pacific for the first time, following the American
U.S.S. Tiiscarora and the German S.S. Gazelle. The combined efforts of all three vessels
showed this ocean to differ markedly from all others, not only in terms of its greater areal
extent but also in terms of its greater depth. By virtue of the latter feature, it was found
also to comprise proportionately larger areas underlain by clay. Here, though, the clay
was associated with larger mineral particles. This led Murray to question Wyville
Thomson's theory that the clay represented the residue derived from dissolution of
'Globigerina ooze'. Murray came to favour a volcanic origin for the clay, citing as
evidence the proximity of numerous volcanic centres (the "Pacific ring of fire') and the
relative ease with which their products could be transported into deep water. Militating
somewhat against this was the associated occurrence of manganese nodules of apparently
concretionary habit. Murray ascribed the origin of these nodules to volcanism also, while
Buchanan had by this time come to favour mineralisation of organic remains as the most
likely mechanism for their formation. Later, the French geologist Dieulafait
hypothesised that they originated by precipitation from sea water at the surface following

124 R. W. JONES

a reaction between salt water and the atmosphere. Even to this day. their precise origin
remains somewhat problematic.

Oceanic Circulation

In 1873. on the leg between Bermuda and Halifax, Nova Scotia, a detour was made to
enable Challenger to study the Gulf Stream. This had first been described by the
sixteenth-century explorer Ponce de Leon, following a voyage from Puerto Rico to
Teneriffe which crossed what is now termed the Florida Current in the vicinity of Cape
Canaveral. Conjectures about its nature were published by Peter Marytr of Anghrera
also in the sixteenth century, and the line of demarcation between warm and cold water
masses was first recorded by Lescarbot in the seventeenth. Cold water eddies were
known by 1810, and there had been a great deal of subsequent research done by the U.S.
Coast Survey: a synthesis of data had been published in 1868.

Serial temperature measurements made by the Challenger crew essentially confirmed
what had been observed earlier, namely that there was a relatively shallow body of warm
water forming the current and a deeper body of cool water underlying it and rising to the
surface at its western flank.

Velocity measurements were made both at the surface and at depth on the whole of
the ensuing equatorial Atlantic leg in order to ascertain whether there was any
subsurface movement of water in a direction counter to that at the surface. A drogue of
similar design to that used by Nares and his crew aboard the Shearwater was used to track
the undercurrents. At Station 106, it was shown using this apparatus that the stength of
the surface current diminished with increasing depth and ceased to have any measurable
effect at 75fm. Unfortunately, the shipboard scientists were content to note at this
juncture 'how very superficial the Equatorial Current is". Had they made additional
measurements at greater depth, they would undoubtedly have discovered for the first
time the existence of the Equatorial Counter Current. As it transpired, this was
discovered by Buchanan during a subsequent cruise on the cable vessel Buccaneer.

As Challenger sailed from the Cape Verde Islands to Brazil, the temperature readings
that she was taking were observed to form a distinct pattern. Nares speculated that the
'cold stream' to the west was separated from warmer waters to the east by a north-south
trending shoal system (subsequently confirmed by sounding) that acted as a barrier to
mixing. We now recognise this as the Mid- Atlantic Ridge, a centre of sea-floor
spreading, and the Walvis Ridge (discovered when Challenger re-entered the South
Atlantic in 1876) running roughly at right angles to it as a transform fault system. The
numerous 'sills' recorded in the East Indian archipelago are also now interpreted in
terms of modern plate tectonic theory, as parts of an island arc system.

While the Challenger crew and scientists relaxed at one of their many ports-of-call
(Sydney, Australia) in March 1874, controversy was raging back in England over the
causes of ocean currents. It had been contended by Carpenter that the motive force lay in
the superior weight of one column of water over another. This thesis was held to be
untenable by James Croll, in that it presupposed the existence of a significant difference
in level between one part of the ocean and another. Observations from the Challenger
cruise did seem to indicate that a dynamic circulatory system could be generated and
maintained by temperature gradients, as then advocated by Carpenter. But Croll
remained unconvinced, citing wind-stress as an equally likely alternative explanatory
mechanism. He attacked Carpenter from many fronts, having at his disposal a greater
knowledge of physical processes and a commendable tenacity. But he was unable to win
the war of words, in which Carpenter's literary grace was a great advantage, or indeed to
shift Carpenter from his entrenched position. Later, Wyville Thomson was to argue that

THE CHALLENGER EXPEDITION 125

there was not the slightest ground for supposing that such a thing existed as 'a general
vertical circulation of the water of the oceans depending upon differences of specific
gravity".

The debate ended somewhat acrimoniously and far from satisfactorily. The modern
view (e.g. Sverdrup, Fleming & Johnson, 1942) is that no one simple model in isolation
can explain the dynamics of ocean circulation. Rather, it is seen as due to the dynamic
interaction of a large number of variable forces and as resulting in a complex series of
inter-related movements. We can thus perhaps excuse Carpenter and Croll their
simplistic models, which at least accounted for some of the phenomena observed by their
time.

Life in the Deep Sea

As recently as the 1840's, Edward Forbes, a lecturer in natural sciences, had stated quite
categorically following the voyages of the Beacon in 1841 and 1842 that conditions below
3()0fm. were incapable of sustaining life. He saw this as due to the lack of light
penetration at those depths, which meant that there could be no photosynthesis. This in
turn meant that there could be no plant life and consequently therefore neither the
oxygen nor the primary food source necessary for the sustenance of animal life.

Wyville Thomson, though, had cause to doubt Forbes's 'Azoic Theory'. He was aware
of the findings of lowly life-forms at great depths during the voyage of the Bulldog in
1860 (Wallich, 1862) and had first-hand reports of the forms attached to the Bona
submarine cable off Sardinia at a depth of KMtOfm. from his Edinburgh colleague
Fleeming Jenkin. He had therefore set sail in 1868 aboard the Lightning and in 1869
aboard the Porcupine to investigate for himself the possibility of life in the deep-sea,
finding abundant evidence of it to depths of 6()0fm . off the Shetlands and Faeroes on the
former cruise and to 20(X)fm. off Ushant on the latter. It was with the publication of the
results of the voyages of the Lightning and Porcupine (Wyville Thomson, 1873) that
Forbes's 'Azoic Theory' finally came to be discredited (Rice et al., 1976; Mills, 1978,
1984; Rehbock, 1979; Rice, 1986).

Nonetheless, it still came as something of a revelation when Challenger discovered
worm tubes from a depth of about 3(X)0fm. in March 1873. These were identified by
Willemoes-Suhm as Annelida. This, and subsequent similar discoveries, prompted
Wyville Thomson to note that 'conditions of the bottom are not only such as to admit the
existence of life, but are such as to allow of the unlimited extension of the distribution of
animals high in the zoological series, and closely in relation to the faunae of shallower
zones'. It was inevitable in the light of this finding that there would come to be developed
a theory of abyssal circulation and regeneration of bottom waters.

Meanwhile, important observations were also being made on the surface-dwelling and
intermediate faunae recovered by plankton tows. Murray was able to document for the
first time the diurnal vertical migration of many species. He was also able to confirm that
the planktonic foraminifera in surface waters (see Plate 3, p. 120) were of the same
species as those comprising the bulk of the underlying sediments. Up until this time, it
was only surmised and sometimes openly contested that the 'Glohigerina ooze' consisted
essentially of planktonic rather than benthonic species.

Also of note was the finding that the abundance and diversity of planktonic
foraminifera varied greatly with latitude. The diversity tended to be much lower in
higher latitudes, and in the highest latitudes few if any specimens were found: here, the
'Glohigerina ooze' passed into diatom ooze.

Particularly noteworthy was the following observation, probably the first on any living
planktonic foraminifer, by Wyville Thomson (1877):

126 R. W . JONES

On one occasion in the Pacific, when Mr Murray was out in a boat in a dead calm
collecting surface creatures, he took gently up in a spoon a litle globular gelatinous
mass with a red centre and transferred it to a tube. The globule gave us our first and
last chance of seeing what a pelagic foraminifer really is when in its full beauty. When
placed under the microscope it proved to be a Hastigerina in a condition wholly
different from anything we had yet seen. The spines, which were mostly unbroken,
owing to its mode of capture, were enormously long, about fifteen times the diameter
of the shell in length; the sarcode, loaded with yellow oil-cells, was almost all outside
the shell, and beyond the fringe of yellow sarcode the space between the spines to a
distance of about twice the diameter of the shell all round was completely filled up with
delicate bullae ... as if the most perfectly transparent portion of the sarcode has been
blown out into a delicate froth of buttles of uniform size. Along the spines fine double
threads of transparent sarcode. loaded with white granules, coursed up one side and
down the other, while between the spines independent thread-like pseudopodia ran
out. some of them perfectly free and others anastomosing .... but all showing the
characteristic fluid movement of living protoplasm. The [accompanying] woodcut
[based on drawings by Wild, the originals of which are now among the Challenger
MSS. in the Special Collections Department of Edinburgh University Library],
excellent though it is, gives only a most imperfect idea of the complexity and the
beauty of the organism with its swimming or floating machinery in its expanded
condition.

In the deeper parts of the Pacific (below about 40(K)fm.) in 1875 a new type of sediment
was discovered. As this was a type of red clay but contained a high proportion of siliceous
radiolarian scierocoma. it came to be termed radiolarian ooze. Working on this material
led incidentally to the solution of the mystery surrounding Bathyhius. B. haeckelii had
orginally been described by Huxley in 1868 from samples collected by the Cyclops and
preserved in spirit. It was regarded as a form of protoplasm and at the time was central to
the debate on abiogenesis or spontaneous generation of life from mud. Wyville
Thomson, with Buchanan's help, demonstrated apparently conclusively that it was of
mineral origin and represented an artefact of preparation technique (a precipitate in
spirit of the calcium sulphate in sea water). Latterly, Rice (1983) has put forward a
possible alternative hypothesis, envisaging Bathyhius as an aggregated mass of phyto-
plankton bound by an amorphous matrix.

Achievements of the Expedition

From the point of view of increasing knowledge of the nature and distribution of deep-
sea sediments, the voyage of the Challenger was hugely successful. Pioneer work by
Buchanan and especially Murray opened up an almost entirely new field which Murray
was to make peculiarly his own.

Despite primitive sampling methods, the biological aims of the cruise were also amply
fulfilled. A tremendous amount of material was collected from trawling stations from all
over the world and from dredging stations to the greatest depths ever sounded. This
material had been sorted, where necessary preserved and classified into the main
systematic groups for further analysis, identification and description. For this further
study. Wyville Thomson carefully recruited seventy-six acknowledged international
specialists, who for their services received a small honorarium to cover their expenses, a
commemorative Challenger medal and eventually a personal copy of the report in which
their results were published: many appear also to have acquired or sent to Ihcir
colleagues duplicate sets of specimens!

THE CHALLENGER EXPEDITION 1 27

About half of the species described (including about a quarter of the foraminifera)
proved to be entirely new to science. Not only was this taxonomic synthesis invaluable in
its own right, it permitted ecological analysis on an ocean — or world-wide basis for the
first time. The deep-sea fauna proved to be remarkably cosmopolitan. Wyville Thomson
was able to note that it bore close affinities to the shallower water fauna of high latitudes,
'no doubt because the conditions of temperature, on which the distribution of animals
mainly depends, are nearly similar [in the two types of environment)". Also that its
relations with Tertiary and newer Mesozoic faunae were much closer than those of the
faunae of shallow water, though not as close as he had been led to expect.

Only in the area of physical oceanography did the voyage fail to achieve wholly
satisfactory results, though even here it fuelled debate and encouraged further study. Of
all the criticisms that have been levelled at it, the most telling was that it did not
incorporate a physicist. As it was, it was left to the chemist Buchanan to make whatever
measurements he could of density, salinity and dissolved oxygen. Instruments such as the
current drogue and reversing thermometers were certainly not used to their full
potential. It was Buchanan, too, who was able to demonstrate by obtaining from his
piezometers indirect but independent temperature values that the Miller-Casella
readings were inaccurate. In view of this finding, and of the crucial importance of
temperature in the debate on oceanic circulation, all earlier data had to be reassessed. It
was therefore not until 1877, when Wild's book Thalassa was published, that the physical
results of the Challenger cruise were adequately synthesised.

Contemporary opinions on the value of the Challenger expedition were divided. One
rather bitter contemporary British commentator wrote, in an article reproduced in the
journal Hydrospace in December, 1971:

The first volume recording the adventures of the Challenger yachting trip is
now out, and the other fifty-nine will be ready in less than a century.
Everyone knows that Mr. Lowe sent a man-of-war laden with Professors, and
that these learned individuals amused themselves for four years. They played
with thermometers, they fished to all depths from two feet to three miles, they
brought up bucketfuls of stuff from the deep-sea bottom, and they plottered
about and imagined they were furthering the Grand Cause of Science. Then
the tons of rubbish were brought home, and the genius who bossed the
expedition proceeded to employ a swarm of foreigners to write monographs
on the specimens. There were plenty of good scientific men in England, but
the true philosopher is nothing if not cosmopolitan; so the taxpayers' money
was employed in feeding a mob of Germans and other aliens. The whole
business has cost two hundred thousand pounds; and in return for this sum we
have got one lumbering volume of statistics, and a complete set of squabbles
which are going on briskly wherever two or three philosophers are gathered
together. I believe the expedition discovered one new species of shrimp, but I
am not quite sure.

In contrast, a letter (now among the Challenger MSS. in the Special Collections
Department of Edinburgh University Library) signed by the Austrian scientist Suess and
several of his colleagues, dated 12 June 1876 and addressed to 'The Editors of the
Periodical Nature, London', reads:

Gentlemen, After having followed the reports of the Naturalists of H.M. Ship
Challenger with the utmost interest we beg leave to ask you kindly to transmit
this simple but sincere expression of a hearty welcome and of thankful
admiration to those distinguished gentlemen, as well as to the officers and

128 R. W. JONES

crew of this gallant ship which has been called to render so prominent services
to science.

The consensus of current opinion (as apparent from retrospective reviews written in
commemoration of the Challenger centenary (Deacon (1971, 1972), Linklater (1972).
Yonge ( 1972) & Charnock (1973)) is that the Challenger expedition was one of the most
significant in the history of science.

'Reports of the Scientific Results of the Voyage of H.M.S. Challenger'.

The publication of the Reports of the Scientific Results of the Voyage of H.M.S.
Challenger was the joint responsibility of the series editor and the Treasury. Wyville
Thomson was the editor until his resignation on the grounds of ill health at the end of
1881, whereupon Murray was appointed as successor. Treasury parsimony then led to
Murray drawing on his own personal fortune to finance the publication of the fifty
lavishly-illustrated royal quarto Challenger volumes to appear between 1880 and 1895.
these included a Narrative of the Cruise: a General Account of the Scientific Results of the
Expedition by Murray, Buchanan, Moseley and Staff-Commander Tizard. published in
two parts in 1885, and six other volumes to which Murray contributed personally.

Incidentally, the cost of the whole enterprise (estimated at one hundred and seventy
thousand pounds sterling) was more than offset by the profits brought about by the
exploitation of the phosphate deposits of Christmas Island in the Indian Ocean. These
had been discovered quite by chance in 1886 by the FIving Fish, on a cruise which had
been organised by Murray for the purpose of increasing knowledge of coral reefs. When
Murray heard about the discovery from the Commanding Officer of the Flying Fish who
had served with him on the Challenger, he was quick to turn unexpected good fortune to
greater advantage. He promptly hired the geologist H. P. Guppy to conduct a detailed
survey, and, when he found out that the phosphate deposits were of commercial
importance, urged annexation of the island and its valuable resources to Great Britain.
On 4 April 1888, he wrote a letter (which survives to this day in the Palaeontology
Library of the British Museum (Natural History) and makes interesting reading) to Sir
Henry Thurston Holland, Secretary of State for the Colonies, on this subject, and in
June of that year, the Imperieuse landed on Christmas Island and hoisted the Union Flag
there.

Murray, ever astute in matters of business, then helped to found the Christmas Island
Phosphate Company, which, as the Admiralty Hydrographer later wrote 'provided . . .
more than the whole cost of the Challenger expedition". After the death of co-founder
Irvine, some of the company's profits were used to set up the Irvine Chair of
Bacteriology at Edinburgh University which is still in place to this day.

This illuminating episode in Murray's life is chronicled in an article that appeared in
the Scotsman of 8th March 1914 entitled "Christmas Island: Fortune from a No-Man's
Land'.

HENRY BOWMAN BRADY (1835-1891)

Henry Bowman Brady (see Plate 4) was born on 22 February 1835 in Gateshead in the
Norlh-East of England, where his parents had settled in 1829. His father, also called
Henry (1805-1883) was a respected medical practitioner and surgeon: he was also, as his

THE CHALLENGER EXPEDITION

129

Plate 4 Top left: Brady as a young man, probably c. 1868-1870. Top right; Brady as an older man. This is the

best-known photograph of Brady, and is the one used by Adams ( 1978) in his recent biography. Bottom left:

Jones. Bottom right: Parker From the Brady Family Photograph Album Reproduced by kind permission of

Newcastle-upon-Tyne City Libraries & Arts.

130 R. W. JONES

biographers (his son-in-law and daughter) T. C. and H. B. Watson in Steel (1899) put it.
'emphatically a Christian physician' who had "yielded to a call to the ministry' in 1861 and
was a member of the Religious Society of Friends (Quakers), offering prayer with
'marked reverence and fervency' and inculcating in his children moral values which
remained with them throughout their lives. His mother. Hannah (1802-1872). daughter
of Ebenezer and Ann Bowman of One Ash Grange. Derbyshire (where the Brady family
spent its summer holidays) was an 'active worker in many of the charitable agencies of
Gateshead'. His elder brother. George Stewardson (18,^2-1921) went on to occupy the
Chair of Natural History at the University of Durham and to achieve international
recognition for his work on the Ostracoda (see. for instance. Davis & Home. 1985). He
had seven other brothers and sisters, including Thomas, who was born in 1837 and whose
descendants survive to this day (he never himself married).

The young H. B. Brady no doubt had an interest in natural history fostered by his
father (a keen amateur naturalist), by Tuffen West (an apprentice of his father's who was
involved in dredging expeditions supported by the British Association in the 1860's and
later achieved fame as an illustrator of zoological monographs), by the teachers in the
two Quaker schools at which he was educated (Ackworth and Tulketh Hall near
Preston), and by John Storey (a teacher, botanist and Secretary to the Tyneside
Naturalists' Field Club from 1849-1857) and various other members of the colony of
naturalists which had its headquarters in the North-East of England for many genera-
tions (Albany and John Hancock, Bewick and Alder among them).

It was evidently a lifelong interest: one of Brady's many letters to Dr. A. Gunther,
Keeper of Zoology in the British Museum (Natural History), (now in the archives of the
General Library of that institution), dated 19 November 1878, concerned Ant-Eaters.
Another letter to Gunther. headed Devonshire Club. St James's SW and dated 6 May
1887, reads:

You were so kind as to tell me some time ago that if I desired tickets for the
Zoological Gardens I need not hesitate to ask you. Can you provide me with
three tickets for Sunday week. May 15th — I have a niece in town who would
be much pleased by the attention.

Brady left school in 1850 at the age of fifteen to serve as an apprentice to a Mr. T.
Harvey or R. Richards (sources differ), a chemist in Leeds, for four years. He then went
on to study pharmacy in the laboratories of Dr. T. Richardson, the forerunner of the
Newcastle College of Medicine. On graduating in 1855. he set himself up as a wholesale
and retail pharmacist on the comer of St. Nicholas' Square in Newcastle. His commercial
career prospered from the start, possibly because pure drugs had previously been in short
supply. He was soon able to move to larger premises in Mosley Street and to diversify
into the export trade and into the sale of scientific instruments. In the latter function, he
established important contacts with many eminent scientists. His ready acceptance by the
inner sanctum of late nineteenth-century foraminiferologists may have been attributable
in some measure to his business reputation.

Brady's dynamic energy and organisational ability were both evident in his role as
pharmacist. He was largely responsible for the foundation of the British Pharmaceutical
Conference and was an active member thereof, serving both as Treasurer ( 1864-70) and
later President (1872-73). He also served on the Council of the Pharmaceutical Society
and was a member of the Board of Examiners until 1870 (when ill-health forced him to
retire). Further, he did much to promote the scientific education of pharmaceutical
chemists and was instrumental in transforming the Pharmaceutical Journal (to which he
was a regular contributor) from a monthly to a weekly publication. Accolades from
professional colleagues were many. Brady was elected an Honorary Member of the

THE CHALLENGER EXPEDITION 131

American Pharmaceutical Association, the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy and the
Pharmaceutical Societies of St. Petersburg and Vienna.

His hunger for intellectual activity also manifested itself in fields other than those
directly associated with his work, even early on. He became an enthusiastic member of
the Tyneside Naturalists Field Club (incidentally the second oldest in the country) and
the Northumberland, Durham and Newcastle-upon-Tyne Natural History Society. His
first papers on the foraminifera appeared in the I86()"s in the transactions of these
societies and as a report of the British Association for the Advancement of Science
(Brady, 1863, 1864a-b, I865a-b) and essentially concerned those living off the coasts of
his native North-East (see also Woodward, 1972). Another significant milestone in
Brady's early career was the co-publication with Carpenter (Carpenter & Brady, 1869) of
a monograph of the genera Loftusia and Parkeria (the latter now known to be non-
foraminiferal). This work received extremely favourable reviews from Duncan and
Parker, the originals of which are now to be found among the Referees Reports in the
Archives of the Royal Society. It is testimony to Brady's dedication that over thirty
subsequent publications on the group (ranging in age from Silurian to Recent) were
forthcoming during the course of his working life, notwithstanding the many and varied
demands on his time. In recognition of his signal services to natural science he was
elected a Fellow of the Geological Society in 1864 and a Fellow of the Royal Society in
1874. In a letter headed Mosley St., Newcastle-on-Tyne and dated 6 June 1874, Brady
wrote to Stokes at the Royal Society acknowledging the latter honour and adding 'I hope
to be attending for admission on the 18th Sept.'. This letter now resides among the
Miscellaneous Correspondence in the Archives of the Royal Society.

Brady was so successful in business that he was able to sign over his business to his one-
time assistant and later partner Nicholas Martin in 1876 (at the age of 41) and to devote
the remainder of his fruitful life to the full-time study of the foraminifera. In his work on
the group, he was variously associated with most of the leading contemporary
authorities, including his sometime co-authors Carpenter (see Plate I), William Kitchen
Parker and Thomas Rupert Jones (see Plate 4; see also Murray, 1981, 1989). Together
with Fortescue William Millett and William Crawford Williamson, these luminaries
constituted what was to become known as the 'English School'. The broad species
concept of the taxonomically conservative 'English School' contrasted radically with the
philosophy of the 'Continental School' (personified by Auguste Emanuel Reuss,
Christian Gottfried Ehrenberg (see Plate 5), Alcide Dessalines d'Orbigny and others).

The pinnacle of Brady's achievements as a foraminiferal worker was undoubtedly
achieved with the publication of the Report on the Foraminifera dredged by H.M.S.
Challenger During the Years 1873-1876 (hereafter Challenger Report). Brady's work on
this colossal project began in 1878 and ended with the submission to the publishers of the
final instalment in 1884. The 814 pages of text (written in a delightfully idiosyncratic style
far removed from the modern terseness) set new standards of comprehensive presenta-
tion of information and attention to detail and make the Challenger Report an
indispensable reference even to this day. The bibliographic section alone occupies 46
pages! Brady's accuracy of observation was particularly examplary and is perhaps his
most enduring legacy. He personally supervised the production of the 116 magnificent
colour plates by the skilled draughtsman and lithographer A. T. Hollick, which are of a
standard rarely matched before or since. Records in a plate proof receipt and despatch
book owned by James Chumley of the Challenger Office, 45 Frederick Street, Edinburgh
(now in the Special Collections Department of Edinburgh University Library) indicate
that this in itself was a very time-consuming task, beginning in 1882.

In later life, Brady received many prestigious awards and honours for his contributions
to foraminiferal studies, among them a gold medal from the Austrian Emperor Franz
Joseph I (see below) and an honorary doctorate from the University of Aberdeen. The

132

R. W. JONES

Plate S Left: Ehrenberg. Centre: Reuss. Right: Karrcr. From the Brady Family Photograph Album
Reproduced by kind permission of Ncwcastlc-upon-Tync City Libraries & Arts.

letter advising him of tiie latter honour is among some of the uncatalogued Brady papers
in the Library of the Royal Society. It is dated 3 March 1S,S8 and signed H. Alleyne
Nicholson and reads 'My Dear Brady. 1 write a most hurried note in order to catch the
early Sunday mail tomorrow morning for the south, that 1 may have the great pleasure of
telling you that the University of Aberdeen has to-day, on my proposal, conferred upon
you the degree of LL.D.". He was also appointed as Corresponding Member of the
Imperial Geological Institute of Vienna, made an Honorary Member of the Royal
Bohemian Museum, Prague and sat on the "Committee of Papers" of the Royal Society.
His review of 3 June 1889 of a paper by Bateson 'on some varieties of Cardium ediile'
resides among the Referees Reports in the Archives of the Royal Society.

Like many other products of his generation, Brady had a great zest for life. Despite (or
perhaps because of) his delicate health (he was troubled by pulmonary disease for many
years), he was an avid gentleman-traveller. He journeyed twice around the world,
visiting such places as Morocco, India, Ceylon, China, Japan, Java, the Pacific Islands,
Australia, New Zealand and the United States. He seems to have been particularly
fascinated by the Orient, and hlled the house he had bought for his fathers retirement
('Hillfield' at the top of Windmill Hill in Gateshead) with Japanese paintings, vases and
curios.

His interest in the local flora and fauna he encountered and the native customs he
observed on his travels frequently prompted him to write short pieces. One of his letters
to Gunther, headed Hillfield and dated 28 October 1878, reads:

During a recent visit to the interior of Morocco, 1 made a good many
observations in respect to the snake performances as practiced by the
Clissowa.

A subsequent letter, dated 13 November 1878, thanks Gunther for his '. . . obliging letter
just to hand . . .", and laments the lack of ". . . accurate knowledge on the characters of
snakes . . .' displayed earlier, adding: "... had they only been Protozoa, 1 could have lold
you more about them — but this comes from having lapsed into a specialist".

THE CHALLENGER EXPEDITION 1 33

On his last overseas trip, to the Upper Nile in 1889-1890, Brady fell seriously ill with
oedema of the feet and legs. He spent some time laid up in Cairo before being forced
home. On his return, he took up residence in Bournemouth, where he lived as a semi-
invalid and was unable to fulfil his final ambition (alluded to in a letter to Gunther dated
22 May 1888) of producing a monograph of the British Foraminifera.

Brady died of pneumonia on Saturday 10 January 1891. The Newcastle Daily
Chronicle posted a short obituary notice the following Monday, and an account of the
funeral the following Thursday. Obituaries were also published in the Geological
Magazine, in the Pharaceutical Journal and in the 'Notices of Fellows Deceased' in the
Proceedings of the Royal Society for 1891-1892 (the last-named by the metallurgist W. C.
Roberts-Austen).

Brady's most fitting epitaph is provided by Dr. Michael Foster, who wrote in the issue
of Nature dated 29 January 1891:

Science has lost a steady and fruitful worker, and many men of science have
lost a friend and helpmate whose place they feel no-one else can fill. His wide
knowledge of many branches of scientific inquiry and his large acquaintance
with scientific men made the hours spent with him always profitable; his
sympathy with art and literature, and that special knowledge of men and
things which belongs only to the travelled man made him welcome also where
science was unknown; while the brave patience with which he bore the many
troubles of enfeebled health, his unselfish thoughtfulness for interests other
than his own, and a sense of humour which, when needed, led him to desert
his usual staid demeanour for the merriment of the moment, endeared him
to all his friends.

Readers interested in further details of Brady's life are referred to the two fine and
factual biographies known to the author, the one contemporary (by his brother-in-law
Thomas Carrick Watson, in Steel, 1899), the other modern (Adams, 1978).

Brady Library

Watson, the executor of Brady's will, wrote to the Treasurer of the Royal Society in a
letter (now among the Miscellaneous Correspondence in the Archives of the Royal
Society) headed 83 Osborne Road, Newcastle-upon-Tyne and dated 2 July 1891: 'I beg
to hand you herewith . . . eight hundred pounds, being the sum bequeathed by the late
Henry Bowman Brady to the Royal Society.'

Five hundred pounds was to be placed in the Scientific Relief Fund of the Royal
Society in accordance with Clause 10 of the will. The remaining three hundred pounds
was to be used for the maintenance and increase of the Brady Library in accordance with
Clause 3 of the will, which read:

I bequeath all my books and papers relating to the Protozoa to the Royal
Society and I recommend for the greater convenience of reference thereto the
said books and papers should be kept together in one place and a distinct
collection ....

The Brady Library, incidentally the only named collection in the entire Library of the
Royal Society (though currently in the basement!) now comprises some 180 volumes.
Among these are a number of rare and valuable books by such authors as Agassiz,
d'Archaiac & Haime, Batsch, de Blainville, Costa, Dujardin, Ehrenberg, Fichtel &

134 R.W.JONES

Moll, Geinitz, Haeckel, Karrer, Karrer, d'Orbigny, Schaudinn, Seguenza, Silvestri,
Soldani. Spengler, Stache & Schwager and Terquem. Also in the collection are a
complete early run of the journal Annals and Magazine of Natural History and volumes
of reprints and unpublished manuscripts and drawings by various workers annotated by
Brady himself, some of which are bound under the title Memoirs and Papers Relating to
the Foraminifera. Some material has been bound and some added by the Royal Society.

Some letters, manuscripts and sundry papers are archived separately in the Library of
the Royal Society.

The letters include one from Edward Heron-Allen to the Library Committee of the
Royal Society, headed 33 Hamilton Terrace N.W. and dated 21 October 1914, which
reads:

Gentlemen, By the introduction of Prof. Herdman and with the kind and
courteous assistance of the Asst. Librarian Mr. Hastings White, it has been
my privilege for some time past to make use of the unique and remarkable
collection of works on the Foraminifera bequeathed to your library by the late
Dr. H. B. Brady . . .

Other letters in the collection include ones to Brady from G. S. Brady, Carter [?].
Guppy, Halkyard, Hantken, Howchin. Millett, Murray, Schwager and Sherborn.

The manuscripts include one "On the shallow water and littoral foraminifera of some
of the islands of the southern Pacific", probably written c. 1890 and never published.

The sundry papers include numerous drawings and tracings of foraminifera by Brady
together with a key, plates of Crag foraminifera by Brady and West, taxonomic notes on
Pacific foraminifera (New Caledonia, 1884, Fiji, 1884-1885 and Samoa), and distribution
data on the Challenger foraminifera.

The Challenger data are contained in three black foolscap volumes. Two of these
tabulate the distributions of all of the species of foraminifera figured in the Challenger
Report (Brady, 1884), species-by-species. The first of these deals with those figured on
Plates 1-55 of the Challenger Report (Miliolidae-Astrorhizidae-Lituolidae-Textularidae-
Chilostomellidae) and the second with those figured on Plates 56-115 (Lagenidae-
Globigerinidae-Rotalidae-Nummulinidae). The tables are interspersed with notes (e.g.
from Rev. A. M. Norman on Psarnrnatodendron) . The third volume lists the distribu-
tions of all of the foraminifera figured in the Challenger Report, station-by-station, and
adds the date on which the station was sampled, its latitude and longitude, and depth,
bottom temperature and substrate data. This volume contains an unsigned note to the
effect that 'Brady gives lists from . . . stations not in his Report'.

Brady Family Photograph Album

Additional insights into the Brady's shared characters may be gained by browsing
through their family photograph album in the Local Studies Department, Central
Library, Newcastle-upon-Tyne. The frontispiece page features one of the best-known
photgraphs of Brady (that used by Adams (1978); see also Plate 4) and dedicates the
album to his "affectionate remembrance'. Many of the photographs in this remarkable
and fascinating compilation were evidently taken by Brady himself: a number of the
earliest ones of the Great Fire of Gateshead are dated October 1854 and signed H. B. B.,
and it seems reasonable to attribute some later photomicrographs (including ones of
pennate and centric diatoms and holothurians) to him also. However, some were also
taken by R. B. Bowman (probably a cousin) and some evidently bought as postcards,
etc.

THE CHALLENGER EXPEDITION 1 35

Among the photographs present in the album (this is by no means an exhaustive list)
are ones of local scenes, beauty spots (home and abroad), still lives, staged set-pieces
somewhat in the style of Henry Peach Robinson, family and friends (including the
Quaker families Pumphrey and Robinson), literary figures (contemporary English and
French authors and the Romantic Poets), works of art (principally in the classical, neo-
classical, renaissance and Pre-Raphaelite schools and often with a religious theme) and
architecture (principally ecclesiastical, but also industrial and municipal), contemporary
figures, politicians and captains of industry (including such diverse figures as the
performing artists Ellen Terry and Sarah Siddons, Florence Nightingale and the 'iron
master" Crawshay, David Livingstone and the imperialist Rajah Brooke, abolitionist
Abraham Lincoln and the Tsar of Russia, the Pope and Garibaldi) and leading
contemporary scientists and naturalists. A touching chord is struck by the inclusion of the
obviously much-loved prize-winning dog 'Cato', and a somewhat bizarre one by the
inclusion of one 'Crockett the Lion Tamer".

THE CHALLENGER FORAMINIFERA

The 600 cases of Challenger material, including 100,000 mountable specimens" were
originally assumed all to have been deposited in the British Museum (Natural History),
in accordance with Admiralty instructions to that effect. However, some material was
disposed of during the voyage, some was never returned by the specialists to whom it was
sent for description and some was sent out on subsequent request to various institutions:
in particular, sediment samples were very widely dispersed.

The history of dispersal of the Challenger material is admirably summarised by
Lingwood (1981) and Kempe & Buckley (1987). The following discussion of the location
of Challenger foraminiferal material is based partly on these accounts, and partly on
those of Adams (1960), Adams el al. (1980) and Murray & Taplin (1984fl). McConnell
(in press) provides further information on the whereabouts of correspondence and
papers pertaining to the Challenger expedition and its organisers and participants.

Foraminiferal Slides

According to records in the catalogue of 'Challenger Office specimens sent out 1873-
1915' housed in the Palaeontology Library of the British Museum (Natural History),
Challenger material was sent to Brady in ten batches between 25 November 1882 and 9
September 1887, that despatched on 1 June 1887 being directed to 5, Robert Street,
Adelphi, London WCl. This material is only recorded as having been returned in three
instances! However, it would seem that little of importance remains unaccounted for.

Most of the specimens of foraminifera figured in the Challenger Report (Brady, 1884)
are to be found in picked slides in handsome polished wood cabinets in the Heron-Allen
Library in the Palaeontology Department of the British Museum (Natural History) (see
Plate 6); a few are to be found in the Carpenter collection in the Royal Albert Memorial
Museum, Exeter (Murray & Taplin, 1984a). The slides in the BM(NH) pertain to the
cruises of the Challenger herself (1872-1876), the Lighlning (1868), the Porcupine (1869)
and the Knighl Errant (1879) and to the Austro-Hungarian and British North Polar
expeditions (1872-74 and 1875-76 respectively). Comparison with authenticated
specimens of Brady"s handwriting (e.g. signed letters to Gunther and to John Hancock
(now in the museum that bears his name in Newcastle-upon-Tyne)) suggests that the

136 R. W. JONES

Victorian copper-plate inscriptions on the bottoms of many of these slides are attribut-
able to the man himself.

Unfigured but sorted specimens and unpicked and unsorted residues are also to be
found in slides in the Palaeontology Department of the BM(NH) (see Plate 6). Henry
Sidebottom made some attempt to catalogue the former in his unpublished "MS. index to
the collection of type-slides used by H. B. Brady . . .', probably compiled at around the
turn of the century. Adams (1960) and Adams el at. (1980) list the BM(NH) registered
numbers of many of the specimens figured in the Challenger Report (Brady, 1884). They
also discuss the status of the specimens of the 97 species described as new in the
Challenger Report (Brady, 1884) and the 140 species described as new in earlier works
(principally Brady, 1878, \819a-b, 1881a-c, 1882) and subsequently figured (in many
cases for the first time) in the Challenger Report. All of these are interpreted as syntypes.
Some have been designated as lectotypes and paralectotypes.

Adams and Adams et al. (op. cit.) also give something of the history of the
collections. It appears from their accounts that Brady presented the Porcupine material
to the BM(NH) in 1885 and the Knight Errant material and 612 slides of Challenger
material in 1888. At least the bulk of the remainder of the Challenger material was
originally deposited in the University Museum of Zoology, Cambridge, whence, at the
instigation of Sir Clive Forster-Cooper and Edward Heron- Allen, it was removed to the
BM(NH) between 1939 and 1959 (see also Joysey, 1960). There are no records of any
material remaining at Cambridge (R. Symonds, personal communication).

In fact, Brady appears to have presented some Challenger material to the BM(NH) as
early as 1885. A letter from Brady to Gunther, headed Savile Club, Piccadilly and dated
8 October 1885, intimated that Brady expected to finish the following day "... sorting
and arranging the collection of Challenger and other Foraminifera and mounting a
suitable series for exhibition [in the BM(NH)|'. A second letter, dated 9 October,
confirmed that he had indeed "... finished, as far as I can at the moment, the work I have
been engaged upon ... in connection with the collections'. A third letter, headed White
Hart Hotel, Reigate and dated 13 October, noted that Brady was '. . . well pleased that
the series of Foraminifera meets with your approval. I hope still, as I may have time, to
do a good deal to render it more complete'.

Brady is also known to have presented 435 slides of Challenger and Porcupine material
and practically all of the Austro-Hungarian North Polar expedition material to his friend
Felix Karrer (see Plate 5) at the Naturhistorisches Museum, Vienna, in 1887, which
resides there still. In recognition of this, Franz von Hauer, a geologist who at the time
was director of the Museum, approached the Austrian Emperor Franz Joseph I and
arranged for Brady to be presented with a gold medal inscribed 'k. k. osterr.-ung.
Ehrenzeichen fiir Kunst und Wissenschaft" (Insignia of the Royal and Imperial Austro-
Hungarian Empire for Art and Science) and bearing His Imperial Majesty's portrait and
device (F. RogI, personal communication).

Additional Challenger material was presented to David Robertson, 117 slides of which
are now in the Robertson Museum and Aquarium collection, Millport, and Art Gallery
and Museum collection, Glasgow (F. Woodward, personal communication). The
Hancock Museum, Newcastle-upon-Tyne also has "... a few slides . . ." (P. S. Davis,
personal communication), and the Laboratorium voor Paleontologie, Katholieke
Universiteit, Leuven, Belgium, has twelve (Hooyberghs & van de Sande, 1988).

Raw Material

A vast number of sediment sounding samples collected by Challenger are now housed in
the BM(NH). These were originally stored in one collcctiim in the C/ia/Ztvi^'fr expedition

THE CHAl I ENGER EXPEDITION

137

r-., t^Li.

'*9^^^)//-. ■

X

'-ir

z F

Names' Mat tout ^IJJjU^^

10H(d'

"^r"- ^ \

Challenger"

J'f-xvi.E.,**.^,™

Plate 6 Top left: Slide of residue material from Challenger Station 150. between Kerguelen and Heard Island.
Upper middle left: Slide of picked residue from Challenger Station 218A. Admiralty Islands (top), with old
British Museum (Natural History) registered number (1885.10.27.104). Ix)wer middle left: Bottom of same
slide annotated by Brady. Bollom left: Slide of sorted residue from Station VIIC. The fauna in many of these
so-called 'type slides' has been identilied by Sidebottom ('MS. index to the collection of type-slides used by H.
B. Brady . . .'). Top right: Slide of the benthonic foraminifer Kerarnosphaera murrayi Brady from Challenger

Station 157, with new BM(NH) registered number (ZF3hl7). Upper middle right: Slide of the planktonic
foraminifer Globigerina aequilateralis Brady [now identified as Globtgerinella aequtlateralis (Brady)) from a
surface tow in the PaciHc. with new BN(NH) registered number (ZF14<i6). Figured in the Challenger Report

(Brady. 1884; PI. 80. Fig. 20). I^wer middle right: Slide of the benthonic foraminifer Alveolina boscii
Defrance, sp. (now Alveolinella quoyi (d'Orbigny)] from Challenger Station 218A. Admiralty Islands, with new

BM(NH) registered number (ZF1046). Figured in the Challenger Report (Brady. 1884; PI. 17. Figs. i>-10).

Bottom of same slide annotated by Brady, with old BM(NH) registered number (1885 >*. 25.1 1). Bottom right:

Thin-section slide of the benthonic foraminifer Orhitolites complanata var. laciniata Brady |now Marginupora

vertebralis var. plicata Dana] from Challenger Station I72A. Tongatabu Reef, with new BM(NH) registered

number (ZF2037) Figured in Challenger Report (Brady. 1884; PI. 16. Fig. II).

All reproduced by courtesy of the Palaeontology Department of the BM(NH).

138 R. W. JONES

commission's offices in Queen Street in Edinburgh, which was moved in 1890 to nearby
Frederick Street. A set of samples from this collection, one from each Challenger slation .
was sent to the Geology Department of the BM(NH) in 1895 and subsequently
transferred to the Zoology Department of that institution in 1922 and to the Mineralogy
Department in 1938. The remainder of the Edinburgh collection was transferred in 1904
to Sir John Murray's residence "Villa Medusa' on the northern outskirts of the city,
where it remained until long after Murray's death in an automobile accident in 1914.
Here it was examined by Edward Heron-Allen and Arthur Earland in 1919 and found to
comprise 9746 samples of 'Marine Deposits' (soundings, dredging, etc. in bottles and
boxes), together with the C/ia//eMger expedition glass photographic plates, microscopical
preparations and an extensive oceanographic library. This part of the collection was
eventually acquired by the Zoology Department of the BM(NH) in 1921 and by the
Mineralogy Department either later in 1921 (a few specimens of phosphates, etc.) or in
1935. Some of it has subsequently been transferred to the Palaeontology Department.

Murray had stipulated in 1914 to Heron-Allen that in the event of his untimely death
his collection should be bequeathed either to his two sons, if they wished to carry on his
work, or to a reputable institution such as the BM(NH) or to the Imperial College of
Science (University of London). In the latter event a responsible curator, salaried from a
trust fund, was meticulously to catalogue every sample. After the inevitable delay, this
condition (subsequently stressed by the Murray family solicitor) has now been fully
complied with: the Sir John Murray Collection of zoological, botanical and geological
specimens from the cruise of H.M.S. Challenger is catalogued by Buckley el al. (1979,
1984) and most of it has been entered onto a computer database.

PLANNED REVISION TO THE TAXONOMY OF THE CHALLENGER
FORAMINIFERA

The original report on the Challenger foraminifera (Brady. 1884) dates from what might
best be termed the systematic or descriptive phase of deep-sea research. It was conceived
in the pervasive intellectual atmosphere of the "English School' and consequently
embodies a broader ('lumping') species concept than is usually acceptable today (Cifelli
& Richardson, 1990; Haynes, 1990). Because of its archaic taxonomy, it cannot be used
without qualification in the type of analytical and synoptic work currently being undertaken.
Previous revisions to the taxonomy of the Challenger foraminifera include those of
Nuttall (1927, 1931), Thalmann (1932, 1933, 1937, 1942) and most notably, R. Wright
Barker (1960). Barker's work was particularly important and useful in that it synthesiscd
all of the great variety of names assigned to Brady's figured species in the literature up to
1960 (including those of Nuttall and Thalmann. opp. cil.) However, Barker did not
subjectively assess which names were valid and which not, referring simply to the ". . .
return in . . . recent times to the principles of Reuss . . .', the 'splitting of a large number
of Brady's "species" . . .' and ". . . their allocation to new genera . . .'. He proposed
nomina nova for four species whose earlier names were pre-occupied, but did not
formally describe the thirty-one species and three varieties he regarded as new, stating
that "a number of the forms figured by Brady, and as yet undescribed, have been
indicated but have not been named, for the writer has not had the opportunity to study
Brady's specimens in order to prepare adequate descriptions and to designate types.'
And in many cases he left problems of generic assignment unresolved, commenting in
the case of the nodosariids, for instance, that "there is still confusion in the treatment of
this group, . . . and nt) attempt has been made to clarify the question here, the generic

THE CHALLENGER EXPEDITION 1 39

names in all cases being quoted unchanged". His work was essentially, as he himself
stated. '. . . of a bibliographic nature and in no sense a critical revision of the Challenger
Report.'

Since Barker's time there have been a large number of publications bearing on the
taxonomy of the Challenger foraminifera: some of the more important are those of
Loeblich & Tappan (1964, 1988), Shchedrina (1964, 1969), Srinivasan & Sharma (1969,
1980), Hornibrook ( 1971 ), Saidova (1975, 1981 ). McCulloch (1977, 1981 ). Zheng ( 1979),
Haynes (1981), Rogl & Hansen (1984), Papp & Schmid (1985) and Van Morkhoven,
Berggren, Edwards t'? o/. (1986).

In my opinion, the taxonomic advances since Barker's time allow a fresh revision of
the taxonomy of the Challenger foraminifera, while the growing interest in cosmopolitan
deep water benthonic foraminifera and their stratigraphic, palaeobathymetric and
palaeo-oceanographic potential necessitates it.

I am therefore planning a further revision of the taxonomy of the Challenger
foraminifera. My intention is to reproduce all of the text-figures and 116 colour plates
from the original report on the Challenger foraminifera (Brady, 1884) in book form and
to annotate them with up-to-date taxonomic notes. Identifications will be based on
examination of the specimens themselves in the British Museum (Natural History).
Locations and depths of sampling sites from which figured specimens came will be
checked at source and given in full, as will BM(NH) registered numbers and relevant
information on the status of specimens (lectotypes etc.). A list of cited references and a
comprehensive taxonomic index will also be given.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

Grateful thanks are due to Professor F. T. Banner of the BP Research Centre, Sunbury-
on-Thames, and the Palaeontology Department of the British Museum (Natural
History), London, to Drs C. G. Adams (recently retired) and J. E. Whittaker and Mr R.
L. Hodgkinson also of the Palaeontology Department, to Mrs Eileen Brunton of the
Palaeontology Library, to Mr H. A. Buckley of the Mineralogy Department and to the
staff of the General Library of the BM(NH); to Mr P. S. Davis and the staff of the
Hancock Museum, Newcastle-upon-Tyne; to Mr J. V. Howard and the staff of the
Special Collections Department, Edinburgh University Library; to Mr F. Manders and
the staff of the Local Studies Department of the Central Library, Newcastle-upon-Tyne;
to Mr K. Moore of the Royal Society, London; to Dr A. L. Rice of the Institute of
Oceanographic Sciences Deacon Laboratory, Wormley, Surrey; to Dr F. Rogl of the
Palaeontology Department of the Naturhistorisches Museum, Vienna, Austria; to Mrs
Ann Shirley of the Ships Department of the National Maritime Museum, Greenwich,
London; to Mr R. Symonds of the University Museum of Zoology, Cambridge; to Mr F.
Woodward of the Natural History Department of the Museum and Art Gallery,
Kelvingrove, Glasgow. Extracts from papers in the Archives of the Royal Society are
reproduced by kind permission of the President and Council of that Institution. The
National Maritime Museum gave permission to reproduce the photographs of H.M.S.
Challenger. Edinburgh University Library gave permission to reproduce the photograph
of the Challenger crew, Gulland's pen-and-wash sketch of Wyville Thomson and
Buchanan and Wild's original drawing of Globigerina bulloides d'Orbigny. Newcastle-
upon-Tyne City Libraries and Arts gave permission to reproduce the photographic
portraits from the Brady family album. The photographs of the Challenger slides appear
courtesy of the Palaeontology Department of the BM(NH).

140 R.W.JONES

Pippa Senior, Press Officer of the Royal Society and coincidentally a descendant of the
Brady family provided much valuable information on the Brady family genealogy,
including a family tree. This had been compiled by her great grand-mother Nora Gillie,
born Brady, who was Thomas Brady's daughter and one of Henry Bowman Brady's nine
nieces.

My father also assisted with some of the biographical work. My wife Heather and my
colleague Mike Simmons proof-read early draughts of the text and suggested various
stylistic and scientific improvements.

Permission to publish was granted by the British Petroleum Company p. I.e.

CITED REFERENCES

Adams, C. G. 1960. A note on two important collections of foraminifcra in the British Museum
(Natural History). Micropaleontology <>: 417^18.

1978. Great names in micropalaeontology. 3. Henry Bowman Brady, 1835-1891. Pps. 275-

280 in Hedley, R. H. & Adams, C. G. (Eds): Foraminifera. Volume 3. Academic Press;
London, New York, San Francisco.

Adams, C. G., Harrison, C. A. & Hodgkinson, R. L, 1980. Some primary type specimens of
Foraminifcra in the British Museum (Natural History). Micropaleontology 26: 1-16.

Barker, R. W. 1960. Taxonomic notes on the species figured by H. B. Brady in his Report on the
Foraminifera dredged by H.M.S. Challenger during the years 1873-1876. Accompanied by a
reproduction of Brady's plates. Special Publications of the Society of Economic Paleontologists
and Mineralogists. Tulsa, Oklahoma 9: 238 pps.

Boog Watson, W. N. 1967. Sir John Murray — a chronic student. University of Edinburgh Journal
23: 123-138.

Brady, H. B. 1863. Report on the Foraminifcra. Pps. 291-294 in Mcnncll, H. T. (Ed.): Report on
the dredging expedition to the Dogger Bank and the coasts of Northumberland. Transactions of
the Tyneside Naturalists' Field Club 5.

1864a. Notes on foraminifera new to the British fauna. Reports of the British Association for

the Advancement of Science 1863: 100-101; London.

1864fe. Report on the Foraminifera. Pps. 193-194 in Brady G. S. (Ed.): Report of Dredging

Operations on the Coasts of Northumberland and Durham in July and August 1863. Trans-
actions of the Tyneside Naturalists' Field Club 6.

1865a. Report on the Foraminifcra. Pps. 51-83 in Brady. G. S. (Ed.): Reports of Deep Sea

Dredging on the Coasts of Northumberland and Durham, 1862^. Transactions of the Natural
History Society of Northumberland. Durham and Newcastle-upon-Tyne Old Scries 1: 51-82.

1865i). A catalogue of the Recent Foraminifcra of Northumberland and Durham. Trans-
actions of the Natural History Society of Northumberland, Durham and Newcastle-upon-Tyne
Old Series 1: 83-107.

1878. On the Reticularian and Radiolarian Rhizopoda (Foraminifera and Polycystina) of the

North Polar Expedition of 1875-76. Annals and Magazine of Natural History (5) I: 425-440.

1879a. Notes on some of the reticularian Rhizopoda of the Challenger Expedition. 1 . On new

or little known arenaceous types. Quarterly Journal of Microscopical Science New Scries 19: 2(>-
63.

1879/). Notes on some of the reticularian Rhizopoda of the Challenger Expedition. 2.

Additions to the knowledge of porcellaneous and hyaline types. Quarterly Journal of Micro-
scopical Science New Series 19: 261-299.

1881a. Notes on some of the reticularian Rhizopoda of the Challenger Expedition. 3. 1 —

Classification, 2 — Further notes on new species, 3 — Note on Bihuulina mud. Quarterly Journal
of the Microscopical Society New Series 21: 31-71.

1881ft. On some Arctic Foraminifera from soundings obtained on the Austro-Hungarian

North Polar Expedition of 1872-1874. Annals and Magazine of Natural History (5) 8: 9.V418.

THE CHALLENGER EXPEDITION 141

1881c. Ubcr einige arktische Ticfsce-Foraminifcrcn gesainmclt wiihrcnd dcr ostcrreichisch-

ungarischcn Nordpol-F.xpcdition in dcr Jahrcn 1872-74. Denkschriflen der Kaiserlkhen
Akademie der Wissenschaften, Wien, Mathematisch-Naliirwi.ssenschaflen Klusse 43: y-110.

in Tizard, Staff-Commander & Murray, J. 1882. Exploration of the Fiiroc Channel during the

Summer of 188(1 in Her Majesty's Hired Ship Knight Errani'. Proceedings of the Roval Socielv of

Edinburgh U: b?:»^120.
1884. Report on the Foraminifera dredged by H. M.S. C/iu/Ze/igfr during the years 1873-1876.

Report of the Scientific Results of the Voyage of H. M.S. Challenger. IH73-1876, Zoology 9: 814

pps. London.
Buckley. H. A., Elliot, C. J., Graham, N. M., Johnson, L. R., Kempe, D. R. C, Morgan, D. L. &

Williams, D. B. 1974. Catalogue of the ocean bottom deposits collection in the British Museum

(Natural History). Part 1. British Museum (Natural History); London.

1984. Catalogue of the ocean bottom deposits collection in the British Museum (Natural

History). Part 2. British Museum (Natural History); London.

Burstyn, H. L. 1968. Science and government in the nineteenth century: the Challenger expedition
and its report. Bulletin of the Institute of Oceanography. Monaco. Special Issue 21: 60.^-613.

1972. Pioneering in large-scale scientific organisation: the Challenger expedition and its

report. 1. Launching the expedition. Proceedings of the Second International Congress on the
History of Oceanography. Edinburgh. 1972 (Challenger Expedition Centenary Volume): 47-62.

Carpenter, W. B. 1862. Introduction to the study of the foraminifera. 319 pp. Ray Society; London.
1883. Report on the specimens of the genus Orbitoliles collected by H. M.S. Challenger dunng

the years 1873-1876. Report of the Scientific Results of the Voyage of H. M.S. Challenger, 1873-

1876, Zoology 7: 47 pps. London.
Carpenter, W. B. & Brady, H. B. 1869. Description of Parkeria and Loftusia. two gigantic types of

arenaceous foraminifera. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society 159: 721-754.
Charnock, H. 1973. H.M.S. Challenger and the development of marine science. Journal of

Navigation 26: 1-12.
Cifelli, R. & Richardson, S. L., 1990. A history of the classification of foraminifera (1826-1933)

Cushman Foundation for Foraminiferal Research, Special Publication, Washington DC. 27,

119pp.
Davis, P. S. & Home, D.J. 1985. George Stewardson Brady (1832-1921) and his collections at the

Hancock Museum, Newcastle-upon-Tyne. Journal of Micropalaeonlology 4: 141-152.
Deacon, M. 1971 . The voyage of H.M.S. Challenger. Pps. 333-365 in: Scientists and the Sea, 1650-

1900. Academic Press; London.

1972. The Challenger Expedition and Geology. Proceedings of the Second International

Congress on the History of Oceanography, Edinburgh, 1972 (Challenger Expedition Centenary
Volume): 145-154. '

Haynes, J. R. 1981. Foraminifera. 433 pps Macmillan, London.

Haynes, J. R. 1990. The classification of the foraminifera — a review of historical and philosophical

perspectives. Palaeontology 33: 503-528.
Herdman, Sir W. 1923. Founders of oceanography and their work: an introduction to the science of

the sea. 340 pps. Edward Arnold & Co. , Ixindon.
Hooyberghs, H. & van de Sande, G. 1988. Remarques sur une collection dcs foraminiferes de

quelques enchantillons originaux de I'cxpedition du 'Challenger' (1873-1876), conservee a

Leuven (Belgique). Revue de Micropaleontologie 30: 261-266.
Hornibrook, N. de B. 1971. A revision of the Oligocene and Miocene foraminifera from New

Zealand described by Karrer and Stache in the Reports of the Novara' Expedition (1864). New

Zealand Geological Survey, Paleontological Bulletin 43: 84 pps. Wellington.
Joysey, K. A. 1960. Note on the Brady Collection of Foraminifera. Micropaleontology 6: 416.
Kempe, D. R. C. & Buckley, H. A. 1987 Fifty years of oceanography in the Department of

Mineralogy, British Museum (Natural History). Bulletin of the British Mu.'teum (Natural

History). Historical Series 15: .59-97.
Lee, S. (Ed.). 1898. Dictionary of National Biography Smith, Elder & Co; London.
Lingwood, P. F. 1981 The dispersal of the collections of H.M.S. Challenger: an example of the

importance of historical research in tracing a systematically important collection. Pps. 71-77 in

Wheeler, A. & Price, J. H. (Eds): History in the service of systematics. Special Publications of

the Society for the Bibliography of Natural History, 1 , London.

142 R. W. JONES

Linklater, E. 1972. The Voyage of the Challenger. 288 pps. John Murray. London.

Loeblich, A. R., Jr. & Tappan, H. 1964. Protista 2. Sanodina. chiefly Thecamoehians' and

Foraminiferida. Part C. In Moore, R. C (Ed.): Treatise on Invertebrate Paleontology. 2 vols.

Geological Society of America and University of Kansas Press; Lawrence, Kansas.

1988. Foraminiferal Genera and their Classification. 2 vols. Van Nostrand Reinhold

Company; New York.

McConnell, A. 1981. Historical instruments in oceanography. 52 pps. Her Majesty's Stationery
Office; London.

(Co-Ordinator). In press. Directory of source materials for the history of oceanographv.

UNESCO technical papers in marine science.

McCulloch, I. 1977. Qualitative observations on Recent foraminiferal tests with emphasis on the

Eastern Pacific, 3 vols. University of Southern California; Los Angeles.
1981. Qualitative observations on Recent foraminiferal tests. Pt. IV: with emphasis on the Allan

Hancock collection. North Atlantic. University of Southern California; Los Angeles.
Mills, E. L. 1978. Edward Forbes, John Gwyn Jeffreys, and British dredging before the Challenger

expedition. Journal of the Society for the Bibliography of Natural History 8: 507-536.

1984. A view of Edward Forbes, naturalist. Archives of Natural History 11: 365-393.

Moseley, H. N. 1879. Notes by a Naturalist. An account of obsenations made during the voyage of

H.M.S. Challenger' . 620 pps. MacMillan, London.
Murray, J. W. 1971. The W. B. Carpenter Collection. .Micropaleonlology 17: 105-106.
1981. Some Early Students of Foraminifera in Britain. Pps. 9-12 in Jenkins, D. G. & Murray,

J. W. (Eds): Stratigraphical Alias of Fossil Foraminifera. Ellis Horwood Ltd; Chichester.

1989. Some Early Students of Foraminifera in Britain. Pps. 13-19 in Jenkins, D. G. &

Murray, J. W. (Eds): Stratigraphical Atlas of Fossil Foraminifera, Second Edition. Ellis
Horwood Ltd; Chichester.

Murray, J. W. & Taplin, C. M. 1984a. The W. B. Carpenter Collection of Foraminifera: a
catalogue. Journal of Micropalaeontology 3: 55-58.

1984b. Larger agglutinated foraminifera collected from the Faeroe Channel and Rockall

Trough by W. B. Carpenter. Journal of Micropalaeontology 3: .59-61.

Nuttall, W. L. F. 1927. The localities whence the Foraminifera figured in the Report of H.M.S.

Challenger by Brady were derived. Annals and Magazine of Natural History (9) 19: 209-241.
1931 . Additional localities of the 'Challenger' Foraminifera. Contributions from the Cushman

Laboratory for Foraminiferal Research 7: 46-47.
Papp, A. & Schmid, M. E. 1985. Die fossilen Foraminiferen des Teriuiren Reckens von Wien.

Revision der Monographic von Atcide d'Orbigny (IH4b). Abhandlungen der Cieologischcn

Bundesanstalt. Wien 35: 31 1 pps.
Rehbock, P. F. 1979. The early dredgers: 'naturalising' in British seas, 1830-1850. Journal of the

History of Biology 12: 293-368.
Rice, A. L. 1983. Thomas Henry Huxley and the strange case of Bathybius haeckelii; a possible

alternative explanation. Archives of Natural History 2: 169-180.

1986. British Oceanographic Vessels I ti()0- 1 950 . 193 pps. Ray Society; London.

Rice, A. L., Burstyn, H. L. & Jones, A. (J. E. 1976. G. C. Wallich M.D. — megalomaniac or mis-
used oceanographic genius. Journal of the Society for Bibliography of Natural History 7: 423-450.
Rogl, F. & Hansen, H. J. 1984. Foraminifera described by Fichtel & Moll in 1798. A revision of

Testacea Microscopies. Neue Denkschriften des Nalur-Historischen Museums in Wien 3: 143 pps.
Saidova, Kb. M. 1975. Benthonic Foraminifera of the Pacific Ocean Moscow; Institut Okcanologii

P. P. Shishova. Akadcmiya Nauk S.S.S.R.: 3 vols (in Russian).
1981 . On an up-to-date syste/n of supraspecific ta.xonomy of C enozoic benthonic foraminifera .

73 pps. Institut Okcanologii P.P. Shishova. Akadcmiya Nauk S.S.S.R. Moscow; (in Russian).
Sbchedrina, Z. (I. 1964. On some changes in the systematicsof the order Rolaliida (Foraminifera).

Voprosy Mikropalcontologii H: 91-101. (in Russian).

1969. On some changes in the systemalics of the families Astrorhizidae and Reophacidac

(Foraminifera). V{>prosy Mikropalcontologii II: 15 (in Russian)

Sriniva.san, M. S. & Sharma, V. 1969 The status of the Late Tertiary foraminifera of Kar |Car|
Nicobar described by Schwagcr in 1866. Micropaleonlology 15: 107-1 10.

1980. Schwager's Car Nicobar Foraminifera in the Reports of the Novara Expedition - A

Revision. 83 pps. Today & Tomorrow's Printers and Publishers; New Delhi.

THE CHALLENGER EXPEDITION 1 43

Steel, J. W. 1989. A historical .sketch of the Society of Friends in scorn called Quakers' in Newcastle

and Gateshead. I653-IH98. 224 pps. G. Robinson & Co. Ltd.; Newcastlc-upon-Tync.
Sverdrup, H. U., Johnson, N. W. & Fleming, R. H. 1942. The Oceans. Prcnticc-Hall, Inc.:

Eaglcwood Cliffs, New Jersey.
Thalmann, H. E. 1932. Nomenclator (Um — und Neubcnnungen) zu den Tafeln 1 bis 1 15 in H. B.

Brady's Wcrk iiber die Foraminifercn der C/ia//enger-Expedition, London 18H4. Eclogae

Geologicae Helvetiae 25: 293-312.
1933. Bcitrag zum Nomenclator zu Brady's Tafeiband der Foraminifercn der Challenger'-

Expedition. Eclogae Geologicae Helvetiae 26: 251-255.
1937. Mitteilungcn iiber Foraminifercn III. Weitere Nomina mutata in Brady's Wcrk iiber die

Foraminifercn der 'Challenger'-Expcditmn (1X84). Eclogae Geologicae Helvetiae 30: 340-342.

1942. Nomina Bradyana mutata. American Midland Naturalist 28: 463-464.

Van Morkhoven, F. P. C. M, Berggren, W. A., Edwards, Anne S., et al. 1986. Cenozoic

Cosmopolitan Deep-Water Benthic Foraminifera. 421 pps. Centres de Recherches Exploration-
Production Elf-Aquitaine: Pau, France.
Wallich, G. C. 1862. The North-Atlantic Sea-Bed: comprising a diary of the voyage on board

H.M.S. Bulldog, in I tityO; and observations on the presence of animal life, and the formation and

nature of organic deposits, at great depths in the Ocean. 16() pps. John Van Voorst; London.
Wild, J. J. 1877. ThaliLssa: an essay on the depth, temperature and currents of the ocean. 140 pps.

Marcus Ward; London.
Woodward, W. B. 1972. Sources of information on the natural history of County Durham. The

Vasculum 57 (supplement): 1^0.
Wyville Thomson, C. 1873. The Depths of the Sea. 527 pps. Macmillan & Co.; London.
1877. The Voyage of the Challenger. The Atlantic. A preliminary account of the general results

of the exploring voyage of H.M.S. Challenger during the year 1873 and the early part of the year

1876. 2 vols. London.
Yonge, Sir. M. 1972. The inception and significance of the Challenger Expedition. Proceedings of

the Second International Congress of the History of Oceanography, Edinburgh, 1972 (Challenger

Expedition Centenary Volume): 1-14.
Zheng, S. Y. 1979. The Recent foraminifera of the Xishe Islands: Guangdong Province. China. 11.

Studia Manna Smica 15: 101-232.

Bull. Br Mux. Nai. Hisi. (hist- Scr.) 18(2): 14_S-:(I2 Issued 29 November 1990

The Lady Blake Collection:
Catalogue of Lady Edith Blake's
Collection of Drawings of
Jamaican Lepidoptera and Plants

C. V. ELLWOOD & J. M. V. HARVEY

DeparlmenI of Library Services, The Nalural History Museum. Cromwell
Road. London SW7 5BD

CONTENTS

Introduction 145

Early Life 146

Ireland, 1874-1884 149

Colonial Life 151

After Retirement 156

The Collection 156

History of the Collection 157

Publications 1 58

Location of Collections 158

Bibliography 159

Explanation of Catalogue Entry 160

Indexes 161

Acknowledgements 161

The Catalogue 162

Index of Lepidoptera Names 197

Index of Plant Names 199

INTRODUCTION

The fascinating collection of watercolours drawn by Lady Edith Blake (1845-1926)
between 1889 and 1898 is housed in the Entomology Library of the Natural History
Museum. London. The 196 drawings depicting Lepidoptera and plants found in Jamaica,
were painted from nature during the lime that Lady Blake's husband. Sir Henry, was
Governor of the colony.

Edith Blake was a skilled amateur artist, who also had a keen interest in natural
history and an ability to observe in detail the objects she drew. Many of the drawings
show the various stages in the life cycle of a moth or butterfly and the foodplant of the
larval stage. The result of her work in Jamaica is a collection of drawings which have
scientific and artistic interest.

The purpose of this paper is to provide a detailed catalogue of these unpublished
drawings. As a result of this work it is hoped that the collection and the scientific
information it contains will be made available to a wider audience. Each drawing has

146 C. V. ELL WOOD & J. M. V. HARVEY

been studied by scientists working in the Departments of Entomology and Botany in the
Natural History Museum. Their identifications and notes are included in the catalogue
together with Lady Blake's own annotations.

Very little has been published on the life of Lady Edith Blake. The biographical
information on the lives of the Blakes has been brought together for the first time and
reveals an interesting life story. Edith lived in many different parts of the world during
the colonial days of the British Empire and as an educated lady exhibited an interest in
many different subjects.

Most of Edith Blake's manuscript material remains in Ireland as part of private
collections. These include diaries, notebooks, letters and watercolours, mostly land-
scapes. It is expected that a complete biography will be published by a member of the
family in the near future.

A list of works written by Edith and Henry Blake is given. The bibliography includes
some references to works not directly referred to in the text. These are listed to aid
further reading and are not intended to be comprehensive.

EARLY LIFE

Edith Osborne was born at Newtown Anner, Clonmel, Ireland, in 1845. She was the
elder daughter of Ralph Bernal Osborne (1808-1882) and Catherine Isabella Osborne.
Edith's sister, Grace Osborne (1848-1926), became Duchess of St. Albans (Ireland)
when she married William, Duke of St Albans, on ?i January 1874.

Ralph Bernal had a considerable reputation as an outspoken and witty member of the
House of Commons. He was educated at Charterhouse School and entered Trinity
College, Cambridge, in 1829. He never settled into his studies; when his father remarried
in 1831 he was removed from Cambridge and sent into the army. He spent some time as
ensign of the 71st Regiment but soon transferred into the 7th Royal Fusiliers. He was
promoted to Captain and remained in the army until entering Parliament in 1841. He
spent much of his time enjoying society and developed a reputation as a composer of
satirical verses.

His engaging personality helped him to enter the House of Commons as Member of
Parliament for Chipping Wycombe. During his career as an MP he held seats at
Middlesex (1847-57), Dover (1857-59), Liskeard (1859-65), Nottingham (1866-68) and
Waterford (1870-74). He supported the liberal interest and was widely known as one of
the most able (if often controversial) debaters in the House, especially when speaking on
Irish topics. Indeed, when he retired from politics there were many who thought that his
loss 'contributed to the decline of the House of Commons and the decline and fall of
statesmanship' (Ward, 1885).

On 20 August 1844 he married Catherine Isabella Osborne, the only child of Sir
Thomas Osborne of Newtown Anner, County Tipperary, and heiress to considerable
estates. On his marriage he assumed the surname Osborne by Royal licence. Catherine
was an intelligent woman and her daughters, Edith and Grace, grew up in a stimulating
and intellectual environment.

Catherine Osborne died at Newtown Anner on 21 June 1880 and Ralph died at
Bestwood Lodge, the seat of the Duke of St Albans, on 4 January 1882.

Although Edith's father was more often in England than in Ireland, there was a
constant succession of visitors at Newtown Anner. Edith met men of distinction in art,
politics, science, philosophy and literature, and developed an interest in many different
subjects. Her particular interests included anthropology, social issues, art and natural

THE LADY BLAKE COLLECTION

147

Lady Edith Blake (Courtesy of the National Library of Jamaica)

148

C. V. hl,LWOOD& J, M. V, HARVEY

history. She was also an excellent linguist and learned the language of whichever country
she lived in. According to Patricia Cockburn (1985) "she could speak nine languages:
Irish, English, Spanish, French, German, Portuguese, Italian. Russian and Chinese,
which later she learned to both read and write'. She corresponded with Joseph Paxton,
the landscape designer, who helped design the gardens at Newtown Anner where he is
believed to have stayed during a visit to Ireland. She was also a tine horsewoman and
well known as a daring rider in the hunting field.

Edith's interest in painting developed early in her life. When she was only 8 years old
her sketches already showed promising talent (S. Murray, pers. comm.). Although she
was chiefly self-taught, it is likely that she also received some instruction from visitors to
the house at Newton Anner. The Osborne family always had an interest in art. Her
grandfather, also called Ralph Bernal, was a well-known art collector and many
watercolourists stayed at the house. Among them were the Swiss landscape painter
Alexandre Calame and Thomas Shotter Boys. Shotter Boys stayed at the house when he
exhibited a work painted at Newtown Anner, probably in 1865 or 1866.

A close friend of both sisters was Fanny Currey (d. 1912) who stayed with them when
she was a girl. She helped Edith and Grace illustrate envelopes for letters sent to their
mother. Fanny Currey later exhibited at the Irish Fine Art Society, the Grosvenor
Gallery, the Royal Institute of Painters in London and the Royal Hibernian Academy,
Dublin (National Gallery of Ireland & Douglas Hyde Gallery, 1987). Grace painted
competent watercolours when an adult, but it seems likely that her social position
prevented her exhibiting or developing her art. Edith never exhibited her work but
continued painting throughout her life.

In February 1872, at the age of 26, Edith began a one-year tour of southern Europe
with a clergyman cousin and a maid. She visited Greece, Malta, Sicily, Italy, Austria,
Germany and Turkey, everywhere taking an interest in customs, social conditions and

Tlic Mi>nk's and Nun'b Ishinds. Corfu
Illustratiun from Twelve monlhs in southern Europe 1876

THE LADY BLAKE COLLECTION 149

architecture. She kept a diary of her travels and observations and published these in
Twelve months in southern Europe in 1876. It is illustrated with four of her drawings of
landscapes and buildings. Considering her later interest in natural history, there is very
little observation on the countryside. Her interest at this time focussed on the people and
architecture.

Edith was a strong character and had a good sense of humour. Two incidents which she
relates in her book are amusing. On one occasion she and her companions walked
through the streets of Constantinople wearing dressing-gowns, slippers and travelling
hats in search of a bath. On another occasion in Italy they borrowed some fishermen's
costumes in order to go swimming.

In 1874 Edith married Henry Arthur Blake (1840-1918). Blake was the son of Peter
Blake, County Inspector of Irish Constabulary. Henry Blake's first wife, Jeannie Irwin,
died in 1866. Edith and Henry had two sons and a daughter, Olive. The marriage was not
approved by Edith's parents. They had been negotiating an arranged marriage (still
common in Ireland in the nineteenth century) when Edith eloped with Captain Henry
Blake, head of the Clonmel police. Royal Irish Constabulary. This resulted in Edith
being disinherited and her name was not mentioned in the house again (Cockburn,
1985). Since Edith had been the heiress to considerable estates and wealth, this was a
significant sacrifice. Henry Blake's family was of a lower social standing than her own.
His wages from his post in the Royal Irish Constabulary had to support his widowed
mother and 12 brothers and sisters.

IRELAND, 1874-1884

After their wedding the Blakes moved to Belfast where Olive, their first child was born.
During the early days of their marriage they had little money but Henry was a highly
capable man and achieved rapid promotion through the ranks of the police force. His
successful career included service as District Inspector at French Park, County
Roscommon (Anon., 1918). In 1876 the Blakes' circumstances improved greatly when
Henry was appointed Resident Magistrate. It was common in this period for Resident
Magistrates to have previously served in the constabulary (McDowell, 1964).

In 1879 Edith Blake published her second book. The ReaUties of Freemasonry. This
work is remarkable because it is a woman revealing many of the secrets of a male
fraternal society. She attempted to dispel many of the mysteries of Freemasonry and
present an unbiased picture of the Fraternity.

The book includes details of the Society's history and explains the ceremonies, secret
words and signs used by Freemasons. The text of the work does not reveal the source of
her information for this expose. However, in the introduction she states: 'There are few
persons who do not reckon a member of the Fraternity amongst their friends or
acquaintances'. Indeed Henry was also a Freemason who achieved high office later in
life. It is likely that at least some of her information was obtained from her husband.

During the next few years the Blakes' lives were significantly affected by the social
turmoil that was sweeping through Ireland. The agricultural depression of the 187()s had
caused a further deterioration in the already desperate conditions of tenant farmers. As a
response to the growing discontent the Land League was founded in 1879. Its aim was to
protect the tenant farmer and to abolish the landlord system. ITte League was led by
Michael Davitt and Charles Stewart Parnell and they received support from many
different levels of Irish Society.

Prime Minister William Gladstone was determined to restore law and order to Ireland.

150

C. V. ELLWOOD&J. M. V. HARVEY

-:S^-

Sir Henry Arthur Blake (Courtesy of the National Library of Jamaica)

THE LADY BIAKE COLLECTION 151

In 1881 he introduced a severe so-called 'Coercion Bill". Part of this legislation included
the suspension of habeas corpus and the appointment of five 'Special Magistrates". Henry
Blake was one of these selected Magistrates who could execute wide ranging powers. It
was intended that these 'Special Magistrates" should provide firm justice and thereby
pacify the growing lawlessness in Ireland.

This duty placed the Blakes in a very dangerous position and Henry was constantly
threatened by assassination. A picture of this frightening period and the brave response
to danger by Edith Blake is illustrated by the following statement that Henry Blake"s life
was 'saved on several occasions by his wife's fearlessness. Lady Blake was a fine revolver
shot and insisted on accompanying him wherever he went, sitting by him on his jaunting
car with her revolver ready cocked in her hand below the rug and similarly armed she sat
by him on the bench when he was presiding in court' (Anon., 1927).

During the disturbances Blake distinguished himself with great courage and ability.
However, it would not be correct to picture the Blakes as part of an upper class which
had no sympathies for Irish nationalist demands. Edith Blake was a highly political
woman and held nationalist connections. Indeed one of her close friends was Anna
Parnell (1852-191 1 ), sister of Charles Stewart Parnell. Anna founded the radical Ladies
Land League which aided the Land League by collecting information on the estates in
Ireland. Charles became increasingly concerned about the activities of these ladies and
dismantled its organisation. Edith expressed 'dislike and contempt for Charles Stewart
Parnell' and retained 'affectionate nostalgia for Anna" (Cockburn, 1985).

After serving as a 'Special Magistrate" Henry Blake applied for a colonial post in the
British Empire. He had shown himself to be an extremely capable man and in 1884 he
was offered the Governorship of the Bahamas. This represented a spectacular rise in his
social position in a relatively short time.

COLONIAL LIFE

Henry Blake's appointment as Governor of the Bahamas was the first of a series of
governorships which were to take the couple to many areas of the British Empire. He
was Governor of the Bahamas, 1884-1887, Newfoundland, 1887-1888, Jamaica, 1889-
1897, Hong Kong, 1897-1903, and Ceylon, 1903-1907. Everywhere the Blakes went they
took a deep interest in the development and conditions of the country. Henry took an
active role in developing the countries' economies and Edith concerned herself with
social welfare, often intervening in situations where she saw injustice or oppression.
Their obvious interest in the conditions of the people made them well regarded and
elicited support for many of their ideas. Edith also continued to show interest in local
customs and natural history. She collected native artefacts, including pottery and stone
implements, and painted the flora, fauna and landscape.

Little is known about the Blakes' time in the Bahamas. As it was Henry's first
appointment as Governor it is likely that he spent much of his time becoming familiar
with his duties and acquainting himself with the state of the country and its people. His
interest in the Colony and its progress is indicated in the following extract from a letter
from Blake to Sir Joseph Hooker (1817-1911) who was at that time Director of the Royal
Botanic Gardens, Kew (12 May 1881):

I want to get a man for a couple of years who knows something of botany and
chemistry & is capable of making analysis of soils. There is an inspector of agriculture
here who knows nothing whom I desire to replace ... It strikes mc that with the ticid

152 C. V. ELLWOOD& J. M. V. HARVEY

for observation so extended and lunworked) as it is here, a young man might be willing
to take the post who has gone through a course of study at home ... If he were an
ornithologist he could prepare specimens & make money of them as the birds are
practically unknown . . . Will you kindly let me know if in your opinion such a man as I
want is to be had on these terms.
(Kew: Leeward Islands Letters 1864-1900; 212(579)).

Kings House. Spanish Town, Jamaica, c. 1880s (Courtesy ul Ihc National l.itirary of Jamaica)

As always Edith would have supported him, in addition to pursuing her particular
interests in natural history and anthropology. Native Indian artefacts which she collected
in the Bahamas are to be found at the Museum of the American Indian in New York (see
p. 158).

In 1887 Henry was posted to Newfoundland where he remained for only a year.
During this short time he made a favourable impression. His travels around the country
to meet people and assess the needs of the colony earned him the reputation 'of being an
able and vigorous administrator, one solicitous to know the true state of the country and
its resources and the real condition of its inhabitants' (Anon., 1888/)).

Henry and Edith were also active in setting up the Newfoundland Society for the
Prevention of Cruelty to Animals. They held a bazaar in Government House to raise
funds and accepted the offer of the Committee to become Patron and Patroness of the
Society when it was inaugurated in November 1888 (Anon., I888(/).

Edith wrote a series of articles in the Evening Telegram on the "Beothuks of
Newfoundland' between 26 December 1888 and 17 January 1889. In these articles she
traces the history of the discovery of Newfoundland and the effect this had on the native
populations. Her concern for local people shows when she says 'no Spanish freebooter or
Yankee could show more utter disregard for the life of an Indian than did Britishers in

THE LADY BLAKE COLLECTION 153

Newfoundland' [Evening Telegram 5 January 1889). The series also reveals her interest
in natural history as she describes the Newfoundland countryside, identifying mosses and
lichens as well as the more obvious flowers and trees.

In October 1888 Henry was appointed as Governor of Queensland. However, he
resigned without taking up his appointment owing to opposition from a section of the
Irish residents of the Colony who resented his previous activities as 'Special Magistrate'.

Instead he was made Captain General and Governor-in-Chief of Jamaica, taking up
the appointment on 9 March 1889. The couple again made a good impression following
their arrival and spent nine years in Jamaica, the term of office being extended twice at
the request of the legislature and public bodies.

While in Jamaica Henry Blake worked hard to make the country better known
throughout the world. He believed strongly in the future economic success of Jamaica
and put energy and money into improving the island's resources. Soon after their arrival
Blake wrote to Daniel Morris (1844-1933), Assistant Director at Kew (9 April 1889):
'We like Jamaica immensely. It is very lovely and I think is on the eve of considerable
progress" (Kew: Jamaica Letters 1865-1900; 210(10)). Morris had previously been
Director of the Public Gardens of Jamaica (1879-1886).

Blake encouraged industry and development. Due to his enthusiasm, many roads and
bridges were built, the railway was extended to all parts of the island, an underground
system of drainage for Kingston was constructed and many new hotels were built
throughout the island.

Henry and Edith obviously loved Jamaica and actively advertised the 'extraordinary
beauty and delight of the Island as a health resort' (Morris, 1891). Morris also says that
'the development of the tourist trade . . . was due in great measure to the efforts of
himself [Henry] and Lady Blake' (Morris, 1891).

One of Blake's most important initiatives was the organization of the International
Exhibition of 1891, opened by George, Prince of Wales on 27 January and remaining
open until 2 May. The exhibition displayed the natural and manufactured products of the
island and led to improved trade and tourism (Morris, 1891; Anon., 1897).

Henry was also aware of the importance of agriculture to the Jamaican economy. He
took advantage of trips to England to discuss policy with Sir William Thistleton Dyer
(1843-1928), Director at Kew, as this extract from a letter from Blake to Lord Ripon
shows (23 October 1894):

I had a long conversation today [with] Mr. (Thistleton] Dyer and Mr. Wangficid and I
find there is no divergence in our views as to the course to be pursued in the matter of
the Botanic Department and the question of Agricultural development financially.
(BL: Lord Ripon's Papers Vol. LXXIV, Add. Mss 43564).

Blake also founded the Jamaica Agricultural Society in 1895, and became its first
President. Edith supported the construction of a marine laboratory to encourage visiting
scientists to study the rich flora and fauna of the island (Anon., 1892a).

It is in Jamaica that Edith's interest in botany, entomology and painting becomes
evident. The first major flora of Jamaica, W. Fawcett & A. B. Rendle's Flora of Jamaica
(1910), lists both Henry and Edith as significant collectors and the authors acknowledge
Blake's support, when they '. . . thank the Government of Jamaica for the loan of the
whole of the material contained in the Jamaican Herbarium'.

The spectacular Jamaican flora and fauna inspired Edith to spend more time at her
painting. The results can be seen in this collection of drawings of plants and Lepidoptera
which Clark (1898) describes: 'Lady Blake has painted from life, the caterpillars,
chrysalids and adults of many of the native Lepidoptera, and her collection of over 100
watercolours of this order are a treat to the artist as well as to the entomologist'. Edith

154 r. V. ELLWOOD&J. M. V. HARVEY

also painted landscapes and many of the beautifully coloured fisfi found in the Caribbean
Sea (now in private collections). She was evidently well known for her interest in art:
"Lady Blake did much to encourage the taste for art. she herself making many
entomological drawings and some landscapes' (Sherlock. 1940).

During this time Edith corresponded with Daniel Morris at Kew and sent him several
consignments of seeds as this letter from Edith to Morris shows (29 September 1895):

I was fortunate enough the other day to [procure] some of the seeds & two roots of
that magnihccnt white lotus which I believe was supposed to have disappeared from
this island. The flowers are beautiful, as large if not larger than those of the Victoria
Regia ... I send you three of the seeds in case you have not already got them . . .
(Kew: Jamaica L.ctters 186.'5-19(X); 210(8)).

(The letter is annotated ".'Nelumbium luteum 3 seeds, quite dead WW).

Henry and Edith lived in King's House, the official residence of the Governor,
throughout their stay in Jamaica. They planted the garden with many ornamental
palms, orchids, ferns and other plants and maintained attractive borders. The garden
was considered one of the most attractive ornamental gardens in Jamaica (Morris.
1891).

Edith's interest in anthropology continued and there are specimens from Jamaica in
the Museum of the American Indian (see p. 158).

When Henry was appointed Governor of Hong Kong in 1898 their loss to Jamaica was
regretted; 'For the past nine years natural science in Jamaica has enjoyed the patronage
and support in countless ways of his Excellency Sir Henry Blake, the Governor of the
island and his estimable wife . . ." (Clarke. 1898). Henry and Edith arrived in Hong Kong
at a difficult time politically and it seems likely there was little opportunity for Edith to
continue with her own interests. Certainly there is little information on her during this
period. Henry continued to show enthusiasm and dedication to his work and Edith no
doubt continued to support him.

Blake's major task was to take over the New Territory leased by China to Great
Britain in June 1898. The many arguments over concessions to China produced an
atmosphere of crisis and uncertainty and the Boxer Rebellion of 1900 added to the
tension. Blake supported the retention of Chinese law and customs and hoped that the
New Territory could be administered through existing Chinese headmen. Although this
did not work in practice his support for the Chinese cause won him many friends.

Plague became endemic during this period, adding to Blake's problems. He was one of
the first to accept that the plague was carried by rats. He initiated a scheme to pay 2 cents
per rat killed, which had to be abandoned when it was discovered that the Chinese
imported rats from the mainland to collect the reward! He continued with extensive
disinfestation and disinfection programmes which failed to make much impact. There
was much disagreement as to the source of the infection and even the Medical Officer of
Health was of the opinion that 'it was more probable that rats caught plague from men
than that men were infected through rats' (Endacott, 1965).

Blake corresponded with Thistleton Dyer about his experiments on treating the
plague. This letter written by Blake from Ceylon indicates his interest (2 February I9(M):

... I entered upon the experiment because I wanted in the first place to try to enlist the
people which in China can always be accomplished by those who treat them properly
& who have acquired their confidence ... as it turned out my plan so far succeeded
that the professional men have endeavoured to follow the same lines . . .
(Kew: Ceylon, Aiden & Persian Letters 1901 1914; 164(171)).

THE LADY BLAKE COLLECTION 155

In 1898, Sir Ronald Ross (1857-1932) discovered that malaria was carried and trans-
mitted by the mosquito and Henry again acted promptly. He employed Professor W.
Simpson of the London School of Tropical Medicine to deal with the control of
mosquitoes in Hong Kong.

Henry and Edith continued to show interest in botany. Two species of oak, native in
the New Territories of Hong Kong, are separately named after the couple. Quercus
hlakei 'is named after the distinguished Governor of Hong Kong, Sir Henry Blake,
G.C.M.G., from whom botanical investigations in the colony have received constant
support and encouragement" and Q. edithae is named after Edith Blake (Skan, 1901).
The floral emblem of Hong Kong, the rare Hong Kong orchid tree Bauhinia blakeana, is
also named in tribute to the Blakes. It commemorates their 'kindly interest taken in the
Hongkong Botanic Gardens' (Dunn, 1908).

When Henry was appointed Governor of Ceylon in 1903, petitions were sent from
Hong Kong to London urging for an extension of his term of office, but were
unsuccessful. He had again proved a popular Governor: '. . . he not only managed to win
the support of the vast majority of the population, and most importantly the business
community and the Legislative Council, but managed to translate this support into
effective action for the betterment of Hong Kong' (Routledge, 1980).

Before their departure in November 1903 the Blakes were honoured by a ceremony
marking the Colony's appreciation, especially in regard to the efforts made to improve
the treatment of victims of the plague. They were presented with an embroidered canopy
and a speech was made thanking Blake for his sympathy and support of the poorer
citizens.

The country greatly interested Blake and he later published a book on the country's
history and customs entitled China (1909). He included anecdotes from this time as
Governor and an extract from an address given by Edith on the position of women in
China.

Evidence of the Blake's interest in botany while in Ceylon appears in letters at Kew.
Soon after his arrival Henry wrote to Thistleton Dyer (2 February 1904):

... I think wc have an excellent staff here at Pcradcniya, but to my mind the
horticultural [sic] is not sufficiently looked into. Man cannot live by bread alone and I
want to sec more prominent floral attraction where so many people visit. It need not
interfere with the solid work of the department but even here there might be
interesting & valuable experiments in hybridisation. I wish you would give a hint to
Mr. Willis . . .
(Kew: Ceylon. Aiden & Persian Letters 1901-1914; 164(171)).

The 'Mr. Willis' referred to is John Christopher Willis (1868-1958), Director of the
Botanic Garden at Peradeniya, 1896-1911.

In 1904 Blake started an Agricultural Society on the same lines as that in Jamaica
which was 'faring splendidly" in September 1905 when he wrote to Thistleton Dyer (Kew:
West Indies Letters 1893-1916; 164(179)).

Edith continued to send plants to Kew and also to William Fawcett (1851-1926) who
was collecting plants in Jamaica (17 April 1905): 'The mango & banana plants that you
wanted have been despatched to you from Peradeniya via Kew'. She also offered advice
on keeping silk worms: 'If the silk worms were kept in sheds that had net over the doors
& windows to [keep] out flies, they ought to do well in Jamaica. I had some of a kind that
eat castor oil plants at Kandy' (Kew: West Indies Letters 1893-1916; 208(379)). When
she and Henry visited London in September 1905 she brought insects and plants with
her.

156 C. V. ELl.WOOD&J. M. V. HARVKY

Henry retired as Governor of Ceylon and from the colonial service in 1907 at the age
of 67 years. He had a long and successful career which earned him respect and popularity
which Edith had also shared.

AFTER RETIREMENT

The following year the Blakes returned to their beloved Jamaica on a triumphant visit.
They arrived on Christmas day and received a great welcome which included official
addresses and a public banquet (Anon.. 1918).

On their return to Ireland, they settled into Myrtle Grove, a Tudor House in Youghal.
County Cork. Tliey carried out extensive repairs and alterations to the house which had
once been the residence of Sir Walter Raleigh.

During his retirement Henry Blake resumed his interest in Irish reform work. He
contributed many articles on Irish topics to reviews such as the Nineteenth Century. Due
to his wide experience in colonial affairs he was consulted about the system of Crown
Colony Government for Ireland. He accepted a seat as a Southern Unionist in the Irish
Convention which was established in 1917 in response to demands for Home Rule.

Henry Blake died on 23 February 1918. The Journal of the Cork Historical and
Archaeological Society published an obituary which described him as 'A man of a broad
and well-cultured mind an interesting and delightful lecturer" (Lee. 1918).

On hearing of Sir Henry's death the Legislative Council in Jamaica passed a resolution
of condolence to Edith and stated that his "administration of the affairs of Jamaica for
many years improved this colony considerably to the best interest of the people" (Anon..
1918).

The death of Henry Blake was a tragic loss for Edith and subsequently she would
rarely leave the house except to sit in the garden (Cockburn. 1985). She suffered from
rheumatism and wore only mourning black. Her great desire to be once more in contact
with her husband lead her to seek the services of a medium. Miss Barlow. She was one of
only a few visitors to the house during this sad time. Edith died at Myrtle Grove on 18
April 1926.

THE COLLECTION

The Lady Blake Collection consists of 196 drawings of Jamaican Lepidoptera and plants.
Most of the drawings are finished watercolours depicting the life cycle of Lepidoptera.
The butterfly or moth is frequently illustrated with a plant which in many examples is the
foodplant of the larva. Larval damage to the plant is also shown.

Most of the Lepidoptera drawings are accurate and illustrate the different stages in the
life cycle. The egg stage is never illustrated. The larval stage and. in some examples, the
different larval instars are depicted. Larvae are often shown in their characteristic
feeding position. The damage caused to the plants by the larvae is clearly and accurately
recorded. This aspect of the collection is of special interest and value as it provides
details of the larval foodplants. Heineman (Brown & Heineman, 1972) wrote in his
work on Jamaican butterflies: 'There is a crying need for lepidopterists to work on the
life histories of butterflies. In many instances we do not know the food plant of the
larvae.'

THE LADY BLAKE COLLECTION 157

The pupae are accurately drawn either attached to the plant or separately when the
larva pupates away from its foodplant. Most adults are shown in flight but occasionally
are depicted at rest. For some drawings it has not been possible to determine whether the
adult is male or female.

A few Hymenoptera and Diptera are also illustrated. For example Drawing no. 66
illustrates Tachinid adults and puparia. Drawing no. 53 includes the only non-insect
animal species, a lizard (Anolis sp.) which is commonly found in Jamaica.

The plant illustrations vary in their quality and detail and clearly have not received the
same level of attention as the Lepidoptera. Over one-third of the drawings have been
accurately identified. Many of the more common plants found in Jamaica are illustrated
including introduced species.

The drawings consist of watercolour on paper. To provide greater body to some of the
illustrations, varnish and gouache have also been used. Most of the drawings are
completed although a few are unfinished studies of plants or Lepidoptera. Drawings vary
from delicate works with well-balanced composition to bold and dramatic images.
Edith's technique was obviously that of an amateur; although quite detailed, many of the
plant illustrations appear rather flat on the page.

A wide range of papers have been used throughout the collection including some dyed
blue. This suggests that Edith did not have access to a large stock of standard paper and
used anything suitable as it became available.

The drawings were not simply the result of artistic interest. Edith spent time collecting
and rearing Lepidoptera and made observations about their life cycle. She also kept a
natural history notebook, which is referred to in Drawing no. 74. moreover many of the
drawings have been annotated by her. The annotations include tentative identifications
of Lepidoptera and notes and observations on the dates of pupation and adult
emergence. These notes show that she took pupae with her during voyages from
Jamaica. For example Drawing no. 170 includes a note that she took a pupa home to
England in 1894; the adult emerged in London.

HISTORY OF THE COLLECTION

On Edith Blake's death in 1926 her daughter, Olive Arbuthnot. presented the collection
to the British Museum (Natural History). This occurred on the recommendation of Lord
Lionel Walter Rothschild (1868-1937) and Dr Charles Gahan (1862-1939), Keeper of
the Department of Entomology.

The drawings were sorted and stamped numerically in the centre of each sheet. It was
recognised that they provided valuable information about the Lepidoptera and flora of
Jamaica. Norman D. Riley (1890-1979), Keeper of Entomology at the Museum, made a
preliminary study of the collection and his pencil notes of possible identifications appear
on the drawings.

During 1984, as part of a programme of conservation in the Department of Library
Services, the drawings were treated by a specialist paper conservator. Each drawing
was cleaned and mounted in acid-free paper folders and protected by a sheet of
Melinex.

In 1987 two drawings, nos. 13 and 17, were loaned to the National Gallery of Ireland
and were included in an exhibition, 'Irish Women Artists from the Eighteenth Century to
the Present Day' (National Gallery of Ireland & Douglas Hyde Gallery, 1987). This
supported the recognition of Lady Blake as a notable amateur Irish artist.

158 r. V. EI.IWOOD & J. M. V. harvey

PUBLICATIONS

Sir Henry Arthur Blake

1880. Pictures from Ireland (as Terence M'Grath). 2()6pp. London.

1881. 2nd ed. 206pp. London.

1881. 3rd ed. 206pp. London.

1896. Jamaica: photographs of the principal bridges erected in the island from l/i'Jd to IS95.

Kingston. (Held in the West India Library of the Institute of Jamaica; not seen.)
1907. Progress of the colony of Ceylon. 190'4^1907. 57pp. Colombo.
1909. China (illustrations by M. Menpes). vii. 138pp. London.

Lady Edith Blal<e

1876. Twelve months in southern Europe. 34Ipp. 4 pis. London.

1879. The realities of Freemasonry. 264pp. London.

1888-1889. Beothuks of Newfoundland. Evening Telegram 26 December 1888-17 January 1889.

1888. The Beothuks of Newfoundland. Nineteenth Century 24: 899-918.

1888. In the Bahamas. Nineteenth Century 23: 682-692.

1891. A chat about Newfoundland. North American Review 152: 714-722.

1892. Highlands of Jamaica. North American Review 154: 343-352.

1912. The Triad Society and the restoration of the Ming Dynasty. Nineteenth Century 71: 667-687.

1912. The position of women in China. Nineteenth Century 72: 1040-I05I.

1913. Santa Sophia and its memories. Nineteenth Century 73: 355-376.

1913. 'Tir-na-Bes'. a study of Irish life - and death. Nineteenth Century 74: 130-135.

1914. The sacred Bo Tree. Nineteenth Century 76: 660-673.

LOCATION OF COLLECTIONS

Most of Edith Blake's manuscripts and drawings are in private collections. Papers
relating to Henry Blake's colonial service are to be found at the Public Record Office,
Kew. The sources located during research for this paper are listed below.

1 . NATURAL HISTORY MUSEUM. Entomology Library, Cromwell Road, London SW7 5BD.
196 watercolour drawings of Jamaican plants and Lepidoptera, 1889-1898.

(Entomology Library drawings collection.)

2. ROYAL BOTANIC GARDENS, KEW, Richmond. Surrey TW9 3AB. (Kew)
17 letters from Edith and Henry Blake to Directors of Kew, 1884-1905.
(Archives: Director's correspondence).

3. BRITISH LIBRARY, Department of Manuscripts, Great Russell Street, London WCIB 3DG.
(BL)

Letters from Henry Blake to Lord Ripon, 1892-1894.
(Additional Manuscripts 43564: Lord Ripon Papers, volume 74).

4. PROVINCIAL ARCHIVES OF NEWFOUNDLAND AND LABRADOR, CoUmial
Building, Military Road, St. John's, Newfoundland AlC 2C9.

Letter of appointment as Governor (29 June 18X7) and Invitation to become Patrons of the
Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals plus Prospectus (29 October 1887).
(ON 1/3A series).

5. MUSELIM OF THE AMERICAN INDIAN, Heye Foundation, Broadway at 155th Street,
New York, New York 1(K132 USA.

THE LADY BLAKE COLLECTION 159

29 pages of correspondence from Edith and Henry Blake (1916-1917). Catalogue notes relating
to the purchase of archaeological collections from the Caicos Islands, Jamaica, the Bahamas,
etc. (some of the notes dated 1896).
(Archives Box OC123, Folder 25).

6. AMERICAN MUSEUM OF NATURAL HISTORY, Anthropology Department, Central
Park West at 79th Street. New York, New York 10024 USA.

Fossil shell cast, marine and land shells and beetles from Jamaica, accessioned in 1896.
(Accession numbers: 2450 & 2477).

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Anon. 1S44. Gentleman's Magazine Pt. ii: ."^lO, 538.

1882a. Times 5 January.

1882b. Times 11 January.

1884u. Temple Bar September.

1884/). Fonnightly Review October.

1887. Our new Governor. Evening Telegram 8 September.

1888a. Promotion of Governor Blake. Evening Telegram 25 October.

1888b. Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals. Evening Telegram 12 November.

1888f . Farewell to Sir Henry. Evening Telegram 14 November.

1888d. About Governor Blake. Evening Telegram 8 December.

1889. Governor Blake's son. Evening Telegram 17 January.

1892o. A marine laboratory for Jamaica. Journal of the Institute of Jamaica 1(3): 89.

1892b. Notes and queries. Journal of the Institute of Jamaica 1(3): 184.

1897. Resume of the work & transactions of the Society. Journal of the Jamaica Agricultural

Society 1(1): 2-3.

1913. Gossip. Irish Book Lover 5: 6.3-64.

1918. Irish Times 25 February.

Bagenal, P. H. D. 1884. Life of Ralph Bernat Osborne. MP. x, 37lpp London.

Brown, F. M. & Heineman, B. 1972. Jamaica ami its butterflies. 478pp. lOfl] pis. London.

Clark, H. L. 1898. Zoological Jamaica. Natural Science (September): 161-171.

Cn, J. 1918 Sir Henry Blake G. CM. G /n,v/i Book Lover 9. ll(^-lll.

Cockburn, P. 1985. Figure of eight. 243pp. 8 pis. London.

Crone, J. S. 1928. A concise dictionary of Irish biography, viii, 27()pp. Dublin.

Cundall, F. 1915. Historic Jamaica xxiii, 424pp. London.

Currey, F. W. 1877. Prime Ritto: or the four-leaved shamrock. 39pp, London.

Desmond, R. 1977. Dictionary of Britith and Irish botanists and horticulturists, xxvi, 747pp.

London.
Dunn, S. T. 1908. New Chinese plants. Journal of Botany 46: 32.5-326.
Endacott, G. B. 1965. They lived in Government House. China Mail 19 June.
1973. A history of Hong Kong. Rev. edn. xii. 324pp. (Oxford in Asia paperbacks). Hong

Kong.
Fawcett. W. & Rendle, A. B. 1910. Flora of Jamaica. Vol. 1: LSOpp. 32 pis. London.
Hickey, D. J. & Doherty, J. E. 1987. A dictionary of Irish history I800-I9S0. 615pp. Dublin.
Jarrett, V. H. G. 193-V1935. Old Hong Kong. South China Morning Post. 17 June 1933-13 April

1935.
Kee, R. c. 1980. Ireland: a history. 256pp. 16 pis. London.
Lee, P. G. 1918. The late Sir Henry Arthur Blake, G.C.M.G. Journal of the Cork Historical and

Archaeological Society 24: 45.
McDowell, R. B. \9M' Iri.sh administration I80I-19I4. xi, 328pp. (Studies in Irish history, 2nd

series; vol. 2) London.
Morris, D. 1891. Report of a botanical mission to the West Indies . . . [Jamaica]. Kew Bulletin

1891: 154-1.58.

160 C. V. F,l,LWOOD& J. M. V. HARVEY

National Gallery of Ireland & Douglas Hyde Gallery 1^87. Irish women artists: from the eighteenth

century to the present day. xxxxviii, 2()Spp. Dublin.
Parsons, A. A. 1920. Governors 1 have known. Newfoundland Quarterly 20(3): 1-3.
Prowse, D. W. 1895. A history of Newfoundland from the English, Colonial and foreign records.

xxiii, 742pp. London.
Riley, N. D. 1975. A field guide to the butterflies of the West Indies. 224pp. London.
Routledge, T. 1980. Governors of Hong Kong 13: Sir Henry Arthur Blake. Hong Kong Taller

4(41): 28-31.
Sayer, G. R. 1975. Hong Kong 1862-1919. xiv, 166pp. 13 pis. Hong Kong.
Sherlock, P. M. (Ed.) 1940. Jamaica to-day. 240pp. [London).
Skan, S. A. 1901. Quercus Edithae Skan. Hooker's Icones Plantarum 4th series 7: pi. 2661.

1901 . Quercus blakei. Skan, Hooker's Icones Plantarum 4th scries 7: pi. 2662.

Smallwood, J. R. & Pitt, R. D. W. (Eds) 1981-. Encyclopedia of Newfoundland and Labrador.

Vol. 1- St. John's. Newfoundland.
Stenton, M. (Ed.) 1976. Who's who of British Members of Parliament, volume I: I832-IH75. xvi,

448pp. Hassocks.
Stephen, L. (Ed.) 1885. The dictionary of national biography. Vol. 2: 1395pp. London.
Ward, T. H. (Ed.) 1885. Men of the reign, iv. 1020pp. London.
Who was who. 1916-1928. xv, 1159pp. London.

EXPLANATION OF CATALOGUE ENTRY

SAMPLE ENTRY

134. Moth: Earn. Sphingidae: Macroglossinae Probably Pseudosphinx tetrio L. (Frangipani
Sphinx)

1 larva on stem, 1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa drawn separately; 1 adult in flight
Plant: Earn. Apocynaceac Plumeria rubra L. (Frangipani) Stem, leaves and flowers. Shows
larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 15th June. Moth emerged 8th July. 1893.'; "King's
House 8th June. 1893'
Size: 331 x 456 mm

Notes: Food plants of P. tetrio recorded in literature as P. rubra and Jasminum sp.
(Oleaceae).

Catalogue number

The catalogue number refers to the running number stamped on the drawing.

BUTTERR.Y/MOTH

The currently accepted scientific name of the butterfly or moth is given as identified by the staff of
the Natural History Museum Entomology Department. The Family name is given and where
possible the Genus and Species. It has not always been possible to give a full identification. Where
there is doubt the terms probably' and possibly' have been used. The common name is given
where one is known to exist.

The numbers of larvae, pupae and adults figured are given. Adult males and females are
distinguished where possible.

Where there is more than one species, the numbers in square brackets before the family name
refer cither to Edith Blake's own numbers on the drawing or to a given number on the verso ol the
drawing.

Plant

The modern botanical name for the plant is given. The Family name is given and where possible
the Genus and Species name. Where a full identification cannot be made it is usually because only

THE LADY BLAKE COLLECTION 161

a leaf is figured or the drawing is unfinished. The common name is also given where one is known.
Plant names are based on C. D. Adams Flowering plants of Jamaica. 1972. Where a name has been
changed since this publication, the new name is given in brackets.

A short description of the image indicates the presence of stems, leaves, flowers, fruit and larval
or other damage.

Annotations

Annotations in Edith Blake's hand are recorded. Annotations in other hands are not given

Annotations on the recto of the drawing arc preceded by r and those on the verso by v The

medium of the annotations (i.e. pencil or ink) is noted in square brackets. All annotations arc

included between inverted commas.
The annotations generally include date of pupation, date of emergence of adult and occasionally

localities.

In some instances part of the annotation has been partially deleted by Edith Blake and these

have been transcribed and enclosed in double square brackets, e.g. [[]].

SiZt;

The size of the drawing is recorded in millimetres as follows: height x width. These arc the
dimensions of the paper support.

Notes

The notes area contains information on identification and/or food plants where these are
considered useful. It also gives details of previous reproductions of the image.

INDEXES

1. Index of lepidoptera names - alphabetical, including family names, modern species
names and common names with reference to the catalogue entry number.

2. Index of plant names - alphabetical, including family names, modern species names
and common names with reference to the catalogue entry number.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

The authors would like to express their thanks for the specialist help given by colleagues
in the Department of Entomology, The Natural History Museum, London, especially Dr
Gaden Robinson, Mr Phil Ackery, Mr David Carter, Dr Malcolm Scoble, Dr Ian
Kitching, Mr Michael Schaffer. Mr Kevin Tuck, Mr Martin Honey, Mr David Goodger
and Mr Gerry Tremewan. We would also like to thank Dr Dennis Adams, Research
Associate in the Department of Botany. We are also grateful for the generous help
afforded by: Nancy Rosoff, Museum of the American Indian. Pat O'Sullivan, National
Museum of Ireland; Valerie Seymour, St. Patrick's College Library, Co. Kildare; Paula
Howard, Dublin Public Libraries; D. O. Luanaigh, National Library of Ireland; Eppie
D. Dwars, National Library of Jamaica; staff of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew; Nora
de Brun, The Boole Library, University College, Cork; Sharon S. L. Law, Hong Kong
Museum of Art; C. C. Wong, Reference Librarian, Chinese University of Hong Kong;
Sarah C. Choy, Public Records Office of Hong Kong; Derek Bussey, Newfoundland
Public Library Service and Howard C. Brown, Provincial Archives of Newfoundland and
Labrador.

162 C. V. EUWOOD & J. M. V. HARVEY

We acknowledge the assistance given by the family and in particular Mrs Shirley
Murray and the late Mrs Patricia Cockburn.

This project has been supported and encouraged by our library colleagues in particular
bv Mr Rex Banks, Miss Pamela Gilbert. Mrs Kathy Martin, Mr Malcolm Beasley and Mr
Nick Stead.

THE CATALOGUE

1. BuTTERFl.'i : [I] Fam. Papilionidae Battus polydamus jamaicensis Rothschild & Jordan
(Jamaican Polydamus)

1 larva on leaf, 1 larva on stem; I pupa on stem. 1 pupa drawn separately: 1 adult in flight.

BLHTERn Y: [2| Fam. Papilionidae Possibly Battus polydamus jamaicensis Rothschild & Jordan

(Jamaican Polydamus)

1 larva on stem.

Plant: Fam. Aristolochiaceae Aristolochia trilobata L. (Tref)

Twining stem with leaves and flowers. Shows larval damage. Also separate stem with pupa

attached.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Caterpillar no. 2 having devoured one of the butter-fly chrysalidac,

buried itself 25th July.'; 'Chrysalis formed lOth June. Butterfly emerged 26th July. 1893.'

Size: 456 x 3.7,0 mm

Notes: Foodplant of B. polydamus jamaicensis recorded in literature as A. trilobata.

2. BinTERFLY: Fam. Papilionidae Papilio thersites Fabricius (Thersites Swallowtail)

1 larva on stem; I pupa on stem; 1 adult female in flight.

Plant: Fam. Rutaceae Fagara pterota L. (= Zanlhoxylum fagara (L.) Sarg.) (Bastard

Ironwood, Savcn Tree)

Stem and leaves. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] Chrysalis formed 21st Sept. Butterfly emerged 20th Oct 97'

Size: 306 x 243 mm

Notes: Foodplant of P. thersites recorded in literature as citrus plants (Rutaceae).

3. Butterfly: Fam. Papilionidae Papilio thoas melonius Rothschild & Jordan (Jamaican
Swallowtail)

2 larvae on stem; 1 pupa on stem; 1 adult in flight.

Plant: Fam. Rutaceae Fagara pterota L. (= Zanthoxylum fagara (L.) Sarg.) (Bastard

Ironweed, Saven Tree)

Stem, leaves and flowers in very young bud. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 7th June. Butterfly emerged 28th June 1893.'; v

[pencil] 'Chrysalis formed 7th June. Butterfly emerged 28th June.'

Size: 300 x 235 mm

Notes: Foodplant of P. thoas melonius recorded in literature as Piper sp. (Piperaceae).

4. Butterfiy: Fam. Papilionidae Papilio homerus Fabricius (Homerus .Swallowtail)
1 larva on stem; 1 pupa on stem; 1 adult in flight.

Plant: Fam. Hernandiaceae Hernandia caialpifolia Britton & Harris (Water Mahoc, Water

Wood)

Stem and leaves. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] Caterpillar attached itself to branch 29th Nov. Chrysalis formed 2d

Dec. Butterfly emerged 29th Dec 1893.'; i' [pencil] 'Caterpillar fixed itself 29th Nov Chrysalis

formed 2nd Dec'

Size: 456 x 3.30 mm

Notes: Foodplant of P. homerus recorded in literature as Ipomoea sp. (Convolvulaceae) and

possibly Chimarrhis sp. (Rubiaceae) Thcspesia sp. (Malvaceae) and Hernandia sp.

(Hernandiaceae).

THE LADY BLAKE COLLECTION 1 63

5. BuTTERFlY: Fam. Pieridac Appias drusilla jacksoni Kaye (Jamaican Albatross)
I larva on leaf; I pupa on leaf: I adult male in flight.

Plant: Unidentified

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annot.ations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 15lh Sept. Butterfly emerged 23d. Sept. 1893.'

Size: 306 x 243 mm

Notes: Foodplants o( A. drusilla jacksoni recorded in literature as Capparis sp. (Capparaceae)

and Drypetes sp. (Euphorbiaceae).

6. Butterfly: Fam. Pieridac Ascia monuste euhotea Godart (Antillean Great White)

1 larva on stem, 2 larvae on leaves; 1 pupa on stem; 1 adult male in flight, 1 adult female in

flight.

Plant: Fam. Capparaceae Cleome spmosa ]a<:q.

Stem and leaves. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 3d August. Butterfly emerged 13th August. 93.'

Size: 3(X) x 235 mm

Notes: Foodplants of A. monuste eubotea recorded in literature as Crataeva sp., Cleome sp.

(Capparaceae), Brassica sp., Lepidium sp. (Cruciferae (Brassicaceae)) and Tropaeoleum sp.

(Tropaeolaccae).

7. Butterfly: Fam. Pieridac Eurema daira palmira Pocy (Poey's Barred Sulphur)
1 larva on stem; 1 pupa on stem; 1 adult male in flight.

Plant: Unidentified

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 6th Sept. Butterfly emerged 12th Sept. 95.'

Size: 351 x 249 mm

Notes: Foodplants of E. daira palmira recorded in literature as Papilionaceae (Aeschynomene

sp., Stylosanthes sp., Desmodium sp.) and Caesalpinaceae (Cassia sp.)

8. Butterfly: Fam. Pieridae Eurema elathea Cramer (Cramer's Barred Sulphur)
1 larva on stem; 1 pupa on stem; 1 adult male in flight.

Plant: Fam. Papilionaceae (Fabaceae) Stylosanthes hamata (L.) Taub. (Cheesy Toes,

Donkey Weed, Pencil Flower)

Stem, leaves and flowers. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 16th Feb. Butterfly emerged 27th Feb. 94 Terias

elathea = Cramer.'; v [pencil] 'Chrysalis I6th Feb'

Size: 238 x 30() mm

Notes: Foodplant of E. elathea also recorded in literature as Zornia sp. (Papilionaceae).

9. Butterfly: Fam. Pieridae Eurenm lisa euterpe Mcnetries (Little Sulphur)

1 larva on stem; 1 pupa on stem; 1 adult female in flight, 1 adult male in flight.

Plant: Fam. Mimosaceae Mimosa pudica L. (Shame Weed)

Stem, leaves and flower. No larval damage.

Size: 352 x 251 mm

Notes: Foodplant of E. lisa euterpe recorded in literature as M. pudica

10. Butterfly: Fam. Pieridae Kricogonia lyside Godart (Lyside)

1 larva on stem; 2 pupae on stem; 1 adult male in flight, 1 adult female in flight.

Plant: Fam. Zygophyllaccae Guaiacum officinale L. (Lignum Vitae)

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 3d August. Butterfly emerged 9th Aug. 97'

Size: 250 x 180 mm

Notes: Foodplant of K. lyside also recorded in literature as Porliena sp. (Zygophyllaceae).

11. BLiTTERn.Y: Fam. Pieridae Anteos maerula maerula Fabricius (Maerula)
1 larva on stem, 1 larva on leaf; 2 pupae on stem; I adult male in flight.

Plant: Fam. Papilionaceae (Fabaceae) Gliricidia .sepium (Jacq.) Kunth ex Griseb. (Aaron's

Rod, Grow Stick, Quick Stick)

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 10th Nov."

j^ C. V. ELLWOOD& J. M. V. HARVEY

Size: 299 x 235 mm

Notes: Foodplant of A. maerula maerula recorded in literature as Cassia sp. (Caesalpmiaceae).

12. BltterfI-Y: Fam. Pieridae Phoebis sennae sennae L. (Cloudless Sulphur)

1 larva on stem; 2 pupae on stem; 1 adult female in flight. 1 adult male in flight.

Plant: Fam. Caesalpiniaceae Cassia emarginata L. (Senna Tree. Yellow Candle Wood)

Stem, leaves and flowers. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] Chrysalis formed 14th Nov. Butterfly emerged 24th Nov. 1893.'

Size: 299 x 238 mm

Notes: Foodplant of P. sennae sennae recorded in literature as Cassia sp. (Caesalpiniaceae).

13. BuTTERnv: Fam. Nymphalidae: Danainae Danaus gitippas jamaicensis Bates (Jamaican
Queen)

1 larva on stem: 1 pupa on leaf; I adult female in flight.

Plant: Fam. Asclepiadaceae Asclepias curassavica L. (Redhead, Red Top)

Stem, leaves and flowers. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] '1 Chrysalis formed 28th Nov. Butterfly emerged 9th Dec. 1893."

Size: 456 x 239 mm

Notes: Published in National Gallery of Ireland & Douglas Hyde Gallery ( 1987).

14. Butterfly: Fam. Nymphalidae: Heliconiinae Heliconnis charilonius simulator Robert
(Jamaican Zebra)

2 pupae on tendril; 1 adult in flight.

Plant: Fam. Passifloraceae Passiflora laurifolia L. (Golden Apple)
Sketch of tendril.
Size: 301 x 236 mm

15. Bitterfly: Fam. Nymphalidae: Heliconiinae Heliconius charilonius simulator Robert
(Jamaican Zebra)

1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf; 1 adult in flight.

Plant: Fam. Passifloraceae Passiflora laurifolia L. (Golden Apple)

Stem, leaves, tendrils and flower. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 5th Dec. Butterfly emerged 15th Dec. 1893.'

Size: 508 x 239 mm

16. Butterfly: Fam. Nymphalidae: Heliconiinae Dryas iulia delila Fabricius (Julia)

1 larva on tendnl, I "larva on leaf; 2 pupae on tendril; 1 adult female in flight, I adult male in
flight.

Plant: Fam. Passifloraceae Passiflora suberosa L.

Stem, leaves, tendrils, flowers and fruit. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 27th Nov. Buttertly emerged 10th Dec. 1893.'

Size: 300 x 237 mm

Notes: Foodplants of D. iulia delila recorded in literature as Passiflora vespertilio L. and

Passiflora ichlhyura Mast.

17. Butterfly: Fam. Nymphalidae: Heliconiinae Agraulis vanillae insulans Maynard (Tropical
Silverspot)

2 larvae on leaf; 1 pupa on stem; 1 adult in flight

Plant: Fam. Passifloraceae Passiflora laurifolia L. (Golden Apple)

Stem, leaves, tendrils and flowers. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 25th Dec. 92 Butterfly emerged 5th Jan 93.'

Size: .508 x 238 mm

Notes: Published in National Gallery of Ireland & Douglas Hyde Gallery (1987).

18. Butterfly: Fam. Nymphalidae: Heliconiinae Agraulis vanillae insularis Maynard (Tropical
Silverspot)

1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa on tendril; 1 adult at rest on leaf.

Plant: Fam. Passifloraceae Passiflora laurifolia L. (Golden Apple)

Stem, leaves and tendrils. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 4th Dec. Butterfly emerged 15th Dee. 95'

Size: 350 x 249 mm

THE LADY BLAKE COLLECTION ] 65

19. BLiTTERnY: Fam. Nymphalidae Euploiela claudia daudia Cramer (Variegated Fritillary)

2 larvae on leaf; 1 pupa on stem; 1 adult in flight.

Plant: Fam. Turneraceae Turnera ulmifolia L. (Ram-Goat Dashalong)

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 7th August. Butterfl [sic] emerged 13th Augst. [sic]

97-

Size: 350 x 250 mm

Notes: E. claudia claudia is widely polyphagous.

20. Blitterfly: Fam. Nymphalidae Euptoieta claudia claudia Cramer (Variegated Fritillary)

1 larva; 1 pupa; I adult in flight.
Plant: No plant figured

Annotations: r [ink] Chrysalis formed 16th Oct. 92 Butterfly emerged 31st Oct. 92."
Size: 301 x 236 mm

21. Butterfly: Fam. Nymphalidae Antillea proclea Doubleday & Hewitson (Jamaican Crescent-
Spot)

3 larvae on leaves; 1 pupa on leaf stem; 1 adult in flight.
Plant: Fam. Acanthaceae Dicliptera sexangularis (L.) Juss.
Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r (ink| 'Chrysalis formed 5th Sept. Butterfly emerged 12th Sept. 93'
Size: 507 x 237 mm

22. BuTTERn.Y: Fam. Nymphalidae Junonia evarete zonalis Felder & Felder (West Indian
Buckeye)

2 larvae on leaves; 1 pupa on stem; 2 adults in flight.
Plant:: Fam. Plantaginaceae Plantago virginica L.
Stem, leaves and flowers. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 28th Augst. [sic] Butterfly emerged Sept. 5th 89

Craigton.'

Size: 227 x 14(l mm

Notes: Foodplants of J. evarete zonalis also recorded in literature as Slachytarphela sp.,

Lippia sp. (Verbenaceae) and Valeriana sp. (Valerianaceae).

23. BUTTERFI.Y: Fam. Nymphalidae Junonia evarete zonalis Felder & Felder (West Indian
Buckeye)

1 larva on stem; I pupa on stem; 1 adult in flight.

Plant: Fam. Verbenaceae Stachylarpheta jamaicensis (L.) Vahl (Porter Weed, Vervine)

Stem, leaves and flowers. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 21st Sept. Butterfly emerged [5]th Oct. 1893'

Size: .3(X) x 2,36 mm

Notes: Foodplants of /. evarete zonalis also recorded in literature as Slachytarphela sp..

Lippia sp. (Verbenaceae) and Valeriana sp. (Valerianaceae).

24. Butterfly: Fam. Nymphalidae Siproeta stelenes stelenes L. (Antillcan Malachite)

2 larvae on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf stem; 2 adults in flight.
Plant: Fam. Acanihaccac Justicia pectoralis }acq. (Fresh Cut)
Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 21st August. Butterfly emerged 31st August 97'

Size: 351 x 249 mm

Notes: Foodplants of S. stelenes stelenes recorded in literature as Blechum sp. and Ruellia sp.

(Acanthaceae).

25. Butterfi.y: Fam. Nymphalidae Anartia jatrophae jamaicensis Moschler (Jamaican White
Peacock)

1 larva on leaf, 1 larva on stem; 1 pupa on stem; 1 adult male in flight.

Plant: Fam. Acanthaceae Ruellia tuberosa L. (Duppy Gun, Menow Weed)

Stem, leaves and fruit. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: ;■ [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 4th Nov. Butterfly emerged 12th Nov 92.'

Size: 300 x 235 mm

166

C. V. ELLWOOD& J. M. V. HARVEY

No. 24 Spirueta stelenes slelenes L. (bullcrfly), JustUa pecloralus Jacq. (plant)

THE LADY BLAKE COLLECTION

167

l.!a/,. ;.,„,/ /-'jOf,

No. 26 Hisliiris odius uiliiis Fabricius (butterfly 1); Cohhura dirce avmoffi Comslock (butterfly 2); Cccropia

pellala L. (plant)

168 C. V. ELLWOOD & J. M. V . HARVEY

26. BinTERFLY: [l] Fam. Nymphalidae Hislori.s odius oilius Fabricius (Orion)
1 pupa on stem; 1 adult in flight.

BUTTERH V; [2] Fam. Nymphalidae Colohura dirce avinoffi Comstock (Dirce)

1 pupa on stem; 1 adult in flight.

Plant: Fam. Cecropiaceae Cecropia pfluiui 1.. (Snake Wood, Trumpet Tree)

Stem and leaf. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 1. Chrysalis formed 17lh Nov. Butterfly emerged 5th Dec. 92"; '2.

Chrysalis formed 1st Dec. Butterfly emerged IKth Dec. 92"

Size: 457 x 330 mm

Notes: 6 larvae are shown on a leaf but are not sufficiently distinct to distinguish between the

two species.

27. Butterfly: Fam. Nymphalidae Mestra dorcas Fabricius (Dorcas)

3 lar\ae on stem; 2 pupae on stem; 1 adult in flight.

Plant: Fam. Euphorbiaceae Tragia voliibili.'^ L. (Twining Cowitch)

Stem, leaves, flowers and fruit. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 9th Sept. Butterfly emerged 17th Sept. 97'

Size: 352 x 249 mm

28. Butterfly: Fam. Nymphalidae Adelpha ahyla Hewitson (Jamaican Admiral)

2 larvae on leaf; 2 pupae on leaf; 1 adult in flight.
Plant: Fam. Rubiaceae Mussaenda ireuden Stapf.
Stem, leaves and flowers. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] "Chrysalis formed 17th August. Butterfly emerged 26th August. 97'

Size: 351 x 249 mm

Notes: M. ireutleri is a cultivated ornamental, native of tropical Asia.

29. Butterfly: [1] Fam. Lycaenidae Helerosmaitia bourkei Kaye (Bourke's Hairstreak)

2 larvae on flowers, 1 larva on stem; 1 pupa on leaf. 1 pupa on stem; 1 adult male in flight.
Moth: [2] Fam. Geometridae

4 larvae on leaves; 2 adults in flight.

Plant: Fam. Sterculiaceae Wallheria indica L. (Raichie)

Stem, leaves and flowers. No larval damage.

Annotations: r[ink[ '1 Chrysalis formed 30th August. 1 Butterfly emerged 12th Sept 93. 2

Chrysalis formed 9th Sept 2 Moth emerged 21st Sept. 1893.'; v [pcncil| Chrysallis 2 formed 9th

Sept.'

Size: 306 x 243 mm

30. Butterfly: Fam. Hesperiidae Vrbanus proteus L. (Common Tailed Skipper)

1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf; 1 adult male in flight.

Plant: Fam. Papilionaceae (Fabaceae) Cenlrosema virginiaiuim (L.) Bcnth.

Stem, leaves and pod. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink| 'Chrysalis formed 18th Jan 93 Butterfly emerged 5th Feb.'

Size: 300 x 236 mm

Notes: U. proteus is polyphagous.

31. Butterfly: Fam. Hesperiidae Polygonus leo hagar Evans (Evans' Jamaican Skipper)

2 larvae on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf; 1 adult in flight.

Plant: Fam. Papilionaceae (Fabaceae) Piscidia piscipula (L.) Sarg. (Dogwood)

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 1 1th Dec. Butterfly emerged 29th Dec 1893."

Size: 509 x 239 mm

Notes: Foodplants of P. leo hagar recorded in literature as Piscidia sp.. Derris sp.. and

Lonchocarpus sp. (Papilionaceae).

32. BinTERR-Y: Fam. Hesperiidae Aguna asander jasper Evans (Asander)
1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf; 1 adult in flight.

Plant: Fam. Cacsalpiniaccae Possibly Fiaiihinia monandra Kurz

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 12th June. Butterfly emerged 30th July. 1893"

THE LADY BLAKE COLLECTION 169

Size: 300 x 235 mm

Notes: Foodplant of A. asander jasper recorded in literature as in Leguminosae.

33. BUTTERFl y: Fam. Hesperiidae Cahares polrillo polrillo Lucas (Lucas Skipper)
2 larvae on leaves: 1 pupa on leaf; 1 adult in flight.

Plant: Fam. Verbenaceae Priva lappulacea (L) Pers. (Clammy Bur. Fasten-'pon-Coat.

Styptic Bur, Velvet Bur)

Stem, leaves and burs. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r |ink] 'Chrysalis formed about 16th Nov. Butterfly emerged 27th Dec. 1892.'

Size: 300 x 234 mm

Notes: Foodplants of C. potrillo polrillo recorded in literature as Schrankia sp. (Mimosaceae)

and Indigofera sp. (Papilionaceae).

34. Butterfly: Fam. Hesperiidae Ephyriades zephodes Hiibner or E. areas phileman Fabricius
(Hiibner's Hairy Dusky Wing or Fabricius" Hairy Dusky Wing)

1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf; 1 adult in flight.

Plant: Fam. Possibly Moraceae Fieussp.

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: v [pencil] 'Butterfly emerged 2nd March'

Size: 300 x 239 mm

Notes: The two butterfly species are virtually indistinguishable in general features.

35. BuTTERn.Y: Fam. Hesperiidae Gesla gesta gesla Hcrrich-Schaffer (Common Dusky Wing)
1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf; 1 adult in flight.

Plant: Fam. Papilionaceae (Fabaccae) Possibly Seshania sp. or Tephrosia sp.

Stem and leaves. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] '1 Chrysalis formed 16th August. Butterfly emerged 25th Aug 97'; "2

Caterpillar fastened itself up 22 August. Moth emerged 2d Sept 97'

Size: 238 x 161 mm

36. Butterfly: Fam. Hesperiidae Possibly Gesta gesta ^esta Herrich-Schaffer (Common Dusky
Wing)

1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf; 1 adult in flight.

Plant: Fam. Papilionaceae (Fabaceae) Indigofera suffruticosa Mill. (Guatemala Indigo,

Markham Gungo, Wild Indigo)

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] Chrysalis formed 21st Feb. Butterfly emerged 5th March. 94'; v [pencil]

'1 Chrysalis 21st Feb [chrysalis| 26th Feb'

Size: 3tX) x 239 mm

37. Moth: [1] Fam. Tortricidac Platynota sp.
1 adult in flight.

BUTTERR Y: [2] Fam. Hesperiidae Anastrus sempiternus dilloni Bell & Comstock (Dillon's

Dusky Wing)

1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf; 1 adult in flight.

Plant: Fam. Myrtaceae Psidium guajava L. (Guava)

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] '1 Chrysalis formed 6th Feb. Moth emerged 19th Feb. 1894'; '2 Chrysalis

formed 18th Feb. Butterfly emerged 2d March. 94'; v [pencil] 'Small Chrysalis 6th Feb";

'[indecipherable] 18th Feb'

Size: 300 x 238 mm

Notes: Foodplant of A. sempiternm guajava recorded in literature as P. guajava.

38. Butterfly: Fam. Hesperiidae Pyrgus oileus L. (Syrichtus) 3 larvae on leaves; 1 pupa on leaf;
1 adult in flight.

Plant: Fam. Malvaceae Sida acuta Burm. f. (Broomweed)

Stem, leaves, flowers and buds. No larval damage.

Annotations r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 14th Sept. Butterfly emerged 26th Sept 1893.'; v

[pencil] 'Chrysalis formed 14th Sept'

Size: 300 x 236 mm

Notes: Foodplant of P. oileus recorded in literature as Sida rhombifolia L.

]70 C. V. ELLWOOD & J. M. V. HARVFY

39. BlTTERFl y: Fam. Hesperiidae Pyrrhocullcs jaimiUrnsis Schaus (Schaus' Skipper)
1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf; 1 adult in flight.

Plant: Fam. Palmae (Arecaceac) Coco.s iiiicifcru L.

1 leaf. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r |ink] Chrysalis formed 4th Feb. Butterfly emerged 22nd Feb. 1S94';

•Pamphila utho = Hewitson"; v [pencil] "Chrysalis 4th Feb'

Size: 330 x 456 mm

40. BuTTERn.Y: Fam. Hesperiidae Calpodes elhliux StoU (Canna Skipper)
1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf; 1 adult in flight.

Plant: Fam. Possibly Heliconiaceae Hclianua sp. or Cannaceae Canna sp.

1 leaf. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 23rd Oct. Moth emerged 7th Nov. 92."
Size: 300 x 235 mm

41. BUTTERn.Y: Fam. Hesperiidae Nycteliii.s nyclclius nyaelius Latreille (Latreille's Cane Skipper)

2 larvae on leaves; 1 pupa on leaf; 1 adult in flight.
Plant: Fam. Gramineae (Poaceae)

Leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 15th Jan. Butterfly emerged 1st Feb. 93'; 'The last few

days before the perfect insect emerges the chrysalis becomes of a dark colour'

Size: 300 x 236 mm

42. Butterfly: Fam. Hesperiidae Panoquina sylvicola woodruffi Watson (Watson's Cane
Skipper)

1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf; 1 adult in flight.

Plant: Fam. Gramineae (Poaceae) Possibly Pankum maximum Jacq.

Leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 27th Nov. Butterfly emerged 7th Dec. 96'

Size: 352 x 249 mm

43. Butterfly: Fam. Hesperiidae Perichares plutetes pluletes Gmclin (Confusing Branded Skipper)

2 larvae on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf, 1 pupa drawn separately; 2 adults in flight.
Plant: Fam. Gramineae (Poaceae) Possibly Panuum maximum Jacq.
Leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 10th Jan. Butterfly emerged 26th Jan. 94';
"Pamphila Juliana = Hesperia carydon Fabr.'; v [pencil] Chrysalis 10th Jan'
Size: 354 x 185 mm

44. Lepidoptera: [1] Unidentified

1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa on stem.

Moth: [2] Fam. Possibly Lycaenidae

1 larva on leaf.

Plant: [1] Fam. Papilionaceae (Fabaceae) Slylnsanlhe.t hamata (L.) Taub (Cheesy Toes.

Donkey Weed, Pencil Flower)

Stem, leaves and flower. Shows larval damage.

Plant: [2] Fam. Gramineae (Poaceae)

Leaves. Shows larval damage.

Size: 248 x .351 mm

45. LEPlDorn ra: No Lepidoptera figured

Pl.ANI: Fam. Boraginaceae Probably Tournejorlia hirsulissima L.

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Size: 350 x 2.50 mm

Notes: a rolled leaf is figured but the identification of the insect responsible is not possible.

The leaf damage and leaf rolling might be the work of a pyralid moth larva.

46. Lepidoptera: No Lepidoptera figured

Plant: Fam. Mimosaceae Acacia macracantha Humb. & Bonpl. ex Willd. (Park Nut)
Stem, leaves and fruit. No larval damage.

THE LADY BLAKE COLLECTION 171

Annotations: r [ink] 'King's House 4th August 97.'
Size: 253 x 354 mm

47. Moth: Fam. Possibly Tortricidae
1 larva on leaf.

Plant: Fam. Compositac (Astcraccac) Synedrella nodiflora (L.) Gacrtn. (Fatten Barrow)
Stem, leaves and flowers. No larval damage.
Size: 239 x 125 mm

48. Moth: Fam. Possibly Tortricidae
1 larva on leaf.

Plant: Fam. Solanaceae Browallia americana L. (Jamaican Forget-me-not)
Stem, leaves and flowers. No larval damage.
Size: 301 x 237 mm
Notes: Unfinished sketch.

49. Moths: Fam. Notodontidae

1 larva on leaf.

Plant: Fam. Myrtaceae Pxidium guajava L. (Guava)
Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.
Size: 352 x 248 mm

50. Moth: Fam. Arctiidae: Pericopinae Hyalurga leucophaea Walker

2 larvae on leaf; I pupa on leaf; 1 adult male in flight, 1 adult female in flight.
Plant: Fam. Boraginaceae Heliolropium indicum L. (Scorpion Weed, Wild Clary)
Stem, leaves and flowers. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed about 12th Dec Moth emerged 23d Dec. 1892.'
Size: 300 x 235 mm

51. Moth: Fam. Pyralidae: Pyraustinae Slenoptycha sp.

1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf; 1 adult male in flight, 1 adult female at rest.

Plant: Fam. Solanaceae Capsicum frulescens L. (Bird Pepper, Cayenne Pepper, Chilli)

Stem, leaves, flower and fruit.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 1st March. Moth emerged 11th March. 94'; v [pencil]

'1st March Chrysalis formed 30th July'

Size: 300 x 236 mm

Notes: Details of the wing markings arc unclear. At least two species of this Ptcrophorid-like

genus occur in Jamaica, S. pterophoralis Walker and S. fontetla Hampson. A third undescribed

species is known from the BM(NH) collection. The illustration appears closest to S.

pterophoralis .

52. Moth: [1] Fam. Geomctridae

1 larva on leaf; I pupa drawn separately; 2 adults in flight.
Moth: [2] Fam. Ptcrophoridae

2 larvae on stems; 1 pupa on leaf; 2 adults in flight.
Moth: [3] Fam. Geomctridae

2 larvae on stems; 1 pupa drawn .separately; 2 adults in flight.

Plant: Fam. Nyctaginaceae Boerhavia coccinea Mill. (Hog Weed)

Stem, leaves and flowers. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 1 Chrysalis formed 17th Jan Moth emerged 31st Jan'; '2 Chrysalis

formed 21st Jan. Moth emerged 28th Jan. 95'; '3 Chrysalis formed 17th Jan Moth emerged

29th Jan'

Size: 356 x 255 mm

53. Moth: [I] Fam. Pyralidae: Pyraustinae Probably Syngamia haemorrhoidalis Guenee
1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf; 1 adult in flight.

Moth: [2| Fam. Arctiidae: Pericopinae Synlomidopsis variegata Walker

1 adult male at rest.

Moth: [3] Fam. Ctenuchidae Dinia menu Hubncr

1 adult male at rest.

J72 C. V. ELLWOOD& J. M. V. HARVEY

Lizard: Fam. Iguanidae Anolis sp.

On stem.

Plant: Fam. Papilionaceae (Fabaceae) Possibly Desmodium loriiiosum (Sw.) DC.

Stem and leaves. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] Chrysalis formed 29th August. Moth emerged 8th Sept. 1983"

Size: 306 x 242 mm

54. Moth: Fam. Arctiidae: Ctenuchinae Eunomia rubripunclata Butler

1 larva on leaf. 1 larva on stem; 1 pupa on stem; 1 adult male in flight.

Plant: Fam. Convolvulaceae Merremia quinqucfoUa (L.) Hallier f. (Rock Rosemary) or M.

aegyptia (L.) Urb.

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r |ink] 'Chrysalis formed 23d Jan. Moth emerged 13th Feb. 93."

Size; 360 x 242 mm

55. Moth: Fam. Arctiidae: Ctenuchinae Empyreuma anassa Forbes

1 larva on stem. 1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa suspended from stem; 1 adult male in flight.
Plant: Fam. Apocynaceae Urechites lutea (L.) Britton (Nightsage, Nightshade)
Stem, leaves and flower. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 12th July Moth emerged 30th July 1892.'
Size: 300 x 236 mm

56. Moth: Fam. Arctiidae: Ctenuchinae Cosmosoma auge L.

1 larva on leaf; 1 cocoon on leaf; 2 adult males in flight.

Plant: Fam. Compositae (Asteraceae) Mikania micrantha Kunth (Guaco)

Twining stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r |ink] 'Craighton. Chrysalis formed 16th August The chrysalis was white till

the 27th August when the fore part became brown, on the 28th the whole chrysalis was brown.

Moth emerged 29th August 1892.'

Size: 300 x 235 mm

57. Moth: Unidentified

2 larvae on leaves; 1 pupa drawn separately; 1 adult in flight.
Plant; Fam. Boraginaceae Ehretia linifolia L. (Bastard Cherry)
Stem, leaves and fruit. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 29th Nov. Moth emerged lOth Dec. 1893"
Size: 300 x 236 mm

58. Moth: Fam. Arctiidae Paraeuchaeles insutala Walker

1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf; 1 adult male in flight

Plant: Fam. Compositae (Asteraceae) Eupalorium udoratum L. (Christmas Bush, Jack-in-

thc-bush)

Stem, leaves and flowers. No larval damage.

Annotations: r (ink) 'Chrysalis formed 5th July Moth emerged 19th July 1893.'; v |pencil|

'Chrysalis formed 5th July'

Size: 300 x 235 mm

59. Moth: Fam. Arctiidae /tmma/o sp.

2 larvae on leaf; 1 pupa rolled in dead leaf still attached to stem; 1 adult female in (light.
Plant: Fam. Moraceac Ficus sp.

Stem and leaves. No larval damage.

Annotations: r (ink) 'Chrysalis formed 20th Dec. 91 Moth emerged 28th Jan 92"

Size: 3(X) x 236 mm

60. Moth: Fam. Arctiidae Hypercompe nigriplaga Walker

1 larva on leaf. 1 larva drawn separately; 1 pupa drawn separately; I adult female in flight.

Plant: Fam. Rosaceac Rosa sp. (Rose (cultivated))

Stem, leaves and flower. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 17th Dec. 92 Moth emerged 14th Jan. 93:

THE LADY BLAKE COLLECTION 1 73

'Caterpillar was found under a tussock of grass. Foodplant unknown, but I kept the
caterpillar for a month on pink roses, which it ate greedily.'
Size: 300 x 235 mm

61. Moth: Fam. Arctiidae Amastus ramona Schaus

I larva on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf; I adult male in flight.

Plant: Fam. Cccropiaceae Cecropia pellala L. (Snake Wood, Trumpet Tree)

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 7th March. Moth emerged 16th April 97.'

Size: 328 x 451 mm

62. Moth: Fam. Arctiidae Ulelheisa bella L.

1 larva on stem, I larva on flower; 1 pupa suspended from leaf; 2 adult males in flight.

Plant: Fam. Papilionaceae (Fabaceae) Crntalaria relusa L. (Rattlewced)

Stem, leaves, flowers and immature pods. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed about 18th May 91 Moth emerged 29th May 91'

Size: 355 x 161 mm

63. Moth: Fam. Lymantriidae

1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf.

Plant: Fam. Rubiaceae Rondelelia sp.

Stem, leaves and flowers. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 7th Sept'

Size: 240 x 179 mm

64. Moth: Fam. Arctiidae: Pericopinae Composia crediila Fabricius

3 larvae on leaves; 1 pupa suspended between leaf and stem; 1 adult male in flight.

Plant: Unidentified

Twining stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 26th Jan. Moth emerged 13th Feb 1893'

Size: 300 x 235 mm

65. Moth: Fam. Arctiidae Paraeuchaetes insulata Walker
1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf; 1 adult male in flight.

Plant: Fam. Compositae (Asteraceae) Eupulorium oJuratum L. (Christmas Bush, Jack-in-

the-Bush)

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink) 'Caterpillar spun itself up. 10th Feb. Moth emerged 26th Feb. 97.'

Size: 352 x 246 mm

66. Moth: Fam. Possibly Lymantriidae

1 larva on leaf, I larva on flower, 1 larva in cocoon; I cocoon on stem, 1 cocoon drawn
separately; 1 adult in flight.

Diptera: Fam. Tachinidae

2 puparia: 2 adults in flight.

Plant: Fam. Solanaceae Datura Candida (Pers.) Safford (Angel's Trumpet)
Stem, leaves and flower. Shows larval damage.
Annotations: r [ink] 'Solandra Longiflora Cinchona. 19th July. 90.'
Size: 328 x 240 mm

67. Moth: Fam. Noctuidae: Agaristinae Euschirroplerus poeyi Grote

2 larvae on plant; 1 pupa drawn separately; ! adult female in flight.

Plant: Fam. Nyctaginaceae Pisonia aculeata L. (Cockspur, Fingrigo, Wait-a-bit)

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'King's House. July 1892'

Size: 301 x 236 mm

68. Moth: Fam. Arctiidae: Pericopinae Are marginala Drury

2 larvae on leaves: 1 pupa drawn separately; 1 adult female in flight.
Plant: Fam. Compositae (Asteraceae) Mikania micruniha Kunth (Guaco)
Stem and leaves. No larval damage.

174 C. V. EI,LWOOD& J. M. V. HARVEY

Annotations: r [ink] Chrysalis formed 15th Oct 92 Moth emerged 7th Nov. 92."
Size: 226 x 140 mm

69. Moth: Fam. Arctiidae: Pericopinae Are marginata Drury

2 larvae on leaves; 1 pupa suspended from leaf, last larval skin also present; 2 adult males in

flight.

Plant: Fam. Gesneriaceae Besleria lutea L.

Stem, leaves, flower-buds and fruit. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] "Besleria Lutea Chrysalis formed 21st Dec. 9.^ Moth emerged 23d Jan

94"; V [pencil] turned about 26th Nov.'; 31st Dec'

Size: 514 x 242 mm

70. Moth: Fam. Arctiidae: Pericopinae Are marginata Drury

1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa suspended from leaf, last larval skin also present; 1 adult male in llight.

1 adult male at rest.

Plant: Fam. Gesneriaceae Besleria lutea L.

Stem, leaves and flower-buds. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r (ink) 'Chrysalis formed at King's House 17th Moth |sic| [March] Moth

emerged on board the 'Atrat.[o[' Kith April. 94.'; v [pencil| 'Spun up 13th. March Chrysalis

17th March'

Size: 506 x 240 mm

71. Moth: Fam. Pyralidae: Pyraustinae Possibly Samea sp.

1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa in leaf with edges spun together; 1 adult in flight.

Plant: Fam. Labiatae (Lamiaceac) Hyptis suaveolens (L.) Poit. (Pignut, Spikenard)

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink| "Chrysalis formed 17th Nov. Moth emerged 29th Nov 95'

Size: 382 x 240 mm

72. Moth: Fam. Noctuidae: Catocalinae (Ophiderinae) Ascalapha odorala 1, (Black Witch)
1 larva on stem; 1 pupa drawn separately; 1 adult male in flight.

Plant: Fam. Mimosaceae Albizia lebbeck (L.) Benth. (Woman's Tongue Tree)

1 leaf. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink| "5th August 92 Jamaica. Chrysalis formed 22d July. Moth emerged 10th

August."

Size: 370 x 239 mm

Notes: Foodplants of A. odorala recorded in literature as Cassia sp. (Caesalpiniaceae) and

Acacia greggii A. Gray (Mimosaceae).

73. Moth: Fam. Geometridae: Ennominae Probably Oxydia sp.

1 larva on stem, 1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa drawn separately; 1 adult in flight.
Plant: Fam. Rutaceae C/rna sp. (Possibly Orange)

Stems and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink[ "Chrysalis formed 7th May Moth emerged 19th May 96'

Size: 351 x 248 mm

74. Moth: [1[ Fam. Noctuidae: Catocalinae (Ophidennac) Gonodonta incurva Sepp

2 larvae on leaf; 1 pupa on stem; 1 adult male in flight. 1 adult female in flight
Moth: [2] Fam. Noctuidae: Catocalinae (Ophiderinae) Gonodonia uxoria Stoll
1 larva on leaf; 1 adult in flight.

Plant: [1| Fam. Piperaceae Piper aduncum L.

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Plant: [2] Fam. Piperaceae Pothomorphe umbellata (L.) Miq. (= Lepianthes umbellala (L.)

Raf.) (Cow Foot)

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink[ "Chrysalis formed 15th 0[c[tober See my notes on natural history p. 54.'

Size: 355 x 321 mm

75. Moth: Fam. Noctuidae: Catocalinae (Ophiderinae) Anomi.s ernsa Hubner (Yellow Scallop
Moth)

THE LADY BLAKE COLLECTION 175

3 larvae on stem; I pupa on leaf; 1 adult female in flight.

Plant: Fam. Malvaceae Wissadulu jachemi Planch, ex R. E. Fries

Stem, leaves and dead flowers. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'I Chrysalis formed 22d Nov. Moth emerged 2 Dec %'

Size: 443 x 239 mm

Notes: Moth may possibly be Anomis flmu fimbriago Stephens which is recorded on

Malvaceae.

76. MoTH: Fam. Pyralidae: Odontiinae Dichogama sp., probably D. redtenbacheri Lederer

1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf; I adult female in flight.
Plant: Unidentilied

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage and dipterous leaf mines.

Annotations: r [ink] Chrysalis formed 7th Jan. Moth emerged 2d Feb. 94'; v [pencil] Spun

up 7th Jan'

Size: 30() x 235 mm

Notes: D. redtenbacheri is a highly variable species which can produce dark forms almost

devoid of markings.

77. Moth: Fam. Noctuidae: Amphipyrinae Spodoptera frugiperda J. E. Smith (Fall Armyworm)

2 larvae on leaves, I larva on ground; 1 pupa drawn separately; 1 adult male in flight, 1 adult
female in flight.

Plant: Unidentified graminoid

Grasslike leaves.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 8th June. Moth emerged 18th June. 97'

Size: 350 x 249 mm

Notes: 5. frugiperda is a well-known pest of grasses, cereals and other crops.

78. Moth: Fam. Noctuidae: Catocalinac Zale fictilis Guenee
2 larvae on grass; 1 pupa on ground; I adult in flight.
Plant: Grasslike monocotyledon

Leaves.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 16th Jan. Moth emerged 3d Feb. 1894.'; 'Homoptera

terrosa = Guenee'; r [pencil] Chrysalis 16th Jan'

Size: 3(X) x 23S mm

Notes: Z. fictilis is the senior name for H. terrosa.

79. Moth: Fam. Noctuidae: Amphipyrinae Spodoptera androgea Stoll form rubrifusa Hampson
1 larva on stem; 1 pupa drawn separately; 1 adult female in flight.

Plant: Fam. Possibly Leguminosae

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Caterpillar buried itself 10th Sept. Moth emerged 5th Oct 1893.'; v

[pencil] 'Caterpillar buried itself 10th Sept"

Size: 300 x 236 mm

Notes: This form of 5. androgea is more or less restricted to Jamaica. It is polyphagous.

80. Moth: Fam. Noctuidae: Noctuinae Agrolis sp.

1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa drawn separately; I adult male in flight.

Plant: Fam. Solanaceae Solanum tuberosum L. (Irish Potato)

1 leaf. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink[ Chrysalis formed 20 or 21st Sept. Moth emerged 8th Oct. 92"

Size: 220 x 235 mm

Notes: 5. tuberosum is an introduced species in cultivation.

81. Moth: Fam. Noctuidae: Amphipyrinae Spodoptera ornilhogalli Guenee (Yellow-striped
Armyworm)

1 larva on stem, 1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa drawn separately; 1 adult male in flight.

Plant: Fam. Geraniaeeae Pelargonium sp.

Stem and leaves. No larval damage.

Size: 292 x 160 mm

Notes: S. ornilhogalli is polyphagous. Pelargonium is a cultivated ornamental.

176 f~- V. ELLWOOD & J. M. V. HARVEY

82. Moth; Noctuidae: Catocalinae (Ophidcrinac) Anomis editrix Guenee
1 larva on stem; 1 pupa rolled in leaf; 1 adult in flight.

Pl.ANT; Fam. Tiliaccae Triumfetta semilriloba Jacq. (Bur Weed)

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations; r [inc] 'From Montpelier. Caterpillar rolled itself in leaf 8th Sept. Moth

emerged 18th Sept. 95'

Size; 349 x 249 mm

83. Moth: Fam. Possibly Noctuidae

1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf; 1 adult male in flight. 1 adult male at rest.

Plant; Fam. Malvaceae Urena lobaui L. (Ballard Bush, Bur Mallow)

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations; r [ink] Chrysalis formed 15th August. Moth emerged 25th August 95.'; v

[pencil] 'Chrysalis formed 15th August.'

Size; 349 x 249 mm

Notes: Pencil sketches of unidentified birds on recto.

84. Moth; [1] Fam. Pyralidae Pilocrocis sp.

1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf; 2 adults in flight.
Moth: [2] Fam. Noctuidae

2 larvae on leaf; 1 pupa drawn separately; 2 adult males in flight.

Plant: Fam. Solanaceae Ditnalia arhorescens (L.) Sleumer or Nknliana sp.

1 leaf. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink[ '1 Chrysalis formed 24th Jan Moth emerged 6th Feb. 95 2 Chrysalis

formed 27th Jan. Moth emerged 16th Feb 95"

Size; 255 x 356 mm

85. Moth; Fam. Noctuidae: Hadeninae Xanthopastis timais Cramer (Spanish Moth)

1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa drawn separately; 1 adult in flight.

Plant: Fam. Amaryllidaceae Possibly Crinum sp. or Hippeaslrum sp.

Part of leaf blade. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] Chrysalis formed 18th Sept 89 Moth emerged 6th October 89'

Size; 226 x 140 mm

Notes: Foodplants of X. timais recorded in literature as Ficus carica L. (Moraceae) and

Hippeastrum pitnueum (Lam.) Kuntzc. Narcissus sp. (Amaryllidaceae).

86. Moth: Fam. Noctuidae

2 larvae on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf; 1 adult male in flight.
Plant: Fam. Possibly Solanaceae

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Caterpillar fastened itself into leaf 17th Aug Moth emerged 29th Aug.

95'; 'Montpelier'; v [pencil] 'Caterpillar fastened itself up 16th August'

Size: 250 x 349 mm

87. Moth; Fam. Noctuidae; Catocalinae (Ophidcrinac) Thysania zenobia Cramer (Owl Moth)
2 larvae on leaves; 1 pupa spun up in leaves; 1 adult male in flight, 1 adult female in flight.
Plant; Fam. Lcguminosae Possibly Cassia sp.

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations; r [ink] 'Caterpillar fastened itself up in the leaves 7th August. Moth emerged

24th August 97'

Size: 351 x 249 mm

Notes; Foodplant of T. zenobia recorded in literature as m Lcguminosae.

88. Moth: Fam. Noctuidae

1 larva on leaf; I pupa drawn separately; 1 adult in flight. 1 adult at rest.

Plant; Grasslikc monocotyledon

Stem and leaves. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed lOth March. Moth emerged 22d March 95'; 'This

caterpillar devoured two skipper larvae found also on the Para grass'

Size; 356 x 256 mm

THE LADY BLAKE COLLECTION 177

89. Moth: Unidentified

2 larvae on leaves; 1 pupa drawn separately; 1 adult male in flight.

Plant: Fam. Possibly Ericaceae or Myrsinaceae

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Caterpillar buried itself 29th May Moth emerged 10th June 96'

Size: 249 x 189 mm

90. Moth: Fam. Noctuidac: Amphipyrinae Spoilopteru lalifasiia Walker
2 larvae on stem; I pupa drawn separately; 1 adult male in flight.

Plant: Fam. Labiatae (Lamiaceae) Hyptis suaveolens (L.) Poit. (Pignut, Spikenard)

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 9th Nov. Moth emerged 2.Sth Nov. 96'

Size: 352 x 248 mm

Notes: 5. latifascia is polyphagous.

91. MOTH: Fam. Noctuidae: Acontiinae Bagisara repanda Fabricius.

1 larva on leaf, 1 larva on stem; 1 pupa drawn separately; 1 adult in flight.
Plant: Fam. Malvaceae Sida sp. or Malvastrum sp.

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink| 'Chrysalis formed 29th Dec 93 Moth emerged 19th Jan. 94'; v [pencil]

'Chrysalis 29th Dec'

Size: 300 x 238 mm

92. Moth: Fam. Geometridae

2 larvae on stem; 1 adult in flight.

Plant: Fam. Caesalpiniaceae Cassia pitosa L.

Stem, leaves, flowers and seed pods. No larval damage.

Size: 301 x 235 mm

93. Moth: Fam. Geometridae

2 larvae on stem; 1 adult in flight.

Plant: Fam. Mimosaccac Desmanlhus virgatus (L.) Willd. (Ground Tamarind)

Stem, leaves and seed pods. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Caterpillar fastened itself up in leaf 21st June. Moth emerged on board

the Alleghany 4th July. 96."

Size; 352 x 249 mm

94. Moth: Fam. Geometridae

2 larvae on stem; 1 adult in flight.

Plant: Fam. Papilionaceae (V ahaccac) Aeschynomene sp.

Stem, leaves and flowers. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [link[ Caterpillar ate its way into a cork, 6th Nov. Moth emerged 26th

Nov. 1893.'; v [pencil] 'Eat its way into cork 6th Nov'

Size: 331 x 227 mm

95. Moth: Fam. Noctuidae: Heliothinae Heliothis virescens Fabricius or H. subflexa Guenee
2 larvae on leaves; 1 pupa drawn separately; 1 adult female in flight. 1 adult at rest.
Plant: Fam. Caesalpiniaceae Cassia ahsus L.

Stem, leaves, flowers and seed pods. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Caterpillar buried itself 5th Dec Moth emerged 27th Dec 95'

Size: 350 x 250 mm

Notes: The key character not illustrated but more likely to be H. virescens, which is

polyphagous on flowers and secdpods.

96. Moth: Fam. Noctuidae: Catocalinae (Ophiderinae) Anomis sp., possibly A. edilrix Guen6e
1 larva on stem; 1 pupa on leaf; 1 adult in flight.

Plant: Fam. Malvaceae Urena lohata I.. (Ballard Bush, Bur Mallow)

Stem, leaves and flower. No larval damage.

Annotations: r Jink] 'Caterpillar fastened itself up. 9th August. Moth emerged 19th August

97. From Bath.' v (pencil] Fastened itself up 9th August'

Size: 248 x 172 mm

178 C. V. ELL WOOD & J. M. \'. HARVEY

97. Moth: Fam. Possibly Noctuidac
1 larva on leaf.

Plant: Fam. Melastomataccac Possibly Mkonia laevigata (L.) DC (Johnny Berry, White

Wattle)

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: v [pencil] 'Buried itself 6th Dec."

Size: 300 x 235 mm

98. Moth: Fam. Noctuidae: Catocalinae (Ophiderinae) Melipolis famelica Guenee

1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa drawn separately; 1 adult male in flight, 1 adult female in flight.

Plant: Fam. Mimosaceac Acacia lortiwsa (L ) Willd (Wild Poponax)

Stem and leaves. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 23d June. Moth emerged 8th July y.'^'; i' [pencil]

'Chrysalis 23d June'

Size: 251 x 348 mm

99. Moth: Fam. Noctuidae: Catocalinae (Ophiderinae) Oraesia excilans Walker

1 larva on stem, 1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf; 1 adult in flight, 1 adult at rest.
Plant: Fam. Menispermaceae Cissampelos pareira L. (Pareira Brava, Velvet Leaf)
Stem, leaves and male flowers. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Caterpillar spun itself up in a leaf 21st June. Moth emerged dth July
95"; I' [pencil] 'Spun up 21st June.'
Size: 349 x 252 mm

100. Moth: [1] Fam. Hyblaeidac Hyblaea puera Cramer

2 larvae on leaves; 1 pupa on leaf; 1 adult male in flight
Moth: [2] Fam. Hyblaeidac Hyblaea puera Cramer

I larva on leaf; 1 adult female in flight.

Plant: Fam. Bignoniaceae Calalpa loni^issima (Jacq.) Dum.-Cours. (French Oak, Mast

Wood, Yoke Wood)

Stem, leaves and flower. No larval damage.

Annotations: r |ink| 'Moth number I emerged of [[froni|[ caterpillar 1. Dec 2d 1890 Moth

emerged from 2 Dec 3d'

Size 183 x 262 mm

Notes: Larvae in figs I and 2 may indicate different species; however no information

available on puera group from West Indies in general.

101. Moth: Fam. Noctuidae: Amphipyrinac Spodoplera frugiperda J. E. Smith (Fall
Armyworm)

1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa on corn head; I adult female in flight.

Plant: Fam. Gramineae (Poaceae) Zea rruiys L. (Indian Corn, Maize)

Corn head and leaves. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 14th Jan. Moth emerged 28th Jan 97'

Size: 351 x 248 mm

Notes: S. frugiperda is a well-known pest of grasses, cereals and other crops.

102. Moth: Fam. Noctuidae: Catocalinae (Ophiderinae) Anomis editri.x (iucncc

1 larva on stem. 1 larva on leaf; I pupa in cocoon on leaf; 1 adult in flight, 1 adult at rest.

Plant: Fam. Tiliaceae Triumfella semiiriloba Jacq. (Bur weed)

Stem, leaves, flowers and burs. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed about 15th Nov. Moth emerged 4th Dec. 1892'

Size 3(X) x 235 mm

103. Moth: Fam. Noctuidae: Acontiinae

1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa drawn separately; 1 adult in flight.

Plant: Fam. Convolvulaccae Merremia quimjuejoUa (1.) Hallicr f (Rock Rosemary)

Stem, leaves and flower. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r (ink| 'Chrysalis formed 8th Nov. Moth emerged 21st Nov. 1893.'; r [pencil]

'Chrysalis 8th Nov.'

Size: 330 x 228 mm

THE LADY BLAKE COLLECTION 179

104. Moth: Fam. Possibly Noctuidac

1 larva on stem, 1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa drawn separately; 1 adult in flight.

Plant: Fam. Solanaceae Solaniim lorvum Sw. (Gully Bean, Susumber, Turkey Berry)

Stem, leaves, flower and fruits. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] Caterpillar buried itself 9th May Chrysalis formed 10th Moth emerged

22dMay95.'

Size; 300 x 237 mm

105. Moth; Fam. Noctuidae: Catocalinae (Ophiderinae) Diphlhera festiva Fabricius (Hieroglyphic
Moth)

2 larvae on stem; 2 pupae on stem; 1 adult in flight.
Plant: Fam. Sterculiaceae Waltheria indica L. (Raichie)
Stem, leaves and inflorescences. Shows larval damage
Annotations: r [ink] 'Kings House. 21st Nov. 90.'
Size: 294 x 197 mm.

106. Moth: Fam. Noctuidae: Plusiinae Pseudoplusia incliidens Walker (Soybean Looper)
1 larva on leaf; I pupa on leaf; 1 adult in flight, 1 adult at rest.

Plant: Fam. Amaryllidaccae Eucharis grandiflora Planch. & Linden (Eucharist Lily)

Leaf and flowers. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink| 'Caterpillar spun itself up 11th March. Moth emerged 23d March

1894'; V [pencil] 'Spun up 1 1th March'

Size: 300 x 238 mm

Notes: P. incliidens larva is polyphagous. E. grandiflora is cultivated and potentially

naturalised, native of Colombia.

107. Moth: Fam. Noctuidae

1 larva on leaf; I pupa drawn separately; 1 adult in flight.

Plant: Fam. Solanaceae Ceslnim diurniim L. (Wild Jasmine)

Stem, leaves, flowers and berries. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Caterpillar buried itself 28th Feb. Chrysalis formed 3d March. Moth

emerged 22d March. 1894.'

Size: 300 x 239 mm

108. Moth: Fam. Noctuidac: Catocalinae (Ophiderinae) Epidromia suffusa Walker
1 larva on leaf; I pupa on leaf; I adult female in flight.

Plant: Myrtaceae Psidium guajava L. (Guava)

Stem, leaves and fruit. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 23d August. Moth emerged 1 Ith Sept. 1893.'

Size: 306 x 242 mm

109. Moth: Fam. Possibly Geometridae

1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa drawn separately; 1 adult in flight.
Plant: Fam. Oleaceae Jasminum grandiflorum L. (Poet's Jasmine)
Stem, leaves and flowers. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 7th May Moth emerged 18th May 96'
Size: 238 x 299 mm

110. Moth: Fam. Geometridae: Ennominae Oxydia sp.

2 larvae on stems; 1 pupa on leaf; 1 adult in flight.
Plant: Fam. Rosaceae Rosa sp. (Rose (cultivated))
Stem, leaves and flowers. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Caterpillar] fastened itself up in leaves 1 1th May Moth emerged 28th

May 1896.'

Size: 350 x 250 mm

111. Moth: [I] Fam. Geometridae: Ennominae Oxydia sp.
I larva on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf; 1 adult in flight.
Moth: 12] Unidentified

1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf; 1 adult in flight.

180 C. V. ELLWOOD & J. M. V. HARVEY

Pi ANT; Fam. Myrtaceae Psidium guajava L. (Guava)

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] "1 Caterpillar began to turn 28th May Moth emerged 14th June. %'; '2

Caterpillar began to turn 5th June. Moth emerged 19th June 1896'.

Size: 351 x 248 mm

1 12. Moth: Fam. Noctuidae: Catocalinae (Ophiderinae) AnomLs editrix Guenee.
1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf; 1 adult in flight.

Plant: Fam. Tiliaceae Triumfeila sp.

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] "Chrysalis formed 3d Oct. Moth emerged 12th Oct 1893.'

Size: 301 x 236 mm

113. Moth [1] Fam. Noctuidae: Catocalinae

1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf; 1 adult in flight.

Moth: [2] Fam. Noctuidae: Catocalinae

1 larva on stem; 1 adult in flight

Plant; [1] Fam. Compositae (Asteraceae) Synedrella nodiflora (L.) Gaertn. (Fatten Barrow)

Stem, leaves and flowers. Shows larval damage.

Plant; [2] Fam. Gramineae (Poaceae) Paspalum sp.

Leaves. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] *1 Chrysalis formed 31st Jan. Moth emerged 13th Feb. 94'; '2

Caterpillar enclosed itself in leaf 26th Jan. Moth emerged 16th Feb. 1894"; v [pencil]

'Chrysalis 31st Jan'

Size: 307 x 243 mm

114. Moth: Fam. Noctuidae: Catocalinae Mods sp.

3 larvae on leaves; 1 pupa in leaves; I adult male in flight, 1 adult female in flight.

Plant: Fam. Gramineae (Poaceae)

Leaves. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis of light coloured caterpillar formed 4th or 5th Nov. Moth

emerged 24th Nov. 92'

Size: 300 x 235 mm

1 15. Moth: Fam. Noctuidae: Catocalinae (Rivulinae) Probably Rivula sp.

1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf; 1 adult in flight.
Plant: Fam. Gramineae (Poaceae) Lasiacis sp.
Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 23d Oct. Moth emerged 31st Oct 1893.'; v [pencil]
Chrysalis formed 23d Oct'
Size: 301 x 236 mm

116. Moth: Fam. Noctuidae: Hadeninae Mylhimna sp.

2 larvae on leaves; 1 pupa drawn separately; I adult male in flight.
Plant: Fam. Gramineae (Poaceae)

Leaves. No larval damage.

Annotations r [ink] "Chrysalis formed 2()th Jan. Moth emerged 8th Feb. 1894'; v [pencil]

'Chrysalis 20th Jan'

Size: 300 x 238 mm

117. Moth: [I| Fam. Noctuidae: Catocalinae (Ophiderinae) Possibly Gonodonta clolilda Stoll
I larva on leaf; 1 pupa on stem; 1 adult male in flight; 1 adult female in flight.

Moth: [2] Fam. Noctuidae: Catocalinae (Ophiderinae) Gonodonta nulrix Stoll

I larva on leaf; 2 pupae drawn separately; I adult in flight

Plant: Unidentified

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] '1 Chrysalis formed 2d August. Moth emerged 22d August. 93'.; "2

Chrysalis formed 14th August. 2 Moth emerged 29th August 93.'; v [pencil[ "Blue chrysalis

formed 14th August.'

Size: 3(H) x 236 mm

THE LADY BLAKE COLLECTION 181

Notes: C milrix is a pest of citrus crops (Rutaccae) in Mexico, Cuba and elsewhere (Florida
- Paraguay). G. doliUla is also found on citrus. Several species look like this but the painting
is not precise enough to distinguish them.

118. Moth: [1] Fam, Pyralidae: Pyraustinae Pilocrocis ramentalis Lcderer
1 larva on leaf; I adult in flight.
Moth: [2] Fam. Noctuidae: Hypeninae
1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa drawn separately; 2 adults in flight.
Plant: Fam. Possibly Acanthaccae Justicia sp. or Bteciium sp.
Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] '1 Chrysalis formed 19th Nov. Moth emerged 1st Dec. 1H93'; Chrysalis
formed 20th Nov. Moth emerged 2d Dec. 1893'; 'I. Botys agavealis. Walker'
Size: 229 x 238 mm

119 Moth: Fam. Noctuidae: Amphipyrinae Caltopistna flondensis Gucnec.
1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa drawn separately; I adult male in flight
Plant: Fam. Blechnaceae Blechniim sp.
1 leaf. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Caterpillar spun itself up in cocoon 4th August. Moth emerged. 17th
August. 97'
Size: 308 x 215 mm
Notes: C ftoridensis is a well-known pest of ferns in glasshouses.

120. Moth: Fam. Pyralidae: Pyraustinae /Ic/iyra .vfrniVafe Guencc

1 larva on stem; 1 pupa in cocoon on stem; 1 adult female in flight.

Plant: Fam. Leguminosae Possibly Tephrosia sp.

Stem and leaves. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 29th Sept. Moth emerged 11th Oct. 93.'; v [pencil]

'Chrysalis 29th Sept'

Size: 3(X) x 236 mm

121. Moth: Fam. Possibly Noctuidae

1 larva on stem; 1 pupa on leaf; 1 adult in flight, 1 adult at rest.

Plant: Fam. Papilionaceae (Fabaceac) Macroptilnim hithyroides (L.) Urb.

Stem, leaves, flower and immature pods. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink| 'Chrysalis formed 18th August. Moth emerged 30th August. 95.'; v

[pencill 'Chrysalis 18th August'

Size: 349 x 252 mm

122. Moth: Fam. Noctuidae: Acontiinae Bagisara repanda Fabricius
1 larva on leaf; I pupa drawn separately; 1 adult in flight.
Plant: Fam. Malvaceae Sida aggregata C. Prcsl

Stem, leaves and flower. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink| 'Caterpillar spun itself up 8th Nov. Moth emerged 24th. Nov. 1893.'; v

[pencill 'Caterpillar spun 8th Nov."

Size: 3(K) x 238 mm

123. Moth: Fam. Possibly Noctuidae

1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa on stem; 1 adult in flight.

Plant: Fam. Verbenaceae Priva lappulacea (L.) Pers. (Clammy Bur, Fasten-'pon-coat,

Styptic Bur, Velvet Bur)

Stem, leaves and burs. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 25th Sept Moth emerged 6th Oct 1893.'; v [pencil]

'Chrysalis 25th Sept'

Size: 370 x 242 mm

124. Moth: Fam. Sphingidae: Macroglossinae Probably Xylophanes sp.

2 larvae.

Plant: No plant figured
Size: 422 x 240 mm

182 r. V. ELIWOOD&J. M. V. HARVEY

125. Moth: |1| Fam. Sphingidae: Sphinginae Possibly Manduca quinquemaculata Haworth
(Tomato Hornworm) or M. sexta L.

1 larva.

Lepidoptera: [2] Unfinished sketch of unidentified larva.

Plant: No plant figured

Size: 455 x 232 mm

126. Moth: Sphingidae: Macroglossinae Eumorpha lubruscac L. (Gaudy Sphinx)

1 larva.

Plant: No plant figured
Size: 449 x 240 mm

127. Moth: Sphingidae: Macroglossinae Erinnyis ello L.

2 larvae on stem; 1 pupa drawn separately; 1 adult female in flight.

Plant: Fam. Probably Euphorbiaceae Hevea hrasiliensis (Kunth) Mull Arg. or possibly

Capparaceae Craieva sp.

Stem and leaves. No larval damage.

Annotations: r |ink| 'Chrysalis formed at King's House 2nd April. Moth emerged in London

7th May 1894'

Size: 331 x 456 mm

Notes: Foodplant of E. ello recorded in literature as Poinsettia sp., etc. (Euphorbiaceae) and

Psidiiim guajava I. (Myrtaceac).

128. Moth: Fam. Sphingidae: Macroglossinae Enyo luguhris lalipennis Rothschild & Jordan
4 larvae on tendril; I pupa drawn separately; 1 adult (probably female) in flight.

Plant: Fam. Vitaceae Possibly Cissiis sicyoides L. (= C.verlicillata (L.) Nicolson & Jarvis)

(Pudding Withe, Snake Withe)

Stem, leaves and tendrils Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Caterpillar buried itself 27th March King's House. Moth emerged m

London. 10th May 1894'; v |ink| 'Two caterpillars buried themselves 27th & 28th March'; v

[pencil] 'Brown c(atcrpillar] buried itself 9th Feb'

Size: 456 x 330 mm

Notes: Foodplants of £. luguhris latipennis recorded in literature as Cissits sp., Vitis sp.,

Ampelopsis sp. (Vitaceae).

129. Moth: Fam. Sphingidae: Macroglossinae Pachylia ficus L.

1 larva on stem; 1 pupa drawn separately; 1 adult male in flight.

Plant: Fam. Moraceae Ficus sp.

Stem and leaves. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] Caterpillar spun itself up 4th Jan. Moth emerged 9th Feb. 96.'

Size: 456 x 331 mm

Notes: Foodplant of P. ficus recorded in literature as Ficits sp. The larva is shown coloured

red which is the colour it turns prior to pupation.

130. Moth: Fam. Sphingidae: Macroglossinae Erinnyis atope Drury
1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa drawn separately; 1 adult in flight.
Plant: Fam. Possibly Malvaceae Hibiscus sp.

1 leaf. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] Caterpillar retired under moss 31st Oct Chrysalis formed 2d Nov Moth

emerged 22d Nov. 1893.'; v [pencil] Caterpillar buncd itself 31st Oct. Chrysalis formed 2d Nov.

Size: 456 x 331 mm

Notes: Foodplant of E. alope recorded in literature as Carica papaya I.. (Caricaceae),

Jatropha sp. (Euphorbiaceae), AUamanda sp. (Apocynaceae).

131. Moth: Fam. Sphingidae: Macroglossinae Eumorpha lahruscae L. (Ciaudy Sphinx)
1 larva on ground; 1 pupa drawn separately; 1 adult in flight.

Plant: Fam. Solanaccae Lycopersicon esculenlum Mill. (Tomato)

Stem, leaves, flowers and fruits. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Craigton. 30th Oct 90. Caterpillar buried itsell 31st Oct Moth

emerged 7th Dec. 1890'

THE LADY BLAKE COLLECTION 183

Size: 501 x 355 mm

Notes: Foodplants of E. lahruscae recorded in literature as Cissus sp., Vilis sp. (Vitaceae),

and Eupatorium sp. (Compositae (Astcraceae)). L. esculentum is not the larval foodplant.

132. Moth: Fam. Sphingidae: Macroglossinae Xylophones lersa L.
1 larva on stem; I pupa drawn separately; I adult in flight.

Plant: Fam. Vitaceae Viiis vinifera L. (European or Wine Grape (cultivated))

Stem and leaves. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Caterpillar spun itself up 26th Dec 95 Moth emerged 23d Jan W

Size: 251 x 350 mm

Notes: Foodplants of A', lersa recorded in literature as Spermacoce sp., Pentas sp.. and

Manettia sp. (Rubiaceac). Vilis unusual but not impossible. Larva figured is the less common

green form.

133. Moth: [1 & 2| Fam. Sphingidae: Macroglossinae Eumorpha fasciatus Sulzer
4 larvae on stem; I pupa drawn separately; 2 adults in flight.

Plant: Fam. Onagraceae Luclwigia octovalvis (Jaeq.) Raven

Stem, leaves and flowers. Shows larval damage

Annotations: r [ink] '1 Caterpillar buried itself Sth Sept Moth emerged 30th Sept 95'; '2

Caterpillar buried itself lOth Sept Moth emerged 30th Sept 95'

Size: 457 x 331 mm

Notes: Foodplant of E. fasciala recorded in literature as in Onagraceae.

134. MOTH: Fam. Sphingidae: Macroglossinae Pseudosphinx letrio L. (Frangipani Sphinx)
1 larva on stem, 1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa drawn separately; 1 adult in flight.

Plant: Fam. Apocynaceae Plumeria rubra L. (Frangipani)

Stem, leaves and flowers. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 15th June. Moth emerged Sth July. 1893.'; 'King's

House 8th June. 1893'

Size: 331 x 456 mm

Notes: Foodplants of P. letrio recorded in literature as P. rubra and Jasminum sp.

(Oleaceae).

135. Moth: Fam. Sphingidae: Macroglossinae Xylophanes up.

1 parasitised larva attached to twig.
Plant: Twig and grass.

Annotations: \' (pencil) '240 Chrysalidae in nest'

Size: 136 x 150 mm

Notes: Larva shown parasitised by Braconidae, possibly Apanleles sp. (Hymenoptera).

136. Moth: Fam. Sphingidae: Macroglossinae Probably Erinnyis cllo L.

2 larvae.

Plant: No plant figured
Size: 300 x 2.36 mm

137. Moth: Fam. Sphingidae: Sphinginac Prolambulyx strigilis L.
1 larva on stem; I pupa drawn separately; 1 adult in flight.
Plant: Fam. Anacardiaceae Spondias purpurea L. (Jamaican Plum)
Stem and leaves. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 9th Dec 92. Moth emerged 1st Jan. 93.'

Size: 3(X) x 235 mm

Notes: Foodplants of P. strigilis recorded in literature as all Anacardiaceae including

Spondias sp. S. purpurea introduced from the South Pacific.

138. Moth: Fam. Sphingidae: Sphinginac Cocylius antaeus antaeus Drury (Giant Sphinx)
1 larva on stem; I pupa drawn separately; I adult female in flight.

Plani: Fam. Annonaceae

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink[ 'Caterpillar buried itself 8th Nov. Chrysalis formed 14th Nov Moth

emerged 20th Dec. 92.'

184

C. V. ELLWOOD&J. M. W HARVEY

'.lulf

No. 138 Cotyius antaeus antaeus Drury (molh); Annonaceae (plant)

Size: 300 x 235 mm.

Notes: Foodplant of C. antaeus anlaeus recorded in literature as Annona sp. (Annonaceae).

139. Moth: Fam. Sphingidae: Sphinginac Manduca quinquemaculata Haworth (Tomato Homworm)
1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa drawn separately; 1 adult female in flight.
Plant: Unidentified
I lanceolate leaf. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r (ink) 'Moth emerged on board the Para lOth June 1891'
Size: 355 x 214 mm

THE LADY BLAKE COLLECTION 185

Notes: Foodplants of M. quinquemacitlata recorded in literature include Solatium tuberosum
L. and Lycopersicon esculentum Mill. (Solanaceae).

140. Moth: Fam. Sphingidac: Macroglossinae Erinnyis ello L.

1 larva on stem; 1 pupa drawn separately; I adult male in flight.

Plant: Fam. Euphorbiaccae Manihol esculenta Crantz (Cassava. Tapioca)

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations; r [ink] "From Pedro Plain.'; 'Chrysalis formed 13th Jan. Moth emerged

5th Feb 97'

Size: 253 x 354 mm

141 . Moth: Fam. Sphingidae: Macroglossinae Probably Eumorpha labruscae L. (Gaudy Sphinx)
1 parasitised larva on stem.

Plant: Fam. Vitaceae Cissus sicyoides L. ( = C verlicillala (L.) Nicolson & Jarvis) (Pudding

Withe, Snake Withe)

Stem, leaves, and flower buds. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Ichnoumon chrysalidae formed 4th August 97. Till that day the

caterpillar had seemed quite healthy. Flies emerged 9th August.'; v [pencil] 'Ichnoumon

chrysalidae formed on caterpillar 4th August 97. Till that day the caterpillar had seemed quite

healthy'

Size: 238 x 130 mm

Notes: Larva parasitised by Braconidae, probably Apanteles sp. (Hymenoptera).

142. Moth: Fam. Sphingidae: Macroglossinae Eumorpha salellilia saletlitia L.
I larva on stem; I pupa drawn separately; I adult in flight.

Plant: Fam. Vitaceae Vilis vinifera L. (European or Wine Grape (cultivated))

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Size: 356 x 255 mm

Notes: Foodplant of E. saletlitia licaon Cramer recorded in literature as Cissus sp. (Vitaceae)

in Brazil.

143. Moth: Fam. Sphingidae: Sphinginae Manduca rustica rustica Fabricius (Rustic Sphinx)

1 larva on stem, I larva on leaf.

Plant: Fam. Boraginaceae Cordia brownei (Friesen) I. M. Johnston or C jamaicensis 1. M.

Johnston

Stem, leaves and flowers. Shows larval damage.

Size: 352 x 247 mm

Notes: Foodplants of M. rustica rustica recorded in literature as in Verbenaceae and

Boraginaceae.

144. Moth: Sphingidae: Macroglossinae Pachylia ficus L.

2 larvae on stem; 1 pupa drawn separately.
Plant: Fam. Possibly Moraceae Ficus sp.
Stem, leaves and fruit. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] Began to turn 14th June. Moth emerged on board the Alleghany 3d

July 96'

Size: 351 x 248 mm

Notes: The larva is shown the colour it turns just prior to pupation.

145. Moth: Fam. Sphingidae: Macroglossinae Eumorpha fascialus Sulzer
2 larvae on stem; 1 pupa drawn separately; 1 adult female in flight.
Plant: Fam. Onagraceae Ludwigia octovalvis (Jacq.) Raven
Stem, leaves and flowers. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Caterpillar began to turn 19th April.'; Moth emerged 1 1th May 96'; v
[pencil] "began to turn April 96. Caterpillar [[buried itself 6th Sept]]'
Size: 349 x 251 mm

146. Moth: Fam. Sphingidae: Sphinginae Agrius cingulata Fabricius (Sweet Potato Hornworm)
2 larvae on stem; I pupa drawn separately; 1 adult female in flight.

Plant: Fam. Convolvulaccac Ipomoea sp.

186

C. V. ELLWOOD&J. M. V. HARVEY

X ^-^l

No. 14ft A^rius cin^ulata Fabricius (moth); Ipomoea sp. (plant)

THE LADY BLAKE COLLECTION

187

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Caterpillar buried itself 28th May Moth emerged 19th June. 1896'; v

[pencil] 'Caterpillar buried itself 13th August"; 'In an earlier stage this caterpillar is green"

Size: 349 x 250 mm

Notes: Foodplant oi A. cingulaUi recorded in literature as Ipomoea batatas (L.) I^am. (Sweet

Potato). Bottom left corner redrawn on paper which has been pasted over the original image.

147. Moth: Fam. Sphingidae: Sphinginae Probably Manduca sp.
1 larva on stem.
Plant: Fam. Possibly Solanaceae Capsicum sp.

Hut/i emerge-^ ^o'^/'c^ /<SV;,

No. 149 Erinnyis ello L. (moth); Euphorbia hirta L. (plant)

188 C. V. ELLWOOD&J. M. V. HARVEY

Unfinished sketch of stem and leaves.
Size: 300 x 236 mm

148. Moth: Fam. Sphingidae: Sphinginae Manduca ruslica ruslica Fabricius (Rustic Sphinx)
1 larva on stem; 1 pupa drawn separately; 1 adult male in flight.

Plant: Unidentified

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Caterpillar buried itself 7th June. Moth emerged 12th July 1893."; v

[pencil] 'Caterpillar buried itself 7th June'

Size: 300 x 235 mm

NOTE.S: Foodplants of M. rustica ruslica recorded in literature as in Verbenaceae and

Boraginaceae.

149. MoTH: Fam. Sphingidae: Macroglossinae Erinnyis ello L.

1 larva on stem; 1 pupa drawn separately; 1 adult female in flight.
Plant: Fam. Euphorbiaceae Euphorbia hirta 1..

Stem, leaves and flowers. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] Chrysalis formed 23d Jan. Moth emerged 20th Feb 1894*

Size: 300 x 238 mm

150. Moth: Fam. Sphingidae: Macroglossinae Xylophanes lersa L.

2 larvae on stems, 1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa suspended from leaves; 1 adult in flight.

Plant: Fam. Rubiaceae Borreria laevis (Lam.) Griseb. (= Spermacoce assurgens Ruiz &

Pavon) (Button Weed)

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 7th Oct. Moth emerged 29th Oct 1893.'; v (pencil]

'Spun 7th Oct'

Size: 301 x 237 mm

Notes: Common brown form of larva figured.

151. Moth: Fam. Sphingidae: Macroglossinae Hyles lineata Fabricius (White-lined Sphinx)
1 larva on stem; 1 pupa drawn separately; 1 adult in flight.

Plant: Fam. Nyctaginaceae Boerhavia erecia L.

Stem, leaves and flowers. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 5th Nov. Moth emerged 1st Dec. 92.'

Size: 300 x 235 mm

Notes: H. lineata larva is polyphagous.

152. Moth: Unidentified

1 larva on stem; 1 pupa on leaf; 1 adult in flight, 1 adult at rest on leaf.
Plant: Fam. Meliaceae Trichilia hiria I, (Wild Mahogany)

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 25th Feb. Moth emerged 5th March. 94.'; v [pencil]

'Caterpillar rolled itself up 23d Feb Chrysalis 25th. Feb"

Size: 330 x 456 mm.

Notes: Plant shows signs of possibly leaf mines or disease.

153. Lepidoptera: Unidentified

2 larvae on leaves.

Plant: Fam. Gesneriaceac Rylidophyllum lomeniosum (1.) Martius ex G. Don
Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.
Size: 350 x 250 mm

154. Moth: Fam. Possibly Geometridae: Geometrinae

3 larvae on stem, 2 larvae suspended from stem; 1 pupa drawn separately; 1 adult in flight.
Plant: Fam. Possibly Caesalpiniaceac Parkinsonia aculeaia 1..

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 2Slh June Moth emerged 5th July 97.'; Spanish

Town."

Size: 249 x 352 mm

THE I ADY BLAKE COLLECTION

189

No. 151 Hyles lineata Fabncius (niolh); Boerhavia erecla L. (plant)

190 C. V. ELLWOOD & J. M. V. HARVEY

155. Moth: Fam. Gcometridae: Gcometrinae

2 larvae on leaves; 1 pupa on stem; 1 adult in flight.

Plant: Fam. Possibly Rosaccac Prunus sp

Stem and leaves. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] Caterpillar fastened itself up 22d May. Moth emerged 2d June. %'

Size: 250 x 256 mm

156. Moth: Fam. Geomctridac: Geometrinae

1 larva on flower; I pupa on stem; 1 adult in flight.
Plant: Fam. Anacardiaceac Mangifera indka L. (Mango)
Stem, leaves and flowers. No larval damage.

Annotations: r |ink| 'Chrysalis formed 20th Feb. Moth emerged 28th Feb. 95'

Size: 255 x 356 mm

Notes: M. indka is introduced in Jamaica.

157. Moth: Fam. Geometridac: Ennominae Melanochroia sp.. possibly M. chephise Stoll

2 larvae on leaves, 2 larvae on stems; 1 pupa drawn separately; 2 adults in flight.

Plant: Fam. Euphorbiaceae Phyllanthus acidits (L.) Skeels (Cheramina, Jimbling, Otaheite

Gooseberry. Short Jimbelin)

Stem, leaves, flowers and fruit. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r |ink] Chrysalis formed 8th Feb. Moth emerged 21st Feb. 1893'

Size: 242 x 307 mm

158. Moth: Fam. Sphingidae: Macroglossinae Eiimorpha fasciatus Sulzer

2 larvae.

Plant: No plant figured
Size: 300 x 236 mm

159. Moth: [1] Fam. Possibly Noctuidae
1 larva on leaf.

Moth: [2] Fam. Saturniidae

1 larva on leaf.

Plant: Fam. Myrtaceae Psidium guajava L. (Guava)
Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.
Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 9th Sept'
Size: 306 x 242 mm

160. Moth: Fam. Possibly Epiplemidae

3 larvae on leaves; 2 pupae on leaf; 2 adults in flight.

Plant: Fam. Verbenaceae Stachytarpheta mutabilis (Jacq.) Vahl

Stem, leaves and flowers. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 1 Ith August. Moth emerged 19th August, 1893.'

Size: 383 x 237 mm

161. Moth: Fam. Psychidae Oiketkus s\>.

2 larvae on leaf.

Plant: Fam. Caesalpiniaceae Delonix regia (Boj. ex Hook.) Raf. (Flamboyant. Poinciana)

Stem and leaves. No larval damage.

Size: 350 x 249 mm

Notes: D. regia is an introduced ornamental from Madagascar.

162. Moth: Fam. Psychidae Oiketicus sp.
2 larvae on leaves.

Plant: Fam. Combretaccae Terminalia catappa L. (West Indian Almond)

Stem, leaves and flowers. Shows larval damage.

Size: 314 x 453 mm

Notes: Larvae are shown feeding from their characteristic larval cases.

163. Moth: Fam. Pyralidae: Pyraustinae Probably Mesocondyla concordalis Hiibner
1 larva on leaf; I pupa on leaf; 1 adult male in flight.

Plant: Fam. Bignoniaceae C'rescenlia cujete 1,. (Calabash Tree)

THE LADY BLAKE COLLECTION

191

No. 16() Epiplemidae (moth); Stachytarphela mulahilis (Jacq.) Vahl (plant)

192 C. V. ELLWOOD & J. M. V. HARVEY

Stem and leaves. Shows lanal damage.

Annotations: r [ink] Chrysalis formed about 18th Nov. Moth emerged .'^Dth Nov. 1893'; v

[pencil] 'Spun up about 18th Nov'

Size: 508 x 237 mm

164. Moth: Fam. Lasiocampidae Tilya sp.

2 larval nests suspended from stems; 7 larvae on leaves, stem and outside of larval nest; 1

cocoon on stem; 2 adult females in flight. 1 adult female at rest.

Plant: Fam. Rosaceae Prunus mynifoha (L.) Urb. (Ant's Wood, Wild Cassada)

Stems, leaves and flowers. Shows larval damage.

rut/. e„,o,feJ: /rT f^^y /^t'
No. 164 Tuya sp. (moth); I'runus myrtifolia (L.) Urb. (plant)

THE LADY BLAKE COLLECTION 193

Annotations: r [ink) 'On the night of April 13th the cateipillars fed, after this they retired
permanently into their purse-like nest, in which they assumed the chrysalis stage. Moth
emerged 15th May 95.'
Size 456 x 3.V) mm

165. Moth: [1] Fam. Limacodidae Alarodia nana Moschler

4 larvae on stems and leaves; 6 pupae on stems; 2 adults in flight, 3 adults at rest.

Moth: [2] Unidentified

1 adult in flight, 1 adult at rest.

Plant: Fam. Anacardiaceae Spondias sp.

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 16th Julv Moth emerged 1st August 1893"

Size: 456 x 3.311 mm

166. Moth: [1] Fam. Pyralidae: Pyraustinae Probably Epicorsia sp. near oedipodalis Guenee and
cerata Fabricius

1 pupa (cocoon) on leaf; 2 adult males in flight.
Moth: |2| Unidentified

2 larvae on leaves.

Plant: Fam. Possibly Rubiaceae or Acanthaceae

Annotations: r [ink] 'Cocoon spun 23d Nov. Moth emerged 9th Dec. 1893"; v [pencil]

'Chrysalis formed 23d Nov'

Size: 457 x 331 mm

167. Moth: Fam. Pyralidae: Pyraustinae Mesocondyhi concnrdalisWuhncx
2 larvae on leaf; I pupa on leaf; 1 adult male in flight.

Plant: Fam. Bignoniaceae Tabehuia nifescens J. R. Johnston (Yellow Poui)

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage and dipterous leaf mine.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 17th Feb. Moth emerged 5th March, 94'; 'Bolys

gastralis. Guenee'; i' [pencil] 'Chrysalis 17th Feb.'

Size: 457 x 331 mm

168. Moth: Fam. Psychidae Oikelicus sp.
2 larvae on leaf.

Plant: Fam. Palmac (Arecaceae) Palm leaf.

Size: 3.31) x 4.56 mm

Notes: The drawing shows the portable larval cases of a pair of Oiketicus. In one the larva is

retracted and in the other the larva is protruded and feeding.

169. Mf)TH: Fam. Pyralidae: Phycitinac Probably Elasmopalpiis lignnsella Zcller

1 larva on pod; I pupa on pod; I adult male in flight.

Plant: Fam. Papilionaceac (Fabaceae) Cajanus cajan (L.) Millsp. (Gungo Pea, Pigeon

Pea)

Stem, leaves, flowers and pods. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] Caterpillar fastened itself up 19th Feb. Moth emerged 9th March 97'

Size: 351 x 248 mm

Notes: Plant is unfinished sketch.

170. Moth: Fam. Pyralidae: Pyraustinae Conchylodes diphteralis Geyer

2 larvae on leaf; 1 adult male in flight.

Plant: Fam. Possibly Boraginaceae Cordia gerascanthus L. (Juvenile)

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage and pest damage (possibly mites).

Annotations: r [ink] 'Caterpillar fastened itself up m leaf 3d March. King's House. Moth

emerged in London Kith May 1894'; r [pencil] 'Fastened up leaves 3d March'

Size: 238 x 301 mm

171. MOTIL Fam. Pyralidae: Pyraustinae Syngtimia haemorrhoidalis Guenee
1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf; 1 adult male in flight.

Plant: Fam. Papilionaceac (Fabaceae) Teramnus uncinatus (L.) Sw.
Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

194 C. V. ELLWOOD& J. M. V. HARVEY

Annotations: r [ink) 'Chrysalis formed 28th August. Moth emerged 7th Sept 1893."
Size: 307 x 242 mm

172. Moth: Fam. Pyralidae: Pyraustinae Diaphania hvalinala L.
2 larvae on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf; 1 adult male in flight.

Pi ANT: Fam. Cucurbitaceae

1 leaf. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] "Chrysalis formed 2d Jan 93. Moth emerged 14th Jan."

Size: 3(X) x 236 mm

173. Moth: Fam. Pyralidae: Pyraustinae Hoterodes ausoiua Cramer

1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf; 1 adult male in flight.

Plant: Fam. Burseraceae Bursera simaruba (L.) Sarg. (Red Birch)

Stem and leaves. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink) 'Chrysalis formed 1st June. Moth emerged about 1 1th June 97.'

Size: 249 x 352 mm

174. Moth: Fam. Probably Pyralidae: Pyraustinae

2 larvae on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf; 1 adult male in flight.
Plant: Fam. Possibly Asclcpiadaceae

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 28th Feb. Moth emerged 1 1th March 97'

Size: 350 x 248 mm

175. Moth: Fam. Pyralidae: Pyraustinae Syllepte sp.. possibly S. prorogata Hampson

3 larvae on leaves; 1 pupa on leaf; 2 adult males in flight.
Plant: Unidentified

Large alternate leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 19th Dec. Moth emerged 29th Dec. 1894"; v [pencil]

'Chrysalis formed 19th Dec'

Size: 255 x 355 mm

176. MoTH: Fam. Pyralidae: Pyraustinae Desmia sp

1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa drawn separately; 1 adult (probably female) in flight

Plant: Fam. Myrtaceae Psidium guajaval.. (Guava)

Stem and leaves. Shows lar\al damage

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 23d Dec. 96 Moth emerged 5th Jan 1897'

Size: 248 x 185 mm

177. Moth: [1| Fam Pyralidae: Pyraustinae Syngamia florella Cramer

1 larva on stem; 1 pupa on stem; 1 adult in flight.
Moth: [2| Unidentified.

2 larvae on leaf.

Plant: Fam. Possibly Rubiaceae

Stem and leaves. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 1 Chrysalis formed 25th Oct. Moth emerged 4th Nov. 1893.'; ^■ [pencil]

'Chrysalis formed 25 [[Kith Sept.]] Oct'

Size: 300 x 256 mm

178. Moth: Fam. Pyralidae: Pyraustinae Probably Udea sp.

1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf; I adult (probably male) in flight.

Plant: Fam. Possibly Legummosae

Stem and leaves. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] Caterpillar began to turn 29th May Moth emerged 14th June. 96'

Size: 351 x 248 mm

179. Moth: Fam. Pyralidae: Nymphulinae Possibly /1ri;vraf/(,s sp.

1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf; 1 adult (possibly male) in flight.
Plant: Fam. Araccae Pixiia stratuHes 1.. (Water Lettuce)
Plant floating on water. No larval damage.

THE LADY BLAKE COLLECTION 195

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 22d March. Moth emerged 31st March. 95"
Size: 255 x 133 mm

180. Moth: Fam. Pyrahdae: Pyraustinae Phoslria hiimeralis Gucnee.
1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf; 2 adult males in flight.

Plant: Fam. Mimosaceae Inga vera Willd. (Panchock, River Koko)
Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] Chrysalis formed 25 Dec 96 Moth emerged 6th Jan 97'
Size: 351 x 248 mm

181. Moth: Fam. Pyralidac: Pyraustinae Probably Pilocrocis hvpoleucaUs Hampson
1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf; 2 adult females in flight.

Plant: Fam. Solanaccac Solanum americanum Mill. (Black Nightshade, Gouma)
Stem, leaves, flowers and fruit. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink over pencil| 'Chrysalis formed 3d Feb. Moth emerged 18th Feb. 94.'
Size: 306 x 242 mm

182. Moth: Fam. Pyralidae: Pyraustinae Possibly Pilocrocis glaucusalis Walker
1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf; 1 adult male in flight.

Plant: Fam. Moraceae Ficits cilrifolia Mill.

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink| 'Chrysalis formed 10th August, Moth emerged 20th August. 1893.'

Size: 345 x 239 mm

183. Moth: Fam. Pyralidae: Pyraustinae Possibly Acrospila gaslralis Guenee
1 larva on leaf, 1 pupa on leaf; 2 adult males in flight

Plant: Fam. Bignoniaceae Tecoma slans (L.) Kunth

Stem, leaves and flowers. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] Chrysalis formed 5th Jan. Moth emerged 19th Jan. 1894'; 'Batys

gastralis Guenee'; v [pencil| 'Chrysalis 5th Jan'

Size: 300 x 238 mm

184. Moth: Fam. Pyralidae: Pyraustinae Probably Epipagis mopsalis Walker
1 larva on leaf; I pupa on leaf; 1 adult female in flight.

Plant: Fam. Melastomataccae Miconia laevigata (L.) DC (Johnny Berry, White Wattle)
Stem and leaves. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 20th August. Moth emerged 6th Sept 93'
Size: 307 x 242 mm

185. Moth: Fam. Pyralidae: Pyraustinae Phoslria sp., possibly P. fulvicaucla Hampson
39 larvae grouped together on one leaf; 7 pupae on one leaf; 3 adult males in flight.
Plant: Fam. Caesalpiniaccae Bauhinia sp.

Stem and leaves. No larval damage.

Annotations: r Jink] Chrysalis formed 28th Nov Moth emerged 12th Dec 1893'; v [pencil]

'28th Nov'

Size: 306 x 242 mm

Notes: This is possibly an undescribed species.

186. Moth: Fam. Pyralidae: Glaphyrinae Symphysa discalis Hampson

3 larvae on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf; 1 adult male at rest, 1 adult male in flight.

Plant: Fam. Capparaceae Possibly Cralevasp.

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [pencil] 'L. 25th Feb.'

Size: 299 x 238 mm

Notes: 5. discalis is endemic to Jamaica.

187. Moth: Fam. Pyralidae: Pyraustinae Sylleple silicalis Guenee
1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf; 2 adult males in flight.
Plant: Fam. Probably Urticaccae

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 23d Dec. 92 Moth emerged 8th Jan 93"

J9(, C. V. ELLWOOU&J. M. V. HARVFY

Sizu; 31X) X 235 mm

Notes: Specimen from Jamaica m BM(NH) feeding on Boehmena sp (Urticaceae).

188. Moth: Fam. Pyralidae: Pyraustinac Pilocroas inpunclaia Fabricius
1 larva on leaf; 1 cocoon on plant; 1 adult male in flight.

Plant: Fam. Convolvulaceac Ipomoea sp.

Tendril with leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Botys campalis = Guenee'; v [pencil] Chrysalis formed 4th Oct.

Emerged 5th Nov."

Size: 306 x 242 mm

189. Moth: Fam. Pyralidae: Crambinae Microcramhus sp.

1 larva on stem; 1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf; 2 adults in flight.

Pi ant: Fam. Papilionaceae (Fabaccae) Imliaofera subulahi Poir,

Stem, leaves and flowers. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 2d Sept. Moth emerged Kith Sept 1893"

Size: 300 x 236 mm

190. Moth: Unidentified

1 larva on leaf; 2 pupae on leaf; I adult in flight.

Plant: Fam. Possibly Apocynaceae

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r Jink] 'Chrysalis formed 11th Feb. Moth emerged 21st Feb. 94. ; v |pcncil|

•Chrysalis 11th Feb.'

Size: 457 x 330 mm

191. Moth: Fam. Tortncidae Platynota rostrana Walker

1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf; 1 adult in flight; 1 adult at rest.
Plant: Fam. Passifloraeeae Passiflora suberosa L.

Stem, leaves and fruit. No larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed Uth Feb Moth emerged 21st Feb 94 ; r |pcncil|

•Chrvsalis nth Feb'

Size: 238 x 143 mm

192. Moth: Fam. Tortncidae Platynota rostrana Walker

2 larvae on leaves; 2 adults in flight, 1 adult at rest.
Plant: Fam. Anacardiaceae Spondias mombin 1..
Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 4th Dec Moth emerged 13th Dec. 96'
Size: 149 x .354 mm

193. Moth: Fam. Possibly Tortricidae

1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa on leaf; 1 adult in flight.

Pi ANT: Fam. Urticaceae Pitea sp.

Stem and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r Jink) 'Chrysalis formed 22d Feb. Moth emerged 2d March 97"

Size: 300 x 184 mm

194. Moth: Unidentified

3 larvae on leaves; 1 pupa on leaf; 1 adult in flight.

Plant: Fam. Labiatae (Lamiaceae) Hyptis capilata Jacq. (Ironwort, Wild Caesar Obeah)
1 stem with leaves; I dead stem with old inflorescences. Shows larval damage.
Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 18th August Moth emerged 25th August. 1893.'
Size: 507 x 238 mm

195. Moth: Fam. Pterophoridae: Pterophorinae Plerophorux sp.
1 larva on leaf; 1 pupa on tendril; 2 adults at rest on leaf
Plant: Fam. Convolvulaceac Ipomoea sp.

Tendril and leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r ]ink] 'Chrysalis formed 30th April Moth developed 7th May 1896'

Size: 300 x 236 mm

THE LADY BLAKE COLLECTION

197

196. Moth: Fam. Noctuidae: Hadcninac Faronia diffusa Walker (Wheat Head Armyworm)
2 larvae on leaves; 1 pupa drawn separately; 1 adult at rest, 1 adult in flight.
Plant: Fam. Gramineae (Poaceac)
Leaves. Shows larval damage.

Annotations: r [ink] 'Chrysalis formed 18th Jan Moth emerged 7th Feb. 94.'; v [pencil]
'Chrysalis 18th Jan. emerged 7th Feb'
Size: 300 x 238 mm

Index of Lepidoptera Names

Numbers refer to catalogue entries. Family names are in bold, genus and species names
are in italics. Catalogue numbers marked with an asterisk indicate uncertain identifications.

Achyra similalis 120

Acrospila gastralis 183*

Adelpha ahyla 28

Agraulis vanillae insidaris 17. 18

Agrius cingidala 146

Agrotis sp. 80

Alarodia nana 165

Amastus ramona 61

Ammalo sp. 59

Anartia jatrophae jamaicensis 25

Anastriis sempitermis dilloni 3>1

Anomis editrix 82, 96'. 102. 112

Anomis erosa 75

Anleos maerida maerula 1 1

Anlillea proclea 2 1

Antillean Great White 6

Anlillcan Malachite 24

Appias drusilla jacksoni 5

Aquna asander jasper 32

Arctiidae 50, 53, 54. 55, 56, 58. 59, 60, 61. 62, 64, 65,

68, 69, 70
Are marginata 68. 69, 70
Argyractis sp. 179*
Asander 32
Ascalapha odorata 72
Ascia moniiste euhotea 6

Bagisara repanda 91 . 1 22
Battiis poh'damiis jamaicensis 1
Black Witch 72
Bourke's Hairstreak 29

Cabares potrillo potriUo 33
Callopistria fiortdensis 119
Calpodes ethlius 40
Canna Skipper 40
Cloudless Sulphur 12
Cocylius antaeus anlaeus 138
Colohura dirce avinoffi 26
Common Dusky Wing 35. 36*

Common Tailed Skipper 30
Composia credida 64
Conchylodes diphteralis 170
Confusing Branded Skipper 43
Cosmosoma auge 56
Cramer's Barred Sulphur 8
Ctenuchidae 53

Danaus gilippus jamaicensis 13

Desmia sp. 176

Diaphania hyalinata 172

Dichogama redtenhacheri 76*

Dillon's Dusky Wing 37

Dinia mena 53

Diphthera festiva 105

Dirce 26

Dorcas 27

Dry as iulia deliia 16

Elasmopalpus lignosella 169
Empyreuma anassa 55
Eriyo lugubris latipennis 128
Ephyrlades areas phileman 34*
Ephyriades zephodes 34*
Epicorsia cerata 166'
Epicorsia oedipodalis 166*
Epidromia suffusa 108
Epipagis mopsalis 184*
Epiplemidae 160'
Ennnyis alope 130
Ermnyisello 127, 136*, 140. 149
Eumorpha fascialus 133, 145, 158
Eumorpha labnvicae 126. 131, 141*
Eumorpha satellida salellitia 142
Eumomia rubripunctata 54
Euptoieta claudia claudia 19, 20
Eurema daira paimira 7
Eurema elathea 8
Eurema lisa euterpe 9
Euschirropierus poeyi 67

198

Evans' Jamaican Skipper 31

Fabricius' Hairy Dusky Wing 34"
Fall Armyworm 77. 101
Faronta diffusa 196
Frangipani Sphinx 134

94, \W\ no. 111,

Gaudy Sphinx 126. 131. 141'
Geometridae 29, 52. 73, 92. 93.

154. 155. 156. 157
Gesta gesla gesla 35, 36"
Giant Sphinx 138
Gonodonta Clotilda 117*
Gonodonla incurx'a 74
Gonodonola nutrix 1 17
Gonodonola uxoria 74

Heliconius chariloniics simulalor 14, 15

Heliothis subjiexa 95*

Helioihis virescens 95*

Hesperiidae 30, 31, 32, 33, 34. 35. 36. 37, 38, 39, 40,

41.42,43
Heterosmaitia bourkei 29
Hieroglyphic Moth 105
Hisloris odius odius 26
Homerus Swallowtail 4
Hoterodes aitsonia 173
Hiibner's Hairy Dusky Wing 34*
Hyalurga leucophaea 50
Hyblaea puera 100
Hyblaeidae 100
Hyles lineata 151
Hypercompe nigriplaga 60

Jamaican Admiral 28
Jamaican Albatross 5
Jamaican Crescent-Spot 21
Jamaican Polydamus 1
Jamaican Queen 13
Jamaican Swallowtail 3
Jamaican White Peacock 25
Jamaican Zebra 14. 15
Julia 16
Jummia evarete zonalis 22. 23

Khcogonia lyside 10

Lasiocampidae 164

I-atrcillc's Cane Skipper 41
IJmacodidae 165
Little Sulphur 9
Lucas Skipper 33
l.ycaenidae 29. 44'
lAmantriidae 63. 66*
Lysidc 10

Macnila H

C. V. ELLWOOD&J. M. V. HARVEY

Manduca sp. 147'

Manduca quinquemaculata 125". 139

Manduca rustica rustica 143, 148

Manduca scxta 125'

Melanochroia chephi.se 157*

Melipoiis famelica 98

Mesocondyla concordalis 163*, 167

Meslra dorcas 27

Microcramhus sp. 189

Mocis sp . 114

Mythimna sp. 1 16

Noctuidae67. 72. 74. 75. 77. 78. 79. 80. 81. 82. 83",

84. 85. 86. 87, 88. 90. 91. 95, 96. 97*. 98. 99. 101.

102. 103, 104*. 105. 106, 107. 108. 112. 113. 114.

115. 116. 117. 118. 119. 121*, 122. 123', 159*. 196
Notodontidae 49
Nycleltus nvctclius nyclelius 41
Nymphalidae 13. 14. 15, 16. 17, 18, 19,20,21,22,23.

24.25.26.27.28

Oiketicus sp. 161. 162. 168
Oraesia excitans 99
Orion 26
Owl Moth 87
Oxydiasp.lV, 110, 111

Pachylia fictis 129. 144

Panoquina sylvicola woodruffi 42

Papilio homerus 4

Papilio thersiles 2

Papilio thoas melonius 3

Papilionidae 1.2.3.4

Paraeuchaetes insulata 58, 65

Perichares philetes philetes 43

Phoebis sennae sennae 12

Phostria fulvicauda 185'

Phostria humeralis 180

Pieridae5.6. 7.8, 9. 10, II, 12

Pilocrocis sp. 84

Pilocrocis glaucusalis 182*

Pilocrocis hvpoleucalis 181*

Pilocrocis ramentalis 1 18

Pilocrocis tripunctaia 1S8

Platynota sp. 37

Platynota rostrana 191. 192

Polygoniis leo hagar 31

Protambuhx singilis 137

Psfudoplusia includen.s 1 (►6

Psvudosphinx tclrio 134

Psychidae 161. 162. 168

Pterophoridae 52, 195

Ptcrophonv, sp. 195

P>ralidae 51. 53. 71.76.84. 118, 120. 163. 166. 167.

169. 170. 171, 172. 173, 174*. 175. 176, 177. 178.

179. 180. 181, 182. 183. 184, 185. 186. 187. 188. 189
Pyrgus oileus 38

THE LADY BLAKE COLLECTION

199

Pyrrhocaltes faniaicensis 39

Rivula sp. U-S*
Rustic Sphinx 143. 148

Sameii sp. 71 *

Schaus' Skipper 39

Siproeta stelenes stelenes 24

Soybean Looper 106

Spanish Molh 85

Sphingidae 124, 125, 126, 127, 12S,
132, 133, 134, 135, 136, 137. 138
142, 143, 144, 145. 146. 147. 148.

Spodoptera androgea rubnfusa 79

Spodopfera frugiperda 71 , 101

Spodoptera latifascia ^U

Spodoptera ornilhogalli 81

Slenoptvcha sp. 51

Sweet Potato Horn worm 146

Sylleple prorogata 1 75 *

Sylleple sUicalis 1 87

Syrfjphysa discalis 1 86

Syngartiia florella 177

Syngamia haemorrhouialis 53', 171

Syntomidopsis variegala 53

Syrichtus 38

12^. 130. 131.
139. 140. 141.
149, 150,151, 158

Thersitcs Swallowtail 2

Thysania zenobia 87

Tit\a sp. 164

Tomato Hornworm 125*. \}>*^

Tortricidae37. 47*,48*, 191, 192. 193'

Tropical Silverspot 17, 18

Udea sp. 178'
(Jrbanus proteus 3U
Vtelhcisa bella 62

Variegated Fritillary 19. 20

Watson's Cane Skipper 42
West Indian Buckeye 22, 23
Wheat Head Armyworm 196
White-lined Sphinx 151

Xanlhopaslis timais 85
Xylophar^essp. 124*. 135
Xylophanes lersa 132, 150

Yellow Scallop Moth 75
Yellow-striped Armyworm 81

Zale fictilis 1>^

Index of Plant Names

Numbers refer to catalogue entries. Family names are in bold, genus and species names
are in italics. Catalogue numbers marked with an asterisk indicate uncertain identifications.

Aaron's Rod 1 1
Acacia tnacracanlha 46
Acacia lorluosa 98
Acanthaceae21.24.25, 118*. 166*
Aeschvnomene sp 94
Albizia lebbeck 72
Amaryllidaceae 85. 106
Anacardiaceae 137. 156, 165. 192
Angels Trumpet 66
Annonaceae 138
Ant's Wood 164
Apocynaceae 55, 134. 190*
Araceae 17^
Arecaceae see Palmae
Aristolochia trdobaia 1
Aristolochiaceae 1
Asclepiadaceae 13, 174*
Asclepias curassavica 13
Asteraceae see Compositae

Ballard Bush 83. 96

Bastard Cherry 57
Bastard Ironwood 2, 3
Bauhtnia sp. 1H5
Bauhinia monandra 32*
BesleruiluteaW, 70
Bignoniaceae KK), 163. 167. 183
Bird Pepper 51
Black Nightshade IKl
Blechnaceae 1 19
Blechnum sp, 1 19
Blechumsp. 118*
Boerhavia coccinea 52
Boerhavia erecla 151
Boraginaceac 45. 50. 57. 143, 170*
Borrcria Uievis 150
Broomweed 38
BrowaHia arnericana 48
Bur MalK)wH3.96
Bur Weed 82. 102
Bursera simaruha 173
Burseraceae 173

2(X)

Button Weed 150

Cacsalpiniaceae 12, 32. 92. 95. 154V 161. 185

Cajanus cajan 169

Calabash Tree 163

Carina sp. 40'

Cannaceae 40*

Capparaceae 6, 127*. 186*

Capsicum sp, 147*

Capsicum frutescens 5 1

Cassava 140

Cassia sp. 87'

Cassia absus 95

Cassia emarginata 12

Cassia pilosa 92

Catalpa longissima 1 (K)

Cayenne Pepper 51

Ct'cropia peltata 26. 61

Cecropiaceae 26. 61

Cenirosema virginianum 30

Ceslrum diurnum 107

Cheesy Toes 8. 44

Cheramina 157

Chilli 51

Christmas Bush 58. 65

Cissampelos pareira 99

Cissus sicyoides 128*. 141

Cissits verticillata see Cissus sicyoides

Citrus 73

Clammy Bur 33. 123

Cleome spinosa 6

Cockspur 67

Cocos nucifera 39

Combretaceae 162

Compositae 47. 56. 58. 65. 6H. 113

Convolvulaceae54. 103. 146. 18.'. 195

Cordia brownei 143'

Cordia gerascanlhus 170

Cordia jamaicensis 143*

Cow Foot 74

Cralevasp. 127', 186*

Crescentia cujete 1 63

Crinum sp. 85'

Crolalarta retusa 62

Cucurbitaceae 172

Datura candida 66
DelonLx regia 161
Desmanthus virgalus 93
Desmodium tortuosum 53*
Dtcliptera sexangularis 2 1
Dogwood 3 1
Donkey Weed 8. 44
Dunalia arborescens 84*
Duppy Gun 25

Ehretia tinifolia 57

C. V. ELLWOOD&J. M. V. HARVI-Y

Ericaceae 89'

Euchans grandifiora 106
Euchanst L.ily 106
Eupatorium odoratum 58. 65
Euphorbia hiria 149
Euphorbiaceae27. 127*. 140. 149. 157

Fabaceae see Papilionaceae

Fagara pieroia 2. 3
Fasten-'pon-Coat 33, 123
Fatten Barrow 47, 113
F(a«sp.34'.59. 129. 144*
Fict4s citrifolia 1 82
Fingrigo 67
Flamboyant 161
Frangipani 134
French Oak 100
Fresh Cut 24

Geraniaceae St

Gesneriaceae 69. 70. 153

Gliricuiia septum 1 1

Golden Apple 14. 15, 17

Gouma 18!

Graniineae41.42.43.44, 101, 113, 114. 115. 116. 196

Grape (European or Wine) 132. 142

Ground Tamarind 93

Grow Stick 1 1

Guaco 56, 68

Guaiacum officinale H)

Guatemala Indigo 36

Guava37,49. 108. 111. 159, 176

Gully Bean 104

Gungo Pea 169

Heluonia sp, 40*
Helictmiaceae 40*

Hetioiropium indicum 50
Hernandia calalpifolia 4
Hernandiaceae 4

Hcvtu hnisdwnsis 127*
Hibiscus sp. 130*
Hippeasirum sp. 85*
Hog Weed 52
Hxptts capttala 194
Hxptis suaveolens 71 , 90

Indian Corn 101
Indigofera subulata 189
Indigofera suffruiicosa 36
Inga vera 180
Ipomoea sp. 146. 188. 195
Irish Potato 80
Ironwort W4

Jack-in-the-bush 58. 65
Jamaican Forgel-me-not 48

THE LADY BLAKE COLLECTION

201

Jamaican Plum 137
Jasminum grandifiorum KJM
Jimbling 157
Johnny Berry ^7, 1K4
Justicia sp. 118*
Justicia pecionilis 24

Ubiatae7I,90, 194
Lamiaceae see Labiatae

Lasiacis sp. lis

Leguminosae79*,87, 120, 178*

Lepianthes umbellata see Pothonwrphe umbelUiia

Lignum Vitac 10

Ludwigia octovalvis 133. 14?

Lycoperskon esculentum 131

Macroptilium lathy roides 121

Maize 101

Malvaceae 38, 75. 83. 91. 96, 122, 130*

Malvastrum sp. 91*

Mangifera indica 1 56

Mango 156

Manihot esculenla 140

Markham Gungo 36

Mast Wood \m

Melastomataceae 97, 184

Meliaceae 152

Menispermaceae 99

Menow Weed 25

Merremia aegyptia 54*

Merremia quinquefolia 54*. 103

Miconia laevigata 97*. 184

Mikania mkrarxtha 56. 68

Mimosa pudica 9

Mimosaceae 9. 46. 72, 93, 98. 180

Moraceae 34*. 59, 129, 144*, 182

MiLssaenda treutleri 28

Myrsinaceae 89*

Myrlaceae37.49. 108. Ill, 159, 176

Nicotiana sp. 84*
Nightsage 55
Nightshade 55
Nyctaginaceae 52, 67, 151

Oleaceae HW
Onagraceae 133, 145
Orange 73*
Otaheite Gooseberry 157

Palmae39. 168

Panchock 180

Panicum maximum 42*, 43*

Papilionaceae 8, 11.30.31,35.36.44.53.62.94, 121.

169. 171. 189
Pareira Brava 99
Park Nut 46

Parkinsonia aculeata 154

Paspalum sp. 113

Passiflora laurifolia 14. 15. 17. 18

Passifiora suberosa 16. 191

Passifloraceae 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 191

Pelargonium sp. 81

Pencil Flower 8. 44

Phyllaruhus acidus 157

Pigeon Pea 169

Pignut 71. 90

Pilea^p- 193

Piper adimcum 74

Piperaceae 74

Piscidia piscipula 31

Pisonia aculeata tTI

Pistia siratiotes 174

Planlaginaceae 22

Plantago virginica 22

Plumena rubra 134

Poaceae see Gramineae

Poet's Jasmine 109

Poinciana 161

Porter Weed 23

Pofhomorphe umhellata 74

Priva lappulacea 33. 123

Prunus sp. 155*

Prmius mvrtifolia 164

Psidium guajava 37. 49. 108. 111. 159. 176

Pudding Withe 128*, 141

Quick Stick 1 1

Raichie2y. 105

Ram-Goat Dashalong 19

Rattlewecd 62

Red Birch 173

Red Top 13

Redhead 13

River Koko 180

Rock Rosemary 54*. 103

Romieletia sp. 63

Rosa sp. 60. 110

Rosaceae60. 110. 155*. 164

Rose 60. 110

Rubiaceae28.63. 150, 166*. 177*

Ruellia tuberosa 25

Rutaceae 2. 3. 73

Rytidophvllum fomentosum 153

Saven Tree 2, 3
Scorpion Weed 50
Senna Tree 12
Sesbania sp. 35*
Shame Weed 9
Short Jimbelin 157
Sidasp. 91*
Sida acuta 38

202

Sida aggregala 122

Snake Withe 128*. 141

Snake Wood 26. 61

Solanaceae 4S. 51, 66. SO. 84. 86'. 104. 107. 131.

147', 181
Sotanum americanitm 1 8 1
Solatium lorvum 104
Solanum mherosum 80
Spermacoce assurgens see Borreria laevis
Spikenard 71. 90
Spondias sp. 165
Spondias momhin 192
Spondtas purpurea 1 37
Stachxtarpheta jamaKencis 23
Stachytarphfla mutahilis 160
Sterculiaceae 29, 105
Slylosanlhes hamala 8. 44
Styptic Bur 33. 123
Susumber 104
Synedrella nodiflora 47. 113

Tahehum rufescens 167
Tapioca 140
Tecoma starts 1 83
Tephrosia sp. 35*, 120'
Teramnus uncinatus 1 7 1
Terminalia catappa 162
Tiliaceae82, 102. 112
Tomato 131

Tournefortia hirsutissima 45
Tragia volubilis 27
Tref 1

Trichilia hiria 1 52
Triumfetta sp. 112
Trmmfetta semitrHoba 82. 102
Trumpet Tree 26. 61
Turkey Berry 104
Turnera ulmifolia 19

C. V. ELLWOOD&J. M. V. HARVFY

Turneraceae 19
Twining Cowitch 27

Vrechilcs lulea 55
Urena lobala 83, 96
llrticaceae 187*, 193

Velvet Bur 33, 123
Velvet Leaf 99
Verbenaceae 23, 33, 123, 160
Vervinc 23

Vitaceae 128. 132. 141. 142
Vi;« vinifera 132. 142

Wait-a-bit 67
Walllwria iridica 29. 105
Water Lettuce 179
Water Mahoe 4
Water Wood 4
West Indian Almond 162
White Wattle 97, 184
Wild Caesar Obeah 194
Wild Cassada 164
Wild Clary 50
Wild Indigo 36
Wild Jasmine 107
Wild Mahogany 1.52
Wild Poponax 98
Wissadula fadyeriii 75
Woman's Tongue Tree 72

Yellow Candle Wood 12
Yellow Poui 167
Yoke Wood KHI

Zanlhnxylum fagara see Fagara plerola
Zea mays 101
Zygophyllaceae 10

Bull Br Mils. Nal. HisI (his! Scr ) 18(2): 2().V22K Issued 2'^ Novemher 1990

Charles Darwin's St Helena
Model Notebook

Edited by GORDON RUSSELL CHANCELLOR

Cily Museum and An Gallery, Prieslgale. Peterborough PEI ILF

CONTENTS

Introduction 203

The Notebook 205

Evidence for dating 206

The St Helena Model Notebook and Darwin's Crater of Elevation

Theory 207

Editorial conventions 210

Acknowledgements 211

Notes 219

Bibliography 225

References 226

INTRODUCTION

Charles Darwin (1809-1882) is beyond question one of the most important figures in the
history of science, and as each year passes our appreciation of his importance seems only
to increase. At the present time students of Darwin's life and work are being treated to a
definitive edition of his Correspondence (Burkhardt & Smith, 1985-) and there recently
appeared a similarly definitive edition of his theoretical notebooks (hereinafter referred
to as Notebooks (Barrett, Gautrey, Herbert, Kohn & Smith, 1987)).

It will take historians a long time fully to assimilate all this new material into their
understanding of Darwin and the milieu in which he worked. Nevertheless, there is now
a clear consensus that he became an evolutionist ("transmutationist' being the word he
would have used) in the spring of 1837, within six months of his return from the voyage of
the Beagle. It is also established that he constructed his theory of natural selection in the
autumn of 1838, elaborating it and working out most of its radical implications during the
winter and spring of 1839 (see Notebooks). Twenty years were to elapse, however,
before Darwin published On the Origin of Species (1859), and in the intervening period
few people were allowed to know the conclusion to which his work had led him. With the
full publication of Darwin's Correspondence and Notebooks we can now, for the first
time, trace his path to natural selection — and beyond — in as much detail as the
documentary record will ever allow.

There is one small Darwin notebook, omitted for practical reasons from the Note-
books, which Darwin seems to have kept about his person for 'on the spot' jottings
throughout the important last few months of 1838. This notebook has become known as
the 'St Helena Model' notebook, because these words are written on its cover, and
because it contains notes concerning a model of the island of St Helena. This notebook

204

G. R. CHANCELLOR

Fig 1 The St Helena Model' notebook of Charles Darwin, open at pp. 26-7. Courtesy of the

Royal College of Surgeons.

must, however, have had a greater meaning to Darwin, as it records many of his thoughts
relating to variation, breeding and so on, albeit in telegraphic style. Most of these
thoughts are much more fully expressed in the Notebooks, so that the St Helena Model
notebook assumes an importance as the first medium available to a thinker who was
eager not to forget the details of some observation or to lose the thread of a conversation
before he could get home to his private study. Unfortunately twenty-one of the original
fifty pages of the St Helena Model notebook have been excised — presumably by
Darwin — and none of these excised pages has yet been found. This is all the more
regretable because it was probably the theoretically most interesting pages which were
excised.

In spite of its fragmentary nature the St Helena Model notebook is worthy of
publication. Much remains in the notebook of interest to those studying Darwin's
work as a geologist at the time when he was entering the elite of London scientists
(Rudwick" 1982), but perhaps its greatest charm lies in the glimpse it gives us of the daily
thoughts and activities of a young genius at the most creative period of his life. In the
weeks leading up to his marriage and election to Fellowship of the Royal Society, even
Charles Darwin had to think about laundry and the problems of moving into a new
address: 'Two easy chairs — Blinds in Red Rooms washed — Muslin all to be washed"
(p.31x).

CHARLES DARWIN S ST HELENA MODEL NOTEBOOK

205

Fig 2 The 'St Helena Model' notebook of Charles Darwin. Note the writing on the front and the
orientation of the brass clasp. Courtesy of the Royal College of Surgeons.

THE NOTEBOOK

The St Helena Model notebook was briefly described and partially transcribed by Nora
Barlow (Darwin's grand-daughter) in her Charles Darwin and the Voyage of the Beagle
(1945: 255). Lady Barlow noted that Darwin had written 'Nothing' and 'St Helena
Model' in bold, thick ink on the red leather cover of the notebook (see Figs 1-2), which
measures approxiinateiy 7cm x 11cm and is very similar to the smallest of the pocket
notebooks (referred to as 'field notebooks' in Correspondence 1: 545) used by Darwin
during the Beagle voyage, with which it is now kept on display at Down House.

The surviving pages of the notebook were written almost entirely in pencil, except in a
few cases where I have indicated that ink was used. So far as I can tell, none of the ink
used is of the grey variety which is to be found in some of Darwin's other notebooks from
this period (Notebooks: 14). Darwin seems almost always to have written 'down' the
page, that is to say holding it with the hinge (which is 7cm long) oriented horizontally.
We may imagine therefore, that the notebook was carried at all times by Darwin, ready
to be jotted in whenever occasion arose; in this sense the notebook is equivalent to one
of the pocket notebooks used during the Beagle voyage, and differs from the Notebooks
which are essentially of post-voyage date. Evidence for dating of passages in the
notebook is discussed further below; the bulk of the entries date from September to

206 G- K- CHANCl I.IOR

December 1838, although there is one reference (written in ink on the inside baclc cover)
dated 1839.

The front end paper of the notebook has the number 1.5 written in the top right hand
corner, in heavy pencil, in an unknown hand; this is the notebook's Down House
catalogue number (see Correspondence 1: 545). The front end paper is also inscribed in
the bottom left hand corner, in pencil, with a number 15 in which the 5 is written over a
6. This number 15 is uniform with a series to be found in each of the other Down House
notebooks which reflect the approximate chronological order in which they were used.
The 'Red Notebook" (Notebooks: 17-81) is numbered 16 in this series, but in fact entirely
predates the St Helena Model notebook. I am informed by Sandra Herbert and Peter
Gautrey that this second series of numbers is in Nora Barlow's handwriting. Since
neither the 1.5 nor the 15 are in Darwin's hand they are omitted from the present edition.

The pages of the notebook were not numbered by Darwin and because he wrote in it
from both ends inwards, I have numbered the pages in two sequences, pp. 1-64 and pp.
lx-32x. I refer to these two sequences as the front and back of the notebook respectively,
although there is no real evidence that one was started before the other. As can be seen,
however, from Figures 1-2, the notebook has a hinged brass clasp similar to ones on
Darwin's other surviving notebooks, in almost all of which the hinge of the clasp is on the
back cover (clearly the easiest arrangement for a right-handed person). I therefore refer
to that end of the St Helena Model notebook which bears the hinge of its brass clasp as
the back end.

EVIDENCE FOR DATING ENTRIES IN THE NOTEBOOK

There is only one reference in the notebook as it survives today which is actually dated,
and this is the 1839 reference mentioned above. All other entries in the notebook must,
therefore, be dated from internal evidence and by comparison with other Darwin
manuscripts which can be dated. Broadly there are three more or less distinct sections of
the notebook, each of which can be dated in this way.

Firstly, the text from p. 1 to p. 15 forms a discrete essay on the geology of the island of
St Helena, based on examination of a large model of the island. The evidence for dating
this essay is given in more detail below, but suffice it here to say that it seems to
have been written at one sitting, on or about 15 September 1838 (which was a
Saturday). Just possibly this essay was written a few months before this date, following a
conjectural earlier examination of the model. Darwin himself seems to have treated
these first fifteen pages of the notebook as a separate entity, to judge from the pinhole
through them.

Secondly, the texts from p. 16 to p. 48 and from p. 5x to p. 29x are almost entirely
concerned with the many geological and biological problems that Darwin was examining
in the latter months of 1838. There are numerous entries on these pages which have close
parallels in the Notebooks, the dating of entries in which can often he stated with
certainty, not least because Darwin dated many of them himself. Whilst all such parallel
references to the Notebooks which I have found are given in the notes which follow the
text, 1 give here the most closely datable pages against the corresponding Notebooks
pages (in parentheses) and dates:

p. 22 (D40) between 19 and 22 August 18.38

p. 41 (M142) between 13 and 15 September 18.38

p. 46 (D105) 13 September 1838

CHARLE-s Darwin's st Helena model notebook 207

p. 47 (DlOO) 13 September 1838

p. 48 (Dl()8, 1 12) 14 to 16 September 1838

p. 29x (D163) 25 September 1838.

Clearly, most of the references support a dating for these pages to September 1838.

Thirdly, the texts from p. 59 to p. 64 and from p. 30x to p. 32x (i.e. the last entries in
the notebook) are concerned with house hunting in London. In Darwin's pocket
'Journal' which (as Sandra Herbert first pointed out in 1977: 208) seems to have been first
used in August 1838, there is the following entry for 1838 (see Correspondence 2: 432):
'To the end of year House hunting'. Darwin took possession of the keys to 12 Upper
Gower Street on 29 December 1838, so that one can say with reasonable confidence that
these entries date from late November to December 1838.

THE ST HELENA MODEL AND DARWIN'S CRATER OF ELEVATION

THEORY

As noted above, the first fifteen pages of the notebook form an essay on the geology of
St Helena, and the words 'St Helena Model' are written on the notebook's cover (see

Fig 3 Map of The Island & Forts of St Helena (c.l815), scale of 2 miles = 1.75 inches, :5cin
19cm. Courtesy of the Syndics of Cambridge University Library. (CUL Maps 546.81.1).

208 G. R. CHANCELLOR

Fig. 3). In order to date this essay and to establish its significance, it is necessary to
review Darwins manuscript record concerning St Helena.

When H.M.S. Beagle visited St Helena in July 1836. Darwin took the opportunity to
make a detailed examination of its geology, recording his observations in Down House
notebooks 1.3 and 1.6. Aboard ship Darwin wrote up his personal diary, which is also
today preserved at Down House, and sorted out his geological specimens, which are
listed as numbers 37tK)-28 in the third of four catalogue notebooks which are now on
deposit at Cambridge University Library. He also wrote up his detailed geological notes
on paper watermarked Wilmot 1834; these notes are now at Cambridge University
Library, DAR 38ii, ff. 920-35. At some point before the Beagle reached England,
Darwin made some notes on St Helena in his Red Notebook, the most extensive being
those on pp. 38-40. which he subsequently excised and are now in DAR 42. f. 84 (see
Notebooks: 31).

While Darwin's servant and amanuensis Syms Covington was making a fair copy of his
master's personal diary, probably in the early months of 1837. for eventual publication as
Journal of Researches (hereinafter referred to as JR). Darwin prepared an additional
section on the geology and natural history of St Helena. This section appears on pp. 581-
3 of JR. but as Nora Barlow pointed out in her edition of the personal diary (Barlow,
1933: 439n58) the manuscript of this section appears to be lost, and cannot therefore be
precisely dated.

In July 1837 Darwin opened the first two of his post-voyage Notebooks. Notebook A
was devoted to geology, notebook B to species. Notebook A contains a reference to St
Helena on p. 41; 'The fact of Galapagos Isld. steep side to windward in allusion to St.
Helena discussion.' (Notebooks: 96). This note is on an excised fragment now in DAR
42, f. 25, which can be dated approximately to November-December 1837 (Notebooks-
83).

The next datable manuscript dealing with the geology of St Helena is a single sheet of
Eyehorn 1837-watermarked paper, bound near the back of DAR 44. The recto of this
document is dated 15 September 1838, and headed 'St Helena Model'; it is written in
pencil with a few ink annotations and concerns the topography of the north-west and
north-east coasts of St Helena. It is written in a similar style to, and clearly overlaps in
subject matter with the first fifteen pages of the St Helena Model notebook. Both
documents seem to have been written during or immediately after examination of the
•gigantic model' of St Helena, which we know Darwin saw at the East India Company's
Military College at Addiscombe, which is now part of Croydon in Surrey (see Darwin
1844, hereinafter referred to as VI: 75 footnote; 1846, hereinafter referred to as GSA:
25). This dating for Darwin's work on the model is substantiated bv a letter he wrote to
an unknown recipient dated 12 September {1838}, in which he asks permission to
examine the model, having apparently seen it "some months since' (Correspondence 2:
103).

The model itself, which I have not been able to locate and which probably no longer
exists, was constructed by Robert Scale, author of The Geognosy of the Island of St
Helena (Scale, 1834).

The verso of the DAR 44 manuscript, reproduced here as Figure 4, is an inked-ovcr
pencil diagram showing cliff formation on the north-west coast of St Helena. It is clearly
developed from the diagram on p. 38 of the Red Notebook, and via various intermediate
states preserved in DAR .39ii was published in the section on cliff formation in GSA:
25-6; (see also Notebooks: 31n38-4).

The remaining manuscripts which deal with the geology of St Helena are a series of
pencilled notes written, like the DAR 44 sheet discussed above, on Eyehorn 1837 paper
and preserved as DAR 42, ff. 94-7. These too are mainly concerned with the subject of
coastal erosion and they may well have been written at the same time as the DAR 44

CHARLES DARWIN'S ST HELENA MODEL NOTEBOOK

209

<>

J.

I V

.1

r

sft

1 t

■I

■'

hi

,1,1,

-

1" oo

« "5

* c

o c

x: ra

</i (J

j= ^-

.y o

00 c

00 in

^ CJ

X) ^
E o

D. o
OJ *-
C/5 5
U-, o

- U

T3

is

o £

— rt

o <u

o

n

I g-

3
C

o

lib

210 G. R. CHANCELLOR

note. The geological notes in DAR 38ii are in places heavily annotated in pencil which
may also have been written at the same time as the DAR 44 sheet. There is a light pencil
note in the margin of DAR 38ii, f. 931 to "Vlide] Model'.

There is one other line of evidence to support the dating of the first fifteen pages of the
St Helena Model notebook to 15 September 1838 or thereabouts. This is the evidence
from Darwin's pocket "Journal' (see above, p. 207) of his scientific activities at that
time:

September 6th Finished paper on Glen Roy — one of the most difficult & instructive
tasks I was ever employed on

Sept. 14th Frittered these {foregoing days added) away in working on Transmutation
theories & correcting Glen Roy Began craters of F.lcvation Theory

Burkhardt & Smith (1987, Correspondence 2: 436n24) were not able to locate any
manuscript by Darwin dealing with his novel explanation for the form of islands such as
St Jago. Mauritius and St Helena. Darwin publi,shed his 'Crater of Elevation theory' in a
special section appended to the chapter on St Helena in VI: 93-6. Darwin's theory, in
essence, was that certain types of volcanic islands which consisted of an outer ring of
mountains, enclosing a more or less level inner plateau, were the result of differential
uplift, with the inner area less elevated than the outer ring of mountains. Such islands —
referred to by previous authors as craters of elevation — would otherwise have been
explained as resulting from collapse of the inner area following blister-like elevation, or
by postulating that the central part of the island had been destroyed by volcanic
explosion.

In my opinion, knowing that Darwin began work on the theory on almost the same
date that he made his notes on the model of St Helena, we may identify all the Eyehorn
1837-watermarked manuscripts itemized above, and possibly also the annotations to the
Beagle notes on St Helena, together with the essay at the start of the St Helena Model
notebook, as Darwin's surviving manuscripts on "Craters of Elevation'.

EDITORIAL CONVENTIONS

In the following transcription of Darwin's "St Helena Model' notebook the original
spelling and punctuation have been retained, together with the horizontal lines Darwin
drew across the page to mark off pieces of text. All other markings, such as vertical
cancelling lines and marginal scoring have been ignored. Notes to the text are indicated
by superscript numbers. All editorial matter is included in square brackets and is
italicized. Page stubs have not been transcribed. It should be noted that there are no
obvious annotations in this notebook, in the sense of text added much later than the main
body of the text. I'his is in marked contrast to some of Darwin's other notebooks (see
Notebooks: 12).

< > Darwin's deletion
<< >> Darwin's insertion
bold type written in ink
dleg illegible
/- -/ doubtful reading

Page numbers arc given in square brackets. Excised pages are signified by the
notation 'e'.

CHARLES DARWIN S ST HELENA MODEL NOTEBOOK

211

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

My thanks are due especially to the Royal College of Surgeons, for allowing me to
publish the 'St Helena Model' notebook, and for agreeing most generously to depositing
the notebook temporarily at Cambridge University Library so that I could work on it
there. It is a pleasure also to acknowledge the help I received at Cambridge from Mr
Peter Gautrey, whose ability to read Darwin's handwriting has aided my task a great
deal, but who is in no way responsible for the accuracy of the present edition. I am
grateful also to Dr Sandra Herbert of the University of Maryland, who has greatly
improved my work at several stages and encouraged me to complete the project, as has
my partner AUi.son Butt. Finally I thank the Syndics of Cambridge University Library for
permission to quote from manuscripts in their care, and for providing the illustrations for
this paper.

[FRONT END PAPER'

[1]

[3|

An Elevation inter=
= mediate between
Longwood' &
Alarm house'
will give

mean inclination
of stream before
elevation at
Flagstaff

/-Bluimans-/'" probably
modern lava.

Horse pasture""
island slopes
impossible to guess
what it is

High Hiir. I

should think external

<<a <little> more elevated then rest

of ring>>

/-Vide-/ basalt & V[/We] specimens

Hollow <<on coast>> near Man
& Horse** I should <<certainly>>
think end of <<?capped with
/-Lava-/ & elevated ?>>
external ring: to

The S. [illeg] Is
like inside of
Crater.

/-Evidently-/ great
/-remnant-/ near
Flat Rocks."

[4] ?<<very doubtfuh
old rocks near
Flat rocks?

Whether any

Asses ears'" so very
near coast

South Barn"
I should think
Basaltic, as well
as Long Range
point'- XXX

Cuckolds point''

2672

Hally'sMount'^
2400

According to
colouring, base of
Man & Horse"
<extemal> basaltic

X X X X & I can
scarcely doubt great

[6] Stone top"" <<is likewise basaltio
High Hill" most

212

G. R. CHANCELLOR

[7]

1«]

[9]

anomalous

Part of Barn"*
nearest to Flagstaff'**
higher than seaward
point from
elevation -

The form of South

Barn"" would lead
to supposition that
it dipped to SE by
S.-

If we complete the
crater<s> /-by-/ Green Hill"'
/-to-/ Nest [Lodge written over
Loge']", the
longer axis will be
parallel to S. Coast
as /-rise-/ of Green

Hill is nearly obliterated
We need not be surprised
at SW part of
circle being entirely
obliterated

1 1(1) connection true
or false?

The tops of
basaltic masses
stick up

above the modern =
strewn all round
a little higher

1111

[12]

The /-state-/ of outer
/-ring at-/ (/-true-/ SW)
point, is quite
doubtful.-, cause
of dip of S Barn"-^
doubtful. -

[13]

Excepting from
disturbance at the
/-?-/ Barn-'' axis of
Crater parallel to
island. -

New crater placed
rather at one
end of ring of
Rocks

Lot. Lots Wife" &
& Flagstaff^* in line

[14]

TTie lava of Flagstaff-^
did not proceed
<over> from so
low a place as
<Consons> Casons Gate^*

When I talk of
dip from High
/-Peak"'' have-/ 1 said
SWforNW!!!??

The irregular
position of the
external /-knobs-/,
/-would certainly-/
appear more
probably due to
elevation, than
<<to>> crater of subsidence

Appears to have

less regularity,
than true crater
tho' having
crateriform
dip

Prosperous Bay^^"
Flagstaff ought"
to have dipped
due E.

Barn'- NE
ought to have
dipped

South <<Barn>>" ought to

have dipped

SbyE

From black angular

CHARLES DARWIN S ST HELENA MODEL NOTEBOOK

213

[15]

projecting <<mass>> at base
of Man & Horse'''
no doubt external
basaltic, but
top too smooth
I must suspect
structure like
Flagstaff''

[16] Dr Lind/-stay-/-^* Curator

Ask Gould" about
East Indian & Australian
Birds, with respect
to /-islets-/^**

Eyton^"— Waterhouse*^
think/-s grey-/ with black
bars cat differ species
from small tortoise =
shell caf" — skeletons
Do get shepherds tail

17e-2()e]

[21] Sulivan""" get head of
ox called "Nata"^'

History of cross breeds

Gould drawing of
ostrich''^

D'Orbigny'" is giving
figure shells from
Cordillera^"

Ear Doctor'*^

[22] Tell Lyell* of Desnoyers
Paper'^"

Tell Mr Owen""'
of Caout chouk""'
to stop bottle

admirable tables
of distribution of
reptiles of <S. America>
/-bound-/ in Suites
de Buffon", of

[23e-24el

[25] /-Wrappers-/ ??

about sending to Subscribers^'

Stewart' about payment
of the 100 guineas
for Gould -

Curtis'" my bill

Dr Smith'' sharks
teeth Navedad
Chile

/-will examine them
hereafter-/

[26] Major Mitchell'"

Height of Escarpment

of Blue Mountains

«do hybrid does <foxes> /-Austral-/

dogs, breed.-' >>

Depth of rivers near
mouths'*

Any Fossils /-in the-/ Sandstone"
/-Pecten Terebratula-/

Name of Mr Brown*^ leaves*'

Do Australian dogs hunt in
packs*^ /-Watuaya-/

Woodcut of Bomb"-'

27 1 Pay Lonsdale"* Geolog
Transactions
Pseudo-strata,
-craters.

There are some

? May I quote your statement

214

G. R. CHANCELLOR

about steep shore deep beneath
water.''^ find out about cliffs
on banks of rivers.

/-during-/ a stormy night
in water transported
90 yards, & the person
on the /-spot was confused-/

At Head of /-CJrose-/ are there

cliffs & confine attention to this

one valley yes

Do the rivers continue deep

a little way above tidal action <<no

cliffs>> /-Look out for shells with

bones not always cliffs-/

[two illeg words]
Henrietta /-St-/ Bath*^
would probably answer letter
& give information
about tailless breed of
cats*''' (origin?) near
Walmesbury breed??

|37e^()el

1411

all preserving their
NEdip

Miss Marlineau p. 213^^
Charity everywhere
<<1 doubted it at first>> Byron & the
Fuegian women Have any

Wiltshire sheep, with
teeth pushing each
other out
Plants from Henslow^'

Sulivan^' about
English Weeds
Fennel, Sow Thistle
/-Reach—/

[42]

other associated animals
charity — cows not
wild cattle & [illeg]

Wouett on Cattle'*
Waterhouse, has it''

Ask [Fox™ ink over pencil] to

experimentise''*

on Frogs spawn & to

procure eggs of

Land Snail, for me —

[29e-34el

[35] Council of
Geolog Soc
for map of
Scotland

Owen's Edition

of <<Hunters's>> Animal

Economy**"

Dunford field
/-Church-/ St

[43e-44e]
[45] n.b.

[36]

/-Last-/ number of Lancet, account
of Owen & Magnetism'" "

Vol. VII Ed. T.

p.l57'-'Sir J Hall

states that "a <<large>> block

of <rock> <<slone>> 4 or 5 ft

in diam, lying within

high water mark, &

well known as <<having>> serving

to denote the boundary

of two estates was

Pintail & Common

Duck to get

some half /-breed-/**'

Bring Picture

for /-M-/

Cross between Black
Grouse Ptarmigan**"

Pheasant & Grouse in*"

wild — when species decreasing

CHARLES DARWIN'S ST HELENA MODEL NOTEBOOK

[46] Capercailzie^'*

215

Place
Park-

Black Grouse &
subalpina*^

Anthus S. American

species.- furthest

south — Anthus

going further <South> <<North>

than S. American

species"*'

[47] Mr Yarrell" 3"6cl

for number of
Physiology****

Mr Yarrell [1765 writien over

•I780-],

has book history of

Pidgeon.*'''

Treatise on Domestic
Pidgeons — very
curious, in comparison
for time, — Mr Yarrell
has /-recent-/ comparison

[48] Has rock Pidgeon
<pouter's> specks on
shoulder. Pouters
have specks'"'

Have any new
varieties of Pidgeons
been established?'"

There must be laws of
variation chance would never
produce feathers or make
breed—"- ?cat without legs?"^

[49e-58e]

[59] /-modesty [<<lwo illeg words>>] &
shame-/
Mr Fuller 8 Albany

[62|

-/-ll-/ Regent
- 20()£'"'

Albany St. 7()£.

per annum

no 161 — 100£ per annum

Another further up
this street 80£
no 27

[60] Clarges St.

Montague Place
House. Parker
Keppel St Agent
Furnished

Kemp & Son
37 Judd St.
House in Woburn
Place — no 20

[61] Pearsall & Jorden
1. Bernard St
Russell Square
House in do

12 Upper Gower"-

St. Furnished or

unfurnished. <<must be latter>

Furniture

at Valuation? Pearsall

& Jordan: 100 year

with stables: 4 years-

[Will hear on Tuesday from France
wnlleri up left margin]

Mr Stokes'*" 4
North Place
Gray Inn Lane

Gordon Square

40

Built l-iwo-l years

216

G. R. CHANCELLOR

[63]

<L)pper> <<20>> Woburn Place

bare, (with fixtures

some) want some

painting <<Landlord probably will

do no more>> rather

nice house -

offices rather bad.

look out /-believing-/

moderately good

140 Kemp'&

Son [37 '3' written over '2'\ Judd St

with stables

[6xj Lonsdale: S. American
Fossils?""

17. Woburn Place
to Purchase Furniture
rent 1 10 Lease 7 or
14

[64] Tavistock Square"*^
2 houses from-
near Mr /-Crompton's-/
I45£: New
House belonging to Cubitt^"

Regent Square.

[INSIDE BACK COVER]
2/6

Lyell"

Geograph Journal
1839 p. 288
Subsidence
at Tyre'""

[Back end paper excised]

[lxe-4xe]

[5x] by seeds or not? & what
will it go back to?

Give Miller'"' a
hint, about specimens

[378 yellow encircled]^°^

VonHofftranslated??"'^

Take the passage

& see about my mistake

Correction for Lyell
in little Book'""^

Lyell Vol.11 Poggendorf
Annalen about Albite
ask /-Lvell-/ to look'*"

[illeg]>

Earle'"^ Tristan D-Acunha""*

Mr Whewell"^ depths at
which sea breaks'

[7x] Cone ofTree from Chile'"

Mr Brown/-e-/

Bomb"-' [<<cannot find it>>

+ Mark of Tree boxed] -

Is Australian wood coniferous"'

[<<yes all I brought>> ink mer pencil]

<<nearly all filled with agate /-Red

Jasper-/ does not>>

+ Norfolk Isld

Macquarie Is??

where can I get account?

Australia & S. America
at all allied Flora.

Wild dogs on West Coast
See l/-st-/ Vol of Geograph
Journal"^

Bog Iron ore
infusoria"''

Fern «of Australia» being found in
India.

Ask directions about good
lens in Paris.-

CHARLES DARWIN'S ST HELENA MODEL NOTEBOOK

[8x] Lyell flint in Potteries'"' [20x]

Owen tooth in Sir
Woodbine's" '' possession"'*

217

Dr Smith'-'*
/-Quartz-/ Rock, no
formation of ??
with respect to origin of
sandstone'-''

[9xe-10xe]

[llx] Vol III p. 30 Lyell""

wrong about P. vulpina
Waterhouse

Granite large
Formation????

?Type? size for Zoological

Ask Lonsdale"" about
«stalagtite layer on>> Chalk &
look at
[three illeg words]

Ask Bailliere'

Roget, Bridgewater'-'
Treatise

Translation of Muller'"

(with the exception
of some quartz Hills
on <near> the West Coast
near the mouth of Orange
River) Dr Smith.-'^'

[12x] Ice transport of storm
in Frith of Forth
p. 157 VII Vol
«& 8th» Edinburgh Transact'"

Have they <<a>> Leucopterus

from Falkland Isd

at Brit Museum

for comparison with

those from T del

Fuego brought by King'-''

[13xe-18xe]

[19x] Ask Dr Smith

thickness of sandstone
atC. of Good Hope'-'

How high is the capping of
sandstone on Lions Head
2100ft above sea

[21xe-
[23x]

22xe]

Tooth of Mastodon "-
for Merchant

Sonnerat'"" has
given account
of Seychelles
Voyage aux Indes
Orientales 1774
1781

Gould"^ has seen
Parrot

[24x]

/-Cheiroptamus-/'-*^

Exact Locality

Cast

Corvus do Mar
for Henslow'-^

[Whether litters of true hybrids
are heterogenous or homogenous
written upside down]''^^

Sir P Egerton""
says that Kaup'"
considers M. augusti =
dens"" as only found
in India-
European species <come
from> are M.
longirostris

218
[25x]

G. R. CHANCELLOR

[26x]

Jaw of Elephant in
Geolog Soc

Edin Transacts

Vol. VI p les'-^"

considers Somma
is fragment of large
volcano Sir J
Hall

do p. IVS'-'" Has seen
clay stiff enough for
potters use with
/-great-/ crystals of ice
/-found-/ in them, &
fragments of rock, with
angles <stay> sharp, yet with
[character completely altered &
iwo illeg words superinduced
written up right margin]

Edentate Head, one plate''"

[28x]

[29x1

Mastodont one plate

4 Plates

2 Plates for little

bones

I Tessalated covering
6 Scelidotherium
1 — Lower jaw
1 Megatherium
1 && [\iboxed]2'\^

[27x] TTieory of Volcanos

<</-Count-/>> Byelandt
Palstercamp''*-

Rat from
Australia??'''-'
Owen- fossil -'■"

Shall I give Institute
/-d'-/France Mammalia''*^

[30x]

Lyell Volcanic
Dust''*"

/-Macaio-/
Is there any relation
between boss of Indian
cattle & structure
Bison &c'^'

Analyse this in
all cases whether
variation /-assumes-/
character allied to
specific ones
same genus —

Write to Sulivan'** to

enquire about wild

<<Have they long ears & what

colour??>>

dogs on the Pampas

Do male animals lose
passion from breeding in &
in.-'^'

How many generations was

this effected in case of

Bantam & Polish Cochin""

in Pidgeons how many generations

old on an

average"'

[Vertebra of Indian Cattle ink over

pencil]'"

Evton. dissect.-"''

Skeletons of Pidgeons

1/2 one. 3. oclock
1/4.1. 1/2 past one

Pay Lyell"''for

Pritchard'^'^Chemical Co/-ncre-/
tions

Volcanic Dust'''"

Remnants of Carpets"' Mat for

Hall

Windows cleaned

Staircase cover washed

Walls cleaned

white curtains washed

CHARLES DARWIN'S ST HELENA MODEL NOTEBOOK 219

[31x] Two easy chairs T. Carlyle '''''- Public
Library

Blinds in red

Rooms washed P''"' '" Po"e''y

written upside down

1160

[32x] Common table &
Muslin all to be 2nd Washing stand
washed

Lyell"''-Maclarens"'- has written
[Lyell"'* on Salisbury Craigs

NOTES

Biographical notes are adaptations of those given in the Correspondence.

1. There arc five lines of illegible very feint words written on the inside front end paper.

2. Longwood (elevation 1760') was Napoleon's residence on St Helena; it is located in the east-
central part of the island (see Cross, 1980).

3. Alarm House (elevation I960'?) is approximately 1 mile west of Longwood.

4. Flagstaff Hill (elevation 2275') is on the north-east coast, overlooking Flagstaff Bay.

5. Not identified.

6. Horse Pasture is a large sloping area about three miles south-west of Jamestown.

7. High Hill (elevation 2314') is about two miles south of Horse Pasture.

8. Man and Horse is a high cliff area at the south-west corner of St Helena.

9. The Flat Rocks arc two of the islets off the southern tip of St Helena.

10. The Asses Ears (elevation about 1660') are two peaks at the the southern tip of the island.

11. South Barn is presumably Sandy Bay Barn (elevation 1413') which is in the centre of the
south coast, on the eastern side of Sandy Bay.

12. Long Range (elevation 1936') and Long Range Point are on the south-eastern edge of Sandy
Bay.

13. Cuckholds Point (elevation 2672') is in the centre of the island, on the northern rim of Sandy
Bay.

14. Halley's Mount (elevation 22(X)') is halfway between Cuckhold's Point and Alarm House. It
was from this point that Edmund Halley observed the transits of Mercury and Venus in 1676.

LS. See note 8.

16. Great Stone Top (elevation 1620) is near the south-east corner of the island.

17. See note 7.

18. The Barn (elevation 2019') is at the north-west tip of the island.

19. See note 4.

20. See note 11.

21 . Green Hill (elevation 1650') is about I mile south of Cuckhold's Point.

220 G. R. CHANCKLLOR

22. West Lodge (elevation 2200') is about 1 mile east-south-east of High Hill. Darwin both here
and in VI refers to it as Nest Lodge.

23. See note 1 1 .

24. See note 18.

25. Lot (elevation 1489') and Lot's Wife (elevation 1516') are peaks in the interior of Sandy Bay.

26. See note 4.

27. See note 4.

28. Casons Gate has not been located.

29. High Peak (elevation 2616') is about 2 miles east of High Hill. Darwin's question to himself
here almost certainly relates to his Beagle notes (DAR 38ii, f. 929).

30. Prosperous Bay is on the north-east coast of St Helena.

31. See note 4.

32. See note 18.

33. See note 1 1 .

34. See note 8.

35. See note 4.

36. Not identified.

37. Gould, John (1804-81). Self-taught ornithologist and artist. Taxidermist to the Zoological
Society of London, 1826-81 . Described the birds collected on the Beagle expedition (Gould,
1838-41). FRS 1834.

38. Related matter appears in B249.

39. Eyton, Thomas Campbell (1809-80). Shropshire naturalist and collector of bird skins and
skeletons. Friend and Cambridge contemporary of Darwin.

40. Waterhouse, George Robert (1810-88). Naturalist. A founder of the Entomological Society,
1833. Curator, Zoological Society of London, 1836-43. On staff of the British Museum
1843-80. Described some of Darwin's entomological specimens from the Beagle voyage (see
Smith. 1987) as well as the Beagle mammals (Waterhouse, 1838-9).

41 . Waterhouse thinks two main divisions of cats. Tortoise shell & grey-banded, '.'species?' B250.

42. Sulivan, Bartholomew James (1810-90). Naval officer and hydrographer. Lieutenant in the
Beagle. 1831-6. Surveyed the Falkland Islands, 1836-46 (Moore & Scannell, 1986). Admiral
1877.

43. Nata cattle are described in Varialion 1 : 89-91 . They may also be the subject of a manuscript
Darwin sent to George Robert Gray in December 1838 (see Correspondence 2: 1.16).

44. Almost certainly a reference to Gould's illustration of Darwin's Rhea, Plerocnemia pennala
d'Orbigny, which was published in Gould (1841).

45. D'Orbigny, Alcide Charles Victor Dessalines (1802-57) French palaeontologist who travelled
widely in South America, 1826-34.

46. Probably a reference to the figures of South American fossils which appeared in the Atlas de
la partic historique' of d'Orbigny (1846).

47. Colp (1977) does not seem to have found any evidence that Darwin had any ear complaint.

48. Lyell. Charles (1797-1875). Uniformitarian geologist. Professor of Geology. King's College,
London, 1831-3. President of the (ieological Society, 18.14-6 and 1849-50. Scientific mentor
and friend of Darwin. FRS 1826. Lvcll was in Scotland from late August until mid-November
1838 (Wilson, 1972).

CHARLES DARWIN'S ST HELENA MOI3EL NOTEBOOK 221

49. Possibly Desnoyers (1831-2), although Lyell already knew of this paper (Notebooks: 405n35-
I).

50. Owen, Richard (1804-92). Comparative anatomist. Assistant conservator at the Hunterian
Museum, Royal College of Surgeons. 1827; Hunterian Professor. 1836-56. Superintendent of
the Natural History Department of the British Museum. 1856-84. Described the Beagle fossil
mammal specimens (Owen, 1838-40). FRS 1834.

51. Caoutchouc, or India-rubber, could be used to seal a bottle.

52. An almost identical reference occurs on D40 and the 'Suites" arc also referred to on D 1 79 and
on the inside back cover of C (Notebooks: 327niB(-4). The D40 note was made between the
19th and 22nd of August 1838.

53. Presumably a reference to subscribers to the Zoology (Freeman. 1977; Correspondence 2).

54. Mr Stewart of Stewart and Murray, printers of the Zoology.

55. See note 37.

56. C. M. Curtis, artist for the Zoology mammalia volume (Waterhouse, 1838-9), no. 2 of which
appeared in September 1838.

57. Smith, Andrew (1797-1872). Army surgeon stationed in South Africa, 1821-37. Principal
Medical Officer at Fort Pitt, Chatham, 1837; Deputy Inspector-General, 1845. Director-
General. Army Medical Department, 1853-8. FRS 1857. Darwin collected sharks' teeth at
Navedad in 1834 (sec GSA). but I can trace no connection between Andrew Smith and South
America or sharks' teeth.

58. Mitchell, Thomas Livingstone (1792-1855). Surveyor-General, New South Wales, 1825-55.

59. See CI59,189 and D180 on the subject of breeding between native and european dogs.

60. See VI: 135 for Mitchell's information on Australian river valleys, published in Mitchell
(1838). Darwin records a communication with Mitchell, probably datable to April 1838, on
the same subject (see Notebooks: 113n92-l).

61. Probably a reference to fossils from Tasmania, judging from the proximity to the following
reference (note 62). See Banks (1971) and DAR 40, ff. 45-9.

62. Brown, Robert (1773-1858). Botanist. Librarian to Joseph Banks, 181(K58. Keeper of the
Botanical collections, British Museum, 1827-58. FRS 1811. Mabberley (1985).

63. The text on pp. 26-7 is drawn over heavily with doodles and sketches of plants. These may be
fossil plants from Tasmania given to Robert Brown for description. See fig. 1. and VI: 140.

64. 'Major Mitchell is not aware that Australian dogs ever hunt in company-' C213. Entry made
in the early summer of 1838.

65. May refer to the woodcuts of volcanic bombs in VI: 36. 38.

66. Lonsdale, William (1794-1871). Geologist. Served the Geological Society from 1829 to 1842,
first as curator and librarian, and after 1838 as assistant secretary and librarian. Lonsdale was
a frequent source of information for Darwin.

67. This question may be directed at Major Mitchell. See note 60.

68. Henrietta Street is near the centre of Bath.

69. 'There is a breed of tailless cats, near Bath. Lonsdale' C175. William Lonsdale (see note 66)
provided Darwin with other examples of varieties of domesticated animals (Notebooks:
293--4).

70. Henslow, John Stevens (1796-1861). Clergyman, botanist, and mineralogist, Cambridge
University. 1822-7; Professor of Botany, 1825-61. Darwin's teacher and friend. The
background to Henslows involvement with plants collected by Darwin is given in Porter
(1985).

222 G. R. CHANCELLOR

71. See note 42.

72. The last two lines arc written horizontally as was the previous page of text, judging from
words on the stub of 34e. The other lines on p. 35 were written vertically in the remaining
blank space.

73. See note 50. TTie reference has not been traced, although there was correspondence on
"animal magnetism' in The Lancet at this time (e.g. issue of September 22, p. 34).

74. Hall (1815) is also referred to in A36. See also note 123.

75. 'Miss Martineau (How to Observe p. 213) says charity is found everywhere (is it not present
with all associated animals?) I doubted it in Fuegians, till I remembered Bynoes story of the
women.-' M142. This entry was made between 13 and 15 September 1838. Note that the
name in the St Helena Model notebook is clearly Byron. The reference is to Martineau
(1838). See also Correspondence 1: 520.

76. Youatt (1834).

77. See note 40. 'Wowett on Cattle- (Waterhouse has it)' Cim.

78. Fox. William Darwin (1805-80). DaiAvin's second cousin. A close friend at Cambridge who
shared Darwin's enthusiasm for entomology.

79. 'Experimentise on land shells in salt water & lizards do.-' B248.

80. Hunter (1837), listed on C270. See note 50.

81. Hybrid pintail and common ducks are referred to on D25, 26, 33,89, IBC. See also Natural
Selection: 433nl, and Variation 2: 45.

82. Crossing between black grouse and ptarmigan is referred to on D72, dated 8 September 1838
and on D105-6, datable to 13 September 1838, The subject is dealt with in some detail in
Natural Selection. 434-6, and Darwin's interest in it seems likely to have originated during his
fieldwork at Glen Roy in late June 1838, See Notebooks: .345n43-l,

83. Grouse-pheasant hybrids are mentioned on B189,D33, 105-6 and E106. See note 82,

84. The capercailzie is mentioned on D73 and 105,

85. See note 82.

86. Probably a reference to Anlhus corrender Viellot, mentioned in Gould (1839: 85) as having
■probably a further range southward than any other land-bird in the southern hemisphere.'

87. Yarrell, William (1784-1856). Zoologist. Engaged in business as newspaper agent and
bookseller in London. Wrote standard works on British birds and fishes.

88. Possibly Hunter (1786) or (1792). listed on C267.

89. Moore (1765). An almost identical entry occurs on DIOO. See Notebooks: .362nUX)-l. This
cross-reference almost certainly dates to 13 September 1838.

90. This is discussed on DlOO-1 . See Notebooks: 362nlOO-2, and note 89.

91. 'as in pidgeons no new races.-' D104.

92. I agree with the reading of this page given in Notebooks: 362nlOO-2, although the phrase may
be 'produce feathers and make bones'. Very similar wording occurs on D112.

93. 'Yarrell told me of a cat & a dog, born without front legs-' D108. 'if armless cat can
propogatc' Dl 12. These pages are datable to between 14 and 16 September 1838.

94. Darwin started househunting on or about 25 November 1838 (See Correspondence 2: 120).

95. Freeman (1982) gives an excellent account of the events leading up to the establishment of
the newlywed Darwin household at 12 Upper Gower Street ('Macaw Cottage') in January
1839.

96. This may be Charles Stokes (1783-1853). See Wilson (1972, chapter 10).

CHARLES DARWIN'S ST HELENA MODEL NOTEBOOK 223

97. A prospective house in Tavistock Square is mentioned in a letter from Darwin to Emma
Wedgwood dated 27 November 1838 (Correspondence 2: 129).

98. Thomas Cubitt (1788-1855) is mentioned as the developer of Tavistock Square in Freeman

(1982).

99. '2/6' is written in the top left hand corner. It is presumably the price of the notebook (two
shillings and six pence).

1(X). This reference of 1839 is the latest date in the notebook. The reference is to De Berthou
(1839). The only other reference to the 1839 volume of the Journal of the Roval
Geographical Society of London in Darwin's handwriting of which I am aware is the
annotation on the letter from J. G. Malcolmson of 7 October 1839 {Correspondence 2: 225).

lUl. Miller. William Hallowes (1801-80). Mineralogist and crystallographcr. Professor of
Mineralogy, Cambridge University, 1832-80. FRS 1838.

102. Geological specimen 3378. from Tahiti. There is a note in Darwin's specimen catalogue (on
deposit at CUL) to 'V. applendix] p. 19', which is a reference to DAR 39.l,f.88. The
specimen is mentioned in a note from J. S. Hcnslow dated 5 November 1837-March 1838
(Correspondence 2: 55n2). in Darwin's letter to Henslow of 26 March 1838 (Correspondence
2: 79n4), and in Darwin's letter to W. H. Miller of 16 October-27 November 1842
(Correspondence 2: 339n2).

103. Presumably Hoff (1822-24)

104. See note 66. One explanation of this entry is that Darwin was entertaining the possibility of
William Lonsdale describing at least some of his invertebrate fossils from South America. In
the event Lonsdale described Darwin's fossils from Tasmania (Lonsdale 1844) while George
Brettingham Sowerby (1788-1854) and Fdward Forbes (1815-54) described Darwin's
Cenozoic and Mesozoic fossils respectively (Sowerby 1846, Forbes 1846). Darwin enquired
concerning Sowerby's credentials for the task in a letter to J. S Henslow of October 1836
(Correspondence 1: 512n4). Sowerby also described Darwin's shells from the Cape Verdes
and from St Helena and Tasmania (Sowerby 1844).

105. Possibly a reference to Lyell (1840). Darwin was reading this work in manuscript in
September 1838 (sec Correspondence 2: 107n8).

106. Lyell (1837,2: 175) 'According to Von Buch, the American volcanic rocks contain generally
less albite instead of common felspar as a principal ingredient (Poggendorf's Annalen, 1836,
p. 190).'

107. Earle, Augustus (1793-1838). Artist and traveller. Artist in the Beagle, 1831-2. Hackforth-
Jones(1980).

108. Augustus Earle spent nine months on Tnstan da Cunha in 1824 (see note 107). Darwin may
have been interested in the action of waves on the island (see note 1 10).

109. Whewell. William (1794-1866). Mathematician and historian and philosopher of science.
Tutor at Trinity College, Cambridge, 182.3-38; Master 1841-66. Professor of Mineralogy,
Cambridge University, 1828-32. FRS 1820.

110. In a letter to Robert Mallet (1810-81) of 26 August 1846 Darwin says he consulted William
Whewell (see note 109) on the subject of waves while preparing JR. Sec Correspondence 3:
335. In A59 the subject of breaking waves is mentioned with respect to Tristan da Cunha
(see note 108).

1 1 1. See note 62.

1 12. See note 65.

1 13. There is a general connection between these entries and those on B187 and C238-9.

1 14. The wild dogs of King George's Sound are discussed by Nind (1832: 29).

115. See Ehrenberg (1837), mentioned on A93 (Notebooks: 1 I4n93-1).

224 G. R. CHANCELLOR

116. See notes 140 and IW).

1 17. Parish, Woodbine (1796-1882). Diplomat Charge d'affaires in Buenos Aires. 1825-32. FRS
1824.

118. Possibly a reference to the "single detached tooth' of a Mef;alherium. mentioned as having
been in Parish's collection by Owen (1840; 102).

119. "Thus the Phalangista vulpina inhabits both Sumatra and New Holland' l.yell (1S37. 3: 30).
Lyell took his reference from Tcmminck (1827: 16. 19). Watcrhouse told Darwin that he did
not believe Temminck's statement to be true, in a letter sent to 12 Upper Gower Street (and
therefore dating from the last few days of 1838 at the earliest; see Correspondence 2: 154).
There is a very similar entry in B249e (Notebooks: 232-3).

120. Bailliere, Hippolyte (d.l867). Bookseller and publisher in London who specialised in
French medical and scientific texts.

121. Roget(1834).

122. Muller (1838-42).

123. Hall (1815: 157). This entry cross-refers to p. 36 (see note 74). It is not clear why Darwin has
added a reference to the eighth volume of the Transactions of the Royal Society of
Edinburgh .

124. See King (1828: 423-6).

125. See note 57. The sandstone, which is 2000 feet thick, is described in VI: 150-152.

126. See note 70. A mistake for Cocos do mer, mentioned on E164 in relation to discussions with
Henslow on 27 May 1839.

127. 'Are the hybrids of those species, which cross & are fertile heterogenous' D,bc- See
Notebooks: 345n43-l .

128. See note 56.

129. These two entries relate to information given by Smith on the geology of South Africa (see
notes 125 and 131).

130. See note 66.

131. This is presumably Smith's reply to Darwin's enquiry at the top of the page.

132. Darwin found Mastodon teeth at Gorodona (GSA: 87-8; Owen. 1840: 108). Sec notes
137-8.

133. Sonnerat (1782).
1.34. See note 37.

135. Cheroptamus Cuvier is an Eocene mammal related to pigs (Buckland. 1836 1: 80).

136. Egerton, Philip dc Malpas Grey (1806-81). Of Oulton Park. Cheshire. Tory MP for South
Cheshire, 183.5-68. FRS 1831. Egerton was a vertebrate palaeontologist, specializing in
fossil fish and footprints.

137. Kaup (18.32-5).

138. Mastodon augustidens Cuvier is referred to on C46 and E32. the latter reference dated 26
October 18.38. See note 1.32.

139. Hall (1812).

140. Hall (1812). An almost verbatim reference to the same observation occurs on Al 1 1 . datable
to before 11 August 1838. This may cross-refer to the subject touched on in notes 116 and
160.

141. This is a list of the plates thought necessary to illustrate the fossil mammalia of the Beagle
(Owen, 1838-40). The following are the most probable identifications of the plates listed:

CHARLES DARWIN'S ST HELENA MODEL NOTEBOOK 225

'Edentate Head' Glossotherium in Owen (1839: pL 16)

'Mastodont' not illustrated

'Tessalated covering' Hoplophorus Owen (1840: pi. 32, figs. 4-5)

•Scelidotherium' Scelidolherium Owen (1839^0: pis. 20-8)

'Lower jaw' Megalonyx in Owen (1840: pi. 29)

'Megatherium' Megatherium Owen (1840: pi. 30)

142. Not identified.

143. Probably refers to a supposed fossil rat listed by Clift (1831), mentioned on C131 (see
Notebooks: 278nl31-l). See note 144.

144. See note 50. Possibly Darwin was seeking Owen's opinion as to whether the rat (see note
143) was correctly identified.

145. Darwin seems to be asking if he should donate a copy of Waterhouse (1838-9) to the
Institute de France.

146. See notes 48 and 156. Lyell gave Darwin a letter written to him in March 1838 which
reported volcanic dust falling on a ship at sea {Correspondence 2: 77-8).

147. A very similar passage occurs on D65, dated 7 September 1838. See also note 152.

148. Sec note 42. There are several entries concerning wild dogs of the world in the Notebooks
(e.g. D7-8).

149. 'Breeding in & in Infertility & loss of passion '.'? in Male?" occurs in draft Questions for Mr
Wynne', datable to February-July 1838 (Correspondence 2: 71).

150. Closely related discussion occurs on D163, dated 25 September 1838.

151. '(. . & not effect of breeding in & in like our pidgeons)' D88.

152. See note 147.

153. See notes 39 and 151.

154. See note 48.

155. Prichard(1836).

156. Sec note 146.

157. See note 94.

158. See note 48.

159. Carlyle, Thomas (1795-1881). Essayist and historian. Darwin met Carlyle for the first time
in November 1838 (Correspondence 2:128).

160. Sec notes 1 16 and 140.

161. See note 48. Lyell mentioned Salisbury Craigs in his letter to Darwin dated 6 and 8
September 1838 (Correspondence 2:99).

162. Maclarcn, Charles (1782- 1866). Established The Scotsman. 1817; editor, 1820-45. Wrote on
geological subjects. Presumably Darwin knew of Maclarcn (1839).

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Short Titles of Darwin Worlts and Editions

Correspondence

The Correspondence of Charles Darwin. Vol. 1. Eds. Frederick Burkhardt, Sydney Smith; David

226 G. R. CHANCELLOR

Kohn. William Montgomery and Stephen V. Pocock. Cambridge |yS5; Vol. 2: Eds. Frederick
Burkhardt. Sydney Smith; Janet Browne, David Kohn. WiMiam Montgomery. Stephen V.
Pocock, Charlotte Bowman, Anne Secord. Cambridge 1486. Vol. 3. idem 1W7.

GSA

Geological observations on South America. Being the third part of the geology of the voyage of the
Beagle', under the command of Capt. FitzRoy, R.N. during the years 1832 to 1836. London
1846.

JR

Journal of researches into the geology and natural history of the various countries visited by H. M. S.
'Beagle', under the command of Captain FitzRoy, R.N. from /S.?2 to 1836. London 18.14.

Natural Selection

Charles Darwin's Natural Selection, being the second part of his big species book written from 1856
to 1858. Ed. Robert C. Stauffer. Cambridge 1975.

Notebooks

Charles Darwin's Notebooks, 1836-1844. Eds Paul H. Barrett, Peter J. Gautrey, Sandra Herbert,
David Kohn & Sydney Smith. London and Cambridge 1987.

Variation

The variation of animals and plants under domestication. 2 vols. London 1868.

VI

Geological observations on the volcanic islands, visited during the voyage of H.M.S. Beagle',
together with some brief notices on the geology of Australia and the Cape of Good Hope. Being
the second part of the geology of the voyage of the 'Beagle', under the command of Capt. FitzRoy,
R.N. during the years I H32 to 1836. London 1844.

Zoology

The zoology of the voyage of H.M.S. 'Beagle' under the command of Captain FitzRoy, R N.,

during the years 1832 to 1836. Published with the approval of the Lords Commissioners of Her

Majesty's Treasury. Ed. ChaHes Darwin London 1839^3.

REFERENCES

Banks, M. R. 1971. A Darwin manuscript on Hobart Town. Papers and Proceedings of the Royal

Society of Tasmania 105: 5-19.
Barlow, N. 1933 (Ed.). Charles Darwin's diary of the voyage of H.M.S. Beagle. Cambridge.
Barlow, N. 1945. Charles Darwin and the voyage of the Beagle'. London.
Buckland, W. 1836. Geology and mineralogy considered with reference to natural theology. 2 vols.

London.
Clift, W. 1831. Report by Mr Clift, of the College of Surgeons, London, in regard to the fossil

bones found in the caves and bone-breccias of New Holland. Edinburgh New Philosophical

Journal 10: 394-5.
Colp, R. 1977. To be an invalid: the illness of Charles Darwin. 285pp. Chicago.
Cross, T. 1980. .S'( Helena, including Ascension Island and Tristan da Cunha. Newton Abbott &

London.
De Berthou, J. 1939. Extract from a notice on the site of ancient Tyre. Journal of the Royal

Geographical Society 9: 286-94.
Desnoycrs, J. P. F. S. 18.30-2. Sur les osscmcnts humains dcs cavernes. Bulletin de la .Society

Geologique de France 2: 126-33.
Ehrenberg, C. G. 1837. Remarks on the real occurrence of fossil infusoria, and their extensive

diffusion. Scientific Memoirs 1: 4(X>-7.
Forbes, E. 1846. Descriptions of Secondary fossil shells from South America. In Geological

observations on South America . . . (sec GSA): 265-8.

CHARLES DARWIN'S ST HELENA MODEL NOTEBOOK 227

Freeman, R. B. 1977. The works of Charles Darwin. An annotated bibliographical handlist. 2nd

ed. 235pp. Folkestone.
Freeman, R. B. 1982. Darwin and Gower Street. London.
Gould, J. 1X38^1 , The zoology of the voyage of H.M.S. 'Beagle' under the command of Captain

FilzRoy. R.N.. during the years 1832 to 1836 . . . Part 3: Birds. London.
Hackforth-Jones, J. 19X0. Augustus Earle, Travel Artist. London.
Hall, J. 1812. Account of a scries of experiments, shewing the effects of compression in modifying

the action of heat. Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh 6: 71-186.
Hall, J. 1815. On the revolutions of the Earth's surface Transactions of the Royal Society of

Edinburgh 7:139-67 (part 1), 169-21 1 (part 2).
Herbert, S. 1977. The place of man in the development of Darwin's theory of transmutation. Part

II. Journal of the History of Biology 10: 155-227.
Hoff, K. E. A. von 1822-24. Geschichte der durch Ueberlieferung nachgewiesenen natiirlichen

Veriinderungen der Erdoberfliiche. 3 vols. Gotha.
Hunter, J. 1786. Observations on certain parts of the animal oeconomy. London.
Hunter, J. 1792. Observations on certain parts of the animal oeconomy. 2nd ed. 273pp. London.
Hunter, J. 1837. Observations on certain parts of the animal oeconomy . . . with notes by Richard

Owen. 506pp. London.
Kaup, J. J. 1832-5. Description d'ossements fossiles de mammiferes inconnus jusqu' ii present qui se

trouvent au Museum grand ducal de Darmstadt; avec figures lithographiees. 4 vols. Darmstadt.
King, P. P. 1828. Extracts from a letter addressed by Capt. Philip Parker King, R.N., F.R.S. and

L.S.. to N.A. Vigors, Esq., on the animals of the Straits of Magellan. Zoological Journal

London 3:422-32.
Lonsdale, W. 1844. Description of six species of corals, from the Palaeozoic formation of Van

Diemen's Land. In Geological observations on the volcanic islands . . . (see VT): 161-9.
Lyell, C. 1837. Principles of geology: being an enquiry how far the former changes of the earth's

surface are referable to causes now in operation. 5th edition. 4 vols. London.
Lyell, C. 1840. Principles of geology: or, the modern changes of the earth and its inhabitants,

considered as illustrative of geology. 6th ed. 3 vols. London.
Mabberley, D. J. 1985 Jupiter Botanicus. Robert Brown of the British Museum. 5(IOpp. Braunsch-
weig & London.
Maclaren, C. 1839. A sketch of the geology of Fife and the Lothians, including detailed descriptions

of Arthur's Seat and Pentland Hills. 235pp. Edinburgh.
Martineau, H. 1838. How to observe. Morals and Manners. London.

Mitchell, T. L. 1838. Three expeditions into the interior of eastern Australia. 2 vols. London.
Moore, J. 1765. A treatise on domestic pigeons. London.
Moore, D. M. and Scannell, M. J. P. 1986. Bartholomew Sulivan and early watercolors of the

Falkland Islands vegetation in the National Botanic Gardens, Dublin. Archives of Natural

History 13: 155-163.
Muller, J. 1838-42. Elements of physiology. 2nd ed. 2 vols. London.
Nind, S. 1832. Description of the Natives of King George's Sound (Swan River Colony) and

adjoining Country. Journal of the Royal Geographical Society 1: 21-51 .
Orbigny, A. C. V. D. d' 1835-47 Vovage dans TAmerique Meridionale . . ., execute pendant tes

annees 1826 . . . 1833. 9 vols. Paris & Strasbourg.
Owen, R. 1838-40. The zoology of the \'oyage of H.M.S. Beagle' under the command of Captain

FitzRoy, R.N., during the years 1832 to 1836 . . . Part 1: Fossil Mammalia. London.
Porter, D. M. 1985. The Beagle collector and his collections. In Kohn, D. (Ed.) The Darwinian

Heritage: 973-1019. Princeton.
Prichard, J. C. 1836-47. Researches into the physical history of mankind. 2nd ed. 2 vols. London.
Roget, P. M. 1834. Animal and vegetable physiology considered with reference to natural theology. 2

vols. London.
Rudwick, M. J. S. 1982. Charles Darwin in London: the integration of public and private science.

Istsli: 186-206.
Seale, R. F. 1834. The geognosy of the island of St Helena, illustrated m a .'series of views, plans and

sections: accompanied with explanatory remarks and observations. 25pp. London.
Smith, K. G. V. 1987. Darwin's insects. Bulletin British Museum {Natural History) Historical Series

14: 1-143.

228 ti. R. CHANCELLOR

Sonnerat, P. 1782. Voyage aux Indes Oriemales et a la Chine, fait par ordre dii Roi, depui.t 1774

jusqu'eu 1781. 2 vols. Paris.
Sowerby, G. B. 1844. Description of fossil shells. In Geological observations on the volcanic islands

... (sec Vf). 15-V60.
Sowerby, G. B. 1846. Descriptions of Tertiary fossil shells from South America. In deological

observations on South America . . . (see GSA): 294-64.
Temminck, C. J. 1827-41. Monographies de mammalogie, ou description de qiielques genres de

marnmiferes. dont les especes ont ete observees dans les differents mu.sees de I'Europe. 2 vols.

Paris & Leiden.
Waterhousc, G. R. 1838-9. The zoology of the voyage of H.MS. Beagle' under the command of

Captain FitzRoy, R.N., during the years IHM to 1836 . . . Part 2: Mammalia. London.
Wilson, L. G. 1972. Charles Lyell: The years to 1841 . The revolution in geology. 553pp. New Haven

& London.
Youatt, W. 1834. Cattle: their breeds. Library of Useful Knowledge. 6<)0pp. London.

"^

^

Revista Latinoamericana de Historia
de las Ciencias y la Tecnologia

Editor: Juan Jose Saldafia (University of Mexico)

Quipu (Latin American Journal of History of Science and
Technology), is devoted to the history of science and tech-
nology in Latin America. Founded in 1984, it is published
three times a year. Contributions are welcome and articles are
accepted in Spanish, English, Portuguese and French. Quipu
has become indispensable for all those who study Latin Ameri-
can science and technology as well as for scholars interested
in the diffusion of science in different cultural contexts.

Suscription rates for 1989,
including postage and handling;

Latin America:
Individual US $25
Institutional US $40

All other regions:
Individual US $25
Institutional US $60

A complementary collection of Quipu is:

QUIPU NOTEBOOKS
The price of each volume, including postage and handling:

Latin America: US$10 All other regions: US $ 1 5

■•.:'.. :. ::Tilt

.: ■ i3f:

Orders and suscriptions by check or money order:

Quipu. Apartado Postal 21-873, 04000 Mexico, D.F.MEXICO

CONTENTS

115 The C/jaZ/e/jger Expedition (1872-1876), Henry Bowman Brady (1835-1891) and thi
Challenger Foramlnifera

ROBERT WYNN JONES

145 The Lady Blake Collection: Catalogue of Lady Edith Blake's Collection of Drawing:
of Jamaican Lepidoptera and Plants

C. V. ELLWOOD & J. M. V. HARVEY

203 Charles Darwin's St Helena Model Notebook

GORDON RUSSELLCHANCELLOR